用户名: 密码: 验证码:
异质性视角下团体贷款研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
鉴于团体贷款在世界范围内的广泛运用,以及其在消除贫困、促进落后地区经济发展方面可能发挥的重要作用,考查和研究团体贷款的具体效率和影响因素问题便具有重要的理论意义和实际运用价值。目前针对团体贷款的研究存在着如下一些不足。首先,现有大部分针对团体贷款的研究文献都揭示了团体贷款在解决金融部门“四大难题”上表现出的巨大的优越性,但却没有回答团体贷款与个体贷款相比,是否真的是一种“严格占优”模式的问题。其次,目前的研究没有解释为何目前团体贷款的应用绝大部分都集中在农村,没有回答团体贷款模式可否大规模应用于城市地区的问题。另外,由于现有研究假设上局限的限制,现有研究不能对团体贷款的实践提出有效见解。
     针对上述问题,本文通过理论与实证相结合的方式,在成员异质性的视角下探讨和研究了团体贷款与个体贷款的相对优势问题,以及农村与城市的区别问题,最后根据研究结果本文对金融业管理提出了部分建议。
     总结本文得到的研究结论如下:
     (1)通过对担保物效应、横向监督理论的分析考察,本文发现团体贷款与个体贷款之间不存在严格的优劣关系。横向监督与纵向监督在监督成本与可行性上面临的问题,是制约个体贷款与团体贷款效率差别的重要因素。
     (2)团体贷款中成员异质性的存存会对团体贷款的效率产生诸多影响。由于成员社会身份的不同可能导致调整成本,进而使得团体贷款中出现逆向选择:实行团体贷款区域的原有社会资本存量,社会关系的稳定程度等因素,会直接影响到团体组建成本的大小,以及团体组建发起者的积极性,进而影响团体贷款的效率;在团体贷款中实施动态激励,可以较好的抑制团体贷款中个体的策略性违约行为。
     (3)由于农村和城市地区的人们在生产生活交叉领域、行为间交互影响的纬度、非货币性影响的存在性与否等多方面存在不同,导致了农村和城市地区在社会链接和动态激励问题上出现重大差别,这些差别将在团体贷款的实施或成功产生重要影响。
     (4)在团体贷款中团体成员承担连带责任的概率由其投资成功的概率外生地决定,并且安全团体成员承担连带责任的概率未必小于风险团体成员承担连带责任的概率。贷款项目投资成功概率对团体贷款影响的大小与方向,受到贷款团体规模的作用。
     (5)团体成员的异质性程度,即团体成员的风险异质性会影响团体贷款的效率。当贷款团体内部成员具有很高的相似性时,银行能够通过提供契约组合的方式,让企业家自我选择契约,从而实现团体贷款信贷市场的效率。团体贷款的成功实施,可能并不是依赖某些单一的甄别机制就能够实现的。
     最后,本文通过实验验证并考察了上述因素的具体作用。实验对本文的上述研究成果提供了正面支持。
For the widely use of group-lending in the world, and it's important role in fighting against property, promoting the economic growth in developing countries, it's very valuable for us to pay much attentions in group-lending in both theory and in practice. It is with great meaning to find out that to what content the efficiency can reach and what aspects can influence these efficiencies. However, it is a pity to see that there are many un-efficiencies in the study of group lending. Firstly, most of these studies have point out that group-lending has great power in solving the " Four Problems " in finance sector, but they have not answer the question that whether the group-lending is a strong dominant institution against personal lending? Secondly, the studies since now have not explain the fact that why most use of group-lending institution are in countries, why this "Excellent" institution can not be widely used in cities? Thirdly, for the restraints of default assumptions, normal studies can not give useful suggestions to the finance sector.
     Pointing at these questions, by using theoretical and practice methods, this issue studies the relative advantages of group-lending and personal lending under the angel of member heterogeneities, we also studied the difference of countries and cities, we give some advises to the finance sector at last.
     We conclude my studies as follows:
     (1)By studying the collateral effect, the peer monitoring theory, we find out that there is no absolute advantage relation between group-lending and personal lending. The problems of monitoring cost and possibilities of peer monitoring and direct monitoring, are the main aspects which influence the efficiencies of group-lending and personal lending.
     (2)Member heterogeneities will have many influences in the group-lending efficiency in group-lending institutions.The adjustment costs coming from the member social identities may cause adverse selections in group-lending. The social assets in societies, the stability of social ties will directly affect the costs of constructing a group, it will also influence the incentives of the leaders, and the efficiencies of group-lending. Creating dynamic incentives in group-lending will get many advantages, such as diminishing the strategic defaults in group-lending constructions.
     (3) Because there are many difference between countries and cities, such as the crossing areas in lives, the aspects that can be influenced together, the existing or not of the un-money punishment methods, make the big difference in social ties and dynamic incentives between countries and cities. Those difference will have great impact on the efficiency of group-lending.
     (4)The probabilities of liability that the members should take is determined by the probabilities of investment. It is not sure that the probabilities of safe-member will less than the risk-member.
     (5)The member heterogeneities ,especially the heterogeneities of risks will affect the efficiency of group-lending very much. If the heterogeneities in members is high enough, the bank can screening out the enterprises by offering different contracts. It will get a efficiency market. The successful use of group-lending can not rely on any single screening mechanism.
     At last ,this issue runs an experiment to study the aspects that mentioned above. All the conclusions are backed up by our experiment.
引文
[1]章元,非对称信息下的团体贷款研究[M],上海:上海人民大学出版社,2005
    [2]Hussain,Mahabub,1986," Credit for Alleviation for Rural Property:The Experience of the Grameen Bank in Bangladesh,"[C].Washington,DC:International Food Policy Research Institute and Dhaka:Bangladesh Institute of Development Studies.
    [3]Pitt,M.and S.R.Khandker,1996," Household and Intrahousehold Impacts of Grameen Bank and Similar Targeted Credit Programs in Bangladesh," World Bank Discussion Paper,no 320,Washington DC.
    [4]Pitt,Mark M.and Khandker Pochering,1998," The Impact of Group-Based Credit Programs on Poor Household in Bangladesh:Does the Gender of Participants Matter?"[J]Journal of Political Economy,vol.10G(5),pp.958-996o
    [5]Ghatak,M.,1999." Group lending,local information and peer selection"[J].Journal of Development Economics,vol.60,(27-50).
    [6]Levine,R.,1997," Financial Development and Economic Growth:Views and Agenda,"[J],Journal of Economic Literature 35(2),pp.688-726.
    [7]Hollis,Aidan and Arthur Sweetman,1998," Microcredit:What can we learn from the past?"[J].World Development,vol.25,no.10,pp.1875-1891.
    [8]Barham,B.L.,S.Boucher and M.R.Carter,1996," Credit Constrains,Credit Unions,and Small-scale Producers in Guatemala,"[J].World Development 24(1),pp.793-806.
    [9]Hulme and Mosley,1996,"The role of groups and credit cooperatives in rural lending." The World Bank Research Observer 5,187- 204.
    [10]Grosh,B.,and G.Somolekae,1996," Mighty oaks from Little Acorns:Can Micro-enterprise serve as the seedbed of industrialization?"[J].World Development 24(1),pp.1879-1890.
    [11]Bernasek M.,and S.Stainfield,1997," When and how far is group formation a route out of chronic poverty?" Working Paper,Queen Elizabeth House,Oxford University.
    [12]Morduch,Jonathan,1999," The Microfinance Promise,"[J].Journal of Economic Literature,vol.37,4,pp.1569-1614.
    [13]Tohtong,Chamlong,1988," Joint Liability Groups for Small Farmer Credit:The BAAC Experience in Thailand,"[J].Rural Development in Practice,vol.1,pp.4-7.
    [14]罗绒战堆:《西藏的贫困与反贫困问题研究》,中国藏学出版社,2002版
    [15]茅于轼.小额贷款为什么大多失败,http://club,cat898,com/newbbs/list,asp?boardid=3
    [16]汤敏、姚先斌:《孟加拉“乡村银行”的小额贷款扶贫模式》,载《改革》,1996年第4期.
    [17]Williamson,O.(1979)."Transaction-Cost Economics:The Governance of Contractual Relations," Journal of Law and Economics,22(October):233-261.
    [18]Williamson,O.(1975).Markets and Hierarchies:Analysis and Antitrust Implications.New York:Free Press.a
    [19]Alchian,hrmen and Demsetz,Harold,1972."Production,Information Costs and Economic Organization",American Economic Review,62(50):777-795
    [20]Jones,Derek C.and Takao Kato,1995," The Productivity Effects of Employee Stock-Ownership Plans and Bonuses:Evidence from Japanese Panel Data."[J].American Economic Review,vol.85,no.3,pp.391-414.
    [21]Williamson,O.(1985).The Economic Institutions of Capitalism.New York:Free Press.
    [22]张维迎,邓峰,《信息、信任与连带责任:对中国古代连坐、保甲制度的法和经济学解释》[J],载《中国社会科学》2003年第3期
    [23]Rhea,N.,1987," People Make Productivity Work in a Jet Engine Parts Plant,"[J].Target,Journal of Association for Manufacturing Excellence(Spring),pp.35-38.
    [24]Puckett,J.H.and J.Pacheco,1990," Excellence at XEL Communications:Self-directed Work Teams,"[J].Target,Journal of Association for Manufacturing Excellence.(Spring),pp.22-27.
    [25]Aaron,H.,1990." Making Incentives Pay During A Recession,"[J].Management Journal in the Wall Street Journal,October 29,pp.A14.
    [26]Chinn,D.L.,1979," Team Cohesion and Collective Labor Supply in Chinese Agriculture,"[J].Journal of Chinese Economics,vol.3,pp.375-394.
    [27]Arnott,R.and Joseph Stiglitz,1991," Moral Hazard and Non-Market Institutions Dysfunctional Crowding Out or Peer Monitoring?"[J].American Economic Review.March,pp.179-190.
    [28]Zingales,L.,2000,"In Search of New Foundations." NBER Working Paper no.7706,published in Journal of Finance,vol.55,no.4
    [29]Besley,Timothy and Steven Coate(1995),"Group Lending,Repayment Incentives and Social Collateral," Journal of Development Economics 46:1-18.
    [30]Conlin,Michael(1999),Peer group micro-lending programs in Canada and the United States,Journal of Development Economics,60,249-269.
    [31]Wenner,M.(1995),Group credit.A means to improve information transfer and loan repayment performance.Journal of Development Studies,32,263-281.
    [32]Wydick,Bruce(1999):Can social Cohesion be harnessed to repair market failures?Evidence from group lending in Guatemala,The Economic Journal,109,463-475.
    [33]GUINNANE,Timothy W.(1994):A failed institutional transplant:Raiffeisen credit cooperatives in Ireland 1894-1914,Explorations in Economic History,31,38-61.
    [34]Varian,Hal R.(1990):Monitoring Agents with Other Agents,Journal of Institutional and Theoretical Economics,146,153-174.
    [35]Stiglitz,Joseph E.(1990):Peer monitoring and credit markets.World Bank Economic Review,4,351-366.
    [36]Banerjee,Abhijit,Timothy Besley,and Timothy Guinnane(1994),"The Neighbor' s Keeper:The Design of a Credit Cooperative with Theory and a Test" Quarterly Journal of Economics 109:491-515.
    [37]Akerlof,G.(1970),"The Market for Lemons:Quality Uncertainty and the Market Mechanish" Quarterly Journal of Economics 89:488-500.
    [38]Ghatak,Maitreesh(1995),"Group Lending and the Peer Selection Effect",Draft,Harward University,November.
    [39]Kandel,E.and Edward Lazer,1992," Peer Pressure and Partnerships,"[J].Journal of Political Economy.vol.100,no.4,pp.801-817.
    [40]Baron,J.N.and Kathy Paulson Gjerde,1997," Peer Pressure in an Agency Relationship,"[J].Journal of Labor Economics,vol.15,no.2,pp.234-254.
    [41]Ghatak,M.,Guinnane,W.T.,1999.The economics of lending with joint liability:Theory and practice.Journal of Development Economics,vol.60,(195-228).
    [42]Armendariz de Aghion,Beatriz(1999),"On the Design of a Credit Agreement with Peer Monitoring," Journal of Development Economics 60:401-420.
    [43]Conning,Jonathan(1996),Group lending,Moral Hazard,and the Creation of Social Collateral,Working Paper,Center for Institutional Reform and the Informal Sector,University of Maryland at College Park.
    [44]Zeller,Mansfred,1998," Determinants of Repayment Performance in Credit Groups:The Roll of Program Design,Intra-group Risk Pooling,and Social Cohesion,"[J].Economic Development and Culture Change,pp.599-620.
    [45]Wydick,Bruce,2000," Group Lending under Dynamic Incentives as A Borrower Discipline Device,"[J],Review of Development Economics 4:345-364.
    [46]Huppi,M.,Feder,G.,1990.The role of groups and credit cooperatives in rural lending.The World Bank Research Observer 5,187-204.
    [47]Che,Yeon-Koo(2001),Joint Liability and Peer Monitoring under Group Lending,Working Paper,Department of Economics,University of Wisconsin-Madison.
    [48]Conning,Jonathan(2000),Monitoring by the Delegates or by Peers? Joint Liability Loans under Moral Hazard,Working Paper,Williams College Center of Development Economics.
    [49]Madajewicz,Margaret(1999),Capital for the Poor:The Effect of Wealth on the Optimal Credit Contract,Colombia University,Memo.
    [50]Floro,Sagrario L.,and Pan A.Yotopoulos(1991),Informal Credit Markets and the New Institutional Economics:The Case of the Philippine Agriculture,Westview Press,Boulder.
    [51]Besley,Timothy and Steven Coate(1995),"Group Lending,Repayment Incentives and Social Collateral," Journal of Development Economics 46:1-18.
    [52]Wydick,Bruce(1996),Credit Access for Household Enterprises in Developing Countries under Asymmetric Information,PhD Thesis,University of California at Berkeley.
    [53]Wydick,Bruce(2001),"Group Lending under Dynamic Incentives as a Borrower Discipline Device," Review of Development Economics 5:406-420.
    [54]路易斯·普特曼,兰德尔·克罗茨纳:企业的经济性质[M].上海:上海财经大学出版社,2000。
    [55]埃瑞克·G.菲吕博顿,鲁道夫·瑞切特:新制度经济学[M].上海:上海财经大学出版社,1998。
    [56]Bergstrom,T.,L.Blumeand H.Varian,On the Private Provision of Public Goods[J],Journal of Public Economics,29(1986),25-49.
    [57]Dayton-Johnson,J.,P.Bardhan,Inequality and Conservation on the Local Commons:A Theoretical Exercise[J],Economic Journal 112(2002),577-6020
    [58]Bardhan,P.,Analytics of the Institutions of Informal Cooperation in Rural Development[J],World Development,1993,21(4),633-639.
    [59]Kanbur,R.,Heterogeneity,distribution,and cooperation in common property resource management,Policy Research Working Paper WPS 844(1992),World Bank:Washington,D.C。
    [60]Hackett,C.,Heterogeneity and the provision of governance for common-pool resources[J],Journal of Theoretical Politics,(1992)4,325-342.
    [61]Ostrom,E.,Crafting Institutions for Self-6overning Irrigation Systems,ICS Press,San Francisco,California(1992).
    [62]Bergstrom,C.T.,The algebra of assortative encounters and the evolution of cooperation[J],international game theory review,5(3),2003,211-228.
    [63]Baland,J.M.,Platteau,J.P.,Wealth inequality and efficiency in the commons:I.The unregulated Case[J],Oxford Economic Papers,49(1997),451-482.
    [64]Johnson,D.,P.Bardhan,Inequality and Conservation on the Local Commons:A Theoretical Exercise[J],Economic Journal,2002(112),577-602.
    [65]曾军平,集体行动的个体异质效应研究[J],财经研究,2004,3.
    [66]焦少飞,农村强势成员与农村公共产品供给[J],财经科学,2006.6。
    [67]Armendariz de Aghion,B.and J.Morduch,2005,"The Economics of microfinance,"[M]MIT press,Cambridge Massachusetts.
    [68]Becchetti L.,Durante,R.and S.Sambataro,2005,"A matching of two promises:microfinance and social responsibility",mimeo,University of Tor Vergata.
    [69]Chowdhury P.R.,2005,"Group-Lending:Sequential Financing,Lender Monitoring and Joint Liability",Journal of Development Econrnics,vol.77,pp.415-439.
    [70]Townsend R.and K.Ueda,2001,"Transitional growth with increasing inequality and financial deepening" IMF working paper,01 no.108.
    [71]Conning J.,2005,"Monitoring by Delegates or by Peers? Joint Liability Loans under Moral Hazard",Paper presented at the international conference "Does Microfinance Work?",Groningen,The Netherlands,1-2 July 2005.
    [72]ISAAC,R.Mark and James M.WALKER(1988):Communication and free riding behavior:the voluntary contribution mechanism,Economic Inquiry,26,585-608.
    [73]Gangopadhyay S.,M.Ghatak and R.Lensink,2005,"On Joint Liability and the Peer Selection Effect",forthcoming.
    [74]MOSLEY,Paul and Rudra Prasad DAHAL(1987):Credit for the Rural Poor:A Comparison of Policy Experiments in Nepal and gangladesh.Manchester Papers on Development,3,45-59.
    [75]DEVEREUX,John and,Rauymond P.H.FISHE(1993):An Economic Analysis of Group Lending Programs in Developing,Developing Economies,31,102-121.
    [76]IMPAVIDO,Gregorio(1998):Credit rationing,group lending and optimal group size,Annals of Public and Cooperative Economics,69,243-260.
    [77]Buckley,Graeme(1996):Rural and agricoltural credit in Malawi:A study of the Malawi Mudzi Fund and the smallholder agricultural credit administration,in:David Hulme and Paul Mosley(eds):Finance Against Poverty,London:Routledge.
    [78]Foss,Nicolai J.,1999."The Theory of the Firm:an Introduction to Themes and Contributions",Theories of the Firm:Critical Perspectives in Economic Organization,London:Rout ledge
    [79]Coase,R.(1937)."The Nature of the Firm," Economica N.S.,4:386-405.
    [80]Jensen,Michael and William Meckling,1976."Theory of the Firm:Managerial Behavior,Agency Costs and Ownership structure",Journal of Financial Economics 3: 305-360.
    [81] Holmstrom, Bengt and Paul Milgrom, 1994. "The Firm as an Incentive System" ,American Economic Review, 84(4):927-991
    [82] Grossman, S., and O. Hart , 1986, "The Costs and Benefits of Ownership: A Theory of Vertical and Lateral Integration, " [J], Journal of Political Economy, 94, 691-719.
    [83] Hart, Oliver, and John Moore , (1990) "Property Rights and the Nature of the Firm, "Journal of Political Economy 98: 1119-5
    [84] Hart, O. (1995), Firms, Contracts, and Financial Structure. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
    [85] Williamson, O. (1979). "Transaction-Cost Economics: The Governance of Contractual Relations," Journal of Law and Economics, 22 (October): 233-261.
    [86] Williamson, O. (1996). The Mechanisms of Governance. New York: Oxford University Press
    [87] Oliver E. Williamson. 2000. "Why Law, Economics, and Organization? ". Working Paper
    [88] Sen, A., 1999. Reason before identity. Oxford India Paperbacks.
    [89] Akerlof, G., Kranton, R., 2000. Economics and identity. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, vol. 115, (715-753).
    [90] Alesina, A , La Ferrara, E., 2000. Participation in heterogeneous communities.The Quarterly Journal of Economics, vol. 115, (847-904).
    [91] Hirshleifer, D. and T. Rasmusen, 1989, " Corporation in a Repeated Prisoners'Dilemma with Ostracism," [J],Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization,vol. 12, pp. 1-31.
    [92] Masters, R. D., 1984, " Ostracism, Voice, and Exit: The Biology of Social Participation," [J]. Social Science Informaiton, vol. 23, pp. 877-893.
    [93] Luthans, F., 1985, " Organizational Behavior, " .McGraw -Hill.
    [94] Bolton, Patrick and David S. Scharfstein, 1990, " A Theory of Predation Based on Agency Problems in Financial Contracting," [J], American Economic Review, March, pp. 93-106.
    [95] Woolcock, Micael J. V., 1999, " Learning from Failures in Microfinance: What Unsuccessful Cases Tell Us About How Group-Based Programs Work, " [J]. American Journal of Economics and Sociology, vol. 58, pp. 17-42.
    [96] Besley, T., 1995. Savings, credit and insurance. In: Chenery, H. Srinivasan, T. N.Eds. , Handbook of Development Economics, Vol. 3A. North-Holland, Amsterdam, pp.2123-2207.
    [97] Fehr, E.,S., G(?)chter, G. Kirchsteiger , Reciprocity as a Contract Enforcement Device[J], Econometrica 65, (1997), 833-860。
    [98] Spagnolo, G., 1999, " Social Relations and Cooperation in Organizations," [J].Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization, vol. 38, pp. 1-25.
    [99] Granovetter, M., 1985, " Economic Action and Social Structure: The Problem of Embeddedness, " [J]. American Journal of Sociology 23, pp. 481-580.
    [100] Baron, J. N., 1988, " The Employment Relation as A Social Relation, " [J]. Journal of the Japanese and International Economics, 2/4, pp. 492-525.
    [101] Thorp, R., Stewart, F., Heyer, A., 2003. When and how far is group formation a route out of chronic poverty? Working Paper, Queen Elizabeth House, Oxford University.
    [102]Goldstein,M.,2000.Intra-household allocation and farming in Southern Ghana,Ph.D.dissertation,University of California at Berkeley.
    [103]Fafchamps,M.,Lund,S.,2000.Risk-sharing networks in rural Philippines,Working Paper,University of Oxford.
    [104]De Weerdt,J.,2002.Risk-sharing and endogenous network formation,Working Paper,K.U.Leuven.
    [105]Mondal,W.,Tune,R.,1993.Replicating the Grameen Bank in North Aerica:The Good Faith Fund experience.In:Walid,A.N.M.(Ed.),The Grameen Bank:Poverty relief in Bangladesh,Westview Press,San Francisco.
    [106]Coke,R.2002.Household bargaining power and micro-finance default:Evidence from the Philippines.Working paper,Belmont University.
    [107]Godquin,M.,2002.Objective repayment rates in Bangladesh and their determinants:How to improve the efficiency of the attribution of loans by MFIs? Working Paper,
    [108]Olomola,A.,2000.Determinants of the smallholder loan repayment performance:Evidence from the Nigerian microfinance system,Working Paper,NISER Ibadan.
    [109]Rahman,A.,1999.Microcredit initiatives for equitable and sustainable development:Who pays? World Development,vol.27,(67-82).
    [110]Khandekar,S.,Khalily,B.,and Khan,Z.,1995.Grameen Bank:Performance and sustainability.World Bank Discussion Paper 306,Washington DC.
    [111]Coke,R.2002.Household bergaining power and micro-finance default:Evidence from the Philippines.Working paper,Belmont University.
    [112]Alesina,A.,La Ferrara,E.,2000.Participation in heterogeneous communities.The Quarterly Journal of Economics,vol.115,(847-904).
    [113]朱宪辰,李玉连,《领导、追随与社群合作的集体行动--行业协会反倾销诉讼的案例分析》,《经济学(季刊)》,2007年第2期
    [114]Elinor Ostrom,Collective Action and the Evolution of Social Norms[J],Journal of Economic Perspectives,(2000) 14,137- 158。
    [115]La ferrara,Inequality and Group Participation:Theory and Evidence from Rural Tanzania[J],Journal of Public Economics,(2002) 85:235-73。
    [116]Dayton-Johnson,J,Irrigation organization in Mexican unidades de rlego:results of a field study[J],Irrigation and Drainage Systems,1999,13,55 -74。
    [117]Heckathorn,D.W.,Collective action and group heterogeneity:Voluntary provision versus selective incentives[J],American Sociological Review(1993) 58,329-a50。
    [118]Chan,K.S.,S.,Mestelman,R.,Moir,andR.A.,Muller,The Voluntary Provision of Public Goods under Varying Income Distributions[J],Canadian Journal of Economics,1996,29(1),54-69。
    [119]Johnson,D.,P.Bardhan,Inequality and Conservation on the Local Commons:A Theoretical Exercise[J],Economic Journal,2002,112,577-602。
    [120]Chan,K.S.,S.Mestelman,R.Moir,and R.A.Muller,Heterogeneity and the Voluntary Provision of Public Goods[J],Experimental Economics,1999,2,5-30。
    [121]Kazuo,Y.,Subjective Rationality of Initiators and of Threshold-Theoretical Behavior of Followers in Collective Action:TheoreticalInsight from Non-Expected Utility Models[J],Rationality and Society,(2000) 12,2,185-225。
    [122]青木昌彦,比较制度分析[M],上海远东出版社,2001,2
    [123]Elster,J.,Emotions and Economic Theory[J],Journal of Economic Perspectives 36(1998):47-74。
    [124] Frank, R. H., melding sociology and economics:james coleman' s foundations of social theory[J], journal of economic literature,30, 1992, 147-170。
    [125] Sartorius, C., The Evolution of Social Norms and Values by Means of Social Group Selection[J], Constitutional Political Economy 13 (2002), 149-172。
    [126] Witt, U., Social Cognitive Learning and Group Selection - A Game-theoretic Version of Hayek' s Societal Evolution[J], Austrian Economics and Game Theory, 2000,8 (1), 123-145。
    [127] Ghatak, M., 1997. Group lending contracts and the peer selection effect. Working Paper, University of Chicago.
    [128] Rothschild, M., Stiglitz, J., 1976. Equilibrium in competitive insurance markets:an essay on the economics of imperfect information. Quarterly Journal of Economics 80,629 - 649.
    [129] Riley, J.G., 1979. Informational equilibrium. Econometrica 47, 331-360.
    [130] Spence, A.M., 1974. Market Signaling. Harvard Univ. Press, Cambridge.
    [131] Ghatak, Maitreesh (2000): Screening by the company you keep: Joint liability lending and the peer selection effect. The Economic Journal, 110, 601-631.
    [132] Tassel, E. Van. Group lending under asymmetric information. Journal of Development Economics. Vol. 60 1999 3 - 25
    [133] 章元,《论团体贷款对信贷市场低效率的可能改进》,《经济研究》[J], 2005年第1期.
    [134] Conlin , Michael (1999): Peer group micro-lending programs in Canada and the United States, Journal of Development Economics, 60, 249-269.
    [135] Armendariz De Aghion, Beatriz and Jonathan Morduch (2000): Microfinance beyond group lending, Economics of Transition, 8, 401-420.
    [136] IMPAVIDO, Gregorio (1998): Credit rationing, group lending and optimal group size, Annals of Public and Cooperative Economics, 69, 243-260.
    [137] Barr , Abigail, and Bill K (2002): Do Men Really have no Shame? Working paper,University of Oxford.
    [138] LEDGERWOOD, Joanna (1999): Microfinance Handbook. World Bank, Washington D. C.
    [139] MORDUCH, Jonathan (1999): The microfinance promise, Journal of Economics Literature, 37, 1569-1614.
    [140] GOETZ, Anne Marie and Rina SEN GUPTA (1996): Who Takes The Credit? Gender, Power and Control over Loan Use in Rural Credit Programmes in Bangladesh, World Development,24, 45-63.
    [141] KABEER, Naila (2001): Conflicts Over Credit: Re-Evaluationg the Empowerment Potential of Loans to Women in Rural Bangladesh, World Development, 29, 63-84.
    [142] SULEIMAN, Ramzi , Taly WEISS and Gary BORNSTEIN (2002): The Enhancing Effect of Uncertainty about Individual Endowments on the Provision of Public Goods, mimeo, Hebrew University Jerusalem
    [143] GACHTER, Simon and Ernst FHER(1999): Collective action as a social exchange,Journal of Economic Behavior and organization, 39, 341-369.
    [144] DAWES, Robyn M., Jeanne MCTAVISH and Harriet SHAKLEE (1977): Behavior,communication, and assumptions about other people's behavior in commons dilemma situation, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 35, 1-11.
    [145] ISAAC, R. Mark, Kenneth F. MCCUE and Charles R. PLOTT (1985) : Public goods provision in an experimental environment, Journal of Public Economics, 26, 51-74.
    [146] ISAAC, R. Mark and James M. WALKER (1988): Communication and free riding behavior:the voluntary contribution mechanism, Economic Inquiry, 26, 585-608.
    [147] ISAAC, R. Mark and James M. WALKER (1991): Costly communication: An experiment in nested public goods problem, in: Laboratory Research in Political Economy, Thomas Palfrey (ed.), Ann Arbor University of Michigan Press, 269-286.
    [148] BOHNET, Iris and Bruno S. FREY (1999): The sound of silence in prisoner' s dilemma and dictator games, Journal of Economic Behavior and organization, 38, 43—57.
    [149] VAN DIJK, Frans, Joep SONNEMANS and Frans VAN WINDEN (2002): Social Ties in a Public good Experiment. Journal of Public Economics, 85, 275-299.
    [150] RANDTS , Jordi, Arno RIEDL and Frans VAN WINDEN (2002): Competitive Rivalry and Social Ties. An Experimental Study, mimeo. Institut d' An(?)lisi Econ(?)mica (CSIC),Barcelona.
    [151] ISAAC, R. Mark, James M. WALKER and Arlington W. WILLIAMS (1994): Group Size and the voluntary provision of public goods, Journal of Public Economics, 54, 1—36.
    [152] CARPENTER, Jeffrey P. (2002): Punishing Free-Riders: how group size affects mutual monitoring and the provision of public goods, Middlebury College Working Paper Series No. 0206.
    [153] SELTEN, Peinhard and Axel OCKENFELS (1998): An experimental solidarity game,Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization, 34, 517-539.
    [154] STIGLITZ, Joseph E. and Andrew WEISS (1981): Credit Rationing in Markets with Imperfect Information, The American Economic Review, 71, 393-410.
    [155] ARMENDARIZ DE AGHION , Beatriz and Christian GOLLIER (2000): Peer group formation in an adverse selection model, The Economic Journal, 110, 632-643.
    [156] Kreps, David M., Paul Milgrom, John Roberts, and Robert Wilson, 1982, Rational Cooperation in the Finitely Repeated Prisoner's Dilemma, Journal of Economic Theory,27, pp. 245-252.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700