用户名: 密码: 验证码:
哈尔滨城市居住区公共空间声环境评价及分析研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
城市居住区的公共空间形态构成和整体空间环境品质是影响城市整体的宜居水平的关键要素之一。其质量会对使用者的生活产生很大的影响,消极的居住区公共空间会使居民对公共生活产生排斥感。当前,居住区公共空间在使用的过程中存在诸多问题,如何营建舒适的居住区公共空间声环境就是其中之一。不利的声环境将对人们生理和心理双方面造成危害,包括听力视力的损害;心血管系统的损害;甚至影响到人的神经系统,产生急躁,易怒等情绪。因此营造令人们满意的居住区公共空间声环境,适宜的声场条件以及使用者、物理环境等多方面因素与声环境影响的考虑,可以解决人们对生存环境舒适度的要求,缓解居民生活的压力,舒缓心情。
     本文以哈尔滨典型居住区具有代表性的公共空间作为研究对象,将声环境研究与居住区公共空间营造相结合,通过对既有研究成果与研究方法进行梳理和综述,结合现场实测调研、计算机软件模拟、问卷调查和统计分析等方法,对哈尔滨典型居住区公共空间进行了全面深入调查与分析,从而拓宽了居住区公共空间可持续发展的研究视野,确立了哈尔滨居住区公共空间声环境的评价方法与设计策略。
     本文通过文献调研和实地考察对哈尔滨典型住区及代表性公共空间进行了分析,选取哈尔滨典型住区公共空间展开现场实测,结合计算机软件模拟分析,对居住区公共空间的声场分布特征和设计因子影响机制展开了研究,即规划层面上的区块规模、建筑密度、后退距离、道路交通、空间绿化以及空间封闭性等因素,以及与建筑层面上的建筑开口、建筑高度以及空间组合多样性等因素。其次,对居住区居民展开问卷调研,通过调研结果的相关性分析,深入研究居住区公共空间中声音、听者和环境三者的内在关系,对使用者基于声喜好的声环境评价影响机制进行了解读,即交通声、施工声和商业设施声、自然声、人行为声同使用者行为特征和社会特征方面存在的显著相关性。最后,综合实测和模拟结果,依托问卷调研和统计分析结论,挖掘物理环境特征、设计因子与声环境评价的关联性,分析了声环境总体特征和不同影响因素对哈尔滨居住区公共空间声环境评价的影响。对居住区公共空间声环境舒适性的营造进行了针对性的设计。对典型居住区抗噪性能进行评价,从宏观整体上把控,提出针对居住区空间声环境的优化设计方法;并针对受访者特征和物理环境因素影响下的声环境评价分析结果,提出营建符合人们心理需求的舒适居住区声环境设计策略和原则,以最终的成果来指导具体的居住区工程设计实践,从而体现了科研成果的价值转换。
     论文取得了下列创造性研究成果:
     (1)提出了居住区空间结构声环境的影响因子。
     (2)揭示了使用者社会人口特征对居住区声环境评价影响的规律。
     (3)探寻了居住区公共空间声环境设计策略。
     本研究主要是以哈尔滨居住区公共空间声环境进行展开,由于我国幅员辽阔,各地空间环境各有不同,因此在今后本方向进一步后续研究中,可找南方(如广州)等地设计院进行深入,以适应全国的运用。
Generally, Pattern construction and overall space environment quality of publicarea in urban are important factors which can influence overall suitable living levelof city. Their quality can influent people’s life seriously, such as negative publicarea of residential area leads people reject public life. Of course, there are still someproblems in using process of public area of residential area, including how to buildcomfortable acoustic environment of public area in residential area. Bad acousticenvironment will harm people’s physiology and mentality, including audition,vision, cardiovascular system, which even will harm people’s nervous system sothat make irritable and fractious emotion. Therefore, suitable acoustic environmentof public area in residential area, sound condition, users, physical environment andother factors can meet comfort level needs of living environment, which can remittheir life pressure and relieve their temper.
     Taking representative public area of typical Harbin residential area as study ofobject, this thesis combines acoustic environment research and public areaconstruction of residential area to study and analysis public area of typical Harbinresidential area roundly and deeply by methods of field research, computer softwaresimulation, questionnaire and statistic analysis to broaden research vision of itssustainable development for establishing evaluation methodology and designstrategy.
     Through researching literature and field study of typical Harbin residentialarea and representative public area, the writer chooses public area of Harbin typicalresidential area to do the field visit by combing computer software simulationanalysis to research influence factors mechanism of sound space distributioncharacteristics and design, which includes district model, construction density,backway, road traffic, space greening, space closure on the level of planning, andbuilding openings, height and variety of spatial organization on the level ofconstruction. Second, through questionnaire survey and analysis about resultcorrelation, the writer studies the relationship among sound, listeners andenvironment in public area of residential area to interpret acoustic environmentvaluation mechanism of users’ sound favor. That is studying the correlation betweensound, including traffic sound, construction sound, commercial design sound,nature sound, human behavior sound, and users’ behavior and socialcharacteristics. Last, combing results of field research and simulation, the writerexplores correlations among physical environment characteristics, design factorsand acoustic environment valuation, and analyzes the influence of general characteristics of acoustic environment and different factors to acousticenvironment valuation of public area in Harbin residential area by the methods ofquestionnaire survey and statistic analysis. In addition, the writer does pointeddesign for constructing comfort acoustic environment in public area of residentialarea. By analyzing anti-noise of typical residential area, the writer puts forwardprioritization plan to acoustic environment of residential space from macroscopicperspective. Moreover, focusing on analysis results of interviewee characteristicsand physical influences factors, the writer puts forward design strategy andprinciple of constructing the acoustic environment which can meet people’spsychological needs. Directing concrete design of residential area, this thesis canembody the value shift of scientific payoffs.
     This thesis gets following achievement:
     (1) Putting forward the influence factors of acoustic environment in spacestructure of residential area.
     (2) Revealing laws of population characteristics of users’ society to acousticenvironment of residential area.
     (3) Exploring acoustic environment design strategy of public area in residentialarea.
     This research focuses on acoustic environment of public area in Harbinresidential area. We can study some southern cities to study in the further researchto adapt to application of nationwide, because different places have differentcharacteristics of space and environment.
引文
[1]吴静.高层建筑室内外声环境评价与分析[D].重庆:重庆大学学位论文,2007:7.
    [2]康健,杨威.城市公共开放空间中的声景[J].世界建筑,2002(6):76.
    [3]建设部.声环境国家标准与指南[M].中国建筑工业出版社,2000.
    [4] Jacobs.美国大城市的生与死[M].金衡山,译.译林出版社,2005.
    [5]林玉莲,胡正凡.环境心理学[M].中国建筑工业出版社,2000.
    [6]秦佑国.声景学的范畴[J].建筑学报,2005(1):46.
    [7]葛剑敏,王佐民,洪宗辉,等.改善城市人居环境噪声的方法及应用分析[J].工程建设与设计,2003(3):78.
    [8] Marialena N. Rediscovering the Urban Realm and Open Spaces(RUROS),2004.
    [9] Kang J. Urban sound environment[M]. Taylor&Francis,2006:18-61.
    [10] Mudri L, Lenard J D. ComforTab. and/or pleasant ambience: conflicting issues?Proceeding of Plea. Cambridge. UK,2000.
    [11] Griffiths I D, Landon F J, Swan M A. Subjective effects of traffic noiseexposure: reliability and seasonal effects[J]. Journal of sound and vibration,1980,71:227-240.
    [12] Recuero M, Blancomartin E, Grundman J. Study of the acoustical environmentof a city[M]. Proceedings of InterNoise, Liverpool, UK.1996.
    [13] Vallet M, Vernet I, Champerlovier P, Maurin M. A road traffic noise index forthe night time[M].. Proceedings of InterNoise, Liverpool, UK,1996.
    [14] Porteous J D, Mastin J F. Soundscape. Journal of Architectural and PlanningResearch,1985:2,169-186.
    [15] Porteous J D. Environmental Aesthetics–Ideas, Politics and PlanningLondon[M]. Routledge Press,1996.
    [16] Apfel R E. Deaf Architects and Blind Acousticians–A Guide to the Principlesof Sound Design New Haven[M]. Apple Enterprises Press,1998.
    [17] Carles J L, Barrio I L, Delucio J V. Sound influence on landscape values[J].Landscape and Urban Planning.1999:43,191-200.
    [18] Southworth M. The sonic environment of cities[J]. Environment and Behavior,1969:1,49-70.
    [19] Viollon S. Two examples of audiovisual interactions in an urban context[M]..Proceedings of EuroNoise, Naples,2003, Italy.
    [20] Maffiolo Z, David S, Dubois D, Vogel C, Castellengo M.Soundcharacterization of urban environment. Proceedings of interNoise,Budapest, Hungary.1997.
    [21] Tsai KT, Lai P R. The research of the interaction between the environmentalsound and sight.Proceedings of the17th International Congress onAcoustics(ICA), Rome, Italy,2001.
    [22] Hashimoto T, Hatano S. Effect of factors other than sound to the perception ofsoundquality. Proceedings of the17th International Congress on Acoustics(ICA), Rome, Italy,2001.
    [23] Yoichi A, Peter C. Theory of planning physical environments incorporatingtemporal and spatial factors[C].城市化进程中的建筑与城市物理环境.华南理工大学出版社,2008:16-19.
    [24] Edmund N M, Chu P S, Ng C K, Lee C W, et al. Use of GIS and Interactive3DTechnology to Enhance Visualization of Acoustical Environment[C]. The2005Congress and Exposition on Noise Control Engineering. Rio de JaneiroBrazil,2005(8):7-10.
    [25] Alais, D, Burr D, Carlile S. Audiovisual Interactions in The Perception ofSpace and Time[C]. International Congress on Acoustics–Ica2007.madrid,2007.
    [26] T KangTing, L RongPing. The Research of the Interactions Between theEnvironmental Sound and Sight[C].2007.
    [27] EU. Direcrive2002/49/EC[S].2002:4.
    [28] Aboqudais S A, Alhiary A. Effect of distance from intersection on developedtraffic equivalent noise levels[J]. Canadian Journal of Civil Engineering.2004,31(4):53-58.
    [29] Kluijver H, Stoter J. Noise mapping and GIS: optimising quality andefficiency of noiseeffect studies[J]. Computer Environment and UrbanSystems,2003(27):85-102.
    [30] Klxboe R, Engelien E, Steinnes M. Context sensitive noise impact mapping.AppliedAcoustics[J].2006(67):620-642.
    [31] Vos P H. De Europese dosismaten Ldenen Lnight[J]. In Proceedings of NSGGeluidshinderdag, Utrecht Dutch,2001:2115..
    [32]冯晓飞.基于Cadna/A的城市交通噪声预测和noising mapping研究[D].天津:南开大学学位论文,2010:59-60.
    [33]康健.城市声环境论[M].北京:科学技术出版社,2011:126-131.
    [34]冯雅,杨红,陈启高.中国传统四合院式民居的生态环境[J].重庆建筑大学学报,1994(4):24-27.
    [35]袁晓梅,吴硕贤.拙政园的隔声降噪功能研究[J].建筑科学,2007(11):75-78.
    [36]李英,王玉卓,邹越.旧住宅小区改造的声环境规划设计研究[J].城市问题,2008(3).
    [37]蔡春颖.重庆住宅小区声环境模拟与控制研究[D].重庆:重庆大学学位论文,2006.
    [38]李国祺.声景研究与声景设计[D].北京:清华大学博士学位论文,2004:64-68.
    [39]邰惠鑫.城市住区的声景研究[D].南京:东南大学博士学位论文,2004:93.
    [40]郭昊栩,吴硕贤.对高校教学建筑的满意度调查与统计分析[C].城市化进程中的建筑与城市物理环境[M].华南理工大学出版社,2008:695-699.
    [41]葛坚,罗晓予,沈婷婷,燕艳.城市开放空间GIS声景观图及其声景观解析中的应用[C].城市化进程中的建筑与城市物理环境.华南理工大学出版社,2008:118-121.
    [42]刘琦.建筑物理环境设计[M].中国水利水电出版社,2010:13.
    [43]孙秀敏,徐忆红,颜淼,郭宇红.住区交通噪声污染影响分析及防治对策的研究[J].辽宁师范大学学报,2007,30(1):121-123.
    [44]苏琰,赵越喆,吴硕贤.临街住宅小区环境噪声预测[J].噪声与振动控制,2007:55-58.
    [45]刘培杰,孙海涛,赵越喆,吴硕贤.居住小区交通噪声预测评价[J].噪声与振动控制,2009:140-143.
    [46]过春燕,卢向明.德国Cadna/A环境噪声模拟软件在公路交通预测中的应用[J].商丘职业技术学院学报,2002,1(3):12-16.
    [47] http://www.wikipedia.org/.
    [48]罗亚蒙.宜居:我国第三大城市理论[J/OL].http://info.uPla.cn/html/2006/1123/8854.shtml.
    [49] http://wwtv.upla.cn/special/yijues/article_8774.shtml.
    [50]杨·盖尔.交往与空间[M].中国建筑工业出版社,2002.10.
    [51]卢淑华.社会统计学[M].第三版.北京:北京大学出版社,1989:18-19.
    [52]艾尔巴比.社会研究方法[M].邱泽奇,译.第11版.北京:华夏出版社,2009.
    [53]李勤.现代住区户外空间环境“交互性”设计方法研究[D].南京:东南大学,2006.
    [54]吴明隆. SPSS统计应用实务——问卷分析与应用统计[M],北京:科学出版社,2003:36-42.
    [55]赖国毅,陈超. SPSS17.0中文版常用功能与应用实例精讲[M].电子工业出版社,2010:28-29.
    [56] Kang Jian. Urban Soundscape[J]. Journal of South China University ofTechnology,2005,10(35):11-16.
    [57] Ronald F. Czaja, Johnny Blair(美).抽样调查设计导论[M].沈崇麟,译.重庆:重庆大学出版社,2007.04.
    [58][58]王建侠.不同启动情绪状态下的态度变化研究[D].华南师范大学硕士论文.2008.
    [59] Zhang Mei, Kang Jian. Acrosscultural semantic differ entail analysis of thesoundscape in urban open public spaces[J]. Technical Acoustics,2006,25(6):523-532.
    [60]刘培杰,孙海涛,赵越喆,吴硕贤.居住小区交通噪声预测评价[J].噪声与振动控制,2009:140-143.
    [61]柳孝图编.建筑物理[M].北京:中国建筑工业出版社,2010:310-312.
    [62]冯晓飞.基于Cadna/A的城市交通噪声预测和noising mapping研究[D].天津:南开大学学位论文,2010:59-60.
    [63] Yang W, Kang J. Acoustic Comfort Evaluation in Urban Open Public Squares.Journal of Urban Design[J].2005,10(1):69-88.
    [64] Kang J. Urban sound environment[M]. Taylor&Francis,2006:18-61.
    [65]朱艺婷,翟国庆,高婷婷,等.低频环境噪声对思维判断能力的干扰影响[J].环境科学,2008,04:1144-1147.
    [66]李成,王波.城市物理环境与人体健康[J].工业建筑,2003,33(7):89-90.
    [67]刘德智.统计学[M].清华大学出版社,2007:67-68.
    [68]孟琪.地下商业街声景研究[D].哈尔滨:哈尔滨工业大学,2010:69-117.
    [69]郑有飞.人体舒适度及舒适度指数计算[J].气象教育与科技,2000,54(2):7-10.
    [70]冯定原,邱新法.我国各地四季感热温度的计算和分析[J].南京,气象学院学报.1990,13(1):71-79.
    [71] Kaczmarska A, Luczak A. A study of annoyance caused by low frequencynoise during mental work [J]. International Journal of Occupational Safety andErgonomics,2007,13(2):117-125.
    [72]孟小峰.重庆主城区空气质量时空分布及其影响因素研究[C],2011:16.
    [73] Defiance J, Jean P. Integration of the noise barrier caps in a3D ray tracingmethodn[J]. Case of a T shaped diffracting device,2003,64(8):765-780.
    [74] Minamihara H, Ohta M, Nishimura M, Takakuwa Y. Estimation method of Lxfor arbitrary random noises based on the limited fluctuation level range[J]. theAcoustical Society of Japan.1995.(8):185.
    [75] Kang J. Sound Propagation in Interconnected Urban Streets: A ParametricStudy[J]. Environment and Planning: Planning and Design,2001,28:28-194.
    [76] Kang J. Sound Propagation in Street Canyons:Comparison between Diffuselyand Geometrically Reflecting Boundaries[J]. The Journal of AcousticalSociety of America,2000,107:1394-1404.
    [77] Kang J. Acoustics of Long Space:Theory and Design Guide[M]. London:Thomas Telford Publishing,2002.
    [78] Kang J. Numerical Modelling of the Sound Fields in Urban Square [J]. Journalof Acoustical Society of America,2005,117:3695-3706.
    [79] Picaut J. Experimental Study of Sound Propagation in a Street[J]. AppliedAcoustics,2005,66:149-173.
    [80] Wang B, Kang J, Zhou J. Comparison of Traffic Noise Distribution betweenHigh and Low Density Cities[C]. Internoice, Shanghai, China,2008.
    [81]冯雅,杨红,陈启高.中国传统四合院式民居的生态环境[J].重庆建筑大学学报,1999(4):24-27.
    [82]蔡春颖.重庆住宅小区声环境模拟及控制研究[D].重庆:重庆大学,2006.
    [83]周兆驹,孙明霞,盖磊,等.村庄布局及院落形式对交通噪声衰减的影响[J].山东建筑工程学院学报,2006(3):223-225.
    [84]袁晓梅,吴硕贤.拙政园的隔声降噪功能研究[J].建筑科学,2007(11):75-78.
    [85]李英,王玉卓,邹越.旧住宅小区改造的声环境规划设计研究[J].城市问题,2008(3).
    [86] Southworth M, The Sonic Environment of Cities[J]. Environment andBehavior,1969(1):49-70.
    [87] Schafer R M. The Tuning of the World[M]. New York: Knopf,1977(Reprintedas Our Sonic Environment and the Soundscape: The Tuning of the World.DestinyBooks,1994.)
    [88] Tamura A. An Environmental Index Based on Inhabitants’ Recognition ofSounds[C]. Proceedings of the7th International Congress on Noise as a PublicHealth Problem, Sydney, Australia,1998.
    [89] Zhang M, Kang J. A Crosscultural Semantic Differential Analysis of theSoundscape in Urban Open Public Spaces[J]. Technical Acoustics,2006,6:523-532.
    [90] Moreira N, Bryan M. Noise Annoyance Susceptibility[J]. Journal of Sound andVibration,1972,21:449-462.
    [91] Gulian E, Thomas J R. The Effects of Noise, Cognitive Set and Gender onMental Arithmetic Performance[J]. British Journal of Psychology,1986,77:503-511.
    [92] Gifford R. Environment Psychology[M]. Boston: Allyn and Bacon.1996.
    [93] Schulte Fortkamp B, Nitsch W. On Soundscapes and Their Meaning RegardingNoise Annoyance Measurements[C]. Proceedings of InterNoise, FortLauderdale, FL,1999, USA.
    [94] Ellermeier W, Eigenstetter M, Zimmer K. Psychoacoustic Correlates ofIndividual Noise Sensitivity[J]. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,2001:1464-1473.
    [95] Southworth M. The Sonic Environment of Cities[J]. Environment andBehavior,1969,1:49-70.
    [96] Maffiolo V, Castellengo M, Dubois D. Qualitative Judgements of UrbanSoundscapes[C]. Proceedings of internoise99,1999,1251-1254.
    [97] Tsai K T, Lai P R. The Research of the Interactions between the EnvironmentalSound and Sight[C]. Proceedings of the17th International Congress onAcoustics(ICA),2001.
    [98] Hathano S, Hashimoto T. Sound Quality Evaluation of ConstructionMachine[C]. Proceedings of the17th International Congresson Acoustics(ICA), Rome, Italy,2001.
    [99] Viollon S. Two Examples of Audiovisual Interactions in an Urban Context[C].Proceedings of EuroNoise, Naples, Italy,2003.
    [100]Mudri L. Lenard J D, ComforTab. and Pleasant Ambience: ConflictingIssues[C]. Proceeding of PLEA, Cambridge, UK,2000.
    [101]赵旭东.声景以及声音意向设计[D].合肥:合肥工业大学,2005:51-52.
    [102]袁晓梅,吴硕贤.中国古典园林的声景观营造[J].建筑学报,2007(2):70-72.
    [103]Ma H, Wang DD. Research on Soundscape Elements and its PrimaryQuantification of Urban Parks[C]. Internoise2008. ShangHai, China.2008.
    [104]孟琪.地下商业街声景研究与预测[D].哈尔滨:哈尔滨工业大学,2010.
    [105]唐征征.地下商业街声喜好研究[D].哈尔滨:哈尔滨工业大学,2010.
    [106]刘玉莲,周海龙,苍蕴琦.四季分明是哈尔滨气候的显著特征[J].黑龙江气象,2003(4):21-22.
    [107]周旻.城郊住宅小区防噪设计[C].第十届全国建筑物理学术会议论文集(城市化进程中的建筑与城市物理环境).广州:华南理工大学出版社,2008:161-163.
    [108]艾尔巴比.社会研究方法[M].邱泽奇,译.第11版.北京:华夏出版社,2009.
    [109]Kang J. Urban Soundscape[J]. Journal of South China University of Technology,2005,10(35):11-16.
    [110]赵勇.中国历史文化名镇名村保护理论与方法[M].北京:中国建筑工业出版社,2008:81.
    [111]罗应婷,杨钰娟. SPSS统计分析[M].北京:电子工业出版社,2010:1.
    [112]李沛良.社会统计的应用[M].北京:社会科学文献出版社,2002:9.
    [113]http://www.statshlheb.gov.cn/xw!detaPage.action?tid=19371.
    [114]阳建强,吴明伟.现代城市更新[M].南京:东南大学出版社,1999:8.
    [115]王岩,陆彤.哈尔滨道外近代建筑的形态表征[J].低温建筑技术,2006(6).
    [116]Schafer R M. The Soundscape: Our Sonic Environment and the Tuning of theWorld[M]. Rochester(VT): DestinyBooks,1994.
    [117]Yu L, Kang J. Effects of Social, Demographical and Behavioral Factors on theSound Level Evaluation in Urban Open Spaces[J]. The Journal of theAcoustical Society of America,2008,123:772-783.
    [118]Yang W, Kang J. Acoustic Comfort Evaluation in Urban Open PublicSpaces[J]. Applied Acoustics,2005,66:211-229.
    [119]Miedema H M E, Vos H. Demographic and Attitudinal Factors that ModifyAnnoyance from Transportation Noise[J]. The Journal of the AcousticalSociety of America,1999,105:3336-3344.
    [120]Verzini A, Frassoni C, Ortiz A H. A Field Study about Effects of LowFrequency Noises on Man[J]. The Journal of the Acoustical Society ofAmerica,1999,105:942.
    [121]Fields J M. Effect of Personal and Situational Variables on Noise Annoyancein Residential Areas[J]. The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,1993,93:2753-2763.
    [122]Yang W, Kang J. Soundscape and Sound Preferences in Urban Squares[J].Journal of Urban Design,2005,10(1):69-88.
    [123]Yu L, Kang J. Factors Influencing the Sound Preference in Urban OpenSpaces[J]. Applied Acoustics,2010, doi:10.10-16.
    [124]孟琪,康健,金虹.使用者的社会因素对地下商业街主观响度和声舒适度影响的调查研究[J].应用声学,2010(5):371-381.
    [125]Nyuk Hien Wong, Alex Yong Kwang Tan etc. Acoustics Evaluation of VerticalGreenery Systems for Building Walls[J]. Building and Environment,2010(45):411-420.
    [126]Can A, Leclercq L, Lelong J.etc. Traffic Noise Spectrum Analysis:DynamicModeling vs.Experimental Observations[J]. Applied Acoustics,2010(71):764-770.
    [127]VanRenterghem T, Botteldooren D. The Importance of Roof Shape for RoadTraffic Noise Shielding in the Urban Environment. Journal of Sound andVibration,2010(329):1422-1434.
    [128]Joan C. Blanco, Ian Flindell. Property Prices in Urban Areas Affected by RoadTraffic Noise [J]. Applied Acoustics,2010(11):004.
    [129]石福良.寒地城市典型居住区噪声控制研究[D].哈尔滨:哈尔滨工业大学,2010:61.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700