用户名: 密码: 验证码:
物流服务供应链企业间管理控制机制研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
物流服务供应链(LSSC)是随着企业物流外包深入发展出现一种新兴的物流运作组织形式,对LSSC管理问题的研究也在过去十年中也取得了重要进展。然而,针对物流服务供应链管理控制问题的研究还极其有限。另一方面,作为供应链管理环境下的一个重要研究主题,企业间管理控制机制的理论研究还很不成熟,有着极大的理论拓展空间。因此,本文的研究不仅有着重要的现实意义,也具有一定的理论价值。
     首先,针对学术界出现的对LSSC内涵指代不一致的问题进行了分析,进一步明确了LSSC的组织构成,借鉴企业间管理控制模式类型分析的研究成果,定性分析并构建了LSSC企业间管理控制关系总体框架模型,分析得出了LSSC企业间管理控制机制研究的主要企业间管理控制关系,即:物流外包方(LO)与集成物流服务商(LSI)以及集成物流服务商(LSI)与伙伴物流服务分包商(LSS)两个层次的企业间管理控制。随后,根据企业间关系管理研究的基础理论及相关研究成果,提出了影响企业间管理控制的前因变量、控制手段变量、控制目标变量间作用关系的理论假设及概念模型。最后,利用LO对LSI以及LSI对伙伴LSS两层企业间管理控制问卷调查数据,进行了实证检验。研究发现:⑴交易内容的复杂度、供方能力、对供方的依赖度和合作经验是影响LSSC企业间管理控制手段选择四个主要前因变量,而四个前因变量对三种控制手段的影响却各不相同;⑵合同控制对制度控制有负向作用,对社会控制有正向作用;制度控制对社会控制的正向促进作用在物流外包中表现显著,在物流分包中不显著。⑶合同控制、制度控制及社会控制在LSSC两层企业间伙伴关系管理控制中均会对合作绩效产生显著的正向影响,但合同控制与制度控制在两层关系中的作用强度却有着较大差异。其中:在LO对LSI的管理控制中,制度控制对合作绩效的影响最强;而在LSI对LSS的管理控制中,合同控制对合作绩效的影响最大。⑷从两层管理控制关系的修正模型路径系数对比可知,合同控制和制度控制的不同组合所构成的正式控制对合作绩效的影响大于社会控制的影响。因此,企业间管理控制模式类型中的混合控制应该更多的是指合同控制与制度控制的不同组合,而不是正式控制与社会控制的不同组合。
     与己有的国内外相关研究相比,本文的创新之处体现在以下几点:
     ⑴构建了LSSC企业间管理控制关系总体框架模型。在对物流外包形态演变情况、LSSC的组织构成及企业间关系深入剖析的基础上,对LSSC企业间管理控制模式类型进行了定性分析,构建了LSSC企业间管理控制关系总体框架模型。这一理论成果有助于LSSC管理相关研究中对基本概念术语使用的规范化,也有助于对LSSC企业间管理控制基本概貌的认识。
     ⑵细化了正式控制的内涵,厘清了正式控制与社会控制的边界。从企业间管理控制的基准依据出发,识别并明确提出了制度控制是企业间正式控制的一种重要手段,从而将企业间管理控制手段中的正式控制分为了合同控制和制度控制,并与社会控制一起构成了企业间管理控制手段的三种基本形态。这一分类进一步明确了正式控制与社会控制的边界,细化并拓展了对企业间正式控制手段的认识。
     ⑶完善了企业间管理控制机制理论模型。用LSSC中的两层企业间管理控制的问卷调查数据,对本文提出的理论假设进行了检验,对构建的LSSC企业间管理控制机制模型进行了修正。由于模型在前因要素、控制手段及合作绩效三个方面均对已有的研究进行了一定的补充或细化。因此,除了对已有理论命题再次验证之外,本文也提出并实证检验了一系列新的理论命题。
     ⑷修正了对正式控制与社会控制之间的相互作用关系的争议性认识。已有研究结论中对正式控制与社会控制之间究竟是替代还是互补关系存在着争议,本文在明确区分出三种控制手段的基础上,用LSSC企业间管理控制的经验数据研究证实:“正式控制中的合同控制与制度控制在对合作绩效的影响中是替代关系”,而“正式控制与社会控制在对合作绩效的影响中是互补(正向促进)关系”。当然,这一结论还有待其他行业的企业间管理控制研究做出进一步的证实。
Logistics Service Supply Chain (LSSC) is a new form of supply chain emerged under theconditions of the rapid development of logistics outsourcing, and researches about LSSCmanagement has made great progress in the past decade. However, there has been extremelylimited research that studies for the management control of LSSC. On the other hand, theresearch of management control in interfirm relationships is still in its infancy, and there hasgreat theoretical space to be developed.
     As there were two Inconsistent interpretations about the meaning and structure of LSSCin previous literature, this paper first reanalyzed what is the really meaning and reasonablestructure of LSSC in according to the progress of logistics outsouring practice, thenconstructed an overall framework model of management control between LSSC enterprises.We extracted out two important levels of intefirm management control relationships in LSSCenterprises from this framework model, namely: logistics outsourcer (LO) with logisticsservice Integrator (LSI) and logistics service Integrator (LSI) with logistics servicesubcontractor (LSS). Subsequently, this paper proposed an interfirm management controlmechanism model between two levels enterprises in LSSC and a series of theoreticalassumptions. And then, we conducted structural equation modeling analysis with the surveydata of management control of LO to LSI and LSI to LSS.
     Empirical research gained four key findings. First, there are four main factors couldaffect the management control strategy of logistics buyer, they are transaction complexity,supplier’s capability, dependency to the supplier and the experience of cooperation, and theimpact of these four variables to contract control, institutional control and social control aredifferent; Second, the result shows that contract control has negative effect on institutionalcontrol and positive effect on social control. Institutional control has positive effect on socialcontrol in LO controls on LSI, but this effect is not significant in LSI controls on LSS. Third,the path coefficients in the revised structural model suggests contract control, institutionalcontrol, and social control all have significant positive effect on cooperation performance bothin the control relation of LO to LSI and LSI to LSS. As for the effect degree, institutional control is the strongest factor in the control of LO on LSI, and contract control is the strongestfactor in the control of LSI on LSS. Fourth, in general, the impact of formal controls oncooperative performance is greater than social control.
     The study has four main theoretical or managerial implications. First, we reanalyzed thestructure of LSSC in according to contradictory interpretation about the meaning and structureof LSSC in previous literature, then constructed an overall framework model of managementcontrol between LSSC enterprises based on interfirm management control patterns researchliteratures. This contribution may help us to clearly recognize the practical meaning of LSSCand lay a consolidate foundation to LSSC management-related researches. Obviously, thecontrol relationship of LO on LSI and LSI on LSS are the two most import relationship ofinterfirm management control relationship in LSSC.
     Second, we clearly proposed institutional control as one form of formal control measuresand extend the notion of formal control in interfirm management control into contract controland institutional control. This clarification not only offers insights on the operationalmeasurement of the concept of formal control and social control, but also paves the way toverify the dispute opinions on whether the relationship between formal control and socialcontrol is substitute or complement.
     Third, this paper extended the theoretical model of interfirm management controlmechanisms in review of previous studies, then tested this theoretical model by survey data oftwo levels of interfirm management in LSSC enterprises. Since most of the model elementsand theoretical hypotheses were proposed for the first time, the testing result gives out manynew conclusions to interfirm management control mechanism theory and offers concreteinsights to LSSC management.
     Fourth, based on the empirical analysis by interfirm management control date in LSSC,we found that institutional control is a substitute to contract control and social control is acomplement to formal control in achieving cooperation performance goals. These finding willhelp to revise the dispute about the relationship between formal control and social control.
引文
[1] Christopher M.Logistics and competitive strategy[J].European Management Journal,1993,11(2):258–261.
    [2] Fuller J B,O'Conor J&Rawlinson R.Tailored Logistics:the next advantage[J].Harvard BusinessReview,1993,71(3):87–97.
    [3] Sanders N R,Locke A,Moore C B,et al.A multidimensional framework for understandingoutsourcing arrangement[J].Journal of Supply Chain Management:A Global Review of Purchasing&Supply,2007,43(4):3–15.
    [4] Langley C J Jr.&Capgeminig.2012Third-party Logistics Study: The State of LogisticsOutsourcing[R/OL].[2011-12-15].http://www.3plstudy.com/downloads/2012-3pl-study/.
    [5] Lemoine W&Dagnaes L.Globalisation startegies and business organisation of a network of logisticsservice providers[J].International Journal of Physical Distribution&Logistics Management,2003,33(3):209–228.
    [6]田宇.物流服务供应链构建中的供应商选择研究[J].物流技术,2002,(4):21–26.
    [7]闫秀霞,孙林岩,王侃昌.物流服务供应链模式特性及其绩效评价研究[J].中国机械工程,2005,16(11):969–974.
    [8] K nn l T, Unruh G C&Carrillo H J. Prospective voluntary agreements for escapingtechno-institutional lock-in[J].Ecological Economics,2006,57(2):239–252.
    [9] Langley C J Jr.&Capgemini.2013Third-Party Logistics Study: The State of LogisticsOutsourcing [R/OL].[2013-4-19]. http://www.3plstudy.com.
    [10]中国仓储协会.第6次中国物流市场供需状况调查报告摘要[J].物流技术与应用,2005,(11):41–47.
    [11]刘伟,高志军.物流服务供应链:理论架构与研究范式[J].商业经济与管理,2012,246(4):19–25.
    [12] Anthony R N.Planning and Control Systems:A Framework for Analysis[M].Boston:HarvardUniversity Press,1965.
    [13] Simons R.Levers of Control:How Managers Use Innovative Control Systems to Drive StrategicRenewal[M].Boston:Harvard Business Press,1995.
    [14]张先治,顾水彬.管理控制研究主题与研究方法的变迁——国外A类期刊40年研究文献的回顾[J].经济管理,2011,31(12):173–184.
    [15] Ittner C D,Larcker D F,Nagar V,et al.Supplier selection,monitoring practices,and firmperformance[J].Journal ofAccounting&Public Policy,1999,18(3):253–281.
    [16] Carbone V&Stone M A.Growth and relational strategies used by the European logistics serviceproviders:Rationale and outcomes[J].Transportation Research Part E,2005,41(6):495–510.
    [17]杜胜利.没有控制系统就没有执行力—构建基于执行力的管理控制系统[J].管理世界,2004,(10):145–146.
    [18] Foster S T.质量管理:整合供应链(第4版)[M].何桢译.北京:中国人民大学出版社,2013.
    [19] Bienstock C C,Royne M B,Sherrell D,et al.An expanded model of logistics service quality:Incorporating logistics information technology [J].International Journal of Production Economics,2008,113(1):205–222.
    [20] Lai Kee-Hung,Wong C W Y&Cheng T C E.Acoordination-theoretic investigation of the impact ofelectronic integration on logistics performance[J].Information&Management,2008,45(1):10–20.
    [21] Turner W L&Stylianou A C.The IT advantage assessment model Applying an expanded value chainmodel to academia[J].Computers&Education,2004,43(3):249–272.
    [22] Lai Fujun,Li Dahui,Wang Qiang,et al.The information technology capability of third-partylogistics providers:A resource-based view and empirical evidence from china[J].Journal of SupplyChain Management,2008,44(3):22–38.
    [23]崔爱平,刘伟,张旭.LSSC的基本理论框架[J].上海海事大学学报,2008,(3):1–6.
    [24]高志军,刘伟.物流服务供应链集成管理的演化机制研究[J].物流工程与管理,2009,31(6):78–80.
    [25]刘伟华.物流服务供应链能力合作的协调研究[D].上海:上海交通大学,2007.6.
    [26] Klein R&Rai A.Interfirm strategic information flow in logistics supply chain relationships [J].MISQuarterly,2009,33(4):735–762.
    [27] Cui Lianguang&Hertz S.Networks and capabilities as characteristics of logistics firms[J].Industrial Marketing Management,2011,40(6):1004–1011.
    [28] Liu Weihua,Xie Dong&Xu Xuecai.Quality supervision and coordination of logistic servicesupply chain under multi-period conditions[J].International Journal of Production Economics,2013,142(2):353–361.
    [29] Liu Weihua,Liu Chunling&Ge Meiying.An order allocation model for the two-echelon logisticsservice supply chain based on cumulative prospect theory[J].Journal of Purchasing and SupplyManagement,2013,19(1):39–48.
    [30] van Hoek R I&Chong I.Epilogue: UPS logistics-practical approaches to the e-supply chain[J].International Journal of Physical Distribution&Logistics Management,2001,31(6):463–468.
    [31] Vitasek K. Supply Chain Management Terms and Glossary [R/OL].[2013-6-19].http://cscmp.org/sites/default/files/user_uploads/resources/downloads/glossary.pdf.
    [32]张辰彦.物流服务供应链协同问题探讨[J].科技与管理,2007,9(5):33–36.
    [33]陆永明.物流服务供应链协调研究综述[J].科技与管理,2010,12(1):106–109.
    [34]李毅斌,董千里,孙浩杰.基于流程管理的物流服务供应链运作协同研究[J].物流技术,2012,31(5):174–177.
    [35]刘伟华,葛美莹,谢冬等.基于ANP-Fuzzy方法的物流服务供应链流程对接绩效评价[J].武汉理工大学学报(交通科学与工程版),2012,36(6):1113–1117.
    [36]崔爱平.基于供应链契约的物流服务供应链能力优化与协调研究[D].上海:上海海事大学,2008.
    [37]田宇.面向信息甄别的第三方物流分包合同模型研究[J].软科学,2004,18(6):31–33.
    [38]田宇,杨秀苔,熊中楷.基于二层决策的第三方物流分包合同设计[J].重庆大学学报,2005,28(5):139–142.
    [39]田宇.第三方物流服务分包管理中的质量博弈行为研究[J].管理科学,2006,19(2):2–5.
    [40]王勇,罗富碧,林略.第四方物流努力水平影响的物流分包激励机制研究[J].中国管理科学,2006,14(2):136–140.
    [41]桂云苗,龚本刚,程幼明.需求不确定下物流服务供应链协调[J].计算机集成制造系统,2009,15(12):2412–2416,2438.
    [42]樊琦.物流服务供应链收益分享的变权激励模型[J].工业技术经济,2008,27(12):117–118.
    [43]孟丽君,黄祖庆.二级物流服务供应链的供应链契约选择研究[J].重庆大学学报(社会科学版),2012,18(3):64–72.
    [44] Wei S L.A lemons market? An incentive scheme to induce truth-telling in third party logisticsproviders [J].European Journal of Operational Research,2000,125(3):519–525.
    [45] Logan M S.Using agency theory to design successful outsourcing relationships [J].The InternationalJournal of Logistics Management,2000,11(2):21–32.
    [46]刘志学,许泽勇.基于非对称信息理论的第三方物流合作博弈分析[J].中国管理科学,2003,11(5):85–88.
    [47]田宇.基于Stackelberg主从对策Nash均衡下的TPL分包合同设计研究[J].管理工程学报,2005,19(4):100–103
    [48]彭本红,李太杰,周叶.物流外包的多阶段合约分析[J].中国管理科学,2006,14(SI):474–477.
    [49]彭本红,罗明,周叶.物流外包中的最优契约分析[J].软科学,2007,21(1):26–28,36.
    [50]吴庆.第三方物流服务提供商与客户企业的协调合同研究[D].重庆:重庆大学,2008.6.
    [51]李毅斌,董千里.考虑业务规模及经济环境的物流外包合同分析[J].统计与决策,2012,(9):56-58.
    [52]田宇,吴佩勋.物流服务供应链收益分享合同模型[J].科技管理研究,2006,(1):227–229.
    [53] Choy K L,Li Chung-Lun,So S C K,et al.Managing uncertainty in logistics service supplychain[J].International Joumal of Risk Assessment and Management,2007,7(l):19–43.
    [54]张德海,邵培基,刘德文.面向物流服务供应链的商业智能系统设计[J].管理学报,2007,4(3):288–292.
    [55]鄢飞.物流服务供应链的协同机理研究[D].西安:长安大学,2009.
    [56]高志军,刘伟,朱卫平等.客户企业奖惩下的LSCC安全和质量激励[J].上海海事大学学报,2012,33(3):46–51.
    [57]梁静.物流外包中的相关委托-代理模型研究[J].科技管理研究,2009,(8):337–340.
    [58]刘伟华,季建华,周乐.两级物流服务供应链任务分配模型[J].上海交通大学学报,2008,42(9):1524–1528,1533.
    [59]丁蕊.物流服务供应链的供应商选择与优化研究[D].大连:大连海事大学,2011.
    [60]王芝泉,刘晋浩.物流服务供应链任务分配问题研究[J].森林工程,2011,27(4):78–81.
    [61]刘伟华,曲思源,钟石泉.随机环境下的三级物流服务供应链任务分配[J].计算机集成制造系统,2012,18(2):381–388.
    [62]罗博,孙林岩,闫秀霞.一种考虑物流服务供应链可靠性的服务商数量确定研究[J].生产力研究,2003,(l):181–182.
    [63]张德海,刘德文.物流服务供应链的故障树分析及优化[J].统计与决策,2009,(14):175–177.
    [64]陈香,龚本刚,胡朝忠.物流服务供应链可靠性诊断的FTA模型及应用[J].计算机工程与应用,2012,48(29):243–248.
    [65]李阳珍,张喜征.基于Markov过程的物流服务供应链可靠性分析[J].重庆交通大学学报(自然科学版),2012,31(4):895–899.
    [66]李丹,张蕾.物流服务供应链整合的风险来源分析[J].中国储运,2010,(4):86–87.
    [67]高志军,刘伟.物流服务供应链风险管理模型研究[J].商业时代,2010,(9):29–30.
    [68]王勇,姜意扬,邓哲锋.不确定环境下的物流服务供应链风险分析[J].商业研究,2011,(7):179–184.
    [69]李倩,张圣忠,吴群琪.物流服务供应链中违约风险形成机理探析[J].经济与管理,2010,24(6):61–64.
    [70]张圣忠,李倩,吴群琪.基于隐马尔可夫模型的物流企业客户违约风险评估[J].财经理论与实践,2010,31(165):113–116.
    [71]李倩,张圣忠.第三方物流企业自身违约风险评估模型[J].西北农林科技大学学报(社会科学版),2010,10(4):68–72.
    [72]田宇.物流服务供应链构建中的供应商选择研究[J].系统工程理论与实践,2003,(5):49–53.
    [73]丁蕊,陈燕,刘树勇.基于物流服务供应链模式的供应商选择研究[J].物流科技,2009,(11):40–42.
    [74]郭梅,朱金福.基于模糊粗糙集的物流服务供应链绩效评价[J].系统工程,2007,25(7):48–52.
    [75]倪霖,王伟鑫.基于灰色AHP的物流服务供应链绩效评价研究[J].计算机工程与应用,2011,47(32):236–238,248.
    [76]霍红,林青.基于灰关联熵的物流服务供应链绩效评价[J].物流工程与管理,2012,34(9):67–70.
    [77]刘伟华,周丽珍,刘春玲等.基于网络层次分析方法的物流服务供应链综合绩效评价[J].工业工程,2011,14(4):52–57.
    [78] Giglioni G B&Bedeian AG.A conspectus of management control theory:1900-1972[J].Academyof Management Journal,1974,17(2):292–305.
    [79][法]法约尔.工业管理与一般管理[M].周安华译.北京:中国社会科学出版社,1982:119–122.
    [80] Carenys J.Management Control Systems:A Historical Perspective [J].International Journal ofEconomy,Management and Social Sciences,2012,1(1):1–18.
    [81]罗伯特·安东尼,维杰伊·戈文达拉杨.管理控制系统(12版)[M].刘霄仑,朱晓辉译.北京:人民邮电出版社,2011:6–7.
    [82] Ouchi W G.A Conceptual Framework for the Design of Organizational Control Mechanisms [J].Management Science,1979,25(9):833–848.
    [83] Eisenhardt K M.Control:Organizational and Economic Approaches [J].Management Science,1985,31(2):134–149.
    [84] Nooteboom B.Inter-firmAlliances:Analysis and Design[M].London:Routledge,1999.
    [85]秦晓.组织控制、市场控制:公司治理结构的模式选择和制度安排[J].管理世界,2003,(4):1–8.
    [86]张先治,顾水彬.西方管理控制学派梳理与观点评述[J].审计与经济研究,2012,27(1):79–89.
    [87] Simons R.Control in an Age of Empowerment[J].Harvard Business Review,1995,March-April:80–88.
    [88] Kloot L.Organizational learning and management control systems:responding to environmentalchange [J].Management Accounting Research,1997,8(1):47–73.
    [89] Fisher J.Contingency-based research on management control systems:categorisation by level ofcomplexity [J].Journal ofAccounting Literature,1995,14:24–53.
    [90] Lebas M&Weigenstein J.Management Control:The Roles of Rules,Markets and Culture[J].Journal of Management Studies,1986,23(3):259–272.
    [91] Das T K&Teng B-S.Between Ttrust and Control:Developing Confidence in Partner Cooperation inAlliances[J].Academy of Management Review,1998,233(3):491–512.
    [92] Speklé R F. Explaining management control structure variety: A transaction cost economicsperspective [J].Accounting, Organizations and Society,2001,26(4/5):419–441.
    [93] Ouchi W G&Maguire M A.Organizational Control:Two Functions [J].Administrative ScienceQuarterly,1975,20(4):559–569.
    [94] Caglio A&Ditillo A. A review and discussion of management control in inter-firm relationships:Achievements and future directions[J].Accounting,Organizations and Society,2008,33(7/8):865–898.
    [95] Kallunki J-P, Laitinen E K&Silvola H. Impact of enterprise resource planning systems onmanagement control systems and firm performance[J]. International Journal of AccountingInformation Systems,2011,12(1):20–39.
    [96] Otley D. Budgetary use and managerial performance[J].Journal ofAccounting Research,1978,16(1):122–149.
    [97] Otley D.The contingency theory of management accounting:Achievement and prognosis [J].Accounting, Organizations and Society,1980,5(4):413–428.
    [98] Rotch W.Management Control Systems:One View of Components and their Interdependence [J].British Journal of Management,1993,4(3):191–203.
    [99] Malmi T&Brown D A.Management control systems as a package—Opportunities,challenges andresearch directions[J].Management Accounting Research,2008,19(4):287–300.
    [100] Sandelin M.Operation of management control practices as a package—A case study on controlsystem variety in a growth firm context [J].Management Accounting Research,2008,19(4):324–343.
    [101]何晴,张黎群.组织间管理控制模式与机制评价[J].外国经济与管理,2009,31(10):47–53.
    [102] Williamson O E.The Economics of Organization:The Transaction Cost Approach[J].TheAmerican Journal of Sociology,1981,87(3):548–577.
    [103]林向红,李垣,吴海滨.组织间学习及其控制模式与企业创新关系的实证研究[J].现代管理科学,2008,(10):15–17.
    [104] Smith K G,Carroll S J&Ashford S J.Intra-and inter-organizational cooperation:Toward a researchagenda[J].Academic Management Journal,1995,38(1):7–23.
    [105] Inkpen A C&Currall S C.The Coevolution fo Trust,Control,and Learning in Joint Ventures[J].Organization Science,2004,15(5):586–599.
    [106] Carson S J,Madhok A&Wu T.Uncertainty,opportunism,and governance:the effects of volatilityand ambiguity on formal and relational contracting [J].Academy of Management Journal,2006,49(5):1058–1077.
    [107]李垣,陈浩然,赵文红.组织间学习、控制方式与自主创新关系研究—基于两种技术差异情景的比较分析[J].科学学研究,2008,26(1):199–204.
    [108] Li Yuan,Xie En&Teo Hock-Hai,et al..Formal control and social control in domestic andinternational buyer-supplier[J].Journal of Operations Management,2010,28(4):333–344.
    [109] Doz Y.The evolution of cooperation in strategic alliances:Initial conditions or learning processes?[J].Strategic Management Journal,1996,17(Summer Special Issue):55–84.
    [110] Makhija M V&Ganesh U.The relationship between control and partner learning in learning-relatedjoint ventures[J].Organization Science,1997,8(5):508–520.
    [111] Deakin S&Wilkinson F.Contract law and the economics of interorganizational trust [M].//Lane C,Bachmann R. Trust Within and Between Orgniaztions: Conceptual issues and empiricalapplications,Oxford,U. K.:Oxford University Press,1998:146–172
    [112] MBA智库百科.机制(Mechanism)[EB/OL].[2013.7.19]. http://wiki.mbalib.com/wiki/机制.
    [113]马占杰.对组织间关系的系统分析:基于治理机制的角度[J].中央财经大学学报,2010,(9):86–90.
    [114]董千里.高级物流学[M].北京:人民交通出版社,2006:2–3.
    [115] Aoyama Y&Ratick S J.Trust,Transaction,and Information Technologies in the U.S. LogisticsIndustry [J].Economic Geography,2007,83(2):159–180.
    [116] Hertz S&Alfredsson M.Strategic development of third party logistics providers [J].IndustrialMarketing Management,2003,32(2):139–149.
    [117] Andersson D&Norrman A.Procurement of logistics services—a minutes work or a multi-yearproject [J]? European Journal of Purchasing&Supply Management,2002,8(1):3–14.
    [118] Hsiao H I,Kemp R,Vorst J,et al..A classification of logistic outsourcing levels and their impacton service performance:Evidence from the food processing industry [J]. International Journal ofProduction Economics,2010,124(1):75–86.
    [119] Bask A H. Relationships among TPL providers and members of supply chains–A strategicperspective[J].Journal of Business&Industrial Marketing,2001,16(6):470–486.
    [120] Mentzer J,Min S&Zacharia Z.The nature of inter-firm partnering in supply chain management[J].Journal of Retailing,2000,76(4):549–568.
    [121]刘小群,马士华.供应链战略性物流外包中的界面管理研究[J].工业工程与管理,2005,(6):83–88.
    [122] Kelly B&Berger S.Interface management:Effective communication to improve process safety [J].Journal of Hazardous Materials,2006,130(3):321–325.
    [123]李毅斌,董千里,孙浩杰.物流服务质量测评及管理研究评述[J].物流技术,2012,31(4):14–17.
    [124]汪应洛.系统工程(第3版)[M].北京:机械工业出版社,2006:12–30.
    [125]李毅斌,董千里,孙浩杰.物流服务供应链管理控制体系框架研究[J].华东经济管理,2012,26(9):55–58.
    [126] Selviaridis K&Spring M.The dynamics of business service exchanges: Insights from logisticsoutsourcing [J]. Journal of Purchasing&Supply Management,2010,16(3):171–184.
    [127] Sánchez J M,et al.Do suppliers' formal controls damage distributors' trust [J]? Journal of BusinessResearch,2012,65(7):896–906.
    [128] Heide J B.Inter-organizational Governance in marketing channels [J].Journal of Marketing,1994,58(January):71–85.
    [129] Williamson O E.Markets and hierarchies:Analysis and antitrust implication[M].New York:FreePress,1975.
    [130] Williamson O E.Transaction cost economics:the governance of contractual relations[J].Journalof Law and Economics,1979,22(2):233–261.
    [131] Williamson O E. The economic institution of capitalism:Firms, Markets, Relational Contracting
    [M].New York:Free Press,1985.
    [132] Heide J B&John G.Allinaces in industrial purchasing:The detemrinants of joint action inbuyer-supplier relationships [J].Journal of Marketing Research,1990,27(1):24–36.
    [133] Dyer J H&Chu W.The role of trustworthiness in reducing transaction costs and imporvingperformance:Empirical evidence from the United States,Japan and Koera[J].OrganizationScience,2003,14(1):57–68.
    [134] Williamson O E. Comparative economic organization: The analysis of discrete Structuralalternatives[J].Administrative Science Quarterly,1991,36(2):269–296.
    [135] Williamson O E.The mechanisms of governance[M].New York:Oxford University Press,1996.
    [136] Doz Y L&Prahalad C K.Managing DMNCs:A search f or a new paradigm[J].StrategicManagement Journal,1991,12(S1):145-164.
    [137] Gulati R.Allinaces and networks[J].Strategic Management Journal,1998,19:293–317.
    [138] Blois K.Transaction costs and networks [J].Strategic Management Journal,1990,11(6):493–496.
    [139] Zajac E J&Olsen C P.Form transaction cost to transactional value analysis:Implications for thestudy of interorganizational srtategies[J].Journal of Management Studies,1993,30(1):131–145.
    [140]张维迎.博弈论与信息经济学[M].上海:格致出版社,上海三联书店,上海人民出版社,2004.
    [141]杨蕙馨,冯文娜.中间性组织研究[M].北京:经济科学出版社,2008.
    [142]李毅斌,董千里.网络组织的概念、核心判定指标及分类探析[J].中国商贸,2011,(35):251–252.
    [143] Chen H&Chen T-J. Governance structures in strategic alliances: transaction cost versusresource-based perspective[J].Journal of World Business,2003,38(1):1–14.
    [144]蔡会明.在华国际合资企业中母公司控制与绩效关系研究—基于资源基础论的视角[D].上海:复旦大学,2007.
    [145]巫景飞.企业战略联盟:动因、治理与绩效一基于我国企业的经验研究[D].上海:复旦大学,2005.
    [146] Wernerfelt B.Aresource-based view of the firm[J].Strategic Management Journal,1984,5(2):171–180.
    [147] Barney J. Firm resources and sustained competitive advantage[J]. Strategic Journal ofManagement,1991,17(1):99–120.
    [148] Das T K&Teng B-S. A Resource-Based Theory of Strategic Alliances[J]. Journal ofManagement,2000,26(1):31–61.
    [149] Gulati R.Social structure and alliance formation pattern:Alongitudinal analysis[J].AdministrativeScience Quarterly,1995,40(4):619–652.
    [150] Lambe C J, Wittmann C M&Spekman R E. Social exchange theory and research onbusiness-to-business relational exchange [J].Journal of Business-to-Business Marketing,2001,8(3):1–36.
    [151] Heide J B&John G.Do norms matter in marketing relationships[J].Journal of Marketing,1992,56(4):32–44.
    [152] Gulati R&Singh H. The Architecture of Cooperation: Managing Coordination Costs andAppropriation Concerns in Strategic Alliances[J].Administrative Science Quarterly,1998,43(4):781–814.
    [153] Lambert D M&Cooper M C.Issues in Supply Chain Management[J].Industrial MarketingManagement,2000,29(1):65–83.
    [154]邱泽奇.社会学是什么[M].北京:北京大学出版社,2005.
    [155]罗力.信任和关系承诺对第三方物流整合与绩效的影响[D].广州:华南理工大学,2010.
    [156]彼得M布劳.社会生活中的交换和权力[M].李国武译.北京:商务印书馆,2008.
    [157]乔纳森H特纳.社会学理论的结构[M].邱泽奇,张茂元译.北京:华夏出版社,2008.
    [158] Wilson D T.An integrated model of buyer–seller relationships[J].Journal of the Academy ofMarketing Science,1995,23(4):335–345.
    [159] Morgan R M&Hunt S D.Relationship-based competitive advantage:The role of relationshipmarketing in marketing strategy[J].Journal of Business Research,1997,46(3):281–290.
    [160] Luo X.Trust production and privacy concerns on the internet:A framework based on relationshipmarketing and social exchange theory[J].Industrial Marketing Management,2002,31(2):111-118.
    [161] Ferguson R J,Paulin M&Bergeron J.Contractual governance,relational governance and theperformance of interfirm service exchanges:The influence of boundary-spanner closeness[J].Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science,2005,33(2):217–234.
    [162] Kingshott R P J. The impact of psychological contracts upon trust and commitment withinsupplier-buyer relationships:A social exchange view [J].Industrial Marketing Management,2006,35(6):724–739.
    [163] Zhao X,Huo B, Flynn B B,et al.The impact of power and relationship commitment on theintegration between manufacturers and customers in a supply chain[J]. Journal of OperationsManagement,2008(26):368–388.
    [164] Sobrero M,Schrader S.Structuring inter-firm relationships:a meta-analytic approach [J].Organization Studies,1998,19(4):585–615.
    [165] Dekker H C.Control of inter-organizational relationships:evidence on appropriation concerns andcoordination requirements[J].Accounting,Organizations and Society,2004,29(1):27–49.
    [166] Grandori A. An organizational assessment of interfirm coordination modes[J]. OrganizationStudies,1997,18(6):897–925.
    [167] Ireland R D, Hitt M A&Vaidyanath D. Alliance management as a source of competitiveadvantage[J].Journalof Management,2002,28(3):413–446.
    [168] Tomkins C.Interdependencies,trust and information in relationships,alliances and networks[J].Accounting,Organizations and Society,2001,26(2):161–191.
    [169]陈雨田.价值网络中不同竞合结构下的关系治理模式及绩效研究[D].上海:上海交通大学,2012.
    [170] Langfield-Smith K&Smith D. Management control systems and trust in outsourcingrelationships[J].ManagementAccounting Research,2003,14(3):281–307.
    [171] Nelson P.Information and Consumer Behavior[J].Journal of Polotical Economy,1970,78(2):311–329.
    [172] Nelson P.Advertising as Information[J].Journal of Polotical Economy,1974,82(4):729–754.
    [173] Darby M R&Karni E.Free Competition and the Optimal Amount of Fraud [J].Journal of Lawand Economics,1973,16(1):67–88.
    [174] Anderson E&Weitz B.Determinants of continuity in conventional industrial channel dyads [J].Marketnig Seience,1989,8(4):310–323.
    [175] Ganesan S.Determinanst of Long-Term Orientation in Buyer-Seller Relationships [J].Journal ofMarketing,1994,58(2):1–19.
    [176] Doney P M&Cannon J P. An Examination of the Nature of Turst in Buyer-SellerRelationships[J].Journal of Makreting,1997,61(2):35–51.
    [177] Selnes F.Antecedents and consequences of trust and satisfaction in buyer-seller relationships [J].European Journal of Marketing,1998,32(3):305–322.
    [178] Neumann K.Ex ante governance decisions in inter-organizational relationships: A case study inthe airline industry[J].Management Accounting Research,2010,21(4):220–237.
    [179] Chen J V,Yen D C,Rajkumar T M,et al..The antecedent factors on trust and commitment insupply chain relationships[J].Computer Standards&Interfaces,2011,33(3):262–270.
    [180] Kale P,Singh H&Perlmutter H.Learning and Protection of Proprietary Assets in StrategicAlliances:Building Relational Capital [J].Strategic Management Journal,2000,21(3):217–237.
    [181] Contractor F J,Ra W.How knowledge attributes influence alliance governance choices:A theorydevelopment note[J].Journal of International Management,2002,8(1):11–27.
    [182] Nielsen B B.Strategic fit,contractual,and procedural governance in alliances [J].Journal ofBusiness Research,2010,63(7):682–689.
    [183] Lambe C J, Wittmann C M&Spekman R E. Social exchange theory and research onbusiness-to-business relational exchange [J].Journal of Business-to-Business Marketing,2001,8(3):1–36.
    [184] Achrol R S&Gundlach G T.Legal and social safeguards against opportunism in exchange [J].Journal of Retailing,1999,75(1):107–123.
    [185] Deeds D L&Hill C W L.An examination of opportunistic action within research alliances:Evidence from the biotechnology industry[J].Journal of Business Venturing,1999,14(2):141–163.
    [186] Lai C S,Liu S S,Yang C F,et al..Governance mechanisms of opportunism:Integrating fromtransaction cost analysis and relational exchange theory[J].Taiwan Academy of ManagementJournal,2005,5(1):1–24.
    [187] Goodman P S&Leyden D P. Familiarity and group productivity[J]. Journal of AppliedPsychology,1991,76(4):578–586.
    [188] McAllister D J.Affect-and Cognition-based Trust as Foundations for Interpersonal Cooperation inOrganizations [J].Academy of Management Journal,1995,38(1):24–59.
    [189] Uzzi B.Social Structure and Competition in Interfirm Networks:The Paradox of Embeddedness[J].Administrative Science Quarterly,1997,42(1):37–69.
    [190]杨静.供应链内企业间信任的产生机制及其对合作的影响—基于制造业企业的研究[D].杭州:浙江大学,2006.
    [191] Dyer J H&Chu W.The determinants of trust in supplier-automaker relationships in the U.S.,Japan and Korea [J].Journal of International Business Studies,2000,31(2):259–285.
    [192] van der Meer-Kooistra J&Vosselman E G J.Management control of interfirm transactionalrelationships:the case of industrial renovation and maintenance [J].Accounting,Organizations andSociety,2000,25(1):51–77.
    [193] Mahama H. Management control systems, cooperation and performance in strategic supplyrelationships:A survey in the mines[J].Management Accounting Research,2006,17(3):315–339.
    [194] Gietzmann M B.Incomplete contracts and the make or buy decision:Governance design andattainable flexibility [J].Accounting,Organizations and Society,1996,21(6):611–626.
    [195] Nooteboom B,Berger H&Noorderhaven H G.Effects of trust and governance on relational risk[J].Academy of Management Journal,1997,40(2):308–338.
    [196] Inkpen A C&Currall S C.The Coevolution of Trust,Control,and Learning in Joint Ventures [J].Organization Science,2004,15(5):586–599.
    [197] Ferreira A,Otley D.The design and use of performance management systems:An extendedframework for analysis[J].Management Accounting Research,2009,20(4):263–282.
    [198] Stevens J.Integrating the supply chain[J].International Journal of Physical Distribution andMaterials Management,1989,19(8):3–8.
    [199] Tan K C,Kannan V R&Handfield R B.Supply chain management:supplier performance and firmperformance[J].International Journal of Purchasing and Materials Management,1998,summer:2–9.
    [200] Sanders N R.Pattern of information technology use:the impact on buyer–suppler coordination andperformance[J].Journal of Operations Management,2008,26(3):349–367.
    [201] Krause D R,Handfield R B&Tyler B B.The relationships between supplier development,commitment,social capital accumulation and performance improvement [J].Journal of OperationsManagement,2007,25(2):528–545.
    [202] Villena V H,Revilla E&Choi T Y.The dark side of buyer–supplier relationships:A social capitalperspective [J].Journal of Operations Management,2011,29(6):561–576.
    [203] Cousins P D,Handfield R B,Lawson B,et al..Creating supply chain relational capital:the impactof formal and informal socialization processes[J].Journal of Operations Management,2006,24(6):851–863.
    [204] Lawson B,Tyler B B&Cousins P D.Antecedents and consequences of social capital on buyerperformance improvement[J].Journal of Operations Management,2008,26(3):446–460.
    [205] Im G,Rai A.Knowledge sharing ambidexterity in long-term interorganizational relationships[J].Management Science,2008,54(7):1281–1296.
    [206] Sanders N R.Pattern of information technology use:the impact on buyer–suppler coordination andperformance[J].Journal of Operations Management,2008,26(3):349–367.
    [207] Carey S,Lawson B&Krause D R.Social capital configuration, legal bonds and performance inbuyer–supplier relationships[J].Journal of Operations Management,2011,29(4):277–288.
    [208] Stank T P,Goldsby T J,Vickery S,et al..Logistics Service Performance:Estimating its Influenceon Market Share[J].Journal of Business Logistics,2003,24(1):27–55.
    [209]张延锋.战略联盟中信任、控制对合作风险的影响及其组合绩效研究[D].西安:西安交通大学,2003.
    [210] Spralls III S A, Hunt S D&Wilcox J B.Extranet Use and Building Relationship Capital inInterfirm Distribution Networks:The Role of Extranet Capability [J].Journal of Retailing,2011,87(1):59–74.
    [211] Liu Y, Luo Y D&Liu T. Governing buyer–supplier relationships through transactional andrelational mechanisms: Evidence from China[J].Journal of Operations Management,2009,27(4):294–309.
    [212] Parkhe A.“Messy” Research,Methodological Predisposition,and Theory Development inInternational Joint Ventures[J].Academy of Management Review1993,18(2):227–268.
    [213] Williamson O E.Strategy research:governance and competence perspectives [J].StrategicManagement Journal,1999,20(12):1087–1168.
    [214] Lusch R F&Brown J R.Interdependency,contracting,and relational behavior in marketingchannels [J].Journal of Marketing,1996,60(4):19–38.
    [215] Wathne K H&Heide J B. Opportunism in interfirm relationships: forms, outcomes, andsolutions[J].Journal of Marketing,2000,64(4):36–51.
    [216] Granovetter M.Economic action and social structure: the problem of embeddedness [J].AmericanJournal of Sociology,1985,91(3):481–510.
    [217] Brown J R,Dev C S&Lee D J.Managing marketing channel opportunism:the efficacy ofalternative governance mechanisms[J].Journal of Marketing,2000,64(2):51–65.
    [218] Rokkan A I, Heide J B&Wathne K H. Specific investment in marketing relationships:expropriation and bonding effects[J].Journal of Marketing Research,2003,40(2):210–224.
    [219] Rokkan A I,Heide J B&Wathne K H. Specific investments in marketing relationships:Expropriation and bonding effects[J].Journal of Marketing Research,2003,40(2):210–224.
    [220] Dekker H C.Partner selection and governance design in interfirm relationships [J].Accounting,Organizations and Society,2008,33(7/8):915–941
    [221] Kim K K,Park S-H,Ryoo S Y&Park S K.Inter-organizational cooperation in buyer–supplierrelationships:Both perspectives[J].Journal of Business Research,2010,63(8):863–869.
    [222] Paulraj A,Lado AA&Chen I J.Inter-organizational communication as a relational competency:Antecedents and performance outcomes in collaborative buyer-supplier relationships[J].Journal ofOperations Management,2008,26(1):45–64.
    [223] Uzzi B.Social structure and competition in interfirm networks:The paradox of embeddedness[J].Administrative Science Quarterly,1997,42(1):37–69.
    [224] Dyer J H&Singh H.The relational view:cooperative strategy and sources of interorganizationalcompetitive advantage[J].Academy of Management Review,1998,23(4):660–679.
    [225] Luo Y.Contract,cooperation,and performance in international joint ventures [J].StrategicManagement Journal,2002,23(10):903–920.
    [226] Poppo L,Zenger T.Do formal contracts and relational governance function as substitutes orcomplements?[J].Strategic Management Journal,2002,23(8):707–725.
    [227] Stouthuysen K,Slabbinck H&Roodhooft F.Controls,service type and perceived supplierperformance in interfirm service exchanges[J].Journal of Operations Management,2012,30(5):423–435.
    [228]荣泰生.企业研究方法[M].北京:中国税务出版社,2005.
    [229]孙国强.管理研究方法(1版)[M].上海:格致出版社,2010.
    [230]陈晓萍,徐淑英,樊景立.组织与管理研究的实证方法(2版)[M].北京:北京大学出版社,2012.
    [231] Tangpong C,Hung K-T&Ro Y K.The interaction effect of relational norms and agentcooperativeness on opportunism in buyer–supplier relationships[J]. Journal of OperationsManagement,2010,28(5):398–414.
    [232] JoshiAW&Arnold S J.How relational norms affect compliance in industrial buying [J].Journalof Business Research,1998,41(2):105–114.
    [233] Provan K G&Skinner S J. Interorganizational dependence and control as predictors ofopportunism in dealer–supplier relations[J].Academy of Management Journal1989,32(1):202–212.
    [234] Jap S D&Anderson E.Safeguarding interorganizational performance and continuity under ex postopportunism[J].Management Science,2003,49(12):1684–1701.
    [235] Mohr J&Spekman R.Characteristics of Partnership Success:Partnership Attributes [J].StrategicManagement Journal,1994,15(2):135–152.
    [236] Knemeyer A M,Corsi T M&Murphy P R.Logistics Outsourcing Relationships:CustomerPerspectives[J].Jounal of Business Logistics,2003,24(1):77–109.
    [237] Lyons B&Mehta J.Contracts,opportunism,and trust:self interest and social orientation [J].Cambridge Journal of Economics,1997,21(2):239–257.
    [238] Lusch R F,Brown J R.Interdependency,contracting,and relational behavior in marketingchannels [J].Journal of Marketing,1996,60(4):19–38.
    [239] Cavusgil S T,Deligonul S&Zhang C.Curbing foreign distributor opportunism:An examinationof trust,contracts,and the legal environment in international channel relationships [J].Journal ofInternational Marketing,2004,12(2):7–27.
    [240] Ring P S,Van de Ven A H.Structuring cooperative relationships between organizations [J].Strategic Management Journal,1992,13(7):483–498.
    [241] Balakrishnan S,Koza M P.Information asymmetry,adverse selection and joint ventures:Theoryand evidence [J].Journal of Economic Behavior&Organization,1993,20(1):99–117.
    [242] Lui S S, Wong Y-Y&Liu W. Asset specificity roles in interfirm cooperation: Reducingopportunistic behavior or increasing cooperative behavior?[J].Journal of Business Research,2009,62(11):1214–1219.
    [243] van Hoek R I.The Purchasing and Control of Supplementary Third-Party Logistics Services [J].The Journal of Supply Chain Management,2000,36(4):14–26.
    [244] Peng M W,Sun S L,Pinkham B&Chen H.The institution-based view as a third leg for a strategytripod [J].Academy of Management Perspectives,2009,23(4),63–81.
    [245]周浩,龙立荣.共同方法偏差的统计检验与控制方法[J].心理科学进展,2004,12(6):942–950.
    [246]梁建,樊景立.理论构念的测量[M]//陈晓萍,徐淑英,樊景立.组织与管理研究的实证方法(2版).北京:北京大学出版社,2012.
    [247] Flynn B B,Sakakibara S,Schroeder R G,et al..Empirical research methods in operationsmanagement [J].Journal of Operations Management,1990,9(2):250–284.
    [248] Gerbing D W, Anderson J C. An Updated Paradigm for Scale Development IncorporatingUnidimensionality and Its Assessment[J].Journal of Marketing Research,1998,25(5):186–192.
    [249] Bagozzi R P,Yi Y.On the Evaluation of Structural Equation Models[J].Academy of MarketingScience,1988,16(1):74–94.
    [250] O'Leary-Kelly S W,Vokurka R J.The empirical assessment of construct validity [J].Journal ofOperations Management,1998,16(4):387–405.
    [251] Hair J F,Anderson R E,Tatham R L,et al..Multivariate data analysis (5th Ed.)[M].UK:PrenticeHall International,1998.
    [252]吴明隆.统计应用实务[M].北京:科学出版社,2003.
    [253]卢纹岱.SPSS for Windows统计分析[M].北京:电子工业出版社,2002.
    [254] Schwab D P. Construct validity in organizational behavior[J]. Research in OrganizationalBehavior,1980,2:3–43..
    [255] Fornell C,Larcker D F.Evaluating structural equation models with unobserved variables andmeasurement error[J].Journal of Marketing Research,1981,18(1):39–50.
    [256]侯杰泰,温忠麟,成子娟.结构方程模型及其应用[M].北京:教育科学出版社,2004.
    [257] Anderson J C, Gerbing D W. Structural Equation Modeling in Practice: A Review andRecommended Two-Step Approach[J].Psychological Bulletin,1988,103(3):411–423.
    [258]黄芳铭.结构方程模式理论与应用[M].北京:中国税务出版社,2005.
    [259] Garver M S,Mentzer J T.Logistics research methods:Employing structural equation modeling totest for construct validity[J].Journal of Business Logistics,1999,20(1):33–57.
    [260] Mentzer J T,Flint D J,Kent J L.Developing a logistics service quality scale[J].Journal ofBusiness Logistics,1999,20(1):9–32.
    [261] Parasuraman A,Zeithaml V A&Berry L L.A Conceptual Model of Service Quality and ItsImplications for Future Research[J].Journal of Marketing,1985,49(3):41–50.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700