用户名: 密码: 验证码:
石化企业生态效率评价研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
石化工业在我国国民经济中占有举足轻重的地位。一方面,作为国民经济的支柱行业,石化行业的增加值在我国GDP中的比例逐年增长,目前已接近6%。另一方面,石油化工是一个高耗能、高污染的行业,仅化工行业每年排放的工业废水、废气和废渣占全国工业三废排放总量的比例就分别达到22%、8%和12%。因此,如何在可持续发展的背景下评价我国石油化工企业的发展水平,是理论和实践共同面临的重大课题。
     本文以石化企业为例,对石化企业生态效率评价理论和方法做了深入探讨,首先通过文献研究、专家咨询、企业调查以及对国内外研究的比较,构建与我国石化企业技术经济特点相适应的生态效率评价指标体系;其次,针对单个石化企业,构建石化企业生态承载力模型,并通过大连地区典型石化企业生态效率案例分析,对模型进行了验证;最后,通过对生态效率评价方法的研究,构建了基于数据包络分析(DEA)的石化企业相对生态效率评价模型,对大连地区石化行业的经营效率和生态效率进行比较分析。
     论文的主要创新和研究贡献可归纳为以下三点:
     (1)构建了适合我国石化企业特点的生态效率评价指标体系
     与现有的多从一般意义上研究企业生态效率指标的文献不同,本研究从建立石化企业生态效率评价体系的目标出发,对现有的生态效率指标做了全面梳理。构建了石化企业生态效率评价指标体系的层次结构,其分为状态层和变量层两个层次,状态层指标的选取充分借鉴了国际权威专业研究机构如WBCSD等的相关研究成果,保证了本研究的先进性。对于变量层指标的选取,一方面深入现场征询了石化行业的技术、经济、管理专家的意见,另一方面借鉴了已有的国内外关于生态效率和可持续发展评价指标体系的研究成果,保证了本研究的合理性。据此构建的石化企业生态效率评价指标体系,具有较高的理论研究参考价值,可作为相关实证分析的工具。
     (2)构建了基于生态承载力分析的石化企业生态效率评价模型
     与现有的多侧重于行为动机和战略视角的关于企业生态效率的定性研究文献不同,本研究从提高研究成果的应用价值出发,尝试了将生态承载力理论应用于石化企业生态效率评价模型的研究,构建的企业生态承载力评价模型能够从资源、经济和环境三方面定量描述石化企业的经济活动以及和资源、环境的相互作用。该模型在三维的几何空间中,将石化企业本身作为对自然资源和自然环境的施压者,状态空间的三个轴分别代表石化企业的经济状况,资源的使用状况和企业对环境的影响状况,评价指标由经济类、环境类和资源类三大类指标组成,具体从经济效益、生产技术经济、环境污染、环境管理、资源总量和资源利用六个方面出发,可以准确描述企业经济活动与资源、环境紧密相联的互动关系。该模型很好地反映了WBCSD提出的“使企业整个生命周期对环境的影响和消耗资源的强度逐渐降低到与生态承载力一致的水平”的理念和追求,开发了生态承载力模型新的应用领域,可作为企业生态效率分析和评价工具,为企业从可持续发展的角度研制和改进发展战略提供方向指引。
     (3)构建了基于数据包络分析(DEA)的多个石化企业相对生态效率评价模型
     与现有的行业生态效率评价研究文献大多采用指标评价法进行定性或单指标定量研究不同,本研究从石化行业多投入、多产出的技术经济特性出发,构建了基于数据包络分析(DEA)的石化行业生态效率综合评价模型。实证研究表明,应用该模型不仅可以评价行业内不同企业的相对生态效率,而且揭示企业经营效率与生态效率的差异,开发了DEA模型新的应用领域,是企业和行业度量自身可持续发展水平的更先进、有效的评价方法。另外,DEA的投影分析可为企业确定生态效率改进方向提供决策参考,对提高企业可持续发展水平具有一定理论指导价值。
The petrochemical industry plays an important role in the economy.As one of the key industries of national economy,the value added of petrochemical industry is keeping increased to reach nearly 6%in national GDP.However,petrochemical industry is a high energy consuming and polluting industry.The waste water,waste gas and solid waste produced by chemical account for 22%,8%and 12%of the total industrial waste per year.It is a big challenge that how to evaluate the development of petrochemical industry in such a sustainable background for both research and practice.
     This dissertation takes petrochemical industry as case study to discuss the industrial eco-efficiency evaluation theory and method.First establish a petrochemical industry eco-efficiency indicator system by literature reviews,specialists,surveys and comparation of existing researches.Second,establish carrying capacity model to evaluate individual petrochemical industry.The model is testified by a typical case study in Dalian.Finally, establish comparative eco-efficiency evaluation system of petrochemical industry which is based on Data Envelopment Analysis.
     The main contribution of this research can be concluded in three aspects:
     (1) Establish an indicator system based on Chinese petrochemical industry's development as the first research in this area.
     Different with current researches of industrial eco-efficiency indicators,this research bases on summarizing all existing eco-efficiency and tries to establish an eco-efficiency evaluation system.The petrochemical industry eco-efficiency indicator system composes two levels indicators which are stating indicators and variable indicators.The stating indicators are mainly based on researches from famous organizations such as WBCSD which can ensure this research a leading position.The variable indicators are based on suggestion from experts from the industries and international advanced researches on eco-efficiency indicator systems and sustainable indicators which make the indicators are suitable for Chinese petrochemical industries.The research can be the first academic attempt in this area so that it has relatively high academic value.
     (2) Establish petrochemical industry eco-efficiency evaluation model based on carrying capacity analysis which.
     Different with existing industry eco-efficiency researches which are focus on motivation and strategy,this research tries to apply carrying capacity for industry eco-efficiency evaluation model.The industry carrying capacity model uses a three-dimensioned space describe the resource aspect,economic aspect and environmental aspect of the industry.It has a better understanding of the eco-efficiency concept proposed by WBCSD which can be a useful tool for industry to evaluate eco-efficiency from sustainability aspect and developed new application field of carrying capacity theory.
     (3) Establish relative eco-efficiency evaluation model which is based on Data Envelopment Analysis.
     Different with existing industry eco-efficiency evaluation methods,the method in this research is based on Data Envelopment Analysis which can describe the multiple inputs and multiple outputs character.The model used in the research can not only evaluate the relative eco-efficiency of different petrochemical industries but also can compare the difference between economical efficiency and eco-efficiency and suggest improvements.It developed new application field of DEA model and contributes on industry eco-efficiency evaluation method.Also it is a more effective method for industries to self evaluates their sustainability so that it has a good academic value to improve sustainability.
引文
[1]Willard B.The sustain,ability advantage:seven business case benefits of a triple bottom line[M].Gabriola Island:New Society Publishers.2002
    [2]Bjrn Stigson.Eco-efficiency:creating more value with less impact[M].WBCSD,2000:5-36.
    [3]OECD.Eeo-efficiency.Organization for economic co-operation and development[M].Paris,France.1998
    [4]Meier,M.Eeo-efficiency evaluation of waste gas purification systems in the chemical industry[M].Landsberg/Lech,Germany:Eeomed.1997.
    [5]DeSimone,L.D.,Popoff,F.Eco-efficiency.The Business Link to Sustainable Development[M],2~(nd) ed.MIT Press,Cambridge,MA.1998.
    [6]Muller K,Sterm A.Standardized eco-efficiency indicators-report 1:concept paper[R].Basel.2001.
    [7]Roger L.Burritt,Chika Saka.Environmental management accounting applications and eco-efficiency:case studies from Japan[J].Journal of Cleaner Production.2006(14):1262-1257
    [8]诸大建,朱远.生态效率与循环经济[J].复旦学报(社会科学版),2005,2:60-66
    [9]周国梅,彭昊,曹凤中.循环经济和工业生态效率指标体系[J].城市环境与城市生态,2003,16(6):201-203.
    [10]戴铁军,陆钟武.钢铁企业生态效率分析[J].东北大学学报(自然科学版).2005,26(12):1168-1173
    [11]汤慧兰,孙德生.工业生态系统及其建设[J].中国环保产业.2003,2:14-16
    [12]WBCSD.Measuring eco-efficiency.A guide to reporting company performance[R].World Business Council for Sustainable Development,Geneva,2000b
    [13]Hertwich,Edgar G.Eco-efficiency and its role in industrial transformation.Working paper,Institute for Environmental Studies,Free University of Amsterdam,NL[R].http://www.tev.ntnu.no/edgar.hertwich/download/Ecoefficiency_IHDP.pdf.1997
    [14]黄光宇,杨培峰.城乡空间生态规划理论框架试析[J].规划师.2002,18(4):5-9
    [15]余德辉,王金南.发展循环经济是21世纪环境保护的战略选择[J].环境保护.2001(10):36-38
    [16]岳媛媛,苏敬勤.生态效率:国外的实践与我国的对策.科学学研究[J].2004,22(2):170-173.
    [17]World Commission on Environment and Development(WCED),Our Common Future[M].Oxford:Oxford University Press.1987
    [18]EEA(European Environment Agency).Making sustainability accountable:Eco-efficiency,resource productivity and innovation.Topic Report No.11/1999 JR].Copenhagen:EEA.1999
    [19]Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations.The State of World Fisheries and Aquaculture[R].Rome:FAO,1995
    [20]Intergovermental Panel on Climate Change,Climate Change 1995[M].Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.1996
    [21]Ehrlich,P.R.and J.P.Hoidren.One-dimensional ecology[J].Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists 1972,28(5):16-27
    [22]Michael H.Huesemann.Guarantee Sustainability:Future Challenges for Industrial Ecology[J].Environmental Progress.2004,23(4):264-270
    [23]任勇.中外循环经济的比较[J].企业科协.2004,(8):7-9
    [24]Pearce,D.W.and Turner,P.K..Economics of Natural Resources and the Environment[M].1990
    [25]布朗.生态经济[M].东方出版社.2002
    [26]Yasuo K,Ko-suke H and Ryota K.A discussion on the resource circulation strategy of the refrigerator [J].Resources Conservation and Recycling.2001,33(3):153-165
    [27]Stuart R,David E.The environmental effect of reusing and recycling a plastic-based packaging system [J].Journal of Cleaner Production.2003,11(5):561-571
    [28]John T.E.The future of recycling[J].Resource Policy.25(3):197-204
    [29]Sujit D,Randall C.T and Colleen R.G.Automobile recycling in the United States:Eergy impacts and waste generation[J].Resources Conservation and Recycling.1995,14(3-4):265-284
    [30]Spatari S.,Bertram M.and Fuse K.The contemporary,European copper cycle:1 year stocks and flows [J].Ecological Economics.2002,42(1-2):27-42
    [31]Hirohisa K,Kazunori H,Hidetoshi Y.Correspondence analysis of paper recycling society,:consumers and paper maker in Japan[J].Resources Conservation and Recycling.1998,23(4):193-208
    [32]王如松.循环经济建设的生态学方法[M].中国环境科学出版社.2003
    [33]诸大建.可持续发展呼唤循环经济[J].科技导报.1998(9):39-42
    [34]诸大建.循环经济:上海跨世纪发展途径[J].上海经济研究.1998(10):28-32
    [35]诸大建.循环经济与上海可持续发展[J].上海环境科学.1998(10):1-4
    [36]解振华.走循环经济之路实现可持续生产和消费[J].环境保护.2003,(3):3-4
    [37]曲格平.循环经济与环境保护[J].光明日报.2000-11-20
    [38]段宁.清洁生产、生态工业和循环经济[J].环境科学研究.2001,14(6):1-8
    [39]陈赛.循环经济及其法律调控模式[J].环境保护.2003,(1):10-12
    [40]冯久田,尹建中,初丽霞.循环经济理论及其在中国实践的研究[J].中国人口、资源与环境.2003,13(2):28-33
    [41]武春友.创造全社会参与的资源效率与生态和谐系统[J].价值工程.2006,(1):1-3
    [42]诸大建,邱寿丰.生态效率是循环经济的合适测度[J].中国人口、资源与环境.2006,16(5):1-6
    [43]邱寿峰.循环经济规划的生态效率方法及应用[D].同济大学.2007
    [44]周国梅,彭吴,曹凤中.循环经济和工业生态效率指标体系[J].城市环境与城市生态.2003,16(6):201-203
    [45]刘华波,杨海真,顾国维.基于生态效率建立我国循环经济评价指标体系的思考[J].四川环境.2006,25(2):78-82
    [46]诸大建,朱远.从生态效率的角度深入认识循环经济[J].中国发展.2005(1):6-11
    [47]Wernick I.K,Robert H,Shekhar G,Ausubel J.H.Materialization and demterialization:measures and trends[J].Daedalus[0011-5266]Wernick.1996,125(3)
    [48]Ester van der Voet,Lauran van Oers,Igor Nikolic.Dematerialization:not just a matter of weight[J].Journal of Industrial Ecology.2004,8(4):121-138
    [49]彭新育,侯先荣.中国与其他国家物质消耗--收入关系的比较分析[J].中国软科学.2000(9):33-38
    [50]徐明,张天柱.中国经济系统的物质投入分析[J].中国环境科学.2005,5(3):324-328
    [51]谢芳,李慧明.非物质化与循环经济[J].城市环境与城市生态.2006,19(1):30-32
    [52]Von Weiszacker,Lovins A.B.et al.The factor four[M].London:Earthscan.1997
    [53]Schmidt-Bleek.F.Sustainability requires a factor 10 in resource productivity.In Environmentally Conscious Poducts Network News 7[M].Tokyo:JEMAL.1997
    [54]Factor 10 Club.The International Factor 10 Club's statement to government and business leaders:A tenfold leap in energy and resource efficiency[R].Wuppertal:Wuppertal Institute.1997
    [55]Jansen L.and P.Vergragt.Sustainable development:A challenge to technology.Leidschendam:Ministry for Housing[M].Physical Planning and Environment.1992
    [56]中国科学院.2006年中国可持续发展战略报告[R].科学出版社.2006
    [57]Von Wernick,Wag,goner P and Ausubel J.Searching for leverage to Conserve Forests:The Industrial Ecology of Wood Products in the United States[J].Journal of Industrial Ecology.1998,1(3):125-145
    [58]Reijnders L.Environmentally improved production process and products[M].Dordrecht:Kluwer.1996
    [59]Van der Ven,B.Stedelijk waterbehheer(Urban water management)[M].Apeldoorn,the Netherlands:TNO Milieu,Energie en Procesinnovatie.1997
    [60]Von Weiszacker,Lovins A.B.et al.Factor Vier:Doppeiter Wohlstand- haibierter Naturverbrauch[M].Munchen:Droemer Knaur.1994
    [61]Overleg Commissie Verkenningen.Factor 4:Essays over meer doen met minder(Essays about doing more with less)[M].Den Haag:SDU.1997
    [62]Cleveland,C.J,Ruth,M.R.When,where,and by how much do biophysical limits constrain the economic process? A survey of Nicholas Georgescu-Roegen's contribution to ecological economics [J].Ecological Economics.1997(22):203-223
    [63]Hukkinen J.Eco-efficiency as abandonment of nature[J].Ecological Economics.2001(38):311-315
    [64]Adriaanse,A.,S.Bringezu,A.Hammond,Y.Moriguchi,E.Rodenburg,D.Rogich and H.Schutz.Resource flows:The material basis of industrial economics[M].Washington,DC:World Resource Institute.1997
    [65]Schmidt-Bleek F.Wieviel Umwelt Braucht der Mensch?(How much environment does man need?)[M].Berlin:Birkhauser Verlag,1994
    [66]Kobayashi Y,Kobayashi H et al.A practical method for quantifying eco-efficiency using eco-design support tools[J].Journal of Industrial Ecology.2005,9(4):131-144
    [67]Taeko A.Eco-efficiency and ecodesign in electrical and electronic products[J].Journal of Cleaner Production.2007(15):1406-1414
    [68]Weizsacker C.C.Notes on endogenous change of tastes[J].Journal of Economic Theory.1971(3):345-372
    [69]Mokyr,J.The level of riches:Technological Creativity and economic progress[M].Oxford University Press,New York.1990
    [70]孙施文.后现代城市规划[J].规划师.2002(6):20-25
    [71]Mol A.P.J.Ecological modernization:industrial transformations and the environmental reform.In:Redclif-t,M.,Woodgate,G.(Eds)[M].The Intemational Handbook of Environmental Sociology.Edward Elgar Publishing,Cheltenham.1997
    [72]Weale A.The new polotics of pollution[M].Manchester:Manchester University Press.1992
    [73]Hajer M.A.The politics of environmental discourse:ecological modernization and the policy process [M].Oxford:Clarendon.1995
    [74]Dryzek JS.The politics of the earth:Environmental discourses[M].Oxford University Press:Oxford.1997
    [75]Spaargaren G.and A.P.J.Sociology,environment and modernity:ecological modernization as a theory of social change[J-].Society and Nature Resources.1992,5(4):323-344
    [76]Langhelle.Why ecological modernization and sustainable development should not be conflated.John Wiley & Sons,Ltd.2001
    [77]Orssatto R.J.The ecological modernization of industry:Developing multi- disciplincary research on organization & environment.University of Technology.Sydney.2001.
    [78]Christoff P.Ecological modernization,ecological modernities.Environmental Politics.1996,5(3):476-500
    [79]黄英娜.西方生态现代化思想述评[D].哈尔滨工业大学.2002
    [80]Gouldson A,Murphy J.Ecological modernization:restructuring industrial economies,in:Jacobs,M.(Eds).Greening the millennium? The New Politics of the Environment[M].Blackwell Publishers,Oxford.1997
    [81]Pellow D.N,Schnalberg A,Weinberg A.S.Advanced industrial countries[J].Environmental Politics.2000,9(1):109-137
    [82]Gille Z.Transitional economies[J].Environmental Politics.2000,9(1):203-231
    [83]Frijns J,Phuong P.T,Mol A.P.J.Developing countries[J].Environmental Politics.2000,9(1):257-292
    [84]郭熙保,杨开泰.生态现代化理论述评[J].教学与研究.2006(4):46-52
    [85]蒋俊明.西方生态现代化理论的产生及对我国的借鉴[J].农业现代化研究.2007,28(4):462-466
    [86]余谋昌.生态伦理学[M].北京:首都师范大学出版社.1999
    [87]黄英娜.叶平.20世纪末西方生态现代化思想述评[J].国外社会科学.2001(4):2-9
    [88]陈烈,李丹燕.生态现代化与广州市可持续发展[J].经济地理.2004,24(1):134-138
    [89]刘昌寿.生态现代化理论及其对我国城市可持续发展的启示[J].城市规划学刊 2006(6):54-59
    [90]中国现代化战略研究课题组.中国现代化报告2007[R].北京大学出版社.2007
    [91]何晋勇,吴仁海.生态现代化理论及在国内决策中的应用[J].中国人口·资源与环境.2001(4):
    [92]Revell A.The ecological modernization of SMEs in the UK's construction industry[J].Geoforum.2007,38:114-126
    [93]Buttel,F.H.Ecological modernization as social theory[J].Geoforum.2000(31):57-65
    [94]Janicke M.Ecological modernization:new perspectives[J].Journal of Cleaner Production.2008(16):557-565
    [95]武春友.资源效率与生态规划管理[M].清华大学出版社.2006
    [96]Helminen R.Developing tangible measures for eco-efficiency:The case of the Finnish and Swedish pulp and paper industry[J].Business Strategy and Environment.2000,(9):196-210
    [97]Schmidheiny,S.Changing Course[M].MIT Press,Cambridge,MA.1992
    [98]Fussler C.and James P.Driving Eco Innovation.A Breakthrough Discipline for Innovation and Sustainability[M].Pitman,London.1996
    [99]Opschoor,H.et al.Towards a Sustainable Industrial Metabolism:Economic and Policy Strategies for Dematerialisation in Technology,Production and Consumption(project proposal for the European Commission)[R].Free University of Amsterdam,Amsterdam.1995
    [100]WBCSD.Wco-efficient Leadership for Improved Economic and Environmental Performance.World Business Council for Sustainable Development[M].Geneva,1998
    [101]NRTEE.Measuring Eco-Efficiency in Business:Backgrounder.National Round Table on the Environmental and the Economy.Task Force on Eco-Efficiency[R].Canada,1997
    [102]Verfaillie H.and Bidwell R.Measuring eco-efficiency:A Guide to reporting company performance [R].London:World Business Council of Sustainable Development.2000
    [103]Ekins P.Eco-efficiency:Motives.Drivers,and Economic Implications [J].Journal of Industrial Ecology.2005 9(4):12-14
    [104]NetRegs.SME-2003:A survey to assess environmental behaviors among smaller UK businesses [R].2003 Accessed December 12,2004 at vAvw.netregs.gov.uk
    [105]Van Berkel R,Narayannswamy V.Sustainability as a Framework for Innovation in Minerals Processing [J].The AusIMM Bulletin:Journal of the Australasian Institute of Mining and Metallurgy.2004
    [106]Van Berkel R,Narayannswamy V.Eco-efficiency for Design and Operation of Minerals Processing Plants [M].In:CHEMECA 2005.Brisbane:Institute for Chemical Egineering Australia.2005
    [107]Verfaillie,H.A,Bidwell,R.Measuring Eco-efficiency:A Guide to Reporting Company Performance[R].WBCSD.2000
    [108]Huisman J,Stevels A.L.N,Stobbe 1.Eco-Efficiency Considerations on the End-of-Life of Consumer Electronic Products [J].IEEE Transactions on Electronics Packing Manufacturing.2004(27):9-25
    [109]Bleischwitz R.Cognitive and institutional perspectives of eco-efficiency [J].Ecological Economics.2003 (46):453-467
    [110]Kerr W,Ryan C.Eco-efficiency gains from remanufacturing:A case study of photocopier remanufacturing at Fuji Xerox Australia [J].Journal of Cleaner Production,2001,(9):75-81
    [111]Park P.J,Tahara K,et al.Comparison of four methods for integrating environmental and economic aspects in the end-of-life stage of a washing machine [J].Resources Conservation & Recycling.2006(48):71-85
    [112]Park P.J,Tahara K,Inaba A.Product quality-based eco-efficiency applied to digital cameras [J].Journal of Environmental Management.2007(83):158-170
    [113]Fuse,K,Horikoshi,Y.,Kumai,T,et al.Application of eco-efficiecy factor to mobile phone and scanner [C].Proceedings of EcoDesign2003:Third International Symposium on Environmentally Conscious Design and Inverse Manufacturing.Tokyo,Japan.2003
    [114]Wall-Markowski C,Kicherer A,Wittlinger R.Eco-efficiency:inside BASF and beyond [J].Management of Environmental Quality.2005,16(2):153-160
    [115]Sarkis J,Dijkshoorn J.Eco-efficiency of solid waste management in Welsh SMEs [J].Environmentally Conscious Manufacturing.2005 (5997)
    [116]Nieuwlaar E,Warringa G,Brink C,et al.Supply curves for Eco-efficient Environmental Improvements Using Differeng Weighting Methods [J].Journal of Industrial Ecology,2005,9(4):85-96
    [117]Roland W.Scholz,Amim Wiek.Operational Eco-efficiency,Comparing Firm's Environmental Investments in Different Domains of Operation [J],Journal of Industrial Ecology.2005,9(4):155-170
    [118]Gavin Hilson.An Examination of Environmental Performance and Eco-efficiency in the North American Gold Mining Industry [D].University of Toronto.2000
    [119]Dahlstrom K,Ekins P.Eco-efficiency Trends in the UK Steel and Aluminum Industries:Differences between Resource Efficiency and Resource Productivity [J].Journal of Industrial Ecology.2005,9(4):171-188
    [120]Cramer J.Design for eco-efficiency within the chemical industry:The case of Akzo Nobel [J].Environmentally Conscious Design and Inverse Manufacturing,1999.
    [121]Morales M.A,Herrero V.M,Martinez S.A,et al.Cleaner Production and Methodological Proposal of Eco-efficiency Measurement in a Mexican Petrochemical Complex[J].Water Science & Technology.2006,153(11):11-16
    [122]Huppes G,Davidson M.D,Kuyper J,et al.Eco-efficient Environmental Policy in Oil and Gas Production in the Netherlands[J].Ecological Economics.2007(61):43-51
    [123]Golany B,Roll Y,Rybak D.Measuring Efficiency of Power Plants in lsrael by Data Envelopment Analysis[J].IEEE Transactions on Engeering Management.1994,41(3):291-301
    [124]Pekka J.Korhonen,Mikulas Luptacik.Eco-efficiency analysis of power plants:An extension of data envelopment analysis[J].European Journal of Operational Research.2004(154):437-446
    [125]Stevels A.Eco-efficiency of take-back systems of electronic products[C].Proceedings of the 1999IEEE International Symposium on Electronics and the Environment.Danvers,MA.1999.
    [126]Park J,Cha K,Hur T,et al.Tackling challenges in measuring and communicating eco-efficiency[C].Proceedings of the 2006 IEEE International Symposium on Electronics and the Environment.2006.
    [127]Christopher M.Logistics and supply chain management.Strategies for Reducing Cost and Improving Service[M],second ed.Financial Times/Prentice-Hall,London.1998
    [128]Michelsen O,Fet A.M,Dahlsrud A.Eco-efficiency in extended supply chains:A case study of furniture production[J].Journal of Environmental Management.2006,(79):290-297
    [129]D'Agosto M,Riberio S.K.Eco-efficiency Management Program(EEMP) - A model for Road Fleet Operation[R].Transportation Research Part D:Transport and Environment.2004,9(6):497-511
    [130]Breedveld L,Timellini G,Casoni G,et al.Eco-efficiency of fabric filters in the Italian ceramic tile industry[J].Journal of Cleaner Production.2007(15):86-93
    [131]Maxime D.Marcotte M.Arcand Y.Development of eco-efficiency indicators for the Canadian food and beverage industry[J].Journal of Cleaner Production.2006(14):636-648
    [132]Raymond Cote,Aaron Booth,Bertha Louis.Eco-efficiency and SMEs in Nova Scotia,Canada[J].Journal of Cleaner Production.2006(14):542-550
    [133]Welford R.Hijacking Environmentalism? - Corporate Reponses to Sustainable Development.In:Uihφi JP,Madsen H,editors.Industry and the Development:Practical Applications of Environmental Management Approaches in Business[M].Aarhus:The Aarhus School of Business.1996
    [134]Olli Salmi.Eco-efficiency and industrial symbiosis - a counterfactual analysis of a mining community[J].Journal of Cleaner Production.2007(15):1696-1705
    [135]Hinterberger Fr.,Bamberger K,Manstein Ch,et al.Eco-eficiency of regions:How to improve competitiveness and create jobs by reducing environmental pressure[R].Vienna:Sustainable Europe Research Institute(SERI).2000
    [136]Melanen M,Koskela S,Maenpaa I,et al.The Eco-efficiency of Regions - Case Kymenlaakso:ECOREG Project 2002-2004[J].Management of Environmental Quality.2004
    [137]Seppala J,Melanen M.How can the eco-efficiency of a region be measured and monitored[J].Journal of Industrial Ecology,2005,9(4):117-130
    [138]Mickwitz P,Melanen M,Rosenstrom U,et al.Regional eco-efficiency indicators-a participatory approach[J].Journal of Cleaner Production.2006,14:1603-1611
    [139]Hu.A.H,Shih S.H,Hsu C.W,et al.Eco-efficiency Evaluation of the Eco-industrial Cluster[J].Environmentally Conscious Design and Inverse Manufacturing.2005
    [140]商华,武春友.基于生态效率的生态工业园评价方法研究[J].大连理工大学学报(社会科学版).2007,28(2):25-29
    [141]World Business Council for Sustainable Development.Measuring Eco-efficiency:A Guide to reporting company performance [M].WBCSD.2000
    [142]UN(United Nations).A manual for the preparers and users of eco-efficiency indicators [R].United Nations Publication UNCTAD/ITE/IPC/.2003
    [143]Huppes G,Ishikawa M.Quantified Eco-efficiency:An introduction with applications [M].Springer.2007
    [144]Eik A,Steinmo S,Solem S,et al..Eco-efficiency in recycling systems-Evaluation methods and case studies for plastic packing [R].NTNU Industrial Ecology Program (IndEcol).2002.http://www.indecol.Nunu.no/
    [145]United Nations Conference on Trade and Development.Integrating Environmental and Financial Performance at the Enterprise level:A Methodology for Standardizing Eco-efficiency Indicators [C].United Nations Publication,2003
    [146]Bonne R.A.Eco-efficiency and performance strategies in construction and demolition waste recycling systems [D].Norwegian University of Science and Technology.2005
    [147]Huppes G,Ishikawa M.A framework for Quantified Eco-efficiency Analysis [J].Journal of Industrial Ecology.2005,9(4):25-41
    [148]Rebitzer,G.,D.Hunkeler,Life Cycle Costing in LCM:Amnitions,Opportunities,and Limitations.Discussing a Framework [J].International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment.2003(8),253-256
    [149]Rudenauer I,Gensch C.O,et al.Integrated environmental and economic assessment of products and processes:A method of eco-efficiency analysis [J].Journal of Industrial Ecology.2005.9 (4):105-116
    [150]Gaining,J.Peace by Peaceful Means:Peace and Conflict,Development and Civilization [M].London:SAGE.1996
    [151]Consoli F,Alen D,Boustead I.Guidelines for life-cycle assessment:A code of practice [M].SETAC.Pensacola,FL.1993
    [152]Guinee J.B,ed.Handbook on life cycle assessment.Operational guide to the ISO standards.Eco-efficiency in Industry and Science Series [M].Berlin:Springer-Verlag.2002 (7)
    [153]Udo de Haes,H.A.,G.Finnveden,M.Goedkoop,et al eds.Life-cycle impact assessment:Striving toward best practice [M].Pensacola,FL:SETAC Press.2002
    [154]Itsubo,N,lnaba A.A new LCIA method:LIME has been completed [J].International Journal of Life-Cycle Assessment.2003,8(5):305
    [155]UNEP-SETAC LCI (UN Environmental Programm-Society of Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry,Life-Cycle Initiative) [R].2005.
    [156]Saling P,Kicherer A,et al.Eco-efficiency analysis by BASF:The method [J].The International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment.2002,7(4):1-15
    [157]Hellweg S,Hofstetter T.B and Hungerbuhler K.Disscounting and the environment-Should current impacts be weighted differently than impacts harming future generations [J]? International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment.2003,8(1):8-18
    [158]Johanson P.Valuing environmental damage [J].Oxford Review of Economic Policy.1990(6):34-50
    [159]Garrod G,Willis K.G.Economic valuation of the environment:Methods and case studies [M].Northampton,MA:Edward Elgar.1999
    [160]Carson,R.T.Contingent valuation:A user's guide [J].Environmental Science and Technology.2000(34):1413-1418
    [161]Brookshire,D.S.,M.A.Thayer,W.D.Schulz and R.C.d'Arge.Valuing public goods:A comparison of surveys and hedonic approaches[J].American Economic Review.1982,72(1):165-177
    [162]Palmquist R.B.Hedonic models.In Handbook of environmental and resource economics,edited by J.van den Bergh[M].Northampton,/viA:Edward Etgar.1999
    [163]PIU(Performance and Innovation Unit).Resource productivity:Making more with less[M].London:The Cabinet Office.2001
    [164]Hoh H,Schoer K,Seibel S.Eco-efficiency indicators in German Environmental Economic Accounting[J].Statistical Journal of the United Nations.2002,(19):41-52
    [165]顾晓薇,王青.可持续发展的环境压力指标及其应用[M].冶金工业出版社.2005
    [166]Hashimoto S,Moriguchi Y.Proposal of six indicators of material cycles for describing society's metabolism:from the viewpoint of material flow analysis.Resources[J],Conservation and Recycling.2004,40(3):185-200
    [167]Hoffren J.Measuring the eco-efficiency of welfare generation in a national economy[D].Tampere University.2001
    [168]Morioka T,Tsunemi K,Yamamoto Y,et al.Eco-efficiency of Advanced Loop-closing Systems for Vehicles and Household Appliances in Hyogo Eco-town:A Case Study of Solid Waste Management [J].Journal of industrial Ecology.2005,9(4):205-221
    [169]Toshiba.Corporate Social Resposibility Report[R].2005
    [170]李广军,顾晓薇,王青,刘建兴,严欢欢.沈阳市高校生态足迹和生态效率研究[J].资源科学.2005,27(6):140-146
    [171]李兵,张建强,权进民.企业生态足迹和生态效率研究[J].环境工程.2007,25(6):85-88
    [172]Odum T.Environmental Accounting:Emergy and Environmental Decision Making[M].New York:Wilely,1996,15-163
    [173]李祚泳,沈仕伦,邓新民.社会、经济与环境协调发展指数评价模型.[J]上海环境科学.2000,19(5):201-204.
    []74]李双成,傅小锋,郑度.中国经济持续发展水平的能值分析[J].自然资源学报.2001,16(4):297-304.
    [175]Odum H T..Living with Complexity[J].In:Crafoord Prize in the Biosciences,Crefoord Lectures.Royal Swedish Academy of Science,Stockholm,1987:19-85
    [176]隋春花,蓝盛芳.广州城市生态系统能值分析研究[J].重庆环境科学.2001,23(5):4-6.
    [177]田龙.基于能值分析的工业园生态效率评价研究[D].大连理工大学.2005
    [178]商华.工业园生态效率测度与评价[D].大连理工大学.2007
    [179]Charnes A,Cooper W.W,Rhodes E.L.Measuring the efficiency of decision making units[J].European Journal of Operation Research.1978,2(6):429-444
    [180]魏权龄.数据包络分析[M].科学出版社.2004
    [181]朱乔.数据包络分析(DEA)方法综述与展望[J].系统工程理论方法应用.1994,3(4):1-9
    [182]吴文江.数据包络分析及其应用[M].中国统计出版社.2002
    [183]吴德胜.数据包络分析若干理论和方法研究[D].中国科学技术大学.2006
    [184]Criswell D.R,Thompson R.G.Data envelopment analysis of space and terrestrially-based large-scale commercial power systems for earth[J].Solar Energy..1996(56):119-131
    [185]Kao C,Chang P.L,Hwang S.N.Data Envelopment analysis in measuring the efficiency of forest managemem[J].Journal of Environmental Management.1993(38):73-83
    [186]Karkazis,1,Boffey B.Spatial organization of an industrial area:distribution of the environmental cost and equity policies[J].European Journal of Operational Research.1997(101 ):430-441
    [190]Lovell C.A.K,Pastor J.T,Turner J.A.Measuring macroeconomic performance in the OECD:a comparison of European and non-European countries[J].European Journal of Operational Research.1995(87):507-518
    [191]Thompson R.G,Singleton F.D,Thrall R.M,et al.Comparative site evaluations for locating a high-energy physics lab in Texas[J].Interface.1986(16):35-49
    [192]Yaisawarng S,Klein J.D.The effects of sulfur-dioxide controls on productivity change in the United States electric-power industry[J].Review of Economics and Statistics.1994(76):447-460
    [193]Ball V.E,Lovell C.A.K,Nehring R.F,et al.Incorporating undesirable outputs into models of production:An application to U.S.agriculture[J].Cashiers d'Economique et Sociologie Rurales.1994(31):59-73
    [194]Poit-Lepetit I,Vermersch D,Weaver R.D.Agriculture's environmental externalities:DEA evidence for French agriculture[J].Applied Economics.1997(29):331-338
    [195]Haynes K.E,Ratick S,Bowen W.M,et at.Environmental decision models:U.S.experience and a new approach to pollution management[J].Environment International.1993(19):261-275
    [196]Haynes K.E,R.atick S,Bowen W.M,el al.Toward a pollution abatement monitoring policy:Measurements,model mechanics,and data requirements[J].The Environmental Professional.1994(16):292-303
    [197]Sarkis J.Cordeiro J.An investigation of the relationship between environmental and financial performance of organizations[C].In:Neerly AD,Waggoner DB(eds) Conference Proceedings of Performance Measurement- Theory and Practice,Cambridge,U.K.1998
    [198]Tyteca D.On the measurement of environmental performance of firms- a literature-review and a productive efficiency perspective[J].Journal of Environmental Management.1996(46):281-308
    [199]王波,张群.环境约束下不同生产效率模型研究[J].系统工程理论与实践.2002(1):1-8
    [200]王波,张群,王飞.考虑环境因素的企业DEA有效性分析[J].控制与决策.2002,17(1):24-28
    [201]孙广生,冯宗宪,曾凡银.DEA在评价工业生产环境效率上的应用[J].安徽师范大学学报(自然科学版).2003,26(2):112-116
    [202]武玉英,何喜军.基于DEA方法的北京可持续发展能力评价[J].系统工程理论与实践.2006(31:117-123
    [203]Dyckhoff H,Allen K.Measuring ecological efficiency with data envelopment analysis[J].European Journal of Operational Research.2001(132):312-325
    [204]Sarkis J.Ecoefficiency:how data envelopment analysis can be used by managers and researchers[C].Proceedings of SPIE.2001(4193):194-203
    [205]Kuosmanen T,Kortelainen M.Measuring eco-efficiency of production with data envelopment analysis[J].Journal oflndustrial Ecology.2005,9(4):59-72
    [206]Hua Z.S,Bian Y.W,Liang L.Eco-efficiency analysis of paper mills along the Huai River:An extended DEA approach[J].Omega.2007(35):578-587
    [207]Vogtlander J.G,Bijma A.Communicating the eco-efficiency of products and services by means of eco-cost/value model[J].Journal of Cleaner Production.2002,10:57-67
    [208]Hellweg S,Doka G,et al.Assessing the Eco-efficiency of End-of-Pipe Technologies with the Environmental Cost Efficiency Indicator:A Case Study of Solid Waste Management[J].Journal of Industrial Ecology.2005,9(4):189-203
    [209]Hertwich E.G.Consumption and the rebound effect:An industrial ecology perspective[J].Journal of Industrial Ecology.2005,9(1-2):85-98
    [210]Jollands N,Lermit J.Aggregate eco-efficiency for New Zealand-a principal components analysis [J].Journal of Environmental Management.2004,73:293-305
    [211]Kuhndt,M.,von Geibler,J.and Eckermann,A.Developing a sectoral sustainability indicator set taking a stakeholder approach[C].The 10~(th) International Conference of the Greening of lndustry Network 23-26 June,2002,Goteborg,Sweden.http://www.gin2002.milijo.chalmers.se
    [212]World Business Council for Sustainable Development Sustainable Production and Consumption:A Business Perspective[R].Geneva:WBCSD,1996
    [213]GR1.S ustainability reporting guidelines.Global Reporting Initiative[R].http://www.globalreporting.org/guidelines/2002.asp.2002
    [214]Kolk,A.and Mauser,A.The evaluation of environmental management:from stage models to performance evaluation[J].Business Strategy and the Environment.2002(11):14-31
    [215]Hart,M.Guide to sustainable community indicators[M].2~(nd) ed.Massachusetts:Hart Environmental Data.1999
    [216]高吉喜.可持续发展理论探索-生态承载力理论、方法与应用[M].中国环境科学出版社,2001
    [217]郭秀锐,毛显强,冉圣宏.国内环境承载力研究进展[J].中国人口·资源与环境.2000.10(3):28-30
    [218]Arrow K,Bolin B,Costanza R.et al.Economic growth,carrying capacity,and the environment[J].Science.1995.268:520-521
    [219]许联芳,杨勋林,王克林等.生态承载力研究进展[J].生态环境.2006,15(5):111-116
    [220]Schneider D.The carrying capacity concept as a planning tool[J].Chicago:American Plaaning Association.1978,22-59
    [221]唐剑武,郭怀成,叶文虎.环境承载力及其在环境规划中的初步应用[J].中国环境科学.1997,17(1):6-9
    [222]彭再德,杨凯,王云.区域环境承载力研究方法初探[J].中国环境科学.1996,16(1):7-10
    [223]Wachernagel M,Rees W.Our ecological footprint:reducing human impact on the earth[J].Gabriola Island:New Society Publishers.1996:56-76
    [224]Barrett J,Vallack H,Jones A,et al.A material flow analysis and ecological footprint of York[J].York:Stockholm Environmental Institute.2003
    [225]徐中民,张志强,程国栋.甘肃省1998年生态足迹计算与分析[J].地理学报.2000,55(5):607-61
    [226]张志强,徐中民,程国栋等.中国西部12省(区市)的生态足迹[J].地理学报.2001,23(2):164-169
    [227]余丹林,毛汉英,高群.状态空间衡量区域承载状况初探-以环渤海地区为例[J].地理研究.2003.22(2):201-210
    [228]国家环保总局.清洁生产标准-石油炼制业[S].中华人民共和国环境保护行业标准HJ/T 125-2003
    [229]王宗军.综合评价的方法、问题及其研究趋势[J].管理科学学报.1998,1(1):73-79
    [230]苏为华.多指标综合评价理论与方法问题研究[D].厦门大学.2000
    [231]Charnes A,Cooper W.W.and Rhode E..Measuring the efficiency of decision making units[J].European Journal of Operational Research.1978(2):429-444
    [232]朱乔.数据包络模型与收益分析[J].系统工程学报.1993,8(2):54-60
    [233]申思平,张青山.用数据包络模型评价企业相对效率研究[J].沈阳工业大学学报.1998.20(1):82-84
    [234]陈世宗,赖邦传.基于DEA的企业绩效综合评价方法[J].系统工程.2005(6):97-104
    [235]Sarkis J.A methodological framework for evaluating environmentally conscious manufacturing programs[J].Computers & Industrial Engineering.1999(36):793-810
    [236]Taskin F,Zaim O.The role of international trade on environmental efficiency:a DEA approach[J].Economic Modeling.2001(18):1-17
    [237]Zofio J.L,Prieto A.Environmental efficiency and regulatory standards:the case of CO_2 emission from OECD industries[J].Resource and Energy Economics.2001(23):63-83
    [238]盛昭翰,朱乔,吴广谋.DEA理论、方法与应用[M].北京:科学出版社.1996
    [239]Chung Y.H,Fare K,Grosskopf S..Productivity and undesirable outputs:A directional distance function approach[J].Journal of Environmental Management.1997(51):229-240
    [240]卞亦文.基于DEA理论的环境效率评价方法研究[M].中国科学技术大学.2007
    [241]Seiford,L.M.,Zhu J..A response to comments on modeling undesirable factors in efficiency evaluation[J].European Journal of Operational Research.2005(161):579-581
    [242]Courcelle.C,Kastemont.M.P,Tyteca D,et al.Assessing the economic and environmental.performance of municipal solid waste collection and sorting programmes[J].Waste Management and Research.1998,16(3):253-263
    [243]宋金山,汪永辉,路献品.数据包络分析(DEA)模型在清洁生产评价中的应用[J].四川环境.2003,22(5):58-152
    [244]Golany B and Roll Y.An application procedure for DEA[J].Omega.1989(9):237-250

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700