用户名: 密码: 验证码:
小企业互助融资与风险控制研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
小企业在我国国民经济的发展过程中扮演着举足轻重的角色,然而,融资难问题始终是其发展的主要障碍。企业规模小、经营不稳定、财务不透明等因素提高了金融机构的监管成本和信贷风险。信贷配给政策是金融机构风险控制的重要手段,其结果是小企业经常被金融机构排除在信贷市场之外,许多小企业因融资问题,被迫退出市场。
     为解决小企业融资难题,理论界和实务界都进行了大量的研究。其中,互助融资作为商业银行为缓解小企业融资难而进行的金融创新,在实践中已运作多时,积累了丰富的实践经验。通过对互助融资模式的研究,可以较好地了解这种模式的成功关键和潜在风险,对于完善互助融资模式、深化商业银行风险控制理论等具有重要的理论和现实意义。
     从理论上看,小企业互助融资模式的研究,有助于解决“强制性优序融资”、“道德风险”和“信息不对称”等困扰小企业融资的难题。小企业要生存,首先必须解决资金供给问题,而企业自身发展的不确定性和企业内部信息的不对称性使得外部投资者将小企业融资视为次品市场:小企业主要依靠自身的利润积累,在融资方式的选择上按优先顺序依次为企业内部积累、各种商业信用、银行债务、股权等。这种顺序并非企业偏好所致,而是外部环境强迫所致。
     在实践上,互助融资既能够降低银行风险又能够协助小企业获得融资。小企业利用这种融资模式,能够提高银行对它们的信任度,增加小企业的信贷额度,缓解企业的资金压力,促进企业稳定发展。同时,互助模式也能较好地实现借款成员的相互监督,减少银行的监督成本和信贷风险。通过对互助融资运作模式进行分析,了解互助融资的运行机制、风险识别、风险分析和风险控制,有利于促进这种模式在现实生活中的成功运用,更好地实现企业、银行、政府的共赢效果。
     本文首先介绍了国内外互助融资的主要模式——互助担保融资模式和联保联贷融资模式,并针对我国实践中的互助融资模式进行进一步深入比较。在联保联贷模式的基础上,构建了互助融资参与者的行为制约博弈模型,从银行角度对互助融资借款人的甄别及其获得款项后的监督以及防范借款者策略违约的机制设计进行分析,并利用博弈方法,构建互助融资契约中的利益分享机制,寻找利益的最优分配值。
     然后,针对小企业互助融资的善意风险和恶意风险的形成机理进行探讨,从动态角度分析了我国小企业在整个互助借款过程中的每个阶段(选择阶段、投资阶段、收益阶段和执行阶段)所面临的风险以及解决方案。
     最后,以实际案例具体分析了联保联贷及互助担保融资模式的风险控制手段。在此基础上,从政府、金融机构以及互助机构三个层面提出加强小企业互助融资风险控制的措施。
     经研究,本文得到主要结论如下:
     第一,互助融资有利于解决小企业信息不对称问题,一定程度上缓解了小企业的融资难题。该模式是金融机构获取小企业融资信息的有效途径,提高了银行对小企业融资风险的防控能力。同时,该模式也有利于缓解信贷配给制度对小企业的融资约束。
     第二,社会资本对互助融资的形成、发展具有积极影响。它能激励参与人进行横向选择,由相互熟悉的个体形成互助小组,提高联盟的稳定性。同时,它还能加强成员间的相互监督,通过声誉受损等社会惩罚来降低违约率,保障互助模式的长期稳定发展。
     第三,为了维持互助联盟的稳定性,互助组织应建立适当的利益分享机制,保证互助融资的三方参与者(银行、借款企业、担保企业)获得公平且不被优超的利益。同时,依据沙普利值计算得到的最优支付进行各方的利益分配,可以看出三方合作所创造的收益比任意两者的合作或各自独立创造的收益更大。
     第四,互助融资的风险可分为善意的和恶意的。为了防范风险,互助机构应注重提高信息透明度,加强成员管理;而金融机构应细化运作流程和机制设计、制定服务小企业的放贷和风控标准、合理发展互联网金融等,只有双方共同努力才能降低违约概率。
     本文可能的创新之处概括如下:
     一是系统研究了互助融资模式的运作原理。在安全型联盟和风险型联盟的甄别机制分析中,设置了不同的有限连带责任比例,使得机制分析既符合实际,又能够克服借款企业责任边界过大造成的风险分担不均衡造成的后果,可以有效促进了互助融资的推广和应用。
     二是从理论上分析中小企业互助融资的信用机制及利益分享机制。为保持互助融资中银行与中小企业联盟的稳定进行,一方面,取决于联盟各方的信用;同时也要建立适当的利益分享机制。同时本文还对风险分享机制和利益分享机制进行设计,力图构建一个有利于互助融资稳定运行的利益分享和风险控制机制。
     三是通过善意风险和恶意风险的形成机理研究,确定恶意风险的影响因素。应用博弈分析模型,得出在互助融资联盟成员人数增加时,联盟成员初始目标和网络的异化将会增大恶意风险出现的可能性。
Small enterprises play an important role in economy development. However, financing difficulty presents a big challenge on the way of their growth. Small enterprises'characteristics, such as small size, high performance volatility and accounting opaqueness, increase monitoring cost and credit risk of financial intermediaries. Therefore, credit rationing is an important measure to control risk, which leads to crowding-out effect for small enterprises. As a result, small enterprises are expected to be driven out of credit market.
     In order to solve the problem of financing difficulty of small enterprises, researches have been conducted by practitioners and academic scholars. Mutual financing is a finance innovation of commercial banks to mitigate the financing difficulty for small enterprises, which has been in business for a long time and accumulated much experience in practice. By studying mutual finance, we could obtain a good understanding of the key to success and potential risk of this financing channel, which contributes to improvement of mutual financing and risk control of commercial bank in practice and theory.
     From the perspective of theory, mutual financing of small enterprises is considered as a good solution to the problem of "mandatory pecking order","information asymmetry" and "adverse selection", which perplex small enterprises. In order to survive, small enterprises must have access to funds. But potential outside investors regard financial market related to small enterprises as lemon market because of growth uncertainty and information asymmetry. So small enterprise development relies on internal profit accumulation first, then commercial loans and stock lastly. The pecking order is not the preference of small enterprises, but the result of external financial constraints.
     From perspective of practice, mutual financing could reduce the risk of bank and ensure small enterprises to obtain funds at the same time. That is, small enterprises could get higher credit and greater rationing from banks, which alleviate financing pressure of firm and promote the development of firm steadily. Simultaneously, mutual financing requires screening among borrowers, thus, reducing monitoring cost and credit risk. Through analyzing mutual financing, learning about operation mechanism, identifying risk, and understanding risk control, could prompt the successful application of mutual financing in practice and achieve a win-win goal among small enterprises, banks and government.
     First, the paper introduces the mutual financing at home and aboard:mutual guarantee loan and group loan. We make a detailed comparison aiming at the practice of our nation between those two patterns. Based on group loan, we construct a behavior game theory model of players in group loan. In view of bank, we analyze mechanism design in mutual financing from the following three aspects:borrower identification, en ante screening, en post monitoring, In addition, we use game theory to design an interest share mechanism in mutual financing contract to find an optimal point of interest allocation.
     Then, we analyze the mechanism aiming at contract default in mutual financing of small enterprise, In dynamic analysis, we study every stage (selection, investment, return, performance) of mutual financing in small enterprises facing with risk and solutions. Last, we analyze risk control of three more general and specific mutual financing mechanisms:group loan in chamber, group loan in cyberspace and mutual guarantee loan. Based on the above analysis, we provide specific measures enhancing the risk control of mutual financing in small enterprises from aspects of government, financial institutions and mutual financing intermediaries.
     From the analysis of research, the main conclusions are as follow.
     First, mutual financing can alleviate the information asymmetry of small enterprises and resolve the difficulty of financing in small enterprises to some extent. It is a good way for banks to get the inside information of enterprises, improving the ability of risk control for small enterprise financing. At the same time, mutual financing could ease the financial constraints of small enterprises as a result of credit rationing.
     Second, public funds have a positive impact on the development of mutual financing. It encourages horizontal selection among participants, and helps form mutual groups, thus increasing the stability of alliances, In addition, it enhances peer monitoring, and reduces default probability through the reputation punishment, thus, ensuring the long term development of mutual financing.
     Third, to stabilize the alliance of mutual financing, it is essential to establish appropriate interest share mechanism, ensuring the fair interests of banks, borrowing firms and guarantors. Based on Shapley value in alliance of banks and firms, the benefit created by collaboration is more than that created separately.
     Fourth, the risk can be classified into good and ill-will ones. In case of risk, mutual financing intermediaries must focus on transparency of information and member management. On the other hand, financial institutions design operation rules and mechanisms, set standards of risk control aiming at bank loans of small enterprises and develop cyberspace finance. Only hard work in common could reduce the probability of default.
     Our research has the following contributions.
     First, we study operation principles of mutual financing systematically. We analyze risk recognition mechanism between security and risk alliance, set different proportion of joint liability, thus providing a practical analysis framework, overcoming the unbalanced risk sharing, as a result, promoting the application of mutual financing.
     Second, we analyze the credit mechanisms and interest share mechanisms of mutual financing in small enterprises. To ensurethe smooth operation of mutual financing, on one hand, it depends on creditability of members in alliance; on the other hand, it needs to establish an appropriate interest sharing mechanism. In addition, it requires interest share and risk share mechanisms, which enable the mutual financing to operate normally.
     Third, we analyze the development mechanisms of goodwill and ill-will risk, and find the factors of ill-will risk. By applying the game theory, we find that, when the number of participants increases, initial objectives of members and the heterogeneity of network lead to greater ill-will risk.
引文
① 数据来源:《小微企业融资发展报告:中国现状及亚洲实践》,2013
    ② 泉州市金融办课题《创新金融服务小微企业报告》,2013
    ⑤ 中央政府门户网站www.gov.cn,2007年07月01日,来源:四川日报
    ④ 杜晓山、孙若梅:中国小额信贷的实践和政策思考,财贸经济,2000(7):32-37
    ⑤ 朱民等译:穷人的的诚信,中信出版社,2007:1-252
    ⑥ BrettE Coleman. The impact of group lending in Northeast Thailand. Joumalof Development Economics.1999.105-141
    ⑦ Myers, Stewart, Nicholas S., Majluf. Corporate Financing and Investment Decisions when Firmshave Information that Investors Do Not Have[J]. Journal of Financial Economics.1984,13(2):187-221
    ⑧ 黄友松:中小企业互助融资研究——社会资本的视角,世界图书出版公司,2011:17-19
    ⑨ StiglitzJE,Weiss.A. Credit Rationing in Markets with Imperfect Information.American Economic Review.1981.17(3):393-410
    ⑩ Williamson SD.Costly Monitoring,Loan Contracts and Equilibrium Credit Rationing.Quarterly Journal of Economics.1986(2):135-145
    11 尼尔.格雷戈里、斯托伊安.塔涅夫:中国民营企业的融资问题.经济社会体制比较,2001(6):22-23
    12 Ang J.S. On the Theory of Finance for privately Held Firms. Journal of Small Business Finance.2002(5):185-203P
    13 Irwin D.,Jonathan M.,Scott. Barriers Faced by SMEs in Raising Bank Finance.International Journal of Entrepreneurial Behaviour & Research.2010,16 (3):245-259
    14 李扬、杨益群:中小企业融资与银行,上海财经大学出版社,2001
    15 周兆生:中小企业融资的制度分析,财经问题研究,2003(5):27-32
    16 纪杰、唐仕军:我国中小企业融资困难的成因及对策,统计与决策,2005(10)
    17 徐中丽:中小企业贷款难的主要原因及对策,经济师,2005(1):217-218
    18 杨建国、张桂智:关于建立小企业贷款风险补偿基金问题的研究,华北金融,2009(6):20-21
    19 谭文柱、陈光:联合贷款担保:解决小企业融资难的新途径一以意大利小企业联合担保贷款的形成和发展为例,天府新论,2003(2):28-31
    20 Altenburg.T,Meyer.Stamer.J.HowtoPromoteClusters:PolicyExperiencesfromLatinAmerica.WorldDevelopme nt.1999,27(9):1693-1713
    21 Gianluca Baldoni, Carlo Belliti, Lee M Miller, Paola Papini, Silvano Bertini, small firm consortianItaly:aninstrumentforeconomicdevelopment.UNIDO.1998:95-144
    22 Columba et al. Mutual guarantee institutions and small business finance. Journal of Financial Stability.2010(6):45-54
    23 Naveen.Kumar.K. Dynamic Incentives in Microfinance Group Lending:An Empirical Analysis of Progressive Lending Mechanism. SAGE Open.2012:67-96
    24 Francesca Bartoli.Giovanni.Ferri,Pierluigi Murro.Zeno Rotondi. Bank-firm relations and the role of Mutual Guarantee Institutions at the peak of the crisis.Joumal of Financial Stability.2013(9):90-104
    25 罗云:中小企业融资两类担保模式中博弈信息分析,商业现代化,2006(13):238-239
    26 夏蔚平:中小企业团贷融资的有效性分析,商业时代,2006(9):6-7
    27 巴劲松:从“浙江模式”的经验看我国中小企业信用担保模式的建立,上海金融,2007(8):75-78
    28 彭江波:以互助联保为基础构建中小企业信用担保体系,金融研究,2008(2):75-80
    29 倪克勤、郭鲜林:中小企业融资困境与内生性互助联保融资,西南金融,2009(2):44-46
    30 曾刚:信息不对称与小额信贷创新,金融理论与实践,2012(3):4-9
    31 Varian HR.Monitoring agents with other agents. Journal of Institutional and Theoretical Eeonomics.1990,146(1):153-174
    32 Wenner M.Group credit:a means to improve information transfer and loan repayment performance, Journal of Development Studies.1995,32(2):263-281
    33 Ghatak.M.Group lending, local information and peer selection.Journal of Development Economics.1999,60(1):27-50
    34 Ghatak.M.ScreeningbytheCompanyYouKeep:JointLiabilityLendingandthePeerSelectionEffect.Eeonomie Joumal.2000,110(465):601-63
    35 Xinhua.G. Search Approach to Group-based lending with Joint Liability under Asymmetric Information.WorkingPaper.Ontario:UniversityofToronto.2001:78-91
    36 江能、邹平,王泽丽等:组员规模对联保贷款信贷风险的影响机制分析,统计与决策,2007(23):42-43
    37 Giovanni,B. Alberto,Z. Mutual Loan-Guarantee Societies in Monopolistic Credit Markets with Adverse Selection. Journal of Financial Stability.2012,8(8):15-24
    38 Sadoulet.L.EquilibruimRisk-Matchingin Group Lending. ECARES; University of Brussels.1999:134-158
    39 Armendariz de Aghion B, Gollier C. Peer Group Formation in an Adverse Selection Model. The Economic Journal.2000,100(465):632-643
    40 Laffont Jean Jacques, Tchetche N'Guinssan. Group Lending with Adverse Selection. EuropeanEconomic Review.2000(44):773-784
    41 Sadoulet L,Carpenter S. Endogenous Matching and risk Heterogeneity:Evidence on Miero-credit Group FormationinGuatemala.ECARES:UniversityofBrussels.2001:179-194
    42 Mehrteab HT. Adverse Seleetion and Moral Hazard in Group-Based Lending:Evidence from Eritrea. Netherlands:UniversityofGroningen.2005:25-46
    43 章元:团体贷款中不同贷款条件甄别机制的可行性研究,复旦大学社会主义市场经济研究中心,2004:34-39
    44 Armendariz B and Morduch J.The economics of microfinance[M]. Cambridge, MA:MIT Press.2005
    45 SadouletL.EquilibmimRisk-Matchingin Group Lending. ECARES; University of Brussels.1999:134-158
    46 GuttmanJM.Assortativematching,adverseseleetionandgroup lending.JoumalofDevelopment Eeonomics.2008,87(1):51-56
    47 Zhang W.Group lending with adverse selection.Intemational Economics and Finance Journal.2009,4(12):33-58
    48 Stiglitz.J.E.PeerMonitoringandCreditMarkets.TheWorldBankEeonomic Review.1990,4(3):351-366
    49 Varian HR.Monitoring agents with other agents. Journal of Institutional and Theoretical Eeonomics.1990,146(1):153-174
    50 Rashid.M,Townsend.R.Targeting creditandinsuranee:effcideney,mechanismdesignandProgramevaluation.WorldBank.Allleriea:UniversityofChic ago.1992:146-164
    31 Banerjee.A. V,et al.The neighbors keeper. The design of a credit cooperative with theory and a test.Quarterly Journal of Economics.1994,109(2):491-515
    52 Basley.T,Coate.S. Group lending, repayment incentives and social collateral. Journal of Development Eeonomies.1995,46(1):1-18
    53 Conning.J.Group Lending,MoralHazard,andtheCreationofsocialCollateral.. WorkingPaper.CenterforInstitutionalReformandthe informalSector.UniversityofMarylandatCollegePark.1996:254-278
    54 ImpavidoGregorio.CreditRationing,Group LendingandOptimalGroup Size.AnnalsofPublic& CooperativeEeonomies.1998,69(2):243-260
    55 董颖颖、孔柯林:信用计量技术及其在我国的应用分析,华东经济管理,2002:34-36
    56 章元、李全:论产出分布对还款率的影响,经济研究,2003(2):23-28
    57 Mehrteab HT. Adverse Seleetion and Moral Hazard in Group-Based Lending:Evidence from Eritrea. Netherlands:UniversityofGroningen.2005:25-46
    58 潘楚楚、杨宜:高科技中小企业信用担保运作模式的选择,北京工业大学学报(社会科学版),2007(10):32-34
    59 曹国华、闫彩云:不同担保模式对中小企业融资条件的影响,技术经济与管理研究,2012(2):82-85
    60 Gine, X. and D. S. Karlan. Group versus Individual Liability:Short and Long Term Evidence from Philippine Microcredit Lending Groups. Review of Economic Studies.2011:132-168
    61 Banerjee, A. V. Microcredit under the microscope:What have we learnt in the last two decades, what do we need to know?. Annual Review of Economics.2013:102-134
    62 Bolton P and Scharfestein D A theory of predation based on agency problems in financial contracting.American Economic Review.1990.80(1):93-106
    63 Basley.T,Coate.S.Group lending, repayment incentives and social collateral. Journal of Development Eeonomies.1995.46(1):1-18
    64 Armendariz B and Morduch J. Microfinance beyond group lending. Economics of Transition.2000.8(2):401-420
    65 Zhang W. Ex-ante moral hazard and repayment performance under group lending. Journal of East Asian Studies(Japan).2008.6(1):145-171
    66 Armendariz de Aghion B, Gollier C. Peer Group Formation in an Adverse Selection Model. The Economic Journal.2000.100(465):632-643
    67 Baron.J.N, Kathy.Paulson. Gjerde.Peer Pressureinan Agency Relation ship. Journal of Labor Economies.1997.15(2):234-254
    68 Diagneetal.A,Simtowe.F,Chimombo.W,Mataya.C. Design and Sustain ability Issues of Rural Credit and Savings Programs for the Poor in Malawi.An Action-Oriented Research project. IEPRI.2000:145-153
    69 SimtoweF, ZellerM. Determinants of Moral Hazard in Mierofinanee:Empirical Evidence from Joint Liability Lending Program in Malawi. Germany:UniversityofHohenheim.2006.
    70 Basley.T,Coate.S.Group lending, repayment incentives and social collateral. Journal of Development Eeonomies.1995.46(1):1-18
    71 Beatrix Pall, Thomas Wiseman. Group lending with endogenous social collateral.UNIVERSTIY OF TEXAS ATAUSTIN.2002:67-91
    72 ImpavidoGregorio.CreditRationing,Group LendingandOptimalGroup Size.AnnalsofPublic& CooperativeEeonomies.1998.69(2):243-260
    73 MauriceKugler,RossellaOppes.CollateralandRiskSharinginGroup Lending:EvidencefromanUrbanMicrocreditProgram.DiscussionPapersinEconomicsandEconometries.2005:235-265
    74 Beatrix Paal.Thomas Wiseman. Group insurance and lending with endogenous social collateral.Journal of Development Economics.2011(1):30-40
    75 ThienyVanBastelaer,HowardLeathers.TrustinLendingSocialCapitalandJointLiabilitySeed Loans in Southern Zairlbia. World Development. 2006.34(10):1788-1807
    76 章元:对团体贷款高还款率的解释:一个社会担保模型,世界经济文汇,2005(2):67-72
    77 Bratton M. Financing Smallholder Production:A Comparison of Individual and Group Credit Schemesin Zimbabwe. Public Administration and Development.1986(6):115-132
    78 Park, Shen. Joint liability lending and the rise and fall of China's townshipand village enterprises. Journal of Development Economics.2003.71(2):497-531
    79 Basley.T,Coate.S.Group lending, repayment incentives and social collateral. Journal of Development Eeonomies.1995.46(1):1-18
    80 Ghatak. M and Guinnane TW. The economics of lending with joint lisbility:Theory and practice.Joumal of Development Economics.1999.60(2):195-228
    81 Zhang W. Ex-ante moral hazard and repayment performance under group lending. Journal of East Asian Studies(Japan).2008.6(1):145-171
    82 Remco van Eijkel.Niels Hermes.Robert Lensink. Group lending and the role of the group leader. Small Bus Econ.2011 (36):299-321
    83 Naveen.Kumar.K. Dynamic Incentives in Microfinance Group Lending:An Empirical Analysis of Progressive Lending Mechanism. SAGE Open.2012:67-96
    84 Chowdhury R.P.Group lending:Sequential financing, lender monitoring and joint·libility.Journal of Development Economics.2005.77(2):415-439
    85 Aniket C and Townsend RM. Selection into and across credit contracts:Theory and field research0Journal of Econometrics.2007.136(2):665-698
    86 Cason T.N, et al. Moral hazard and peer monitoring in laboratory microfinance experiment[R]. Working Paper. No.1208.2008
    87 Zhang W. China's non-governmental microcredit sector:History and challenges Journal of Family and Economic Issues.2010,31 (3):280-296
    88 史小坤:团队激励从背叛走向合作——兼谈Grameen银行的成功贷款制度科技进步与对策,2004(5):155-157
    89 叶湘榕:我国互助担保基金发展的博弈分析,经济论坛,2004(5):23-28
    90 贺学会、尹晨:信用体系与征信:概念与基本框架,金融理论与实践,2005:6-8
    91 江能、邹平、王泽丽等:联保贷款联保小组规模研究,企业经济,2007(10):130-132
    92 郭倩:中小企业信用担保机构风险控制研究,金融经济,2009(3):87-88
    93 张宇涵:中小企业互助担保融资模式设计及其博弈分析,天津财经大学,2009
    94 Wydick B. Can social cohesion be harnessed to repair market failures?, Evidence from group-lending in Guatemala. EconomicJoumal.1999:463-475
    95 DeanS.Karlan.The Impact of Social Capital on Poor Borrowers and Savers. Department of Economics.2001:123-159
    96 Dean S.Karian.SocialCapitalandGroupBanking.WorkingPaper.2004:21-46
    97 MargueriteRobinson.The MicrofinanceRevolution:SustainableFinanceforthePoor[M].WorldBank.2001
    98 Karlan,D.Social Capital and Group Banking[R].Working Paper.Department of Economics.M.I.T.2002
    99 Gomez R, Santor E. Do peer group members outperform individual borrowers? A test of peer group lending using Canadian microcredit data. Canada:Bank of Canada. Working Paper.2003(10)
    100 Alessandra C, Luke C, Bruce W. The Effect of Social Capital on Group Loan Repayment:Evidence from Field Experiments. The Economic.2007:56-78
    101 Dean S K. Social Connections and Group Banking. The Economic Journal.2007:52-84
    102 Cassar A, Crowley L, Wydick B. The effect of social capital on group repayment:evidence from art factual field experiments.Economic.2007
    103 Fabio S. Social.Capital as Social Networks:a New Framework for Measurement and an empirical analysis of its determinants and consequences. The Journal of Socio-Economics.2009:78-95
    104 彭江波:以互助联保为基础构建中小企业信用担保体系,金融研究,2008(2):75-80
    105 刘轶、张飞:基于社会资本的中小企业集群融资分析,湖南大学学报,2009(3):64-67
    106 Joe chen, Joint liability borrowing and suicide:The case of Japan. EconomicsLetters Journal of Development Economics.2010:69-71
    107 张婷:社会资本在中小企业融资中的效应分析,统计与决策,201 1(6):34-37
    108 孟晞、钟田丽:小微企业与互助担保组织的动态博弈研究,财经问题研究,2012(12):138-143
    109 Moh'dAl-Azzam,R. Carter Hill,Sudipta Sarangi. Repayment performance in group lending:Evidence from Jordan. Journal of DevelopmentEconomics.2012:404-414
    110 Feigenberg, B, E. Field, and R. Pande. The Economic Returns to Social Interaction Experimental Evidence from Microfinance. Review of Economic Studies.2013:68-112
    111 Lutz.G.Amold,Johannes.Reeder,Susanne.Steger. On the Viability of Group Lending when Microfinance Meets the MarketA Reconsideration of the Besley-Coate Model. Journal of Emerging Market Finance.2013:59-106
    112 Columba F, Leonardo G, Paolo E M. Firms as Monitor of Other Firms:Mutual Guarantee Institutions and SME Finance. Rome:joint journal of Financial Stability and World Bank conference on Partial Credit Guarantee Schemes.2008:145-176
    113 陈晓红、吴小瑾:中小企业社会资本的构成及其与信用水平关系的实证研究,管理世界,2007(1):12-16
    114 张意如:异性视角下的团体贷款研究,南京理工大学,2008(6)
    115 Shahidur R. Khandker. Grameen Bank Lending:Does Group Liability Matter?. World Bank Policy Research Working Paper.2012(9):52-82
    116 AndersonCL,LauraLoeker. Mieroer edit, Social Capital and Common Pool Resources. World Development.2002,30(1):95-105
    117 Asif Dowla.in ceredit we trust:Building social caplital by Grameen Bank in Bangladesh. The Journal of Socio—Economies.2006,35(1):102-122
    118 SahariaKanak,Yoshiakiliguni. Mierofianee Programs and Social Capital Formation:The Present See narioina Rural Village of Bangladesh. The hintemational Joumal of APPlied Economies and Finance.2007,1(2):97-104
    119 陈军、曹远征:农村金融深化与发展评析,中国人民大学出版社,2008
    120 AlchianAA, DemsetzH. Production, Information Costs, and Economic Organization. E.R.1972,(62):777-795
    121 HolmstromB.MoralHazardinTeams.BellJoumalofEconomies.1982,13:324-334
    122 Mcafee,PrestonR.,McMillan J.Optimal Contracts for Teams. International Economic Review.1991,32(3):561-577
    123 BernheimB.D,WinstonMD.CommonAgeney.Eeonometriea.1986,54(4):923-942
    124 TiroleJ.AccessPrieingandComPetition[J].EuroPeanEconomicReview.1994,38(9):1673-1710
    125 CheYK,Yoo S W. Optimal Incentives for Teams. The American Economic Review.2001,91(2):525-541
    126 孟晞、钟田丽:小微企业与互助担保组织的动态博弈研究,财经问题研究,2012(12):138-143
    127 王志强、邹高峰、左军:欧盟中小企业互助担保融资的经验与启示,天津大学学报,2012,14(4):300-305
    128 崔晓玲、钟田丽:中小企业互助性信用担保运行机理分析,管理学报,2010,7(12)
    129 福州工商联:小组联保或可破解中小企业贷款难题,福州新闻网,2010.6.4
    130 傅皓天:网络联保融资模式的成功机理,现代企业教育.,2009:171-172
    131 张朝元、梁雨:经济低增长企业对策:中小企业融资渠道,机械工业出版社,2009:135-186
    132 黄友松:中小企业互助融资研究——社会资本的视角,世界图书出版公司,2011:17-19
    133 杨立华:基于社会资本的小微信贷批量化模式——中国民生银行福州分行小微信贷的探索与实践,福建金融,2012.11:40-42
    134 张卫国、冉晖、陈苏苏:中小企业团体贷款的博弈分析,系统工程,2010(5):25-29
    135 冉晖、张卫国:基于内部监督及社会惩罚机制的中小企业团体贷款还款研究,亚太经济,2011(6):39-43
    136 (德)尼克拉斯·卢曼.信任:一个社会复杂的简化机制,瞿铁鹏、李强译,上海人民出版社,2005.05
    137 于维生:博弈论与经济,高等教育出版社,2007.04:115-119
    38 张伟:微型金融理论研究,中国金融出版社,2011:36-125
    39 张伟:微型金融理论研究,中国金融出版社,2011:36-125
    40 赵敬华:联保贷款中的策略违约规避机制研究,硕士学位论文,湖南大学,2010
    141 张意如:异质性视角下的团体贷款研究,博士学位论文,南京理工大学,2008
    42 泉州市金融办课题《创新金融服务小微企业报告》,2013
    [1]AlchianAA, DemsetzH. Production, Information Costs, and Economic Organization. E. R.,1972
    [2]Alessandra C, Luke C, Bruce W. The Effect of Social Capital on Group Loan Repayment:Evidence from Field Experiments. The Economic,.2007
    [3]Altenburg.T,Meyer. Stamer.J. HowtoPromoteClusters:Policy Experiences from Latin America. WorldDevelopment,1999
    [4]AndersonCL,LauraLoeker.Mieroeredit,SocialCapitalandCommon PoolResources.World Development.2002
    [5]Ang J.S. On the Theory of Finance for privately Held Firms. Journal of Small Business Finance.2002
    [6]Aniket C and Townsend RM. Selection into and across credit contracts: Theory and field research. Journal of Econometrics,2007
    [7]Armendariz B and Morduch J. Microfinance beyond group lending. Economics of Transition,.2000
    [8]Armendariz B and Morduch J. The economics of microfinance. Cambridge. MA:MIT Press,2005
    [9]Armendariz de Aghion B, Gollier C. Peer Group Formation in an Adverse Selection Model. The Economic Journal.2000
    [10]Asif Dowla.in ceredit we trust:Building social caplital by Grameen Bank in Bangladesh. The Journal of Socio—Economies.2006
    [11]Baker W E. Market networks and corporate behavior. American journal of sociology.1990
    [12]Banerjee, A. V. Microcredit under the microscope:What have we learnt in the last two decades, what do we need to know?. Annual Review of Economics.2013
    [13]Banerjee.A.V,et al. The neighbors keeper:The design of a credit cooperative with theory and a test. Quarterly Journal of Economics.1994
    [14]Baron.J.N,Kathy.Paulson.Gjerde.PeerPressureinanAgencyRelationship.Jo urnalofLabor Economies.1997
    [15]Basley.T,Coate.S. Group lending, repayment incentives and social collateral. Journal of Development Eeonomies.1995
    [16]Beatrix Paal,Thomas Wiseman. Group insurance and lending with endogenous social collateral. Journal of Development Economics.2011
    [17]Beatrix Pall, Thomas Wiseman. Group lending with endogenous social collateral. UNIVERSTIY OF TEXASATAUSTIN.2002
    [18]Belliveau M A, O'REILLY C A, Wade J B. Social capital at the top: Effects of social similarity and status on CEO compensation. Academy of Management Journal.1996
    [19]BernheimB.D, Whinston MD. Common Ageney. Eeonometriea.1986
    [20]Bolton P and Scharfestein D A theory of predation based on agency problems in financial contracting. American Economic Review,1990
    [21]Bourdieu P. The social space and the genesis of groups. Theory and society.1985
    [22]Bratton M. Financing Smallholder Production:A Comparison of Individual and Group Credit Schemesin Zimbabwe. Public Administration and Development.1986
    [23]BrettE Coleman. The impact of group lending in Northeast Thailand. Journalof Development Economics.1999
    [24]Burt R S, Hogarth R M, Michaud C. The social capital of French and American managers. Organization science.2000
    [25]Cason T.N, et al. Moral hazard and peer monitoring in laboratory microfinance experiment[R]. Working Paper No.1208.2008
    [26]Cassar A, Crowley L, Wydick B. The effect of social capital on group repayment:evidence from art factual field experiments.Economic,2007
    [27]CheYK,Yoo S W.OptimalIncentivesforTeams.TheAmericanEconomic Review.2001
    [28]Chowdhury R.P. Group leading:Sequential financing, lender monitoring and joint libility. Journal of Development Economics.2005.
    [29]Columba et al. Mutual guarantee institutions and small business finance. Journal of Financial Stability.2010
    [30]Columba F, Leonardo G, Paolo E M. Firms as Monitor of Other Firms: Mutual Guarantee Institutions and SME Finance. Rome:joint journal of Financial Stability and World Bank conference on Partial Credit Guarantee Schemes.2008
    [31]Lending,MoralHazard,andtheCreationofSocialCollateral.WorkingPaper.C enterforlnstitutionalReformandthe informalSector.UniversityofMarylandatCollegePark.1996
    [32]Dean S K. Social Connections and Group Banking. The Economic Journal.2007
    Dean S.Karian.SocialCapitalandGroupBanking.WorkingPaper.2004
    [33]DeanS.Karlan.TheImpactofSocialCapitalonPoorBorrowersandSavers.Dep artmentofEconomics..2001
    [34]Diagneetal.A,Simtowe.F,Chimombo.W,Mataya.C.DesignandSustainabilit ylssuesofRural Credit and Savings Programs for the Poor in Malawi. An Action-Oriented Research project. IEPRI.2000
    [35]Fabio S. Social Capital as Social Networks:a New Framework for Measurement and an empirical analysis of its determinants and consequences. The Journal of Socio-Economics.2009
    [36]Feigenberg, B, E. Field, and R. Pande. The Economic Returns to Social Interaction Experimental Evidence from Microfinance. Review of Economic Studies.2013
    [37]Francesca Bartoli,Giovanni Ferri,Pierluigi Murro,Zeno Rotondi. Bank-firm relations and the role of Mutual Guarantee Institutions at the peak of the crisis. Journal of Financial Stability.2013(9)
    [38]Fukuyama. Social capital. Tanner lectures, Brasenose College, Oxford; Processed, Institute of Public Policy, George Mason University, Fairfax, Virginia. 1997
    [39]Fukuyama. Trust:the social virtues and the creation of prosperity. New York:Free Press.1995
    [40]Ghatak. M and Guinnane TW. The economics of lending with joint liability:Theory and practice. Journal of Development Economics.1999.
    [41]Ghatak. M. Group lending, local information and peer selection. Journal of Development Economics 1999
    [42]Ghatak.M.ScreeningbytheCompanyYouKeep:JointLiabilityLendingandth ePeerSelectionEffect.Eeonomie Joumal.2000
    [43]Gianluca Baldoni, Carlo Belliti, Lee M Miller, Paola Papini, Silvano Bertini,small firm consortiamItaly:aninstrument for economic development. UNID O.1998
    [44]Gine, X. and D. S. Karlan. Group versus Individual Liability:Short and Long Term Evidence from Philippine Microcredit Lending Groups. Review of Economic Studies.2011
    [45]Giovanni,B.Alberto,Z. Mutual Loan-Guarantee Societies in Monopolistic Credit Markets with Adverse Selection. Journal of Financial Stability.2012
    [46]Gomez R, Santor E. Do peer group members outperform individual borrowers? A test of peer group lending using Canadian microcredit data. Canada: Bank of Canada, Working Paper.2003(10)
    [47]GuttmanJM.Assortactivematching,adverseselectionandgrouplending.Jour nalofDevelopment Eeonomics.2008
    [48]HolmstromB.Moral Hazard inTeams. Bell Journal of Economies.1982
    [49]Impavido Gregorio.CreditRationing,Group Lending and Optimal Group Size.Annals of Public& CooperativeEeonomies.1998
    [50]Inglehart R. Culture shift in advanced industrial society. Princeton: Princeton University Press.1990
    [51]Irwin D.,Jonathan M.,Scott. Barriers Faced by SMEs in Raising Bank Finance.International Journal of Entrepreneurial Behaviour & Research.2010
    [52]Joe chen, Joint liability borrowing and suicide:The case of Japan. EconomicsLetters. Journal of Development Economics.2010
    [53]Karlan,D.Social Capital and Group Banking[R].Working Paper, Department of Economic Review.2008
    [54]Laffont Jean Jacques, Tchetche N'Guinssan. Group Lending with Adverse Selection. EuropeanEconomic Review.2000(44)
    [55]Lutz.G.Arnold,Johannes.Reeder,Susanne.Steger. On the Viability of Group Lending whenMicrofinance Meets the MarketA Reconsideration of the Besley-Coate Model. Journal of Emerging Market Finance.2013
    [56]MargueriteRobinson.The Microfinance Revolution:Sustainable Finance for the Poor.WorldBank.2001
    [57]MauriceKugler,RossellaOppes.CollateralandRiskSharinginGroup Lending:Evidence from an Urban Micro credit Program.Discussion Paper sinEconomics and Econometries.2005
    [58]Mcafee, PrestonR., MeMillanJ. Optimal Contracts for Teams. Intemational Economic Review.1991
    [59]Mehrteab HT. Adverse Seleetion and Moral Hazard in Group-Based Lending:Evidence from Eritrea. Netherlands:UniversityofGroningen.2005
    [60]Moh'd Al-Azzam, R Carter Hill, Sudipta Sarangi. Repayment performance in group lending:Evidence from Jordan. Journal of DevelopmentEconomics.2012
    [61]Myers, Stewart, Nicholas S., Majluf. Corporate Financing and Investment Decisions when Firmshave Information that Investors Do Not Have. Journal of Financial Economics.1984
    [62]Nahapiet J, Ghoshal S. Social capital, intellectual capital, and the organizational advantage. Academy of management review.1998
    [63]Naveen.Kumar.K. Dynamic Incentives in Microfinance Group Lending: An Empirical Analysis of Progressive Lending Mechanism. SAGE Open.2012
    [64]Park, Shen. Joint liability lending and the rise and fall of China's townshipand village enterprises. Journal of Development Economics.2003
    [65]Paxton Julia. A Worldwide Inventory of Microfinance Institutions. Sustainable Banking with thePoor Project, Washington D.C.:World Bank.1996
    [66]Pennar K, Mueller T. The ties that lead to prosperity. Business Week.1997
    [67]Pharr S J, Putnam R D. Disaffected democracies:what's troubling the trilateral countries?. Princeton:Princeton University Press.2000.
    [68]Portes A. Social capital:Its origins and applications in modern sociology. Annual review of sociology.1998
    [69]Rashid.M,Townsend.R.Targeting creditandinsuranee:efficieney,mechanismdesignandProgramevaluation.WorldBank. Allleriea:UniversityofChieago.1992
    [70]Remco van Eijkel.Niels Hermes.Robert Lensink. Group lending and the role of the group leader. Small Bus Econ.2011
    [71]Sadoulet L,Carpenter S. Endogenous Matching and risk Heterogeneity: Evidence on Miero-credit Group Formationin Guatemala. ECARES:University of Brussels.2001
    [72]Sadoulet.L Equilibruim Risk-Matching in Group Lending. ECARES; University of Brussels.1999
    [73]SahariaKanak,YoshiakiIiguni.Microfiance Programs and Social Capital Formation:The Present Seenarioina Rural "Village of Bangladesh.The Hitemational Journal of Applied Economiesand Finance.2007
    [74]Schiff L B. A Collection of Tributes and Contributions to Honor, Celebrate and Congratulate Dr. Botha de Meillon on His Ninetieth Birthday. October 15,1992
    [75]Shaply L S, Shubik M. On the core of an economic system with externalities. American Economic Review.1969
    [76]SimtoweF, ZellerM. Determinants of Moral Hazardin Microfinance:Empirical Evidence from JointLiability Lending PrograminMalawi.Germany:UniversityofHohenheim.2006.
    [77]Stiglitz.J.E.PeerMonitoringandCreditMarkets.TheWorldBankEeonomic Review.1990
    [78]StiglitzJ E,Weiss.A.Credit Rationing in Markets with Imperfect Information.American Economic Review.1981
    [79]ThienyVanBastelaer,HowardLeathers.TrastinLendingSocialCapitalandJoi ntLiabilitySeed Loans in Southern Zairlbia. World Development.2006
    [80]TiroleJ. AccessPricingandCompetition.EuropeanEconomicReview.1994
    [81]VanTassel. E. A study of group lending incentives in Bolivia. International Journal of Social Economics.2000
    [82]Van TasselE. Group lending under asynmetric information.Joumal of Development Economies.1999
    [83]Varian HR. Monitoring agents with other agents. Journal of Institutional and Theoretical Eeonomics.1990
    [84]Wenner M. Group credit:a means to improve information transfer and loan repayment performance, Journal of Development Studies.1995
    [85]Williamson SD.Costly Monitoring,Loan Contracts and Equilibrium Credit Rationing.Quarterly Journal of Economics.1986(2)
    [86]Wydick B. Can social cohesion be harnessed to repair market failures?, Evidence from group-lending in Guatemala. EconomicJournal.1999
    [87]Xinhua. G. Search Approach to Group-based lending with Joint Liability under Asymmetric Information.WorkingPaper.Ontario:UniversityofToronto.2001
    [88]Zhang W. China's non-governmental microcredit sector:History and challenges Journal of Family and Economic Issues,2010
    [89]Zhang W. Ex-ante moral hazard and repayment performance under group lending. Journal of East Asian Studies(Japan),2008
    [90]Zhang W. Group lending with adverse selection. International Economics and Finance Journal,2009
    [91]巴劲松:从“浙江模式”的经验看我国中小企业信用担保模式的建立,上海金融,2007(8)
    [92]曹国华、闫彩云:不同担保模式对中小企业融资条件的影响,技术经济与管理研究,2012(2)
    [93]曾刚:信息不对称与小额信贷创新,金融理论与实践,2012(3)
    [94]陈军、曹远征.:农村金融深化与发展评析,中国人民大学出版社,2008
    [95]陈晓红、吴小瑾:中小企业社会资本的构成及其与信用水平关系的实证研究,管理世界,2007(1)
    [96]崔晓玲、钟田丽:中小企业互助性信用担保运行机理分析,管理学报,2010.7(12)
    [917](德)尼克拉斯·卢曼.信任:一个社会复杂的简化机制,瞿铁鹏、李强译,上海人民出版社,2005.05
    [98]董颖颖、孔柯林:信用计量技术及其在我国的应用分析,华东经济管理,2002
    [99]杜晓山、孙若梅:中国小额信贷的实践和政策思考,财贸经济,2000(7)
    [100]福州工商联:小组联保或可破解中小企业贷款难题.,福州新闻网,2010.6.4
    [101]傅皓天:网络联保融资模式的成功机理,现代企业教育,2009
    [102]郭倩:中小企业信用担保机构风险控制研究,金融经济,2009(3)
    [103]贺学会、尹晨:信用体系与征信:概念与基本框架,金融理论与实践,2005
    [104]黄友松:中小企业互助融资研究——社会资本的视角.,世界图书出版公司,2011
    [105]纪杰、唐仕军:我国中小企业融资困难的成因及对策,统计与决策,2005(10)
    [106]江能、邹平、王泽丽等:联保贷款联保小组规模研究,企业经济,2007(10)
    [107]江能、邹平、王泽丽等:组员规模对联保贷款信贷风险的影响机制分析,统计与决策,2007(23)
    [108]李扬、杨益群:中小企业融资与银行,上海财经大学出版社,2001
    [109]刘轶、张飞.:基于社会资本的中小企业集群融资分析,湖南大学学报.,2009(3)
    [110]罗云:中小企业融资两类担保模式中博弈信息分析,商业现代化,2006(13)
    [111]孟晞、钟田丽:小企业与互助担保组织的动态博弈研究,财经问题研究,2012(12)
    [112]尼尔.格雷戈里、斯托伊安.塔涅夫:中国民营企业的融资问题.,经济社会体制比较,2001(6)
    [113]倪克勤、郭鲜林.:中小企业融资困境与内生性互助联保融资,西南金融,2009(2)
    [114]潘楚楚、杨宜:高科技中小企业信用担保运作模式的选择,北京工业大学学报(社会科学版),2007(10)
    [115]彭江波:以互助联保为基础构建中小企业信用担保体系,金融研究,2008(2)
    [116]冉晖、张卫国:基于内部监督及社会惩罚机制的中小企业团体贷款还款研究,亚太经济,2011(6)
    [117]史小坤:团队激励从背叛走向合作——兼谈Grameen银行的成功贷款制度科技进步与对策,2004(5)
    [118]谭文柱、陈光:联合贷款担保:解决小企业融资难的新途径—以意大利小企业联合担保贷款的形成和发展为例,天府新论,2003(2)
    [119]王志强、邹高峰、左军:欧盟中小企业互助担保融资的经验与启示,天津大学学报,2012(4)
    [120]夏蔚平:中小企业团贷融资的有效性分析,商业时代,2006(9)
    [121]徐盈盈:我国中小企业联保贷款融资模式研究,硕士学位论文,中国海洋大学,2011
    [122]徐中丽:中小企业贷款难的主要原因及对策,经济师,2005(1)
    [123]杨建国、张桂智:关于建立小企业贷款风险补偿基金问题的研究.,华北金融,2009(6)
    [124]杨立华:基于社会资本的小信贷批量化模式——中国民生银行福州分行小信贷的探索与实践,福建金融,2012(11)
    [126]杨天宇:国有商业银行对民营企业的信贷配给行为研究,经济科学,2002(4)
    [127]叶湘榕:我国互助担保基金发展的博弈分析,经济论坛,2004(5)
    [128]于维生:博弈论与经济,高等教育出版社,2007.04
    [129]约翰·冯诺依曼,奥斯卡·摩根斯特恩:竞赛论与经济行为,王建华、顾玮琳译,科学出版社,1963
    [130]赵敬华:联保贷款中的策略违约规避机制研究,硕士学位论文,湖南大学,2010
    [131]张婷.:社会资本在中小企业融资中的效应分析.,统计与决策,2011(6)
    [132]张伟:微型金融理论研究,中国金融出版社,2011
    [133]张卫国、冉晖、陈苏苏:中小企业团体贷款的博弈分析,系统工程,2010(5)
    [134]张意如.:异质性视角下的团体贷款研究,博士学位论文,南京理工大学,2008
    [135]张宇涵.:中小企业互助担保融资模式设计及其博弈分析,天津财经大学,2009
    [136]张元红:中国农村民间金融研究:信用、利率与市场均衡.,社会科学文献出版社,2012.11
    [137]章元、李全:论产出分布对还款率的影响,经济研究,2003(2)
    [138]章元:对团体贷款高还款率的解释:一个社会担保模型,世界经济文汇,2005(2)
    [139]章元:团体贷款中不同贷款条件甄别机制的可行性研究,复旦大学社会主义市场经济研究中心,2004
    [140]周兆生.:中小企业融资的制度分析,财经问题研究,2003(5)
    [141]朱民等译:穷人的的诚信,中信出版社,2007

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700