用户名: 密码: 验证码:
中国农民专业合作社治理机制与绩效
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
农民专业合作社是在农村家庭承包经营基础上,同类农产品的生产经营者或者同类农业生产经营服务的提供者、利用者,自愿联合、民主管理的互助性经济组织。在我国,农民专业合作社作为一种农村组织创新,正充分地利用它的组织优势,立足当地资源,解决一家一户小生产与千变万化大市场的矛盾,使分散的农户经营更加适应市场乃至具有国际竞争力。在我国市场深化和金融深化的大背景下,农民专业合作社通过提高农民组织化程度与市场竞争能力,在实现农业生产专业化、现代化方面发挥着越来越重要的作用。然而,从整体而言,我国农民专业合作社还处于比较低的发展层次。一方面,农民专业合作社应有的组织优势还远远没有发挥出来;另一方面,许多发展较快、规模较大的专业合作在规范运行和持续发展方面存在的问题也逐渐显现。健全和完善治理机制是解决上述问题的关键,也是我国农民专业合作社下一阶段发展所面临的重大任务。
     有效的治理机制是提高农民专业合作社绩效的必要条件,绩效又是农民专业合作社治理机制健全与否的最直接和最有效的反映。治理良好的农民专业合作社,其成长能力和赢利能力相对较强,社员满意度也相对较高。对于尚处在发展初期的农民专业合作社,完善和健全治理机制可以为合作社运行创造良好的条件和环境,提高合作社绩效,使合作社的组织优势得到充分发挥;对于已经发展相对成熟的农民专业合作社而言,完善和健全治理机制则是农民专业合作社进一步提升竞争力,引领中国农业走向国际化、具备国际市场竞争力的关键。
     相对于一般法人企业而言,农民专业合作社的经营宗旨是社会公平与经济效率的二元结构,这种经营宗旨决定了合作社治理机制的特殊构造,进而决定了评价合作社运营绩效不能简单套用企业评价标准。本文运用新制度经济学和演化经济学的分析范式,结合我国农民专业合作社发展的现实背景,考察了我国农民经济合作社的治理机制,建立了关于农民专业合作社治理机制与绩效的理论分析框架,采用建模研究和演绎的方法推导出研究结论。这些结论修正和完善了目前国内农民专业合作组织的认识,为现阶段规范我国农民专业合作社发展提供了参考和借鉴。
     本论文由七章组成。第一章导论,介绍研究背景、研究的目的与意义,评述国内外研究现状,明确本研究重点解决的问题、研究思路与研究方法。第二章我国农民专业合作社治理机制的基础理论,在一般组织和治理理论的基础上结合农民专业合作社的特征维度阐述农民专业合作社面临的独特治理机制问题,并构建模型予以解释。第三章我国农民专业合作社发展分析,从政治制度、经济模式、文化理念三个因素论述了我国农民专业合作社发展环境,分析我国农民专业合作社的发展历程,总结我国农民专业合作社发展的特点与存在的问题。第四章农民专业合作社治理机制与绩效:样本选择与数据收集,介绍本文实证研究的样本区域选择、问卷设计过程和数据收集方法,并对回收的调查问卷进行汇总分析。第五章农民专业合作社绩效评价指标与模型选择,首先介绍了本文进行农民专业合作社绩效评价指标选取理论依据和方法,接着分析了本文选用的评价农民专业合作社绩效的主成分评价方法和模型,并对153家样本农民专业合作社绩效进行了计算。第六章农民专业合作社治理机制与绩效的实证分析,通过前述理论分析我们确立了一些可以验证的假设,用以检验理论分析中农民专业合作社的治理机制对于其绩效的影响。第七章是结论与展望,对全文的主要结论进行了概括性总结,并在理论研究结论和经验验证基础上,得出对我国农民专业合作社健全治理机制、完善治理结构的启示。最后分析了本文研究存在的不足以及未来研究的展望。
     本文在已有国内外大量相关文献及通过调查所收集到的实际数据的基础上,力图在以下方面作出贡献:(1)通过构建基本理论分析框架,为农民专业合作社治理机制与其绩效关系提供逻辑自洽的分析体系,深入地研究了我国农民专业合作社治理结构与治理机制问题。这一研究视角的创新,克服了已有研究成果主要运用逻辑推理和规范分析而缺乏实证检验、过分强调农民专业合作社治理结构形式的构建而相对忽视治理的根本目的的不足;(2)建立基于平衡计分卡的农民专业合作社绩效评价指标体系,并将主成分分析等计量研究成果应用于我国农民专业合作社绩效的综合评价中,克服已有农民专业合作社绩效评价研究中选择单一指标或简单加权综合评分衡量绩效的局限性,较好地体现对农民专业合作社绩效评价的客观性;(3)通过对153份样本农民专业合作社数据进行实证研究,验证了农民专业合作社治理机制与绩效的关系,拓展和深化了农民专业合作社治理问题的研究,得出的相关结论也为农民专业合作社治理机制的理论研究提供了依据和支撑。
Farmers'specialized cooperatives is the mutual aid organization for economic that producers and traders of similar agricultural products or providers and users of similar agricultural production and business services unite voluntarily to manage democratically in the base of farmers contracted management in the unit of family. In our country, farmers'specialized cooperatives as a rural organization innovation is making good use of its organizational advantages, based on local resources, to solve the conflict between small-scale production based on households and ever-changing large market, which make the decentralized household management more responsive to the market and adapt to international competition situation. Especially, under the background of the market deepening and financial deepening, farmers'specialized cooperatives play an increasingly important role to specialize and modernize the agricultural production by improving the degree of farmers'organization and market competition ability. However, as a whole, farmers'specialized cooperatives in our country are also at lower levels of development. On the one hand, the organizational advantages of farmers'specialized cooperatives that have not yet developed are vastly underexplored. On the other hand, many problems are emerging in regulating the operation and sustainable development in many relatively fast developed and larger scale specialized cooperatives. Completing internal governance structure of farmers'specialized cooperatives, and improving the governance mechanism are the keys to resolving above two issues.
     Effective governance is a sine qua non for improving performance of farmers'specialized cooperatives, and performance is the most direct and effective reflection on the soundness of governance level and governance structure of farmers'specialized cooperatives. The farmers'specialized cooperatives of sound governance have relatively strong growth and profitability, and have much higher member satisfaction. Therefore, as to farmers'specialized cooperatives still in early stages, it could create favorable conditions and environment for cooperatives corporation, and improve cooperatives performance to make the organizational advantages of cooperatives full play by improving the governance structure and governance mechanism. And for the relatively mature farmers'specialized cooperatives, improving the governance structure and governance mechanism are the keys to further enhance competitiveness, and lead the Chinese agriculture to internationalization and Chinese farmers to participate in international market competition.
     Relative to general corporate, the business objectives of farmers'specialized cooperatives possess the double property of social equity and economic efficiency, which determines not only the uniqueness of the governance structure and governance mechanism, but also determines the construction of performance evaluation system of farmers'specialized cooperatives. This paper uses the analytical paradigm of institutional economics and evolutionary economics, combined with the development background of Chinese farmers'specialized cooperatives, to research the governance mechanism of farmers'specialized cooperatives in our country, and initially establish an analysis framework on the governance mechanism and performance of farmers'specialized cooperatives. Meanwhile, this paper derive inferences to complete the governance structure of farmers'specialized cooperatives, improve the governance mechanism and performance of farmers'specialized cooperatives by using the modeling method and deductive method. These inferences not only amend and improve the current domestic findings of the farmers'specialized cooperatives, as well as provide a reference for the current normative development of Chinese farmers'specialized cooperatives. This dissertation consists of seven chapters. Chapter1:introduction, and this chapter describes the background, purpose and significance of the study, review the current research at home and abroad, and clear research emphasis, idea and methods. Chapter2:basic theories of the governance mechanism of farmers'specialized cooperatives in our country, and this chapter describes the unique governance mechanism faced by farmers' specialized cooperatives by combining the theoretical basis of organizational analysis and characteristics dimension of farmers'specialized cooperatives, and build the model to explain. Chapter3:the development analysis of farmers'specialized cooperatives, and this chapter from the political system, the economic model and cultural concept discusses the development environment of our farmers'specialized cooperatives, analyze the development course of our farmers'specialized cooperatives, and summarize the development characteristics of our farmers'specialized cooperatives and existing problems. Chapter4:the governance mechanism and performance of farmers' specialized cooperatives:sample selection and data collection, and this chapter introduce the sample area selection, questionnaire design and data collection methods in empirical research, and analyze the recycling questionnaire. Chapter5:the performance evaluation index of farmers'specialized cooperatives and model selection, and firstly, this chapter introduces the theoretical basis and method of the performance evaluation index selection of farmers'specialized cooperatives, followed by an analysis of principal components analysis and model selected to evaluate the performance of fanners' specialized cooperatives, and calculates the performance of153samples of farmers' specialized cooperatives. Chapter6:the empirical analysis of the governance mechanism and performance of farmers'specialized cooperatives. In this chapter, we establish some verifiable assumptions through the above theoretical analysis to explore the influence of the different governance mechanisms on the performance in the theoretical analysis. Chapter7:conclusions and outlook. In this chapter, we synoptically summarize key findings in our full-text, and indicate the enlightenment of the theoretical analysis and empirical study to complete the governance structure of fanners'specialized cooperatives and improve the governance mechanism of farmers'specialized cooperatives. At last, we analyze this research deficiency and future research prospects.
     In the base of a large number of related literature at home and abroad and investigating the actual data collected, this article try to make a contribution in the following areas:(1) We select a special perspective, that is a systematic study of the relationship between governance mechanism of farmers'specialized cooperatives and its performance, to lucubrate the problems of the governance structure and the governance mechanism of farmers'specialized cooperatives. This innovation from the research perspective overcomes the lack of the existing research results, which mainly use logical reasoning and canonical parse so that to lack empirical test, and too excessively emphasize the formal structure of the governance structure of farmers'specialized cooperatives to relatively neglect the fundamental objective of governance.(2) We establish the performance evaluation index system of farmers'specialized cooperatives based on balanced scorecard, and apply the measurement results, such as principal component analysis, into comprehensive evaluation of performance of farmers' specialized cooperatives. It overcomes the limitation to select single target or simple weighted score to measure performance in the existing performance evaluation study of farmers'specialized cooperatives, which better reflects the objectivity of the performance evaluation of farmers'specialized cooperatives.(3) The empirical study to153samples data of farmers'specialized cooperatives identifies the relationship between governance mechanism of farmers'specialized cooperatives and its performance, and expand and deepen research on the governance of farmers'specialized cooperatives. Meanwhile, the relevant conclusions drawn provide some bases and support for the theoretical study of the governance mechanism of farmers'specialized cooperatives.
引文
① (美)罗西瑙主编,张军等译:《没有政府统治的治理》,江西人民出版社,2001年,第5页。
    ② 考夫曼:“治理与反腐败”,载胡鞍钢主编:《中国:挑战腐败》,第285页。
    ③ 1992年,28位国际知名人士发起成立,由卡尔松和兰法尔任主席,该委员会于1995年发表了《天涯成比邻》(OurGlobal Neighborhood)的研究报告.
    ④ (法)斯莫茨:“治理在国际关系中的正确应用”,载俞可平主编:《治理与善治》,社会科学文献出版社,2000年,第271-271页。
    ① 马歇尔:《经济学原理》上、下卷,商务印书馆,1983年中文版第424至426页
    ② 马歇尔:《经济学原理》,商务印书馆,1997年,第626页。
    ① 马歇尔:《经济学原理》,商务印书馆,1997年,第454页。
    ① [美]弗兰克·道宾:《经济社会学》,上海:上海人民出版社,2008年版,第9页。
    ① 乔佳妮 孙甜甜,“陕西省今年投入3000万元提升百强合作社”,《陕西日报》,2013年3月24日。
    ① 中共河南省委农村工作办公室,《工作简报:全省农民专业合作社工作考评报告》,2012年第6期。
    ① 张玉甫韩俊杰,“河南表彰优秀青年农民专业合作社”,《中国青年报》,2013年01月05日第02版。
    蔡昉.1999.合作与不合作的政治经济学—发展阶段与农民社区组织.中国农村观察,(5):1-7
    曹阳,姚仁伦.2008.自由退出权、组织稳定、组织效率.华中师范大学学报:人文社会科学版,(7):46-50
    陈冲.2007.农民参与合作影响因素的实证研究.农村经济,(6):122-124
    陈俊梁,张雅文.2010.创新农民专业合作社治理结构促进农村改革和发展实现“第二次飞跃”.改革与战略,(11):92-94,98
    程承坪,岳锋利.2008.农业生产合作社的经济学分析.当代经济管理,(3):34-36
    程克群,孟令杰.2011.农民专业合作社绩效评价指标体系的构建.经济问题探索,(3):70-75
    崔宝玉,李晓明.2008.资本控制下的合作社功能与运行的实证分析.农业经济问题,(1):40-47
    崔宝玉,刘峰,杨模荣.2012.内部人控制下的农民专业合作社治理——现实图景、政府规制与制度选择.经济学家,(6):85-92
    崔宝玉,张忠根,李晓明.2008.资本控制型合作社合作演进中的均衡—基于农户合作程度与退出的研究视角.中国农村经济,(9):63-71
    崔宝玉.2011.农民专业合作社中的委托代理关系及其治理.财经问题研究,(2):102-107
    丁为民.1998.西方合作社的制度分析.北京:经济管理出版社
    董纯.2010.产权视角下的农民专业合作社制度安排.湖北经济学院学报(人文社会科学版),(12):22-24
    董晓媛,Gregory K. Dow.2000.自由退出是否减少了生产队中的偷懒?,载林毅夫:《再论制度与中国农业发展》附录一,北京:北京大学出版社
    杜党勇,蓝海林.2006.农村社区股份合作经济组织的内部治理结构与代理成本的实证研究.江西财经大学学报,(4):18-23
    范远江,杨贵中.2011.农民专业合作社绩效评价研究范式解析.经济纵横,(10):58-61
    范远江,杨贵中.2011.农民专业合作社绩效评价研究综述.经济研究导刊,(7):67-68
    费方域.1998.企业的产权分析.上海:上海三联书店
    冯飞.2007.西部地区农民专业合作经济组织发展研究.[博士学位论文],杨凌:西北农林科技大学
    冯开文.2000.合作社:兼顾公平与效率的经济组织.农村合作经济经营管理,(1):12-14
    冯开文.2003.村民自治、合作社和农业产业化经营制度的协调演进——来自山东烟台的调查报告.中国农村经济,(2):45-50
    冯开文.2003.借鉴与反思——日本农协近况及其对中国农村合作经济发展的启示.农村经营管理,(6):46-47,44
    冯开文.2005.建立健全合作社分配制度.农村经营管理,(11):17-19
    扶玉枝.2012.农业合作社效率研究.[博士学位论文].杭州:浙江大学
    傅晨.2003.“新一代合作社”:合作社制度创新的源泉.中国农村经济,(6):25-28
    傅晨.2006.中国农村合作经济:组织形式与制度变迁.北京:中国经济出版社
    高飞进,柳辉林,赵佳荣.2010.浏阳农民专业合作社绩效分析.合作经济与科技,(7):16-21
    高菲.2013.农民专业合作社社员退社问题研究.时代金融,(5):33-36
    吴彬,徐旭初.2013.合作社的状态特性对治理结构类型的影响研究——基于中国3省80县266家农民专业合作社的调查.农业技术经济,(1):107-119
    郭红东,蒋文华.2004.影响农户参与专业合作经济组织行为的因素分析——基于对浙江省农户的实证研究.中国农村经济,(5):10-16
    郭红东,钱崔红.2005.关于合作社理论的文献综述.中国农村观察,(1):72-77
    郭红东.2004.美国新一代合作社及其对中国的启示.农村经营管理,(7):
    国鲁来.2001.合作社制度及专业协会实践的制度经济学分析.中国农村观察,(4):36-48
    韩国明,田智文.2012.乡镇集市农民合作社内部治理结构的演化分析.软科学,(6):43-47
    韩洁,薛桂霞.2007.农民专业合作社利润分配机制研究.农业经济问题,增刊:148-152
    韩俊.2007.中国农民专业合作社调查.上海:上海远东出版社
    郝小宝.2005.农民合作经济组织的利益机制与治理结构分析.理论导刊,(4):51-54
    吴桂芝,曹明宏.2007.农村合作经济组织的组织绩效与治理特征.信阳农业高等专科学校学报,(1):9-11
    何国平.2007.走向市场:农业流通领域合作组织的理论与实践.北京:中国经济出版社
    洪闫华.2012.国外农业合作社治理的经验及启示.经济纵横,(6):96-99
    胡敏化.2007.中国农民合作行为的博弈分析.中国经济问题,(1):48-55
    胡冉迪.2012.当前我国农民专业合作社创新发展问题与对策研究.农业经济问题,(11):44-48
    胡仙芝.2001.从善政向善治的转变.中国行政管理,(9):22-25,31
    黄宁静.2008.农民专业合作组织的激励机制研究.[博士学位论文].成都:西南交通大学
    黄珊,顾海英,朱国玮.2005.基于认知角度的农民合作经济组织治理问题研究.经济问题探索,(8):28-30
    黄少安,韦倩.2011.合作与经济增长.经济研究,(8):51-64
    黄胜忠,林坚,徐旭初.2008.农民专业合作社治理机制及其绩效实证分析.中国农村经济,(3):65-73
    黄胜忠,徐旭初.2008.社员异质性与农民专业合作社的组织结构分析.南京农业大学学报(社会科,(3):1-7
    黄胜忠.2008.转型时期农民专业合作社的组织行为分析.浙江大学出版社
    黄祖辉,王祖锁.2002.从不完全合约看农业产业化经营的组织方式.农业经济问题,(3):28-31
    黄祖辉,徐旭初,冯冠胜.2002.农民专业合作组织发展的影响因素分析——对浙江省农民专业合作组织发展现状的探讨.中国农村经济.(3):13-21
    黄祖辉,徐旭初.2005.中国的农民专业合作社与制度安排.山东农业大学学报(社会科学版),(4):1-20
    黄祖辉,徐旭初.2006.基于能力和关系的合作社治理——对浙江省农民专业合作社治理结构的解释.浙江社会科学,(1):60-66
    晋入勤.2008.合作社治理结构研究——公司治理结构理论的演绎.天津市政法管理干部学院学报,(4):49-54
    孔川,陈宁.2007.对苏州农民合作组织创新的思考.改革与发展,(11):27-28
    孔祥智,蒋忱忱.2010.成员异质性对合作社治理机制的影响分析——以四川省井研县联合水果合作社为例.农村经济,(9):8-11
    李维安.2001.公司治理.天津:南开大学出版社
    李小卉.2001.试论农村合作组织的内部人控制.乡镇经济,(5):7-8
    李玉勤.2008.农民专业合作组织发展与制度建设研讨会综述,农业经济问题,(2):98-102
    梁巧.2010.合作社对农户生产效益和规模效率的影响.[博士学位论文].杭州:浙江大学
    廖媛红.2011.农民专业合作社的内部社会资本与绩效关系研究.农村经济,(7):126-129
    廖祖君,赵璐,凌渝智.2008.公司领办型合作社发展研究.农村经济,(10):119-121
    廖祖君.2010.农民合作经济组织的激励机制及其演变路径.经济体制改革,(3):12-17
    林坚,黄胜忠.2007.成员异质性与农民专业合作社的所有权分析.农业经济问题,(10):12-17
    林坚,马彦丽.2006.农业合作社和投资者所有企业的边界.农业经济问题,(3):1-20
    林毅夫.2005.制度、技术与中国农业发展.上海:上海三联书店、上海人民出版社
    刘滨,陈池波,杜辉.2009.农民专业合作社绩效度量的实证分析——来自江西省22个样本合作社的 数据.农业经济问题,(2):90-95
    刘洁.2011.农民专业合作社契约选择与运营绩效的理论分析与实证研究.[博士学位论文].武汉:华中农业大学
    刘秀娟,赵惫峰,张桂春.2006.对规范农民合作经济组织的探讨.农业经济,(1):50-52
    刘银国.2008.国有企业公司治理研究.合肥:中国科学技术大学出版社
    刘永东,刘明兴,徐志刚,陶然.2008.中国农民组织发展:治理结构与组织功能.经济社会体制比较,(1):110-117
    柳晓阳.2005.农村专业合作社机制与职能转型初探.农业经济问题,(9):10-12
    娄锋.2008.农民专业合作社内部治理机制研究.云南电大学报,(1):63-68
    罗必良.2007.农民合作组织:偷懒、监督及其保障机制.中国农村观察,(2):26-37
    马庆国.2002.管理统计:数据获取、统计原理与SPSS工具与应用研究.北京:科学和出版社
    马彦丽,林坚.2006.集体行动的逻辑与农民专业合作社的发展.经济学家,(2):40-45
    马彦丽,孟彩英.2008.我国农民专业合作社的双重委托——代理关系.农业经济问题,(5):55-60
    马彦丽.2006.我国农民专业合作社的制度解析.[博士学位论文].杭州:浙江大学
    孟英玉.2012.农民专业合作社治理效率的经济学分析.商业时代(原名《商业经济研究》),(6):20-21
    慕永太.2001.合作社理论与实践.北京:中国农业出版社
    倪建林.2001.公司治理结构:法律与实践.北京:法律出版社
    牛若峰.2005.关于农民合作经济组织立法若干问题的认识和建议.农村经营管理,(1):1-12
    农业部.2004.2004中国农业发展报告.北京:中国农业出版社
    农业部赴日本农协考察团.2008.日本农协对我国农民专业合作组织发展的启示.农村经营管理,(7):44-48
    潘劲.2005.农产品行业协会的治理机制分析.中国农村观察,2005:41-52
    齐林.2012.专业合作社的治理结构对农业产业化的影响.人民论坛,(35):78-79
    秦中春.2007.农民专业合作社制度创新的一种选择.中国农村经济,(7):60-66
    邱皓政.2009.量化研究与统计分析——SPSS中文视窗版数据分析范例解析.重庆:重庆大学出版社
    屈浩峰.2007.我国农业合作组织内的协调机制研究.经济经纬,(3):110-113
    屈茂辉.2007.合作社法律制度研究.北京:中国工商出版社
    全国人大农业与农村委员会课题组.2004.农民合作经济组织法立法专题研究报告,2004.3
    冉赤农,霍学喜.2012.杨凌农民专业合作社绩效研究.经济研究导刊,(26):92-95
    任大鹏,郭海霞.2008.合作社制度的理想主义与现实主义.农业经济问题,(3):90-94
    闰长乐.2008.公司治理.北京:人民邮电出版社
    邵科,徐旭初.2008.成员异质性对农民专业合作社治理结构的影响——基于浙江省88家合作社的分
    析.西北农林科技大学学报(社会科学版),(2):5-9
    邵兴全,邵昱.2013.我国农民专业合作社治理机制创新与对策研究——以成都地区农民专业合作社发展为例证.中共四川省委省级机关党校学报,(1):120-123
    邵兴全.2011.新型农民专业合作社治理结构研究.[博士学位论文].成都:西南财经大学
    邵兴全.2012.新型农民专业合作社治理结构研究——一种资本控制受约束的治理嵌入共同治理模式的探讨.中共成都市委党校学报,(3):50-54
    世界银行.2006.中国农民专业协会回顾与政策建议.北京:中国农业出版社
    宋刚,马俊驹.2007.农业专业合作社若干问题研究.浙江社会科学,(5):59-65
    宋茂华.2007.农民专业合作组织治理机制研究.农村经济,(2):126-129
    孙亚范,余海鹏.2009.社员认知、利益需求与农民合作的制度安排分析.南京农业大学学报:社会科学版,(2):1-8
    孙亚范.2006.新型农民专业合作经济组织发展研究.北京:社会科学文献出版社
    孙亚范.2010.农民专业合作社社员退出意愿的影响因素分析---基于江苏省的调查数据.南京农业大学学报(社会科学版),(4):35-42
    王福英,周静.2012.农民专业合作社治理与公司治理比较.会计之友,(1):46-48
    王浩军.2011.当前我国农民专业合作社绩效优势及异化现象分析.湖北农业科学,(8):1701-1704
    王军.2010.合作社治理:文献综述.中国农村观察,(2):71-77,86
    王礼力.2003.农村合作经济理论与组织变迁研究.[博士学位论文].杨陵:西北农林科技大学
    王天宇.2008.我国农村合作社制度分析.三江论坛,(5):34-37
    王立平,张娜,黄志斌.2008.农民专业合作经济组织绩效评价研究.农村经济,(3):124-126
    王文钦.2005.公司治理结构之研究.北京:中国人民大学出版社
    王学民.2007.对主成分分析中综合得分方法的质疑.统计与决策,(4):31-32
    王阳,漆雁斌.2012.农村环境治理的现实困境与机制创新——基于委托代理的博弈分析.四川农业大学学报,(4):473-477
    魏道南,张晓山.1998.中国农村新型合作组织探析.北京:经济管理出版社
    温美荣.2012.社会资本视域下我国农民专业合作社治理机制研究.社团管理研究,(12):23-26
    毋俊芝.中国农民合作经济组织的理论与实践[M].北京:中国社会出版社,2008
    吴彬,徐旭初.2013.合作社的状态特性对治理结构类型的影响研究——基于中国3省80县266家农民
    专业合作社的调查.农业技术经济,(1):107-119
    吴家浩.2010.我国农民专业合作组织的发展现状与影响因素综述.当代经济,(12):74-76
    武光太.2013.我国《农民专业合作社法》的立法完善——以治理结构为中心.农业技术经济,(1):27-29
    夏春萍,何嘉欣.2012.我国农民专业合作社治理结构优化分析.东南学术,(4):29-35
    夏炜,叶金福,蔡建峰,李正锋.2010.非营利组织绩效评估理论综述.软科学,(4):120-125
    夏英.2008.我国农民专业合作社发展现状与走势.中国经贸导刊,(18):28-29
    肖云,陈涛,朱治菊.2012.农民专业合作社成员“搭便车”现象探究——基于公共治理的视角.中国农业观察,(5):47-53
    徐龙志,包忠明.2012.农民合作经济组织的优化:内部治理及行为激励机制研究.农村经济,(1):112-116
    徐旭初,吴彬.2010.治理机制对农民专业合作社绩效的影响---基于浙江省526家农民专业合作社的实证分析.中国农村经济,(5):43-55
    徐旭初.2005.中国农民专业合作经济组织的制度分析.北京:经济科学出版社
    徐旭初.2008.新形势下我国农民专业合作社的制度安排.农村经营管理,(11):13-16
    徐旭初.2009.农民专业合作社绩效评价体系及其验证.农业技术经济,(4):11-19
    徐旭初.2012.农民合作社发展研究:一个国内文献的综述.农业部管理干部学院学报,(6):40-48
    徐旭初.2013.略论农民专业合作社理论研究进展及趋势.中国农民合作社,(1):20-21
    徐勇.2003.乡村治理与中国政治.北京:中国社会科学出版社
    薛天桥.2012.浅谈西方农业合作社新型治理模式及其启示.农业经济,(7):44-45
    杨瑞龙.2001.企业共同治理的经济学分析.北京:经济科学出版社
    叶常林,杨丽华.2006.应用于非营利组织平衡计分卡模型分析.现代管理科学,(4):85-87
    叶双峰.2001.关于主成分分析做综合评价的改进.数理统计统计与管理,(2):52-55
    殷好好.2010.农民专业合作社绩效及规范化发展对策研究——以舟山市为例.浙江海洋学院学报(人文科学版),(1):64-69,95
    应瑞瑶.2004.论农业合作社的演进趋势与现代合作社的制度内核.南京社会科学,(1):13-18
    苑鹏.2001.中国农村市场化进程中的农民合作组织研究.中国社会科学,(6):63-73
    苑鹏.2008.改革以来农村合作经济组织的发展.经济研究参考,(31):20-22
    张满林.2009.我国农民专业合作社治理问题研究.[博士学位论文].北京:北京林业大学
    张满林.2010.农民专业合作社治理机制问题研究.渤海大学学报,(3):110-119
    张梅,郭翔宇.2008.发达国家农业合作社的不同特点与借鉴.农业经济,(5):2-8
    张明林,吉宏.2005.集体行动与农业合作组织的合作条件.企业经济,(8):18-20
    张群.1999.论交易组织及其生成和演变.北京:中国人民大学出版社
    张维迎.1996.企业的企业家一一契约理论.上海:上海人民出版社
    张晓山,国鲁来.1998.改革开放以来中国农村经济集体所有制有效实现形式探析.管理世界,(3):165-174
    张晓山,苑鹏,国鲁来,潘劲.1998.农村股份合作企业产权制度研究.中国社会科学,(2):15-31
    张晓山.2004.促进以农产品生产专业户为主体的合作社的发展——以浙江省农民专业合作社的发展为例.中国农村经济,(11):4-23
    张晓山.2009.农民专业合作社的发展趋势探析.管理世界,(5):89-96
    张晓山.2010.中国城乡经济社会一体化新格局中的农业、农村发展问题刍议.经济经纬,(4):1-8
    张雪莲,冯开文.2008.国内外合作社研究的差异初探.学会,(9):3-8
    张雪莲,冯开文.2008.农民专业合作社决策权分割的博弈分析.中国农村经济,(8):61-69
    赵玻,陈阿兴.2007.美国新一代合作社:组织特征、优势及绩.农业经济问题,(11):99-103
    赵慧峰,李彤,沈月岭.2008.农民专业合作社利益分配机制研究.中国农业会计,(1):24-25
    赵佳荣.2010.农民专业合作社“三重绩效”评价模式研究.农业技术经济,(2):119-127
    赵凯.中国农业经济合作组织发展研究.2004.北京:中国农业出版社
    浙江省农业厅课题组.2008.农民专业合作社绩效评价体系初探.农村经营管理,(10):31-35
    郑少红,刘淑枝.2012.农民专业合作社运营绩效评价——以福建省为例.技术经济,(9):82-87
    中国社科院农村发展研究所等.2005.2004-2005年:中国农村经济形势分析与预测,北京:社会科学文献出版社
    周发源,汤建军,黄云志.2007.发展农民专业合作组织的调查与建议.湖南社会科学,(1):75-78
    周立群、曹利群.2001.农村经济组织形态的演变与创新——山东莱省莱阳市农业产业化调查报告.经济研究,(1):27-35
    周其仁.2004.产权与制度变迁:中国改革的经验研究.北京:北京大学出版社
    周文根.2007.基于企业框架的专业合作社激励机制.中央财经大学学报,(7):47-51
    周小川.2001.公司治理结构的改进.北京:人民出版社,2001
    朱富强.2012.再造农业合作社——林毅夫的合作社失败命题之重审.社会科学研究,(2):20-26
    朱明月.2012.农民专业合作社治理结构完善.社科纵横,(4):77-78
    [俄]恰亚诺夫.1996.农民经济组织.北京:中央编译出版社
    [美]阿尔伯特·0·赫希曼.2001.退出、呼吁与忠诚——对企业、组织和国家衰退的回应.北京:经济科学出版社
    [美]道格拉斯·C·诺思.1991.经济史中的结构与变迁.上海:上海三联书店
    [美]德姆塞茨.1999.所有权、控制与企业.北京:经济科学出版社
    [美]弗兰克·道宾.2008.经济社会学.上海:上海人民出版社
    [美]亨利·汉斯曼.2001.企业所有权论.北京:中国政法大学出版社
    [美]康芒斯.1983.制度经济学.北京:商务印书社
    [美]科斯,阿尔钦,诺斯等.2004.财产权利与制度变迁.上海:上海人民出版社
    [英]罗西瑙.1996.没有政府统治的治理.伦敦:剑桥大学出版社
    Alback, S., C. Schultz.1997. One cow? One vote?. Scandinavian Journal of Economics,99 (4): 597-615
    Alback, S., C. Schultz.1998. On the Relative Advantage of Cooperatives. Economic Letters, 59:397-401
    Banerjee, A. D., D. Mookherjee, K. Munshi, D.Ray.2001. Inequality, Control Rights, and Rent Seeking:Sugar Cooperatives in Maharashtra. Journal of Political Economy,109 (1): 138-190
    Bijman, J.2006. Governance Structures in the Dutch Fresh Produce Industry, in Christien Ondersteijn and Jo Wi jnands(eds.):Quantifying the Agri-Food Supply Chains, Springer, 2006, pp207-223
    Bourgeon, J. M., R.G.Chambers.1999. Producer Organizations, Bargaining, and Asymmetric Information. American Journal of Agricultural Economics,81 (3):602-609
    Choi, E. K., E. Fernerman.1993. Producer Cooperatives, Input Pricing and LandAllocation. Journal of Agricultural Economics,44 (2):230-244
    Condon, A. M.1987. The Methodology and Requirements of a Theory of Modem Cooperative Enterprise, in Royer, J. (Eds.):Cooperative Theory:New Approaches, ACS Service Report No.18, USDA, Washington D. C.,1-31
    Confederation of Finnish Cooperatives November 2000. www. pellervo. fi/cg/rapotti. p
    Cook, M. L.& Tong, L.1997. Definitional and Classification Issues in Analyzing Cooperative Organizational Forms, in Cook, M.; Torgenson, R.& Sporleder, (eds.):Cooperatives: Their Importance in the Future Food and Agriculture System,113-118
    Cook, M. L., Chaddad, F. R.& Iliopoulos, C.2004. Advances in Cooperative Theory since 1990:A Review of Agricultural Economics Literature, in G. W. J. Hendrikse(eds): Restructuring Agricultural Cooperatives, Erasmus University Press,2004:65-90
    Cook, Michael. L.1995. The Future of U. S. Agricultural Cooperatives:A Neo- institutional Approach. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 77:1153-1159
    Eilers, C., C. H. Hanf.1999. Contracts Between Farmers and Farmers Processing Cooperatives: A Principal-agent Approach for the Potato Starch Industry. In Vertical Relationship and Coordination in the Food System, edited by G.Galizzi and L. Venturini, Publisher: Heidelberg, Physical,267-284
    Emelianoff, I. V.1942. Economic Theory of Cooperation. Publisher:Ann Arbor, Edward Brothers
    Enke, S.1945. Consumer Cooperatives and Economic Efficiency. American Economic Review 35 (1):148-155
    Feinerman, E., M.Falkovitz.1991. An Agricultural Multipurpose Service Cooperative:Pareto Optimality, Price-tax Solution, and Stability. Journal of Comparative Economics,15: 95-114
    Fulton, M.1999. Cooperatives and Member Commitment, The Finnish Journal of Business Economics, Vol.14:418-437
    Fulton, M. E.& K. Giannakas.2000. Organizational Commitment in a Mixed Oligopoly: Agricultural Cooperatives and Investor-owned Firms, American Journal of Agricultural Economics,83 (5):1258-1265
    Fulton, M., J. Vercammen.1995. The Distributional Impact of Non-uniform Pricing Schemes for Cooperatives. Journal of Cooperatives,10:18-32
    Fulton, M.E.1995. the Future of Canadian Agricultural Cooperatives:a Property Right s Approach. American Journal of Agricultural Economics,77 (12):1144-1152
    Hakelius, K.1996. Cooperative Values:Farmers'Cooperatives in the Minds of the Farmers, PhD Dissertation, Uppsala, Sweden, Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences, 1996
    Hansmann, H.1996. The Ownership of Enterprise, The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press,1996.
    Harris, Andrea, Brenda Stefanson, Murray Fulton.1996. New Generation Cooperatives and Cooperative Theory. Journal of Cooperatives 11:15-27
    Hart,0.1995. Corporate Governance:Some Theory and Implications, The Economic Journal, Issue 105,678-689
    Hedrikse, G. W. J., J. Bijman.2002. Ownership Structure in Agrifood Chains; the Marketing Cooperative. American Journal of Agriculture Economics,84 (1):104-119
    Helmberger, P. G., S. Hoos.,1962. Cooperative Enterprise and Organization Theory. Journal of Farm Economics,44:275-290
    Helmberger, P.G., S.Hoos.1965. Cooperative Bargaining in Agriculture. University of California, Division of Agricultural Services
    Hendrikse, G. W. J.& Veerman, C. P.2001. Marketing Cooperatives:An Incomplete Contracting Perspective, Journal of Agricultural Economics,52 (1):53-64
    Hendrikse, G. W. J, C. P. Veerman.2001b. Marketing Cooperatives and Financial Structure:A Transact ion Costs Economics Analysis. Agricultural Economics,26 (3):205-216
    Hendrikse, G.W. J.1998. Screening, Competition and the Choice of the Cooperative as an Organizational Form. Journal of Agricultural Economics,49 (2):202-217
    Hendrikse, G. W. J., C. P. Veerman.2001a. Marketing Cooperatives:An Incomplete Contracting Perspective.Journal of Agricultural Economics,52 (1):53-64
    Iliopoulos, C. and Cook, M. L 1999. The Efficiency of Internal Resource Allocation Decisions in Customer-Owned Firms:The Influence Costs Problem, http://www.isnie.org, 1999
    Karantini, K. and A. Zago.2001.. Endogenous Membership in Mixed Duopsonies. American Journal of Agricultural Economics,83 (5):1266-1272
    LeVay, C.1983. Some Problems of Agricultural Marketing Cooperatives'Price/Output Determination in Imperfect Competition, Canadian Journal of Agricultural Economics, Issue 31,105-110
    LeVay, C.1983. Agricultural Cooperative Theory:A Review. Journal of Agricultural Economics 34:1-44
    Malo, M. & Vezina, M.2004. Governance and Management of Collective User-Based Enterprises: Value-Creation Strategies and Organizational Configurations, Annals of Public & Cooperative Economics, Vol.75,113-137
    Nilsson, J.1997. New Generation Farmer Coops, Review of International Cooperation, Issue 90,1997, pp32-38
    Nilsson, J.2001. Organizational Principles for Cooperative Firms, Scandinavian Journal of Management,2001,17:329-356
    0'Connor, John & Thompson, Glen.2001.International Trends in the Structure of Agricultural Cooperatives, Rural Industries Research and Development Corporation,2001
    Phillips, R.1953. Economic Nature of the Cooperative Association. Journal of Farm Economics, 35:74-87
    Robotka, F.1957. A Theory of Cooperation. In Agricultural Cooperation:Selected Readings, M. A. Abrahamsen and C. L. Scroggsedited, Minneapolis:University of Minnesota Press, pp.121-142
    Royer, J. S.1999. Cooperative Organizational Strategies:a Neo-institutional Digest, Journal of Cooperatives, Vol.14,44-67
    Sexton, R. J.1984. Perspectives on the Development of the Economic Theory of Cooperatives.Canadian Journal of Agricultural Economics,32:423-436
    Sexton, R. J.1990. Imperfect Competition in Agricultural Markets and the Role of Cooperatives:A Spatial Analysis. American Journal of Agricultural Economics,72 (3) 709-720
    Shaff, James D.1987. Thinking About Farmers'Cooperative, Contracts, and Economic Coordination.Cooperative Theory:New Approaches, Jeffrey S. Royer, ed., USDA, ACS Research Report No.18,1987
    Short, H. et al.1999. Corporate Governance:From Accountability to Enterprise, Accounting and Business Research,29(4):337-352
    Spear, R.2004. Governance in Democratic Member Based Organizations, in Special Issue of Annals of Public and Cooperative Economics:Governance in the Social Economy, pp33-60
    Staatz, J. M.1987. A Game Theoretic Analysis of Decision-making in Farmer Cooperatives, in Royer, J. (eds.):Cooperative Theory:New Approaches, USDA ACS Service Rep, Issue 18, Washington D. C.,117-147
    Staatz, John M.1983. The Cooperative as a Coalition:A Game-theoretic Approach. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 65:1084-1089
    Taylor, R. A.1971. The Taxation of Cooperatives:Some Economic Implications. Canadian Journal of Agricultural Economics 19 (2)
    Tennbakk, B.1995. Marketing Cooperatives in Mixed Duopolies. Journal of Agricultural Economics,46 (1):33-45
    Torgerson, R. E., B. Reynolds, T. W. Gray.1998. Evolution of Cooperative Thought, Theory and Purpose. Journal of Cooperatives 13:1-20
    USDA:Agricultural Cooperatives in the 21st Century, RBCS, Cooperative Information Report 60, Washington D. C.,2002,1-36
    Vercammen, J., M.Fulton, C. Hyde.1996. Nonlinear Pricing Schemes for Agricultural Cooperatives. American Journal of Agricultural Economics,78:572-584
    Vitaliano, P.1983. Cooperative Enterprise:an Alternative Conceptual Basis for Analyzing a Complex Institute, American Journal of Agricultural Economics, Vol.65,1078-1083
    Zusman, P.1992. Constitutional Selection of Collective-choice Rules in A Cooperative Enterprise. Journal of Economics Behavior and Organization,17:353-362
    Zusman, P., G. C. Rausser.1994. Interorganizational Influence and Optimality of Collective Action. Journal of Economics Behavior and Organization,24:1-17

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700