用户名: 密码: 验证码:
美国精英评论与反恐战争:构架方法
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
本研究试图分析美国精英集团如何从意识形态上构架2001年9月11日的恐怖袭击事件以及之后一年的反恐战争(War on Terrorism campaign)。研究尝试通过构架事件的方式去解读不同的美国精英集团(例如政府官员、企业职员、媒体人员等)是如何有效限制或扩展政府应对911恐怖袭击所采取行动的选择。
     本论文将以社会运动视角方面的文献的构架作为基础。这项研究考察了不同精英集团如何形成自己的主张来动员集体行动服务于各自的利益,利用了在制造“美国”的集体形象和共有的民族、性别、阶级意识,美国的敌人的特征,以及其在更迭世界中的角色。此研究所运用的方法是定性内容分析和批判性构架分析,从现美国总统乔治.布什的主要演讲、《纽约时报》和《华盛顿邮报》的社论、社员评论及专栏评论中理论上有目的性地进行抽样。精英的不同种类和来源间诊断性、预测性和动机性构架的相似与不同之处将被识别出并进行社会学方面的解释。同时将估量各家媒体文献对布什总统演讲中提出的对反恐战争意识形态上假设的支持度来进行此项研究。
     《纽约时报》社论版的读者群远比《华盛顿邮报》的读者更支持反恐战争,然而整体来说《华盛顿邮报》比《纽约时报》更支持反恐战争。出于意外的是两份报纸的媒体精英比政府官员更支持反恐战争。几乎所有精英集团都支持进行先发制人的袭击政策以及伊拉克的萨达姆政权更迭。媒体的作用不仅是解释和传播精英们对反恐战争的意识形态,同时更重要的是他们帮助增强对布什政府反恐战争意识形态的构架。
     当运用批评性构架分析来研究民族、阶级和经济架构、精英评论中的性别时,我从数据中发现可以将一种意识形态描述成一种帝国主义的意识形态。美国精英,尤其是媒体精英不仅试图非法化“恐怖分子”,更试图抵制那些批判全球经济、文化美国化“必不可免”的人。
This study attempts to analyze how American elites groups ideologically framed events of terrorists attack on September 11,2001 and the completion of the first year of the War on Terrorism(WOT) campaign.It tries to understand how the different groups of American elites(e.g., government officials,corporate officials,media officials etc.) effectively limited or expanded options for state action in response to the terrorists attack on 9/11 by framing the events.
     This dissertation will building on the framing perspective of the social movements' literature.This study considers how different elite group shapes their opinion to mobilize collective action to serve their interests,which draw upon a collective identity and shared racial, gender and class ideologies of 'America',its enemies,and its role in the changing world.
     The methodologies that have been employed to this study will be Qualitative Content Analysis and Critical Framing Analysis which theoretically purposive sample of major speeches of George W.Bush(GWB) and New York Times(NYT) and the Washington Post(WP) editorials,staff commentaries and guest Op-Eds.Similarities and differences in diagnostic,prognostic and motivational framing between sources and categories of elites will be identified and sociologically explained. There's also the amount of support of each media document gave for the ideological assumptions of the War on Terror as represented in speeches of George W.Bush will be measured for this study.
     The NYT editorial board was farther ahead of its readership in support of the War on Terror than the WP,but overall the WP was more supportive than the NYT.Media elites from both newspapers were more supportive of the WOT than government officials.Almost all of groups of elites were found for the policy of preemptive strikes and specifically regime change in Iraq.The role of media was not only translate and circulate elite ideologies of the WOT but to help amplify the framing of them as well.
     What I have found from the data while employing Critical Framing Analysis to examine constructions of race;class and economics;and gender in elite discourse,was an ideology that can be described as an imperialist ideology.American elites,particularly media elites not only try to delegitimize 'terrorists' but those who criticized the 'inevitability' of the Americanization of global economy and culture.
引文
1 http://www.cnn.com/2003/US/Northeast/10/29/wtc.deaths/
    2 反恐战争的缩写,我在本研究中使用WOT,此关键词是不意味着有意的支持军事行动,而是所有的各种广泛的现布什行政府的反恐战争政策。使用此关键词并不意味着有意的支持或确认正确性和可靠性。
    3 童兵:《马克思主义新闻经典教程》[M],上海,复旦大学出版社,2002.PP.27.
    1 Bennett,W.L.,and J.B Manheim.1993."Taking the public by storm:Information,cuing,and the democratic process in the Gulf conflict[J]." Political Communication Vol.10,P.335.
    2 Weisler,Adam.1997."Editorial Opinion and Government Policymaking[D]," dissertation from Columbia University,for a summary of the research.
    3 Also see Bennett,W.Lance(1990) 'Toward a theory of press-state relations in the united states[J]",Journal of Communication 40(2):103-125.
    1 < http://www.nytco.com/company/>
    2 < http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Washington_Post>
    3 Bennett, W.L., and J.B Manheim. 1993. "Taking the public by storm: Information, cuing, and the democratic process in the Gulf conflict[J]." Political Communication Vol. 10, P. 335.
    
    4 Retrieved from the World Wide Web: NYT: http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-adv/mediacenter/html/research_demographics.html WP: http://www.nvtimes.whsites.net/mediakit/pdfs/newspaper/MRI_NYTreaderprofile.pdf
    
    5 Retrieved from the World Wide Web: http://librarv.corporate-ir.net/librarv/62/624/62487/items/236847/TWPC2006AR.pdf Retrieved from the World Wide Web: http://www.nvtco.com/investors/financials/revenue.html.
    1 Lakoff, George. (2001, September 16).'Metaphors of Terror.' In The Days After[OL]. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Retrieved from the World Wide Web: http://www.press.uchicago.edu/ News/91 llakoff.html.
    
    2 Rice, Condoleezza. 2003. "Transforming the Middle East[N]." The Washington Post, Washington DC, Editorial section, A21, August 7, 2003.
    
    3 NYT. 1992. "Excerpts From Pentagon's Plan: 'Prevent the Re-Emergence of a New Rival'[N]." in New York Times. New York. March 8,1992.
    1 Friedman,George.2002."Media and War,Appearance and Reality." Summary Coverage of the "War on Terrorism[OL]".January 15,2002.Retrieved from the World Wide Web:http://archive.infopeace.de/msg00833.html
    2 Retrieved from the World Wide Web:http://www.september11news.com/OsamaSpeeches.htm.
    3 Rhem,Kathleen T.2001."DOD to Get Much of Bush Emergency Budget Request[OL]." News briefing,September 13,2001.Retrieved from the World Wide Web:http://www.defenselink.mil/news/newsarticle.aspx?id=44893
    4 Wolfowitz Interview with Sam Tannenhaus,Vanity Fair,Friday,May 09,2003.Retrieved from the World Wide Web:http://www.defenselink.mil/transcripts/transcript.aspx?transcriptid=25945 Wolfowitz,Paul,"United on the Risks of a War With Iraq[N]",The Washington Post,EDITORIAL;Pg.A19,December 23,2002.
    6 See http://www.pollingreport.com-76%in favor in 1998,46-67%in favor in 2002.
    7 Iraq Liberation Act,1998."SEC.3.SENSE OF THE CONGRESS REGARDING UNITED STATES POLICY TOWARD IRAQ." Retrieved from the World Wide Web:http://www.iraqwatch.org/govemment/US/Legislation/ILA.htm.
    8 赵鼎新:《社会与政治运动讲义》[M],北京,社会科学文献出版社,2006.pp.212.CNN/USA today/Gallup Poll of 1,007 adults nationwide,August,2002.http://www.pollingreport.com.
    10 Fox News/Opinion Poll Dynamics Poll of 900 registered voters nationwide,January 29-30,2003.http://www.pollingreport.com.
    11 Commission Report,2005."The Commission on the Intelligence Capabilities of the United States Regarding Weapons of Mass Destruction[R]" Report to the President of the United States,March 31,2005,Washington DC:(pp.3)
    12 李良荣:“西方新闻事业概论”[M],上海,复旦大学出版社,2006.pp.123. See, for example, Reuters, Tuesday, February 11,2003 "Bin Laden Labels Saddam an Infidel - Jazeera TV" by Samia Nakhoul.
    2 Bush, George W., 2001. "President Launches "Lessons of Liberty[OL].", Retrieved from the World Wide Web: http://www.whitehouse.gov/news/releases/2001/10/20011030-7.html.
    3 Bush, George W., 2002. "National Security Strategy - Calls for U.S. Global Preeminence[OL]", Retrieved from the World Wide Web: www.whitehouse.gov.
    4 Ashcroft, John. 2002 "Prepared Remarks of Attorney General John Ashcroft to the National Religious Broadcasters Convention[OL].", February 19, 2002. Retrieved from the World Wide Web: http://www.usdoj.gov/archive/ag/speeches/2002/021902religiousbroadcasters.htm.
    5 Ashcroft, John. 2002 "Prepared Remarks of Attorney General John Ashcroft to the National Religious Broadcasters Convention[OL].", February 19, 2002. Retrieved from the World Wide Web: http://www.usdoj.gov/archive/ag/speeches/2002/021902religiousbroadcasters.htm.
    6 Lubragge, Michael T., The Many Shades of Manifest Destiny[OL]." Retrieved from the World Wide Web: http://odur.let.rug.nl/~usa/E/manifest/manif5.htm.
    7 Cheney, Dick. 2001. "The Vice President appears on Meet the Press with Time Russert[OL]." Camp David, Maryland, September 16,2001. Retrieved from the World Wide Web: http://www.whitehouse.gov/vicepresident/news-speeches/speeches/vp20010916.html.
    8 Bush, George W., 2002. "President Announces Step to Expand Trade & Create Jobs[OL]." Retrieved from the World Wide Web: http://www.whitehouse.gov/news/releases/2002/01/20020116-13.html.
    9 McLean, Christopher. 1995. "The Costs of Masculinity: Placing Men's Pain in the context of Male Power[OL]." in Promoting Gender Equity Conference. Canberra, Australia. Retrieved from the World Wide Web: http://www.mceetya.edu.au/verve/_resources/genderframwk74-144.pdf.
    10 Bush, George W., 2003. "President Bush Names Randall Tobias to be Global AIDS Coordinator[OL]." The Roosevelt Room, July 2, 2003. Retrieved from the World Wide Web: http://www.whitehouse.gov/news/releases/2003/07/20030702-3.html.
    
    11 Lakoff, George. 1995. "Metaphor, Morality, and Politics, Or, Why Conservatives Have Left Liberals In the Dust[J]." Social Research, Summer95, Vol. 62, Issue 2, pp. 177-213. Also see http://www.wwcd.org/issues/Lakoff.html#STRICT.
    1 Kennan, George. 1976. "pps23." Foreign Relations of the United States 1. http://www.firethistime.org/georgekennanpps23.htm
    2 http://www.wordorgins.org/wordort.htm.
    3 Code of Federal Regulations 28 C.F.R. Section 0.85
    4 http://www.state.gov/s/ct/rls/patrpt/2001/html.
    5 Also see Colossus: The Price of America's Empire[M]. By Niall Ferguson. New York: Penguin Press: 2004.
    6 See detailed unclassified documents on this at the National Security Archive http://www.gwu.edu/~nsarchiv/NSAEBB/NSAEBB28/
    7 See, for example, George H. W. Bush's State of the Union Address, Envisioning One Thousand Points of Light, Tuesday, January 29,1991.
    Or, Ignatieff, Michael. 2003. The Burden: With a military of unrivaled might, the United States rules a new kind of empire. Will this cost America its soul - or save it?[J] New York Times Magazine, January 5,2003.
    Or, Friedman, Thomas L. 1999. A Manifesto for the Fast World: From supercharged financial markets to Osama bin Laden, the emerging global order demands an enforcer. That's America's new burden[J]. New York Times Magazine; March 28,1999, p. 40.
    8 Reagan, George W. Bush, and Colin Powell have all used the term "crusade".
    9 See for example, NYT SC 01-09-18
    10 Both Powell's and Racicot's 2004 use of "crusade" was used after widespread criticism of Bush's use of "crusade" in 2001.
    11 Friedman, Thomas. New York Times of March 28, 1999.
    12 Pew Center on Religion and Democracy. 2003. "Difference and Democracy" Carl F. Bowman, University of Virginia.
    13 See http://www.ncac.org.
    [1] Ahmad, Eqbal. 1998. "Unilateral Muscle-Flexing in a Unipolar World[J]." Dawn 52: 227 (August 23, 1998): 15.
    
    [2] Albright, Madeleine. 1998. "Interview of Secretary of State Madeleine Albright on NBC-TV "The Today Show" with Matt Lauer[EB/OL]." Washington DC: U.S. Department of State/Federation of American Scientists. February 19, 1998. Retrieved from the World Wide Web: http://secretary. state. gov/www/statements/1998/980219a. html.
    [3] Altheide, David L. 1996. Qualitative media analysis[M]. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.
    [4] Althusser, Louis. 2001. Lenin and Philosophy and other Essays[M]. New York, NY: Monthly Review Press.
    [5] Ambert et al. 1995. "Understanding and Evaluating Qualitative Research[J]. " Journal of Mariage and the Family, Vol. 57, No. 4. Pp. 879-893.
    [6] Anderson, Nick. 2002. "The Nation; ACTION IN CONGRESS; House Democrats Make History in Electing Pelosi; The San Francisco lawmaker will become the first woman to head her party in Congress[N]." Pp. A 22 in Los Angeles Times. Los Angeles, CA. Nov. 15, 2002.
    [7] Arkin, William M. 2002. "The Secret War; Frustrated by intelligence failures, the Defense Department is dramatically expanding its 'black world' of covert operations [N]." Pp. M.1 in The Los Angeles Times. Los Angeles, CA. October 27, 2002.
    [8] Axtman, Kris. 2003 "The Terror Threat at Home, Often Overlooked[N]. " Pp. 2 in Christian Science Monitor, 12-29-2003, Houston, TX.
    [9] Barnett, Thomas P. M. 2003. "The Pentagon' s New Map: It Explains Why We' re Going to War and Why We' 11 Keep Going to War[J]." Esquire 139:174-181. Mar/2003, Vol. 139, Issue 3.
    [10] Becker, Howard. 1963. Outsiders: Studies in the Sociology of Deviance[M]. New York: Free Press.
    [11] Beelman, Maud, Kevin Baron, Neil Gordon, Laura Peterson, Aron Pilhofer, Daniel Politic, Andre Verloy, Bob Williams, and Brooke Williams. 2003. "Winning Contractors: U.S. Contractors Reap the Windfalls of Post-War Reconstruction[R]." Washington DC:The Center for Public Integrity.Oct.30,2003.
    [12]Bender,Penny.1995."Jumping to Conclusions in Oklahoma City? Press blames Arabs for bombing[J]." American Journalism Review,June 1995,Vol.17,Issue 5,Pp.11-12.
    [133 Benford,Robert,and David Snow.2000."Framing processes and social movements:an overview and assessment[J]." Annual Review of Sociology 26:611-639.
    [14]Bennett,W.L.,and J.B Manheim.1993."Taking the public by storm:Information,cuing,and the democratic process in the Gulf conflict[J]."Political Communication 10:331-351.
    [15]Best,Joel.2002."Constructing the sociology of social problems:Spector and Kitsuse twenty-five years later[J]." Sociological Forum 17.261(p.702)
    [16]Billig,Michael.1995.Banal Nationalism[M].London:Sage Publications.
    [17]Blumer,Herbert.1971."Social Problems as Collective Behavior[J]."Social Problems 18:298-306.(p.300)
    [18]Bolden,Richard,and Jean Moscarola.2000."Bridging the quantitativequalitative divide[J]." Social Science Computer Review 18:450-460.
    [19]Bourdieu,Pierre.1989.The State Nobility.Elite Schools in the Field of Power[M].Translated by Lauretta C.Clough.Stanford,California,Stanford University Press.
    [20]Bourdieu,Pierre.1998.Practical Reason:on the theory of action[M].Stanford,CA:Stanford University Press.
    [21]Bowers et al.,2004 "Power,Ethics,and Journalism:Toward an Integrative Approach[J]." Journal of Mass Media Ethics,19(3 & 4),Pp,223-246.
    [22]Brown,Jane Delano,et al.1987."Invisible Power[J]." Journalism Quarterly 64:45-55.
    [23]Brown,Richard H.1993."Cultural representation and ideological domination[J]." Social Forces,Vol.71,No.3.(Mar.,1993),pp.657-676.
    [24]Brzezinski,Zbigniew.1997.The Grand Chessboard:American primacy and its geostrategic imperatives[M].New York:Basic Books.
    [25]Buell,John.2002." Vacations,Shopping Sprees,and Work Life[J]." The Humanist Jan/Feb2002,Vol.62,Issue 1,pp.40.
    [26]Bush,George H.W.1991."State of the Union Address:Envisioning One Thousand Points of Light[OL].." Washington DC:White House/infoplease.com.January 29,1991.
    [27]Campbell,David.1998.Writing Security:United States Foreign Policy and the Politics of Identity[M].Minneapolis:University of Minnesota Press.
    [28]Carter,Jimmy.1980."State of the Union Address[OL]." Pp.The American Presidency Project in Public Papers of the Presidents.Santa Barbara:University of California,Santa Barbara.January 23,1980.
    [29]Caufield,Susan.1999."Transforming the Criminological Dialogue:A feminist perspective on the impact of militarism[J]." Journal of Political & Military Sociology,Winter 1999.Vol.27,Iss.2,27:291-306.
    [30]CFAWAP.2003."Women In Elective Office 2003 Fact Sheet[R]." Rutgers,NJ:Eagleton Institute of Politics,State University of New Jersey.
    [31]Cherwitz,Richard,and Kenneth Zagacki.1986."Consummatory Versus Justificatory Crisis Rhetoric[J]." Western Journal of Speech Communication,(Fall 1986) 50:307-331.
    [32]Chomsky,Noam.1989.Necessary illusions:thought control in democratic societies[M].Boston:South End Press.
    [33]Chomsky,Noam and Barsamian,David.2001.Propaganda and the Public Mind:Conversations with Noam Chomsky[M].Cambridge,MA:South End Press.
    [34]Clinton,Bill.1998."Address to the Nation on Military Action Against Terrorist Sites in Afghanistan and Sudan[DB/OL]." in Public Papers of the Presidents oft he United States.Washington DC:U.S.Government Printing Office.August 20,1998.
    [35]Cohn,Carol.1995."Wars,Wimps and Women:Talking gender and Thinking War." in Men 's Lives[M],edited by Michael S.Kimmel and Michael A.Messner.Boston:Allyn and Bacon.
    [36]Coles,Roberta.1995."An Analysis of Dominant and Oppositional Ideology in the Persian Gulf Crisis[M]." Madison,WI:University of Wisconsin at Madison.
    [37]Coles,Roberta.2001."Building the Clinton Legacy Through Frame Alignment[J]." Cultural Studies and Critical Methodologies 1:459-487.
    [38]Coles,Roberta.2002."War and the contest over national identity[J]."Sociological Review 50:586-609.
    [39]Collins,Patricia Hill.1998."It' s All in the Family:Intersections of gender,race and nation[J]." Hypatia 13:62-83.
    [40]Commission Report,2005."The Commission on the Intelligence Capabilities of the United States Regarding Weapons of Mass Destruction[R]." Report to the President of the United States,March 31,2005,Washington,DC.
    [41]Connell,Robert.1995a.Masculinities[M].Berkeley,CA:University of California Press.
    [42]Connell,Robert.1995b."Masculinity,Violence and War[M]." in Men's Lives,edited by Michael Kimmel and Michael Messner.Boston:Allyn and Bacon.
    [43]Crenshaw,Kimberly Williams.1988."Race,Reform and Retrenchment:transformation and legitimization in antidiscrimination law[J]." Harvard Law review,May/1988,101:1331-1387.
    [44]Croteau,David,and William Hoynes.2000.Media Soclety:Industries,Images and Audiences[M].Thousand Oaks,CA:Pine Forge Press.
    [45]Dahl,Robert.1961.Who Governs? Democracy and Power in an American City[M].New Haven,CT:Yale University Press.
    [46]Davidson,Ros.2001."Christmas in America 2001:Shop Til Bin Laden Drops[N]." in The Sunday Herald Glasgow.December 23,2001.
    [47]Dedaic,Mirjana,and Daniel N.Nelson(Eds.).2003.At War With Words[M].Berlin:Mouton de Gruyter.
    [48]Domhoff,G.William.1990.The Power Elite and the State:How policy is made in America[M].New York:A.de Gruyter.
    [49]Domhoff,William.1998.Who Rules America:Power and Politics in the Year 2000[M].Mountain View,CA:Mayfield Publishing Company.
    [50]Dowd,Maureen.1991."War Introduced a Tougher Bush to Nation[N]." in New York Times.New York.March 2,1991,Section 1;Pg.1.
    [51]Dreier,Peter.1982."The Position of the Press in the U.S.Power Structure[J]." Social Problems 29:298-310.
    [52]Dye,Thomas.2001.Top Down Policymaking[M].New York:Chatham House Publishers/Seven Bridges Press,LLC.
    [53]Editors,Economist.2003."Let' s all go to the yard sale:Iraq's Economic Liberalisation[J]." Economist 368:44.
    [54]Editors,Fortune.2001."11 Takes on Terror:We asked our cover subjects for their reactions to the WTC disaster[J]." Vol.144,Issue 11,in Fortune.11/26/2001.
    [55]Ehrenreich,Nancy.2002."Masculinity & American militarism[J]." Tikkun,Nov.2002,Vol.17,Issue 6,17:45-48.
    [56]Fairclough,Norman.1992.Discourse and social change[M].Cambridge,UK:Polity.
    [57]Ferguson,Niall 2003."The Empire Slinks Back[N]." In the New York Times,NY.April 27,2003.
    [58]Flint,Colin;Falah,Ghazi-Walid,2004."How the United States justified its war on terrorism:prime morality and the construction of a 'just war[J].' Third World Quarterly,Vol.25,No.8,Pp.1379-1399.
    [59]Foster,John Bellamy.2003."The New Age of Imperialism[J]." Monthly Review 55:1-14.
    [60]Foucault,Michel.1990.The History of Sexuality[M].New York:Vintage.
    [61]Frankel,Glenn.2004."U.S.Mulled Seizing Oil Fields in ' 73[N]." Pp.A01 in The Washington Post.Washington,DC.January 1,2004.
    [62]Fredericks,James.2003."U.S.Foreign Policy Today:Zealotry Triumphant[N]." Pp.19 in National Catholic Reporter.April 18,2003.
    [63]Freeb,Louis.2001." Threat of Terrorism to the United States[R]." Pp.Testimony of Louis J.Freeh,Director,FBI Before the United States Senate,Committees on Appropriations,Armed Services,and Select Committee on Intelligence May 10,2001.Washington,DC:Federal Bureau of Investigation.
    [64]Frum,David.2003.The right man:the surprise presidency of George Bush[M].MY:Random House.
    [65]Fredericks,James.2003."U.S.Foreign Policy Today:Zealotry Triumphant[N]." Pp.19 in National Catholic Reporter.
    [66]Friedman,Thomas L.1999."A Manifesto for the Fast World:From supercharged financial markets to Osama bin Laden,the emerging global order demands an enforcer.That' s America' s new burden[J]." Pp.40 in New York Times Magazine.New York.March 29,1999.
    [67]Fukuyama,Francis.1992.The End of History and the Last Man[M].New York:Free Press.
    [68]Gamson,William,and Andre Modigliani.1987."The changing Culture of Affirmative ActionJ]." Research in Political Sociology 3:137-177.
    [69]Gamson,William,and Andre Modigliani.1989."Media Discourse and Public Opinion on Nuclear Power:A Constructionist Approach[J]." American Journal of Sociology 95:1-37.
    [70]Gerson,Dr.Joesph.2003."U.S.Foreign Military Bases & Military Colonialism:Personal and Analytical Perspectives,International Consultation on U.S.Bases,Seoul Dec.1 & 2,2003[A]." Philadelphia:American Friends Service Committee.
    [71]Gitlin,T.1980.The Whole World Is Watching:Mass Media in the Making &Unmaking of the New Left[M].Berkeley,CA:University of California Press.
    [72]Goffman,Erring.1986.Frame Analysis[HI.New York:Harper and Row,Publishers.
    [73]Gross,Bertram Myron.1980.Friendly Fascism:the new face of power in America[M].New York:M.Evans.
    [74]Gusfield,Joseph.1981.The Culture of Public Problems[M].Chicago:University of Chicago Press.
    [75]Haddad;Khashan 2002."Islam and Terrorism:Lebanese Muslim Views on September 11[J]." The Journal of Conflict Resolution,Vol.46,No.6.Pp.815
    [76]Hall,Stuart,et al.,1978.Policing the Crlsis:Mugging,the state and law and order[M].New York:Holmes & Meier Publishers,Inc.
    [77]Hart,Gary,and Warren B.Rudman.1999."New World Coming:American Security in the 21st Century[R]." in Phase I report on the Emerging Global Security Environment for the First Quarter of the 21st Century.Washington,OC:The United States Commission on National Seeurity/21st Century.
    [78]Hart,Roderick P.1987.The sound of leadership:presidential communication in the modern age[M].Chicago:University of Chicago Press.
    [79]Harvey,David.2003.The New Imperialism[M].Oxford:Oxford University Press.
    [80]Hayden,Craig.2003."Power in Media Frames:Thinking about Strategic Framing and Media System Dependency and the Events of September 11,2001[J]." Global Media Journal 2.Volume 2,Issue 3,Fall 2003,Article No.15.
    [81]Herman,Edward S.1998."The Propaganda Model Revisited[M]." Pp.191-205in Capitalism and the Information Age,edited by Robert McChesney,Ellen Meiksins Wood,and John Bellamy Foster.NY:Monthly Review Press.
    [82]Hess,Stephen.1984.The Government/Press Connection:Press Officers and Their Offices[M].Washington DC:Brookings Institution.
    [83]Hilgartner,Stephen,and Charles Bosk.1988."The Rise and Fall of Social Problems:A Public Arenas Model[J]." The American Journal of Sociology 94:53-78.
    [84]Holmes,Karen L.1998."U.S.presidential response to international terrorism:Implications for generic expectations(Richard M.Nixon,Gerald R.Ford,Jimmy Carter,Ronald Reagan,George Bush)[D]." in College of Communication:The Florida State University.
    [85]Hooks,Bell.1995."Feminism and Militarism:A Comment[J]." Women's Studies Quarterly:Fall 1995.Vol.23,Iss.3-4;Pp.58-64.
    [86]Horsman,Reginald.1981.Race and Manifest Destiny:the Origins of American Racial Anglo-Saxonism[M].Cambridge,MA:Harvard University Press.
    [87]Huntington,Samuel P.1996.The clash of civilizations and the remaking of world order[M].New York:Simon & Schuster.
    [88]Ignatieff,Michael.2003."The Burden:With a military of unrivaled might,the United States rules a new kind of empire.Will this cost America its soul—or save it?[J]." in New York Times Magazine New York.
    [89]Iyengar,Shanto,and Donald Kinder.1987.News that Matters:Television and American Opinion[M].Chicago:University of Chicago Press.
    [90]Johnson,Allan G.1997.The gender knot:unraveling our patriarchal legacy[M].Philadelphia:Temple University Press.
    [91]Johnson,Chalmers.2000.Blowback:The Cost and Consequences of American Empire[M].New York:Metropolitan Books.
    [92]Jordan,June.1995."In the Land of White Supremacy[J]." in The Progressive.Jun95,Vol.59 Issue 6,p21.
    [93]Juhasz,Antonia.2004."Capitalism Gone Wild—Iraq[J]." Tikkun.January-February,2004.
    [94]Kagan,Robert.1998."The Benevolent Empire[J]." Foreign Policy,No.111.(Summer 1998),Pp.24-35.
    [95]Kaufman,Michael.2000."Working with men and boys to challenge sexism and end men' s violence[R]." in Masculinities and Violence:A Culture of Peace Perspective.Paris:UNESCO,Publishing 2000,pp 223-230.edited by Ingeborg Brienes,Robert Connell,and Ingrid Eide.Also see:http://www.michaelkaufman.com/articles/workingwithmen.html.
    [96]Keen,Sam.1986.Faces of the Enemy[M].New York,NY:Harper & Row.
    [97]Kellner,Douglas.2004."The Media and the Crisis of Democracy in the Age of Bush-2[J]." Communication and Critical/Cultural Studies,Vol.1,No.1,March 2004,pp.29-58.
    [98]Kirkpatrick,David,Tkaczyk,Christopher.2001."11 takes on terror:We asked our cover subjects for their reactions to the WTC disaster[J]."Fortune Vol.144,Issue 11,11/26/2001.
    [99]Kitsuse,John,and Malcolm Spector.1973."Toward a Sociology of Social Problems:Social Conditions,Value-Judgments,and Social Problems[J]."Social Problems 20:407-419.(p.415)
    [100]Kivel,Paul.1992.Men's Work:how to stop the violence that tears our lives apart[M].NY:Ballantine Books.
    [101]Klare,Michael T.2000."Permanent Preeminence:U.S.Strategic Policy for the 21st Century[J]." NACLA Newsletter Vol.34,Issue 3.
    [102]Klein,Naomi.2003."Iraq is not America's to Sell[N]." in Guardian.London.November 7,2003.
    [103]Klein,Naomi.2004."Let's Make Enemies[J]." The Nation.April 19,2004.
    [104]Koch,tom.1990.The News as Myth:Fact and Context in Journalism[M].Westport,CT:Greenwood Press.
    [105]Kristol,William,and Robert Kagan.1996."Toward a Neo-Reaganite Foreign Policy[J]." Foreign Affairs.July-August/1996.
    [106]Kumar,Oeepa.2006."Media,War,and Propaganda:Strategies of Information Management During the 2003 Iraq War[J]." Communication and Critical/Cultural Studies,Vol.3,No.1,March 2006,pp.48-69.
    [107]Lakoff,George.1995."Metaphor,Morality,and Politics,Or,Why Conservatives Have Left Liberals In the Dust[J]." Social Research,Summer95,Vol.62,Issue 2,pp.177-213.Also see http://www.wwcd.org/issues/Lakoff.html#STRICT
    [108]Lakoff,George.2003 "Framing the Dams[J]." The American Prospect.Princeton.Sep 2003.Vol.14,Issue 8,pp.32
    [109]Leeman,Richard W.1991.The Rhetoric of Terrorism and Counterterrorism[M].New York:Greenwood Press.
    [110]Lerner,Robert,Althea Nagai,and Stanley Rothman.1996.American Elites[M].New Haven,CT:Yale University Press.
    [111]Lifton,Robert Jay.2003.Superpower Syndrome:America's Apocalyptic Confrontation with the World[M].New York:Thunder's Mouth Press/Nation Books.
    [112]Lind,Michael.2003."The Weird Men Behind George W.Bush's War[J]." Pp.10-13 in New Statesman.April 7,2003.
    [113]Mabee,Bryan.2004 "Discourses of empire:the US 'empire',globalization and international relations[J]." Third World Quarterly,Vol.25,No.8,pp.1359-1378.
    [114]Mannheim,Karl.1936.Ideology and utopia;an introduction to the sociology of knowledge[MJ.New York:Harcourt & Brace.
    [115]McAdam,Doug,Sidney Tarrow,and Charles Tilly.2001.Dynamics of Contention[M].New York:Cambridge University Press.
    [116]McChesney,Robert.1998."Making Media Democratic[J]." A POLITICAL LITERARY FORUM,Summer/1998,Boston Review 22.
    [117]Mead,Walter Russell.2002."Updating America's Foreign Policy[OL]." in Talk of the Nation.Washington DC:National Public Radio.
    [118]Messner,Michael,and Donald Sabo.1994.Sex,Violence and Power in Sports:Rethinking Masculinity[M].Freedom,CA:Crossing Press.
    [119]Mills,C.Wright.1940."Situated Actions and Vocabularies of Motive[J]." American Sociological Review 5:904-913.
    [120]Mills,C.Wright.1956.The Power Elite[M].London:Oxford University Press.
    [121]Mohammad,Fida.1999."Jihad as Terrorism:The western Media and the Defamation of the Qu'ran[M]." Pp.303-317 in Making Trouble:Cultural Constructions of Crime,Deviance and Control,edited by Jeff Ferrell and Nell Websdale.New York:Aldine de Gruyter.
    [122]Nagel,Joanne.1998."Masculinity and nationalism:gender and sexuality in the making of nations[J]." Ethnic and Racial Studie,Vol.21 Number March 1998,21:242-269.
    [123]Nelson,Dana D.1998.National Manhood:Capitalist Citizenship and the Imagined Fraternity of White Men[M].Durham,NC:Duke University Press.
    [124]Nelson,Thomas,Ice Oxley,and Rosalee Clawson.1997."Toward a Psychology of Framing Effects[J]." Political Behavior 19:221-246.
    [125]Nepstad,Sharon.1997."The Process of Cognitive Liberation:cultural synapses,links and frame contradictions in the U.S.-Central America peace movement[J]." Sociological Inquiry 67:470-487.
    [126]Niva,Steve.1998."Tough and Tender:New World Order Masculinity and the Gulf War[M]." Pp.109-128 in The "Man" Question in International Relations,edited by Marysia Zalewski and Jane Parpart.Boulder,CO:Westview Press.
    [127]Noakes,John A.2000."Official Frames in Social Movement Theory:The FBI,HUAC,and the Communist Threat in Hollywood[J]." The Sociological Quarterly 41:657-661.
    [128]Oliver,Pamela,and Hank Johnston.2000."What a Good Idea:Frames and Ideology in Social Movement Research[J]." Mobilization 5:37-54.
    [129]Oliverio,Annamarie.1998.The State of Terror[M].Albany,NY:State University of New York Press.
    [130]Omi,Michael,and Howard Winant.1994.Racial formation in the United States:from the 1960s to the 1990s[M].New York:Routledge.
    [131]Oppel,Richard A Jr.2003." A NATION AT WAR:THE CONTRACTOR;Company Has Ties in Washington,and to Iraq[N]." In New York Times.New York.April 18,2003.Pp.7.
    [132]Palast,Greg.2003.The Best Demoeraey Money Can Buy[M].New York:Plume/Penguin Putnam,Inc.
    [133]Panitch,Leo.2000."The New Imperial State[J]." New Left Review 2:5-20.
    [134]Parry-Giles,Trevor.1995."Ideology and Poetics in Public Issue Construction[J]." Communication Quarterly 43:182-196.
    [135]Perdue,William.1989.Terrorism and the State:A critique of domination through fear[M].Westport CT,Praeger Publishers.
    [126]Phillips,Peter.1998.Censored:the news that didn't make the news[M].New York:Seven Stories Press.
    [137]PNAC.1998."Iraq Clinton Letter[R]." Project for the New American Century.
    [138]PNAC.2000."Rebuilding America's Defenses:Strategy,Forces and Resources for a New Century[R]." Washington,DC:Project for the New American Century.
    [139]Powell,Colin.2004."Opening Remarks Before the National Commission on Terrorist Attacks Upon the United States[OL]." Washington DC:U.S.Department of State.March 23,2004.
    [140]Reagan,Ronald.1982."Address to Members of the British Parliament[OL]." Austin,TX:Ronald Reagan Library/University of Texas.June 8,1982.
    [141]Reagan,Ronald.1985."2nd Inaugural Address[OL]." Austin,TX:Ronald Reagan Library/University of Texas.January 21,1985.
    [142]Reese,Stephen D.2003."Prologue—framing Public Life:A Bridging Model for Media Research[M]." Pp.7-31 in Framing Public Life:Perspectives on Media and Our Understanding oft he Social World,edited by Stephen D.Reese,Jr.Oscar H.Gandy,and August E.Grant.Mahwah,NJ:Lawrence Erlbaum Associates,Publishers.
    [143]Reese,Stephen D.et al.2003.Framing Public Life.Perspectives on Media and Our Understanding of the Social World[M].Mahwah,NJ,Lawrence Erlbaum Associates,Inc.,Publishers.
    [144]Reuters,2004."Bush Letter Cites 'Crusade' Against Terrorism[EB/OL]."Reuters.April 19,2004.
    [145]Ricento,Thomas.2003."The Discursive Construction of Americanism[J]."Discourse & Society 14:637.
    [146]Ritter,Kurt and Martin Medhurst.2003.Presidential Speechwriting:From the new deal to the Reagan revolution and beyond[M].College Station,TX:Texas A & M University Press.
    [147]Robinson,Piers.2001."Theorizing the Influence of Media on World Politics[J]." European Journal of Communication 16:523-544.
    [148]Ross,Susan Dente.2002."An American Frame:New York Times Editorial Discourse on Palestine and Israel[J]." in Intercultural Communication.Barcelona,Spain:International Association for Media and Communication Research.
    [149]Roy,Arundhati.2004."The New American Century[J]." The Nation,January 22,2004.
    [150]Rumsfeld,Donald H.2002."Secretary of Defense Donald H.Rumsfeld At United States Air Force Academy Commencement Ceremony (transcript)[EB/OL]." Colorado Springs,Colorado:U.S.Department of Defense.
    [151]Said,Edward W.1978.Orientalism[M].New York:Pantheon Books.
    [152]Schlesinger,Philip.1989."From Production to Propaganda?[J]" Media,Culture and Society 11(3):283-306.
    [153]Schmierbach,M.et al.,2005 "Civic Attachment in the Aftermath of September 11[J]." MASS COMMUNICATION & SOCIETY,2005,8(4),323-346.
    [154]Sederberg,Peter C.1989.Terrorist Myths,Illusion,Rhetoric,and Reality[M].Englewood Cliffs,NJ:Prentice Hall.
    [155]Shaheen,Jack G.2001.Reel Bad Arabs:how Hollywood vilifies a people[M].New York:Olive Branch Press.
    [156]Shalom,Stephen R.1999."The continuity of US imperialism[J]." New Politics 7.No.2(Winter/1999):33-39.
    [157]Sigal,Leon V.1973.Reporters and Officials:The organization and Politics of Newsmaking[M].Lexington,MA:D.C.Heath.
    [158]Simon,A.;Xenos,M.,2000."Media Framing and Effective Public Deliberation[J]." Political Communication,Oct-Dec 2000,Vol.17,Issue 4,P.363-376.[159]Sivesind,Karl Henrik.1999."Between Singularity and Single-Dimensionality [J]." Quality & Quantity 33:361-380.
    [160]Skocpol,Theda.1979.States and Social Revolutions[M].Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
    [161]Slevin and Priest.2003."Wolfowitz Concedes Iraq Errors[N]." The Washington Post,Washington D.C.,July 24,2003,Final Edition,A section;Pg.A01.
    [162]Slotkin,Richard.1985.The Fatal Environment:the myth of the frontier in the age of industrialization,1800-1890[M].New York:Atheneum.
    [163]Smith,Tom W.,and Lars Jarkko.1998."National Pride:A Cross-national Analysis[R]." in GSS Cross-national Report No.19,edited by NORC.Chicago:National Opinion Research Center/University of Chicago.
    [164]Smith,Tom W.,Kenneth A.Rasinski,and Marianna Toce.2001."America Rebounds:A National Study of Public Response to the September 11~(th)Terrorist Attacks[EB/OL]." Chicago:NORC/University of Chicago.
    [165]Snow,David A.,Jr.et al.1986."Frame Alignment Processes,Micromobilization and Movement Participation[J]." American Sociological Review 51:464-481.
    [166]Solomon,Norman.2002."New Heights for a Remarkable Pundit[J]." in Media Beat.NY:FAIR.
    [167]Stahl,Lesly.2004."Bush Sought 'Way' To Invade Iraq?[EB/OL]" New York;CBS News/60 Minutes.Jan.11,2004.
    [168]Strinati,Dominic.1995.An Introduction to Theories of Popular Culture[M].London:Routledge.
    [169]Svaldi,Aldo,and Kris Hudson.2001."Markets to test financial fears:World watching for signs of confidence as NYSE reopens today[N]." in Denver Post.Denver.Sept.17,2001.
    [170]Team,Pew Global Attitudes Project.2002."What the World Thinks in 2002[R]." Washington,DC:The Pew Research Center for the People and the Press.
    [171]Thompson,John B.1990.Ideology and Modern Culture:Critical social theory in the era of mass communication[M].Stanford,CA:Stanford University Press.
    [172]Thornton,Patricia M.,and Thomas F.Thornton.2002."Blowback." In Collateral Language:A User's guide to Amerlca's New War[M],edited by John Collins and Ross glover.New York:New York University Press.
    [173]The New York Times,2004."The Times and Iraq[N]." May 26,2004,Editorial section:A.
    [174]Useem,Michael.1984.The Inner Circle:Large Corporations and the Rise of Business Political Activity in the U.S.and the U.K.[M].New York:Oxford University Press.
    [175]Van Dijk,Teun A.1998.Ideology:a multidisciplinary approach[M].London:Sage Publications,Ltd.
    [176]Vardy,Jill,and Chris Wattle.2001."Shopping is Patriotic,Leaders Say[EB/OL]." In National Post.Don Mills,Ontario,Canada.Sept.28, 2001.Retrieved from the World Wide Web:http://www.commondreams.org/headlines01/0929-04,htm.
    [177]Vilas,Carlos M.2002."Globalization as Imperialism[J]." Latin American Perspectives 29:70-79.(November/2002).
    [178]Waugh,William L.1982.International terrorism:how nations respond to terrorists[M].Salisbury,N.C.:Documentary Publications.
    [179]Weber,Max.1958.The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism[M].New York:Scribner.
    [180]Weber,Max.1968.Economy and Society:An Outline of Interpretive Sociology[M].New York:Bedminster Press.
    [181]Wilson,John.1973.Introduction to social movements[M].New York:Basic Books.
    [182]Wolfowitz,Paul.2003 Deputy Secretary Wolfowitz Interview with Sam Tannenhaus,Vanity Fair[OL],Friday,May 09,2003.Retrieved from the World Wide Web:http://www.defenselink.mil/transcripts/transcript.aspx?transcriptid=2594
    [183]Yuksel,E.2001."Skyscrapers versus caves;The Unholy war between capitalist crusaders and feudal mujahids[J]." Presence Magazine,November issue,pp.2-8.
    [184]Zaller,J.1992.The nature and origins of mass opinion[M].Cambridge,UK,Cambridge University Press.
    [1]赵鼎新:“社会与政治运动讲义[M]”,北京,社会科学文献出版社,2006.第212页。
    [2]李良荣:“西方新闻事业概论[M]”,上海,复旦大学出版社,2006.第123页。
    [3]陈向明:“质的研究方法与社会科学研究[M]”,北京,教育科学出版社,2006.第270-271页。
    [4]童兵:“马克思主义新闻经典教程[M]”,上海,复旦大学出版社,2002.第27页。

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700