旅游地道路生态持续性评价——以云南省玉龙县为例
详细信息 本馆镜像全文    |  推荐本文 | | 获取馆网全文
摘要
从生态效应与连通功能两个角度,综合运用景观格局指数、总体变异系数、稳定性系数等方法,以云南省玉龙县为例,构建旅游地道路生态持续性评价体系,定量评价全县主要旅游道路生态持续性状态及其空间分异。结果表明,研究区道路的生态持续性状态总体良好,有助于旅游业发展,同时对生态系统影响有限;受承载游客规模不同、沿线生态系统敏感性差异等因素影响,玉龙县道路的生态持续性具有明显的空间差异;旅游地道路生态持续性的影响因素主要包括道路所承载的旅游活动强度,道路的坡度,道路周边山体的地质构造,道路所经过区域的生态系统敏感程度等。
In this research,a synthetic assessment system is developed in order to evaluate the eco-sustainability of roads and their spatial variability in a tourism area.A case study in Lijiang County,located in the northwest of Yunnan Province,is described.The tourism industry in this study area has developed rapidly in the past few years.The assessment employs tools such as landscape pattern metrics,total variation index,and stability coefficients.The study′s results reveal that:(1) generally,the roads have helped to develop the tourism industry in Yulong County,and their impact on the environment is minimal;(2) there is significant spatial variability in eco-sustainability among roads;and(3) factors influencing road ecological sustainability include the intensity of tourist activities,the slope of the roads,the geological structure along the mountain roads,and the ecosystem sensitivity along the roads.The methodology has made major advances in five main areas.First,it considers both of the decisive factors of eco-sustainability in a tourism area—the development of a tourism industry,and its influence on ecosystems.These two form a coherent whole.Second,the methodology evaluates two aspects of road connectivity features: the internal rationale of road design and construction,and the external interference of geological hazards.The third highlight of this research is the establishment of a three-layer evaluation system of ecological effects,which includes the spheres of influence of an ecosystem,its pattern,and ecological factors.Fourth,the evaluation of road eco-sustainability in a tourism area would benefit by showing the spatial distinction of eco-sustainability of different roads.Fifth,the support vector machines model used in this paper could exclude the interference with the man-induced factor when defining weight for the category index.The keys to evaluate the eco-sustainability of the roads in a tourism area are the rational choice of indexes and the identification of thresholds.For instance,besides their tourism functions such as communication,they also perform many social and economic functions.In addition,the impacts of ecological factors such as the weather,soil,water,and creatures surrounding the roads should be considered as much as possible in the evaluation.But since some factors are difficult to quantify or statistics difficult to obtain,future research will focus on improving the evaluation indexes further.To this end,we should carry out experimental studies in order to identify more reasonable ecological thresholds.The ultimate purpose of our research is to provide references for road construction in the tourism area and for the protection of ecological integrity.Therefore,in constructing roads in the tourism area,we should first plan and design road levels in light of the development plan and trend of the tourist area and the tourist capacity of its roads.Next,in road planning and designing,we should consider the slope-elevation relationship and try to circumvent areas where geological disasters are likely to occur,thus improving road safety and comfort.Finally,we should follow the principle of giving priority to conservation and try not to let the roads run across ecologically sensitive areas.Meanwhile,we must consider restoring the disabled ecological functions and improving the habitat quality on the sides of existing roads,and propose measures for ecological restoration.
引文
[1]Martín-Cejas R R,Sánchez P P R.Ecological footprint analysis of road transport related to tourism activity:the case for Lanzarote Island.Tourism Management,2010,31(1):98-103.
    [2]Prideaux B.The resort development spectrum:a new approach to modeling resort development.Tourism Management,2000,21(3):225-240.
    [3]Hou C R,Song B,Wang C.A study on ecological landscape pattern and its optimization of tourism resorts.Shandong Environment,2000,(6):21-22.
    [4]Wang Y H,Chen B G.Spatial correlation among vegetation landscape in Baiyunshan Scenic Spot,Guangzhou.Journal of Mountain Science,2003,21(4):416-421.
    [5]Li S C,Xu Y Q,Zhou Q F,Wang L.Statistical analysis on the relationship between road network and ecosystem fragmentation in China.Progress in Geography,2004,23(5):78-86.
    [6]Shi P J,Chen J,Pan Y Z.Landuse change mechanism in Shenzhen City.Acta Geographica Sinica,2000,55(2):151-160.
    [7]Zhang Y L,Yan J Z,Liu L S,Bai W Q,Li S C,Zheng D.Impact of Qinghai-Xizang Highway on land use and landscape pattern change:from Golmud to Tanggulashan Pass.Acta Geographica Sinica,2002,57(3):253-266.
    [8]Liu S L,Cui B S,Yang Z F,Dong S K.Driving effect analysis of road networks on regional land use change in Lancangjiang river valley.Acta Scientiae Circumstantiae,2006,26(1):162-167.
    [9]Mader H J.Animal habitat isolation by roads and agricultural fields.Biological Conservation,1984,29(1):81-96.
    [10]Qiu L,Feng Z J.Effects of traffic during daytime and other human activities on the migration of Tibetan Antelope along the Qinghai-Tibet high-way,Qinghai-Tibet Plateau.Acta Zoologica Sinica,2004,50(4):669-674.
    [11]Goosem M.Internal fragmentation:the effects of roads,highways and powerline clearings on movements and mortality of rainforest vertebrates∥Bierregaard J R O,Laurance W F,eds.Tropical Forest Remnants:Ecology and Conservation of Fragmented Communities.Chicago:University of Chicago Press,1997:241-255.
    [12]Jaarsma C F,Willems G P A.Reducing habitat fragmentation by minor rural roads through traffic calming.Landscape and Urban Planning,2002,58(2/4):125-135.
    [13]Wang Y H,Miao W Y.Research on the scenic reserve tourism path planning based on the landscape ecology.Journal of Guilin Institute of Tourism,2005,16(4):74-77.
    [14]Kolka R K,Smidt M F.Effects of forest road amelioration techniques on soil bulk density,surface runoff,sediment transport,soil moisture and seedling growth.Forest Ecology and Management,2004,202(1/3):313-323.
    [15]Jones J A,Swanson F J,Wemple B C,Snyder K U.Effects of roads on hydrology,geomorphology,and disturbance patches in stream networks.Conservation Biology,2000,14(1):76-85.
    [16]Liu H Y,Zhang J H.Effects of recreational disturbance on the continus coggygria var.cinerea forest in Xiangshan Mountain,Beijing.Chinese Journal of Plant Ecology,1997,21(2):191-196.
    [17]Cheng Z H,Zhang J T,Shangguang T L,Zhang F.Relationship between tourism development and vegetation environment in Luya Mountain Nature ReserveⅠ.Quality analysis of vegetation environment.Acta Ecologica Sinica,2002,22(10):1765-1773.
    [18]Cheng Z H,Zhang J T.Difference between tourism vegetation landscapes of different distance.Journal of Mountain Science,2003,21(6):647-652.
    [19]Cheng Z H,Zhang J T,Shangguang T L.Relationship between tourism development and vegetation environment in Luya Mountain Nature Reserve:tourism influencing index and some indices analysis.Acta Ecologica Sinica,2003,23(4):703-711.
    [20]Shi Q,Zhong L S,Wang X F.Effects of recreation on plants in Zhangjiajie National Forest Park.Acta Phytoecologica Sinica,2004,28(1):107-113.
    [21]Wang Z J,Cai J,Zhang Q X.Impact of recreation activities on landscape and visual environment in Yumengshan National Forest Park.The Journal of Hebei Forestry Science and Technology,2004,(1):32-35.
    [22]Gssling S,Peeters P,Ceron J P,Dubois G,Patterson T,Richardson R B.The eco-efficiency of tourism.Ecological Economics2005,54(4):417-434.
    [23]Li P,Yang G H.The ecological footprint study of tourism itinerary production in Shangri-La,Yunnan Province.Acta Ecologica Sinica,2007,27(7):2954-2963.
    [24]Trista M P,Niccolucci V,Bastianoni S.Beyond“more is better”:ecological footprint accounting for tourism and consumption in Val di Merse,Italy.Ecological Economics,2007,62(3/4):747-756.
    [25]Blanco E,Lozano J,Rey-Maquieira J.A dynamic approach to voluntary environmental contributions in tourism.Ecological Economics,2009,69(1):104-114.
    [26]Lacitignola D,Petrosillo I,Cataldi M,Zurlini G.Modelling socio-ecological tourism-based systems for sustainability.Ecological Modelling,2007,206(1/2):191-204.
    [27]Zheng J,Li X W,Cui B S,Li C,Song X W,Zhang L N.The multi-scale effect of road network on the ecosystem in Longitudinal Range-Gorge region of Yunnan Province.Acta Ecologica Sinica,2009,29(8):4267-4277.
    [28]Mao J X,Yan X P.Corridor effects of the urban transport artery on land use:a case study of the Guangzhou Avenue.Geography and Geo-Information Science,2004,20(5):58-61.
    [29]Forman R T T,Alexander L E.Roads and their major ecological effects.Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics,1998,29(1):207-231.
    [30]Forman R T T.Estimate of the area affected ecologically by the road system in the United States.Conservation Biology,2000,14(1):31-35.
    [31]Zong Y G,Zhou S Y,Peng P.Perspective of road ecology development.Acta Ecologica Sinica,2003,23(11):2396-2405.
    [32]Wang Z S,Liu Y F,Wei J B,Zeng H.The impacts of road pattern on land uses in rapidly urbanizing regions.Research of Environmental Sciences,2008,21(2):180-185.
    [33]Kong N N,Zeng H,Li S J.A study of the spatial distribution characteristics of human landscape impact in Wolong National Natural Reserve,Sichuan Province.Acta Scientiarum Naturalium Universitatis Pekinensis,2002,38(3):393-399.
    [34]Zeng H,Kong N N,Li S J.Human impacts on landscape structure in Wolong Natural Reserve.Acta Ecologica Sinica,2001,21(12):1995-2001.
    [35]Li S C,Xu Y Q,Zhou Q F,Wang L.Statistical analysis on the relationship between road network and ecosystem fragmentation in China.Progress in Geography,2004,23(5):77-85.
    [36]Liu S L,Wen M X,Cui B S,Dong S K.Effects of road networks on regional ecosystems in Southwest mountain area:a case study in Jinhong of Longitudinal Range-Gorge Region.Acta Ecologica Sinica,2006,26(9):3018-3024.
    [37]Hong Y S,He S Q.Water environment survey and study on Lijiang.Yunnan Environmental Science,2001,20(Z1):143-145.
    [38]Burak S,Dˇo gan E,Gazˇioglu C.Impact of urbanization and tourism on coastal environment.Ocean and Coastal Management,2004,47(9/10):515-527.
    [39]Liu Q L,Guang D S.Non-polluted ecological impact of tourist activities in natural scenic area.Chinese Journal of Ecology,2005,24(4):443-447.
    [40]Yu K J,Duan T W,Li D H,Peng J F.Landscape accessibility as a measurement of the function of urban green system.City Planning Review,1999,23(8):8-13.
    [41]Yu K J,Li W,Li D H,Li C B,Hunag G,Liu H L.Suitability analysis of heritage corridor in rapidly urbanizing region:a case study of TaizhouCity.Geographical Research,2005,24(1):69-76.
    [42]Shi P J,Jiang Y,Wang J A,Liang J S,Li X B,Chen J,Chen Y H,He C Y.Land Use/Cover Change and Ecosystem Security.Beijing:Science Press,2004.
    [43]Zeng H,Guo Q H,Yu H.Spatial analysis of artificial landscape transform in Fenggang Town,Dongguan City.Acta Ecologica Sinica,1999,19(3):10-15.
    [44]Chen H,Li S C,Zheng D.Ecological risk assessment of regions alongside Qinghai-Xizang Highway and Railway based on Artificial Neural Network.Acta Scientiarum Naturalium Universitatis Pekinensis,2005,41(4):586-593.
    [45]Ma D T,Cui P,Yang K,Wang Z J.Road hazards of the segment of Xinjiang-Tibet Highway in Xinjiang and their primary cause analysis.Journal of Natural Disasters,2003,12(3):93-98.
    [46]Han X M,Zhou R Q.Intensity distribution of the M7.0Lijiang earthquake.Journal of Seismological Research,1997,20(1):35-46.
    [47]Peng J,Wang Y L,Zhang Y,Jiang Y Y,Ye M T.Research on the evaluation and analysis of land use sustainability dynamics in mountain areas of northwest of Yunnan Province,China:a case study of Yongsheng County.Geographical Research,2006,25(3):406-414.
    [3]侯翠荣,宋波,王冲.旅游度假区的景观生态格局分析及优化.山东环境,2000,(6):21-22.
    [4]汪永华,陈北光.广州白云山风景区植被景观空间关联分析.山地学报,2003,21(4):416-421.
    [5]李双成,许月卿,周巧富,王磊.中国道路网与生态系统破碎化关系统计分析.地理科学进展,2004,23(5):78-86.
    [6]史培军,陈晋,潘耀忠.深圳市土地利用变化机制分析.地理学报,2000,55(2):151-160.
    [7]张镱锂,阎建忠,刘林山,摆万奇,李双成,郑度.青藏公路对区域土地利用和景观格局的影响——以格尔木至唐古拉山段为例.地理学报,2002,57(3):253-266.
    [8]刘世梁,崔保山,杨志峰,董世魁.道路网络对澜沧江流域典型区土地利用变化的驱动分析.环境科学学报,2006,26(1):162-167.
    [10]裘丽,冯祚建.青藏公路沿线白昼交通运输等人类活动对藏羚羊迁徙的影响.动物学报,2004,50(4):669-674.
    [13]王迎化,苗维亚.基于景观生态学的自然风景区道路规划方法研究.桂林旅游高等专科学校学报,2005,16(4):74-77.
    [16]刘鸿雁,张金海.旅游干扰对香山黄栌林的影响研究.植物生态学报,1997,21(2):191-196.
    [17]程占红,张金屯,上官铁梁,张峰.芦芽山自然保护区旅游开发与植被环境的关系Ⅰ.植被环境质量分析.生态学报,2002,22(10):1765-1773.
    [18]程占红,张金屯.不同距离带上旅游植被景观的特征差异.山地学报,2003,21(6):647-652.
    [19]程占红,张金屯,上官铁梁.芦芽山自然保护区旅游开发与植被环境关系——旅游影响系数及指标分析.生态学报,2003,23(4):703-711.
    [20]石强,钟林生,汪晓菲.旅游活动对张家界国家森林公园植物的影响.植物生态学报,2004,28(1):107-113.
    [21]王忠君,蔡君,张启翔.旅游活动对云蒙山国家森林公园景观及视觉的影响评价.河北林业科技,2004,(1):32-35.
    [23]李鹏,杨桂华.云南香格里拉旅游线路产品生态足迹.生态学报,2007,27(7),2954-2963.
    [27]郑珏,李晓文,崔保山,黎聪,宋晓龙,张黎娜.云南纵向岭谷区道路网络对生态系统影响的尺度效应.生态学报,2009,29(8):4267-4277.
    [28]毛蒋兴,阎小培.城市交通干道对土地利用的廊道效应研究——以广州大道为例.地理与地理信息科学,2004,20(5):58-61.
    [31]宗跃光,周尚意,彭萍.道路生态学研究进展.生态学报,2003,23(11):2396-2405.
    [32]汪自书,刘语凡,魏建兵,曾辉.快速城市化地区道路格局对土地利用的影响研究.环境科学研究,2008,21(2):180-185.
    [33]孔宁宁,曾辉,李书娟.四川省卧龙自然保护区景观人为影响的空间分布特征研究.北京大学学报(自然科学版),2002,38(3):393-399.
    [34]曾辉,孔宁宁,李书娟.卧龙自然保护区人为活动对景观结构的影响.生态学报,2001,21(12):1995-2001.
    [35]李双成,许月卿,周巧富,王磊.中国道路网与生态系统破碎化关系统计分析.地理科学进展,2004,23(5):77-85.
    [36]刘世梁,温敏霞,崔保山,董世魁.道路网络扩展对区域生态系统的影响——以景洪市纵向岭谷区为例.生态学报,2006,26(9):3018-3024.
    [37]洪峪森,和尚勤.丽江城市水环境调查及研究.云南环境科学,2001,20(增刊):143-145.
    [39]刘巧玲,管东生.旅游活动对自然景区的非污染生态影响.生态学杂志,2005,24(4):443-447.
    [40]俞孔坚,段铁武,李迪华,彭晋福.景观可达性作为衡量城市绿地系统功能指标的评价方法与案例.城市规划,1999,23(8):8-13.
    [41]俞孔坚,李伟,李迪华,李春波,黄刚,刘海龙.快速城市化地区遗产廊道适宜性分析方法探讨——以台州市为例.地理研究,2005,24(1):69-76.
    [42]史培军,江源,王静爱,梁进社,李晓兵,陈晋,陈云浩,何春阳.土地利用/覆盖变化与生态安全响应机制.北京:科学出版社,2004.
    [43]曾辉,郭庆华,喻红.东莞市风岗镇景观人工改造活动的空间分析.生态学报,1999,19(3):10-15.
    [44]陈辉,李双成,郑度.基于人工神经网络的青藏公路铁路沿线生态系统风险研究.北京大学学报(自然科学版),2005,41(4):586-593.
    [45]马东涛,崔鹏,杨坤,王掌军.新藏公路(新疆段)沿线道路病害及成因初析.自然灾害学报,2003,12(3):93-98.
    [46]韩新民,周瑞琦.丽江7.0级地震的烈度分布.地震研究,1997,20(1):35-46.
    [47]彭建,王仰麟,张源,蒋依依,叶敏婷.滇西北山区土地持续利用动态评价与分析——以云南省永胜县为例.地理研究,2006,25(3):406-414.

版权所有:© 2023 中国地质图书馆 中国地质调查局地学文献中心