用户名: 密码: 验证码:
政府主导下的公司治理研究:来自我国上市公司CEO更换的证据
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
现代公司制中所有权与控制权分离,导致了委托代理问题的出现。如何从公司治理的角度出发,设立适当的激励和监督机制,限制代理人背离委托人利益行为的发生,减少委托代理成本,一直以来是国内外的研究热点。而能否依据经营业绩对CEO(也即代理人)进行更换是公司治理是否有效的一个标志。本文从我国上市公司CEO更换的实际情况出发,基于政府主导这一制度背景研究我国公司治理的现状和有效性。
     我国的证券市场脱胎于转型经济中,其设立初衷是为国有企业改革和解困服务。为保持国家对上市公司的控制力,国有股权在上市公司中占了很大比重,并且这些股权不能上市流通(股改前)。鉴于此,政府的动机和行为会对上市公司产生重大影响,从而影响委托代理问题的各个环节。由于国有股东作为委托人不具有人格化特质,其对代理人的监督激励往往不足。这种激励可能具有不对称性,乃至可能出现逆向激励(如预算软约束)以及“内部人控制”等问题。同时,由于政府股东本身拥有多重目标(如促进就业、实施某种经济战略、维护社会稳定等),使得其控制的上市公司也具有一定程度的多重目标性,从而表现出非市场化的行为,违背股东利益最大化的原则,使得国有上市公司中的委托代理关系极为复杂。
     因此,利用1995年至2003年间我国上市公司中CEO更换的数据,本文主要从债权人治理的有效性、不同业绩水平下董事会领导结构与公司治理的关系以及多重目标下不同终极产权中公司治理机制的比较等方面,对政府主导下的公司治理问题进行了实证研究。研究结果表明:
     首先,本应该在解决“内部人控制”问题上发挥积极作用的银行债权人没有起到应有的作用,反而进一步导致了预算软约束的出现,降低了经营亏损上市公司的公司治理效率;而作为另一种重要债务融资来源的商业信用债权人由于存在监督激励和监督能力方面的优势,增加了更换业绩不善的CEO的可能性,从而在一定程度上改善了上市公司的公司治理。
     另外,在政府主导背景下,当国有控股上市公司处于不同业绩状态时,股东和董事会对CEO有着不同程度的监督激励,从而导致了不同实质的CEO强制性更换。此时,不同业绩水平对应的董事会领导结构与CEO更换之间的关系有所不同,而其对公司治理的意义也不同。在那些发生亏损的公司中,CEO和董事长两职合一有利于企业问责机制的形成,因而并不能降低CEO更换的可能性:而在那些经营盈利能力一般的公司中,两职合一产生了严重的委托代理问题,限制了董事会对CEO监督和约束效力的发挥,不利于公司治理效率的提升;最后,对于经营状况很好的公司来说,两职合一有利于保护经营业绩出色的CEO免受非业绩原因导致的不正常更换的影响,可以看成公司治理效率良好的一个标志。
     最后,国有控股和民营控股上市公司的治理结构和目标函数有着很大的不同。国有控股上市公司往往面临“行政干预”而承担一定的社会性负担,具有多重目标的特性,因而有可能偏离利润最大化目标。因此,在国有控股上市公司的绩效考核机制中,资产周转率是一个非常重要的绩效指标。而由于存在非营利目标及缺乏成本控制的激励,利润边际并不是国有控股上市公司考核和决定CEO去留的重要指标。此外,在存在超额雇员或追求机会主义行为等非业绩目标时,国有股东更倾向于基于资产周转率来考核和更换CEO,可这一倾向在民营控股上市公司中并不明显。对于民营控股上市公司而言,对成本控制和经营效率的考虑也即对利润边际的考虑是其对CEO进行绩效考核的主要因素。
     对于以上结果,本文认为我国上市公司中很多治理机制失效的根本原因就在于政府主导。因此,考察我国上市公司的公司治理问题必须基于政府主导这一特殊环境进行分析,本文的结束部分对这一问题进行了相应的总结。
The separation of ownership and control leads to the emergence of principal agency problems in modern corporations.In order to reduce the agency costs caused by the divergence of interests between principal(shareholders) and agent(managers), a substantial body of literature has examined the effectiveness of various mechanisms for enhancing the effectiveness of CEO monitoring.And it is also a key indicator of the corporate governance's efficiency that whether CEO turnover decision is linked to his operation performance or not.Thus,this paper try to investigate the current status and efficiency of corporate governance from the view of CEO turnover in China's listed firm under the institutional background of government control.
     As we know,China's stock market comes to existence within the transitional economy and its initial objective is to serve the reform of state-owned firm and to relieve their financial burden during this process.TO keep the government's dominance position in these listed firms,there are huge of non-tradable shares owned by the government(before the split-share reform).Hence,the incentives and behaviors of government will definitely have a strong impact on those listed firms they controlled,which will further have influence on each aspect of the principal agent relationship.Due to the phenonmena of absence of owner as principal,there will be deficient incentive of the state shareholder to monitor its agent.And this kind of incentive will bring on an asymmetry structure or even adverse structure(such as soft budget phenomenon),which can further lead to the "insider control" problem.In the meantime,those state-controlled listed firms will also have multi-objectives when their shareholders(government) bear with these multi-objectives(such as increasing the employment level,implementing some special economic strategy and maintaining the stabilization of the society) naturally.Consequently,these listed firms will not follow the market principle all the time and might sometimes do harm to the market value of themselves,while the principal agent relationship in this situation is much more complicated than that in private-controlled firms.
     In view of the above background,based on the CEO turnover data in China's listed firms from year 1995 to 2003,this study conducts an empirical research on the corporate governance problem under the government control from the following
     three issues:the effectiveness of creditor monitoring,the relation between board leadership structure and corporate governance efficiency with different financial performance and the comparison of different mechanism between state-controlled and private-controlled listed firms with multi-objective functions.The results show that:
     Firstly,bank as a creditor does not behave its supposed role to lessen the "insider control" problem and even induces the soft budget problem,which depressed the effectiveness of corporate governance in loss-making listed firms.
     However,the provider of trade credit which is another important financing source improves the corporate govemance efficiency when it increases the probability of CEO turnover in poorly performed firms because of its advantage on the monitoring incentive and ability.
     Secondly,state shareholders or board of directors have different incentives at different level to oversee CEO under the institutional background of government control when the state-controlled listed firms are experiencing different performance status,which then lead to different nature of forced CEO turnover.Accordingly, there will be different relation between board leadership structure and CEO tumover mechanism under different performance status and the impact of such relation on the efficiency of corporate governance will also be different.Because it is very difficult to find a scapegoat,state shareholders have greater incentive to discipline poorly performing CEOs when the CEO and chairperson is the same person when these firms are making financial losses.There will be severe principal agent problems in the marginal performing firms because the vested position of chairman and CEO into one person can lead to less effective monitoring incentives from board of directors to oversee CEO,which may do harm to the corporate govemance efficiency.However, CEO duality may positively contribute to the corporate governance of out-performing firms by protecting well performing CEOs from being replaced with non-performance reasons,which can be regarded as an indicator of the efficient corporate governance.
     Thirdly,there are great differences on the governance mechanism and objective functions between state-controlled and private-controlled listed firms.Some social responsibilities are assumed on the state-controlled listed firms due to govemment's intervention.These state-controlled listed firms will exhibit some non-profit-seeking behavior and might go against the profit-maximization principle in some situation. For state-controlled listed firms,asset turnover is a very important index in the performance evaluation mechanism.Contrary to asset turnover,profit margin is not a key measure of CEO's performance due to the existence of non-profit objectives and lacking of incentive to control the operational cost.Moreover,state shareholders tend to monitor CEOs and evaluate their performance basing on asset turnover when there is an indication of non-profit objective such as over-employment or opportunistic behavior,while this is not the case for those private-controlled listed firms.Actually, the pursuit of higher profit margin,which means the persuit of cost control and operational efficiency,is the main criteria for private-controlled listed firms to assess CEOs' performance.
     Overall,the government control can be regarded as the root of the failure of some traditional corporate governance mechanism in China's listed firms.Hence,the special background of government control should be placed into the analysis framework whenever we want to study the corporate governance problem in China's listed firms.Thus,some conclusive words are then presented in the final section.
引文
安凡所.2007.上市公司总经理更替:基于董事会有效性的研究[D].暨南大学博士学位论文.
    安凡所.2009.上市公司总经理更替与董事会特征的实证研究[J].南方经济,1:23-32.
    陈冬华,陈信元,万华林.2005.国有企业中的薪酬管制与在职消费[J]_经济研究,2:92-101.
    陈健,席酉民,贾隽.2006.并购高管变更的绩效影响:基于中国上市公司的实证分析[J].南开管理评论,9:33-37.
    陈晓,江东.2000.股权多元化、公司业绩与行业竞争性[J].经济研究,8:28-35.
    陈小悦,徐晓东.2001.股权结构、企业绩效与投资者利益的保护[J].经济研究,11:3-11.
    陈信元,张田余.1999.资产重组的市场反映[J].经济研究,9:47-55.
    陈信元,朱红军.2007.转型经济中的公司治理—基于中国上市公司的案例[M].清华大学出版社.
    陈璇,淳伟德.2006.大股东对公司高层更换影响的实证分析[J].软科学,20(2):134-139.
    费方域.1996.控制内部人控制—国企改革中的治理机制研究[J].经济研究,6:31-39.
    冯根福.2001.关于健全和完善我国上市公司治理结构几个关键问题的思考[J].当代经济科学,23(6):23-28.
    冯根福.2004.双重委托代理理论:上市公司治理的另一种分析框架[J]_经济研究,12:16-25.
    冯根福,韩冰,闰冰.2002.中国上市公司股权集中度的实证分析[J].经济研究,8:12-18.
    金雪军,张学勇.2005.银行监管与中国上市公司代理成本研究[J].金融研究,10:110-119.
    高明华.2001.公司治理:理论演进与实证分析—兼论中国公司治理改革[J]_经济科学出版社:北京.
    龚玉池.2001.企业绩效与高层更换[J].经济研究,10:75-82.
    郭葆春.2008.公司业绩、董事会特征与财务总监变更—来自深沪股市的经验数据[J].财经科学,3:117-124.
    何浚,1998.上市公司治理结构的实证分析[J].经济研究,5:50-57.
    黄志忠.2006.股权比例、大股东“掏空”策略与全流通[J].南开管理评论,9:58-65.
    李斌,江伟.2006.金融中介与商业信用:替代还是互补—基于中国地区金融发展的实证分析[J].河北经贸大学学报,27(1):26-31.
    李常青,赖建清.2004.董事会特征影响公司绩效吗?[J]金融研究,5:64-76.
    李维安,李滨.2008.机构投资者介入公司治理效果的实证研究.基于CCGI的经验研究[J].南开管理评论,1:4-14.
    李增泉.2000.激励机制与企业绩效—一项基于上市公司的实证研究[J].会计研究,1:24-30.
    李增泉.2002.国家控股与公司治理的有效性—一项关于中国证券市场的实证研究[D].上海 财经大学博士学位论文.
    连建辉.2004.“管理者控制权”重探—管理者与企业剩余控制权的配置[J].财经科学,4:37-41.
    林毅夫,蔡昉,李周.1995.国有企业改革的核心是创造竞争的环境[J].改革,3:17-28.
    林毅夫,蔡昉,李周.1997.充分信息与国有企业改革[M].上海:上海人民出版社与上海三联书店.
    刘曼,芮萌,尹立东.2005.转轨背景下中国上市公司高级管理者变更的影响因素研究[J].中国软科学,2:86-90.
    刘芍佳,孙霈,刘乃全.2003.终极产权论、股权结构及公司绩效[J].经济研究,4:51-62.
    马磊,辛立国.2008.公司业绩、董事会特征与高管更换[J].产业经济评论,7(4):105-123.
    南开大学公司治理研究中心公司治理评价课题组.2004.中国上市公司治理指数与治理绩效的实证分析[J].管理世界,2:63-74.
    庞金勇.2008.上市公司高管变更与公司治理关系研究[D].山东大学博士学位论文.
    皮莉莉,Lowe,J.L.,O'Connor,C.2005.中国上市公司业绩与总经理变更分析[J].甘肃社会科学,3:203-206.
    蒲自立,刘芍佳.2004.公司控制中的董事会领导结构和公司绩效[J].管理世界,9:117-123.
    青木昌彦,钱颖一.1995.转轨经济中的公司治理结构[M].中国经济出版社.
    任凌玉.2007.大股东对上市公司的掏空与支持行为研究—基于Johnson模型的实证检验[J].财会月刊,7:4-6.
    宋德舜,宋逢明.2005.国有控股、经营者变更和公司绩效[J].南开管理评论,8(1):10-15.
    宋逢明,袁萍,高峰.2006.国有大股东是否影响中国公司的董事会治理[M].清华大学,工作论文.
    孙永祥.2002.公司治理结构:理论与实证研究[M].上海三联书店,上海人民出版社.
    孙永祥,黄祖辉.1999.上市公司股权结构与绩效[J].经济研究,12:23-28.
    孙永祥,章融.2000.董事会规模、公司治理与绩效[J].企业经济,10:13-15.
    谭伟强.2006.商业信用:基于企业融资动机的实证研究[J].南方经济,12:50-60.
    唐宗明,蒋位.2002.中国上市公司大股东侵害度实证分析[J].经济研究,4:44-50.
    田利辉.2004.杠杆治理、预算软约束和中国上市公司绩效[J].经济学季刊,增刊:15-25.
    田利辉.2005.国有产权、预算软约束和中国上市公司杠杆治理[J].管理世界,7:123-128.
    王丽娜,朱向红.2007.总经理继任者来源的影响因素:739家上市公司样本[J].改革,3:74-79.
    王满四.2005.上市公司负债融资的公司治理效应分析—考虑环境因素[J].证券市场导报,5:71-77.
    魏刚.2000.高级管理层激励与上市公司经营绩效[J].经济研究,3:32-29.
    文守逊,王仁杰.2008.上市公司总经理约束性离职行为研究[J].当代财经,3:59-64.
    吴淑琨.2002a.股权结构与董事会的U型关系研究[J].中国工业经济,1:80-87.
    吴淑琨.2002b.董事长和总经理两职状态的实证检验[J].证券市场导报,3:26-30.
    吴淑琨,柏杰,席酉民.1998.董事长与总经理两职的分离与合一—中国上市公司实证分析[J].经济研究,8:21-28.
    夏立军,方轶强.2005.政府控制、治理环境与公司价值[J].经济研究,5:40-51.
    许均华,李启亚,陈占强等.2002.我国经济、股市与政策之间关系的实证研究[M].南方证券股份有限公司研究报告.
    徐向艺,庞金勇.2008.上市公司主要高管变更后的团队稳定性[J].经济管理,30(13):42-47.
    徐向艺,王俊韡,巩震.2007.高管人员报酬激励与公司治理绩效研究[J].中国工业经济,2:94-100.
    徐晓东,陈小悦.2003.第一大股东对公司治理、企业业绩的影响分析[J].经济研究,2:64-74.
    闫冰.2006.代理理论与公司治理综述[J].当代经济科学,28(6):80-85.
    杨华.2005.公司治理的本土化研究[M].经济科学出版社.
    杨洁,夏新平,余明桂.2007.政策性负担、预算软约束与杠杆治理:基于中国上市公司的实证研究[J].管理评论,19:3-9.
    杨瑞龙,刘江.2002.经理报酬、企业绩效与股权结构的实证研究[J].江苏行政学院学报,1:46-54.
    杨瑞龙,周业安.1997.一个关于企业所有权安排的规范性分析框架及其理论含义[J].经济研究,1:12-22.
    叶五一,缪柏其,吴遵.2009.应用匹配法分析“两职合一”对公司绩效的影响[J].Journal of Data Analysis,4(1):57-68.
    叶祥松.2006.国有公司治理结构存在问题研究综述[J].广东社会科学,1:29-32.
    游家兴,李斌.2007.信息透明度与公司治理效率—来自中国上市公司总经理变更的经验证据[J].南开管理评论,14:73-79.
    于东智.2003a.资本结构、债权治理与公司绩效:一项经验分析[J].中国工业经济,1:78-85.
    于东智.2003b.董事会、公司治理与绩效—对中国上市公司的经验分析[J].中国社会科学,3:29-41.
    于东智,谷立日.2001.上市公司管理层持股的激励效用及影响因素[J].经济理论与经济管理,9:24-30.
    于东智,谷立日.2002.公司的领导权结构和经营绩效[J].中国工业经济,2:70-78.
    俞鸿琳.2006.政府控制和治理机制的有效性—基于中国A股市场的经验证据[J].南开管理评论,1:100-104.
    余剑,何枫.2004.上市公司内部人控制的治理途径[J].企业改革与管理,7:20-21.
    曾庆生,陈信元.2006.国家控股、超额雇员与劳动力成本[J].经济研究,5:74-86.
    张必武,石金涛.2006.总经理更换与高管团队的稳定性研究—来自中国上市公司的经验证 据[J].财经研究,32(1):121-132.
    张彩昌.1998.企业融资结构与资本市场发展[J].管理世界,3:92-102.
    张春霖.1995a.存在道德风险的委托代理关系:理论分析及其应用中的问题[J].经济研究,8:3-8.
    张春霖.1995b.从融资角度分析国有企业的治理结构改革[J].改革,3:34-36.
    张丹,阚海星.2005.中国上市公司高管人员更换与经营业绩关系的实证研究[J].东华大学学报(社会科学版),5(2):24-29.
    张俊瑞,赵进文,张建.2003.高级管理层激励与上市公司经营业绩相关性的实证分析[J].会计研究,9:29-34.
    张俊生,曾亚敏.2005.董事会特征与总经理变更[J].南开管理评论,8:16-20.
    张维迎.1995a.企业的企业家—契约理论[M].上海三联书店,上海人民出版社.
    张维迎.1995b.公有制经济中的委托人-代理人关系:理论分析和政策含义[J].经济研究,4:10-20.
    张维迎.1996.所有制、治理结构与委托-代理关系[J].经济研究,9:3-15.
    张维迎.1998.从公司治理结构看中国国有企业改革[M].载于《企业理论与中国企业改革》,北京大学出版社 1999年第1版.
    张维迎,栗树和.1998.地区之间的竞争与中国国有企业的民营化[J].经济研究,12:13-22.
    张兆国,何威风,闫炳乾。2008.资本结构与代理成本-来自中国国有控股上市公司和民营上市公司的经验证据[J].南开管理评论,1:39-47.
    张兆国,张庆.2006.我国上市公司资本结构治理效应的实证分析[J].管理世界,3:140-141.
    郑琰.2003.中国上市公司收购监管模式评析[J].金融研究,2:38-48.
    中国企业家调查系统.2000.中国企业经营者队伍制度化建设的现状与发展—2000年中国企业经营者成长与发展专题调查报告[J].管理世界,4:92-102.
    中国统计局.2001.2001年中国统计年鉴[M].中国统计出版社.
    周小川,王林,肖梦,银温泉.1994.企业改革:模式选择与配套设计[M].中国经济出版社.
    朱宝宪,王怡凯.2002.1998年中国上市公司并购实践的效应分析[J].经济研究,11:20-26.
    朱红军.2002a.大股东更换与高级管理人员更换:经营业绩的作用[J].会计研究,9:31-40.
    朱红军.2002b.高级管理人员更换的原因和经济后果—一项基于企业绩效的实证研究[D].上海财经大学博士论文.
    朱红军.2004.高级管理人员更换与经营业绩[J].经济科学,4:82-92.
    朱武祥.2000.理性的企业行为与低效的公司控制权市场[J].证券市场导报,9:53-55.
    朱武祥,宋勇.2001.股权结构与企业价值—对家电行业上市公司实证分析[J].经济研究,12:66-72.
    邹风,陈晓.2004.“三分开”政策对董事会结构影响的实证研究[J].经济学(季刊),2:425-436.
    Agrawal,A.,Knoeber,C.R.1996.Firm Performance and Mechanisms to Control Agency Problems Between Managers and Shareholders[J].Journal of Finance and Quantitative Analysis,31:377-397.
    Alchian,A.,Demsetz,H.1972.Production,Information Costs,and Economic organization[J].American Economic Review,62:777-783.
    Allen,F.,Qian,J.,Qian,M.2005.Law,Finance,and Economic Growth in China[J].Journal of Financial Economics,77(1):57-116.
    Ang,J.S.,Cole,R.A.,Lin,J.W.2000.Agency Costs and Ownership Structure[J].The Journal of Finance,55:81-106.
    Ayub,M.,Hegstad,S.1987.Management of Public Industrial Enterprises[J].World Bank Research Observer,2(1):79-101.
    Bai,C.E.,Li,D.,Tao,Z.,et al.2000.A multitask theory of state enterprise reform[J].Journal of Comparative Economics,28:716-738.
    Bai,C.E.,Liu,Q.,Lu,J.,Song,F.2004.Corporate Governance and Firm Valuations in China[J].Journal of Comparative Economics,32(4):599-616.
    Baliga,B.R.,Moyer,R.C.,Rao,C.S.1996.CEO duality and firm performance:What's the fuss?[J]Strategic Management Journal,17:41-53.
    Barber,B.M.,Lyon,J.D.1996.Detecting Abnormal Operating Performance:The Empirical Power and Specification of Test-Statistics[J].Journal of Financial Economics,41:359-399.
    Berle,A.,Means,G.1932.The Modern Corporation and Private Properry[M].Mc-Millan,New York.
    Blair,M.1995.Ownership and Control:Rethinking Corporate Governance for the Twenty First Century[M],Brookings Institution,Washington DC.
    Bonnier,K.A.,Bruner,R.F.1989.An Analysis of Stock Price Reaction to Management Change in Distressed Firms[J].Journal of Accounting and Economics,11:95-106.
    Boyd,B.1995.CEO duality and firm performance:A contingency model[J].Strategic Management Journal,16:301-312.
    Bradley,M.,Desai,A.,Kim,E.H.1988.Synergistic gains from corporate acquisitions and their division between the stockholders of target and acquiring firms[J].Journal of Financial Economics,21:3-40.
    Brennan,M.,Maksimovic,V.,Zechner,J.1988.Vendor Financing[J].Journal of Finance,43(5):1127-1141.
    Brickley,J.A.,Coles,J.L.,Jarrell,G.1996.Checks and balances in the boardroom?[J]Chief Executive,114:66-67.
    Brickley,J.A.,Coles,J.,Jarrell,G.1997.Leadership Structure:Separating the CEO and Chairman of the Board[J].Journal of Corporate Finance,3:189-220.
    Brickley,J.A.,Coles,J.,Linck,J.1999.What Happens to CEOs After They Retire? New Evidence on Career Concerns,Horizon Problems,and CEO Incentives[J].Journal of Financial Economics,52:341-377.
    Brunello,G.,Graziano,C,ParigiB,M.2003.CEO turnover in insider-dominated boards:The Italian case[J].Journal of Banking & Finance,27:1027-1051.
    Burkart,M.,Ellingsen,T.2004.In-Kind Finance:A Theory of Credit[J].American Economic Review,94(3):569-590.
    Cannella,A.A.,Lubatkin,M.1993.Succession as a sociopolitical process:internal impediments to outside selection[J].Academy of Management Journal,36:763-793.
    Chang,E.,Wong,M.L.2009.Governance with Multiple Objectives:Evidence from Top Executive Turnover in China[J].Journal of Corporate Finance,15:230-244.
    Chen,C,Li,Z.,Su,X.,et al.2006.CEO turnover and accounting measures:Effect of Delegation of Control Rights[M].Working paper,City University of Hong Kong.
    Chen,C,Wang,J.W.2004.A Comparison of Shareholder Identity and Governance Mechanism in the Monitoring of Listed Companies in China[M].SSRN,Working paper.
    Claessen,S.,Fan,P.H.,Lang,H.P.2006.The Benefits and Costs of Group Affiliation:Evidence from East Asia[J].Emerging Markets Review,7(1):1-26.
    Coase,R.1991.The Nature of the Firm:Origin,Evolution and Development[M].UK:Oxford University Press.
    Cochran,P.,Wartick,S.1988.Corporate Governance:A Review of Literature[M].Financial Executives Research Foundation,New York,NY.
    Coffee,J.C.1999.The Future as History:The Prospects for Global Convergence in Corporate Governance and Its Implications.Northwestern University Law Review[J],93:641-707.
    Conyon,M.,Florou,A.2002.Top Executive Dismissal,Ownership and Corporate Performance[J].Accounting and Business Research,32:209:225.
    Conyon,M.,Girma,J.S.,Thompson,S.,et al.2000.The Impact of Mergers and Acquisitions on Company Employment in the United Kingdom[J].European Economic Review,46:31-49.
    Dalton,D.,Kesner,I.1983.Inside/outside succession and organizational size:the pragmatics of executive replacement[J].Academy of Management Journal,26:736-742.
    Dalton,D.,Kesner,I.1985.Organizational Performance as an Antecedent of Insider/Outside Chief Executive Succession:An Empirical Assessment[J].Academy of Management Journal,28:749-762.
    Dayha,J.,Lonie,A.A.,Power,D.M.1998.Ownership Structure,Firm Performance and Top Executive Change:An Analysis of UK Firms[J].Journal of Business Finance and Accounting,25:1089-1118.
    DeAngelo,L.E.1988.Managerial Competition,Information Costs,and Corporate Governance:The Use of Accounting Measures in Proxy Contests[J].Journal of Accounting and Economics,10:3-36.
    Defend,M.L.,Park,C.W.1999.The Effect of Competition on CEO Tumover[J].Journal of Accounting and Economics,27:35-56.
    Demirguc-Kunt,A.,Maksimovic,V.2002.Firms as Financial Intermediations:Evidence from Trade Credit Data[M].Mimeo,World Bank.
    Demsetz,H.1983.The Structure of Ownership and the Theory of the Firm[J].Journal of Law and Economics,26:375-390.
    Denis,D.J.,Denis,D.K.1995.Performance Changes Following Top Management Dismissals[J].Journal of Finance,50:1029-1057.
    Denis,D.J.,Denis,D.K.,Sarin,A.1997.Ownership Structure and Top Executive Tumover[J].Journal of Financial Economics,45:193-221.
    Denis,D.,McConnell,J.2003.International Corporate Governance[J].Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis,38:1-36.
    Diamond,D.1984.Financial Intermediation and delegated monitoring[J].Review of Economic Studies,51:393-414.
    Diamond,D.1989.Reputation Acquisition in Debt Markets[J].Journal of Political Economy,97:828-862.
    Diamond,D.1991.Monitoring and Reputation:The Choice between Bank Loans and Directly Placed Debt[J].Journal of Political Economy,99:689-721.
    Dine,S.2005.Politicians and banks:Political influences on government-owned banks in emerging market[J].Journal of Financial Economics,77:453-479.
    Dodd,P.,Warner,J.B.1983.On Corporate Governance:A Study of Proxy Contests[J].Journal of Financial Economics,11(1):401-438.
    Donaldson,L.,Davis,J.H.1991.Stewardship theory or agency theory:CEO governance and shareholder returns[J].Australian Journal of Management,16(1):49-64.
    Easterbrook,F.,Fischel,D.1983.Voting in Corporate Law[J].Journal of Law and Economics,26:395-427.
    Faccio,M.,Lang,H.P.2002.The Ultimate Ownership of Western European Corporations[J].Journal of Financial Economics,65:365-395.
    Fatna,E.1980.Agency Problems and the Theory of the Firm[J].Journal of Political Economy,88:288-307.
    Fama,E.,Jensen,M.1983.Seperation of ownership and control[J].Journal of Law and Economics,26:301-325.
    Fee,C.E.,Hadlock,C.J.2004.Management Turnover across the Corporate Hierarchy[J].Journal of Accounting and Economics,37:3-8.
    Firth,M.,Fung,M.Y.,Rui,M.2006.Firm performance,governance structure,and top management turnover in a transitional economy[J].Journal of Management Studies,43(6):1289-1330.
    Franks,J.,Harris,R.1989.Shareholder wealth effects of corporate takeovers:the UK experience 1955-1985[J].Journal of Financial Economics,23:225-249.
    Franks,J.,Mayer,C.1994.The ownership and control of German corporations[M].Manuscript,London Business School.
    Freedman,R.E.1984.Strategic Management:A stakeholder approach[M].Boston:Pitman.
    Fredrickson,J.W.,Hambrick,D.C.,Baumrin,S.1988.A model of CEO dismissal[J].Academy of Management Review,13(2):255-270.
    Furtado,E.P.,Karan,V.1990.Causes,Consequences,and Shareholder Wealth Effects of Management Turnover:A Review of the Empirical Evidence[J].Financial Management,19(2):60-75.
    Gao,S.,Schaffer,M.2000.Financial Discipline in the Enterprise Sector in Transition Countries:How Does China Compare?[M]in Cook,S.,Yao,S.,and Zhuang,J.(ed.),The Chinese economy under transition,Basingstoke,England:Macmillan Press.
    Gibson,M.S.2003.Is corporate governance ineffective in emerging markets[J].Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis,38:231-250.
    Gibbons,R.,Murphy,K.1990.Relative Performance Evaluation and Chief Executive Officers[J].Industrial and Labor Relations,43:30-51.
    Gibbons R.,Murphy,K.1992.Optimal Incentive Contracts in the Presence of Career Concerns:Theory and Evidence[J].Journal of Political Economy,100:468-505.
    Gilson,S.C.1989.Management Turnover and Financial Distress[J].Journal of Financial Economics,25:241-262.
    Gilson,S.C.1990.Bankruptcy,Boards,Banks and Blockholders[J].Journal of Financial Economics,27:355-387.
    Goyal,V.K.,Park,C.W.2002.Board leadership structure and CEO tumover[J].Journal of Corporate Finance,8:49-66.
    Grossman,S.,Hart,O.1982.Corporate financial structure and managerial incentives[M].Working paper,Chicago:University of Chicago Press.
    Grossman,S.,Hart,O.1986.The Costs and Benefits of Ownership:A Theory of Vertical and Lateral Integration[J].Journal of Political Economy,94:691-719.
    Grusky,O.1969.Managerial succession and organizational effectiveness[J].American Journal of Sociology,75:21-31.
    Harris,M,Raviv,A.1988.Corporate Control Contests and Capital Structure[J].Journal of Financial Economics,20:55-86.
    Harris,M.,Raviv,A.1990.Capital Structure and the Informational Role of Debt[J].Journal of Finance,45(2):321-349.
    Harrison,J.R.,Torres,D.L.,Kukalis,S.1988.The changing of the guard:turnover and structural change in top-management positions[J].Administrative Science Quarterly,33:211-232.
    Hart,O.,Moorve,J.1990.Property Rights and Nature of the Firm[J].Journal of Political Economy,98(6):1119-1158.
    Hart,O.,Moorve,J.1998.Default and Renegotiation:A Dynamic Model of Debt[J].Quarterly Journal of Economics,113:1-41.
    Hay,J.R.,Shleifer,A.,Vishny,R.W.1996.Privatization in Transition Economies:Towards a Theory of Legal Reform[J],European Economic Review,40:559-568.
    Helmich,D.,1980.Board size variation and rates of succession in the corporate presidency[J].Journal of Business Research,8:51-63.
    Holmstrim,B.1982.Moral Hazard in Teams[J].Bell Journal of Economics,13:324-340.
    Huson,M.,Malatesta,P.,Parrino,R.2004.Managerial succession and firm performance[J].Journal of Financial Economics,74:237-275.
    Huson,M.,Parrino,R.,Starks,L.2001.Internal monitoring mechanisms and CEO turnover:a long-term perspective[J].Journal of Finance,56:2265-2298.
    Israel,R.1991.Capital Structure and the Market for Corporate Control:The Defensive Role of Debt Financial[J].Journal of Finance,46:1391-1409.
    Jensen,M.C.1986.Agency Costs of Free Cash Flow,Corporate Finance,and Takeover[J].American Economic Review,76:323-329.
    Jensen,M.C.1993.The Modem Industrial Revolution,Exit,and the Failure of Internal Control System[J].Journal of Finance,48(3):831-880.
    Jensen,M.C.2001.Value maximization,stakeholder theory,and the corporate objective function[J].European Financial Management Review,7(3):297-317.
    Jensen,M.C,Meckling,W.1976.Theory of Firm:Managerial Behavior,Agency Costs and Ownership Structure[J].Journal of Financial Economics,3:305-360.
    Jensen,M.C.,Murphy,K.J.1990.Performance Pay and Top-Management Incentives[J].Journal of Political Economy,98:225-264.
    Jensen,M.C.,Warner,J.B.1988.The distribution of power among corporate managers,shareholders,and directors[J].Journal of Financial Economics,20(1):3-24.
    Johnson,B.,Magee,R.,Nagarajan,N.,et al.1985.An analysis of the stock price reaction to sudden executive deaths:Implications for the managerial labor market[J].Journal of Accounting and Economics,7:151-174.
    Kang,J.,Shivdasani,A.1995.Firm performance,corporate governance,and top executive turnover in Japan[J].Journal of Financial Economics,38:29-58.
    Kaplan,S.,Reishus,D.1990.Outsider Directorships and Corporate Performance[J].Journal of Financial Economics,27:389-410.
    Kato,T.,Long,C.2006.CEO turnover,firm performance and enterprise reform in China:Evidence from micro data[J].Journal of Comparative Economics,34:796-817.
    Khanna,N.,Poulsen,A.1995.Managers of Financially Distressed Firms:Villains or Scapegoats?[J]Journal of Finance,50:919-940.
    Kornai,J.1992.The Socialist System-The Political Economy of Communism[M].Princeton:Princeton.
    La Porta,R.,Lopez-de-Silanes,F.,Shleifer,A.1999.Corporate Ownership Around the World[J].Journal of Finance,54(2):471-517.
    La Porta,R.Lopez-De-Silanes,F.,Shleifer,A.,et al.1997.Legal Determinants of External Finance[J].Journal of Finance,52:1131-1150.
    La Porta,R.Lopez-De-Silanes,F.,Shleifer,A.,et al.1998.law and Finance[J].Journal of Political Economy,106:1113-1155.
    Leech,D.,Leahy,J.1991.Ownership Structure,Control Type Classifications and the Performance of Large British Companies[J].Economic Journal,101:1418-1437.
    Leker,J.,Salomo,S.2000.CEO turnover and corporate performance[J].Scandinavian Journal of Management,16:287-303.
    Lin,J.Y.,Cai,F.,Li,Z.1988.Competition,policy burdens,and state-owned enterprise reform[J].American Economic Review,88(2):422-427.
    Lipton,M.,Lorsch,J.1992.A Modest Proposal for Improved Corporate Governance[J].Business Lawyer,48(1):59-77.
    Mace,M.1971.Directors-Myth and Reality[M].Harvard University Press,Cambridge,MA.
    Marine,H.1965.Mergers and the Market for Corporate Control[J].Journal of Political Economics, 5:110-120.
    Martin,K.J.,McConnell,J.J.1991.Corporate Performance,Corporate Takeovers,and Management Tumover[J].Journal of Finance,46:671-687.
    McConnell,J.,Servaes,H.1990.Additional Evidence on Equity Ownership and Corporate Value[J].Journal of Financial Economics,27:595-612.
    Mehran,H.1995.Executive Compensation Structure,Ownership,and Finn Performance[J].Journal of Financial Economics,38:163-184.
    Mikkelson,W.H.,Partch,M.M.1997.The Decline of Takeovers and Disciplinary Managerial Tumover[J].Journal of Financial Economics,44:205-228.
    Milgrom,P.,Roberts,J.1992.Economics,Organization and Management[M].Englewood Cliffs,NJ:Prentice-Hall.
    Morck,R.,Shleifer,A.,Vishny,R.W.1988.Management Ownership and Market Valuation:An Empirical Analysis[J].Journal of Financial Economics,20:293-315.
    Morck,R.,Shleifer,A.,Vishny,R.W.1989.Alternative Mechanism for Corporate Control[J].American Economic Review,79:842-852.
    Morck,R.,Yueng,B.,Yu,W.2000.The information content of the stock market:why do emerging markets have synchronous stock price movement?[J]Journal of Financial Economics,58:215-260.
    Murphy,K.J.1986.Incentives,Learning,and Compensation:A Theoretical and Empirical Investigation of Managerial Labor Contracts[J].Rand Journal of Economics,17(1):59-76.
    Murphy,K.J.1999.Executive Compensation[M].In Ashenfelter,O.,and Card,D.,Ed.,Handbooks of Labor Economics(Vol 3),North-Holland,New York.
    Murphy,K.J.,Zimmerman,J.L.1993.Financial Performance Surrounding CEO Turnover[J].Journal of Accounting and Economics,16:273-315.
    Nalebuff,B.,Stiglitz,J.1983.Information,Competition,and Markets[J].American Economic Review,73:278-283.
    Neumann,R.,Voetmann,T.2005.Top executive turnovers:separating decision and control rights[J].Managerial and Decision Economics,26:25-37.
    OECD.2001.Corporate Governance in Asia[M].pp.7-10.
    Parrino,R.1997.CEO Turnover and Outside Succession:A Cross-sectional Analysis[J].Journal of Financial Economics,46:165-197.
    Perry,T.2000.Incentive compensation for outside directors and CEO turnover[M].Working paper.Tempe:Arizona State University.
    Petersen,M.A.,Rajan,R.G.1997.Trade Credit:Theories and Evidence[J].Review of Financial Studies,10:661-691.
    Pfeffer,J.,Salancik,G.R.1978.The External Control of Organizations:A Resource Dependence Perspective[M].New York:Harper & Row.
    Pi,L.,Timme,S.G.1993.Corporate Control and Bank Efficiency[J].Journal of Banking and Finance,17:515-530.
    Puffer,S.M.,Weintrop,J.B.1991.Corporate Performance and CEO Turnover:the Role of Performance Expectations[J].Administrative Science Quarterly,36:1-19.
    Rajan,R.1992.Insiders and Outsiders:the Choice between Relationship and Arms-length Debt[J].Journal of Finance,47:1367-1400.
    Rechner,P.L.,Dalton,D.R.1991.CEO duality and organizational performance[J].Strategic Management Journal,12:155-160.
    Rosenstein,S.,Wyatt,J.1990.Outsider Directors,Board Independence,and Shareholder Wealth[J].Journal of Financial Economics,26:175-184.
    Sapienza,P.2004.The effect of government ownership on bank lending[J].Journal of Financial Economics,72:357-384.
    Shlerfer,A.,Vishny,R.W.1986.Large Shareholders and Corporate Control[J].Journal of Political Economy,94:461-488.
    Shleifer,A.,Vishny,R.W.1989.Management Entrenchment:The Case of Manager-Specified Investments[J].Journal of Financial Economics,25:123-139.
    Shleifer,A.,Vishny,R.W.1994.Politicians and firms[J].Quarterly Journal of Economics,109:995-1025.
    Shleifer,A.,Vishny,R.W.1997.A survey of corporate governance[J].Journal of Finance,2:737-783.
    Singh M.,Davidson W.N.2003.Agency Costs,Ownership Structure and Corporate Governance Mechanisms[J].Journal of Banking and Finance,27:793-816.
    Smith,C,Warner,J.1979.On financial contracting:An analysis of bond covenants[J].Journal of Financial Economics,7:117-161.
    Smith,J.K.1987.Trade Credit and Informational Asymmetry[J].Journal of Finance,42(4):863-872.
    Stiglitz,J.1985.Credit Markets and the Control of Capital[J].Journal of Money,Credit and Banking,17(2):133-152.
    Stulz,R.1988.Managerial Control of Voting Rights:Financial Policies and the Market for Corporate Control[J].Journal of Financial Economics,20:25-54.
    Sun,Q.,Tong,W.2003.China share issue privatization:the extent of its success[J].Journal of Financial Economics,70:183-222.
    Tan,R.S.K.,Chang,P.L.,Tan,T.W.2001.CEO share ownership and firm value[J].Asia Pacific Journal of Management,18:355-371.
    Tian,J.J.,Lau,C.-M.2001.Board composition,leadership structure,and performance in Chinese shareholding companies[J].Asia Pacific Journal of Management,18:245-263.
    Tricker,R.1994.International Corporate Governance[M].Prentice Hall.
    Vickers,J.,Yarrow,G.1989.Privatization:An Economic Analysis[M].MIT University Press,Cambridge.
    Volpin,P.F.2002.Governance with Poor Investor Protection:Evidence from Top Executive Turnover in Italy[J].Journal of Financial Economics,64:61-90.
    Walsh,J.P.1988.Top Management Turnover Following Mergers and Acquisitions[J].Strategic Management Journal,9:173-183.
    Wang,X.,Xu,L.,Zhu,T.2004.State-owned enterprises going public:the case of China[J].Economics of Transition,12(3):467-487.
    Warner,J.B.,Watts,R.L.,Wruck,K.H.,1988.Stock Prices and Top Management Changes[J].Journal of Financial Economics,20:461-492.
    Weinstein,D.E.,Yafeh,Y.1994.On the Costs of a Bank2centered Financial System:Evidence from the Changing Main Bank Relations in Japan[M].Manuscript,Harvard University.
    Weisbach,M.1988.Outsider Directors and CEO Turnover[J].Journal of Financial Economics,20:431-460.
    Williamson,O.E.1975.Markets and Hierarchies:Analysis and Antitrust Implications[M].New York:Free Press.
    Williamson,O.E.1988.Corporate Finance and Corporate Governance[J].The Journal of Finance,43:567-575.
    Wong,Y.C.,Wong,M.L.2001.Competition in China's Domestic Banking Industry[J].Cato Journal,21(1):19-41.
    Wooldridge,J.M.2002.Econometric Analysis of Cross Section and Panel Data[M].The MIT Press,Cambridge,Mass.
    Xin,K.R.,Pearce,J.L.1996.Guanxi:Connections as substitutes for formal institutional support[J].Academy of Management Journal,39(6):1641-1658.
    Xu,X.,Wang,Y.1999.Ownership Structure and Corporate Governance in Chinese Stock Companies[J].China Economic Review,10(1):75-98.
    Yanagawa,N.,Ito,S.,Watanabe,M.2006.Trade Credits under Imperfect Enforcement:A Theory with a Test on Chinese Experience[M].Discussion Paper No.58,Institute of Developing Economies,University of Tokyo.
    Yermack,D.1995.Do Corporations Award CEO Stock Options Effectively?[J]Journal of Financial Economics,39:237-269.
    Yermack,D.1996.Higher Market Valuation of Companies with a Small Board of Directors[J].Journal of Financial Economics,40(2):185-212.
    Yermack,D.1997.Good Timing:CEO Stock Option Awards and Company News Announcements!J].Journal of Finance,52:449-476.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700