用户名: 密码: 验证码:
我国货币政策区域效应的存在性和影响因素研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
货币政策研究中最关键和最核心的问题就是有关货币政策传导的问题。货币政策传导的研究主要集中在货币政策是否中性、货币政策传导机制以及近年来出现的也是本文研究主题—有关货币政策区域效应的研究,Scott(1955)是最早研究货币政策区域效应的学者。货币政策统一性的基础就是货币政策实施是总量调控而非微量调控。实施总量调控,如果要达到预定的调控目标有一个非常重要的前提条件,就是实施货币政策区域的经济金融的同一性。1999年诺贝尔经济学奖得主罗伯特·蒙代尔(Robert Mundell)于1961年提出的“最优货币区”是支持货币政策一体化的理论基础。本文的研究主题是探讨和实证检验产生我国货币政策区域效应的最根本原因—微观主体差异。不管是什么货币政策传导机制,货币政策的传导效果主要是依赖于微观主体的行为。
     随着我国改革开放和市场化进程的进一步深入,我国经济的区域特征越来越明显,无论是从金融体系角度、产业结构角度,还是综合角度来看,我国的区域经济体可划分为东部沿海地区、中部地区和西部地区。针对本文的研究主题,本文对2001年至2005年各省级地区市场化指数的平均值进行聚类分析,把我国三十一个省级地区分为经济发达地区、次发达地区和不发达地区。通过比较三个地区的经济金融状况,可以看出我国区域经济体的差异非常大。在这一背景下我国实施统一货币政策会不会产生区域效应呢?如果产生区域效应,其根本影响因素又有哪些呢?针对这些问题,本文的研究结论主要有:
     (1)在基于最优货币区理论和借鉴国内外研究成果的基础上,本文利用结构向量自回归模型(SVAR)以及脉冲响应函数,采用1984年至2006年的年度样本数据,通过对我国发达地区、次发达地区和不发达地区对货币政策响应的实证研究,表明我国货币政策确实存在明显的区域效应。
     (2)本文分析了我国区域金融体系差异的形成和现状以及产生的原因,从理论的角度研究了金融体系的发展水平与效率与经济增长的关系。在研究金融体系差异对货币政策区域效应的影响时,本文把经济增长作为货币政策的目标。通过建立面板数据回归模型实证检验了金融体系的发展水平和效率有利于促进经济增长、不同地区金融体系对经济增长的影响程度不一样,由此便产生货币政策区域效应,从而表明我国区域金融体系差异是我国货币政策区域效应产生的重要因素。
     (3)根据预防性储蓄理论本文推导出我国居民消费模型,通过实证研究得出各省市自治区居民消费模型。影响居民消费的因素在模型中可以体现出来,本文通过比较各省市自治区的影响居民消费的因素的差异性来分析我国居民消费储蓄行为的差异性存在。居民是一国经济活动的重要微观主体,它的行为,特别是消费和储蓄选择行为对货币政策具有重要的影响。居民的消费形成最终需求,居民的储蓄形成重要的投资资金来源,居民的储蓄和消费行为是影响货币政策行为的基本因素之一。
     (4)本文从理论上论述企业结构对货币政策传导的影响,从而推导出不同地区的不同企业结构对货币政策的响应的不一致性,最终导致货币政策的区域效应。通过实证检验,本文验证了区域企业结构差异是我国货币政策区域效应形成的一个重要因素。
     货币政策目标中包含着区域经济协调发展的成份,中国作为一个处于经济转轨时期的发展中大国,只有区域经济协调发展,才能实现全国经济的平稳发展,避免经济的大起大落,实现社会主义市场经济体制生产目的,货币政策应该为这一目标服务。根据本文研究结论,本文提出相关的政策建议,提出要减缓货币政策区域效应首先要畅通货币政策传导机制,然后调整传导过程中各区域微观主体(金融机构、居民和企业)的差异性,最后可以在一定程度上实施差别化的区域货币政策,三管齐下共同治理货币政策区域效应。
The essential and core question in the research of monetary policy is about monetary policy transmission. The research of monetary policy transmission mainly concentrates on whether is monetary policy neutral, monetary policy transmission mechanism and the regional effects of monetary policy which appeared in recent years and is also main subject of this article. Scott (1955) is the scholar who earliest studied the regional effects of monetary policy. The basic of the monetary policy uniformity is that monetary policy implementation is a total regulation and not micro regulation, if we want to achieve the predetermined regulative goal, there is a very important prerequisite in the process of total regulation which is economical and financial identity in the regions of monetary policy implementation. Optimum Currency Areas which proposed by Robert ? Mundell, Nobel economic prize winner in 1999, is the basic theory supporting monetary integration. The subject of this article is to discuss and empirically examine the most fundamental reasons of the regional effects of Chinese monetary policy-the microscopic subject diversity. The transmission effects of monetary policy mainly depend on the behavior of the microscopic subject, regardless of monetary policy transmission mechanism.
     With the deepening of Chinese reform and opening-up、marketability advancement, regional characteristics of Chinese economy become more and more obvious. Chinese regional economies can be divided into eastern coastal areas, central region and western regions, whether from the perspective of financial system, industrial structure or general perspective. In view of the research subject, this article made a cluster analysis of marketability mean value index of various provincial levels areas from the year 2001 to 2005, and split Chinese 31 provincial level areas into economically developed regions, sub-developed regions and under-developed regions. We can see that China's regional economies' differences are very obvious by comparing the economic and financial situation of the three regions. In this background, whether china will have a regional effect of monetary policy in the process of the implementation of a unified monetary policy? What are the basic influencing factors? In the view of these questions, the main conclusions of this article are following:
     (1)Based on the theory of Optimum Currency Areas and the domestic and foreign research results, this article shows that Chinas' monetary policy has indeed an obvious regional effect, by using SVAR model and impulse response function, adopting the annual sample data from 1984 to 2006, and by empirical research on response to monetary policy of developed areas, sub-developed areas and underdeveloped areas.
     (2) This paper analyzes the formation and present situation as well as the causes of Chinas' regional differences of financial system, and has studied the relationship between financial system's level of development and the efficiency with the economic growth. This article takes the economic growth as the goal of monetary policy in the research of the influence of financial system difference on the regional effect of monetary policy. This paper empirically testes that financial system's level of development and the efficiency are advantageous to the promotion economic growth and that different regional financial system is dissimilar to economic growth's influence by establishing panel data regression model, so the regional effect of monetary policy bring about, which shows that china's regional financial system diversity is an important factor of the regional effect of monetary policy.
     (3) According to the theory of precautionary savings, this article inferred Chinese resident consuming model of various provinces and autonomous regions' residents consuming mode by empirical research. The factors that influent people's consumption can be reflected in the model, the paper analyzes the diversity existence of Chinas' consuming and savings behaviors by comparing the difference of factors that influent the various provinces and autonomous household consumption. Residents are important micro activities in a country, whose behaviors, especially the consuming-saving behaviors, have an important influence on monetary policy. Resident's consumption forms the final demand, resident's deposit forms the important origin of capital funds, resident's deposit and the consuming behavior is one of the fundamental factors that affect the monetary policy.
     (4)This article discusses theoretically the influence of enterprise's structure on monetary policy transmission and infers that different enterprise's structure in different regions have inconsistent response to the monetary policy and then causes the regional effect of monetary policy. By empirical examine, this paper validates that regional diversity of enterprise's structure is an essential factor in the formation of the regional effects of Chinese monetary policy.
     The objectives of monetary policy contain the composition of coordinated development of regional economy, China, as a large developing country in a period of economic transition, in order to achieve a smooth development of the national economy and avoid big ups and downs in the economy, and to realize the socialist market economic system of production purpose, only depend on the coordinated development of regional economy, monetary policy should serve for this goal. According to the conclusion, this article puts forward the related policy proposal, proposes that in order to slow down the regional effects of monetary policy, we should firstly smooth monetary policy transmission mechanism, then adjust the diversity of regional microscopic subjects (financial institutions, residents and enterprises) in the process of transmission, at last to a certain extent implements differentiated regional monetary policy, three-pronged common governance of regional effects of monetary policy.
引文
[1]Feldstein,M.(1997)."EMU and international conflict," Foreign Affairs,Vol.76,No.6,November/December,pp.60-73.
    [2]Mundell.Robert A.(1961)."A theory of optimum currency areas"[J],American economic review,vol.51,pp657-64.
    [3]Owyang.M.T.and H.J.Wall(2003)."Structural Breaks and Regional Disparities in the Transmission of Monetary Poliey".Working paper series,Working Paper 2003-008B:Federal Reserve Bank of st.Louis:http://research.stlouisfed.org/wp/2003/2003-008.pdf.
    [1]田霖,“金融地理学视角下的区域金融成长差异研究”,浙江大学博士学位论文,2005年
    [1]曾宪久,“货币政策传导机制论”,[M]中国金融出版社,北京,2004年版
    [1]樊太明,“金融结构及其对货币传导机制的影响”,[J]《经济研究》,2004第7期
    [2]陈学彬、杨凌、方松,货币政策效应的微观基础研究-我国居民消费储蓄行为的实证分析[J],《复旦学报(社会科学版)》,2005年第1期,第42-54页
    [3]陈安平,“我国财政货币政策的区域差异效应研究”,[J]《数量经济技术经济研究》,2007年第6期
    [1]Friedman,M.Essays in Positive Economics,University of Chicago Press.1953
    [2]Mundell.Robert A.(1961)."A theory of optimum currency areas"[J],American economic review,vol.51,pp657-64.
    [1]McKinnon,R.I.,1963,"Optimum Currency Areas",American Economic Review,53,717-725
    [2]Kenen,p.B.,1969,"The Theory of Optimum Currency Areas:An Eclectic View",in Mundell,R.A and A.K.Swoboda,ed.,Monetary Problems of the International Economy,Chicago:Chicago University Press.41-46.
    [3]Ingram,J.C.RegionalPaymentsMechanisms:The Case ofPuerto Rico.University ofNorth Carolina Press.1962
    [4]Fleming,J."On Exchange Rate Unification." The Economic Journal,1971,Vo.l 81,pp.467-488
    [5]Visser,Hans.AGuide to InternationalMonetaryEconomics:ExchangeRateTheories,Systems and Policies.Ch.6.Edward ElgarPublishing,2000.
    [1]祝丹涛,“最优货币区批判性评析”,[J]《世界经济》,2005年第1期
    [1]Bemanke,B.s.,and M.Gertler,1995,Inside the Black Box:The Credit Channel of Monetary Policy Transmission[J],Journal of Economic Perspect,9,27-48.
    [1]Beare,John B.A Monetarist Model of Regional Business Cycles.Journal of Regional Science.1976(16).
    [1]Toal,William D.(1977)."Regional Impacts of Monetary and Fiscal Policies in the Postwar Period:Some Initial Tests",Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta,Working Paper.
    [2]Garrison.Charles B.and Chang,Hui S.(1979)."The Effects of Monetary Forces in Regional Economic Activity".Journal of Regional Science.V19.p15-29
    [1]Owyang,M.T.and H.J.Wall(2003)."Structural Breaks and Regional Disparities in the Transmission of Monetary Policy".Working paper series,Working Paper 2003-008B;Federal Reserve Bank of st.Louis:http://research.stlouisfed.org/wp/2003/2003-008.pdf.
    [2]Beare,John B.A Monetarist Model of Regional Business Cycles.Journal of Regional Science,1976(16).
    [1]Arnold,I.J.M.and E.B.Vrugt(2004)."Firm Size,Industry Mix and the Regional Transmission of Monetary Policy in Germany." German Economic Review 5(1):35-59.
    [2]Ganley J.Salmon C.The industrial impact of monetary policy shocks:Some stylized facts[R].Working Paper from Bank of England.1997.
    [1]Ehrmann,M.Comparing Monetary Policy Transmission across European Countries.Review of World Economics.Vol.136,No.1.
    [1]Carlino,G.A.and Defina,R H.,1998,"The Differential Regional Effects of Monetary Policy"[J].The Review of Economics and Statistics,Vol.80,No.4:572-587.
    [1]王振山、王志强,“我国货币政策传导途径的实证研究”[J].《财经问题研究》,2000年第12期.
    [2]李斌,“中国货币政策有效性”,[J]《金融研究》,2001年第7期.
    [3]索彦峰、陈继明,“中国货币政策的区域效应研究—来自信用观点的解释”,[J]《当代经济科学》,2007年11月,第29卷 第6期
    [1]李雅丽,“基于信贷渠道视角的我国货币政策区域效应探析”,[J]《经济经纬》 2007第6期,第23-26页
    [2]宋旺、钟正生,“我国货币政策区域效应的存在性及原因-基于最优货币区理论的分析”,[J].《经济研究》,2006,3:46-58
    [3]丁文丽,“转轨时一期中国货币政策效力的区域差异研究”,[M]中国社会科学出版社,2005年
    [4]赵平,“企业负债率-形成我国货币政策区域效果差异的重要因素”,[J]《上海金融》,2006年第8期
    [5]李海海,“中国货币政策区域效应研究—非对称的机制与治理”,华东师范大学博士学位论文,2006年
    [6]常海滨、徐成贤,“我国货币政策传导机制区域差异的实证分析”,[J]《经济科学》,2007年第5期
    [1]陈学彬、杨凌、方松,货币政策效应的微观基础研究-我国居民消费储蓄行为的实证分析[J],《复旦学报(社会科学版)》,2005年第1期,第42-54页
    [2]陈安平,“我国财政货币政策的区域差异效应研究”,[J]《数量经济技术经济研究》,2007年第6期
    [3]卢盛荣、邹文杰,“货币政策地区效应的微观基础研究:我国省际居民消费储蓄行为的实证分析”,[J]《经济科学》,2006年第5期,第40-50页
    [4]张晶,“货币政策区域效应及其银行结构地区差异的关联”,[J]《改革》,2007年第10期
    [1]黄先开、邓述慧,“货币政策中性与非对称性的实证研究”,[J]《管理科学学报》,2000年第3卷第2期
    [2]刘金全、刘兆波,“我国货币政策作用非对称性和波动性的实证检验”,[J]《管理科学学报》,2003年第6卷第3期
    [3]赵进文、闵捷,“央行货币政策操作效果非对称性实证研究”,[J]《经济研究》,2005年第2期
    [4]张晶,“中国货币政策区域效应差异及其原因研究”,[J]《广东金融学院学报》 2006,7:70-79
    [5]张晶,“基于面板模型的我国货币政策区域不对称效应研究”,[J]《价格月刊》,2007年第3期
    [1]于刚,“我国货币政策的区域效应分析”,[J]《管理世界》,2006年第2期
    [2]刘玄、王剑.“货币政策传导地区差异:实证检验及政策含义”,[J]《财经研究》,2006,5:70-77
    [3]杨晓,杨开忠:“中国货币政策影响的区域差异性研究”,[J]《财经研究》 2007,2:4-15
    [4]周逢民,“论货币政策的结构调整职能”,[J]《金融研究》,2004年第7期
    [1]孙天琦,“货币政策:统一性前提下部分内容区域差别化研究“,[J]《金融研究》,2004年第5期
    [1]Mundell.Robert A.(1961) "A theory of optimum currency areas".[J]American economic review.vol.51,pp657-64.
    [1]Carlino G.and R.DeFina..1998,"The differential regional effects of monetary policy"[J],The Review of Economics and Statistics.Vol.11.PP572-587
    [1]丁文丽:转轨时期中国货币政策效力的区域差异研究[M].北京:中国社会科学出版社,2005
    [2]宋旺,钟正生:我国货币政策区域效应的存在性及原因[J].经济研究,2006,(3):46-58
    [3]张晶:货币政策区域效应及其银行结构地区差异的关联[J],改革,2007年第10期,第49-55页
    [1]陈安平:我国财政货币政策的区域差异效应研究[J],数量经济技术经济研究,2007年第6期,第56-64
    [2]高铁梅,计量经济分析方法与建模-Eviews应用及实例,[M]清华大学出版社,2006
    [1]周孟亮,“我国区域金融差异下货币政策传导机制效应研究”,暨南大学博士学位论文,2006年
    [1]周立、胡鞍钢,“中国金融发展的地区差距状况分析”,[J]《清华大学学报(哲学社会科学版)》,2002年第2期
    [2]田霖,“金融地理学视角下的区域金融成长差异研究”,浙江大学博士学位论文,2005年
    [1]张杰.中国的货币化进程、金融控制及改革困境[J].经济研究,1997,(8)
    [2]世界银行.1989a:中国:宏观经济稳定与工业增长(中译本)[M].北京:中国财政经济出版社,1990.
    [1]吴伟军,方霞,“居民储蓄行为差异对货币政策区域效应的影响”,[J]《山西财经大学学报》,2008年11月,第30卷第11朋
    [2]宋铮,“中国居民储蓄行为研究”,[J]《金融研究》,1999,第6期
    1 孙凤,“预防性储蓄理论与中国居民消费行为”,[J]《南开经济研究》2001.1,第54-58页
    [1]宋铮,中国居民储蓄行为研究,金融研究,1999,第6期
    [2]孙凤,预防性储蓄理论与中国居民消费行为,南开经济研究,2001,1
    [3]陈学彬、杨凌、方松:《货币政策效应的微观基础研究-我国居民消费储蓄行为的实证分析》[J].《复旦学报(社会科学版)》2005年第1期。
    [1]石长洪,“货币政策传导过程中的企业机构分析“,[J]《上海金融》2005年第1期,15-17
    [2]谢林林,“论中小企业存货币政策传导中的作用”,[J]《南方金融》2007年第8期,17-19
    [1]钱德勒,“企业规模经济与范围经济”,[M]北京:中国社会科学出版社.1999:5-9
    [1]常海滨、徐成贤,“我国货币政策传导机制区域差异的实证分析”,[J]《经济科学》,2007年第5期
    [2]陈安平,“我国财政货币政策的区域差异效应研究”,[J]《数量经济技术经济研究》,2007年第6期
    [3]陈德伟、徐琼、孙崎岖,“我国货币政策效果的非对称性实证研究”,[J]《数量经济技术经济研究》,2003年第5期
    [4]陈淼鑫,“最优货币理论及东亚单一货币区的构想”,[J]《财经研究》,2002年2月,第28卷第2期
    [5]陈学彬、杨凌、方松,货币政策效应的微观基础研究-我国居民消费储蓄行为的实证分析,[J]《复旦大学学报(社会科学版)》,2005年第1期,第42-54页
    [6]丁文丽,“转轨时一期中国货币政策效力的区域差异研究”,[M]中国社会科学出版社,2005年
    [7]斐平、熊鹏,“我国货币政策传导过程中的“渗漏”效应”,[J]《经济研究》,2003年第8期
    [8]樊太明,“金融结构及其对货币传导机制的影响”,[J]《经济研究》,2004第7期
    [9]樊纲、王小乞一、张立文、朱恒鹏,“中国各地区市场化相对进程报告”,[J]《经济研究》2003年第3期
    [10]冯涛、乔笙等:“双重调控下的货币政策绩效研究”,[J]《金融研究》,2006年第2期(总308)
    [11]耿同劲,“货币政策工具区域化研究”,[J]《上海金融》,2003年第5期。
    []耿识博、谢士强、董军,“货币政策区域不对称效应”,[J]《金融研究》,2005年第7期
    [12]高铁梅,计量经济分析方法与建模-Eviews应用及实例,[M]清华大学出版社,2006
    [13]高铁梅、王金明,“我国货币政策传导机制的动态分析”,[J]《金融研究》,2001年第3期
    [14]郭海宁,“货币政策区域差异性探讨”,[J]《南方金融》,2005年第11期
    [15]何泽荣,“中国货币政策:1994-2003”,[J]《经济学家》,2004年第1期
    [16]胡援成,“中国的货币乘数与货币流通速度研究”,[J]《金融研究》,2000年第10期
    [17]胡援成,蔡伟,“我国财政政策与货币政策的效应分析”,[J]《江西财经大学学报》,2002年第4期
    [18]胡援成,陶长高,“入世后我国货币传导机制的变化与对策”,[J]《中国审计》,2003年第1期
    [19]胡援成、程建伟,“中国资本市场货币政策传导机制的实证研究”,[J]《数量经济技术经济研究》,2003年第5期
    [20]胡振华、胡绪红,“金融结构差异与货币政策的区域效应”,[J]《财贸研究》2007年第5期
    [21]黄先开、邓述慧,“货币政策中性与非对称性的实证研究”,[J]《管理科学学报》,2000年第3卷第2期
    [22]黄梅波,“最优货币区理论与东亚货币合作的可能性分析”,[J]《世界经济》,2001年第10期
    [23]蒋瑛琨、刘艳武等,“货币渠道与信贷渠道传导机制有效性的实证分析”,[J]《金融研究》,2005年第5期
    [24]焦谨璞、孙天琦、刘向耕,“货币政策执行效果的区域差异分析”,[J]《金融研究》,2006年第3期
    [25]柯冬梅,“最优货币区理论及其对中国货币政策的借鉴”,[J]《中央财经大学学报》,2001年第1期
    [26]李炜,“关于区域金融行为与区域经济技术结构形成的研究”,[J]《金融研究》,2000年第6期
    [27]李雅丽,“基于信贷渠道视角的我国货币政策区域效应探析”,[J]《经济经纬》2007第6期,第23-26页
    [28]李心丹、刘瑛、刘铁军,“中国内地和香港能否构成最优货币区研究—来自实证结果的分析”,[J]《复旦学报(社会科学版)》2003年第5期
    [29]李海海,“中国货币政策区域效应研究—非对称的机制与治理”,[D]华东师范大学博士学位论文,2006年[
    30]林元辉、宛旭明,“非均衡区域金融体系中的货币政策传导差异分析”,[J]《新疆财经》,2004年第2期
    [31]刘玄、王剑.“货币政策传导地区差异:实证检验及政策含义”,[J]《财经研究》,2006,5:70-77
    [32]刘金全、刘兆波,“我国货币政策作用非对称性和波动性的实证检验”,[J]《管理科学学报》,2003年第6卷第3期
    [33]雷平、施祖麟,“企业数量、规模与经济增长—基于省级工业面板数据的研究”,[J]《经济经纬》,2008年第2期,101-104
    [34]卢盛荣、邹文杰,“货币政策地区效应的微观基础研究:我国省际居民消费储蓄行为的实证分析”,[J]《经济科学》,2006年第5期,第40-50页
    [35]卢盛荣,“转型期中国货币政策地区效应的实证研究”,[D]厦门大学博士学位论文,2007年
    [36]骆玉鼎,“区域经济发展不平衡与货币政策的局限性:最优货币区理论的启示”,[J]《金融研究》,1998年第4期
    [37]吕江林,“关于适度从紧的货币政策的反思”,[J]《当代财经》,2000年第3期
    [38]吕江林,“中国股票市场对货币政策影响的实证分析”,[J]《当代财经》,2004年11期
    [39]吕江林,“我国的货币政策是否应对股价变动做出反应?”,[J]《经济研究》2005年第3期
    [40]吕江林、张有,“中国不同经济流动性区制下的货币政策工具效应研究—基于马尔可夫区制转移(MS)模型的实证分析”,[J]《广东金融学院学报》,2008年第5期
    [41]吕江林,“改革开放30年的货币政策规范变迁—回顾与评析”,[J]《当代财经》,2008年12期
    [42]马根发,“最优货币区理论与我国区域货币政策选择”,[J]《当代经济研究》,2005年第9期
    [43]钱德勒,“企业规模经济与范围经济”,[M]北京:中国社会科学出版社,1999:5-9
    [44]钱彦敏、蒋振声,“论适度差别的货币金融区域发展模式”,[J]《经济研究》,1995年第5期
    [45]谢林林,“论中小企业在货币政策传导中的作用”,[J]《南方金融》2007年第8期,17-19
    [46]宋旺、钟正生,“我国货币政策区域效应的存在性及原因-基于最优货币区理论的分析”,[J]《经济研究》,2006,3:46-58
    [47]宋铮,“中国居民储蓄行为研究”,[J]《金融研究》,1999,第6期
    [48]石长洪,“货币政策传导过程中的企业机构分析”,[J]《上海金融》2005年第1期,15-17
    [49]孙凤,“预防性储蓄理论与中国居民消费行为”,[J]《南开经济研究》2001,1,第54-58页
    [50]孙天琦,“货币政策:统一性前提下部分内容区域差别化研究”,[J]《金融研究》,2004年第5期
    [51]世界银行,中国:宏观经济稳定与工业增长(中译本),[M]中国财政经济出版 社,北京,1990
    [52]索彦峰、陈继明,“中国货币政策的区域效应研究—来自信用观点的解释”,[J]《当代经济科学》,2007年11月,第29卷第6期
    [53]田霖,“金融地理学视角下的区域金融成长差异研究”,[D]浙江大学博士学位论文,2005年
    [54]王振山、王志强.:“我国货币政策传导途径的实证研究”,[J]《财经问题研究》.2000年第12期
    [55]王剑、刘玄,“货币政策传导的行业效应研究”,[J]《财经研究》,2005年第5期
    [56]王小鲁、樊纲,“中国地区差距的变动趋势和影响因素”,[J]《经济研究》2004年第1期
    [57]吴伟军,“转轨时期中国货币政策传导机制有效性的实证研究”,[J]《江西社会科学》,2008年第2期
    [58]吴伟军,“我国存在货币政策区域效应的实证研究”,[J]《金融理论与实践》,2008年第7期
    [59]吴伟军,方霞,“居民储蓄行为差异对货币政策区域效应的影响”,[J]《山西财经大学学报》,2008年11月,第30卷第11期
    [60]吴伟军,胡援成,“中国金融体制改革与货币政策区域效应”,[J]《社会科学家》,2008年第12期
    [61]吴伟军,“区域企业结构差异对我国货币政策区域效应的影响”,[J]《上海金融》,2009年第3期
    [62]杨晓,杨开忠:“中国货币政策影响的区域差异性研究”,[J]《财经研究》2007,2:4-15
    [63]于刚,“我国货币政策的区域效应分析”,[J]《管理世界》,2006年第2期
    [64]张晶,“中国货币政策区域效应差异及其原因研究”,[J]《广东金融学院学报》2006,7:70-79
    [65]张晶,“国外货币政策区域效应研究的新进展”,[J]《上海金融》,2006年第12期
    [66]张晶,“货币政策区域效应及其银行结构地区差异的关联”,[J]《改革》,2007年第10期
    [67]张晶,“基于面板模型的我国货币政策区域不对称效应研究”,[J]《价格月刊》,2007年第3期
    [68]张晓恫,“计量经济学软件EViews使用指南”,[M]南开大学出版社,2003年版
    [69]张杰,“中国的货币化进程、金融控制及改革困境”,[J]经济研究,1997,(8)
    [70]曾宪久,“货币政策传导机制论”,[M]中国金融出版社,北京,2004年版
    [71]周逢民,“论货币政策的结构调整职能”,[J]《金融研究》,2004年第7期
    [72]周英章、蒋振声:“货币渠道、信用渠道与货币政策有效性”,[J]《金融研究》,2002年第9期(总267期)
    [73]周立、胡鞍钢,“中国金融发展的地区差距状况分析”,[J]《清华大学学报(哲学社会科学版)》,2002年第2期
    [74]周孟亮,“我国区域金融差异下货币政策传导机制效应研究”,[D]暨南大学博士学位论文,2006年
    [75]赵平,“企业负债率-形成我国货币政策区域效果差异的重要因素”,[J]《上海金融》,2006年第8期
    [76]赵进文、闵捷,“央行货币政策操作效果非对称性实证研究”,[J]《经济研究》,2005年第2期
    [77]祝丹涛,“最优货币区批判性评析”,[J]《世界经济》,2005年第1期
    [1]Adam Elbourne,Jakob de Haan(2006),Financial structure and monetary policy transmission in transition countries,Journal of Comparative Economics.Vol.34,No.1,p.1-23.
    [2]Aksoy,Y,P.De Grauwe,H.Dewachter.Do Asymmetries Matter for European Monetary Policy? European Economic Review.2002(46).
    [3]Allen,C.and J.L.Vega,(1997)."The Credit Channel in the Monetary Transmission Process in the EU countries",MESD mimeo,European Monetary Institute.
    [4]Alessandra Guariglia and Simona Mateut,"Credit channel,trade credit channel,and inventory investment:Evidence from a panel of UK firms"[J]Journal of Banking&Finance,Volume 30,Issue 10,October 2006,Pages 2835-2856.
    [5]Almila Karasoy,KUrgat Kunter and Vuslat Us,"Monetary transmission mechanism in Turkey under free float using a small-scale macroeconomic model"[J]Economic Modelling,Volume 22,Issue 6,December 2005,Pages 1064-1073.
    [6]Angelo Baglioni,"Monetary policy transmission under different banking structures:The role of capital and heterogeneity"[J]International Review of Economics&Finance,In Press,Corrected Proof,Available online 22 June 2005.
    [7]Angeloni,Anil K.Kashyap and Benoit Mojon:Monetary policy transmission in the Euro area:a study by the Eurosystem Monetary Transmission Network,New York: Cambridge University Press,c2003.
    
    [8]Arnold, LJ.M. and C.G, de Vries, (1999). "Endogenous Financial Structure and the Transmission of ECB Policy", in: J. von Hagen en C. Waller (eds.) Common Money, Uncommon Regions, Kluwer Academic Publishers, forthcoming.
    
    [9]Arnold, I. J. M. and E. B. Vrugt (2004). "Firm Size, Industry Mix and the Regional Transmission of Monetary Policy in Germany." German Economic Review 5(1): 35-59.
    
    [10]Arnold, I. J. M.,. C. J. M. Kool, et al. (2005). "New evidence on the firm size effects in us monetary policy transmission." Discussion Paper Series OS-11, Utrecht School of Economics,Bailing C. Koopmans Research Institute.
    
    [11]Barran, F, V Coudert and B. Mojon, (1997). "The Transmission of Monetary European Countries", in: European Monetary Policy, Pinter, London, 81-118.
    
    [12]Barro, R.and Gordon, D. (1983). "Rules discretion and reputation in a model of monetary policy",journal of monetary economics, 12:101-21.
    
    [13]Beare,John B.A Monetarist Model of Regional Business Cycles. Journal of Regional Science, 1976(16).
    
    [14]Bemanke, B.s., and M.Gertler, 1995, Inside the Black Box: The Credit Channel of Monetary Policy Transmission[J], Journal of Economic Perspect, 9, 27-48.
    
    [15]Bernanke Ben · S, Blinder, A· The Federal Funds Rate and the Channels of Monetary Transmission. American Economic Re-view, 1992(9): 900-922.
    
    [16]Beng Soon Chong, Ming-Hua Liu and Keshab Shrestha, "Monetary transmission via the administered interest rates channel"[J]Journal of Banking&Finance, Volume 30, Issue 5, May 2006, Pages 1467-1484.
    
    [17]Bini Smaghi, L. and S. Vori, (1993). "Rating the EC as an Optimal Currency Area" Temi di Discussione, No. 187, Banca d'Italia, Rome.
    
    [18]Blachard,Olivier and Danny Quach. The Dynamic Effect of Aggregate Demand and Supply Disturbances[J].American Economic Review,1989,79:655-673.
    
    [19]Britton, E. and J. Whitley(1997), Comparing the Monetary Transmission Mechanism in France, Germany and the United Kingdom: Some issues and Results Bank of England Quarterly Bulletin, May, pp. 152 - 162.
    
    [20]S. N. Brissimis, N. S. Magginas. Changing in Financial Structure and Asset Price Substitutability:A Test of the Bank Lending Channel[J].Economic Modelling,2005:l-26.
    
    [21]Carlo Ahavilla. Measuring Monetary Policy Asymmetries across EMU Countries.Federal Reserve Bank of ST.LOUIS Working Paper.May 2000.
    
    [22]Carlo, A. and L. Luigi (2005), "Cross-country asymmetries transmission: evidence from EMU members" International in monetary policy Review of Applied Economics, 19, pp. 87-106.
    
    [23]Carlino,G.A.and Defina,R H.,1998,"The Differential Regional Effects of Monetary Policy"[J].The Review of Economics and Statistics, Vol.80,No.4:572-587.
    
    [24]Carlino Gerald A, Robert DeFina, Regional income dynamics [J] Journal of Urban Economics, 1995, 37,88 - 106.
    
    [25]Cecchetti, S.G, 1995, Distinguishing Theories of The Monetary Transmission Mechanism[J], Federal Reserve Bank of St.Louis Review, 77, 83-97.
    
    [26]Cecchetti S.Legal Structure, Financial Structure, and the Monetary Policy Transmission Mechanism. FRBNY Economic Policy Review. 1999(5)
    
    [27]Charles S. Morris, Gordon H. Sellon Jr, "Bank Lending and Monetary Policy: Evidence on a credit channel"[J], FRBKC Economic Review, 1995, 2nd Quarter.,pp43-52
    
    [28]Christiano, Lawrence J., and L. Ljungqvist,(1988)"Money Does Granger-Cause Output in the Bivariate Money-Output Relation"Journal of Monetary Economics 22. 217-23.
    
    [29]Cover, J·P·Asymmetric Effects of Positive and Negative Money-supply Shocks · Quarterly Journal of Economics, 1992(17): 1261-1282.
    
    [30]Deatom,A., 1991,"Saving and Liquidity Constraints", [J] Econometrica 59(5), 1221-48.
    
    [31]Dedola, L. and F. Lippi (2005), "The monetary transmission mechanism:evidence from the industries of five DECD countries,"European Economic Review;49, pp. 1543-1569.
    
    [32]Duo Qin, Pilipinas Quising, Xinhua He and Shiguo Liu, "Modeling monetary transmission and policy in China" Journal of Policy Modeling, Volume 27, Issue2, March 2005, Pages 157-175.
    
    [33]Di Giacinto Valter, Differential regional effects of monetary policy: A geographical SVAR approach [J], International Regional Science Review,2003,26,301-341.
    
    [34]Ehrmann, M, Comparing Monetary Policy Transmission across European Countries, Review of World Economics, Vol. 136, No. 1.
    
    [35]Ester, Faia. Monetary Policy in a World with Different Financial System, ECB Working Paper NO. 183,October 2002.
    
    [36]Epstein,Larry G., and Zin, Stanley E.1989."Substitution, Risk Aversion, and the Temporal Behavior of Consumption and Asset Returns:A Theoretical Framework." Econometrica 46(July): 937-969.
    
    [37]European Central Bank."EU Banking Structures"[R].Frankrurt, 2005.
    
    [38]Favero, C. and R Giavazzi, (1999). "An Evaluation of Monetary Policy Transmission in the Context of the European Central Bank", A Report to the European Parliament.
    
    [39]Favero, C., F Giavazzi and L. Flabbi, (1999). "The Transmission Mechanism of Monetary Policy in Europe: Evidence from Banks' Balance Sheets", NBER Working Paper, No.7231.
    
    [40]Feldstein, M.(1997)."EMU and international conflict," Foreign Affairs, Vol. 76, No. 6,November/December, pp. 60-73.
    
    [41]Ford, D. and I. Sin. (2003). "The distributional effects of monetary policy." Working Paper(Draft version).
    
    [42]Fountas,Stilianos&Papagapitos, Agapitos.The Monetary Transmission Mechanism: Evidence and Implications for European Monetary Union.2001(3),pp397-404.
    
    [43]Friedman,M,1968 , "The role of monetary policy",American Economic Review ,pp. 1-17.
    
    [44]Friedman, M.Essays in Positive Economics, University of Chicago Press, 1953
    
    [45]Fleming, J." On Exchange Rate Unification." The Economic Journal, 1971,Vo.l 81, pp. 467-488
    
    [46]Garrison, Charles B. and Chang, Hui S. (1979). "The Effects of Monetary Forces in Regional Economic Activity", Journal of Regional Science, V19, p15-29
    
    [47]Ganley J, Salmon C. The industrial impact of monetary policy shocks: Some stylized facts[R]. Working Paper from Bank of England, 1997.
    
    [48]Ganev, G ,Molnar, K.Transmission Mechanism of Monetary Policy in Central and Eastern Europe. CASE Report, 2002(52).
    
    [49]Ganley, J.&C. Salmon.The Industrial Impact of Monetary Policy Shocks; Some Stylised Facts, Bank of England Working Paper, 1997(68).
    
    [50]Glenn D. Rudebusch. A Macro-Finance Model of the Term Structure, Monetary Policy, and the Economy. FRBSF Working 2003(17).
    
    [51]George Georgopoulos. Measuring Regional Effects of Monetary Policy in Canada.International Advances in Economic Research ,2001(7).
    
    [52]Georgios Karras, Are the Output Effects of Monetary Policy Asymmetric? Evidence from a Sample of European Countries, Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics, 1996,3,267-268.
    
    [53]Goldsmith, R. W. (1969). "Financial Structure and Development", Yale University Press.
    
    [54]Gros, D. and N. Thygesen (1998). "European Monetary Integration: From the European Monetary System to European Monetary Union", Addison Wesley Longman, London and New York.
    
    [55]Hayo,B.and B.Uhlenbrock(1999)."Industry effects of monetary policy in Germany".ZEI working paper B14, Center for European Integration Studies, Rheinische Friedrich-Wilhelms-Universitat Bonn.
    
    [56]Hayo, B., and B. Uhlenbrock (1999)."Sectoral Effects of Monetary Policy in Germany", in: J. von Hagen en C. Waller (eds.) Common Money, Uncommon Regions, HIuwer Academic Publishers, forthcoming.
    
    [57]Hallett A.,&Piscitelli L.EMU in reality: the eoect of a common monetary policy on the economies with dioerent Transmission Mechanisms,CEPR Discussion Paper .1998,2068.
    
    [58]Hanna Putkuri.Cross-Country Asymmetries in Euro Area Monetary Transmission: the Role of National Financial Systems. Bank of Finland Discussion Paper. 2003 (15).
    
    [59]Horvath, m. (1998). "Empirical evidence on common money and uncommon regions in the US, paper presented at zei-conference", "common money, uncommon regions", Bonn.
    
    [60]Horvath, m. (1998). "Empirical evidence on common money and uncommon regions in the US, paper presented at zei-conference", "common money, uncommon regions", Bonn.
    
    [61]Hughes Hallett, A.J. and L. Piscitelli (1999). "EMU in Reality: The Effect of a Common Monetary Policy on Economies with Different Transmission Mechanisms, CEPR Discussion Paper, No. 2068.
    
    [62]Ibrahim Chowdhury, Mathias Hoffmann and Andreas Schabert, "Inflation dynamics and the cost channel of monetary transmission" [J] European Economic Review, Volume 50, Issue 4, May 2006, Pages 995-1016.
    
    [63]Ibrahim, Mansoor H. (2005), "Sectoral effects of monetary policy: evidence from Malaysia,"Asian Economic Journal. 19, pp. 83-102.
    [64]Ingram, J. C. Regional Payments Mechanisms: The Case of Puerto Rico.University of North Carolina Press, 1962.
    
    [65]Inna Golodniuk "Evidence on the bank-lending channel in Ukraine" Research in International Business and Finance, Volume 20, Issue 2, June Pages 180-199.
    
    [66]Ippei Fujiwara,"Is there a direct effect of money?: Money estimated monetary business cycle model of the Japanese"[J]economy Japan and the World Economy, In Press, Corrected Proof, Available online 22 August 2006.
    
    [67]Jensen, G R., R. R. Johnson, et al. (1997). "Federal reserve monetary policy and industry stock returns." Journal of Business Finance&Accounting 24(5).
    
    [68]Kaoru Hosono, "The transmission mechanism of monetary policy in Japan: Evidence from banks' balance sheets" [J] Journal of the Japanese and International Economies, Volume 20, Issue 3, September 2006, Pages 380-405.
    
    [69]Kashyap, A.K., (1997)."The Lending Channel and European Monetary Union", in:European Monetary Policy, Pinter, London, 42-71.
    
    [70]Kashyap, Anil K., Stein, Jeremy C., and Wilcox, D. (1993). "Monetary Policy and Credit Conditions: Evidence from the Composition of External Finance", American Economic Review 83, pp. 78-98.
    
    [71]Kieler, M. and T. Saarenheimo, (1998). "Differences in Monetary Policy Transmission? A Case not closed", draft.
    
    [72]Kenen,p.B.,1969, "The Theory of Optimum Currency Areas:An Eclectic View ",in Mundell ,R.A and A.K. Swoboda,ed., Monetary Problems of the International Economy, Chicago:Chicago University Press,41-46.
    
    [73]Leeper, Sims and Zha (1996)."What Does Monetary Policy Do?", Brookings Papers on economic Activity No_ 2_ 1-78.
    
    [74]Leonardo Gambacorta"Inside the bank lending channel"[J] European Economic Review, Volume 49, Issue 7, October 2005, Pages 1737-1759.
    
    [75]Luca Dedola and Francesco Lippi, "The monetary transmission mechanism: Evidence from the industries of five DECD countries"[J]European Economic Review, Volume 49, Issue 6, August 2005, Pages 1543-1569.
    
    [76]McKinnon,R.I.,1963, "Optimum Currency Areas",American Economic Review, 53,717-725
    
    [77]M.Ehrmann, Comparing Monetary Policy Transmission across European Countries[J], Weltwirtschaftlicges Archiv, 2000,136, 58 - 83.
    
    [78]Mishkin, R, (1995)."Symposium on the Monetary Transmission Mechanism",Journal of Economic Perspectives, 9(4), 3-10.
    
    [79]Mishkin, F,(1996)."The Channels of Monetary Transmission: Lessons for Monetary Policy", Banque de France Bulletin: Digest, No. 27,33-44.
    
    [80]Mojon, B. (2000). "Financial structure and the interest rate channel of ECB monetary policy". Working paper series, European Central Bank, 2000.
    
    [81]Mundell.Robert A.(1961)."A theory of optimum currency areas"[J], American economic review, vol.51, pp657-64.
    
    [82]Nelson, C.R. and Plosser, C.l.(1980)."Trends and Random walks in Macroeconomic Time Series: Some Evidence and Implications", Journal of Monetary Economics, September.
    
    [83]Owyang, M. T. and H. J. Wall (2003). "Structural Breaks and Regional Disparities in the Transmission of Monetary Policy". Working paper series, Working Paper 2003-008B; Federal Reserve Bank of st. Louis: http://research.stlouisfed.org/wp/2003/2003-008.pdf.
    
    [84]Rafaf, Kierzenkowski, "The multi-regime bank lending channel and the effectiveness of the Polish monetary policy transmission during transition" [J] Journal of Comparative Economics, Volume 33, Issue 1, March 2005, Pagesl-24.
    
    [85]R. Ghosh and H. C. Wolf. (1994). "How Many Monies? A Genetic Approach to Finding Optimum Currency Areas", NBER, Working Paper, No. 4805.
    
    [86]Rene Garcia and Huntley Schaller, Are the Effects of Monetary Policy Asymmetric? Economic Inquiry, 2002,1, 102-119.
    
    [87]Rose, Andrew K. And W incoop, Eric van."National Money as a Barrier to International Trade: The Real Case for Currency Union."AEA Papers And Proceedings.2001.
    
    [88]Stephen D. Oliner, Glenn D. Rudebusch ,"Is there a broad credit channel of monetary policy?"[J],FRBSF Economic Review, 1996 (1): 21-26.
    
    [89]Taylor,J.,(1995)."The Monetary Transmission Mechanism: An Empirical Framework", Journal of Economic Perspectives, 9(4), 11-26.
    
    [90]Tena J. Dios and A. Tremayna (2006), "Modeling monetary transmission in UK manufacturing industry,"Universidad Carlos III de Madrid, Working paper 06-29(11).
    
    [91]Toal, William D. (1977). "Regional Impacts of Monetary and Fiscal Policies in the Postwar Period: Some Initial Tests", Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta, Working Paper.
    [92]Visser,Hans. A Guide to International Monetary Economics: Exchange Rate Theories, Systems and Policies. Ch. 6, Edward Elgar Publishing,2000.
    
    
    [93]Volker Clausen&Bernd Hayo. Asymmetric Monetary Policy Effects in EMU.ZMI Working Paper.March.2002.
    
    [94]Yoshihide Ishiyama. (1975). "Theory of Optimum Currency Areas: A Survy", IMF Staff Papers VOL 22, No. 2, pp. 357.
    
    [95]Yunus Aksoy&Paul De Grauwe.. Do Asymmetries Matter for European MonetaryPolicy?. European Economic Review .2002(46), 443-469.
    
    [96]Zhang, Z. (2005).accession countries and the Konstanz. "Asymmetries in monetary transmission channels between the EMU countries". Seminar: International Monetary Integration.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700