用户名: 密码: 验证码:
“按收入比例还款”型学生贷款:国际模式与中国设计
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
本研究以中国经济社会发展状况为背景,在国际比较视野下展开“按收入比例还款”型学生贷款(ICL)的运作模式和必备条件的全面研究,阐明该学生贷款形式的实施机理、运作过程和社会功能。本文基于教育个人投资风险理论,探讨中国学生贷款问题,从理论和现实上论证ICL实施的必要性,并从个人收入和制度背景两个角度分析“按收入比例”还款型学生贷款在中国的可行性,试图寻求适合中国背景的学生贷款方案。
     从理论上看,文章以教育个人投资风险作为实施“按收入比例还款”型学生贷款的理论基础。笔者运用中国社会科学院经济研究所“中国城乡居民收入分配”课题组2002年住户调查数据的7000多个样本,以分位数回归明瑟收益率的变异系数作为风险值指标,求得中国个人教育投资风险值为0.18,高于与之进行比较的其他国家的风险值中位数0.14。同时,笔者通过数理模型分析了“按收入比例还款”型学生贷款的风险分担机制,从理论上阐明了实施ICL的必要性。
     从现实角度看,本文分析了中国高等教育收费和学生贷款政策的改革路径,结合中国居民当前平均收入,论证了低收入群体在“即时支付”和定期定额学生贷款模式下按期偿还贷款的难度,指出探索ICL方案的必要性。因为实施ICL的出发点还在于对弱势群体给予必要的补偿,因为他们绝大多数都是改革成本的承担者,政府有必要让他们获得合理的补偿,以保障应有的权利。
     就可供中国考虑的其他国家实施ICL的模式来看,笔者将ICL划分为经典型和变形式,并将经典型区分为“总收入累进比例还款型”、“超额收入固定比例还款型”和“选择型超额收入累进比例还款型”;将变形式区分为“松散型ICL”和“人力资本合同”。再结合澳大利亚、英国、加拿大、美国的实践,文章分别论述了上述各种类型ICL的实施背景、特点和条件。
     探讨发展中国家实施ICL的适用性是本文的主体和核心。论文从五个方面进行了充分的研究并发现,中国若要实施ICL,需要有这样的基本条件:(1)适当学费、合理债务收入比、低教育投资风险和低还款负担率支撑的还款能力;(2)覆盖面广、高度发达的用于回收贷款的税收或养老金系统;(3)相对同质化的收入水平,便于统一还款底线,确定还款率;(4)低通货膨胀率和稳定的银行借款利率;(5)学者们具有前瞻性的研究可为学生贷款的设计、实施和改革发挥作用。
     中国特有的人口、经济、社会条件是学生贷款开展所依赖的基础。在对国际经验和ICL的中国适用条件进行了研究的基础上,笔者设计出中国“按收入比例还款”型学生贷款的实施方案,并提出,毕业生的收入将直接影响到ICL模式中的学生还款能力;政府的财力是ICL学生贷款能否持续开展的决定因素。借用“中华英才网”调查的毕业生平均收入的数据,本文测算了不同学生贷款还款模式下的毕业生偿还情况,结论表明:当实施定期定额还款型学生贷款时,毕业生的还款负担率过高;当实施按收入比例还款时,还款年限太长;假若尝试毕业生税,则还款现值难以弥补高等教育成本支出。因而,提高毕业生收入是促进偿还的关键因素。从政府财力来看,就2004—2020年模拟结果而言,政府提供本金的最高峰出现在2017年,该年度需要提供210亿。而按照当前财政性高等教育经费占GDP的0.61%计算,我国2020年高等教育财政性经费可达到2,135亿元(《十七大报告》指出2020年GDP总值为35万亿元),学生贷款需要的经费将占我国财政性高等教育经费的10%。与此同时,我国正在建设一流大学,基础设施建设和师资队伍建设对经费的需求亟为迫切,可以说,将财政性高等教育经费的10%用于学生贷款在现实中有较大难度。
Based on Chinese social and economic background, this article conducted comprehensive research on the implementation model and required conditions of Income-contingent Loan (ICL). This article explored the feasibility of ICL from empirical and systematic perspective and practical student loan scheme in China.
     The theory of risk on educational investment is the basis of ICL. This article analyzed the sources and characteristic of educational investment risk and make empirical analysis. This thesis estimated the risk value is 0.18 which is higher than average value 0.14 by using the CHIP 2002 data and the co-efficiency of variance of Mincer rate of education return. Furthermore, the author analyzed the risk-shary mechanism of ICL in theory.
     The article described the reform of Chinese college fee and student loan policy. Based on the average income, the author explained the difficult of "up-front payment" and "fixed-time repayment" under mortgage student loan, and the necessisity to carry out ICL. To compensate for the low income group justified the exploration of ICL since the low income group shouldered the cost of economic reform and it's the responsibility for the government to provide the subsidy and ensure their right.
     This article categorized ICL into classical and flexible ICL and also classifies classical ICL into "progressive repayment on total income" and "fixed ratio repayment on extra income". The thesis discussed the background, characteristic and condition for all the different types of ICL.
     The required conditions for ICL are indespensible. This article indicated the importance of five core conditions as following: (1) repayment ability related with suitable tuition fee and debt-to-burden ratio, low educational investment risk and low repayment burden ratio; (2) Income tax or pension system with widespread coverage and high development; (3) Homogeneous income level for streamlined repayment threshold and repayment rate; (4) macroeconomics condition: low inflation rate and interest rate; (5) persistent and far-sighting research conducted by scholar.
     This thesis designed the ICL scheme for China and summarized two challenges from 2 perspectives: graduate income and government financial ability. As for graduate income, the part analyzed the repayment of different student loan scheme using the average income from "China Human Resource Web". The result indicated that the schemes will be faced with different challenges: the repayment burden ratio is extremely high under the Mortgage Student Loan; the repayment periods are too longer under the Income-contingent Loan; the present value of repayment can't meet the private cost of higher education under graduate tax. In the terms of financial ability, the peak of financial capital from government is in 2017 and it's difficult for the government to mobilize 21billion Yuan for student loan.
引文
1 Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development(OECD),On the Edge:Securing a Sustainable Future for Higher Education(2004) at http://www.oecd.org/dataoecd/7/28/19809275.pdf
    2 中国高等教育毛入学率达23%,学生人数世界第一。http://www.jyb.com.cn/xwzx/gdjy/sxkd/t20070912_112025.htm,2007,9,12 中国教育新闻网
    1 可怜天下父母心 送子上学露宿校园心也甜?http://edu.people.com.cn/GB/4727012.html人民网教育频道.2006,8,22
     2 张殊:世界第一的中国大学收费.http://www.eol.cn/yan_lun_1868/20060323/t20060323_135627_2.shtml,中国教育在线.2005,8,17
    1 2004年国家助学贷款统计:国家对高校贫困生资助政策初步建立 新闻中心:http://www.gkzslq.cn/中国高考招生录取网2005-1-8 15:54:56来源:新华网
    2 Adrian Ziderman & D.Albrecht.Cost Recovery for Higher Education:Are Student Loans an Effective Instrument?World Bank Research Observer,1993(8):71-90
    3 北京大学“高等教育规模扩展与劳动力市场”课题组 2005年高校毕业生就业状况的调查分析,桂林:2005年中国教育经济学年会会议论文,2005:2
    1 中华人民共和国教育部.2007年全国教育事业发展统计公报http://www.edu.cn/xin_wen_dong_tai_890/20080505/t20080505 294800.shtml 教育部网站.,2008 年 4 月
    2 普通本科高校、高等职业学样家庭经济困难学生资助政策的贯彻落实情况.教育部网站,网址:http://www,moe.edu.cn/edoas/website 18/leve13.jsp?tablcname=2509&infoid=36768
    1 新西兰教育部,2004年新西兰学生贷款年报,http://www.minedu.govt.nt.nz/index.cfm,p24
    1 赵中建.学生贷款中若干问题的比较研究.外国教育资料,1994(3):32-24
    2 魏新.教育财政学.北京:高等教育出版社.2000:137
    3 何水、刘放、郑磊、谢洪彬等.国家助学贷款还贷问题调研报告.http://zkw.swufe.edu.cn/id2002/20021.doc,2006-03-14
    4 吕炜等著.高等教育财政:国际经验与中国道路选择.大连:东北财经大学出版社,2003:59
    5 钟宇平,等.成本回收:中国高等教育财政的另类选择[J].教育发展研究.1997(12):39-44。
    1 Chapman,B.(2005).Income Contingent Loans for Higher Education:International Reform Centre of Economic Policy Research Discussion Paper No.491 Australian National University.
    2 赵中建.学生贷款中若干问题的比较研究.外国教育资料,1994(3):32-24
    3 魏新.教育财政学.北京:高等教育出版社,2000:137
    4 D.布鲁斯·约翰斯通.按收入比例还款型学生贷款在发展中国家和转型国家的适用性.北京大学教育评论.2004,2(1):20-27
    5 沈华.中国国家助学贷款多元化还款模型的设计--基于高等教育个人收益差异的计量.华中科技大学博士论文2005年.2005:45-46
    1 D.布鲁斯·约翰斯通.按收入比例还款型学生贷款在发展中国家和转型国家的适用性.北京大学教育评论.2004,2(1):20-27
    2 李应军、刘在洲等.大学生缴纳学费的现状调查及分析.现代大学教育,2004(6):86.
    3 刘芳.助学贷款证券化在中国的适用性研究.北京:北京大学硕士学位论文。2004:32
    4 赵中建.学生贷款中若干问题的比较研究.全球教育展望。1994(3):25-34
    5 赵中建.学生贷款偿还方式的比较研究.高等师范教育研究,1994(5):31.38
    6 张民选.高等教育机会均等与大学生资助政策变迁及新的挑战.上海高教研究,1997(12):33
    7 贷款制的理想与理想的贷款制..论我国高等教育贷学金制度的改革.上海高教研究.1995(3):37-40
    8 罗伟成.国家助学贷款中的信用评分方法研究.北京:北方工业大学硕士学位论文.2004:36-42
    9 陈浩.国家助学贷款担保的研究.武汉,华中科技大学2005年硕士论文,2005:1
    1 何文标.放大教育投资规模:调整高教支山负担主体与时段.教育研究,2005(1):41-46
    2 郭从斌.丁小浩.中国劳动力市场分割中的行业代际效应及教育的作用.教育研究.2005(1):34-40
    3 邓娅.地区经济发展差异与高等教育成本补偿届地化.北京:北京大学硕士学位论文,2003:36
    4 知识失业是指受过较高教育的劳动力处于不得其用的状态。来自:杨竹节.论教育深化与知识失业.江苏高教,2003(2):52-53
    1 Alissa Goodman,Andrew Leicester,Howard Reed.A graduate tax for the UK? Economic Journal,2000(110):82-91
    2 Chapman,B.(2005).Income Contingent Loans for Higher Education:International Reform Centre of Economic Policy Research Discussion Paper No.491 Australian National University.
    1 Miguel Palacios.Human Capital Contracts "Equity-like" Instruments for Financing Higher Education.Policy Analysis,2002:8-12
    2 Carmichael H.L.(2004) Timing the Payment of Tuition To Enhance Accessibility:A Graduate Tax? Queen's University.p9-12 http://www.utoronto.ca/presidenl/04conference/downioads/Carmichael.pdf
    1 Christopher.Colclough.Raising Additional Resources for Education in Developing Countries:Are Graduates Payroll Taxes Superior to Student Loans? Educational Development,1990(10):169-180.
    1 赵宏斌.教育收益与风险的国际比较及对我国的启示.比较教育研究,2004(8):44-49
    2 刘乐山.关于进一步发展助学贷款的思考.教育与经济,2002(3):39-42
    3 李小平.助学贷款运行中的问题与对策研究.重庆:西南农业大学硕士学位论文.2003:24-32
    4 张丽萍,钱强.试论国家助学贷款风险规避的原则和对策.教育与经济,2004(2):47-49
    5 胡进.国家助学贷款风险成因的经济学分析.教育与经济,2001(3):38-40
    6 李小平.助学贷欺运行中的问题与对策研究.重庆:西南农业大学硕士学位论文,2003:24-32
    7 崔译文.通过金融创新解决高等教育贷款中的困难.江苏高教,2003(6):9-13
    1 马晓强.我国城镇居民个人教育投资风险的实证研究.教育研究,2005(4):25-31
    2 马晓强.我国城镇居民个人教育投资风险的实证研究.教育研究,2005(4):25-31
    1 Pedro Telhado Pereira,Pedro Silva Martins.Is There a Return-Risk Link in Education? 2002.
    2 陈建宝,丁军军.分位数回归技术综述.统计与信息论坛,2008(3):89-97
    1 Bruce Chapman(2007) Hecs For Tafe:The Case For Extending Income Contingent Loans To The Vocational Education And Training Sector Treasury Working Paper,2007,4,p 17
    2 Claudio E.Montenegro,Wage Distribution in Chile:Does Gender Matter? A Quantile Regression Approach,The World Bank Development Research Group.2001:35
    3 Byung-Joo Lee and Mary J.Lee,Quantile Regression Analysis of Wage Determinants in the Korean Labor Market.The Journal of the Korean Economy,2006,7(1):164
     Corrada Andini,Return to Education and Wage Equations:a Dynamic Approach.availble at www.uma.pt/andini/Documentos/DERWI_DA3%20mod2.pdf p16
    5 Paolo Naticchioni,Andrea Ricci and Emiliano Rustichelli,Education and Wage Inequity in Italy:a Ouantile Decomposition Approach? 2007(2):13
    6 Sourafel Girma and Abbi Kedir.Is education more beneficial to the less able? Econometric evidence from Ethiopia.2003:16
    7 Milton Friedman.(1955).The Role of Government in Education," in Robert A.Solo,ed.,Economics and the Public Interest(New Brunswick,N J.:Rutgers University Press,):32
    1李湘萍.商校助学贷款流向何处[J].科学中国人.2001(12):48-49
    2 胡银环.试论学生资助制度在实现教育公平中的作用[J].教育与经济,2000:27-29
    1 李实.中国城市中的三种贫困类型[J].经济研究.2002(10):47-55
    2 关力群,吕春侠,陈桂芝.加强学生欠费收缴势在必行[J].中国管理信息化,2007,10(3):67
    1 国家教委.关于改革国家教委直属院校学生贷款办法的通知[N],国家教委政报,1995(11)
    1孙汝祥,国家助学货款期待各方合力推进[N].中国经济日报,2006-9-22
    1 教育部连开5次发布会,破解助学贷款违约率困局.[EB/OL]http://315sd.ccn.com.cn/shownews.asp?newsid=1662006.9:15
    1 Milton Friedman.(1955).The Role of Government in Education," in Robert A.Solo,ed.,Economics and the Public Interest(New Brunswick,N J.:Rutgers University Press,.1955:23
    2 Alex Usher.(2004).Much ado about an idea[P].Canadian Higher Education Report Series,Stafford and Toronto Educational Policy Institute:p6.
    3 魏新.教育财政学简明教程[M].北京:高等教育出版社,2000:137
    4 Chapman,B.,Freiberg,A.,Ouiggin,J.and Tait,D.Rejuvenating Financial Penalties:Using the Tax System to Collect Fines[P].Canberra:Australian National University Discussion Papers.Available at:http://econrsss.anu.edu.au/pdf/DP461.pdf 2004:34
    1 D.布鲁斯·约翰斯通著.沈红,李红桃译.高等教育财政:问题与出路fMl.北京:人民教育出版社,2004:293
    2 Human Development Report 2006,Beyond Scarcity:Power,Poverty and the Global Water Crisis[P],Published for the United Nations Development Programme.2006:21
    1 Kim Jackson.The Higher Education Contribution Scheme.Analysis and Policy Group,updated in 2003,8,12 availble at www.aph.gov.au
    2 Chapman,B.and Ryan,C(2002)."Income-contingent Financing of Student Charges for Higher Education:Assessing the Australian Innovation[J]," The Welsh Journal of Education,11(1):64-81.
    1 J.Borland,P.Dawkins,D.Johnson and R.Williams,Returns to Investment in Higher Education.[P]Melbourne Institute of Applied Economic and Social Research,2000:12
    2 Information for Commonwealth Supported Students 2008[P],p34 www.goingtouni.gov.au
    1 Kim Jackson.The Higher Education Contribution Scheme.Analysis and Policy Group,updated in 2003,8,12 availble at www.aph.gov.au
    1 Bridging for Overseas-Trained Professionals Loan Scheme,www.hecs.gov.au/overseas.htm
    2 Harding,A.(1995) Financing higher education:an assessment of income-contingent loan options and repayment patterns over the life cycle[J],Education Economics,Vol.3,pp.173-203.
    3 Kim Jackson.The Higher Education Contribution Scheme.Analysis and Policy Group,updated in 2003,8,12 availble at www.aph.gov.au
    1 Les Andrews(1999),'Does HECS Deter?',Department of Education,Training andYouth Affairs[P],Occasional Paper Number 99F,Canberra.Available at www.dest.gov.au/archive/highered/occpaper/99F/does.pdf
    2 Chapman and Ryan(2002),Income contingent financing of student charges for higher education:assessing the Australian innovation[EB/OL],http://econrsss.anu.edu.au/pdf/DP449.pdf
    3 Richard James(2002),Socioeconomic background and higher education participation:an analysis of school students'aspirations and expectations,available at www.dest.gov.au/.../publications_resources/profiles/socioeconomic_background_higher_education.htm
    4 Aungles,Buchanan,Karmel and MacLachlan(2002),HECS and opportunities in higher education:a paper investigating the impact of the Higher Education Contributions Scheme(HECS) on the higher education system,available at http://www.dest.gov.au/sectors/higher_education/publications_resources/other_publications/hecs_and_opportunities_in_higher_education.htm
    1 澳大利亚经济与文化.gjzx.zjbti.net.cn/nr/xxyd/xfwh/adlyjjywh.doc 24K 2006-10-23
    2 Human Development Report 2006,Beyond Scarcity:Power,Poverty and the Global Water Crisis,p 297,Published for the United Nations Development Programme
    1 张民选.理想与抉择:大学生资助政策的国际比较[M].北京:人民教育出版社,1997:67
    2 Human Development Report 2006,Beyond Scarcity:Power,Poverty and the Global Water Crisis,p 297,Published for the United Nations Development Programme
    1 Student Finance Direct.A guide to financial support for higher education students in 2005/2006.p12,http://www.studentfinancedirect.co.uk/pls/portal/docs/PAGE/SPIPG001/SPIPS0011/SPIPS008/SFD%20G UIDE%20T0%20F1NANCIAL%20SUPPORT%2007-08.PDF
    2 Department of Education and Skill.The Future of Higher Education.London:HMSO,St Clements House:85
    1 王璐.孙明.英国大学生学费与资助政策改革及启示[J]。比较教育研究,2006(7):32-33
    1 Funding Higher Education:Policies for Access and Quality',House of Commons,Education and Skills Committee,Post-16 Student Support,Sixth Report of Session 2001-2002,HC445,(TSO,2002)p,11
    2 Student Loan Company,Annual Report and account 2005-2006.Availble at http://www.slc.co.uk/PDF/annual%20report_0506_for%20website.pdf
    1 Student Loan Company,Annual Reporl and account 2005-2006.Availble at http://www.slc.co.uk/PDF/annual%20report_0506_for%20website.pdf
    1 Femando Galindo-Ruedal,Oscar Marcenaro-Gutierrez & Anna Vignoles,"The Widening Socio-economic Gap in UK Higher Education"(June 2004),Centre for the Economics of Education,LSE,available online at:http://www.lse.ac.uk/collections/pressAndlnformationOffice/PDF/HigherEducationPaperJuneAmended.pdf.
    1 Sveinbjorn Blondal,Simon Field and Nathalie Girouard,"Investment in Human Capital through Upper-Secondary and Tertiary Education"(2001) OECT) Economic Studies No.34,at 77;citing:Universities and Colleges Admissions Service,Statistical Bulletin on Widening Participation(2000).
    1 陈永明.教育经费的国际比较[M].天津:天津教育出版社,2006:47
    1 Taxing Wages Special Feature:The Tax Treatment of Minimum Wages,2005-2006.2006:94-103
    1 Terrence J.Thomas(1994 年),Income-Contingent Student Loans,Parliamentary Research Branch,BP-373E p6
    2 E.G.West.The Yale Tuition Postponement Plan in the mid-seventies[J],Higher Education,Volume 5,Number 2,1976(5):2-13
    3 Taxing Wages Special Feature:The Tax Treatment of Minimum Wages,2005-2006.2006:94-103
    1 Taxing Wages Special Feature:The Tax Treatment of Minimum Wages,2005-2006.2006:94-103
    2 Storrs,David(1974)."Participation in the Tuition Postponement Option"(Research financed by the U.S.Department of Health,Education and Welfare).Yale University,New Haven,Connectiocut.
    1 Philip G Schrag.The Federal Income-Contingent Repayment Option for Law Student Loans.p762
    1 Karl Shell and others,"The Educational Opportunity Bank:An Economic Analysis of a Contingent Repayment Loan Program for Higher Education," National Tax Journal,vol.21(March 1968),pp.2-45.
    1 John Silber,Straigfit Shooting:What's Wrong with America and How to Fix It(New York:Harper and Row,1989).
    2 H.R.2073,introduced by Congressman Thomas Petri on May 11,1993.Memorandum,Issues in Designing a Federal Program of Income-contingent Student Loans,1994,p6
    3 陈浩 沈红.美国联邦家庭教育贷款中担保机构的运作及其对我国国家助学贷款的意义[J].比较教育研究,2006(27):15
    4 梁爱华.我国商业银行学生贷款中的“惜贷”问题探讨--以美国联邦家庭教育贷款为参照.高等教育研究,2006(12):51
    1 Sandy Baum,Student Loans in the US.In High Level Forum on "Financing Post-Compulsory Education in China:Strategies and Options" Paper Collection.Co-Sponsored by Ministry of Finance,Ministry of Education,the World Bank Organized by China Institute for Educational Finance Research,Peking University,2007,June 6-8.p83-89
    2 Galloway,Fred,and Wilson,Hoke(2005).Refrarning the Student Loan Costing Debate:The Benefits of Competition.Washington,DC:Educational Policy Institute,p23.
    3 Sandy Baum,Student Loans in the US.In High Level Forum on "Financing Post-Compulsory Education in China:Strategies and Options" Paper Collection.Co-Sponsored by Ministry of Finance,Ministry of Education,the World Bank Organized by China Institute for Educational Finance Research,Peking University,2007.June 6-8.p83-89
    1 Alternative Market Mechanisms For The Student Loan Program A Report By The U.S.Department Of Education And The U.S.General Accounting Office December 18,2001.p82-92
    1 Philip G.Schrag.The Federal Income-Contingent Repayment Option for Law Student Loans.p785
    1 Alternative Market Mechanisms For The Student Loan Program A Report By The U.S.Department Of Education And The U.S.Gcncral Accounting Offce December 18,2001,p82-92
    1 Ross Finnie and Alex Usher.The Canadian Experiment in Cost-Sharing and its Effects on Access to Higher Education,1990-2002.working paper 39,School of Policy Studies,Queen University.2005:2
    2 Canadian Federation of Students.Compromising Access:A Critical Analysis of Income-contingent Loan Repayment Schemes.2~(nd) Edition.November 1997:3
    1 The Commission of the Future Development of the Universities of Ontario,Ontario Universities:Options and Futures.1984:Government of Ontario.1984:53
    2 Ontario Undergraduate Student Alliance,Our Bright Future,a New Vision for Higher Education in Ontario 2002:169
    3 Ontario Undergraduate Student Alliance,Our Bright Future,a New Vision for Higher Education in Ontario 2002:169
    4 Benjamin Alarie and David Duff.An Income-contingent Financing Program for Ontario,Prepared for Taking Public University Seriously December 3-4,2004.
    s Ontario Undergraduate Student Alliance,Our Bright Future,a New Vision for Higher Education in Ontario 2002:169
    6 常士.马赛克文化中的政治发展探索--加拿大主要政治思想流派.黑龙江:吉林人民出版社,2003:6
    1 Hans Vossensteyn,CHEPS,Subsidizing Students,Families or Graduates? Presented at the CMEC-OECD-Canada Seminar on Student Financial Assistance.2003:4
    2 Usher,A.(2005).Global Debt Patterns:An International Compar/son of Student Loan Burdens and Repayment Conditions.Toronto,ON:Educational Policy Institute.p8
    3 Ministry of Training,Colleges and University,Ontario,Canada,Information About Financial Assistance for Postsecondary Students 2004-2005,2006:.9
    1 Hans Vossensteyn,CHEPS,Subsidizing Students,Families or Graduates? Presented at the CMEC-OECD-Canada Seminar on Student Financial Assistance.2003:4
    1 Edwin G.West.Ending the Squeeze on Universities:Canada in World Perspective.Carleton University,1993:5
    2 Canada Millennium Scholarship Foundation,"Focus on:Ontario,"(November 28,2004) available on the web at:http://www.millenniumscholarships.ca/en/research/pok_on.htm#_ftn 1.
    3 Edwin G.West.Ending the Squeeze on Universities:Canada in World Perspective.Carleton University,1993:5
    4 Sean Junor,Alex Usher.The Price of Knowledge 2004:Access and Student Finance in Canada Toronto,ON:Educational Policy Institute.2004:6
    1 Ross Finnie and Alex Usher.The Canadian Experiment in Cost-Sharing and its Effects on Access !o Higher Education,1990-2002.working paper 39,School of Policy Studies,Queen University.2005:6
    1 Sean Junor,Alex Usher.The Price of Knowledge 2004:Access and Student Finance in Canada Toronto,ON:Educational Policy Institute.2004:285
    2 Sean Junor,Alex Usher.The Price of Knowledge 2004:Access and Student Finance in Canada Toronto,ON: Educational Policy Institute.2004:285
    1 Sean Junor,Alex Usher.The Price of Knowledge 2004:Access and Student Finance in Canada Toronto,ON:Educational Policy Institute.2004:217
    2 Sean Junor,Alex Usher.The Price of Knowledge 2004:Access and Student Finance in Canada Toronto,ON:Educational Policy Institute.2004:232
    3 Sean Junor,Alex Usher.The Price of Knowledge 2004:Access and Student Finance in Canada Toronto,ON:Educational Policy Institute.2004:27
    4 Sean Junor,Alex Usher.The Price of Knowledge 2004:Access and Student Finance in Canada Toronto,ON:Educational Policy Institute.2004:285
    5 Sean Junor,Alex Usher.The Price of Knowledge 2004:Access and Student Finance in Canada Toronto,ON:Educational Policy Institute.2004:205
    1 Sean Junor,Alex Usher.The Price of Knowledge 2004:Access and Student Finance in Canada Toronto,ON:Educational Policy Institute.2004:206
    1 Benedict,Julian.(2007).The Canada Student Loans Program:Solutions to Improve Public Confidence and Operational Effectiveness,Vancouver,2007:3-142 B.C.:The Coalition for Student Loan Fairness.p27
    1 Canadian Federation of Students,Latest Changes to the Canada Student Loan Program,2005:2 www.cfs-fcee.ca
    2 Sean Junor,Alex Usher.The Price of Knowledge 2004:Access and Student Finance in Canada Toronto,ON:Educational Policy Institute.2004:13
    1 Adrian Ziderman & D.Albrecht.Cost Recovery for Higher Education:Are Student Loans an Effective Instrument?World Bank Research Observer,1993(8):4-16
    2 Friedman,Milton,and Simon Kuznets,1945,Income from Individual Professional Practice,New York:National Bureau for Economic Research.1945:27
    3 V.Vandenberghe,O.Debande.Deferred and Income-Contingent Higher Education Fees:An empirical assessment using Belgian,German & UK datal oct.-05 Palacios,M.2004:3-12
    4 Filling the Growing Funding Gap in Education Finance,available at:www.smhib.com/documents/investorgrowthconferencehighlights/PDFs/MRU-conf%20presentation.pdf
    1 Johnstone,D.Bruce.New Patterns for College Lending:Income Contingent Loans.New York:Columbia University Press,1973.
    1 Miguel Palacios.Human Capital Contracts "Equity-like" Instruments for Financing Higher Education.Policy Analysis,December 16,2002:8
    1 杨瑞龙,杨其静.专用性、专有性与企业制度[J],经济研究,2001(3):8
    1 Usher,A.(2005).Global Debt Patterns:An International Comparison of Student Loan Burdensand Repayment Conditions.Toronto,ON:Educational Policy Institute.2005:8
    2 Douglas Albrecht and Adrian Ziderman,Deferred Cost Recovery for Higher Education,Student Loan Programs in Developing Countries.1993 Developing countries.1993:17
    1 Human Development Report 2006,Beyond Scarcity:Power,Poverty and the Global Water Crisis,p 297,Published for the United Nations Development Programme.2006:74
    1 Adrian Ziderman.Student Loan in Thailand:are they effective,equitable,sustainable? United Nations Educational,Scientific and Cultural Organization UNESCO Bangkok UNESCO-Bangkok/IEEP,2003:102-130
    1 Medhi Krongkaew.The Promise of the New University Financing System in Thailand:the Income Contingent Loan(ICL) Scheme,2006:16
    1 曾志雄.泰国就业遇咄咄怪事:大学文化比不上小学文化.光明日报,7月22 日
    1 Douglas Albrecht and Adrian Ziderman,Deferred Cost Recovery for Higher Education,Student Loan Programs in Developing Countries.1993 Developing countries.1993:17
    2 Canadian Federation of Students.Income contingent loans:inequity and injustice on the installment plan.2005:4-15
    3 D.布鲁斯 约翰斯通著.沈红 李红桃译.高等教育财政:问题与出路[M].北京:人民教育出版社,2004:32
    1 Ministry of Education.Student Support in New Zealand[P],Discussion Document,http:www.moe.nl 2003(9):p24.
    2 Barr,Nicholas,and Ian Crawford.1998,"Funding Higher Education in an Age of Expansion",Education Economics 6,(1),45 -70,
    1 Chapman,B.(2005).Income Contingent Loans for Higher Education:International Reform Centre of Economic Policy Research Discussion Paper No.491 Australian National University.2005:32
    2 Chapman,B.,Freiberg,A.,Quiggin,J.and Tait,D.Rejuvenating Financial Penalties:Using the Tax System to Collect Fines[P].Canberra:Australian National University Discussion Papers.Available at:http://econrsss.anu.edu.au/pdf/DP461.pdf
    1 D.布鲁斯 约翰斯通著.沈红 李红桃译.高等教育财政:问题与出路[M].北京:人民教育出版社,2004:32
    1 袁连生,教育成本计量探讨,北京:人民教育出版社,20D3:30http://chronicle.com/prm/daily/2003/09/2003092401 n.htm
    2 Terrence J.Thomas(1994年),Income-Contingent Student Loans,Parliamentary Research Branch,BP-373E 1994:6
    1 College Board,trend in student aid 2005,Trends in Higher Education Serics,2005:8
    2 David Greenway and MichelIe Haynes,Funding Universities to Meet National and International Challenges.p33
    3 Canton,Erika 和 De Jong,Frankb.The demand for higher education in the netherland 1950-1999,CPB and CEPR.2004:4-16
    4 College Board,Trend in College Pricing 2005,Trends in Higher Education Series,2005:4
    5 Human Development Report 2006,Beyond Scarcity:Power,Poverty and the Global Water Crisis,Published for the United Nations Development Programme.2006:331-332
    6 Human Development Report 2006,Beyond Scarcity:Power.Poverty and the Global Water Crisis,Published for the United Nations Development Programme.2006:331-332
    1 David Grecnway and Michelle Haynes,Funding Universities to Meet National and International Challenges.p33
    2 David Greenway and Michelle Haynes,Funding Universities to Meet National and International Challenges.p77
    3 University of Birmingham,Annual Report and Accounts 2005-2006,p77
    1 驻纽约总领事馆教育组.美国大学Donation和Endowrnent 的政策与实践--哈佛大学的做法。www.jncc.edu.cn/jgzy/gjyjs/Upfiles/20064544013
    2 Scherschel,P.(1998).Student indebtedness:Are borrowers pushing the limits? USA Group Foundation.Available at http://www,luminafoundation.org/publications/studentindebtedness.pdf
    3 Illinois Student Assistance Commission(2001).Increasing college access...or just increasing debt? A discussion about raising student loan limits and the impact on Illinois students.http://www.collegezone.com/media/research_access_web.pdf
    4 Tracey King and Ellynne Bannon.(2002).The burden of borrowing:A report on rising rates of student loan debt..Washington,DC:The State PIRG's Higher Education Project,
    5 Allen Mary,Vaillancourt Chantal.(2004).Class of 2000:Profile of postsecondary graduates and student debt.Ottawa:Statistics Canada.Catalogue No.81-595-MIE2004016.
    6 S.General Accounting Office(2003).Student financial aid:Monitoring aid greater than federally defined need could help address student loan indebtedness.GAO-03-508.
    1 个人所得税税制改革年内启动,将用综合税制 http://www.winkinglawyer.cn/article.asp?articleid=93:http://www.taxchina.cn/gwsz/2001-O9/29/cms89934article.shtml
    1 焦建国.个人所得税的限制因素.税务与经济.2001(3):32
    1 Adrian Ziderman.Student Loan in Thailand:are they effective,equitable,sustainable? Bangkok:UNESCO,2003:72
    2 Norman LaRocque.Private Education in Ghana:A Market and Regulatory Survey.Prepared for the World Bank Group.p51-53
    3 http://www.moneyextra.com/dictionary/uk-inflation-history-003663.html
    4 中国统计局《国民经济和社会发展统计公报》.全国居民消费价格总水平指数http://www.stats.gov.cn/tjgb/index.htm
    5 张民选.英国大学生资助政策的演进与启示比较教育研究,2007(5):1-6
    1 张民选.英国大学生资助政策的演进与启示比较教育研究,2007(5):1-6
    1 Chapman,Income Contingent Loans for Higher Education:International Reform Centre of Economic Policy Research Discussion Paper No.491 Australian National University.2005:12
    2 Jacobs,Bas.(2002).An Investigation of Education Finance Reform.Income Contingent Loans and Graduate Taxes in the Netherlands",CPB Discussion Paper No.9,The Hague:CPB Netherlands Bureau for Economic Policy Research.2002:20-61
    3 Douglas Albrecht,Adrian Ziderman.(1993).Deferred Cost Recovery for Higher Education,Student Loan Programs in Developing Countries.1993:15
    1 Usher,Alex.Loan Subsidies in Eight Countries.Presented in the in the international symposium on student loan policy,Bangkok March 14-17,2006
    2 Benjamin Alarie and David Duff.An Income-contingent Financing Program for Ontario,Prepared for Taking Public University Seriously December 3-4,2004.
    3 Barr,Nicholas,and Ian Crawford.(1998).Funding Higher Education in an Age of Expansion,Education Economics.1998(6):45-70
    4 Usher,Alex(2004).Much ado about an idea.Educational Policy Institute,Canadian Higher Education Report Series,Stafford and Toronto:Educational Policy Institute.2004:9-12
    5 Barr,Nicholas,and Ian Crawford.(1998).Funding Higher Education in an Age of Expansion,Education Economics.1998(6):45-70
    1 D.布鲁斯·约翰斯通著.沈红,李红桃译.高等教育财政:问题与出路[M].北京:人民教育出版社.2004:95
    1 梁爱华.我国商业银行学生贷款中的“惜贷”问题探讨--以美国联邦家庭教育贷款为参照[J].高等教育研究.2006(12):51
    2 Norman Larocque.(2004).Who Should Pay? Tuition Fees and Tertiary Education,Financing in New Zealand,Education Forum.2004:11
    1 Medhi Krongkaew.The Promise of the New University Financing System in Thailand:the Income Contingent Loan(ICL) Scheme,2006:16
    2 B.C.:The Coalition for Student Loan Fairness.p27
    3 教育部财务司.高等学校贫困家庭学生资助专题研究报告.2006,11:37-44
    1 Douglas Albrecht,Adrian Ziderman.(1993).Deferred Cost Recovery for Higher Education,Student Loan Programs in Developing Counntries.1993:16
    2 Hoke Wilson,Fred Galloway.Refraining the Student Loan Costing Debate:the Benefit of competition.Educational Policy Institute.2006:13
    3 Student Loan Scheme Annual Report 2004,Prepared by Minister of Education,Inland Revenue and Ministry of Social Development.2004:20
    4 CBO.Subsidy Estimates for Guaranteed and Direct Student Loans.2005(11)p4
    5 Douglas Albrecht,Adrian Ziderman.(1993).Deferred Cost Recovery for Higher Education,Student Loan Programs in Developing Countries.1993:17
    1 Harding,A.(1995) Financing higher education:an assessment of income-contingent loan options and repayment patterns over the life cycle,Education Economics,1995(3):173-203.
    1 Giuseppe,Migali.Analysis of two higher education funding systems under uncertainty.2006:2-15
    2 Jacobs,Bas.(2002).An Investigation of Education Finance Reform.Income Contingent Loans and Graduate Taxes in the Netherlands",CPB Discussion Paper No.9,The Hague:CPB Netherlands Bureau for Economic Policy Research.2002:20-61
    1 陈宪.澳大利亚的HECS经验--我国高等教育借鉴的高校收付费体制[J].比较教育研究,2001(2):43
    2 赵中建.学生贷款偿还方式的比较研究[J].高等师范教育研究,1994(5):37
    3 房剑森.贷款制的理想与理想的贷款制:论我国高等教育贷学金制度的改革[J].上海高教研究.1995(3):37-40
    4 沈华.中国国家助学贷款多元化还款模型的设计--基于高等教育个人收益差异的计量.华中科技大学博士论文2005年,2005:45-46
    1 银行同期贷款利率,数据来源于中国银行网站http://www.boc.cn/cn/common/rmbdeposit.jsp。
    2 陈俊生.高等教育个人内部收益率分析与测算.江苏高教.2006.1:43-45
    1 Carmichacl H.L.(2004) Timing the Payment of Tuition To Enhance Accessibility:A Graduate Tax? Queen's University.p9-12
    1 Blandy,Richard.(1988).Reforming Tertiary Education in New Zealand,New Zealand Business Roundtable.Wellington,1988:9.
    1 Norman Larocque.(2004).Who Should Pay? Tuition Fees and Tertiary Education,Financing in New Zealand,Education Forum.2004:11
    [1][美]布鲁斯·约翰斯通著,沈红,李红桃译.高等教育财政:问题与出路[M].北京:人民教育出版社.2004
    [2][美]古扎拉蒂著,林少宫译.计量经济学(上、下册)[M].北京:中国人民大学出版社,2000
    [3][美]平狄克,鲁宾费尔德著,张军等译.微观经济学[M].北京:中国人民大学出版社,1997
    [4][英]尼古拉斯·巴尔著,郑秉文,穆怀中译.福利国家经济学[M].北京:中国劳动社会保障出版社。2003
    [5][美]米尔顿·弗里德曼夫妇,胡骑等译,朱映校.自由选择:个人声明[M],北京:商务印书馆,1998
    [6][美]米尔顿·弗里德曼著,张瑞玉译.资本主义与白由[M],北京:商务印书馆,2001
    [7]曾贱吉.论高等教育成本分担与补偿的主体[J].建材高教理论与实践.2000(6):11-13
    [8]陈彬.论高等教育成本补偿政策对社会公平的促进作用[J].汕头大学学报:人文社会科学版.2001(1):81-86
    [9]陈共.财政学[M].北京:中国人民大学出版社,2001
    [10]陈国良主编.教育财政国际比较[M].北京:高等教育出版社,2000
    [11]陈宪.澳大利亚的HECS经验[J].比较教育研究,2001(2):39-43
    [12]陈晓宇,陈良煜,夏晨.二十世纪九十年代中国城镇教育收益率的变化与启示[J].北京大学教育评论,2003(2):65-72
    [13]陈晓宇,闵维方.论中国高等教育的预期收益与劳动力市场化[J].教育研究,1999(1):34-39
    [14]陈振明编著.公共政策分析[M].北京:中国人民大学出版社,2002
    [15]丁小浩.中日高等教育成本补偿相关问题的比较研究[J].教育与经济,2002(2):24-28
    [16]国家统计局编.2002年中国统计年鉴.北京:中国统计出版社,2002
    [17]李红桃,沈红.美国降低国家担保学生贷款拖欠率的经验与启示[J].比较教育研究,2003(1):63-66
    [18]李红桃,朱俊文.美国联邦担保学生贷款的经验及其启示[J].教育与经济,2002(4):54-58
    [19]李洪天.高等教育与个人收益率[J].教育发展研究,2002(6):70-73
    [20]李洪天.关于我国高等教育的经济效益和个人收益率的研究[D].河海大学技术经济学院,2001
    [21]李庆豪,沈红.我国大学生资助政策的优化与重构[J].清华大学教育研究,2004(6):84-89
    [22]李实,丁赛.中国城镇教育收益率的长期变动趋势[J].中国社会科学,2003(6):58-72
    [23]李实,李文彬.中国教育投资的个人收益率的估计.中国居民收入分配研究.北京:中国社会科学出版社,1994
    [24]李文利.国家助学贷款的理论探讨和实证分析[J].教育与经济,2004(2):43-46
    [25]李文利.美国、加拿大高校学生贷款研究[J].比较教育研究,2004(9):44-49
    [26]陆根书,钟宇平.高等教育成本回收的理论与实证分析[M].北京:北京师范大学出版社,2002
    [27]马经.助学贷款国际比较与中国实践[M].北京:中国金融出版社,2003
    [28]闵维方.论高等教育成本补偿政策的理论基础[J].北京大学学报,1998(2)
    [29]闵维方等译.教育经济学国际百科全书[M].北京:高等教育出版社,2000
    [30]闵维方等主编.高等教育运行机制研究[M].北京:人民教育出版社,2002
    [31]濮岚澜,陈学飞.话语运动与议题建构:国家助学贷款政策的议程设置分析[J].高等教育研究,2004(2):33-37
    [32]曲恒昌,曾晓东.西方教育经济学研究[M].北京:北京师范大学出版社,2000
    [33]沈红.国家助学贷款:政策与实践中的既成矛盾[J],北大教育评论,2004(1):7-9
    [34]沈红.国家助学贷款与高等教育的大众化[J],高等工程教育研究,2006(6):32-36
    [35]沈华,沈红,黄维.学生贷款偿还负担的国际比较及我国的实证研究[J].比较教育研究,2004(10):38-43
    [36]王善迈.教育投入与产出研究[M].石家庄:河北教育出版社,1999
    [37]王善迈.论高等教育的学费[J].北京师范大学学报:社会科学版.2000(6):24-32
    [38]徐东华,沈红.学生贷款偿还制度研究[J].教育与经济,2000(2):44-47
    [39]杨爱民.国家助学贷款拖欠率问题研究报告[P].北京大学教育经济研究所简报,2003(35)
    [40]杨葆焜,范先佐.教育经济学新论[M].南京:江苏教育出版社,2000
    f41]章达友.人均可支配收入是制定高校收费标准的主要依据[J].教育与经济, 2000(4):25-27
    [42]张民选.理想与抉择--大学生资助政策的国际比较[M].北京:人民教育出版社,1999年3月,第1版
    [43]赵中建.高等学校的学生贷款--国际比较研究[M].成都:四川教育出版社,1996
    [44]赵中建.学生贷款中的“隐性补助”[J].高等教育研究,1994(2):46-48
    [45]郑传坤主编.公共政策学[M].北京:法律出版社,2001
    [46]中国教育部财务司等.高等学校学生资助政策问题回答[M].北京:高等教育出版社,2000
    [47]周正,周佳.关于高校收取学生费用的相关问题探讨[J].哈尔滨师专学报,2000(5):113
    [48]Ziderman,A.(1999).The Student Loans in Thailand:A review and Recommendations for Efficient and Equitable Functioning of the Scheme,ADB Social Sector program Loan,in the framework of the Education Management and Finance Study,Project TA2996-THA
    [49]Ziderman,A.(1999).The Student Loans in Thailand:A review and Recommendations for Efficient and Equitable Functioning of the Scheme[P].ADB Social Sector program Loan,in the framework of the Education Management and Finance Study,Project TA2996-THA
    [50]Ziderman,A.(2000).Financing student loans in Thailand:Revolving fund or open ended commitment?.[J].Economics of Education Review.21:367-380
    [51]Ziderman,A.(2003).Student Loans in Thailand:Are they effective,equitable,sustainable?.[M].UNESCO-Bangkok/IEEP
    [52]Zidennan,A,Albrecht,D.(1995).Financing Universities in Developing Countries[M],Washington DC:Falmer
    [53]Alan,B.Krueger and William G.Bowen.(1993).Income-Contingent College Loans[J].Journal of Economic Perspectives.7:193-201
    [54]Harding,A.(1995).Financial higher education:an assessment of income-contingent loan options and repayment patterns over the life cycle[J].Education Economics.3(2)
    [55]Chapman,B.,Ryan,C.(2002).Income-contingent Financing of Student Charges for Higher Education:Assessing the Austrian Innovation[J].The Welsh Journal of Education
    [56]Chapman,B.,Ryan,C.(2003).The Access Implications of Income Contingent Charges for Higher Education:Lessons from Austrian[P].Discussion Paper No.463, Centre for Economic Policy Research, Australian National University
    [57] Chapman, B. (2004). Income Contingent Loans for Higher Education: International Reform [P]. The economics of education handbook
    [58] Johnstone, D. B. (1998). The Financing and Management of Higher Education: A Status Report on Worldwide Reforms[P]. World Bank
    [59] Johnstone, D. B. (2000). Student Loans in International Perspective: Promises and Failures, Myths and Partial Truths[P]. The International Comparative Higher Education Finance and Accessibility Project, Center for Comparative and Global Studies in Education, Graduate School of Education, State University of New York at Buffalo
    [60] Johnstone, D. B. (1986). Sharing the Costs of Higher Education: Student Financial Assistance in the United Kingdom, the Federal Republic of Germany, France,Sweden, and the United States, New York: the College Board
    [61] Johnstone, D. B. (2003). Cost-sharing and Equity in High Education: Implications of Income Contingent Loans[P]. The International Comparative Higher Education Finance and Accessibility Project, Center for Comparative and Global Studies in Education, State University of New York at Buffalo
    [62] Johnstone, D. B. (1986). Sharing the Costs of Higher Education Student Financial Assisance in the United Kingdom, the Federal Republic of Germany, France,Sweden, and the United States, New York: the College Board
    [63] Johnstone, D. B. Readings in the Economics and Finauce of Higher Education,1997. Universify at Buffalo
    [64] Kenneth, E. (1998). Why Do Students Borrow So Much? Recent National Trends in Student Loan Debt [J]. ERIC Digest
    [65] Federal Student Aid. (2004). The Student Guide 2005-2006: Financial Aid from the U. S. Department of Education [P]. Washington DC: US Government
    [66] Feldman, R. (1976). Some more problems with income contingent loans: the case of medical education[J]. Journal of Political Economy, 84(6): 1305-1311.
    [67] Friedman, M., Simon, K. (1945). Income from Individual Professional Practice, New York: National Bureau for Economic Research. 27
    [68] Psacharopoulos, G. (1994). Returns to Investment in Education: A Global Update,World Development. 22
    [69] Beer, G, Chapman, B. (2004). HECS System Changes: Impact on Students[P].Discussion Paper No. 484, Centre for Economic Policy Research, Australian National University
    [70] Hong Shen. (2001). Fees in Higher Education and Aid to Disadvantaged Students[J]. China Education Forum. http: //www. hku. hk/chinaed/newsletter/, June, 2(1)
    [71] Hong Shen, Wenli Li. (2003). A review of the student loans scheme in China[M].Thailand Bangkok: NNESCO/IEEP
    [72] Hong Shen. (2004). The Most Urgent Problem in Student Loan Scheme in China:Repayment[J]. Harvard China Review, Spring
    [73] Hong Shen. (2004). Access to Higher Education for the Disadvantaged Group in China Summary Report [J]. Chinese Education and Society. January/February. 37(1)
    [74] Hong shen & Qinghao Li. (2001). Policy and Practice of Student Loan Schems for Higher Education in China. Presented to KEDI-UNESCO Bangkok Joint Seminar,Nov 20-23, Gyeongju, Korea
    [75] Jacobs, B. (2002). An Investigation of Education Finance Reform. Income Contingent Loans and Graduate Taxes in the Netherlands", CPB Discussion Paper No. 9, The Hague: CPB Netherlands Bureau for Economic Policy Research
    [76] Monks, J. (2001). Loan burdens and educational outcomes[J]. Economics of Education Review. 20
    [77] Salmi, J. (1999). Student Loans in International Perspective: The World Bank Experience[P]. Washington, D. C: The World Bank
    [78] Jee-peng Tan, Alain Mingat. (1992). Education in Asia: A comparative study of cost and financing[P]. World Bank
    [79] Shell, K. et al. (1968). The Educational Opportunity Bank: An Economic Analysis of a Contingent Repayment Loan Program for Higher Education[J]. National Tax Journal. 21:2-45
    [80] Li, Haizheng. (2003). Economic Transition and Returns to Education in China[J].Economics of Education Review. 22(3)
    [81] Dynarski, M. (1994). Who defrauds on student loans? Findings from the national post-secondary student aid study[J]. Economics of Education Review
    [82] Woodhall, M. (1984). Student Loans as a Means of Financing Higher Education Lessons from International Experience[P]. World Bank, Number 599
    [83] Woodhall, M. (1987). Lending for learning: Designing a student loan programme fordeveloping countries[M]. Commonwealth Secretariat
    [84] Woodhall, M., ed. (2002). Welsh Journal of Education Special Issue on Student Fees,Grants and Loans, University of Wales Press
    [85] Nerlove, M. (1975). Some problems in the use of income contingent loans for the finance of higher education[J]. Journal of Political Economy. 83(1): 157-183
    [86] Nerlove, M. (1972). On Tuition and the Costs of Higher Education: Prolegomena to a Conceptual Framework"[J]. Journal of Political Economy. 80, S178-S218
    [87] Barr, N., Crawford, I. (1998). Funding higher edFunding higher education in an age of expansion[J]. Education Economics. 4(1)
    [88] Barr, N. (2003). Financing higher education in the UK: The 2003 White Paper[P].The Future of Higher Education, Fifth Report of Session 2002-03, Volume II, Oral and written evidence, HC 425-11
    [89] Barr, N. Funding higher education: policies for access and quality[P]. House of Commons, Education and Skills Committee, Post-16 Student Support, Sixth Report of Session, 2001-2002
    [90] Ehrenberg, R. G (2000). Tuition Rising, Why College Costs so Much[M].Cambridge and London: Harvard University Press
    [91] Finnie, R. (2000). Student loans: Is it getting harder? Borrowing, burdens,andrepayment[P]. School of Policy Studies at Queen's University and Visiting Fellow at Statistics Canada
    [92] Schrag, P. G (2002). The Federal Income-Contingent Repayment Option for Law Student Loans. To be published in book form under the title, Repay As You Earn: the Government's Flawed Program to Help Students Have Public Service Careers
    
    [93] Shen Hong. (2004). The most urgent problem in student loan scheme in China:repayment[J]. Harvard China Review, Spring, Vol. 5 Issue 1, p93-97,5p, 2
    [94] Schwartz, S., Finnie, R. (2002). Student Loans in Canada: an analysis of borrowing and repayment[J]. Economics of Education Review
    [95] US General Accounting Office. (1997). Direct Student Loans: Analyses of Borrowers' Use of the Income Contingent Repayment Option. Washington, DC: US General Accounting Office
    [96] Barr, N. (1989). The White Paper on Student Loans[J]. Journal of Social Policy. 18(3), 409-17
    [97] Reprinted in Barr, N. and Crawford, I. (2005). Financing Higher Education. Answers from the UK[P]. London: Routledge, pp. 66-74
    [98] Barr, N. (1993). Alternative Funding Resources for Higher Education. Economic Journal, 103(418), pp. 718-28
    [99] Barr, N. (2001). The Welfare State as Piggy Bank[M]. Oxford: Oxford University Press
    [100] Barr, N. (2003a). Financing Higher Education: Lessons from the UK debate. Political Quarterly, 74 (3), 371-81. Reprinted in Barr, N. and Crawford, I. (2005).Financing Higher Education. Answers from the UK. London: Routledge, pp. 268-82
    [101] Barr, N. and Crawford, I. (2005). Financing Higher Education: Answers from the UK. London: London: Routledge
    [102] Becker, G (1964). Human Capital: A Theoretical and empirical Analysis, with Special Reference to Education. New York: National Bureau of Economic Research
    [103] Bennell, P. (1995). Using and Abusing Rates of Return: a critique of the World Bank's 1995 Education Sector Review. Institute of Development Studies (IDS) Working Paper 22
    [104] Bennell, P. (1998). Rates of Return to Education in Asia: a review of the evidence[J].Education Economics. 6 (2), 107-121
    [105] Bynner, J. and Egerton, M. (2001). The Wider Benefits of Higher Education. London:Higher Education Funding Council for England (HEFCE)
    [106] Callender, C. (2003a). Attitudes to Debt: School Leavers and Further Education Students' Attitudes to Debt and their Impact on Participation in Higher Education.London: Universities UK
    [107] Callender, C. and Wilkinson, D. (2003). 2002/03 Student Income and Expenditure Survey: Students' Income, Expenditure and Debt in 2002/03 and Changes since 1998/99. Nottingham: Department for Education and Skills (DfES)
    [108] Chapman, B. (1997). Conceptual Issues and the Australian Experience with Income Contingent Charging for Higher Education[J]. Economic Journal. 107 (482), 705-30
    [109] Chapman, B. (1999). Reform of Ethiopian Higher Education Financing: Conceptual and Policy Issues. Economics of Education Thematic Group Series 2. Washington:The World Bank.(http://www.worldbank.org/education/eoonomicsed/research/econseries/Chapman.htm)
    [110] Chapman, B. (2005). Income Contingent Loans for Higher Education: International Reform. Discussion Paper No. 491. Australian National University, Centre for Economic Policy Research. [Draft of Chapman 2006a,http://econrsss.anu.edu.au/pdf/DP491.pdf]
    [111] Chapman, B. (2006a). International Reforms in Higher Education Financing: Income related loans. In Hanushek, E. and Welch, F. (Eds.) Handbook on the Economics of Education North-Holland
    [112] Chapman, B. (2006b). Government Managing Risk: Income Contingent Loans for Social and Economic Progress London: Routledge
    [113] Chapman, B. and Ryan, C. (2002). "Income Contingent Financing of Student Charges for Higher Education: Assessing the Australian Innovation." The Welsh Journal of Education Special International. 11(1): 64-81
    [114]Chevaillier, T. and Eicher, J-C. (2002). Higher Education Funding: A Decade of.Changes. Higher Education in Europe. 27 (1-2) 89-99
    [115]Finnie, R. and Usher, A. (2006). The Canadian experiment in cost sharing and its effects on access to higher education, 1990-2002. In Teixeira, P. et al. (Eds.) Cost-Sharing And Accessibility in Higher Education: A Fairer Deal? [M]. Dordrecht:Springer, 159-87
    [116] Friedman M.(1968). The Higher Schooling in America, The Public Interest. 11(108-112)
    [117] Friedman, M. and Friedman R. (1980). Free to Choose: A Personal Statement[P].London: Secker and Warburg
    [118] Glennester, H., Merrett, S., Wilson, G (1968). A Graduate Tax[J]. Higher Education Review, Spring, 65-7
    [119]Greenaway, D. and Haynes, M. (2003). Funding Higher Education in the UK: the role of fees and loans[J]. The Economic Journal. 113(485)
    
    [120] Hanson, J. (1989). Cost Sharing in Higher Education: The United States Experience.In Woodhall, M. (1989) Ed. Financial Support for Students: Grants, Loans or Graduate Tax? London: Kogan Page, pp. 45-66
    
    [121] Harris, S. (1964). Higher Education: Resources and Finance (USA). In OECD, Study Group in the Economics of Education, Economic Aspects of Higher Education. Paris:OECD
    [122] Johnstone, D.B. (1972). New Patterns for College Lending[M]. New York: Columbia University Press
    
    [123] Johnstone, D. B. (1986). Sharing the Cost of Higher Education: Student Financial Assistance in the United Kingdom, the Federal Republic of Germany, France,Sweden and the United States[P]. New York: The College Board
    [124] Johnstone, D. B. (2003a). Cost-Sharing in Higher Education: Tuition, Financial Assistance, and Accessibility[J]. Czech Sociological Review, 39 (3), 351-374
    [125] Johnstone, D. B. (2003b). Income Contingent Loans and Graduate Taxes: Can they Work in Developing and Transitional Countries? [P]Prepared for the International Forum of the Association for the Study of Higher Education (ASHE), 2003.(http://www.gse.buffalo.edu/org/inthigheredfinance/publications.html)
    [126] Johnstone, D. B. (2004a). The Economics and Politics of Cost Sharing in Higher Education:comparative perspectives[J]. Economics of Education Review. 23 (4),403-10
    
    [127] Johnstone, D. B. (2004b). Higher Education Finance and Accessibility: Tuition Fees and Student Loans in Sub-Saharan Africa[J]. Journal of Higher Education in Africa.2 (2), 11-36
    
    [128] Johnstone, D. B. (2004c). Student Loans in the Russia Federation: Policy Options[P].Prepared for Publication (in Russian) in University Management(2005). (http://www.gse.buffalo.edu/org/inthigheredfinance/publications.html)
    [129] Johnstone, D. B. (2005). Fear and Loathing of Tuition Fees: an American Perspective on Higher Education Finance in the UK[J]. Perspectives, 9 (1):12-16
    [130] Johnstone, D. B. and Aemero, A. (2001). The Applicability for Developing Countries of Income Contingent Loans or Graduate Taxes, with Special Consideration of an Australian HECS-type Income Contingent Loan Program for Ethiopia. (Mimeo).(http://www.gse.buffalo.edu/org/inthigheredfinance/publications.html)
    [131] McMahon, W. (1999). Education and Development: Measuring the Social Benefits[M]. Oxford: Oxford University Press
    [132] Morris, M. (1989). Student Aid in Sweden: recent experience and reforms. In Woodhall, M. (1989) Ed. Financial Support for Students: Grants, Loans or Graduate Tax? [M]. London: Kogan Page, pp. 85-109
    [133] Nerlove, M. (1975). Some Problems in the Use of Income-contingent Loans for the Finance of Higher Education[M]. Journal of Political Economy. 83(1), 157-183
    [134] Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD). (2001). The Well-being of Nations: the role of human and social capital[P]. Paris: OECD
    [135] Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD). (2002). Education at a Glance[P]. Paris: OECD
    [136] Palacios, M. (2003). Options for Financing Lifelong Learning. Policy Research Working Paper 2994[P]. Washington: The World Bank
    [137] Palacios, M. (Lleras, M.P.) (2004). Investing in Human Capital: A Capital Markets Approach to Higher Education Funding[M]. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
    [138] Peacock, A.T. and Wiseman, J. (1964). Education for Democrats[P]. London:Institute of Economic Affairs Hobart Paper 25
    [139] Psacharopoulos, G (1994). Returns to Investment in Education: a global update[J].World Development. 22,1325-43
    [140] Psacharopoulos, G and Patrinos, H. (2004). Returns to Investment in Education: a further update[J]. Education Economics. 12 (2), 111-134
    [141] Rees Review. (2005). Fair and Flexible Funding: A Welsh Model to Promote Quality and Access in Higher Education: Report of an Independent Study into the Devolution of the Student Support System and Tuition Fee Regime in Wales (The Rees Review) [P]. Cardiff: Welsh Assembly Government.(www.learning.wales.gov.uk/pdfs/students/mainrr-e.pdf)
    [142] Richards, K. (2002). Reforming Higher Education Student Finance in the UK: The Impact of Recent Changes and Proposals for the Future[J]. The Welsh Journal of Education. Special International. 11(1): 48-63
    [143] Robbins Committee. (1963a). Higher Education: Report of a Committee under the Chairmanship of Lord Robbins[P]. London: Her Majesty's Stationery Office(HMSO)
    [144] Robbins Committee (1963b) Higher Education: Evidence[P]. Part 2, Documentary Evidence. London: Her Majesty's Stationery Office (HMSO)
    [145] Reenen, J. (2002). The Returns to Education: A Review of the Macro-Economic Literature[P]. Institute for Fiscal Studies Working Paper 2002/05. London: Institute for Fiscal Studies
    [146] Task Force on Higher Education and Society. (2000). Higher Education in Developing Countries: Peril and Promise[P]. Washington D.C.: The World Bank
    [147] Teixeira, P.N., Johnstone, D.B., Rosa, M.J. and Vossensteyn, (Eds). (2006).Cost-sharing and Accessibility in Higher Education: A Fairer Deal? [M]. Dordrecht:Springer
    [148] Tekleselassie, A. (2002). Cost-Sharing in higher education in Ethiopia: Demystifying the myth. The International Comparative Higher Education Finance and Accessibility Project Discussion Paper[P]. Buffalo, New York: Graduate School of Education, University of Buffalo.(Mimeo).(http://www.gse.buffalo.edu/org/inthigheredfinance/publications.html)
    [149] West, E. G (1994). Britain's Student Loan System in World Perspective: A Critique[P]. London: Institute of Economic Affairs
    [150] Woodhall, M. (1970). Student Loans: A Review of Experience in Scandinavia and Elsewhere[M].London: George Harrap
    [151] Woodhall, M. (1989). Ed. Financial Support for Students: Grants, Loans or Graduate Tax? [M]. London: Kogan Page
    [152] Woodhall, M. (1990). Student Loans in Higher Education 1: Western Europe and the USA. Educational Forum Series No. 1. Paris: International Institute for Educational Planning (IIEP)
    [153] Woodhall, M. (1991). Student Loans in Higher Education 3: English-speaking Africa. Educational Forum Series No. 3. Paris: International Institute for Educational Planning (IIEP)
    [154] Woodhall, M. (1992). Student loans in developing countries: feasibility, experience and prospects for reform[J]. Higher Education. 23 (4), 347-56
    [155] Woodhall, M. (2006). Financing Higher Education: The Role of Tuition Fees and Student Support[P]. In Global University Network for Innovation (GUNI), World Report on Higher Education 2006: The Financing of Universities. Basingstoke (U.K.) and New York (U.S.): Palgrave Macmillan and GUNI, pp. 122-130
    [156] Woodhall, M. and Richards, K. (2006). Student and University Funding in Devolved Governments in the United Kingdom. In Teixeira, P. et al. (Eds.) Cost-Sharing And Accessibility in Higher Education: A Fairer Deal? [M]. Dordrecht: Springer, 189-211
    [157] Yale Daily News. (1999). Alumni struggle to keep abreast of ongoing loan payments[J]. Yale Daily News, March 25,1999 (http://www.yaledailynews.com/article.asp?AID=1139).
    [158] Yizengaw, T. (2005). Cost Sharing in the Ethiopian Higher Education System: The Need, Implications and Future Directions[P]. (Mimeo).(http://www.gse.buffalo.edu/org/inthigheredfinance/publications.html.)
    [159] Ziderman, A. (2004). Policy Options for Student Loan Schemes: lessons from five Asian countries[P]. Bangkok: UNESCO, and Paris: IIEP
    [160] Ziderman, A. and Albrecht, D. (1995). Financing Universities in Developing Countries[M]. Washington D.C. & London: The Falmer Press

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700