用户名: 密码: 验证码:
区域市场化、管理层权力与高管薪酬契约
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
高管薪酬历来是备受争议的话题之一。特别是由美国次贷危机引发的全球金融海啸全面爆发以来,华尔街金融机构高管获得动辄上千万美元的高额年薪和“突击分红”行为被推上舆论的风口浪尖;而中国上市公司高管“天价薪酬”与“零薪酬”并存的混乱景象也引起了社会公众的广泛关注。虽然有关高管基于其权力影响自定薪酬的报道频繁见诸报端,但中国学者对此鲜有论述。本文基于中国的制度背景,从管理层权力的视角,结合区域市场化的动态变迁过程对高管薪酬契约问题进行较为系统而深入的研究,以期为完善中国上市公司高管薪酬激励制度以及提高高管薪酬契约的有效性提供理论参考与经验依据。
     本文在理论综述与制度背景分析的基础上,提出中国上市公司的高管权力在市场化改革过程中得以逐步形成和扩大,且内生于“一股独大”和“内部人控制”等的公司内部治理缺陷为中国上市公司高管利用其权力影响薪酬契约的行为提供了足够的空间;而外部治理机制尚不健全又使得对高管权力寻租行为的监督难以到位。因此,本文根植于区域市场化非均衡的制度背景,探讨中国上市公司高管薪酬契约的管理层权力效应及其与区域市场化的交互效应,并进一步检验区域市场化对管理层权力与高管薪酬契约有效性之间关系的塑造效应,具有重要的理论与现实意义。
     本文首先以2004~2010年中国A股上市公司为研究样本,通过建立面板数据多元回归模型对管理层权力与高管薪酬之间的关系进行检验,研究发现:管理层权力与高管实际货币薪酬、实际在职消费、超额货币薪酬以及超额在职消费之间存在显著的正相关关系,即管理层权力越大,高管从企业获取的货币薪酬和在职消费金额越高,且其攫取的超额货币薪酬和超额在职消费等私有收益的金额也越高。但在不同所有制性质的企业中,高管运用其权力影响薪酬契约的具体形式具有一定差异,其中,地方国有企业和民营企业高管倾向于利用权力影响牟取更高的货币薪酬待遇;中央国有企业高管则倾向于获取更多的在职消费。
     其次,本文结合区域市场化的动态变迁过程,分别通过按区域市场化程度高低的分组检验和构建面板数据多元回归模型检验了高管薪酬契约中的区域市场化与管理层权力的跨层交互效应,亦即区域市场化对管理层权力与高管薪酬契约之间关系的调节效应。研究结果表明:由市场化改革催生的市场力量对管理层权力与高管薪酬之间的具体关联模式具有显著的调节作用;且此种调节作用主要是通过显著弱化管理层权力对高管薪酬的正向影响得以实现。进一步的研究还发现,在不同所有制性质的企业中,区域市场化塑造高管薪酬契约中的管理层权力效应的内容各有侧重,其中,市场力量对地方国有企业和民营企业高管基于权力影响谋求更高货币薪酬的自利行为具有更为明显的抑制效应;而市场力量对中央国有企业高管利用其权力影响牟取更多在职消费的行为具有更为理想的治理效果。
     再次,目前中国上市公司高管的实际薪酬具有一定的激励作用,但由于管理层权力的干扰,实际薪酬的激励效果在一定程度上被减弱。另一方面,高管超额薪酬基本上不具有实际激励效果,而且受管理层权力的影响,超额在职消费的负面价值效应变得更为明显。通过对实际薪酬的分解和结构性薪酬的研究发现:中国上市公司高管薪酬激励的有效性主要源自以不可操控性业绩为基础的激励性薪酬;建立在管理层权力和操控性业绩基础上的操纵性薪酬则表现出显著的负面价值效应。幸而,随着区域市场化程度的提高,不仅可以使得高管实际薪酬和激励性薪酬之于企业价值的正向敏感性得到不同程度的加强;而且超额薪酬与操纵性薪酬的价值削弱效应也会得到一定程度的抑制;更为重要的是推动区域市场化改革还可以有效缓解管理层权力对高管薪酬契约有效性的负面效应。由此揭示出市场化改革具有提升高管薪酬契约有效性的正面作用,且抑制和削弱高管薪酬契约中的负面管理层权力效应是其塑造薪酬契约有效性的主要途径之一。
     最后,本文着重从治理操纵性薪酬的角度探讨了提高中国上市公司高管薪酬契约有效性的具体策略。研究表明,通过采取减少政府对企业的干预和改善法律制度环境等区域层面的策略以及运用长期股权激励等多样化高管激励手段、将终极控制模式由垂直式转变为矩阵式、提高机构持股比例和提升外部审计质量等企业层面的策略都能够起到很好的抑制薪酬操纵的作用,进而提高高管薪酬契约的有效性。
Executive compensation has always been a controversial issue with wide concern. Espe-cially since the global financial crisis erupted, the high annual salary easily up to ten milliondollars of Wall Street financial institutions’top executives and the “surprise bonus” behaviorhave been suffered in the teeth of the storm. However, in Chinese listed companies, the coex-isted “sky-high salary” and “zero pay” scene of confusion has also drawn public attention.Although stories appear frequently in the press exposing executives influence self-dealingcompensation based on their power, Chinese scholars have rarely discussed about it. Based onthe unique institutional background of Chinese listed companies, from the perspective ofmanagerial power, this paper research on executive compensation contract more systematicand in-depth combined with the regional marketization dynamic change process for the firsttime, to further refine the executive compensation incentive system for Chinese listed compa-nies and provide a theoretical reference and empirical evidence to improve the effectivenessof executive compensation contract.
     On the basis of the theoretical and institutional background analysis, this paper suggeststhat due to the “predominant of one” and “insider control” and other defects of internal cor-porate governance mechanisms, an excellent opportunity is offered for executives of Chineselisted companies to exercise their power to influence self-dealing compensation. At the sametime, external governance mechanisms are not perfect so that to supervise the executives’rent-seeking behavior is more difficult to deal with. Therefore, based on managerial powertheory, discussing the managerial power effects of Chinese listed companies’ executive com-pensation contract to some extent has theoretical and realistic foundation.
     Firstly, we apply the sample of the Chinese listed companies during2004to2010, andtests the relationship between managerial power and executive compensation by constructingmultiple regression model based on panel data. The result shows that managerial power hassignificant positive relation with executives actual monetary remuneration, the actual perks,excess monetary compensation and excess perks. In other words, the greater the managerialpower, the higher the amount of monetary remuneration and perks and the amount of excessmonetary compensation and excess perks of private benefits.
     Secondly, this paper also from the perspective of economy transformation, studies the in-fluence of regional market-oriented reforms on the relationship between the managerial powerand executive pay incentives and their effectiveness, by statistical group comparison andbuilding a panel data multiple regreesion model. We found that market forces spawned by the market-oriented reforms significantly own the role of shaping the specific association be-tween managerial power and executive pay and mainly achieved by significantly weaken thepositive effect of managerial power on executive compensation. A further study finds that, inthe different context of ownership, market-oriented reforms have focused on the content ofshaping the power effect in the executive pay incentives. Specially, in the local state-ownedenterprises, market forces have much more significant inhibitory effect to influence the be-havior of executives grab the monetary private benefits using their power; while in the centralstate-owned enterprises, market forces have better governance effect to influence executivesobtain the behavior of perks and other non-monetary private benefits using their power.
     Thirdly, now in Chinese listed companies, executive compensation incentive has a cer-tain of validity, but the managerial power will weaken the incentive effect to a certain extent,and show a negative effect characteristics. Based on structural pay, this study finds that theeffectiveness of executive compensation incentives mainly due to non-handling perfor-mance-based pay; handling performance-based pay based on managerial power shows a sig-nificant negative effect. Considering market-oriented reforms factors, market forces can sig-nificantly strengthen the sensitivity between the executive pay or incentive pay with the en-terprise value; the value effect of managerial power and manipulation pay also weaken in themarketization process. Therefore, market-oriented reforms enhance the role of executivecompensation incentive validity, suppress and weaken the negative effect of managerial powerin the compensation contract, which is the main way to shape the effectiveness of the com-pensation contract.
     Lastly, from the perspective of governance manipulation compensation, the paper dis-cusses specific measures to improve the effectiveness of executives incentive pay for Chineselisted companies. It finds that using the diversified executive incentives methods, such aslong-term equity incentives, changing ultimate control strategy from vertical to the matrix,increasing the percentage of institutional ownership, taking enterprise-level improvementstrategy, such as enhance external audit quality, lowering governmental intervention degree,improving regional level strategy, such as legal and institutional environment can have greateffect of restraining compensation manipulation and strengthening compensation contract va-lidity.
引文
1转引自新浪网2009年4月29日的博文:《高管无薪酬比天价薪酬更可怕》。
    2参见王珍:《国企高管薪酬:双轨制下两难抉择》,《第一财经日报》2009年4月8日。
    1本文对民营经济发展阶段的划分主要参考了周立群和谢思全主编的《中国经济改革30年:民营经济卷》(重庆大学出版社,2008年)。
    [1]卢锐.管理层权力、薪酬激励与绩效——基于中国证券市场的理论与实证研究[M].北京:经济科学出版社,2008.
    [2]张菁.谁来制约老板——浅谈民营企业管理中的权利制约[J].科学与管理.2002(2):21-23.
    [3] Bebchuk, Fried, Walker. Managerial power and rent extraction in the design of ececutivecompensation[J]. The University of Chicago Law Review.2002,69:751-846.
    [4] Bebchuk L A, Fried J M. Pay without Performance: The Unfulfilled Promise of ExecutiveCompensation[M]. Boalt Working Papers in Public Law, Boalt Hall, UC Berkeley,2004.
    [5]卢中原,胡鞍钢.市场化改革对我国经济运行的影响[J].经济研究.1993(12):49-55.
    [6]陈宗胜,吴浙,谢思全等.中国经济体制市场化进程研究[M].上海:上海人民出版社,1999.
    [7]樊纲,王小鲁,朱恒鹏.《中国市场化指数--各地区市场化相对进程2009年报告》[M].北京:经济科学出版社,2010.
    [8] Berle A A, Means G C. The modern corporation and private property[M]. New York:Macmillan,1932.
    [9] Jensen M C, Meckling W H. Theory of the firm: Managerial behavior, agency costs andownership structure [J]. Journal of Financial Economics.1976,3(4):305-360.
    [10] Jensen M C, Murphy K J. Performance Pay and Top-Management Incentives[J]. Journalof Political Economy.1990(4):225-264.
    [11] Aggarwal R, Samwick A A. The Other Side of the Trade-Off:The Impact of Risk on Ex-ecutive Compensation[J]. Journal of Political Economy.1999,107:65-105.
    [12] Tosi H L, Werner S, Katz J P, et al. How Much Does Performance Matter? A Me-ta-Analysis of CEO Pay Studies [J]. Journal of Management.2000,26(2):301-339.
    [13] Grinstein Y, Hribar P. CEO compensation and incentives:Evidence from M&A bonus-es[J]. Journal of Financial Economics.2004,73(1):119-143.
    [14] Murphy K J. Explaining Executive Compensation: Managerial Power versus the Per-ceived Cost of Stock Options[J]. The University of Chicago Law Review.2002,69(3):847-869.
    [15] Jensen M C, Murphy K J, Wruck E G. Where we’ve been, how we got to here,what arethe problems, and how to fix them[Z].2004.
    [16] Holmstrom B. Pay without Performance and the Managerial Power Hypothesis: AComment[J]. Journal of Corporation Law.2005,30(4):703-715.
    [17] Weisbach M S. Review: Optimal Executive Compensation versus Managerial Power: AReview of Lucian Bebchuk and Jesse Fried's "Pay without Performance: The UnfulfilledPromise of Executive Compensation"[J]. Journal of Economic Literature.2007,45(2):419-428.
    [18] Dorff M B. Does One Hand Wash the Other?Testing the Managerial Power and OptimalContracting Theories of Executive Compensation[J]. Journal of Corporation Law.2005,30(2):255-307.
    [19] Bebchuk L A, Fried J M. Pay Without Performance: Overview of the Issues[J]. Journalof Applied Corporate Finance.2005,17(4):8-23.
    [20] Albuquerque R, Miao J. CEO Power, Compensation, and Governance[Z]. SSRN Work-ingpaper,2008.
    [21] Claessens S, Fan J P H. Corporate Governance in Asia: A Survey[J]. International Re-view of Finance.2002,3(2):71-103.
    [22] Djankov S, Murrell P. Enterprise Restructuring in Transition:A Quantitative Survey[J].Journal of Economic Literature.2002,40:739-792.
    [23] Rosen S. Authority, control, and the distribution of earnings[J]. The Bell Journal ofEconomics.1982,13(2):311-323.
    [24] Krishnan H A, Park D. Effects of top management team change on performance indownsized US companies[J]. Management International Review.1998,38(4):303-319.
    [25] Hambrick D C, Mason P A. Upper Echelons: The Organization as a Reflection of its TopManagers[J]. Academy of Management Review.1984,9(3):193-207.
    [26] Elron E. Top Management Teams within Multinational Corporations:Effects of CulturalKeterogeneity[J]. Leadership Quarterly.1997,8(4):393-412.
    [27] Murphy K J. Executive Compensation[J]. Handbook of Labor Economics.1999,3:2485-2563.
    [28]魏刚.高级管理层激励与上市公司经营绩效[J].经济研究.2000(3):32-40.
    [29]于东智,谷立日.上市公司管理层持股的激励效用及影响因素[J].经济理论与经济管理.2001(9):24-30.
    [30]张俊瑞,赵进文,张建.高级管理层激励与上市公司经营绩效相关性的实证分析[J].会计研究.2003(9):29-34.
    [31]陈冬华,陈信元,万华林.国有企业中的薪酬管制与在职消费[J].经济研究.2005(2):92-101.
    [32]王华,黄之骏.经营者股权激励、董事会组成与企业价值——基于内生性视角的经验分析[J].管理世界.2006(9):101-116.
    [33]高雷,宋顺林.治理环境、治理结构与代理成本——来自国有上市公司面板数据的经验证据[J].经济评论.2007(3):35-40.
    [34]唐清泉,朱瑞华,甄丽明.我国高管人员报酬激励制度的有效性——基于沪深上市公司的实证研究[J].当代经济管理.2008,30(2):59-65.
    [35]李增泉.激励机制与企业绩效:一项基于上市公司的实证研究[J].会计研究.2000(1):24-30.
    [36]朱红军.大股东变更与高级管理人员更换:经营业绩的作用[J].会计研究.2002(9):31-40.
    [37]谌新民,刘善敏.上市公司经营者报酬结构性差异的实证研究[J].经济研究.2003(8):55-69.
    [38]宋德舜.国有控股、最高决策者激励与公司绩效[J].中国工业经济.2004(3):91-98.
    [39]杜胜利,翟艳玲.总经理年度报酬决定因素的实证分析——以我国上市公司为例[J].管理世界.2005(8):114-120.
    [40]吴文锋,吴冲锋,刘晓薇.中国民营上市公司高管的政府背景与公司价值[J].经济研究.2008(7):130-141.
    [41]林浚清,黄祖辉,孙永祥.高管团队内薪酬差距、公司绩效和治理结构[J].经济研究.2003(4):31-42.
    [42]张必武,石金涛.董事会特征,高管薪酬与薪绩敏感性——中国上市公司的经验分析[J].管理科学.2005,18(4):32-39.
    [43]刘凤委,孙铮,李增泉.政府干预、行业竞争与薪酬契约——来自国有上市公司的经验证据[J].管理世界.2007(9):76-85.
    [44]吕长江,赵宇恒.国有企业管理者激励效应研究——基于管理者权力的解释[J].管理世界.2008(11):99-109.
    [45]夏纪军,张曼.控制权与激励的冲突——兼对股权激励有效性的实证分析[J].经济研究.2008(3):87-98.
    [46]李平.上市公司CEO薪酬激励研究[D].长沙:湖南大学,2004.
    [47]纳超洪.管理权力、自由量裁性投资与高管薪酬——基于中国上市公司的实证研究
    [D].广州:暨南大学,2009.
    [48] Rajan R G, Wulf J. Are perks purely managerial excess?[J]. Journal of Financial Eco-nomics.2006,79(1):1-33.
    [49]李增泉,孙铮,刘凤委.企业绩效与薪酬契约——基于最优契约论的解释及经验证据[J].工作论文.2005.
    [50]方军雄.我国上市公司高管的薪酬存在粘性吗?[J].经济研究.2009(3):110-124.
    [51]刘慧龙,张敏,王亚平,等.政治关联、薪酬激励与员工配置效率[J].经济研究.2010(9):109-121.
    [52]姜付秀,黄继承.经理激励、负债与企业价值[J].经济研究.2011(5):46-60.
    [53]中国企业家调查系统课题组.中国企业家队伍成长现状与环境评价——2003·中国企业经营者成长与发展专题调查报告[R].北京:中国企业家调查系统,2002.
    [54]代彬,刘星,郝颖.高管权力、薪酬契约与国企改革——来自国有上市公司的实证研究[J].当代经济科学.2011,33(4):90-98.
    [55] Firth M, Fung P M Y, Rui O M. Corporate performance and CEO compensation in Chi-na[J]. Journal of Corporate Finance.2006,12(4):693-714.
    [56] Core J E, Guay W, Larcker D F. The power of the pen and executive compensation[J].Journal of Financial Economics.2008,88(1):119-143.
    [57] Hardy C, Clegg S R.‘Some dare call it power’. In Clegg, S. R. and Hardy, C.(Eds),Studying Organization: Theory and Method[M]. London: Sage,1999.
    [58] March J G. The power of power,in D. Eston(ed.), Varieties of Political Theory[M].Prentice Hall Press,1966.
    [59] Pfeffer J. Power in organizations[M]. Pitman Pub.(Marshfield, Mass.),1981.
    [60] Finkelstein S. Power in Top Management Teams: Dimensions, Measurement, and Vali-dation[J]. The Academy of Management Journal.1992,35(3):505-538.
    [61]肖丕楚,张成君. CEO权责配置与公司治理结构优化[J].经济与管理.2003(4):35-36.
    [62] Chung K H, Pruitt S W. Executive ownership, corporate value, and executive compensa-tion: A unifying framework[J]. Journal of Banking&Finance.1996(20):1135-1159.
    [63] Combs J G, Skill M S. Managerialist and human capital explanations for key executivepay premiums: A contingency perspective[J]. Academy of Management Journal.2003,46(1):63-73.
    [64] Hu A, Kumar P. Managerial Entrenchment and Payout Policy[J]. Journal of Financialand Quantitative Analysis.2004,39(4):759-790.
    [65] Boyd B K. Board control and ceo compensation[J]. Strategic Management Journal.1994,15(5):335-344.
    [66]盛洪.市场化的条件、限度和形式[J].经济研究.1992(11):71-79.
    [67]胡金林,王长征.论转轨时期的市场缺失与政府越位[J].江汉论坛.1998(8):83-85.
    [68]樊纲,王小鲁.中国市场化指数———各地区市场化相对进程报告(2000年)[M].北京:经济科学出版社,2001.
    [69]李炳炎.马克思产权理论与我国现代产权制度建设[J].高校理论战线.2005(1):37-42.
    [70]岳凯敏.治理语境下的中国政府能力[J].宝鸡文理学院学报(社会科学版).2005,25(3):14-18.
    [71] Marris R. The economic theory of managerial capitalism[M]. London: Macmillan,1964.
    [72] Williamson O E. The economics of discretionary behavior: Managerial objectives in atheory of the firm[M]. Englewood Cliffs, N.J.: Prentice-Hall,1964.
    [73] Baumol W J. Business behavior, value and growth[M]. Harcourt, Brace&World NewYork,1967.
    [74] Wilson R B. The structure of incentives for decentralization under uncertainty[M]. Pairs:La Decision,1970.
    [75] Spence M, Zeckhauser R. Insurance, information, and individual action[J]. The Ameri-can economic review.1971,61(2):380-387.
    [76] Ross S A. The economic theory of agency: The principal's problem[J]. The AmericanEconomic Review.1973,63(2):134-139.
    [77] Mirrlees J."Notes on welfare economics, information, and uncertainty" in Balch,McFadden, and Wu,eds.,Essays on economic behavior under uncertainty[M]. Amsterdam:North Holland Publishing,1974:243-261.
    [78] Holmstrom B. Moral hazard and observability[J]. The Bell Journal of Economics.1979,10(1):74-91.
    [79] Grossman S J, Hart O D. An analysis of the principal-agent problem[J]. Econometrica.1983,51(1):7-45.
    [80]张勇.公司经营者代理行为的研究[D].西安:西安交通大学,2005.
    [81] Mirrlees J A. The Optimal Structure of Incentives and Authority within an Organiza-tion[J]. The Bell Journal of Economics.1976,7(1):105-131.
    [82] Lazear E P, Rosen S. Rank-oeder Tournaments as Optimum Labor Contracts[J]. TheJournal of Political Economy.1981,89(5):841-864.
    [83]张维迎.博弈论与信息经济学[M].上海:上海三联书店,1996.
    [84] Murphy K J. Incentives,learning,and compensation:a theoretical and empirical investiga-tion of managerial labor contracts[J]. The Rand Journal of Economics.1986,17(1):59-76.
    [85] Edmans A, Gabaix X. Is CEO pay really inefficient? A survey of new optimal contract-ing theories[Z]. University of Pennsylvania,2008.
    [86] Taussings F W, Baker W S. American Corporations and Their Executives: A StatisticalEnquiry[J]. The Quarterly Journal of Economics.1925,4(1):1-51.
    [87] Main B G M. Top executive pay and performance[J]. Managerial&Decision Economics.1991,12:219-229.
    [88] Murphy K J. Corporate Performance and Managerial Remuneration: An EmpiricalAnalysis[J]. Journal of Accounting and Economics.1985,7(1-3):11-42.
    [89] Lambert R, Larcker D. An analysis of the use of accounting and market measures ofperformance in executive compensation contracts[J]. Journal of Accounting Research.1987,25:85-125.
    [90] Leone A J, Wu J S, Zimmerman J L. Asymmetric Sensitivity of CEO Cash Compensa-tion to Stock Returns[J]. Journal of Accounting and Economics.2006,42(1-2):167-192.
    [91] Jackson S B, Lopez T J, Reitenga A L. Accounting Fundamental and CEO Bonus Com-pensation[J]. Journal of Accounting and Public Policy.2008,27(5):374-393.
    [92] Hermalin B E, Weisbach M S. Endogenously chosen boards of directors and their moni-toring of the CEO[J]. American Economic Review.1998,88:96-118.
    [93] Adams C P, Economics U S F T. Agent Discretion, Adverse Selection and theRisk-Incentive Trade-Off[M]. Bureau of Economics, US FTC,2002.
    [94] Bebchuk L A, Fried J M. Executive Compensation as an Agency Problem[Z]. NBERWORKING PAPER SERIES,2003.
    [95] Murphy K J, Zabojnik J. CEO pay and appointment: a market-based explanation for re-cent trends[J]. The American Ecomomic Review.2004,94(2):192-229.
    [96] Kay I T. CEO Pay for Performance: The Solution to "Managerial Power"[J]. Journal ofCorporation Law.2005,30(4):785-789.
    [97] Core J E, Guay W R, Thomas R S. IS U.S. CEO COMPENSATION INEFFICIENTPAY WITHOUT PERFORMANCE?[J]. Michigan Law Review.2005,103(6):1142-1185.
    [98] Gümbel A. Managerial power and executive pay[J]. Oxford Journal of Legal Studies.2006,26(1):219-233.
    [99] Crystal G S. In Search of Excess:The overcompensation of Amercian Executies[M]. NewYork: Norton,1991.
    [100] Main B G M, O'Reilly Iii C A, Wade J. Top executive pay: Tournament or team-work?[J]. Journal of Labor Economics.1993,11(4):606-628.
    [101] Conyon M J, Peck S I. Board control, remuneration committees, and top managementcompensation[J]. Academy of Management Journal.1998,41(2):146-157.
    [102] Gomez-Mejia L, Wiseman R M. Reframing Execufive Compensation: An Assessmentand Outlook[J]. Journal of Management.1997,23(3):291-374.
    [103] Shivdasani A, Yermack D. CEO involvement in the selection of new board members:An empirical analysis[J]. The Journal of Finance.1999,54(5):1829-1853.
    [104] Cheng S, Indjejikian R. Managerial influence and CEO performance incentives[J]. In-ternational Review of Law and Economics.2009,29(2):115-126.
    [105] Hambrick D C, Finkelstein S. The effects of ownership structure on conditions at thetop: The case of CEO pay raises[J]. Strategic Management Journal.1995,16(3):175-193.
    [106] Newman H A, Wright D W. Compensation committee composition and its influence onCEO compensation practices[Z]. SSRN Working,1997:1001.
    [107] Core J E, Holthausen R W, Larcker D F. Corporate Governance, Chief Executive Of-ficer Compensation, and Firm Performance[J]. Journal of Financial Economics.1999,51:371-406.
    [108] Cyert R M, Kang S H, Kumar P. Corporate governance, takeovers, andtop-management compensation: Theory and evidence[J]. Management Science.2002,48(4):453-469.
    [109] Eriksson T. The managerial power impact on compensation: some further evidence[Z].workingpaper,2003.
    [110] Bertrand M, Mullainathan S. Are CEOs rewarded for luck? The ones without principalsare[J]. Quarterly Journal of Economics.2001,116(3):901-932.
    [111] Garvey G T, Milbourn T T. Asymmetric benchmarking in compensation: Executivesare rewarded for good luck but not penalized for bad[J]. Journal of Financial Economics.2006,82(1):197-225.
    [112] Gopalan R, Milbourn T, Song F. Strategic flexibility and the optimality of pay for sec-tor performance[J]. Review of Financial Studies.2010,23(5):2060-2098.
    [113] Kuhnen C M, Zwiebel J R. Executive Pay, Hidden Compensation and Managerial En-trenchment [Z]. Rock Center for Corporate GovernanceStanford University,2008.
    [114] Duffhues P, Kabir R. Is the pay-performance relationship always positive?:: Evidencefrom the Netherlands[J]. Journal of multinational financial management.2008,18(1):45-60.
    [115] Otten J A, Heugens P P. Extending the managerial power theory of executive pay: Across national test[M]. Netherlands: Erasmus Research Institute of Management, ErasmusUniversity,2007.
    [116] Lin B, Lu R. Managerial power, compensation gap and firm performance——Evidence from Chinese public listed companies [J]. Global Finance Journal.2009(20):153-164.
    [117] Fahlenbrach R. Shareholder rights,boards,and CEO compensation[J]. Review of Fi-nance.2009,13(1):81-113.
    [118] Goergen M, Renneboog L. Managerial compensation [J]. Journal of Corporate Finance.2011,17(4):1068-1077.
    [119] Morse A, Nanda V, Seru A. Are Incentive Contracts Rigged By Powerful CEOs?[J].The Journal of Finance.2011,66(5):1779-1821.
    [120] Chen J, Ezzamel M, Cai Z. Managerial power theory, tournament thoery, and executivepay in China[J]. JJournal of Corporate Finance.2011,17(4):1176-1199.
    [121] Borokhovich K A, Brunarski K R, Parrino R. CEO contracting and antitakeoveramendments[J]. Journal of Finance.1997,52(4):1495-1517.
    [122] Brickley J A, Coles J L, Jarrell G. Leadership structure: Separating the CEO and chair-man of the board[J]. Journal of corporate Finance.1997,3(3):189-220.
    [123] Anderson R C. Compensation committees, government regulations, and CEO pay[Z].Unpublished manuscript, Washington and Lee University,1997.
    [124] Ryan H E, Wiggins R A. Who is in whose pocket? Director compensation, board inde-pendence, and barriers to effective monitoring[J]. Journal of Financial Economics.2004,73(3):497-524.
    [125] David P, Kochhar R, Levitas E. The effect of institutional investors on the level andmix of CEO compensation[J]. Academy of Management Journal.1998,41(2):200-208.
    [126] Hartzell J C, Starks L T. Institutional investors and executive compensation[J]. TheJournal of Finance.2003,58(6):2351-2374.
    [127] Sun J, Cahan S F, Emanuel D. Compensation committee governance quality, chief ex-ecutive officer stock option grants, and future firm performance[J]. Journal of Banking&Fi-nance.2009,33(8):1507-1519.
    [128] Chhaochharia V, Grinstein Y. CEO Compensation and Board Structure[J]. The Journalof Finance.2009,64(1):231-261.
    [129]潘飞,童卫华.我国高级管理人员激励契约:现状与分析[Z].北京:2005.
    [130]杨贺,马春爱.经理人控制与高级管理人员报酬制定——对实行年薪制上市公司的实证分析[J].经济管理.2005(18):44-50.
    [131]卢锐.管理层权力与薪酬激励——来自中国上市公司的经验证据[Z].2006.
    [132]胡玉明.经理薪酬:解决代理问题还是本身即代理问题[J].财务与会计.2006(5):63-64.
    [133]杜兴强,王丽华.高层管理当局薪酬与上市公司业绩的相关性实证研究[J].会计研究.2007(1):58-65.
    [134]卢锐.管理层权力、薪酬差距与绩效[J].南方经济.2007(7):60-70.
    [135]卢锐,魏明海,黎文靖.管理层权力、在职消费与产权效率[J].南开管理评论.2008,11(5):85-92.
    [136]权小锋,吴世农,文芳.管理层权力、私有收益与薪酬操纵[J].经济研究.2010(11):73-87.
    [137]方军雄.高管权力与企业薪酬变动的非对称性[J].经济研究.2011(4):107-120.
    [138] Grossman S J, Hart O D. The costs and benefits of ownership: A theory of vertical andlateral integration[J]. Journal of Political Economy.1986,94(4):691-719.
    [139] Hart O, Moore J. Property Rights and the Nature of the Firm[J]. The Journal of PoliticalEconomy.1990,98(6):1119-1158.
    [140] Holmstrom B, Milgrom P. The firm as an incentive system[J]. The American EconomicReview.1994,84(4):972-991.
    [141] Greif A. Cultural Beliefs and the Organization of Society:A Historical and TheoreticalReflection on Collectivist and Individualist Societies[J]. The Journal of Political Economy.1994,102(5):912-950.
    [142] Greif A, Milgrom P, Weingast B R. Coordination, commitment, and enforcement: Thecase of the merchant guild[J]. Journa of Political Economy.1994,102(4):745-776.
    [143] Clay K. Trade without law: private-order institutions in Mexican California[J]. TheJournal of Law, Economics&Organization.1997,13(1):202-231.
    [144] Demirguc-Kunt A, Maksimovic V. Institutions,financial markets, and firm debt maturi-ty[J]. Journal of Financial Economics.1999,54(3):295-336.
    [145] Shleifer A, Vishny R. A Survey of Corporate Governance[J]. The Journal of Finance.1997,52(2):737-783.
    [146] La Porta R, Lopez-De-Silanes F, Shleifer A, et al. Law and finance[J]. Journal of Polit-ical Economy.1998,106(6):1113-1155.
    [147] La Porta R, Lopez-De-Silanes F, Shleifer A, et al. Investor protection and corporategovernance[J]. Journal of Financial Economics.2000,58(1-2):3-27.
    [148] Burkart M, Panunzi F, Shleifer A. Family Firms[J]. The Journal of Finance.2003,58(5):2167-2202.
    [149] Fan J P H, Titman S, Twite G J. An International Comparison of Capital Structure andDebt Maturity Choices[Z]. SSNR Workingpaper,2004.
    [150]孙铮,刘凤委,李增泉.市场化程度、政府干预与企业债务期限结构——来自我国上市公司的经验证据[J].经济研究.2005(5):52-63.
    [151]夏立军,陈信元.市场化进程、国企改革策略与公司治理结构的内生决定[J].经济研究.2007(7):82-96.
    [152]辛清泉,谭伟强.市场化改革、企业业绩与国有企业经理薪酬[J].经济研究.2009(11):68-81.
    [153]北京师范大学经济与资源管理研究所.2003中国市场经济发展报告[M].北京:中国商务出版社,2003.
    [154]北京师范大学经济与资源管理研究所.2005中国市场经济发展报告[M].北京:中国商务出版社,2005.
    [155]张厚义.又一支异军在突起——改革开放以来私营经济的再生和发展[M].北京:社会科学文献出版社,1999.
    [156]张厚义,明立志.中国私营企业发展报告(1978-1998)[M].北京:社会科学文献出版社,1999.
    [157] Yueh L Y. Wage reforms in China during the1990s[J]. Asian Economic Journal.2004,18(2):149-164.
    [158]李焰,秦义虎,黄继承.在职消费、员工工资与企业绩效[J].财贸经济.2010(7):60-68.
    [159]姜付秀,张敏.在职消费与公司绩效[Z].工作论文,2009.
    [160] Chen D, Li O Z, Liang S. Do Managers Perform for Perks?[Z]. Workingpaper,2010.
    [161]冯莉,陈修德,梁彤缨.终极控制权、市场化改革与在职消费[Z].工作论文,2011.
    [162] Conyon M J, He L. Executive Compensation in China[Z]. Workingpaper,2010.
    [163]李旭红.国企老总要拿年薪了[N].市场导报,9月12日.
    [164] Lin J Y, Tan G. Policy Burdens,Accountability and Soft Budget Constraint[J]. TheAmerican Economic Review.1999,89(2):426-431.
    [165]林毅夫,刘培林.自生能力与国企改革[J].经济研究.2001(9):60-70.
    [166]林毅夫.自生能力、经济转型与新古典经济学的反思[J].经济研究.2002(12):15-24.
    [167] Summers L H. Russia and the Soviet Union Then and Now: Comment[M]. Chicago:Chicago University Press,1994.
    [168]杜玉鹏.管理层权力对国有企业并购及其财务效应影响研究[D].天津:天津大学,2010.
    [169]陈菊梅.试论国有企业激励与约束机制的构建[J].浙江大学学报(人文社会科学版).1999,29(6):46-50.
    [170]唐清泉.知识型花瓶式有威慑作用的独立董事——我国实施独立董事制度的动机研究[M].广州:中山大学出版社,2005.
    [171]常红军.国有控股上市公司“出资人缺位”问题的思考与对策[J].甘肃社会科学.2003(6):52-54.
    [172]张维迎.企业理论与中国企业改革[M].北京:北京大学出版社,1999.
    [173]青木昌彦,钱颖一.转轨经济中的公司治理结构:内部人控制和银行的作用[M].北京:中国经济出版社,1995.
    [174]李新春.经理人市场失灵与家族企业治理[J].管理世界.2003(4):87-95.
    [175]苏启林,朱文.上市公司家族控制与企业价值[J].经济研究.2003(8):36-45.
    [176]林毅夫,李志.政策性负担、道德风险和预算软约束[J].经济研究.2004(2):17-27.
    [177] Shleifer, Vishny. Large Shareholders and Corporate Control[J]. Journal of PoliticalEconomy.1986,94(3):461-488.
    [178] Easterbrook F H. Managers' Discretion and Investors' Welfare: Theories and Evi-dence[J]. Delaware Journal of Corporate Law.1984,9(2):540-571.
    [179]李晓华.经理人市场失灵与家族管理转型的制度困境[J].当代经济科学.2006,28(6):66-70.
    [180]丁栋虹.制度变迁中企业家成长模式研究[M].南京:南京大学出版社,1999.
    [181]潘晨光.2005:中国人才发展报告[M].北京:社会科学文献出版社,2005.
    [182] Grinstein Y, Hribar P. CEO compensation and incentives: evidence from M&A bonus-es[J]. Journal of Financial Economics.2004,73(1):119-143.
    [183] Monks R A G, Minow N. Corporate Governance[M]. Oxford:Blackwell Publishing,2001.
    [184]王克敏,王志超.高管控制权、报酬与盈余管理———基于中国上市公司的实证研究[J].管理世界.2007(7):111-119.
    [185]卢锐.管理层权力、薪酬与业绩敏感性分析——来自中国上市公司的经验证据[J].当代财经.2008(7):107-112.
    [186] Denis D J, Hanouna P, Sarin A. Is there a dark side to incentive compensation[J]. Jour-nal of Corporate Finance.2006(12):388-467.
    [187]顾斌,周立烨.我国上市公司股权激励实施效果的研究[J].会计研究.2007(2):79-84.
    [188] Berrone P, Otten J."A global perspective onexecutive compensation" in "Global com-pensation: foundations and perspectives" Edited by Luis R. Gomez-Mejia and Steve Wer-ner[M]. New York: Routledge,2008.
    [189]张春霖.国有企业改革与国家融资[J].经济研究.1997(4).
    [190]青木昌彦,钱颖一.转轨经济中的公司治理结构:内部人控制和银行的作用[M].北京:中国经济出版社,1995.
    [191]费方域.控制内部人控制--国企改革中的治理机制研究[J].经济研究.1996(6).
    [192]杨瑞龙,周业安.相机治理与国有企业监控[J].中国社会科学.1998(3):4-17.
    [193] Williamson O. The Economics of Discretionary Behavior: Managerial Objectives in aTheory of the Firm[M]. Englewood Cliffs, N.J., Prentice-Hall,1964.
    [194]杨洪常.论管理者权力与经理薪酬的租金汲取[J].学术界.2007(5):68-74.
    [195]万华林,陈信元.治理环境、企业寻租与交易成本——基于中国上市公司非生产性支出的经验证据[J].经济学(季刊).2010,9(2):553-570.
    [196] Luo W, Zhang Y, Zhu N. Bank ownership and executive perquisites: New evidencefrom an emerging market[J]. Journal of Corporate Finance.2011,12(2):352-370.
    [197] Fan J P H, Wong T J, Zhang T. Institutions and Organizational Structure: he Case ofState-Owned Corporate Pyramids [J]. SSRN Working Paper.2009.
    [198] Cheng S. Board size and the variability of corporate performance[J]. Journal of Finan-cial Economics.2008,87(1):157-176.
    [199]朱克江.经营者薪酬激励制度研究[M].北京:中国经济出版社,2002.
    [200] Coase R H. The Nature of the Firm[J]. Economica.1937,4(16):386-405.
    [201] Spulber D F. Market microstructure: intermediaries and the theory of the firm[M].Cambridge: Cambridge University Press,1999.
    [202] Jensen M C. Agency costs of free cash flow, corporate finance, and takeovers[J]. TheAmerican Economic Review.1986,76(2):323-329.
    [203] Baker G P, Jensen M C, Murphy K J. Compensation and Incentives: Practice vs. Theo-ry[J]. The Journal of Finance.1988,43(3):593-616.
    [204] Fama E F, Jensen M C. Agency Problems and Residual Claims[J]. Journal of law andeconomics.1983,26:327-349.
    [205] Jensen M C, Murphy K J. CEO Incentives—It's not how much you pay, but how[J].Harvard Business Review.1990(3):138-153.
    [206] Demsetz H. Toward a Theory of Property Rights[J]. The American Economic Review.1967,57(2):347-359.
    [207]张五常.“经济组织与交易成本”,载《经济解释———张五常经济论文选》[M].北京:商务印书馆,2002.
    [208] Pinto B, Belka M, Krajewski S, et al. Transforming state enterprises in Poland: Evi-dence on adjustment by manufacturing firms[J]. Brookings Papers on Economic Activity.1993,6(1):213-261.
    [209] Groves T, Hong Y, Mcmillan J, et al. Autonomy and Incentives in Chinese State Enter-prises[J]. The Quarterly Journal of Economics.1994,109(1):183-209.
    [210] Groves T, Hong Y, Mcmillan J, et al. China's evolving managerial labor market[J].Journal of Political Economy.1995,103(4):873-892.
    [211] Denis D K, Mcconnell J J. International Corporate Governance[J]. Journal of Financialand Quantitative Analysis.2003,38(1):1-36.
    [212] Estrin S. Competition and Corporate Governance in Transition[J]. The Journal of Eco-nomic Perspectives.2002,16(1):101-124.
    [213]周建波,孙菊生.经营者股权激励的治理效应研究——来自中国上市公司的经验证据[J].经济研究.2003(5):74-83.
    [214]埃里克·弗鲁博顿,鲁道夫·芮切特.新制度经济学:一个交易费用分析范式[M].上海:上海三联书店,2010.
    [215]夏立军,方轶强.政府控制、治理环境与公司价值——来自中国证券市场的经验证据[J].经济研究.2005(5):40-51.
    [216]邱珉.国有企业职业经理人队伍现状分析[J].中国商界.2010(12):159-160.
    [217]卢现祥.经理市场:形成、类型与功能[J].山东经济.1997(6):43-46.
    [218]梁上坤,陈冬华.市场化水平与薪酬契约成本:在职消费还是货币薪酬?[Z].工作论文,2009.
    [219] LA Porta R, Lopez-De-Silanes F, Shleifer A, et al. Legal determinants of external fi-nance[J]. THE JOURNAL OF FINANCE.1997,52(3):1131-1150.
    [220]樊纲,王小鲁,张立文,等.中国各地区市场化相对进程报告[J].经济研究.2003(3):9-18.
    [221]樊纲,王小鲁,朱恒鹏.中国市场化指数——各地区市场化相对进程2006年度报告[R].北京:中国经济改革研究基金会国民经济研究所,2007.
    [222] Shleifer A, Vishny R W. Management entrenchment: The case of manager-specific in-vestments[J]. Journal of Financial Economics.1989,25(1):123-139.
    [223] Canarella G, Gasparyan A. New insights into executive compensation and firm perfor-mance: Evidence from a panel of“new economy”firms,1996-2002"[J]. Managerial Finance.2008,34(8):537-554.
    [224]周仁俊,杨战兵,李礼.管理层激励与企业经营业绩的相关性——国有与非国有控股上市公司的比较[J].会计研究.2010(12):69-75.
    [225]张樱姝.高管薪酬契约有效性研究——基于市场化改革和公司实际控制人性质视角[D].长春:吉林大学,2010.
    [226] Lewellen W G, Huntsman B. Managerial pay and corporate performance[J]. TheAmerican Economic Review.1970,60(4):710-720.
    [227] Havell, Holmstrom. The economics of earnings manipulation and managerial compen-sation[J]. Journal of Economics.1970,10:118-125.
    [228] Anne C, Schmidt R. Executive compensation,managementturnover, and firm perfor-mance: An emprical investigation[J]. Journal of accounting and Economics.1985,7(1-3):43-65.
    [229] Murphy K J. Corporate performance and Managerial remuneration:An empirical analy-sis [J]. Journal of financial economics.1995,7(1-3):11-42.
    [230] Dow J, Raposo C C. CEO Compensation, Change, and Corporate Strategy[J]. Journal ofFinance.2005,60(6):2701-2727.
    [231] Murphy K R S, Salter M S. Should CEO pay be linked to results?[J]. Harvard BusinessReview.1975,53:66-73.
    [232] Aupperle K E, Figler R A, Lutz R C. Do The In Search Of Excellence Firms EffectivelyMatch CEO Compensation To Corporate Performance?[J]. Journal of Managerial Issues.1991,3(4):445-457.
    [233] Jones D C, Kato T. The determinants of chief executive compensation in transitionaleconomies: Evidence from Bulgaria[J]. Labour Economics.1996,3(3):319-336.
    [234] Andjelkovic A, Boyle G, Mcnoe W. Public disclosure of executive compensation: Doshareholders need to know?[J]. Pacific-Basin Finance Journal.2002,10(1):97-117.
    [235] Dorff M B. THE GROUP DYNAMICS THEORY OF EXECUTIVE COMPENSA-TION[Z]. workingpaper,2005.
    [236]吴育辉,吴世农.企业高管自利行为及其影响因素研究——基于我国上市公司股权激励草案的证据[J].管理世界.2010(5):141-149.
    [237] Hubbard R G, Palia D. Executive Pay and Performance: Evidence from the U. S.Banking Industry [J]. Journal of Financial Economics.1995,39(1):105-130.
    [238] Crawford A J, Ezzell J R, Mites J A. Bank CEO Pay-Performance Relations and theEffects of Deregulation[J]. Journal of Business.1995,68(2).
    [239] Kole S R. Managerial Ownership and Firm Performance:Incentive or Reward?[J]. Ad-vance in Financial Economics.1996(2):119-149.
    [240] Bryan S, Hwang L, Lilien S. CEO Compensation after Deregulation: The Case of Elec-tric Utilities[J]. Journal of Business.2005,78(5):1709-1752.
    [241]陈冬华,梁上坤,蒋德权.不同市场化进程下高管激励契约的成本与选择:货币薪酬与在职消费[Z].工作论文,2009.
    [242] Jensen M, Meckling W. Specific and general knowledge and organizational structure[J].Journal of Applied Corporate Finance.1995,8(2):4-18.
    [243]张维迎,栗树和.地区间竞争与中国国有企业的民营化[J].经济研究.1998(12):13-22.
    [244]林毅夫,蔡昉,李周.现代企业制度的内涵与国有企业改革方向[J].经济研究.1997,3(3):3-10.
    [245] Morck R, Shleifer A, Vishny R W. Management ownership and market valuation: Anempirical analysis [J]. Journal of financial Economics.1988,20(1):293-315.
    [246] Palia D, Lichtenberg F. Managerial ownership and firm performance: A re-examinationusing productivity measurement[J]. Journal of Corporate Finance.1999(5):323-339.
    [247] Lemmon M L, Lins K V. Ownership Structure, Corporate Governance, and Firm Value:Evidence from the East Asian Financial Crisis[J]. The Journal of Finance.2003,58(4):1445-1468.
    [248] Benson B W, Iii W N D. Reexamining the managerial ownership effect on firm value[J]. Journal of Corporate Finance.2009,15(5):573-586.
    [249]白重恩,俏刘,洲陆,等.中国上市公司治理结构的实证研究[J].经济研究.2005(2):81-91.
    [250]毛世平.金字塔控股结构与股权制衡效应——基于中国上市公司的实证研究[J].管理世界.2009(1):140-152.
    [251]俞鸿琳.政府控制和治理机制的有效性——基于中国A股市场的经验证据[J].南开管理评论.2006(1):98-102.
    [252] Demirgü Kunt A, Maksimovic V. Law, finance, and firm growth[J]. The Journal ofFinance.1998,53(6):2107-2137.
    [253] Francis J R, Khurana I K, Pereira R. Investor protection laws, Accounting and auditingaround the world[C].2001.
    [254] Francis J, Krishnan J. Evidence on auditor risk-management strategies before and afterthe Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of1995[J]. Asia Pacific Journal of Accountingand Economics.2002,9(2):135-157.
    [255] Francis J R. What do we know about audit quality?[J]. The British accounting review.2004,36(4):345-368.
    [256] Dyck A, Zingales L. Private Benefits of Control: An International Comparison[J]. TheJournal of Finance.2004,59(2):576-579.
    [257]王艳艳,于李胜.法律环境、审计独立性与投资者保护[J].财贸经济.2006(5):32-38.
    [258]王俊秋,张奇峰.治理环境、治理机制与信息披露质量:来自深交所的证据[J].当代经济管理.2007,29(3):111-115.
    [259] Chen C J P, Chen S, Su X. Profitability Regulation, Earnings Management and Modi-fied Audit Opinions: Evidence from China[J]. A Journal of Practice&Theory.2001,20(2):9-30.
    [260] La Porta R, Lopez-De-Silanes F, Shleifer A. CORPORATE OWNERSHIP AROUNDTHE WORLD[J]. The Journal of Finance.1999,54(2):471-517.
    [261] Claessnens S, Djankov S, Lang L H P. The Separation of Ownership and Control inEast AsianCorporations[J]. Journal of Financial Economics.2000,58(1-2):81-112.
    [262] Faccio M, Lang L H P. The Ultimate Ownership of Western European Corporations[J].Journal of Financial Economics.2002,65(3):365-395.
    [263]刘芍佳,孙霈,刘乃全.终极产权论、股权结构及公司绩效[J].经济研究.2003(4):51-63.
    [264]张婉君,罗威.控股股东、治理环境与机构股东积极治理效应——基于股权融资成本的视角[J].山西财经大学学报.2010,32(11):102-109.
    [265] Gillan S L, Starks L T. Corporate ownership,Corporate Governace and the Role of In-stitutional Investors:A Global Perspectives[J]. Jounal of Applied Finance.2003,17(3):4-20.
    [266] Hirst D E. Auditor Sensitivity to Earnings Management[J]. Contemporary AccountingResearch.1994,11(1):405-422.
    [267] Fan J P H, Wong T J. Do External Auditors Perform a Corporate Governance Role inEmerging Markets? Evidence from East Asia[J]. Journal of Accounting Research.2005,43(1):35-72.
    [268]蔡春,黄益建,赵莎.关于审计质量对盈余管理影响的实证研究——来自沪市制造业的经验证据[J].审计研究.2005(2):3-10.
    [269]张敏,姜付秀.机构投资者、企业产权与薪酬契约[J].世界经济.2010(8):43-58.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700