用户名: 密码: 验证码:
海岸带区域战略决策的环境风险评价研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
环境风险评价是按照一定的评价标准和评价方法对人类活动和各种自然灾害引起的风险进行评估,并提出合理可行的防范、应急与减缓措施,以使事故率、损失和环境影响达到可接受水平。目前国内外的环境风险评价中,未见在海岸带区域战略决策中应用环境风险评价;针对区域战略决策的环境风险评价的技术路线和方法体系缺少系统性研究,其评价结果也较难为区域战略决策提供明确的结论。海岸带作为海陆作用明显的区域,其生态系统面临人类开发活动带来的巨大压力。故针对海岸带区域战略决策环境风险评价的技术路线和方法亟待研究,以避免决策失误而带来严重的后果。
     本文通过对国内外环境风险评价技术路线及方法进行比较,总结了环境风险评价的研究进展、发展趋势和存在问题。通过对海岸带区域的特性的了解,明确海岸带区域战略决策对环境风险评价的需求,针对现有评价存在难以支持决策的问题,构建了海岸带区域战略决策环境风险评价的技术路线和方法体系。
     在海岸带区域战略决策环境风险评价技术路线的构建中,参考国内外决策环境风险评价的发展趋势,并基于海岸带区域特性,设计了一种新的以多维决策法为基础的区域战略决策环境风险评价的技术路线,包括战略决策制定前的环境风险评价以支持决策备选方案的制定、战略决策过程中的环境风险评价以支持决策方案的确定,和决策后的环境风险评价为管理决策服务。
     在方法体系的构建中,参考国内外应用较多的环境风险评价的方法,通过各种方法优缺点的比较,并结合海岸带区域的特性、海岸带区域主要存在的环境风险类型、以及上述基于多维决策法环境风险评价技术路线三个主要阶段中各自的内容和要求,遴选各阶段适合的环境风险评价方法,构建了海岸带区域战略决策环境风险评价的方法体系。包括战略决策制定前的回顾性和现状环境风险评价以及专家评判法等方法;战略决策过程中的多维决策法(Multi-Dimension Decision Mking, MDDM)和多准则决策分析法(Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis, MCDA);以及为管理决策服务环境风险评价方法如概率统计分析法、风险矩阵法等。
     本文在海岸带区域战略决策备选方案选择阶段应用了当前决策方法中较为盛行的MCDA的技术路线和相关方法,并将其与MDDM同时应用于海岸带主体功能区划项目的厦门湾和罗源湾案例中,通过应用过程和评价结果对两种方法进行比较研究。通过比较研究,MCDA和MDDM主要有以下差别:
     从应用过程的比较可以看出:(1) MCDA对评价数据的要求较高,MDDM对基础数据资料的处理更为全面、客观;(2) MCDA仍存在指标选择、指标的标准值确定和权重分配等问题;(3) MCDA相对多维决策法有更明确的评价流程,而MDDM比选备选方案的可操作性较强。
     尽管两种方法最终决策评价的结果较为一致,但从评价结果可以看出:(1)MDDM的结果与公众参与的结果基本一致,而MCDA在罗源湾石油化工风险方面评价的结果与公众参与的结果偏差较为明显;(2) MCDA对两种决策备选方案的决策结果差异不大,对决策的支持较模糊;而MDDM的决策结果较明晰,对决策支持程度明显优于多准则决策分析法。
     本研究建立的以MDDM为基础的海岸带区域战略决策环境风险评价的技术路线和方法体系,打破了传统决策环境风险评价的模式,并且能够通过MDDM有效支持决策,避免海岸带区域战略决策的环境风险失误,确保海岸带区域的可持续发展。
Environmental risk assessment is a process that evaluates risk on the environment caused by human activities and nature disasters in order to formulate precaution and interrelated risk management measures to reduce and mitigate risk and its impact to achieve in acceptable level. In China or international, there is no related application of environmental risk assessment in strategic decision-making processes and no systematic research on the approaches and methods of environmental risk assessment aiming at supporting regional strategic decision-making processes. The coastal ecosystem is confronted with tremendous press from human activities. Therefore, environmental risk assessment that support coastal strategic decision-making processes would be in urgent to avoid the serious risk caused by the errors of decision-making processes.
     The research progress, development, approaches and methods of environmental risk assessment were summarized, and then an approach and methodology of environmental risk assessment for strategic decision-making process in coastal area was proposed in this dissertation.
     According to the features of coastal area and strategic decision-making processes, a new approach of environmental risk assessment based on Multi-Dimension Decision-Making (MDDM) approach was set up, which includes three stages:the environmental risk assessment before decision-making process to support the formulation of alternatives of strategic decision-making (Phase Ⅰ), the environmental risk assessment in decision-making process to support the determination of strategic decision-making (Phase Ⅱ), and the environmental risk assessment after decision-making to service managerial decision-making process (Phase Ⅲ).
     The methodological system of environmental risk assessment for strategic decision-making processes in coastal area was established based on the features of coastal area, main types of environmental risk in coastal area and the approach including three phases mentioned above by comparing the advantages and disadvantages of current main methods in international. The methodology mainly includes:retrospective assessment and experts judgment used in Phase I, multi-dimension decision-making (MDDM) method and its model used in Phase II comparing with Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis (MCDA), and Probability statistic analysis, risk matrix and other suitable traditional methods used in Phase III.
     The MDDM and MCDA were used in the determination of decision-making processes in the case studies of principal coastal functional zoning in the coastal areas of Xiamen Bay and Luoyuan Bay. The comparison of two methods of environmental risk assessment, MDDM and MCDA, are summarized as following:
     In the view of application process, the differences between MDDM and MCDA were found that:(1) MCDA requires more strict and specified data, while MDDM collected all existing data for the assessment to ensure the integrity and objectivity information for decision-making process;(2) MCDA still exists some inherent problems in the selection of criteria or indexes, the determination of standard value of criteria and determination of weight;(3) The technological progress of MCDA is more clear than MDDM and less flexible, while MDDM is more convenient to operate than the MCDA in the comparison of alternative and determination of decision-making processes.
     The final assessment result of decision-making processes calculated by two methods are consistent relatively, but in the view of assessment result, the differences were still found that:(1) the results by MDDM have higher consistency with the result of public involvement and expert-judgment than MCDA. The result of MCDA in the assessment of petroleum industrial risk in Luoyuan Bay was different with that of public participation;(2) In the comparison of alternatives for decision-making processes, the results by MCDA did not show much differences between different alternatives, and less support for decision-making processes than MDDM.
     The approach and methodology of environmental risk assessment of strategic decision-making process in coastal area based on MDDM can combine environmental risk assessment into decision-making process, well support decision-making process, avoid environmental risk caused by the errors of strategic decision-making process in coastal area, and promote the sustainable development in coastal area.
引文
1 福建省海洋与渔业厅.中国福建省沿海风暴潮灾统计,2010.
    1 浙江省海洋与渔业厅.中国浙江省沿海风暴潮灾统计,2011.
    2 浙江省宁波市北仑区交通运输管理局.《象山港港口群和岸线布局规划》,2012.
    1 厦门大学环境与生态学院,海洋与海岸带发展研究院.海湾与海岸带主体功能区划-厦门湾专题报告7生态风险评价,2012.
    1 厦门大学环境与生态学院,海洋与海岸带发展研究院.海湾与海岸带主体功能区划-厦门湾专题报告2社会评价,2012.
    1 厦门大学环境与生态学院,海洋与海岸带发展研究院.海湾与海岸带主体功能区划研究总报告,2012.
    1 厦门大学环境与生态学院,海洋与海岸带发展研究院.海湾与海岸带主体功能区划-厦门湾专题报告3经济,2012.
    2 厦门大学环境与生态学院,海洋与海岸带发展研究院.海湾与海岸带主体功能区划-厦门湾专题报告2社会,2012.
    1 厦门大学环境与生态学院,海洋与海岸带发展研究院.海湾与海岸带主体功能区划-厦门湾专题报告2社会.2012.
    1 厦门大学环境与生态学院,海洋与海岸带发展研究院.海湾与海岸带主体功能区划-厦门湾专题报告3经济,2012.
    2 厦门大学环境与生态学院,海洋与海岸带发展研究院.海湾与海岸带主体功能区划-厦门湾专题报告2社会,2012.
    1 厦门大学环境与生态学院,海洋与海岸带发展研究院.海湾与海岸带主体功能区划-厦门湾专题报告2社会,2012.
    1 厦门大学环境与生态学院,海洋与海岸带发展研究院.海湾与海岸带主体功能区划-厦门湾专题报告3经济,2012.
    1 厦门大学环境与生态学院,海洋与海岸带发展研究院.海湾与海岸带主体功能区划-厦门湾专题报告2社会.2012.
    1 厦门大学环境与生态学院,海洋与海岸带发展研究院.海湾与海岸带主体功能区划-厦门湾专题报告3经济,2012.
    2 厦门大学环境与生态学院,海洋与海岸带发展研究院.海湾与海岸带主体功能区划-厦门湾专题报告2社会,2012.
    1 泉州市港务局.围头湾航道工程环评报告,2009.
    1 厦门大学环境与生态学院,海洋与海岸带发展研究院.海湾与海岸带主体功能区划-厦门湾专题报告3经济,2012.
    2 厦门大学环境与生态学院,海洋与海岸带发展研究院海湾与海岸带主体功能区划-厦门湾专题报告2社会,2012.
    1 厦门大学环境与生态学院,海洋与海岸带发展研究院.海湾与海岸带主体功能区划研究总报告,2012.
    1 厦门大学环境与生态学院,海洋与海岸带发展研究院.海湾与海岸带主体功能区划-厦门湾专题报告3经济,2012.
    1 厦门大学环境与生态学院,海洋与海岸带发展研究院.海湾与海岸带主体功能区划-厦门湾专题报告3经济,2012.
    1 厦门大学环境与生态学院,海洋与海岸带发展研究院.海湾与海岸带上体功能区划-厦门湾专题报告3经济,2012.
    1 《罗源县海洋与渔业局2012工作总结》.罗源县海洋与渔业局,2012.
    1 厦门大学环境与生态学院,海洋与海岸带发展研究院.海湾与海岸带主体功能区划-厦门湾专题报告3经济,2012.
    2 厦门大学环境与生态学院 海洋与海岸带发展研究院.海湾与海岸带主体功能区划-厦门湾专题报告3经济,2012.
    1 厦门大学环境与生态学院,海洋与海岸带发展研究院.海湾与海岸带主体功能区划-厦门湾专题报告3经济,2012
    1 厦门大学环境与生态学院,海洋与海岸带发展研究院.海湾与海岸带主体功能区划-厦门湾专题报告3经济,2012.
    1 厦门大学环境与生态学院,海洋与海岸带发展研究院.海湾与海岸带主体功能区划-厦门湾专题报告3经济,2012.
    1 厦门大学环境与生态学院,海洋与海岸带发展研究院.海湾与海岸带主体功能区划-厦门湾专题报告3经济,2012.
    2 《罗源县海洋与渔业局2012工作总结》.罗源县海洋与渔业局,2012.
    1 厦门大学环境与生态学院,海洋与海岸带发展研究院.海湾与海岸带主体功能区划-厦门湾专题报告3经济.2012.
    1 《罗源县海洋与渔业局2012工作总结》.罗源县海洋与渔业局,2012.
    2 《中国经济社会发展统计数据库-厦门》.国家统计局,2012.
    1 厦门大学环境科学研究中心,福州市环境科学研究所.环罗源湾环境保护规划报告[R],2007.
    1 福建省海洋与渔业局.中国福建沿海的风暴潮灾.2010.
    2 厦门大学海洋与海岸带发展研究院和福州环境科学研究所.环罗源湾区域环境保护规划,2007.
    3 福州海事局.福州市各辖区船舶溢油和潜在溢油事故统计.2010.
    1 福州海事局.福州各辖区船舶溢油和潜在溢油事故统计,2009.
    1 厦门大学海洋与海岸带发展研究院和福州环境科学研究所.环罗源湾区域环境保护规划,2007.
    2 厦门大学海洋与海岸带发展研究院和福州环境科学研究所.环罗源湾区域环境保护规划,2007.
    1 厦门大学环境与生态学院,海洋与海岸带发展研究院.海湾与海岸带主体功能区划研究总报告,2012.
    1 厦门大学环境与生态学院,海洋与海岸带发展研究院.海湾与海岸带主体功能区划-罗源湾专题报告2社会,2012.
    1 厦门大学环境科学研究中心,福州市环境科学研究所.环罗源湾环境保护规划报告[R],2007.
    1 罗源县海洋与渔业局.《罗源县海洋与渔业局2012工作总结》,2012.
    Accorsi R, Apostolakis G E, Zio E. Prioritizing stakeholder concerns in environmental risk management [J]. Journal of Risk Research,1999,2(1):11-29.
    Anderson C M, Labelle R P. Comparative occurrence rate for offshore oil spill [J]. Spill Science Technology Bulletin,1994,11(3):131-141.
    Anderson M E. Toxickinetic modeling and its applications in chemical risk assessment [J]. Toxicology Letter,2003,13(8):9-27.
    Andrews C J. Humble Analysis:The Practice of Joint Fact-Finding, Praeger [R]. Westport, CT, 2002.
    Apel H. Thieken A H, Merz B. Flood risk assessment and associated uncertainty [J]. Natural Hazards and Earth System Science,2004,4(2):295-308.
    Apul D S, Gardner K H, Eighmy T T. Comparision of risks from use of traditional and recycled road construction materials:According for variability in contaminatant release estimates [C]. Linkov I, Ramadan A, editors. Comparative Risk Assessment and Environmental Decision Making. London:Kluwer Academics Publishers,2002,57-75.
    Barnthouse L, Suter G, Rosen A, et al. Estimating responses of fish populations to toxic contamination [J]. Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry,1987,6(1):811-824.
    Belezer R, Bruce G, Peterson M, et al. Using comparative exposure analysis to validate low-dose huan health risk assessment:The case of Perchlorate [C]. Linkov I, Ramadan A, editors. Comparative Risk Assessment and Environmental Decision, Making. London:Kluwer Academics Publishers,2002,57-75.
    Binelli A. Present status of POP contamination in Lake Maggiore in Italy [J]. Chemosphere,2004, 57 (1):27-34.
    Budnitz R J, Apostolakis G E, Boore D M. Use of technical expert panels:Applications of probability seismic hazard analsis [J]. Risk Analysis,1998,18(4):463-469.
    Calamari D, Zhang L P. Environmental risk assessment of pesticides on aquatic life in Xiamen, China [J]. Toxicology Letters,2002,128(1-3):45-53.
    Chen K, Blong R. Towards an integrated approach to natural hazards risk assessment using GIS: with Reference to Bushfires [J]. Natural Hazard,2003,7(3):34-46.
    Chen Z, Li H, Ren H, et al. A total environmental risk assessment model for international hub airports [J]. International Journal of Project Management,2011,11(4):3-13.
    Contini S, Bellezza F, Christou M D, et al. The use of geographic information systems in major accident risk assessment and management [J]. Journal of Hazardous Materials,2000,78 (3): 223-245.
    Cooke R M. Expert in uncertainty:Expert opinion and subjective probability in science [M]. Oxford:Oxford University Press,1991,12-14.
    Covello V T, Merkhorer M. The Determinants of Trust and Credibility in Environmental Risk communication:An Empirical Study [J]. Risk Analysis,1997,17(1):43-52.
    Criehto M. The risk triangle ingleton in Natural Disaster Management [M]. London:Tudor Rose, 1999,102-103.
    Cyranoski D. Visions of China [J]. Nature,2008,4(54):384-387.
    Devanney J W, Stewart R J. A Bayesian Approach to Oil Spill Statisties [M]. London:Society of Naval Architects and Marine Engineers (SNAME),1974,85-87.
    Dilley M, Chen R S, Deichmann U, et al. Natural Disaster Hotspots:A global risk analysis [R]. World Bank:Hazard Management Unit, Washington D.C.,2005.
    DOE (Department of Energy) 0002, Guidebook to decision-making methods [S]. Washington D.C., 2002.
    Eduljee G H. Trend in risk assessment and risk management [J]. The Science of Total Environment,2000,24(9):13-23.
    Erdik M, Aydino N. Earthquake vulnerability of building in Trukey [C]. Risk and Governance, Program of World Congress on Risk editors. Belgium:Brussels Press,2003,55-65.
    Farber J M, Ross W H, Harwig J. Health risk assessment of Listeria monocytogenes in Canada [J]. International Journal of Food Microbiology,1996,1(30):145-156.
    Finizio A, Villa S. Environmental risk assessment for pesticides:A tool for decision-making [J]. Environmental Impact Assessment Review,2002,2(2):235-248.
    Ganoulis J. Evaluating alternative strategies for wastewater recycling and reuse in the Mediterranean area [J]. Water Technology and Water Supply,2004,3(4):9-11.
    Gaudet C L, Power E A, Milne D A, et al. A framework for ecological risk assessment at contaminated sites in Canada:Review and recommendation [J]. Human and Ecological Risk Assessment,1994,1(2):43-115.
    Gouveia N and Fletcher T. Time series analysis of air pollution and mortality:Effects by cause age and socioeconomic status [J]. Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health,2000, 54(10):50-755.
    Grech A, Coles R, Marsh H. A broad-scale assessment of the risk to coastal seagrasses from cumulative threats [J]. Marine Policy,2011,3(5):560-567.
    Hamalanien R. Reversing the Perspective on the applications of decision analysis [J]. Decision Analysis,2003,18(3):13-24.
    Hartman D H and Goltz M N. Application of the analytic hierarchy process to select characterization and risk-based decision-making and management methods for hazardous waste sites [J]. Environmental Engineerging and Policy,2002,11(2):1-7.
    Hayes E, Landis W. Regional ecological risk assessment of a near shore marine environment: Cherry Point, WA [J]. Human and Ecological Risk Assessment,2004,10(2):299-325.
    Health Council of the Netherland. Risk is more than just a number [R]. Committee on Risk Measures and Risk Assessment, The Hague,1989.
    Helm P. Integrated risk management for natural and technological disasters [J]. Tephra,1996, 15(1):4-13.
    Hope B K. An examination of ecological risk assessment and management practice [J]. Environmental International,2006,32(8):955-983.
    IMO (International Maritime Organization) 1023, Guidelines for formal safety assessment [S]. London,2002.
    IPCC (Intergovernment Panel on Climate Changge). Climate Change:The Scientific Basis [M]. London:Cambridge University Press,2001,22-32.
    ITC (International Institute for Geo-Information Science and Earth Observation). Multi-Hazard Risk Assessment [M]. Bangkok:Bangkok University Press,2009,253-265.
    Johnkman S N. Loss of life estimation in flood risk assessment theory and application [D]. Doctoral thesis, Institute for Environmental Technology, Delft University,2007.
    Jonks K. A retrospective on ten years of comparative risk [D]. Doctoral thesis, Institute for Environmental Democracy, Vermont University,1997.
    Kaplan S, Garrik J B. Die quantitative Bestimmungvon Risiko [J]. Risiko und Gesellschaft,1993, 8(3):91-124.
    Keane S E, Cho J. Comparative risk assessment in developing countries [R]. The World Bank: Pollution management Forum,2000.
    Keisler J M, Sundell R C. Combining multi-attribute utility and geographic information for boundary decisions:An application to park planning [J]. Journal of Geographic Information and Decision Analysis,1997,1(2):101-118.
    Khadam I M, Kaluarachichi J J. Multi-criteria decision analysis with probabilitic risk assessment for the management of contaminated ground water [J]. Environmental Impact Assessment Review,2003,2(3):683-721.
    Klauer B, Drechsler M, Messner F. Multi-criteria analysis more under uncertainty with IANUS-method and empirical results [R]. UFZ Discussion Gmbh, Germany,2009.
    Konisky D. Comparative risk projects:Methodology for Cross-Project Analysis of Human Health Risk Rankings [M]. Washington D.C.:RFF Press,1999,1-23.
    Lei S, Chun S. Progress in vulnerability assessment of natural disasters in coastal cities [J]. Journal of Catastrophology,2007,22(1):102-105.
    Levy J K, Hipel K W, Kilgour D M. Using environmental indicators to quantify the robustness of policy alternatives to uncertainty [J]. Ecological Modeling,2000,130(1):79-86.
    Linkov I, Ramadan A B. Comparative Risk Assessment and Environmental Decision [M]. Netherland:Kluwer Acdemic Publishers,2002,2-10.
    Linkov I, Kiker G, Satterstrom F K, et al. From comparative risk assessment to multi-criteria decision analysis and adaptive management:Recent developments and applications [J]. Environmental International,2006,32(10):72-93.
    Linkov I, Kiker G. Environmental Security in Habors and Costal Areas:Management Using Comparative Risk assessment and Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis [M]. Berlin:Springer press,2009,23-32.
    Lowels G. Integrated assessment models-tool for developing emission abatement strategy for black triangle region [J]. Journal of Hazard Material,1998,6(12):2-9.
    Malherbe L. Designing a contaminated soil sampling strategy for human health risk assessment [J]. Journal for Quality, Comparability and Reliability in Chemical Measurement,2002,7(5): 189-194.
    Mark R, Oistein J, Per J B, et al. Oil spill model towards the close of the 20th century [J]. Spill Science and Technology Bulletin,1999,5(1):3-16.
    Markus J. A review of the contamination of soil with spatial distribution and risk assessment of soil lead [J]. Environmental International,2001,27(5):399-411.
    McDaniels T. Using judgment in Resource Management:a multiple objective analysis of a fisheries management decision [J]. Operation Research,1995,43(3):415-426.
    Merrick J R, Van Dorp J R, Blackford J P, et al. Traffic density analysis of proposed ferry service expansion in San Francisco Bay using a maritime simulation model [J]. Reliability Engineering and System Safety,2003,81(2):119-132.
    Merrick J R, Van Dorp J R. Speaking the truth in maritime risk assessment [J]. Risk Analysis, 2006,26(1):223-236.
    Mileti D. Disasters by Design:A Reassessment of Natural Hazards in the United States [M]. Washington D.C.:Joseph Henry Press,1999,234-245.
    Novack S D, Siu N O, Hill S G. The use of event trees in oil spill prevention applications [R]. International Oil Spill Conference,1997.
    ODPM (Office of Deputy Prime minister, USA). Multi-criteria decision-making manual [OL]. 2005, http://www.odpm.gov.uk/stellent/groups/odpre.
    O'Laughilin. Rodentcide act policy for risk assessment in federal land and resource management decision [J]. Forest and ecology management,2005,2(11):15-17.
    O'Neill R V, Gardner R H, Barnthouse L W, et al. Ecosystem risk analysis:A new methodology of environmental toxico and chemistry [J]. Risk Analysis,1982,2(1):67-77.
    Paolo F R. Practical analysis of decision analysis for risk management [C]. Brian J, Jack T, editors. Environmental and Health risk assessment and management. Berlin:Springer press,2006, 415-445.
    Paustenbach D. A survey of health risk assessment [C]. Paustenbach D, editor. The Risk Assessment of Environmental and Human Health Hazard:A text Book of Case Studies. New York:John Wiley & Sons,1989,283-301.
    PCCRARM (Presidential/Congressional Commision on Risk Assessment and Risk management). Risk assessment and risk management in regulatory decision-making, Final Report, [R]. Washington D.C.,1997.
    Pereira R. Plan for an integrated human and environmental risk assessment in the Domingos mine area (Portugal) [J]. Human and Ecological Risk Assessment,2004,10(3):543-578.
    Power M, McCarty L S. Trends in the development of ecological risk assessment and management frameworks [J]. Human and Ecological Risk Assessment,2002,8(1):7-18.
    Prato T. Multiple-attribute evaluation of ecosystem management for the Missiouri River system [J]. Ecological Economics,2003,4(5):297-309.
    Preston B L, Shackelford J. Multiple stressor effects on benthic biodiversity of Cheaspeake Bay: Implications for ecological risk assessment [J]. Ecotoxicology,2002,11(2):85-99.
    Ralston B E, Jackson, J A, Kloeber J M, et al. Development of a decision support system for the department of energy s selection of waste remediation technologies [R]. Center for Modeling, Simulation and Analysis, Washington D.C.,1996.
    Ramanathan R. A note on the use of the analytical hierarchy process for environmental impact assessment [J]. Journal of Environmental Management,2001,6(1):27-35.
    Rauscher H M, Lloyd F T, Loftis D L, et al. A practical decision-analysis process for forest ecosystem management [J]. Computers and Electronics in Agriculture,2000,27(1):195-226.
    Re-Ti, Ai-Jun. Human health risk assessment on contaminants in recycled plastic bags packaged foods [J]. Environmental Science & Technology,2010,33(11):181-185.
    Robert H, Sehulze D. Probability of an oil spill on the St.marys river [R]. Oil Spill Conference, Washington D.C.,1983.
    Rodriguez R and Grant R. Toxicity evaluation and human health risk assessment of surface and ground water contaminated by recycled hazardous waste materials [J]. Water Pollution,2005, 11(2):133-189.
    Santillo D, Stringer R L, Johnston P A, et al. The precautionary principle:Protecting against failures of scientific methods and risk assessment [J]. Marine Pollution Bulletin,1998,36(12): 939-950.
    Satty T L. Decision-Making With Dependence and Feedback:The Analytic Network Process [M]. Pittsburgh:RWS Publication,1996,35-65.
    Schmoldt D L, Peterson D L, Silsbee D G. Developing inventory and monitoring programs based on multiple objectives [J]. Environmental Management,1994,18(5):707-727.
    Schwenk C. Strategic decision-making [J]. Journal of Management,1995,21(3):471-493.
    Siddiqui M, Everett J, Vieux B. Landfill sitting using geographic information system:A demonstration [J]. Journal of Environmental Engineering,1996,11(2):32-43.
    Sinka D, Skanata D. Risk assessment in Kelodiea [C]. Linkov I, Kiker G, Wenning R J, editors. Environmental Security in Habor and Costal Areas:Management Using Comparative Risk Assessment and Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis. Berlin:Springer press,2009,135-137.
    Siu N O, Kelly D L. Bayesian parameter estimation in probabilistic risk assessment [J]. Reliability Engineering and System Safty,1998,62(1):89-116.
    Smith K. Environmental Hazards [M]. London:Routledge,1996, p389.
    Sorvari J, Seppala J. A decision support tool to prioritize risk management options for contaminated site [J]. Science of the Total Environment,2010,408(8):1786-1799.
    Standards Australia/Standards New Zealand. Risk management guidelines:companion to AS/NZS 4360-2004 [S]. New South Wales, Wellington,2004.
    Suter G W, Barnthouse L W, Baes C F, et al. Environmental risk analysis for direct coal liquefaction [S]. ORNL/TM-9074, Oak Ridge National Laboratory, Oak Ridge, USA,1984.
    Suter G W, Vermeire T, Munns W R, Sekizawa. Framework for the integration of health and ecological risk assessment [J]. Human and Ecological Risk Assessment,2003,9(1):281-301
    Tal A. Towards a more coherent regional environmental agenda in the middle east:exploring the role of comparative risk assessment [C]. Linkov I, Ramadan A, editors. Comparative Risk Assessment and Environmental Decision Making. London:Kluwer Academics Publishers, 2002,125-133.
    Therivel R, Wilson E, Thomason S, et al. Strategic Environmental Assessment [M]. London: Earthscan Publication,1992,131-136.
    Topuz E, Talinali I, Aydin E. Integration of environmental and human health risk assessment for industries using hazardous materials:A quantitative multi criteria approach for environmental decision makers [J]. Environment International,2011,37(2):393-403.
    Tsai PJ, Shieh H Y, Lee W J, et al. Health-risk assessment for workers exposed to polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) in a carbon black manufacturing industry [J]. Science of the Total Environmental,2001,278(1):137-150.
    UKDOE (U.K. Department of the Environment). A guide to risk assssment and risk management for environmental protection [S]. Her Majestry's Stationery Office, London, UK,1995.
    USACE (U.S. Army Crop of Engineers). Risk assessment handbook [R]. Washington D.C.: National Academy Press,2010.
    USEPA (U.S.Environmental Protection Agency). Risk assessment and management:Framework for decision-making [R]. Washington D.C.:National Academy Press,1984.
    USEPA (U.S.Environmental Protection Agency). Guidelines for exposure assessment [S]. Washington D.C.,1992.
    USEPA (U.S.Environmental Protection Agency). Guidelines for ecological risk assessment [S]. Washington D.C.,1996.
    USEPA (U.S.Environmental Protection Agency). Guidelines for carcinogen risk assessment [S]. Washington D.C.,1998.
    USEPA (U.S.Environmental Protection Agency). Framework for cumulative risk assessment [R]. National Center for Environmental Assessment, Risk Assessment Forum, Washington D.C.: National Academy Press,2003.
    USNRC (U.S.National Research Council). A guide to the performance of probabilistic risk assessment for nuclear power plant [R]. Washington D.C.:National Academy Press,1975.
    USNRC (U.S.National Research Council). Risk assessment in the federal government:Managing the process [R]. Washington D.C.:National Academy Press,1983.
    USNRC (U.S.National Research Council). Science and Judgment in Risk Assessment [M]. Washington D.C.,:National Academy Press,1994.
    USNRC (U.S.National Research Council). Toxicity Testing in the 21st Century:A Vision and A Strategy [M]. Washington D.C.:National Academy Press,2007,102-103.
    USNRC (U.S.National Research Council). Risk of vessel accidents and spills in the Aleutian Islands:Designing a comprehensive risk assessment [R].Washington D.C.:National Academy Press,2008.
    USNRC (U.S.National Research Council). Science and decision:Advancing risk assessment [R]. Washington D.C.:National Academy Press,2009.
    Van Drop J R, Merrick J R W, Harrald J, et al. A risk management procedure for the Washington State Ferries [J]. Risk Analysis,2001,21 (1):127-142.
    Varghese A. A comparative risk approach to assessing point of use water treatment system in developing countries[M]. Linkov I, Ramadan A editors. Comparative Risk Assessment and Environmental Decision Making. London:Kluwer Academics Publishers,2002,99-113.
    Walker R, Brown P. Developing a regional ecological risk assessment:A case study of a Tasmanian agricultural catchment. Human and Ecological Risk Assessment,2002, 7(2):417-439.
    WBGU (German Advisory Council on Global Change). World in Transition:Strategies for Managing Global Environmental Risk [M]. Berlin:Springer,2000,17-21.
    Wessberg N, Molarius R, Seppala J, Koskela S, Pennanen J. Environmental risk analysis for accidental emission [J]. Chem Health Safety,2008,1(5):24-31.
    Winter C L, Daniel M. A reduced complexity model for probabilistic risk assessment of groundwater contamination [J].Water resource research,2008,44(3):231-245.
    World Health Organization (WHO). IPCS risk assessment terminology [R]. WHO, Geneva,2004.
    Ye J Y, Lin G F, Zhang M F. GIS-Based Study of Natural Disaster Vulnerability for Xiamen City [J]. Journal of natural disaster,2009,3(2):12-32.
    Zhang K, Kluck C, Achari G. A comparative approach for ranking contaminated sites based on the risk assessment paradigm using fuzzy PROMETHEE. Environmental Management [J],2009, 44(9):52-67.
    白健,吴芳,王月明.模糊综合评价与AHP法在项日风险管理中的应用[J].四川建筑,2011,12(1):236-239.
    白志鹏,工珺,游燕.环境风险评价[M].北京:高等教育出版社,2008,117-120.
    陈鸿汉,何江涛.污染场地健康风险评价的理论和方法[J].地学前沿,2006,13(1):216-233.
    陈华,平蕊珍.大气环境健康风险评价研究初探[J].安徽农业科学,2009,37(36):39-41.
    陈华丽,陈刚,丁国平.基于GIS的区域洪水灾害风险评价[J].人民长江,2003,34(6):49-51.
    陈辉,刘劲松,曹宇等.生态风险评价研究进展[J].生态学报,2006,26(5):58-66.
    陈能汪,洪华生,张珞平.流域尺度氮流失的环境风险评价[J].厦门大学学报,2006,19(1):1-5.
    陈则实.中国海湾志(第八分册)[M].北京:海洋出版社,1993,165-235.
    程胜高,鱼红霞.环境风险评价的理论与实践研究[J].环境评价,2001,11(9):23-25.
    崔胜辉,洪华生,张路平等.全球变化下的海岸带生态安全问题与管理原则[J].厦门大学学报(自然科学版)(增刊),2004,43:173-178.
    丁厚成.工业事故风险评价模型[J].工业安全与环保,2004,30(11):36-37.
    付在毅,许学工.区域生态风险评价[J].地球科学进展,2001,16(2):261-271.
    葛全胜,邹铭,郑景云等.中国自然灾害风险综合评估初步研究[M].北京:科学出版社,2008,123-145.
    宫博.石油化工企业危险性分析及评价[D].东北大学硕士学位论文,2006.
    国家海洋局编.中国海洋年鉴(1987-2003)(第一版)[M].北京:中国海洋出版社,2004,177-182.
    过孝民.环境决策与信息支持[J].环境科学研究,1997,5(1):14-15.
    洪晓煜.船舶溢油风险评价在港湾区域环境规划中的应用[D].厦门大学硕士学位论文,2008.
    胡二邦.环境风险评价实用技术和方法[M].北京:中国环境科学出版社,2000,80-82.
    胡光荣.决策树在商业银行风险分析中的应用[J].金融信息化论坛,2005,10(8):17-18.
    黄崇福.自然灾害风险评价理论与实践[M].北京:科学出版社,2004,23-34.
    黄鹄.广西海岸环境脆弱性研究[M].北京:海洋出版社,2005,15-20.
    黄圣彪,王子建,乔敏.区域环境风险评价及其关键科学问题[J].环境科学学报,2007,27(5):221-224.
    黄蒇,张珞平,方秦华.回顾性评价在战略环境评价中的重要性和作用[J].环境与可持续发展,2009,7(1):52-54.
    纪灵,王荣纯,刘昌文.海岸带综合管理中的海洋污染监测及其在决策中的应用[J].海洋通报,2001,20(5):54-59.
    贾晓霞,杨乃定,姜继娇.高新技术项目区域风险多层次灰色评价[J].数学的实践与认识,2004,34(2):2-9.
    姜玲.油库泄露的环境风险评价方法初探[J].江苏环境科技,2005,18(1):44-46.
    蒋维,金磊.中国城市综合减灾对策.北京:中国建筑工业出版社,1992,2(1):74-85.
    金海明,戴林伟.宁波港海域船舶突发性溢油风险估算及防治对策[J].浙江交通职业技术学院学报,2006,7(2):33-36.
    李安云.层次分析法在工程项目风险管理中的应用[J].重庆科技学院学报,2005,46(3):55-59.
    李海凌,宋吉荣.层次分析法在工程项目风险评价中的应用研究[J].四川建筑,2004,5(3):23-26.
    李民,方莉.大坝安全检查和失事模式评估[J].大坝和安全,2005,4(7):11-17.
    林逢春,陆雍森.幕景分析法在累积影响评价中的实例应用研究[J].上海环境科学,2001,2(6):288-291.
    林玉锁.国外环境风险评价的现状与趋势[J].环境科学动态,1993,1(10):8-10.
    林宙峰.海岸工程自然灾害环境风险评价研究[D].厦门大学硕士论文,2007.
    刘芳.山东省水资源适应性管理及其评价研究[D].山东大学硕士学位论文,2009.
    刘桂友,徐琳瑜,李巍.环境风险评价研究进展[J].环境科学与管理,2007,32(2):114-118.
    刘铁民.低概率重大事故风险与定量风险评价[J].安全与环境学报,2004,4(2):89-91.
    陆军.环境风险评价简介[J].污染防治技术,2005,3(3):65-69.
    陆雍森.环境评价(第二版)[M].上海:同济大学出版社,1999,12(2):531-558.
    毛小苓,刘阳生.国内外环境风险评价研究进展[J].应用基础与工程科学学报,2003,11(3):266-273.
    孟萌.环境决策失误研究[D].厦门大学硕士学位论文,2009.
    孟宪林,周定,黄君礼.环境风险评价的实践与发展[J].四川环境,2001,9(2):23-28.
    彭理通.石油化工工业环境风险评价探讨[J].环境科学,1998,8(1):11-18.
    钱淑红和赵光荣.浅析化工/石化类建设项目环境风险评价[J].科技资讯,2011,8(22):126-131.
    曲常胜,毕军,黄蕾等.我国区域环境风险动态综合评价研究[J].北京大学学报,2010,4(3):477-482.
    任剑峰.城市天然气利用工程的环境事故风险评价[J].能源环境保护,2005,19(5):57-59.
    任鲁川.区域自然灾害风险分析研究进展[J].地球科学进展,1999,14(3):242-246.
    尚金城,包存宽.战略环境评价导论[M].北京:科学出版社,2002,2-3.
    史培军.灾害过程与综合灾害风险防范模式[R].第六届DPRI-ⅡASA综合灾害风险管理论坛,土耳其:伊斯坦布尔,2006.
    孙雪景,张硕慧,魏立鸣.渤海海域船舶溢油风险评估[J].水运管理,2009,4(31):32-37.
    孙永明.船舶溢油事故风险评估方法研究[J].中国水运,2007,8(5):15-18.
    田裘学.健康风险评价的基本内容与方法[J].甘肃环境研究与监测,2005,10(4):32-36.
    王君,潘伟然,张国荣等.厦门湾海上溢油风险的评估与分析[J].台湾海峡,2009,28(4):534-538.
    工倩,郭佩芳.海洋主体功能区划与海洋功能区划关系研究[J].海洋湖沼通报,2009,12(4):12-16.
    王茹,任晓飞.模糊综合评价在战略风险评估中的应用[J].工会论坛,2011,9(2):91-93.
    王志霞.区域规划环境风险评价理论、方法和实践[D].同济大学博士学位论文,2007.
    魏一鸣,范英,金菊良.洪水灾害风险分析的系统理论[J].管理科学学报,2001,4(1):13-19.
    吴立志,董法军.城市区域火灾风险评价软件开发及应用[J].安全与环境学报,2005,5(3):5-11.
    奚风华,刘家新.油船溢油风险评价体系的构建及应用[J].航海工程,2010,3(9):38-40.
    厦门海事局编.厦门海域溢油应急计划(1995-2005)(第一版)[M],2005,18-20.
    肖井坤,殷佩海,林建国等.我国海域内船舶溢油发生次数概率的特点[J].海洋环境科学,2002,21(1):21-27.
    许芳.海上溢油事故风险评价-以珠江口为例[D].中山大学硕士学位论文,2004.
    徐伟,王静爱,史培军等.中国城市地震灾害危险度评价[J].自然灾害学报,2004,7(1):9-16.
    徐小红.水利水电施工现场风险评价及事故防御对策[J].甘肃农业,2010,8(5):78-79.
    许学工,林辉平,付在毅等.黄河三角洲湿地区域生态风险评价[J].北京大学学报(自然科学版),2001,37(1):111-120.
    薛峰,柯孟岳.区域环境风险评价的方法研究[J].黑龙江环境通报,2007,9(4):62-64.
    薛雄志,张丽玉,方秦华.海岸带综合管理效果评价方法的研究进展[J].海洋开发与管理,2008,20(1):32-50.
    薛英,王让会,张慧芝等.塔里木河干流生态风险评价[J].干旱区研究,2008,25(4):562-567.
    严超,马量.内河船舶溢油风险的灰色模糊综合评判[J].舰船科学技术,2011,7(33):113-117.
    杨挺.城市局部地震灾害危害性指数及其在上海市的应用[J].国际地震动态,2002,7(2):4 -7.
    杨文士和张雁.管理学原理[M].北京:中国财政经济出版社,1994,25-30.
    杨晓松,谢波.区域环境风险综合评价的程序和方法[J].国外金属矿选矿,1998,1(1):26-28.
    杨晓松,谢波.区域环境风险评价方法的探讨[J].矿冶,2000,9(3):107-112.
    易颂辉.可持续发展与区域环境规划[J].中国环保产业,2006,9(3):12-17.
    尹少华.管理学原理[M].北京:中国农业大学出版社,2010,24-30.
    尹士武.石油化工项目环境风险评价的探讨[J].监测与评价,2001,2(3):27-28.
    殷学林.主观评分法在中海油JU2000-1项目风险评估中的应用[J].信息技术,2005,3(1):12-15.
    曾光明,卓利,钟政林等.水环境健康风险评价模型[J].环境科学与管理,1997,15(4):28-33.
    曾旗,何继新.管理学[M].北京:北京大学出版社,中国农业大学出版社,2008,11-20.
    张加双,杨悦锁,杜新强等.石油污染场地地下水污染健康风险评估[J].安徽农业科学,2010,38(36):87-90.
    张静,田丽娜.决策树分析法在风险决策中的应用[J].数学教学研究,2009,28(10):46-50.
    张俊香,李平日,黄光庆等.基于信息扩散理论的中国沿海特大台风暴潮灾害风险分析[J].热带地理,2007,7(1):11-14.
    张丽佳,刘敏,权瑞松等.中国东南沿海地区热带气旋特点和灾情评估[J].华东师范大学学报,2009,9(2):41-48.
    张丽佳,刘敏,陆敏等.中国东南沿海地区台风危险性评价[J].人民长江,2010,41(6):81-83.
    张珞平,陈伟琪,洪华生.预警原则在环境规划和管理中的应用[J].厦门大学学报(自然科学,2004,42(1):221-224.
    张珞平,洪华生,陈伟琪等.农药使用对厦门海域的初步风险评价[J].厦门大学学报,1998,38(2):96-103.
    张珞平,江毓武,陈伟琪等.福建省海湾数模与环境容量研究-厦门湾[M].北京:海洋出版社,2009,80-81.
    张冉.海湾海岸带主体功能区划分技术对比研究[D].厦门大学硕士学位论文,2011.
    张冉,张珞平,方秦华.海洋空间规划及主体功能区划研究进展[J].海洋开发与管理,2011,9(1):16-20.
    张维新,熊德琪,陈守煜.工厂环境污染事故风险模糊评价[J].大连理工大学学报,1994,34(1):38-44.
    张晓峰,周伟,王洁等.公路网规划环境影响评价中的不确定性分析[J].交通与安全,2005,15(4):40-43.
    张应华,刘志全,李广贺等.基于不确定性分析的健康环境风险评价[J].环境科学,2007,9(7):24-28.
    张永春,林玉锁,孙勤芳.有害废物生态风险评价[M].北京:中国环境科学出版社,2002,23-26.
    张永战,王颖.面向21世纪的海岸海洋科学[J].南京大学学报(自然科学),2000,36(6):702-711.
    张志泉.事故性泄漏的有毒气体的风险评价[J].北方环境,2009,29(4):77-80.
    赵德招,刘杰,吴华林等.近十年来台风诱发长江口航道骤淤的初步分析[J].泥沙研究,2012,46(2):96-101.
    赵连河,孙兆强,熊锦林.油库静电火灾爆炸事故树分析[J].江汉石油学院学报,2004,26(3):132-133.
    郑帆.决策树图在概率分析和投标风险决策中的应用[J].天然气与石油,1999,17(4):1-7.
    郑玉昕,王洪礼.海岸带城市经济发展与环境污染的关系研究[J].天津大学学报,2011,13(4):308-311.
    中国气象局编.中国气象年鉴(1987-2003)(第一版)[M].北京:中国气象出版社,2004,178-180.
    中华人民共和国环境保护行业标准(HJ/T169-2004).建设项目环境风险评价技术导则[S].中华人民共和国环境保护总局,2004.
    钟政林,曾光明,杨春平.环境风险评价研究进展[J].环境科学进展,1996,4(6):17-21.
    周寅康.自然灾害风险评价初步研究[J].自然灾害学报,1995,4(1):6-11.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700