用户名: 密码: 验证码:
牛肉产地同位素与矿物元素指纹溯源技术研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
稳定性同位素比率与矿物元素含量分析是用于食品产地溯源的有效方法之一。为了探索同位素与矿物元素指纹技术对我国牛肉产地溯源的可行性与有效性,本研究利用同位素比率质谱仪(IRMS)检测了不同地域来源的牛组织和饲料中δ~(13)C、δ~(15)N值,利用连续流动的同位素比率质谱仪(CF-IRMS)检测了牛尾毛中的δD值,利用等离子体质谱仪(ICP-MS)检测了脱脂牛肉中的~(206)Pb/~(207)Pb和~(208)Pb/~(207)Pb比值及Na、Mg、Al、K、Ca、V、Mn、Fe、Co、Ni、Cu、Zn、Ga、As、Se、Sr、Zr、Mo、Sn、Sb、Ba、Pb 22种矿物元素的含量,利用热电离质谱(TIMS)测定了脱脂牛肉中~(87)Sr/~(86)Sr比值,并借助SAS和DPS多元统计分析软件对检测结果进行了方差分析、多重比较分析、主成分分析、聚类分析和判别分析,系统研究了不同地域来源牛组织中同位素比率、矿物元素含量的差异,脱脂牛肉、粗脂肪、牛尾毛中碳、氮同位素组成的相关关系,各项同位素指标、矿物元素含量对牛肉产地的判别效果,以及它们与养殖环境的变化关系等。
     此外,针对实际研究中牛肉样品采样困难及成本问题,用牛尾毛代替牛肉进行追溯研究的可能性,设计了以牛尾毛为采样材料的牛肉产地同位素溯源技术模型试验。比较了牛前部、中部、后部肌肉及心脏、肝脏、肺脏之间δ~(13)C、δ~(15)N值的差异,分析了牛尾毛生长的不同段位δ~(13)C、δ~(15)N值随喂养饲料的变化趋势,以及牛尾毛与肌肉组织、饲料中同位素的相关关系,探讨了利用牛尾毛为材料追溯牛肉产地及其生活史的可行性。
     结果表明,不同地域来源的牛各组织中同位素比率与矿物元素含量有很大差异,并且有其各自的指纹特征:脱脂牛肉、粗脂肪、牛尾毛中碳、氮同位素呈极显著相关性,它们对牛肉产地的判别结果基本相同,均可用于牛肉产地溯源研究。在本研究的取样范围内,碳、氮、氘、铅和锶同位素对牛肉产地的判别效果由好到劣的次序依次为δ~(13)C>δD>~(206)Pb/~(207)Pb>δ~(15)N>~(208)Pb/~(207)Pb、~(87)Sr/~(86)Sr,判别较好的矿物元素指标依次为Se、Sr、Fe、Ni和Zn,两类指标组合能显著提高对牛肉产地的正确判别率。不同部位肌肉、不同内脏器官中碳、氮同位素无显著差异,即取样部位不影响碳、氮同位素比值的分析结果。饲料对牛组织中δ~(13)C、δ~(15)N值的影响远大于品种和个体的影响,尤其与主饲料成分密切相关,而且品种与个体对牛组织中δ~(15)N值的影响大于对δ~(13)C值的影响:在牛饲料中C_4植物与C_3植物比例差异较大的地域,δ~(13)C指标对牛肉产地的判别效果比较好:δ~(15)N指标可有效区分牧区与农区喂养的牛。牛组织中的δD值与地理条件密切相关,有随着纬度的增加而减小的趋势。牛组织对饲料中~(13)C的富集比例约在3‰左右,对~(15)N的富集比例约在3‰-5‰之间,饲料种类、牛品种、个体对富集比例均有一定影响;牛尾毛对~(13)C的富集比例大于脱脂牛肉,而对~(15)N的富集比例小于脱脂牛肉,脂肪组织对~(13)C有贫化作用。牛尾毛与脱脂肌肉、粗脂肪组织中碳、氮同位素呈极显著相关性,但随着饲料的改变,不同段位牛尾毛中碳、氮同位素与肌肉组织的相关性有很大差异;一般牛尾毛距离根部0—3cm与肌肉组织中δ~(13)C、δ~(15)N值相关性最高。
     从上述研究结果中可以得出,同位素与矿物元素指纹技术对牛肉产地的追溯是行之有效的,以牛尾毛为研究材料追溯牛肉产地及其生活史是可行的。
The analysis of stable isotope ratio and mineral element content is one of effective methods for food geographical origin traceability. The objective of this article was to probe into the feasibility and validity using the analysis of isotope and minernal element fingerprint for cattle geographical origin traceability. Theδ~(13)C andδ~(15)N values of cattle tissues and feeds were determined using isotope ratio mass spectrometry (IRMS), the 8D values of cattle tail hair were determined using continuous flow-isotope ratio mass spectrometry (CF-IRMS), the ratio of ~(206)Pb/~(207)Pb, ~(208)Pb/~(207)Pb and the content of Na、Mg、Al、K、Ca、V、Mn、Fe、Co、Ni、Cu、Zn、Ga、As、Se、Sr、Zr、Mo、Sn、Sb、Ba、Pb were determined using the inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (1CP-MS), and the ratio of ~(87)Sr/~(86)Sr were determined using the thermal ionization mass spectrometry (TIMS). Then the data were performed using multivariate analysis including ANOVA, principal component analysis (PCA), cluster analysis (CA), linear discrimant analysis (LDA) with the help of SAS and DPS package for windows. The research were mainly focused on different analysis of stable isotope ratio and mineral element content of cattle from different regions, correlation analysis of carbon and nitrogen isotopic composion between de-fatted beef, crude fat and cattle tail hair, discrimant analysis using stable isotope ratios and mineral contents for cattle geographical origin assessment, and the relationship between stable isotope ratios, mineral contents of cattle tissues and their breeding environment.
     In addition, the model experiment for cattle geographical origin traceability using stable isotope analysis was designed because of the difficulties in beef samples taking, higher cost, and the probability of using cattle tail hair instead of beef in the study of cattle traceability. The difference ofδ~(13)C,δ~(15)N values among muscle from foreside, central section, rump of cattle and cattle organs including heart, liver and lung were compared. The changing trends ofδ~(13)C,δ~(15)N values in different segment of cattle tail hair with the change of feeds composition were analyzed, and the correlationship between cattle tail hair, muscle, and feeds were studied to probe into the feasibility of tracing the cattle geographical origin and their feeding history using cattle tail hair instead of muscle.
     The results showed that there were very significant differences according to region in the mean values of carbon, nitrogen, lead, hydrogen isotope ratios and minernal element content in the cattle tissues. The fingerprint of these indicators in cattle tissues from the different regions was unique. A significant correlationship was found in carbon and nitrogen isotope ratios between de-fatted beef, crude fat and cattle tail hair. The results of discrimant ananlysis were consistent using these indicators, which indicated that all of them could be used for cattle geographical origin treaceablity. The order of isotopic indicators wereδ~(13)C>δD>~(206)Pb/~(207)Pb>δ~(15)N>~(208)Pb/~(207)Pb and ~(87)Sr/~(86)Sr according to the rate of correct classification from high to low for cattle geographical origin, and the order of mineral element were Se>Sr>Fe>Ni>Zn according to the rate of correct clissification. Furthermore, the rate of correct classification could be improved by combination of these indicators. The model experiment showed that there was no significant difference inδ~(13)C andδ~(15)N values between muscles from different position and different organs, i.e. theδ~(13)C andδ~(15)N values of cattle tissues was not affected by sample from different position. The feeds, especially the staple feeds, had more effect on theδ~(13)C andδ~(15)N values of cattle tissues, while the variety and individual had less effect on them. The variety and individual had more effect onδ~(15)N thanδ~(13)C. Theδ~(13)C value in cattle tissues was very good in classifying the beef coming from the different regions where cattle feeds were significantly different in the proportion of C_4 and C3. Theδ~(15)N value was good to distinguish the cattle from the farm land and the pasture. The 8D in cattle tissues was closely related to the geographical conditions and was decreasing as the latitude was increasing. De-fatted beef and cattle tail hair enriched in ~(13)C to their feeds in the proportion of 3%o, and enriched in ~(15)N in the proportion of 3‰- 5‰, plus, cattle variety and individual had effect on the proportion of enrichment. Cattle tail hair enriched in ~(13)C much more than de-fatted beef, but less than de-fatted beef in ~(15)N, while fat tissue depleted in ~(13)C relative to feeds. Though a significant correlation was found between cattle tail hair, de-fatted beef and crude fat, there was a different correlation between cattle tail hair of different segment and muscle in carbon and nitrogen isotope ratio. The results showed that theδ~(13)C andδ~(15)N values of cattle tail hair in the segment which distance from root (0-3cm) was highly correlated with that of the muscle.
     The above results showed that the technique of isotope and mineral element fingerprint was an effective method for cattle geographical origin traceability, and was feasible to trace the cattle geographical origin and their feeding histoty using cattle tail hair.
引文
1.白云峰,陆昌华,李秉柏.畜产品安全的可追溯管理.食品科学,2005,26(8):473~477.
    2.蔡德陵,李红燕.稳定碳、氮同位素在河流系统研究中的应用.海洋科学进展,2004,22(2):22~232.
    3.蔡德陵,张淑芳,张经.稳定碳、氮同位素在生态系统研究中的应用.青岛海洋大学学报,2002,32(2):28~295.
    4.陈良洲,叶虎年.一种新的虹膜识别算法研究.华北工学院测试技术学报,2000,14(4):21~216.
    5.范积平,张柳瑛,张贞良,吴玉田.不同产地大黄药材的近红外漫反射光谱法鉴别.药学实践杂志,2005,23(3):14~150.
    6.方炎,高观,范新鲁,陈华宁.我国食品安全追溯制度研究.农业质量标准,2005,(2):37~39.
    7.高欢欢,杨军,郭光沁,郑国锠.DNA指纹技术新进展,2001,23(4):196~199.
    8.郭波莉,魏益民,潘家荣,李勇,张福松.牛不同组织中稳定性碳同位素组成及变化规律研究.中国农业科学,2006,39(9):1885~1890.
    9.郭波莉,魏益民,潘家荣,李勇.碳、氮同位素在牛肉产地溯源中的应用研究.中国农业科学,2007,40(2):365~372.
    10.郭波莉,魏益民,潘家荣.同位素溯源技术在食品安全中的应用.核农学报,2006,(2):148~153.
    11.郭波莉,魏益民,潘家荣.同位素指纹分析技术在食品产地溯源中的应用进展.农业工程学报,2007,23(3):284~289.
    12.黄宝康,朱斌郑,汉臣,秦路平,张巧艳.不同产地楮实子及伪品的近红外漫反射指纹图谱聚类分析.中药材,2002,25(12):874~875.
    13.黄雅平,罗四维,陈恩义.基于独立分量分析的虹膜识别算法.计算机研究与发展,2003,40(10):1451~1457.
    14.黄志勇,杨妙峰,庄峙厦,王小如等.利用铅同位素比值判断丹参不同产地来源.分析化学,2003,31(9):1036~1039.
    15.荆淼,金兴良,庄峙厦,王小如,黎先春.近红外漫反射光谱技术在甘草指纹图谱中的研究.现代中药研究与实践,2004,18(增刊):6~9.
    16.李长有.DNA指纹技术的研究进展及应用.吉林师范大学学报,2004,2:56~58.
    17.梁一鸿,张宏颖.十八倾壕金矿床硫同位素组成的构造学意义,地质与勘探,2004,40(6):1~4.
    18.林金龙,石青云.一种基于结构特征的识别算法.计算机工程与应用,2003,13:83~84,137.
    19.林文珍.DNA指纹技术及应用.医学文选,2000,19(4):540~543.
    20.刘飞.法国对动植物产品实施溯源性管理.全球经济瞭望,2002,(2):16~17.
    21.刘沭华,张学工,周群,孙素琴.近红外漫反射光谱法和模式识别技术鉴别中药材产地.光谱学与光谱分析,2006,26(4):629~632.
    22.刘树俊,程光潮.DNA指纹技术所用的探针及其发展.遗传,1994,16(2):40~43.
    23.庞洪喜,何元庆,张忠林.重要海气天文事件与新德里季风降水中δ~(18)O的关系.冰川冻土,2004,26:42~47
    24.彭林,白志鹏,朱坦,徐永昌,李剑,冯银厂.应用稳定碳同位素组成特征研究环境空气颗粒物中多环芳烃的来源.环境科学,2004,25(6):16~20.
    25.史春香,杨悦武,郭治昕,祝国光.近红外技术鉴别黄芪产地.天津药学,2006,18(1):19~21.
    26.史作民,程瑞梅,刘世荣.高山植物叶片δ~(13)C的海拔影响及其机理.生态学报,2004,12:2901~2906.
    27.苏小四,林学钰,廖资生,王金生.黄河水中δ~(18)O、δD和~3H的沿程变化特征及其影响因素研究.地球化学,2003,24(4):349~357.
    28.孙洪亮,李建辉.全球统一标识系统在食品安全跟踪与追溯体系中的应用.食品科学,2004,125(6):188~194.
    29.涂正超,黄炎坤.DNA指纹技术及其在畜牧科学中的应用.黄牛杂志,1996,22(1):28~30.
    30.王琬,刘咸德,鲁毅强,郭冬发,李玉武,田肖丹,Adams F.北京冬季大气颗粒物中铅的同位素丰度比的测定和来源分析.质谱学报,2002,23(1):21~29.
    31.王平,陈泽琴,谢洪平,蔡铎昌.不同产地中药材的近红外光谱初步研究.西华师范大学学报(自然科学版),2004,25(1):92~95.
    32.王福钧 主编.农学中同位素示踪技术.北京:农业出版社,1989.
    33.王国安.中国北方草本植物及表土有机质碳同位素组成[博士学位论文].北京:中国科学院地质与地球物理研究所,2001.
    34.王蕴红,朱勇,谭铁宁.基于虹膜识别的身份鉴定.自动化学报,2002,28(1):1~10.
    35.肖化云,刘丛强,李思亮.贵阳地区夏季雨水硫和氮同位素地球化学特征.地球化学,2003,32(3):248~254.
    36.邢旺兴,刘荔荔,贾暖,林培英,宓鹤鸣,吴玉田.不同产地红曲的近红外漫反射光谱聚类分析鉴别.中药材,2001,24(8):561~563.
    37.杨同华,刘福旭著.稳定同位素.北京:原子能出版社,1988.
    38.叶学义,庄镇家,张云超.一种新颖的虹膜识别算法.电路与系统学报,2003,8(2):75~80.
    39.于维军.建立质量安全追溯提升我国农畜产品竞争力.动物科学与动物医学,2004,21(9):46~48.
    40.苑金鹏,钟宁宁.稳定碳同位素在污染物源解析中的应用.环境科学动态,2003,4:9~10.
    41.张涵,李素彩.应用条形码技术进行食品溯源的可行性分析.物流技术,2006,(1):32~33.
    42.张鸿斌,胡霭琴,卢承祖,张国新.华南地区酸沉降的硫同位素组成及其环境意义.中国环境科学,2002,22(2):165~169.
    43.张鹏飞,李德胜,王祁.一种快速虹膜算法的研究.光电子·激光,2005,16(8):997~999,1006.
    44.张西营,马海州,谭红兵.Sr的地球化学指示意义及其应用.盐湖研究,2002,10(3):38~44.
    45.周文峰.同位素判官.检查风云,2004,19;62~63.
    46.朱琳,苏小四.地下水硝酸盐中氮、氧同位素研究现状与展望.地质世界,2003,22(4):396~403.
    47. Alissandrakis E, Kibaris A C, Tarantilis P A, Harizanis P C, Polission M. Flavour compounds of Greek cotton honey. Journal of the Science of Food and Agriculture, 2005, 85(9) : 1444~1452.
    48.Al-Jowder O, Kemsley E K, Wilson R H. Detection of adulteration in cooked meat products by mid-infrared spectroscopy. Journal of Agricultural Food Chemistry, 2002, 50(6) : 1325~1329.
    49.Anderson R M, Donnelly C A, Ferguson N M, Woolhouse M E J, Watt C J, Udy H J. Transmission dynamics and epidemiology of BSE in British cattle.Nature,1996,382:779~788.
    50. Anderson R M,Magnuson B A,Tschirgi M L,Smith B.Determination the geographic origin of potatoes with trace element analysis using statistical and neural network classifiers.Journal of Agricultural Food Chemistry,1999,(47) :1568~1574.
    51. Anon.Cheese and processed cheese products.Determination of chloride content.Potentiometric titration method.IDF Standard 88A,1988.
    52. Baldini M,Stacchini P,CubaddaF,Miniero R,Parodi P,Facelli P.Cadmium in organs and tissues of horses slaughtered in Italy.Food Additive and Contaminant,2000,17(8) :679~687.
    53. Baxter G A,O'Connor M,Haughey S A,Crooks S R H,Elliott C T.Evaluation of an immunobiosensor for the onsite testing ofveterinary drug residues at an abattoir.Aanlyst,1999,124(9) :1315~1318.
    54. Beresford T P,Fitzsimons N O,Brennan N L,Cogan T M.Recent advance in cheese microbiology.Int.Dairy J.,2001,(11) :259~274.
    55. Bettina M F,Gremaud G,Hadorn R,Kreuzer M.Geographic origin of meat-element of an analytical approach to its authentication.European Journal of Food Technology,2005,(221) :493~503.
    56. Bettina M F,Koslitz S,MicauxF,Piantini U,Maury V,PfammatterE,Wunderli S,Gremaud G,Bosset J O,Hadorn R,Kreuzer M.Tracing the geographical origin of poultry meat and dried beef with oxygen and strontium isotope ratios.European food resources and technolog,2007,DOI 10. 1007/s00217-007-0588-x.
    57. Boles W W,Boashash B.A human identification technique using images of the iris and wavelet transform.IEEE Transactions on Signal Processing,1998,46(4) :1185~1188.
    58. Boner M,F(?)rstel H.Stable isotope variation as a tool to trace the authenticity of beef.Analytical and Bioanalytical Chemistry,2004,378:301~310.
    59. Boutton T W,Arshad M A,Tieszen L L.Stable isotope analysis of termite food habits in East African grasslands.Oecologia,1983,(1) :1~6.
    60. Branch S,Burke S,Evans P,Fairman B,Céline S J Wollff Briche.A preliminary study in determining the geographical origin of wheat using isotope ratio inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry with ~(13) C,~(15) N mass spectrometry.Journal of analytical atomic spectrometry,2003,18(1) :17~22.
    61. Brescia M A,Caldarola V,Buccoloeri G,Dell'ATTI A,Sacco A.Chemometric determination of the geographical origin of cow milk using ICP-OES data and isotopic ratios:A preliminary stury.Italian Journal of Food Science,2003,15(3) :329~336.
    62. Bricout J,Koziet J.Detection of the addition sugar to orange juice by isotopic analysis.Science aliment.1985,(5) :197~204.
    63. Bryant J D,Froelich P N.A model of oxygen isotope fractionation in body water of large mammals.Geochim.Cosmochim.Acta,1995,59:4523~4537.
    64. Camin F,Wietzerbin K,Cortes A B,Haberhauer G,Lees M,Versini G.Application of multielement stable isotope ratio analysis to the characterization of French,Italian,and Spanish cheeses.Journal of Agriculture and Food Chemistry,2004,52:6952~6601.
    65. Celine Germain.Traceability implementation in developing countries,its possibilities and its constraints. FAO,2003.
    66. Chambaz A,Scheeder M R L,Kreuzer M,Dufey P A.Meat quality of Angus,Simmental,Charolais and Limousin steers compared at the same intramuscular fat content.Meat Science,2003,63:491~500.
    67. Chikuni K,Ozutsumi K,Koishikawa T,Kato S.Species identification of cookies meats by DNA hybridization assay.Meat Science,1990,(27) :119~128.
    68. Chisholm B S,Nelson D E,Schwarcz.Stable carbon isotope ratios as a measure of marine versus terrestrial protein in ancient diets.Science,1982,(216) :1131~1132.
    69. Coetzee P P,Vanhaecke F.Classifying wine according to geographical origin via quadrupole-based ICP-mass spectrometry measurement of boron isotope rations.Analytical and Bioanalytical Chemistry,2005,383:977~984.
    70. CozzolinoD,MattoD,Martins D V.MR reflectance spectroscopy for predicting composition and tracing system of production of beef muscle.Animal Science,2002,74:477~484.
    71. Daugman J G.Complete Discrete 2D Gabor Transformsby Neural Networksoflmage Analysis and Compression.IEEE Transactions on Acoustics Speech & Signal processing,1988,36(1) :1169~1179.
    72. DeNiro M J,Epstein S.Influence of diet on the distribution of carbon isotopes in animals.Geochimicha et Cosmochimica Acta,1981,(45) :341~351.
    73. Farquhar G D,Ehleringer J R,Hubick K T.Carbon isotope discrimination and photosynthesis.Annual review of plant physiology and plant molecular biology,1989,(40) :503~537.
    74. Friedli C,Geering J J,Lerch P.Some aspects of behaviour of ~(90) Sr in the environment.Radiochimica Acta,1991,(52) :237~240.
    75. Froidevaux P,Geering J-J,Pillonel L,Bosset J O,Valley J F.~(90) Sr,~(238) U,~(234) U,~(137) Cs,~(40) K and ~(239/240) Pu in Emmental type cheese produced in different region of Western Europe.Journal of Environmental radioactivity,2004(72) :287~298.
    76. Fronza G,Fuganti C,Grasselli P.Determination of ~(13) C content of glycerol sample of different origin.Journal of Agriculture and Food Chemistry,1998,46:477~480.
    77. Fry B.Natural stable carbon isotope tag traces Texas shrimp migration.Fishery Bulletin,1983,(79) :337~345.
    78. Gajendragad R,Kamath K N Y,Anil P Y,Prabhudas K,Natarajan C.development and standardization of a peszo electric immunobiosensor for foot and mouth disease virus typing.Veterinary Microbiology,2001,78:319~330.
    79. Gannes L Z,O' Brien D M,Martinez del Rio C.Stable isotopes in animal ecology:Assumption,caveats and a call for more laboratory experimens.Ecology,1997,(78) :1271~1276.
    80. Garnsworthy P,Wiseman J,Fegeros K.Prediction of chemical,nutritive and agronomic characteristics of wheat by NIR spectroscopy.Journal of Agricultural Science,2000,135:409~417.
    81. Gonzalez-Martin I,Gonzalez-Perez C,Hernandez-Mendez J.Mineral analysis(Fe,Zn,Ga,Na,K)of fresh Iberian pork loin by near infrared reflectance spectrometry-determination of Fe,Na and K with a remote fibre-optic reflectance probe.Analytical Chimica Acta,2002,468:293~301
    82. Gremaud G.Quaile S,Piantini U,Pfammatter E,Corvi C.Characterization of Swiss vineyards using isotope data in bombination with trace element and classical parameters.European food resources and technolog.2004,(219) :97~104.
    83. Guillou C,Koziet J,Rossmann A,Martin G J.Determination of the ~(13) C content of organic acids and sugars in fruit juices:An intercomparision study.Analytica Chimica Acta,1999,(388) :137~143
    84. Heaton T H F,The ~(15) N/~(14) N ratios of plant in south Africa and Namibia:the relationship to climate and coastal/aline environments.Oecologia(Berlin),1987,(74) :236~246.
    85. Hegerding L,Seidler D,Danneel H J,Gessler A,Nowak B.Oxygen isotope-ration-analysis for the determination of the origin of beef.Fleischwirtschaft,2002,82(4) :95~100.
    86. Higgs D R.et al.Nucleic Acids Research,1981,9:4213~4224.
    87. Hintze K J,Lardy G P,Marchello M J,Finley J W.Selenium accumulation in Beef:Effect of dietary selenium and geographical area of animal origin.Journal of Agricultural Food Chemistry,2002,50:3938~3942.
    88. Hintze K J,Lardy G P,Marchello M J,Finley J W.Areas with high concentrations of selenium in the soil and forage produce beef with enhanced concentration of selenium.Journal of Agriculture and Food Chemistry,2001,49:1062~1067.
    89. Hobbie E A,Werner R A.Intramolecular,compound-soedific,and bulk carbon isotope pattern in C-3 and C-4 plants:a review and synthesis.New Phytol,2004,(161) :371~385.
    90. Hogberg P.Development of N-15 enrichment in a nitrogen-fertilizer forest soil plant-system.Soil Biol.Biochem,1991,(23) :335~338.
    91. IAEA/WMO.Global network of isotope in precipipation.The GNIP Database,http://isohis.iaea.org.
    92. Isaksson K O,EUekjaer H R,Hildrum K I.Determination of the previous maximum temperature of heat treated minced meat by NIRS.Journal of the Science of Food and Agriculture,1989,69:385~387.
    93. Jamin E,Gonzalez J,Remaud G,Naulet N,Martin G G,Weber D,Rossmann A,Schmidt H L.Improved detection of sugar addition to apple juices and concentrates using internal standard ~(13) C IRMS.Analytica Chimica Acta,1997,(347) :359~368.
    94. Jean-Pierre Renou,Guy Bielicki,Christine Deponge,Pierre Gachon,Dedier Micol,Patrick Ritz.Characterization of animal products according to geographic origin and feeding diet using nuclear magnetic resonance and isotope ratio mass spectrometry.Part Ⅱ:Beef meat.Food Chemistry,2004,86:251~256.
    95. Jean-Pierre Renou,Christine Deponge,Pierre Gachon,Jean-Claude Bonnefoy,Jean-Baptiste Coulon,Jean-Paul Garel,Raymond Vérité,Patrick Ritz.Characterization of animal products according to geographic origin and feeding diet using nuclear magnetic resonance and isotope ratio mass spectrometry:cow milk.Food Chemistry,2004,85:63~66.
    96. JefferyA J,Wilson V,Thein S L.Hypervarible Minisatellite Region in Human DNA.Nature,1985,314:67~73.
    97. Kelly S,Heaton K,Hoogewerff J.Tracing the geographical origin of food:The application of multi-element and multi-isotope analysis.Trends in food science & technology,2006(xx):1~13.
    98. Kelly S,Baxter M,C hapman S.Rhodes C,Dennis J,Brereton P.The application of isotopic and elemental analysis to determine the geographical origin of premium long grain rice.European Food Resource and Technology,2002,214:72~78.
    99. Kornexl B E,Thomas Werner Andreas Roβmann,Hanns-Ludwig Schmidt.Measurement of stable isotope abundances in milk and milk ingredients-a possible tool for origin assignment and quality control.Zeitschrift für Lebensmitteluntersuchung und-Forschung A,1997,205:19~24.
    100. Leonard Z.Gannes,Carlos Martínez del Rio,Paul Koch.Natural abundance variations in stable isotopes and their potential uses in animal physiological ecology.Comparative Biochemistry and Physiology-Part A:Molecular & Integrative Physiology,1998,119(3) :725~737.
    101. Manca G,Camin F,Coloru G C,Caro A D,Depentori D.,Franco M.A.,Versini G.Characterization of the geographical origin of Pecorino Cheese by casein stable isotope(13C/12C and 15N/14N)ratios and free amino acid ratios.Journal of Agriculture and Food Chemistry,2001,49:1404~1409.
    102. Manca G,Franco M A,Del Caro A,Coloru G C.The role of the free amino acids profile in characterising "Pecorino Sardo" Cheese.Journal of commodity science,1999,(38) :167~179.
    103. Marisa C R A,Tirsea M S D V.Determination of lead isotope rations in port wine by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry after pre-treatment by UV-irradiation.Analytica Chimica Acta,1999,(396) :45~53.
    104. Marisa C,Almeida R,Tiresa M S D Vasconcelos.Dose the winemaking process influence the wine ~(87) Sr/~(86) Sr? A case study.Food Chemistry,2004,85:7~12.
    105. Martin G J,Koziet J,Rossmann A,Dennis J.Site-specific natural isotope fractionation in fruit juices determined by deuterium NMR,An European inter-laboratory comparison study.Analytica Chimica Acta,1996,(321) :137~146
    106. Martin G J,Martin M L.Deuterium labeling at the nature abundance level as studied by high field quantitative 2H-NMR.Tetrahedron Letters,1991,(22) :3525~3528.
    107. Martin G J.Guillou C,Martin M L,Cabanis M T,Tep X,Aerny J.Natural factors of isotope fractionation and the characterization of wines.Journal of agriculture and food chemistry,1988,(36) :316~322.
    108. Matt Sponheimer,Todd Robison,Linda Ayliffe,Ben Passey.An experiment study of carbon-isotope fractionation between diet,hair,and feces of mammalian herbivores.Canadian Journal of Zoology,2003,81(5) :871~879.
    109. McElhinney J,Doewney G,O'onnell C.Quantification of lamb content in mixture with raw minced beef using visible,near and mid infrared spectroscopy.Journal of Food Science,1999,64(4) :587~591.
    110. Meints V W,Boone L V,Kurtz L T.Natural N-15 abundance in soil,leaves,and grain as influenced by long term additions of fertilizerN at several rates.J.Enviro.Qual,1975,(4) :486~490.
    111. Moe.Perspectives on tracebility in food manufacture.Trends in food science & Technology,1998,(9) : 211~214.
    112. Montet D.Proposition to use DGGE for analysis the microbial flora of fish.2004,CIRAD,Montpellier,France.Http://www.tracenews.net/doddiers/codebarre2. php
    113. Norman A L,Hopper J F,Blanchard P,Ernst D,Brice K.Alexandrou N,Klouda G.The stable carbon isotope composition of atmospheric PAHs.Atmospheric Enviroment,1999,(33) :2807~2814.
    114. O'Leary M H.Carbon isotope in photosynthesis.Bioscience,1988. (38) :328~336.
    115. O'Leary M.Carbon isotope fraction in plants.Phytochemistry,1981,(20) :553~567.
    116. Opara L U,Mazaud F.Food traceability from field to plate.Outlook Agr,2001,(30) :239~247.
    117. Ostrom N E,Konke K E,Hedin L O,Robertson G P,Smucker A J M.Temporal trends in nitrogen isotope values of nitrate leaching from an agricultural soil.Chem.Geol.,1998,(146) :219~227.
    118. Padovan G J,De Jong D,RodriguesLP,Marchini J S.Detection of adulteration of commercial honey sample by the ~(13) C/~(12) C isotope ration.Food Chemistry,2003,82:633~636.
    119. Patrick Ritz,Pierre Gachon,Jean-Paul Garel,Jean-Claude Bonnefoy,Jean-Baptiste Coulon,Jean-Pierre Renou.Milk characterization:effect of the breed.Food Chemistry,2005,91:521~523.
    120. Peres B,Barlet N,Loiseau G,Montet D.Review of the current methods of analytical traceability allowing determination of the origin of foodstuffs.Food Control,2007,18:228~235.
    121. Peter J Y,Thomas H O'Donnell.Source apportionment of polychlorinated bipheyls using compound specific isotope analysis.Organic Geochemistry,2003,34:239~251.
    122. Petzke K J,Boeing H,Klaus S,Metges C C.Carbon and nitrogen stable isotopic composition of hair protein and amino acids can be used as biomarkers for animal-derived dietary protein intake in humans.Nutritional Methodology.2005:1516~1520.
    123. Pfeifer H R,Derron M H,Rey D,Schlegel C,Atteia O,Dalla P R,Dubois J P,Mandia Y.Natural trace element input to the soil-sediment-water-plant system:example of background and contamination situation in Switzerland,Eastern France and Northern Italy.Elsevier,Amsterdam,2000:33~86.
    124. Philip Dziuk.Positive,accurate animal identification.Animal Reproduction Science,2003,(79) :319~323.
    125. Piasentier E,Valusso R,Camin F,Versini G.Stable isotope ratio analysis for authentication of lamb meat.Meat Science,2003,64:239~247.
    126. Pillonel L,Badertscher R,Froidevaux P,Haberhauer G,H(?)lzl S,Horn P,Jakob A,Pfammatter E.,Piantini U,Rossmann A.,Tabacchi R.,Bosset J.O..Stable isotope rations,major,trace and radioactive elements in emmental cheeses of different origins.Lebensm.-Wiss.U.-Technol,2003,36(2003) :615~623
    127. Pires F,Lemos M C,Kessler A M.Use of MR reflectance spectroscopy to analysis vitamin content.Journal of Applied Poultry Research,2001,14(4) :412~418.
    128. Pripp A H,Kieronczyk A,Stepaniak L,S(?)rhaug T.Comparision of biochemical characteristics of three Norweign cheese varieties using multivariate statistical analysis.Milchwissenschaft,1999,54(10) :558~562.
    129. Razminowicz R H,Kreuzer M,Lerch K,Scheeder M R L.Quality of beef from grass-based production systems compared with beef from intensive production systems.In:Lilcher A,Jeangros B,Kessler W,Hugenenin O,Lobsiger M,Millar N,Suter D.Land use systems in grassland dominated regions.2004,9: 1151~1153.
    130. Riley R R,Smith G C,Cross H R,Savell J W,Long C R,Cartwright T C.Chronological age and breed-type effects on carcass characteristics and palatability of bull beef.Meat Science,1986,17:187~198.
    131. Rossmann A,Kornexl B E,Versini G,Pichlmayer F,Laprecht G.Origin assignment of milk from alpine regions by multielement stable isotope ration analysis(SIRA).Journal of food science and nutrition,1998. (1) :9~21.
    132. Rossmann A.Koziet J,Martin G J,Dennis M J.Determination of the carbon-13 content of sugars and pulp from fruit juices by isotope-ration mass spectrometry(internal reference method)A European inter laboratory comparison.Analytica Chimica Acta,1997,340:21~29.
    133. Rossmann A.Determination of stable isotope rations in food analysis.Food Reviews International,2001,17(3) :347~381.
    134. Rossmannn A,Haberhauer G,H(?)lzl S,Horn P,Pichlmayer F,Voerkelius S.The potential of multielement stable isotope analysis for regional origin assignment of butter.Europe Food Resource and Technology,2000,(211) :32~40.
    135. Samsonova J V,Bacter G A,Crooks S R H,Small A E,Elliott C T.Determination of ivermectin in bovine liver by optical immunobiosensor.Biosensors and bioelectronics,2001,17:523~529.
    136. Schipper E F,Rauchalles S,Kooyman RPH,Hock B,Greve J.The waveguide mach-zender interferometer as atrazine sensor.Analytical Chemistry,1998,70:1192~1197.
    137. Schmidt O,Quilter J M,Bahar B,Moloney A P,ScrimgeourCM,Begley I S,Monahan F J.Inferring the origin and dietary history of beef from C,N and S stable isotope ratio analysis.Food Chemistry,2005,91:545~549.
    138. Schw(?)gele F.Traceability from a European perspective.Meat Science,2005,71(1) :164~173.
    139. Schwertl M,AuerswaldK,Sch(?)ufele R,Schnyder H.Carbon and nitrogen stable isotope composition of cattle hair:ecological fingerprints of production system? Agriculture,Ecosystems and Enviromen,2005,www.elsevier.Com / locate/ agee
    140. Schwertl M,Auerswald K,Schnyder H.Reconstruction of the isotope history of animal diets by hair segment analysis.Rapid Communications in Mass Spectrometr,2003,17:1312~1318.
    141. Schwind K H.Patterns of environment contaminants-suitable for determination the geographical origin of meat sanmples.Fleischwirtschaft,2005,85(8) :110~112.
    142. Serra F,Guillou C G,Reniero F,Ballarin L,Cantagallo M I,Wieser M,Iyer S S,Heberger K,Vanhaecke F.Determination of the geographical origin of green coffee by principal component analysis of carbon,nitrogen and boron stable isotope ratios.Rapid Communication in Mass Spectrometry,2005,19(15) :2111~2115.
    143. Simon E W,Richard P E,Rossell J B.δ~(13) C analyses of vegetable oil fatty acid components determined by gas chromatography-combustion-isotope ration mass spectrometry,after saponification or regiospecific hydrolysis.Journal of Chromatography A,1998,805:249~257.
    144. Simpkins W A,Patel G,Harrison M,Goldberg David.Stable carbon isotope ratio analysis of Australian orange juices.Food Chemistry,2000,70:385~390.
    145. Sponheimer M,Robinson T,Ayliffe L,Passey B.An experiment study of carbon-isotope fractionation between diet,hair,and feces of mammalian herbivores.Canadian Journal of Zoology.2003,81(5) :871~879.
    146. Stefaan De Smet,An Balcaen.Erik Claeys,Pascal Boeckx,Oswald van Cleemput.Stable carbon isotope analysis of different tissue of beef animal in relation to their diet.Rapid Communications in Mass Spectrometry,2004,18:1227~1232.
    147. Sutoh M,Obara Y,Yoneyama T.The effects of feeding regimen and dietary sucrose supplementation on natural abundance of N-15 in some components of ruminal fruid and plasma of sheep.Journal of animal science,1993,(71) :226~231.
    148. Thies I,Lüpke M,Seifert H.Factors influencing the ~(18) O/~(16) O-ratio in meat juices.Isotopes Environ.Health Stud,2004,40(3) :191~197.
    149. Thyholt K,Enersen G,Isaksson T.Determination of endpoint temperature in previously heat treated beef using reflectance spectroscopy.Meat Science,1998,48(1/2) :49~63
    150. Van den bossche A,Van Nevel C,Herman L,DecuypereJ,De smet S,Heyndrickx M.PCR-TGGE:A method for fingerprinting the microbial flora in the small inrestine of pigs.In Abstract symposium of the Belgian Society for Microbiology(BSE)and the antional committee for microbiology,emerging and recurrent infectious diseases,2000,Louvain-Neuve,France.
    151. Vaughan R D,Geary E,Pravda M,Guilbault G G.Piezoelectric immunosensors for environmental monitoring.International Journal of Environmental and Analytical Chemistry,2003,83:555~571.
    152. Verkaar E L C,Boutaga K,Nijman I J,Lenstra J A.Differentiation of bovine species in beef by PCR-RFLP of mitochondrial and satellite DNA.Meat Science,2001,(60) :365~369.
    153. Vogel J.C.,Eglington B.,Auret J.M..Isotope fingerprints in elephant bone and ivory.Nature,1990,346(23) :747~749.
    154. Weder J K.Identification of plant food raw material by RAPD-PCR:Legumes.Journal of Agricultural Food Chemistry,2002,(50) :4456~4463.
    155. Weigel J C,Russoe R,K(?)rschens M.Qualification of airbone N-input in long-term field experiments and its validation through measurement using N-15 isotope dilution.J.Plant Nutr.Soil Sci,2000,(163) :261-265.
    156. Wheeler TL,Cundiff L V,Koch R M.Journal of Animal Science,1994,72:3145~3151.
    157. White J W,Winters K,Martin P,Rossmann A.Stable carbon isotope ratio analysis of honey:validation of the internal standard procedure for worldwide application.J.AOAC Int,1998,81(3) :610~619.
    158. Wildes R P et al.Automated iris recognition:An emerging biometric technology.Proceedings of the IEEE 1997,85(9) :1348~1363.
    159. Wintero A K,Thomsen P D,Davies W.A comparison of DNA-hybridization,immunodiffusion,counter current immunoelectrophoresis and isoelectric focusing for detecting the mixture of pork to beef.Meat Science,1990,(27) :75~85.
    160. Wolfram Meier-Augenstein.Stable isotope analysis of fatty acid by gas chromatography-isotope ration mass spectrometry.Analytica Chimica Acta,2002,(465) :63~79.
    161. Woo Y A,Kim H J,Ze K R,Chuang H.Near-infrared(NIR)spectroscopy for the non-destructive and fast determination of geographical origin of Angelicae gigantis Radix.Journal of Pharmaceutical and Biomedical Analysis,2005,36(5) :955~959.
    162. Wurz A,Bluth A.Zeltz P,Pfeifer C,Willmund R.Quantitative analysis of genetically modified organisms(GMO)in processed food by PCR-based methods.Food Control,1999,(10) :385~389.
    163. Ziegler H,Osmond C B,Stichler W,Willmund R.Hydrogen isotope discrimination in higher plants:correlation with photosynthetic pathway and environment.Planta,(128) :85~92.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700