用户名: 密码: 验证码:
基于像元的地表覆盖变化信息提取方法比较
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
由于全球变化对未来人类的生存环境产生长远影响,近几十年得到国际科学界的广泛重视。地表覆盖变化是全球变化研究的重要组成部分,其又包括地表覆盖变化检测、驱动力分析、更新制图等。其中地表覆盖变化检测是变化驱动力分析与更新制图的前提和基础。本文针对地表覆盖数据更新制图的应用需求,对基于像元的灰度差值法、比值法、NDVI差值法、PCA差异法四种方法进行地表覆盖变化信息提取方法的比较实验。主要工作如下:
     (1)单一变化信息提取方法的比较实验:应用上述四种变化信息提取方法对陕西省地表覆盖数据进行变化信息提取实验,比较了这四种方法的提取精度。实验结果表明,这四种方法在30m分辨率ETM/TM影像地表覆盖变化信息提取中,PCA差异法的变化检测精度最高。但总体来讲,四种单一方法的提取精度还是偏低的(使用者精度都低于80%)。
     (2)为了获得更好的变化信息提取效果,本文在单一变化信息提取方法的基础上分析了上述四种方法提取结果的相同和相异性。实验结果表明:灰度差值法与PCA差异法的提取结果较为相似(相同的变化像元达到了76.38%)。同时NDVI差值法与其它三种方法的提取结果相差较大。造成这种状况的主要原因在于各种方法对于不同的地表覆盖的敏感程度是不一样的,其中NDVI差值法对植被覆盖变化较为敏感,故其对植被覆盖的变化检测效果较好,但同时其对水体的变化较为迟钝,造成其对水体的变化检测效果不明显。
     (3)在分析四种方法的相同和相异性的基础上,进一步研究了四种方法的不同组合情况的提取效果,包括四种不同的组合方式:1)比值法与PCA差异法求并;2)NDVI差值法与PCA差异法求并;3)NDVI差值法、比值法、PCA差异法三种方法求并;4)先对差值法、比值法、PCA差异法三种方法进行求交,再将所得结果与NDVI差值法求并。实验结果表明,比值法、NDVI差值法、PCA差异法三种方法求并的组合方式所检测的结果中包含了四种单一检测方法所检测出的全部变化像元,但比四种方法的并大大降低了过度检测现象,这种组合方式的检测效果最好。
Global change will affect human survival environment in the long-term, so it has gotten the extensive attention in the international scientific community in recent decades. Land cover change is an important component in the global change research, and it includes three aspects of contents:land cover change detection, driving force analysis, updating and mapping. Among them, land cover change detection is the premise and foundation. In this paper, image differencing, image ratioing, NDVI differencing and PCA differencing technique based on pixel are used for land cover change information extraction experiment. The main work is as follows.
     (1) Comparison between single change detection methods:Four methods which are mentioned in this paper are used to do change information extraction experiment for land cover of Shanxi province, and their extraction accuracy is evaluated. The results show that PCA differencing own highest change detection accuracy when four methods are used for land cover change information extraction experiment. But overall speaking, the accuracy of various single method is still low (user accuracy less than 80%).
     (2) In order to obtain better change information extraction effect, the sameness and dissimilarity of extraction results of four methods are analyzed in the basis of single change information extraction method. The results show that:differencing and PCA differencing have close extraction accuracy (the same change pixels reached 76.38%). At the same time, the extraction accuracy of NDVI differencing has greater difference compare with the other three methods. This situation is mainly due to a variety of methods has different degree of sensitivity for different surface cover. NDVI difference method is more sensitive to change of vegetation cover, so its change detection effect for vegetation is better. At the same time, NDVI differencing is relatively slow to change of water, so its change detection for water is ineffective.
     (3) In order to improve the change information extraction accuracy, combination of four methods to be applied according to evaluation results of the analysis of the sameness and dissimilarity. There are four different combination forms:1) The union of ratioing and PCA differencing; 2) The union of NDVI differencing and PCA differencing; 3) The union of NDVI differencing, ratioing and PCA differencing; 4) Firstly, calculate the intersection of differencing, ratioing and PCA differencing, and then calculate the union of the result and NDVI differencing. The results show that:the detection results which are generated by the union of image radioing, NDVI differencing and PCA differencing contain all the change pixels detected by four simplex methods. At the same time, this combination form reduces the over-detection phenomenon. So, the article argues that it is the best combination form.
引文
[1]Lambin E.F, Strahler A.H. Indicators of land-cover change for change-vector analysis in multi-temporal space at coarse spatial scales[J]. Remote Sensing of Environment,1994,15(10):2099~2119.
    [2]何春阳,陈晋,陈云浩,史培军.土地利用/覆盖变化混合动态监测方法研究.自然资源学报,2001,16(3):255~262.
    [3]张继贤.论土地利用与覆盖变化遥感信息提取技术框架.测绘科学,2003,28(3):13~16.
    [4]沈润平.土地利用遥感监测的关键技术及其应用研究——以江西鄱阳湖地区为例.博士论文.浙江大学.2002.
    [5]http://www.most.gov.cn/kjbgz/201003/t20100318_76324.htm.
    [6]Singh A. Digital change detection techniques using remotely sensed data[J]. Int Remote Sensing,1989,10(6):989~1003.
    [7]陈晋,李月臣,宫鹏等.基于NDVI时间序列数据的土地覆盖变化检测指标设计[J].应用基础与工程科学学报,2005,9(3)261~273.
    [8]Miller,L.D, K.Nualchawee, C.Tom. Analysis of dynamics of shifting cultivation in the tropic forest of northern Thailand using landscape modeling and classification of Landsat imagery. NASA Goddard Space Flight Center,Technical Memorandum No.79545, Grenbelt, MD,1978.
    [9]Todd, W. J. Urban and regional land use change detected by using Landsat data. U.S.Geological Survey Research Journal,1977,(5):529~534.
    [10]范海生,马蔼乃,李京等.采用图像差值法提取土地利用变化信息方法[J].遥感学报,2001,5(1):75~80.
    [11]Nelson R.F. Detecting forest canopy change due to insect activity using Landsat MSS. Photogramm. Eng. RemoteSens.1983,49:1303~1314.
    [12]赵英时,陈冬梅等.遥感应用分析原理与方法.科学出版社.北京,2003.
    [13]Malila, W. A. Change Vector analysis:an approach for detecting forest changes with Landsat. Proceeding, LARS Machine Processing of Remotely Sensed Data Symposium, W.Lafayette, in:Laboratory for the Application of Remote Sensing, PP.326~336.
    [14]Michalck, J. L., T. W. Wagner, J. J. Luczkovich, etal. Multispectral change vector analysis for monitoring coastal marine environments. Photogrammetric Engineering and Remote Sensing,1993, 59(3):381~384.
    [15]Johnson, R. D., E. S. Kasischke. Change vector analysis:A technique for the multispectral monitoring of land cover and condition. International Journal of Remote Sensing,1998,19(3):411~426.
    [16]陈晋,何春阳,史培军等.基于变化向量分析的土地利用/覆盖变化动态监测----变化阈值的确定方法[J].遥感学报,2001,5(4):259~266.
    [17]Yey A, GO. and Li X. An integrated remote sensing and GIS approach in the monitoring and evaluation of rapid urban growth for sustainable development in the Pearl River Delta, China. International Planning Studies,1997,2(2):193~ 210.
    [18]Coilins J. B. and Woodcock C. E. An assessment of several linear change detection techniques forest mortality using multi~temporal Landsat TM data. Remote Sense. Environ.1996,56:66-77.
    [19]陈志强,陈建飞.基于多波段K-L变化法的福州市城市用地及其变化信息提取[J].福建师范大学学报,2006,22(3),100~103.
    [20]陈志鹏,基于纹理特征的差值变化检测方法研究.硕士论文,中科院电子学研究所,2003.
    [21]李淑坤,李培军等.加入多时相纹理的遥感变化检测[J].国土资源遥感,2009,35~40.
    [22]Howarth J. P and Wichware G. M. Procedure for change detection using Landsat digital data. International Journal of Remote Sensing,1981,2:277~291.
    [23]秦其明.遥感图像自动解译面临的问题与解决的途径[J].测绘科学,2000,25(2):23~26.
    [24]吴柯,牛瑞卿,王毅等.基于PCA与EM算法的多光谱遥感影像变化检测研究[J].计算机科学,2010,37(3):282~285.
    [25]谢仁伟,牛铮,孙睿等.基于多波段统计检验的土地利用变化检测[J].国土资源遥感,2009,2:66~70.
    [26]刘正军.高维遥感数据土地覆盖特征提取与分类研究.博士论文.2000.中科院遥感所.
    [27]程昌秀,严泰来.朱德海,张玮.GIS与RS集成的高分辨率遥感影像分类技术在地类识别中的应用.中国农业大学学报,2001,6(3):50~54.
    [28]霍春雷,程健,卢汉清等.基于多尺度融和的对象级变化检测新方法[J].自动化学报,2008,34(3):251~257.
    [29]王文杰,赵忠明等.面向对象特征融合的高分辨率遥感图像变化检测方法 [J].计算机应用研究,2009,26(8):3149~3151.
    [30]韩闪闪,李海涛,顾海燕等.面向对象的土地利用变化检测方法研究[J].遥感信息,2009,23~29.
    [31]唐朴谦,杨建宇,张超等.基于像素比值的面向对象分类后遥感变化检测方法[J].遥感信息,2010(1),69~72.
    [32]赵福军,张磊等.面向对象的遥感震害信息提取方法----以汶川地震为例[J].地震,2009,(B10)130~137.
    [33]刘仁钊,廖文峰.遥感图像分类应用研究综述[J].地理空间信息,2005,3(5):11~13.
    [34]DAI Xiaolong, S. Khorram. The effects of image misregistration on the accuracy of remotely sensed change detection. IEEE Transactions on Geoscience and Remote Sensing,1998,36(5):1566~1577.
    [35]梅安新,彭望碌,秦其明等.遥感导论.高等教育出版社,北京.2001.
    [36]汤国安,张友顺等.遥感数字图像处理.科学出版社,北京.2007.
    [37]Teillct, PM., PN. Slater.Y. Ding, ct al. Three methods for the absolute calibration of the NOAAA VHRR sensors in—flight. Remote Sensing of Environment,1990,31(2):105~120.
    [38]Elvidge, C. D., D. Yuan, D. W. Ridgeway, etal. Relative radiometric normalization of Landsat Multispectral Scanner(MSS) data using automatic scattergram-controlled regressio. Photogrammetric Engineering and Remote Sens1995ing,1995,61(10):1255~1260.
    [39]邓湘金.基于模式识别知识的遥感图像变化检测研究.博士论文.中科院电子所.2003.
    [40]Singh, A. Digital change detection techniques using remotely sensed data International Journal of Remote Seining,1989,10(6):989~1003.
    [41]Andra, S., O. AI-Kofahi, R. J. Radke, et al. Image Change Detection Algorithms:A Systematic Survey. Technical Report, Department of Electrical, Computer and Systems Engineering, Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute, New York, USA,2003.
    [42]ZHANG Junping, SUN Wenbang. Image Change Detection Algorithm Based on Clustering Characteristic of 2-D Histogram. IEE 10th International Conference on Signal Processing (ICSP),2010,24-28.
    [43]吴谨,李娟,刘成云等.基于最大熵的灰度阈值选取方法[J].武汉科技大学学报,2004,32-35.
    [44]李雁,赵坤,方精云等.城市湖泊地区的土地利用变化——以武汉东湖为 例[J].长江流域资源与环境,2004,13(3):229~233.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700