用户名: 密码: 验证码:
公平偏好下国企高管最优显性和隐性激励组合研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
近年来,大量“天价薪酬”事件曝光以及国家对国企负责人薪酬政策的调整使得国企高管薪酬的公平性一直备受社会各界的争议,尤其是在当前经济低迷和收入差距不断扩大的经济形势下,人们对收入分配公平的关注也越来越强烈,如何制定兼顾公平与效率的薪酬合约成为一个亟待解决的现实问题。以往基于纯自利假设的传统理论已不能为之提供很好的解释,而近年来兴起的公平偏好理论通过大量博弈实验令人信服地证明人们除了具有自利偏好之外还具有公平偏好,它克服了标准经济理论基于纯自利假设的局限性,正逐渐被引入到标准的激励理论中,成为前沿的研究课题,有望更好地解释这些企业激励难题。同时,从实践操作情况看,国企高管激励实际上显性激励和隐性激励的一系列合约组合,但相关研究主要集中在显性激励或隐性激励的某一方面,因此不能系统地揭示国企高管的激励问题。基于此,本文针对国企,在考虑国有企业委托人和代理人公平偏好特殊性的前提下,将公平偏好模型拓展至显性激励和隐性激励并行的环境中,探讨兼顾公平时国企高管最优激励组合及其公平偏好对国企高管激励组合的影响,并通过设计合理的实证模型,对一些研究结论加以检验和说明,为现实中国企高管的激励问题提供新的解释,也为完善国企高管激励机制提供新的理论指导。
     本文基于Fehr&Schmidt公平偏好理论模型,先从显性激励入手,在仅实施显性激励的框架下,引入公平偏好,探讨高管和政府主管部门的公平偏好对最优激励报酬的影响。结果发现:(1)在可被第三方证实的任务目标的激励上,高管因低于公平工资而表现出的嫉妒偏好会增加最优激励报酬,而因高于公平工资而表现出的同情偏好,以及政府主管部门为维护社会公平而表现出的公平偏好都会减少最优激励报酬,从而共同促使高管薪酬向公平工资移动;(2)在不可被证实的任务目标的激励上,最优激励报酬为零,这说明显性激励对该任务目标没有积极的作用,政府主管部门只能通过降低其它任务目标上的激励报酬,来避免高管偏好于其他任务目标而放弃该任务目标。由此可见,面对国企多任务目标要求,仅实施显性激励是不够的。
     本文进一步把公平偏好模型扩展为显性合约和隐性合约并行的激励组合模型,基于重复博弈的背景,探讨高管和政府主管部门公平偏好下国企高管的组合激励问题。研究结果表明:(1)在高管公平偏好的影响方面,在最优激励组合中,高管的公平偏好先影响隐性合约激励,然而在隐性合约的替代关系下间接地影响显性合约激励,最终使得显性薪酬逐渐向公平工资回归,其中,隐性合约激励的变化幅度大于显性合约。研究还发现,高管的同情偏好是实施隐性合约的重要因素,它不仅放松了一阶最优的条件,而且即使在显性合约完美的情况下,对促进隐性合约的实施也有积极的作用。(2)在政府主管部门公平偏好的影响方面,政府主管部门主要通过直接降低显性合约激励和利用隐性合约替代显性合约等两种方式来管制国企高管过高的薪酬,促进社会收入公平。在这两种方式中,政府主管部门更倾向于通过更多的隐性合约来替代显性合约激励,而且用于替代的隐性合约随着政府公平偏好的增加而增加。这反映了实施大量的隐性合约有利于在兼顾激励效率的基础上缓解政府的社会公平约束。但进一步的研究发现隐性合约的这种作用受制于政府对高管贡献的主观评估能力,若政府主管部门的主观评估能力越差,政府薪酬规制政策的效果会越差。
     在实践中,高管除了在乎其薪酬与公平工资的差距之外,与团队内部其他成员的收入差距也会使得他们产生不公的心理,进而影响团队的竞争和合作。为此,本文基于重复博弈的背景,进一步把公平偏好模型拓展为多代理人激励模型,探讨国有企业高管团队内的公平偏好对不同性质和不同种类的团队合约的影响。研究结果表明,团队合约主要包括相对合约(Relative Performance Evaluation)和联合合约(Joint Performance Evaluation),(1)在团队合约性质为显性合约的情况下,实施相对合约最优的条件是高管的嫉妒偏好强度足够大或同情强度足够小;而在联合合约的模式下,只有当嫉妒偏好足够小或同情偏好足够大时,实施极端联合合约才最优。(2)在团队合约性质为隐性合约的情况下,极端联合合约的可行条件严于一般联合合约,而一般联合合约的可行条件严于相对合约,当所有合约都可行时,实施极端联合合约最优,实施联合合约优于相对合约,因为联合合约中,高管团队内成员之间的相互监督和协作有利于降低政府主管部门的期望支付成本,尤其在极端联合合约的期望支付成本最小。公平偏好对极端联合合约的可行条件没有影响,对一般联合合约的可行条件的影响不明确;而对于相对合约来说,嫉妒偏好会放松该合约的可行条件,但同情偏好却会使该合约的可行条件变紧。(3)除极端联合合约以外,无论团队合约性质为显性还是隐性合约,公平偏好对团队合约的激励效应都表现为:团队内高管的嫉妒偏好会降低政府主管部门的期望支付成本,具有正的激励效应,但同情偏好却会使得政府主管部门的期望支付成本增加,具有负的激励效应。
     最后,以我国上市国有企业为样本,合理建立联立方程组、非参数回归和面板GMM等计量模型,实证检验外部薪酬差距和高管团队内薪酬差距的激励效应,并说明对显性薪酬和隐性薪酬决定的影响,所得实证结果与上述理论推导的主要结论一致。并就相关政策层面提出必要的建议。
In recent years, the exposure of the sky-high salary of executives and thegovernment's adjustment of the state-owned enterprises(SOE) executives’compensation policy make the fairness of the compensation of the executives instate-owned enterprises a controversial topic, especially under the circumstances thatthe economy continues to struggle and the income gap becomes lager, people paymore and more attention to the income distribution equity, how to design acompensation contract which both considers fairness and efficiency has becomes apractical issue to be settled. Previous traditional theories based on pure self-interestassumption cannot provide good explanation. With a lot of game experiments,Fairness Preference Theory rising in recent years proves convincingly that besidesself-interest, people also have fairness preference. It overcomes the limitations ofstandard economic theory based on pure self-interest hypothesis, and is graduallybeing introduced into the standard incentive theory and becomes a frontier researchtopic, which is likely to better explain these enterprises incentive problems.Meanwhile, from the practical operation, compensation incentives of executive inChinese SOE actually are a series of incentive contracts combined of explicit andimplicit incentive. But related research mainly concentrated on one aspect of explicitincentive or implicit incentive, thus it can’t reveal the incentive scheme for SOE’sexecutive systematically. So this paper discusses the optimal incentive combination ofSOE’s executive with consideration of fairness by introducing fairness preferencemodel into explicit incentive contract and implicit incentive contract model, andstudies the effect of fairness preference on executive compensation, then test theconclusions from the models we build by empirical methods. So it provides newexplanations to SOE’s executive incentive problem and also provides some newtheoretical guidance for improving the incentive mechanism of SOE’s operators.
     Based on the Fehr&Schmidt Fairness Preference model, we start from theframework of only implementing explicit incentive and explore the impact of fairnesspreferences of executive and government on optimal incentive compensation byintroducing fairness preference. The results show:(1) In the aspect of the taskconfirmed by third party, the jealous that is caused due to owing less than fair wage,will increases the optimal incentive payment, while sympathy preference that iscaused by owing more than fair wage and the government fairness preference thatreflects maintaining social fairness will decrease the optimal incentive payment, thus making the executive compensation move to fair wage.(2) In the aspect of the tasktarget that cannot be confirmed by third party, the optimal incentive compensation iszero, which reflects explicit has no positive incentive effect on this task target, thegovernment has to lower incentive payment of other task targets in order to avoid thatexecutive prefer other task targets with giving up this one. Consequently, there isgreat limitation for the SOE multitask incentive.
     So this paper further extends this fairness preference model to the explicit andimplicit contract parallel incentive compensation model, and discusses the optimalincentive combination with the fairness preference of executive and governmentbased on the repeated game background. The results show:(1) In the executivefairness preference, in optimal incentive combination, executive fairness preferencefirst influences implicit contract, then indirectly affect explicit contract incentiveunder the substitute relation of implicit contract, finally making explicit compensationgradually move to fair wage. Besides, the variation extent of implicit contract isgreater than that of explicit contract. And executive’ sympathy preference is animportant factor for implementing implicit contract, it not only relaxes th e first orderoptimal conditions, but also has positive effect for improving the execution of implicitcontract even though the explicit contract is perfect.(2) In the aspect of government,the government mainly carry out two methods——directly lower explicit contractincentive and substitute implicit contract for explicit contract——to imposerestrictions on overpaid compensation for SOE executive to promote the fairdistribution of social income. In these two methods, the government prefers thesecond, and the substitute implicit contract increases with the increase ofgovernment's fairness preference. This reveals that implementing lots of implicitcontract could help alleviate the government's restrictions of social fairness withconsideration of efficiency. But further research finds that the effect of implicitcontract is subjected to the government's subjective assessment ability on executives,the worse the government's subjective assessment ability, the worse the effect of thegovernment's salary regulation policy is.
     In practice, not only executive could care the gap between his/her wage and fairwage, but also the gap between executive's wage and other team member's wage makethem unfair psychology, then influencing the competition and cooperation of the team.So, on the background of repeated game, we further extents the fairness preferencemodel to multi-agent incentive model, and explores the effect of the fairnesspreference in SOE executive team on the variety of team contract. The results showthat team contract includes relative performance evaluation (RPE) and jointperformance evaluation (JPE).(1)Assuming that team contract belong to explicit contract, implementing the optimal condition of RPE is that the jealousy preference ofexecutives is large enough or the sympathy preference is small enough. While, forjoint performance evaluation, it's optimal for implementing the extreme JPE when thejealousy preference is small enough or the sympathy preference is large enough.(2)Assuming that team contract is implicit contract, the feasible condition of extremeJPE is stricter than the ordinary JPE, and the feasible condition of ordinary JPE isstricter than the RPE. If every team contract is feasible, the extreme JPE is optimal,because the supervision and collaboration between team members could reduce theexpected payment cost of government, which makes the expected payment cost of theextreme JPE lowest. Fairness preference has no effect on the feasible condition ofextreme JPE, and its effect on ordinary JPE is unsure. However, for RPE, jealousypreference can loosen its feasible condition, and sympathy preference can tighten itsfeasible condition.(3)Except for extreme JPE, no matter team contract is implicitcontract or explicit contract, the effect of fairness preference on team contract is: thejealousy preference of executives in the team can reduce the expected payment cost ofgovernment, which has a positive incentive effect; while sympathy preference canincrease the expected payment cost o f government, which has a negative incentiveeffect.
     Finally, this paper sets the econometric models of simultaneous equations,nonparametric regression and panel GMM, taking Chinese listed companies’ data assamples. The models are aimed at empirically testing the incentive effects of theexternal pay gap and the pay gap inside the executive team, and explaining theinfluence on determining explicit and implicit compensation. The empirical resultsobtained agree with the above theoretical conclusions. Fina lly we make necessaryrecommendations on relevant policies.
引文
[1] Berle. AA, GC. Means. The Modern Corporation And Private Property[M].NewYork: Macmillan,1932
    [2] Jensen. MC.,WH Meckling. Theory Of The Firm: Managerial Behavior,AgencyCosts And Ownership Structure[J].Journal Of Financial Economics,1976,3(4):305-360
    [3] Fama. Eugene F.,Jensen. Michael C.Separation of Ownership and Control[J].Journal of Law&Economics,1983,26(2):301-325
    [4] Mirrlees, James A. The Optimal Structure of Incentives and Authority withinan Organization[J].The Bell Journal of Economics,1976,7(1):105-131
    [5] H lmstrom,B. Moral Hazard and Observability[J].The Bell Journal ofEconomics,1979,10(1):74-91
    [6] Shavell,S. Risk Sharing and Incentives in the Principal and AgentRelationship[J].The Bell Journal of Economics,1979,10(1):55-73
    [7] Prendergast.,C. The Tenuous Trade-Off Between Risk And Incentives[J].Journal of Political Economy,2002,110(5):1071-1102
    [8] Core, J., Qian,J. Project Selection, Production, Uncertainty, and Incentives
    [R].Working paper No.297461,2002,1
    [9] DeVaro, J.,F. A.Kurtulus. What Types of Organizations Benefit from TeamProduction, and How Do They Benefit?[J].Advances in the Economic Analysisof Participatory&Labor-Managed Firms,2006,9:3-54
    [10] Shi,L. Respondable Risk and Incentives for CEOs: the Role of InformationCollection and Decision-making[J].Journal of Corporate Finance,2011,17:189-205
    [11] Rosenstein,S.,J.G.Wyatt. Outside Directors,Board Independence,andShareholder Wealth[J].Journal of Financial Economics,1990,26(2):175-191
    [12] Core, J.,Wayne Guay.The Use of Equity Grants to Manage Optimal EquityIncentive Levels[J].Journal of Accounting and Economics,1999,28:151-184
    [13] Korac-Kakabadse,N.,Andrew Kakabadse. IS/IT Governance: Need For AnIntegrated Model[J].Corporate Governance,2001,1(4):9-11
    [14] Lewell J. Film at EPCOT Centre: Organization And Innovat ion[J].BKSTSJournal,1983,65(6)
    [15] Murphy.,Kevin J. Corporate Performance and Managerial Remuneration:An Empirical Analysis[J].Journal of Accounting and Economic s,1985,7(4):11-42
    [16] Coughlan,A.T.Ronald M. Schmidt. Executive Compensation, ManagementTurnover, And Firm Performance: An Empirical Investigation[J].Journal ofAccounting and Economics,1985,7(1-3):43–66
    [17] Kaplan,Steven. The effects of management buyouts on operating performanceand value[J].Journal of Financial Economics,1989,24(2):217-254
    [18] Oyer,P. Why Do Firms Use Incentives That Have No Incentive Effects[J].TheJournal of Finance,2004,59(4):1619-1649
    [19] Rajgopal,S.Terry Shevlin.,Valentina Zamora. CEOs' Outside EmploymentOpportunities and the Lack of Relative Performance Evaluation inCompensation Contracts[J].The Journal of Finance,2006,61(4):1813-1844
    [20]张俊瑞,赵进文,张建.高级管理层激励与上市公司经营绩效相关性的实证分析[J].会计研究,2003,(9):29-34
    [21]林浚清.中国上市公司高管绩效激励研究[D]:[浙江大学博士学位论文].杭州:浙江大学,2004
    [22]赵睿.高管薪酬和团队特征对企业绩效的影响机制研究[J].中国社会科学院研究生院学报,2010,(06):38-44
    [23]朱启明,佘虹志.对上市公司高管团队薪酬公平性的研究[J].广东商学院学报,2006,(04):19-24
    [24]杜兴强,王丽华.高层管理当局薪酬与上市公司业绩的相关性实证研究[J].会计研究,2007,(01):58-65
    [25]魏晶晶.不同激励方式下我国上市公司高管薪酬激励的业绩效应研究
    [D]:[上海大学硕士学位论文].上海:上海大学,2008
    [26]杨蕙馨,王胡峰.国有企业高层管理人员激励与企业绩效实证研究[J].南开经济研究,2006,(04):82-97
    [27]曹郑玉,叶金福“.全新型国有企业”高管激励与公司绩效关系的实证研究[J].经济与管理研究,2007,(12):36-39
    [28]吴刚.我国国有上市公司高层管理者薪酬结构与激励机制研究[D]:[西南大学硕士学位论文].重庆:西南大学,2009
    [29] Joskow,Paul L., Rose,Nancy L. CEO Pay and Firm Performance: Dynamics,Asymmetries, and Alternative Performance Measures[R].Working PaperNo.4976,1994,12
    [30] Boschen, John F., Smith, Kimberly J. You Can Pay Me Now and You Can PayMe Later: The Dynamic Response of Executive Compensation to F irmPerformance[J].The Journal of Business,1995,68(4):577-608
    [31] Benston, George J. The Self-serving Management Hypothesis: SomeEvidence[J]. Journal of Accounting and Economics,1985,7(1-3):67-84
    [32] Lambert, Richard A., Larcker, David F. An Analysis of the Use of Accountingand Market Measures of Performance in Executive CompensationContracts[J].Journal of Accounting Research,1987,25:85-125
    [33] Cho,Myeong-Hyeon. Ownership Structure, Investment, And The CorporateValue: An Empirical Analysis[J].Journal of Financial E conomics,1998,47(1):103-121
    [34] Hansona,Robert C., Moon H Song. Managerial Ownership, Board Structure,And The Division Of Gains In Divestitures[J].Journal of Corporate Finance,2000,6(1):55-70
    [35]刘国亮,王加胜.上市公司股权结构、激励制度及绩效的实证研究[J].经济理论与经济管理,2000,(05):40-45
    [36]刘斌,刘星,李世新,何顺文.CEO薪酬与企业业绩互动效应的实证检验[J].会计研究,2003,(03):40-45
    [37]宋兆刚.我国上市公司管理层股权激励的决定因素研究[J].制度经济学研究,2006,(02):109-125
    [38] Jensen, Michael C., Kevin J. Murphy. Performance Pay and Top-ManagementIncentives[J].Journal of Political Economy,1990,98(2):225-264
    [39] Hermalin, Benjamin E., Michael S. Weisbach. The Effects of BoardComposition and Direct Incentives on Firm Performance[J].FinancialManagement,1991,20(4):101-112
    [40] Faccio, Mara., Meziane Lasfer. Managerial Ownership, Board Structure andFirm Value: The UK Evidence[R].Working paper No.179008,1999,9
    [41] Himmelberg,Charles P., R.Glenn Hubbard.,Darius Palia. Understanding theDeterminants Of Managerial Ownership And The Link Between OwnershipAnd Performance[J].Journal of Financial Economics,1999,53(3):353-384
    [42] Short,Helen.,Kevin Keasey. Managerial ownership and the performance offirms: Evidence from the UK[J].Journal of Corporate Finance,1999,5(1):79-101
    [43] Aboody,D., R Kasznik. CEO Stock Option Awards And The Timing OfCorporate Voluntary Disclosures[J].Journal of Accounting and Economics,2000,29(1):73-100
    [44] Griffith,JM., L Fogelberg.,HS Weeks. CEO Ownership, Corporate Control,and Bank Performance[J].Journal of Economics and Finance,2002,26(2):170-183
    [45]徐大伟,蔡锐,徐鸣雷.管理层持股比例与公司绩效关系的实证研究——基于中国上市公司的MBO[J].管理科学,2005,(04):40-47
    [46]魏锋,孔煜.管理层持股比例的内生性检验——基于公司投资行为的视角[J].软科学,2006,(03):64-68
    [47]吴淑琨.股权结构与公司绩效的U型关系研究——1997~2000年上市公司的实证研究[J].中国工业经济,2002,(01):80-87
    [48]郭文心.我国上市公司高管激励机制与公司业绩关系研究[D]:[厦门大学硕士学位论文].厦门:厦门大学,2009
    [49] Demsetz,Harold.,Kenneth Lehn. The Structure of Corporate Ownership:Causes and Consequences[J].Journal of Political Economy,1985,93(6):1155-1177
    [50] Palia,D.,Frank Lichtenberg. Managerial Ownership And Firm Performance: ARe-Examination Using Productivity Measurement[J].Journal of CorporateFinance,1999,5(4):323-339
    [51] Demsetz,H., Belén Villalonga. Ownership Structure And CorporatePerformance[J].Journal of Corporate Finance,2001,7(3):209-233
    [52]魏刚.高级管理层激励与上市公司经营绩效[J].经济研究,2000,(03):32-39
    [53]李增泉.激励机制与企业绩效——一项基于上市公司的实证研究[J].会计研究,2000,(01):24-30
    [54]张宗益,宋增基.上市公司经理持股与公司绩效实证研究[J].重庆大学学报(社会科学版),2002,(06):1-3.
    [55]谌新民,刘善敏.上市公司经营者报酬结构性差异的实证研究[J].经济研究,2003,(08):55-63.
    [56]胡铭.上市公司高层经理与经营绩效的实证分析[J].财贸经济,2003,(04):59-62.
    [57]薛许军,吴晓萍.我国上市公司经理层报酬激励机制研究——理论模型、经验数据及改进建议[J].当代经济科学,2005,(04):79-84.
    [58]赵息,张志勇.上市公司高管股权激励问题研究[J].中国地质大学学报(社会科学版),2007,(02):70-73.
    [59]邓平飞.中国上市公司高管股权激励机制研究与设计[D]:[西安电子科技大学硕士学位论文].西安:西安电子科技大学,2009
    [60]周晖,马瑞,朱久华.中国国有控股上市公司高管薪酬激励与盈余管理[J].财经理论与实践,2010,(04):48-52
    [61]李琦.上市公司高级经理人薪酬影响因素分析[J].经济科学,2003,(06):113-127
    [62]周佰成,王北星.中国上市公司治理、绩效与高管薪酬相关性研究[J].数理统计与管理,2007,(04):669-675
    [63]刘仲文,刘迪.国企高管层激励与约束机制相关文献分析及实证设想——基于央企相关股权激励与绩效数据的实证分析(上篇)[J].会计之友(上旬刊),2009,(04):96-98
    [64]刘仲文,刘迪.国企高管层激励与约束机制的实证分析——基于央企股权激励与绩效数据的实证分析(下篇)[J].会计之友(中旬刊),2009,(04):97-101
    [65]曲亮,任国良.高管薪酬激励、股权激励与企业价值相关性的实证检验[J].当代经济科学,2010,(05):73-79
    [66] Finkelstein,S.,Donald C. Hambrick. Chief Executive Compensation: A StudyOf The Intersection Of Markets And Political Processe[J].StrategicManagement Journal,1989,10(2):121-134
    [67] McEachern,William A. Managerial Control And Performance[M].LexingtonBooks,1975
    [68] Kroll,M.,Susan A. Simmons.,Peter Wright. Determinants of Chief ExecutiveOfficer Compensation Following Major Acquisitions[J].Journal of BusinessResearch,1990,20(4):349-366
    [69] Jensen,M.C. The Modern Industrial Revolution, Exit, and the Failure ofInternal Control Systems[J].The Journal of Finance,1993,6:831-880
    [70] Lambert,RA., DF Larcker, RE Verrecchia. Portfolio Considerations in ValuingExecutive Compensation[J].Journal of Accounting Research,1991,29(1):129-149
    [71] Lipton,M.,Jay W. Lorsch. A Modest Proposal for Improved CorporateGovernance[J].Business Lawyer,1992,48:59-78
    [72] Finkelstein,S.,Donald C. Hambrick. The Effects Of Ownership Structure OnConditions At The Top: The Case Of CEO Pay Raises[J].Strategic Manage mentJournal,1995,16(3):175-193
    [73] Yermack,D. Higher Market Valuation Of Companies With A Small Board OfDirectors[J].Journal of Financial Economics,1996,40(2):185-211
    [74] Dyl,Edward A. Corporate Control And Management Compensation: EvidenceOn The Agency Problem[J].Managerial and Decision Economics,1988,9(1):21-25
    [75] Conyon,M.J.,Simon I. Peck. Board Control, Remuneration Committees, andTop Management Compensation[J].The Academy of Management Journal,1998,41(2):146-157
    [76] Cole, RE. Managing Quality Fads: How American Business Learned to Playthe Quality Game[M].Oxford University Press,1999
    [77] Firth,M.,M.Tam,M.Tang. The Determinants Of Top Management Pay[J].Omega,1999,27(6):617-635
    [78]林浚清,黄祖辉,孙永祥.高管团队内薪酬差距、公司绩效和治理结构[J].经济研究,2003,(4):31-40
    [79]杜胜利,翟艳玲.总经理年度报酬决定因素的实证分析——以我国上市公司为例[J].管理世界,2005,(8):14-20
    [80]郑珺.完善国有企业高管薪酬激励模式的问题研究[D]:[西南财经大学硕士学位论文].成都:西南财经大学,2005
    [81]葛杰,殷建.国有上市公司高管股权激励机制实证研究[J].山西财政税务专科学校学报,2008,(3):17-20
    [82]黄靖云.公司治理结构对高管薪酬和薪酬—业绩敏感度的影响研究[D]:[中山大学硕士学位论文].广州:中山大学,2008
    [83]邵平,刘林,孔爱国.高管薪酬与公司业绩的敏感性因素分析——金融业的证据(2000~2005年)[J].财经研究,2008,34(1):94-105
    [84] Adams,J.Stacy. Towards an understanding of inequity[J]. The Journal ofAbnormal and Social Psychology,1963,67(5):422-436
    [85] Cook,K.S., Richard M. Emerson, Mary R. Gillmore and Toshio Yamagishi. Thedistribution of power in exchange networks: theory and experimental results[J].American Journal of Sociology,1983,89(2):275-305
    [86] Meyer, B. J. F. The organization of prose and its effects on memory[J]. TheAmerican Journal of Psychology,1975,91(1):146-150
    [87] Tajfel,H.Social Psychology of Intergroup Relations[J]. Annual Review ofPsychology,1982,33:1-39
    [88] Lind,EA., TR Tyler. The social psychology of procedural justice[M]. NewYork,US:Plenum press,1988
    [89] Akerlof, George A., Janet L. Yellen. The Fair Wage-Effort Hypothesis andUnemployment[J]. The quarterly journal of economics,1990,105(2):255-283
    [90] Güth,Werner., Rolf Schmittberger, Bernd Schwarze. An experimental analysisof ultimatum bargaining[J]. Journal of Economic Behavior&Organization,1982,3:367-388
    [91] Roth,Alvin E., Ido Erev. Learning in extensive-form games: Experimental dataand simple dynamic models in the intermediate term[J]. Games and E conomicBehavior,1995,8:164-212
    [92] Camerer,C., Richard H. Thaler. Anomalies: Ultimatums, Dictators andManners[J]. The Journal of Economic Perspectives,1995,9(2):209-219
    [93] Camerer,C.F. Raising the Stakes in the Ultimatum Game:ExperimentalEvidences from Indonesia[J].Economic Inquiry,1999,37(1):47-59
    [94] Henrich,J., Robert Boyd, Samuel Bowles, Colin Camerer, Ernst Fehr, HerbertGintis and Richard McElreath. In Search of Homo Economicus: BehavioralExperiments in15Small-Scale Societies[J]. The American Economic Review,2001,91:73-78
    [95] Fehr,E., Georg Kirchsteiger, Arno Riedl. Does Fairness Prevent MarketClearing? An Experimental Investigation[J]. The Quarterly Journal ofEconomics,1993,108:437-459
    [96] Falk, A., Fehr, E., Fischbacher, U. Testing theories of fairness—Intentionsmatter[R]. Working paper No.63,2000
    [97] Berg,J., John Dickhaut, Kevin McCabe. Trust, Reciprocity, and SocialHistory[J]. Games and Economic Behavior,1995,10:122-142
    [98] Fahr,R., Bernd Irlenbusch. Fairness as a constraint on trust in reciprocity:earned property rights in a reciprocal exchange experiment[J]. Ec onomicsLetters,2000,66:275-282
    [99] Cox, J. Trust and reciprocity: implications of game triads and socialcontexts[R]Univ. of Arizona discussion paper,2000
    [100] Fehr, E., List, A. Do explicit incentives reduce trustworthiness?–anexperiment with CEOs[R]. Working paper,2002
    [101] Ledyard, J. Handbook of Experimental Economics[M]. Princeton: P rincetonUniversity Press,1995
    [102] Fehr,E., Simon G chter. Fairness and Retaliation: The Economics ofReciprocity[R]. Working Paper No.40,2000
    [103] Falk,A., Ernst Fehrc and Urs Fischbacher. Testing theories of fairness—Intentions matter[J]. Games and Economic Behavior,2008,62:287-303
    [104] Brosnan,SF., FBM De Waal.Monkeys reject unequal pay[J]. nature,2003,425:297-299
    [105] Knoch,D., Alvaro Pascual-Leone4, Kaspar Meyer, Valerie Treyer and ErnstFehr. Diminishing Reciprocal Fairness by Disrupting the Right PrefrontalCortex[J]. Science,2006,314:829-832
    [106] Tricomi et al. Transverse-momentum and pseudorapidity distributions ofcharged hadrons in pp collisions at and2.36TeV[J]. Journal of Hig h EnergyPhysics,2010,2010:1-19
    [107] Paul J. Zak, Angela A. Stanton and Sheila Ahmadi. Oxytocin IncreasesGenerosity in Humans[J]. PLoS ONE2: e1128,2007,(11)
    [108] Crockett,M.J.,Luke Clark,Golnaz Tabibnia, Matthew D. Lieberman, Trevor W.Robbins. Serotonin Modulates Behavioral Reactions to Unfairness[J].Science,2008,320:1739
    [109] Rabin,M. Incorporating Fairness into Game Theory and Economics[J]. TheAmerican Economic Review,1993,83:1281-1302
    [110] Fehr,E., Klaus M. Schmidt. A Theory of Fairness, Competition, andCooperation[J]. The Quarterly Journal of Economics,1999,114(3):817-868
    [111] Bolton,G.E., Axel Ockenfels. ERC: A Theory of Equity, Reciprocity, andCompetition[J]. The American Economic Review,2000,90:166-193
    [112] Falk,A.,Urs Fischbacher. A theory of reciprocity[J]. Games and EconomicBehavior,2006,54:293-315
    [113] Meidinger,E.'Private' Environmental Regulation, Human Rights, and Community[R].Working paper No.83,2000
    [114] Fehr,E., Klaus M. Schmidt. Fairness and Incentives in a Multi-task Principal–Agent Model[J]. The Scandinavian Journal of Economics,2004,106:453-474
    [115] Englmaier,F., Achim Wambach. Optimal Incentive Contracts under InequityAversion[R]. Discussion paper No.1643,2005
    [116]魏光兴,覃燕红.激励合约线性结构的行为合约理论解释[J].管理科学,2010,(23):75-80
    [117] Demougin,D., Claude Fluet and Carsten Helm. Output and wages withinequality averse agents[J]. Canadian journal of economics,2006,39:399-413.
    [118] Fehr,E., Alexander Klein, Klaus M Schmidt3. Fairness and Contract Design[J].Econometrica,2007,75:121-154
    [119]魏光兴,蒲勇健.基于公平心理的报酬契约设计及代理成本分析[J].管理工程学报,2008,22(2):58-68
    [120]李训,曹国华.基于公平偏好理论的激励机制研究[J].管理工程学报,2008,22(2):107-116
    [121]陈其安,刘星.基于过度自信和外部监督的团队合作均衡研究[J].管理科学学报,2005,8(6):60-68
    [122]梁丽.基于公平偏好视角的上市公司高管薪酬激励分析[J].经济研究导刊,2010,105:93-94
    [123]袁茂,雷勇和蒲勇健.基于公平偏好理论的激励机制与代理成本分析[J].管理工程学报,2011,25(2):82-86
    [124]黄再胜,王玉.公平偏好、薪酬管制与国企高管激励———种基于行为合约理论的分析[J].财经研究,2009,35(1):16-27
    [125] Main,B.G.,O’Reilly,C.A. and Wade,J. Top Executive Pay: Tournament ofTeamwork?[J]. Journal of Labor Economics,1993,11(4):606-628
    [126] Eriksson, T. Executive Compensation and Tournament Theory: Empirical Testson Danish Data[J]. Journal of Labor Economics,1999,17(2):262-280
    [127] Beaumont, P. B., and R. I. D. Harris. Internal Wage Structures andOrganizational Performance[J]. British Journal of Industrial Relations,2003,41(1):53-70
    [128] Lallemand, T.,R. Plasman, and F. Rycs. Intra-Firm Wage Dispersion and FirmPerformance: Evidence form Linked Employer-Employee Data[J].Kykols,2004,57(4):533-558
    [129] Heyman, F. Pay Inequality and Firm performance: Evidence from MatchedEmployer-employee data[J]. Applied Economics,2005,37(11):1313-1327
    [130] Jirjahn, U., Kraft. Intra-firm Wage Dispersion and Firm Performance-Is there aUniform Relationship?[J]. Kyklos,2007,60(2):231-253.
    [131] Kato, T., and C. X. Long. Tournaments and Managerial Incentives in China’sListed Firms: New Evidence[M].2008.
    [132] Winter-Ebmer, R., J. Zweimueller. Intra-firm Wage Dispersion and FirmPerformance[J]. Kyklos,1999,52(4):555-572.
    [133]林浚清,黄祖辉,孙永祥.高管团队内薪酬差距、公司绩效和治理结构.经济研究,2003,(4):31-40.
    [134]鲁海帆.高管团队内薪酬差距、合作需求和多元化战略[J].管理科学,2007,(4):30-37.
    [135]鲁海帆.内生性视角下高管层薪酬差距与公司业绩研究[J].软科学,2009,(12):22-29.
    [136]卢锐.管理层权利、薪酬差距与绩效[J].南方经济,2007,(7):60-70
    [137]陈震.高管层级差报酬的成因和后果[J].南方经济,2006,(3):59-69
    [138] Cowherd,D. M., D. I. Levine. Product Quality and Pay Equity Between Lower-Level Employees and Top Management: An Investigation of DistributiveJustice Theory.[J] Administrative Science Quarterly,1992,37(2):302-320
    [139] Pfeffer, J., N. Langton. The Effect of Wage Dispersion on Statisfaction,Productivity, and Working Collaboratively: Evidence from College andUniversity Faculty[J]. Administrative Science Quarterly,1993,38(3):382-407
    [140] Grund,C., Westergaard-Nielsen,N. The Dispersion of Employees’ WageIncreases and Firms Performance[J]. Industrial and Labor RelationsReview,2008,(4):485-501
    [141] Martins,P.S. Dispersion in Wage Premiums and Firm Performance[J].Economics Letters,2008,101(1):63-65
    [142]朱启明,佘虹志.对上市公司高管团队薪酬公平性的研究[J].广东商学院学报,2006,(4):19-24
    [143]汪纯孝,伍骁奕,谢礼珊.企业薪酬管理公平性对员工工作绩效的影响[J].中山大学学报(社会科学版),2006,(4):103-108
    [144]张正堂.高层管理团队协作需要、薪酬差距和企业绩效:竞赛理论的视角[J].南开管理评论,2007,(2):4-11
    [145]张正堂.企业内部薪酬差距对组织未来绩效影响的实证研究[J].会计研究,2008,(9):81-87
    [146] Leonard, J. S. Executive Pay and Firm Performance[J]. Industrial and LaborRelations Review,1990,43(3):13S-29S
    [147] Hibbs, D. A., Jr., H. Locking. Wage Dispersion and Productive Efficiency:Evidence for Sweden[J]. Journal of Labor Economics,2000,18(4):755-782
    [148] Braakmann, N. Intra-firm Wage Inequality and Firm Performance-FirstEvidence form German Linked Employer-employee Data[R].Working paper,Leuphana University Luneburg,2008
    [149]覃予.公平偏好、企业内部薪酬不公平与企业绩效[D]:[厦门大学博士学位论文].厦门:厦门大学,2009
    [150] Jensen, M. C., and MurPhy, K. J. Perfomance Pay and Top-ManagementIncentives[J]. The Journal of Political Economy,1990,98(2):225-264
    [151] Antle,R., A Smith. Measuring Executive Compensation: Methods and anApplication[J].Journal of Account ing Research,1985,23(1):296-325
    [152] Finkelstein,S., Donald C. Hambrick. Chief executive compensation: Asynthesis and reconciliation[M].1988
    [153]林江辉.构建现代企业有效报酬系统[J].经济管理,2002,(14):39-44
    [154]张勇.经理长期与短期报酬优化组合激励的探讨[J].管理工程学报,2004,(3):125-127
    [155]黄群慧.企业经营者年薪制的模式比较[R].跨世纪的中国企业改革和发展理论与实践研讨会文集,1999
    [156]王万利.上市公司高管薪酬结构不合理[N].中国商报,2003-7-1
    [157]魏颖辉.高管薪酬、股权、控制权组合激励与绩效[J].统计与决策,2008,(20):141-144
    [158]胡志龙.企业生命周期理论下高管激励机制构建研究[D]:[湖南大学硕士学位论文].长沙:湖南大学,2008
    [159]宋德舜.国有控股、最高决策者激励与公司绩效[J].中国工业经济,2004,(3):91-98
    [160]李垣,张完定.管理者激励组合的理论探讨[J].管理工程学报,2002,(3):26-30
    [161]吕长江,周县华.公司治理结构与股利分配动机——基于代理成本和利益侵占的分析[J].南开管理评论,2005,(3):9-17
    [162] Baker,G., Robert Gibbons, Kevin J. Murphy. Subjective Perfor mance Measuresin Optimal Incentive Contracts[R]. NBER Working Paper NO.4480,1993
    [163] Murphy, K.J.,Oyer, P. Discretion in Executive Incentive Contracts: Theory andEvidence[R], Working paper,2001
    [164]陈爽英,唐小我和马永开.人力资本显性激励与隐性激励的组合合同分析[J].中国管理科学,2005,(6):108-112
    [165]李敬湘,张衔.国有企业高管激励中的契约选择:隐性契约与显性契约[J].云南社会科学,2009,(4):121-124.
    [166]吴俊.高管层内薪酬的显性激励与隐性激励关系研究——基于沪深A股上市制造公司[J].市场周刊(理论研究),2010,(2):23-24,120
    [167] Conyon, M. J. and S. I. Peck. Board control, remuneration committees, and topmanagement compensation. Academy of Management Journal,1997,41(2),146-157
    [168] Core, J. E., R. W. Holthausen, and D. F. Larcker. Corporate Governance, ChiefExecutive Officer Compensation, and Firm Performance[J]. Journal ofFinancial Economics,1999,51(3):371-406
    [169] Carter, M. E. and L. Lynch. An examination of executive stock optionrepricing. Journal of Financial Economics,2001,61,207-225
    [170] Bebchuk,L.,Fried,J. Pay without performance: the unfulfilled promise ofexecutive compensation[M]. Cambridge: Harvard University Press,2004
    [171]赵文红,李垣.中国国企经营者“在职消费”行为探讨[J].经济体制改革,1998,(5):82-84
    [172]颜剑英.经理行为的激励方式与国有企业激励机制的改革[J].江苏大学学报(社会科学版),2002,(2):104-109
    [173]韩晶,张仁德.产权低效与国有企业改革[J].经济体制改革,2003,(4):36-39
    [174] Milton Harris, Artur Raviv. Corporate Governance: Voting Rights andMajority Rules[J]. Journal of Financial Economics,1988,(20):203-235
    [175] Aghion.P., Bolton,P. An Incomplete Contracts Approach to FinancialContracting[J]. Review of Economic Studies,1992,59(3):473-494
    [176]田利辉.国有产权、预算软约束和中国上市公司杠杠治理[J].管理世界,2005,(7):123-128,147
    [177]沈春秋.基于管理者非经济性激励的权力需求分析[D]:[合肥工业大学硕士学位论文].合肥:合肥工业大学,2008
    [178]洪功翔.不同体制下企业经理人员控制权收益比较[J].经济问题,2001,(6):34-36
    [179]童卫华.我国国有企业高层人员报酬:控制权激励观[J].经济学家,2005,(6):53-57
    [180]屠巧平.控制权收益作为国有控股公司高管激励的影响因素研究[J].经济管理,2006,(20):55-60
    [181]卢现祥.关于建立我国经理市场的若干思考[J].湖北社会科学,1997,(8):21-22
    [182] Hirsch, Fred. Social Limits to Growth[M]. Harvard University Press,1976
    [183]曹凤岐.上市公司高管人员股权激励研究——十论社会主义条件下的股份制度[J].北京大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2005,(6):139-150
    [184]张炳申,安凡所.管理权力模式与最优契约模式比较分析[J].外国经济与管理,2005,(3):27-32
    [185]姜硕,于欣.基于控制权的我国高管人员激励约束问题研究[J].西部财会,2007,(8):37-39
    [186]罗宏,黄文华.国企分红、在职消费与公司业绩[J].管理世界,2008,(9):139-148.
    [187] Thibaut, John W., Walker, Laurens. Procedural justice: A psychologicalanalysis[M]. Hillsdale,NJ:Eribaum,1975
    [188] Bies, R. J., Moag, J. S. Interactional justice: Communication criteria offairness. In Lewicki, R. J., Sheppard, B. H.,&Bazerman, B. H.(Eds.),Research on Negotiation in Organizations (Vol.1), Greenwich, CT: JAI Press,1986,43-55
    [189] Forsythe,R,J.L., Horowitz,N.E.Savin, M.Sefton. Fairness in SimpleBargaining Experiments[J]. Games and Economic Behavior,1994,6(3):347-369
    [190] Akerlof, G.A. Labor Contracts as Partial Gift Exchange[J].the QuarterlyJournal of Economics,1982,97(4):543-569
    [191] Ross, S. A. The Economic Theory of Agency: the Principal’s Problem[J]. TheAmerican Economic Review,1973,63(2):134-139
    [192] Sehultz,T.W. Investment in Human Capital[J].The American EconomicReview,1961,51(l):l-17
    [193] Becker Cary. Investment in Human Capital: a theoretical analysis[J].TheJournal of Political Economy,1962,70(2):9-49
    [194] Coase R H.The Nature of the Firm[J].Economics,1937,4(16):386-405
    [195] Hart O.,Moore J. Property Rights and the Nature of the Firm[J]. Journal ofPolitical Economy,1990,98(6):1119-1158
    [196]张五常.企业的契约性质[M].经济解释——张五常经济论文选.北京:商务印书馆,2000
    [197] Blair, M.M. Ownership and Control: Rethinking Corporate Governance for theTwenty-First Cenntury[M]. Brookings Institute (Washington, D.C.),1995
    [198]钱颖一.企业的治理结构改革和融资结构改革[J].经济研究,1995,(01):20-29
    [199]吴敬琏.论现代企业制度[J].财经研究,1994,(02):3-13
    [200]张维迎.西方企业理论的演进与最新发展[J].经济研究,1994,(11):70-81
    [201] Maslow A H.Incentive and Personality[M].NewYork: Harper and Row,1954
    [202] Herzberg,F.I. Worker's Needs: the Same Around the World[J].Industry Week,1987,9(21):29-32
    [203] Alderfer C P.Existence, Relatedness and growth[M].New York:Free Press,1972
    [204]李剑锋.组织行为学[M].北京:首都经济贸易大学出版社,2003
    [205] Vroom V H. Work and Incentive[M].New York: John Wiley and Sons,1964.
    [206] Fritz Heider. The Psychology of Interpersonal Relations[M]. New York: JohnWiley and Sons,1958
    [207] HH Kelley. Attribution Theory in Social Psychology[J].Nebraska Symposiumon Motivation,1967,15:192-238
    [208] Bernard Weiner. Attribution Theory, Achievement Motivation, and theEducational Process[J].Review of Educational Research,1972,42(2):203-215
    [209] Skinner B F. Reinforcement Today[J].American Psychologist,1958,13(3):94-99
    [210] Bai,Chong-En,David D.Li, Zhigang Tao, Yijiang Wang. A Multitask Theory OfState Enterprise Reform[J].Journal of Comparative Economics,2000,28:716-738
    [211]袁江天,张维.多任务委托代理模型下国企经理激励问题研究[J].管理科学学报,2006,(3):45-53
    [212] Su,Dongwei.Corporate Finance and State Enterprise Reform in China[J]. ChinaEconomic Review,2005,16:118-148
    [213] Holmstrom B,Milgrom P. Multi-task Principal-Agent Analyses: IncentiveContracts, Asset Ownership And Job Design[J].Journal of Law, Economics andOrganization,1997,7:24-52
    [214]李军林.关于国有企业经营者激励问题的探讨—非完全竞争条件下的隐性激励[J].教学与研究,2007,(4):37-42
    [215]沈艺峰,李培功.政府限薪令与国有企业高管薪酬、业绩和运气关系的研究[J].中国工业经济,2010,(11):130-139
    [216] Englmaier,F.,Wambach,A. Contracts and Inequity Aversion[R],Working Paper,2002
    [217] Englmaier,F.,Wambach,A. Optimal Incentive Contracts under InequityAversion[R],Working Paper,2004
    [218] Itoh H.Moral Hazard and Other-Regarding Preferences[J].The JapaneseEconomic Review,2004,55(1):18-44
    [219] Che,Y.K., Yoo,S.W. Optimal Incentives for Teams[J]. the American EconomicReview,2001,91(3):525-541
    [220] Kval y Ola, Olsen, Trond E. Team Incentives in Relational EmploymentContracts[J]. Journal of Labor Economics,2006,24(1):139-168
    [221]朱克江.经营者薪酬激励机制架构分析[J].唯实,2002,(11):16-20
    [222]王满四.上市公司负债融资的激励效应实证研究——针对经理人员工资和在职消费的分析[J].南方经济,2006,(7):65-74
    [223]李寿喜.产权、代理成本和代理效率[J].经济研究,2007,(1):102-113
    [224] James S.Ang, Rebel A. Cole, James Wuh Lin. Agency Cost and OwnershipStructure[J]. Journal of Finance,2000,55(1):81-106
    [225]树友林.高管权力、货币报酬与在职消费关系实证研究[J].经济学动态,2011,(5):86-89

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700