用户名: 密码: 验证码:
腐败的预警预控体系研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
本文基于管理学、心理学、社会学及经济学等理论,运用计量统计、博弈论、综合评价、风险控制与结构方程等方法,对腐败预警预控理论展开较为系统、深入的研究。首先分析了腐败预警预控体系的理论基础,其次探讨了腐败预警原理与方法、腐败预控原理与途径,最后通过实证论证了本文的理论成果并提出指导腐败预警预控实践的原则与经验。全文主要内容共分为七部分:
     第一部分:指出腐败预警预控研究的背景、目的与意义,总结并评析了腐败预警预控管理的国内外相关理论研究现状,设计了本文研究的方法与技术路线。
     第二部分:从政治学、社会学、经济学角度对腐败加以界定,剖析了腐败发生的经济人本性、制度漏洞、复杂环境的经济学成因,勾勒出腐败与反腐的经济成本曲线;分析了公职人员腐败的内生与外生警源的主要形式,以反腐预警预控经济收益为参照构建了反腐预警预控的基础信息量与启动时间点的决策模型,以警源分析得分、腐败指数得分、举报监督得分和腐败迹象得分为判断要素展开岗位腐败趋势预测;探讨了腐败预警预控体系的组织结构、人员结构及该体系的组织功能;设计了以公职部门为主体的警源分析、构建预警预控指标体系、腐败岗位趋势预测、警示教育为主要环节的腐败预警预控的主流程,以多方参与主体为核心构建了全方位、全过程的腐败预警预控网状式辅助流程。
     第三部分:首先揭示了腐败预警的信息循环原理,主要包括信息贯穿始终的循环原理,四维源头的信息形成原理,多元性与及时性的信息获取原理;其次,描述了以政治觉悟低下为核心的腐败征兆表征,以需求层次理论解析了腐败征兆倒金字塔发展趋势,运用贝叶斯定理构建了基于腐败征兆分析的预警决策模型;再次,给出了腐败预警的警示内涵,提出了腐败心理的初期警示法与腐败预警的警示防线法,建立了腐败行为的期望收益及决策均衡模型,由此验证了腐败预警的警示价值及其价值实现过程;随后,深入探讨了宏观预警外部动因与微观预警的内部成因,相应提出了宏观与微观预警对策,设计了宏观与微观综合预警模式;最后,详述了腐败虚警、漏警的各种成因,提出了虚警与漏警的识别方法与判别流程。
     第四部分:分析了腐败的集体风险预警点与个人风险预警点的内涵与形式,详述了腐败风险预警点的顺推与逆推方法,指出腐败风险点的制度不完善与岗位设置不合理、思想道德素质低下、外部诱惑、群众监督意识淡薄的四种诱因,探讨了腐败风险预警点的四种途径;介绍了腐败预警推断的主观概率预警法、蓝色预警法、红色预警法与多元回归分析法;设计了包括制度腐败、组织审计、个人廉政、群众评价、腐败因素五个二级指标的腐败预警指标体系;依据腐败威胁程度与官员个人素质实现警报区间的四级划分,以预警紧急程度、预警作用时间为基础将警报时间分隔为短期与长期两种。
     第五部分:提出了腐败时间判断超前、预控实施时机超前、方案制定视角超前的腐败预控超前表征,阐述了腐败超前预控的适度性、渗透性与经济性原则;基于信息集成、方法集成与渠道集成剖析了预控的集成原理,探讨了腐败预控的集成的社会参与原则、综合协调原则与分解定位原则;从时间效益、经济效益与社会效益三个方面解析了腐败预控的效率,指出腐败预控效率提升的系统原则、长效原则与强制原则;以腐败预控部门、政府官员为博弈主体构建腐败预控的博弈模型,得出相应的反腐对策。
     第六部分:以引导帮扶制度、指标反馈制度、惩治制度以及监督制度为对象探索了制度安排,剖析了行为准则制度化、准则普及制度化、准则执行制度化、准则监督制度化等制度创新内容;分析了腐败预控涵盖腐败预控物质文化激励、腐败预控制度文化激励、腐败预控精神文化激励的文化激励方法,从核心成员角度将腐败预控文化激励区分为领袖文化激励与团队文化激励,辨析了腐败预控的文化激励的激励与约束并行、激励与目标结合以及激励与引导的三大要点,从人力资源选、育、用、留等四个关键点出发研究了腐败教育在不同阶段的侧重点,建立了以警示教育、岗位廉政教育、示范教育为主体的教育方法体系。
     第七部分:介绍近年发生的典型腐败案例,运用群体案例分析法指出腐败原因、危害及启示,提出腐败预警预控体现建立的实践规律、措施以及腐败预警预控的实践方法;构建了腐败预警预控的结构方程模型,验证了相关理论假设。
On the basis of management science, psychology science, sociology science and economics, this dissertation carries out a systematic research on the theory of corruption prewarning and precontrol by using methods of statistical measurement, game theory, comprehensive evaluation, risk control structural equation, etc. It first analyzes the theoretical basis for corruption prewarning and precontrol system, then discusses principles and methods of corruption prewarning, principles and methods of corruption precontrol, and in the end empirically demonstrates theoretical achievements in this study and puts forward the norms and experience guiding corruption prewarning and precontrol practices. There are 7 parts in this dissertation.
     Part 1:points out the background, objectives and significance of the research; summarizes and analyzes relevant literature review; designs research methods and routes in this dissertation.
     Part 2:defines corruption in terms of political science, sociology science, economics; probes into such economics causes of corrupt occurrence as the nature of economic man, loopholes in the system, complex environment, draws the economic cost curve of corruption and anti-corruption; analyzes major forms of internal and external crisis origins of civil servants'corruption, constructs the decision model of basic information content and start time point for anti-corruption prewarning and precontrol based on the economic benefit of anti-corruption prewarning and precontrol, predicts the tendency of post corruption in line with the score of crisis origin analysis, the score of corruption index, the score of supervision and report, and score of corruption sign; discusses the organization structure, personnel makeup of the corruption prewarning and precontrol system and its organizational function; designs the main flows of corruption prewarning and precontrol, whose major links are analyzing crisis origin(with public departments as the main part), constructing the index system for prewarning and precontrol, predicting the tendency of post corruption and Warning education, constructs a comprehensive and overall-process netlike supporting flow of corruption prewarning and precontrol, the core of the supporting flow being multi-participants.
     Part 3:first reveals the information circulation principles of corruption prewarning, which mainly include the circulation principle in which information exists from the beginning to the end, the formation principle for information with four-dimensional sources, acquisition principle for information of pluralism and timeliness; then depicts the representation of corruption signs whose core is low political consciousness, analyzes the inverted-pyramid development tendency of corruption signs on the basis of hierarchy theory of needs, constructs a corruption-sign-analysis decision model by using Bayes theorem; again, puts forward warning connotation of corruption prewarning, introduces the initial warning method for corruption mentality and the method of warning defense line for corruption prewarning, establishes the expected revenue and decision-making equilibrium model of malversations, and on this basis, verifies the value of warning for corruption prewarning and the realization process of the value; then, thoroughly explores the external agents of macro-prewarning and the internal factors of micro-prewarning, puts forward corresponding marco-and micro-prewarning strategies, designs a comprehensive marco-and micro-prewarning model; finally, dwells on various causes of corruption false alarm, and corruption miss-alarm, proposes the identification method and distinguishing procedure for false-alarm and missing alarm.
     Part 4:analyzes connotations and forms of collective risk prewarning point and individual risk prewarning point of corruption, elaborates on the pushing method and inverse-deducing method of corruption risk prewarning point, states briefly that the system for corruption risk point is not perfect and such four types of incentives as unreasonable post setting, low ideological and ethical standards, external temptation and low supervisory consciousness of masses, probes into four ways for corruption risk prewarning point; introduces subjective probability warning method, blue warning method, red warning method, and multiple regression analysis to deduce corruption prewarning, works out a corruption prewarning index system which involves such 5 secondary indexes as system corruption, organizational audit, personal integrity, mass evaluation, corruption factor; in line with the 4 grade divisions in the alarm interval ranging from threat level of corruption to realization of officials'personal qualities, divides warning times into short-term and long-term types in accordance with urgent degree of prewarning and action time of prewarning.
     Part 5:presents 3 representations of anticipatory corruption precontrol, i.e., anticipatory judgment of corruption time, anticipatory opportunities of precontrol implementation, and anticipatory perspectives of programma formulation, expounds the moderation criterion, permeability criterion and economy criterion for anticipatory precontrol; on the basis of information integration, method integration and channel integration, analyzes the integration principle of precontrol, discusses social participation standard, comprehensive coordination standard, decomposing and positioning standard of the integration of corruption precontrol; from perspectives of time benefit, economic benefic and social benefit, analyzes the efficiency of corruption precontrol, states clearly the system principle, permanent principle and compulsory principle for the enhancement of precontrol efficiency; with corruption precontrol depattment, government officials as the main body of the game, sets up a game model for corruption precontrol and proposes corresponding countermeasures to combat corruption
     Part 6:taking the guide and support mechanism, index feedback mechanism, penal mechanism, and supervision mechanism as subjects, examines some institutional innovations like institutionalization of code of conduct, institutionalization of norm popularization, institutionalization of norm supervision; analyzes the method of cultural motivation which covers material culture motivation for corruption prewarning, institutional culture motivation for corruption prewarnig, spiritual culture motivation for corruption prewarning, classifies the culture motivation for corruption prewarning into leadership culture motivation and team culture motivation, distinguishes the three points(which are coexistence of incentive and constraint, combination of incentive and target, incentive and guidance)in the culture motivation for corruption prewarning; starting from the 4 key aspects of selecting, fostering, using and retaining human resource, studies the focus of corrupt education at different stage, builds an educational method system whose main parts are warning education, post incorruptibility education and demonstration education.
     Part 7:presents typical corruption cases in recent years, gives out the reasons to corrupt, harms brought by corruption and lessons by adopting the method of group case analysis, puts forward rules of practice and measures for the establishment of the corruption prewarning and precontrol system, and practice methods for corruption prewarning and precontrol.This part sets up the SEM model of the prewarning and precontrol of corruption, proves corresponding theory hypotheses.
引文
[1]Andreski, S. Kleptocracy as a system of government in Africa[J]. in Heidenheimer, Arnold J. Johnson, Michael & Le Vine, Victor(eds.), PoliticalCorruption:A Handbook, New Brunswick, 1978 (35):14-19.
    [2]李开界.学习党章从源头上防止腐败[J].达州新论,2006,(3):34-35.
    [3]王景文.腐败与整治腐败[J].保鸡社会科学,2006,(1):17-18.
    [4]贺寨平.对腐败的一种功能性分析[J].社会,1994,(6):28-29.
    [5]程振源.西方腐败经济学综述[J].国外社会科学,2006,(5):31-36.
    [6]塞缪尔·亨廷顿.变化社会中的政治秩序[M].上海人民出版社,2008.
    [7]雷红.腐败与廉政有关理论观点综述[J].社会主义研究,1989,(4):63-65.
    [8]葛延风.腐败现象的社会学思考[J].管理世界,1994,(3):206-210.
    [9]张定鑫.从反官僚主义到反腐败[J].理论导刊,1994,(12):11-12.
    [10]王贵秀.腐败的实质是权力腐败[J].中国党政干部论坛,1994,(3):18-20.
    [11]高良.当前反腐败斗争中值得关注的几个理论问题[J].内部文稿,1997,(3):16-17.
    [12]林吉吉.权务腐败与权力制约[M].法律出版社,1997.
    [13]李月军.当前腐败根源研究观点综述[J].西安政治学院学报,1999,12(2):60-62.
    [14]史文娟.现代化过程中我国腐败问题的探讨[J].金卡工程·经济与法,2009,(10):158-158.
    [15]陈立兵.惩治和预防腐败的经济学分析[J].湖北财经高等专科学校学报,2009,21(4):7-11.
    [16]刘小维.当前我国腐败现象新变化的防治对策研究[J].法制与社会,2009(1):193-194.
    [17]刘伟.多管齐下治理腐败探析[J].湖金卡工程·经济与法,2009,(1):60-60.
    [18]傅汴玲.腐败综合治理研究综述[J].江汉论坛,2006,(67):134-137,37-37.
    [19]庄振华.腐败的文化成因及其治理研究综述[J].党政论坛,2008,(7):45-47
    [20]王珏,张若定.对政府采购集体腐败与串谋行为防范机制的博弈分析[J].中南财经政法大学研究生学报,2006,(6):22-26,6-6.
    [21]Leff, N.H.. Economic Development through Bureaucratic Corruption[J].The American Behavioural Scientists,1964:8-14.
    [22]Beck,P. J, Mather, M. W. A Comparison of Bribery and Bidding in Thin Markets[J]. in Economic Letters,1986 (20):9-23.
    [23]Tirole, J.A Theory of Collective Reputations[J].Review of Economic Studies,1996 (1):1-22.
    [24]丽贝卡·梅涅斯.限制“掠夺之手”——1880年到1930年美国城市中的腐败和经济增长比较[M].中信出版社,2006.
    [26]Murphy,Kevin M., Shleifer,Andrei,and Robert W. Vishny. The Allocation of Talent: Implications for Growth[J].Quarterly Journal of Economics,1991,106 (2):503-530.
    [27]邱艳红,孙明明.腐败行为的成本收益问题分析[J].经济师,2006(7):44-46.
    [28]张爱军,张亮.腐败收益成本比较分析[J].渤海大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2006(3):51-55
    [29]邹薇.腐败问题的制度透视与经济学分析[J].经济评论,2006,(3):56-64.
    [30]郑良勤,赵燕.论学术腐败的表现及其危害[J].华北水利水电学院学报(社科版),2001,17(4):87-90.
    [31]吴敏玲,汪虹,吴绮慧.学术腐败之我见[J].科技进步与对策,2002(8):177-178.
    [32]程方生.教育学术腐败探源[J].教育评论,2002,(1):4-6.
    [33]柯宝平.彻底清楚学术腐败[N].科技日报,2001-11-05.
    [34]张建华.学术腐败研究综述及经济学分析[J].北京社会科学,2006,(6):105-110.
    [35]乔潮.诱发腐败产生的不良心理及其防治[J].陕西职业技术学院学报,2006,2(4):41-44.
    [36]陈传如.加强党内监督是坚持从源头防治腐败的关键[J].社科论坛,2005(4):1-2,27-27.
    [37]孙怀山.从共产党长期执政的高度多角度思考腐败治理[J].中国党政干部论坛,2009(10):22-24,30-30.
    [38]戴文华.惩治边缘腐败[J].领导科学,2009,(9):50-51
    [39]黄小原,肖四汉.神经网络预警系统及其在企业运行中的应用[J].统工程与电子技术,1995,(10):50-58
    [40]陈国阶.对环境预警的探讨[J].重庆环境科学,1996,18(5):1-4.
    [41]吕武轩,王志民.“安全检测及监控”学科的历史任务[J].中国安全科学学报,1997,7(1):1-3.
    [42]王红印,张明亮,孙素琴,柴旭峥,付红军,李大鹏,王子琦,镐俊杰,孙含笑,胡扬宇,刘建军,周鹏,王景钢.大电网安全可靠运行4级梯度预警预控方法[J].电力系统自动化,2008,32(19):20-24.
    [43]黄贤金,曲福田.耕地生态经济预警的理论与方法[J].生态经济,1998,(5):14-17.
    [44]林鸿潮.试论危机预控的概念、功能和具体措施[J]湖南社会科学,2008(5):74-76.
    [45]夏登友,辛晶,任少云,黄敬.交通工具火灾预警系统的理论模型及其运转模式[J]中国安全科学学报,2006,16(11):263-266.
    [46]阎耀军.社会稳定的计量及预警预控管理系统的构建[J].社会学研究,2004(3):1-10.
    [47]余欢,罗帆.空中交通安全管理的预警组织机制研究[J].武汉理工大学学报(社会科学版),2006,19(5):702-705.
    [48]唐旭,黄本笑.论建立中国金融危机预警系统[J]经济学动态,2002,(6):6-9.
    [49]Laitinen E K, Chong H G. Early-warning system for crisis in SMEs preliminary evidence from Finland and the U K[J].Journal of Small Business and Enterprise Development, 1999,1:89-102.
    [50]佘廉.企业预警管理论[M].石家庄:河北科学技术出版社,1999.
    [51]卢锡慧.企业经营管理预警系统的建立[J].河北农业技术师范学院学报,1998,12(4)42-46.
    [52]王林,唐晓东.经济波动与企业预警[J].经济体制改革,2000,(2):90-93.
    [53]阮平南,王塑源.企业经营风险及预警研究[J].决策借鉴,1999,(3):2-6.
    [54]胡华夏,罗险峰.现代企业生存风险预警指标体系的理论探讨[J].科学学与科学技术管理,2000,21(6):33-34.
    [55]余廉.企业经营新机制-预警预控管理模式[J].科学学研究,1994,12(1):30-35.
    [56]罗帆,佘廉.企业组织管理危机的早期诊断及预警管理[J].经济理论与经济管理,2001,(7):35-38.
    [57]胡华夏.企业成熟期生存风险的预警预控管理[J].武汉汽车工业大学学报,2000,22(2):84-87.
    [58]李佩服.商业客户资信风险预警与预控研究[J].武汉理工大学学报(社会科学版),2003,(6):1-54.
    [59]佘丛国,席酉民.我国企业预警研究理论综述[J].预测,2003,(2):23-29,2-2.
    [60]卜冬梅,李君毅.商业银行经营监测预警方法研究[J].管理科学学报,1998,12(4):63-66.
    [61]王琼,潘杰义.商业银行信贷风险预警系统研究[J].西北工业大学学报(社会科学版),1999,9(3):18-20.
    [62]曹兴亮,张明泉.如何建立风险投资项目的风险预警预控系统[J].价值工程,2006(1):116-118.
    [63]Alan R. Wolfe.The Problems of determining an inteqrated model of buyer behavior [J]. European Journal of Marketing,1970,4 (2):134-139.
    [64]Altman. Financial ratios discriminant analysis and prediction of corporate bankruptcy [J]. Journal of Finance,1968,23 (4):589-609.
    [65]Aziz, Emanuel, Lawom. Bank predicition:an investigation of cash flow based models[J]. Journal of Management Studies,1988,25 (5):419-437.
    [66]顾晓安.公司财务预警系统的构建[J].财经论丛,2000,7(4):65-71.
    [67]张玲.财务危机预警分析判别模型及其应用[J].预测,2000,19(6):38-40.
    [68]刘红霞.企业财务危机预警方法及系统的构建研究[D].中央财经大学,2004.
    [69]刘兴云.对企业投资预警系统的理性分析[J].中央财经大学学报,2003,(5):54-57.
    [70]杨中和.浅析企业财务预警机制[J],中小企业管理与科技,2008,(12):70-70.
    [71]王树文,陈和平.企业成长技术创新预警体系研究[J]科学学与科学技术管理,2008,(5):64-66,81-81.
    [72]高凤彦,赵建华.企业营销组织预警管理指标体系初探[J].河北科技大学学报,1999,20(2):83-86.
    [73]高风彦,佘廉.企业营销组织的风险模糊评价与预警管理[J].武汉交通科技大学学报,2000,24(2):125-128.
    [74]长云起,王丕波 客户资信评估AFA方法及其风险预警[J].中国煤炭经济学院学报,2001,15(1):66-70.
    [75]查先进,杨凤.面向危机预警的企业竞争情报系统模型研究[J],中国竞争情报第十四届年会,2008(3):171-176.
    [76]杨有国.企业人才流失项警指标与预控管理的探讨[J].甘肃科技纵横,2008,37(2):70-71.
    [77]闵惜琳.人才资源管理危机预警系统研究[J].系统工程,2004,22(9):74-77.
    [78]徐晓曼.失业风险的预警机制研究[D].东北师范大学,2005.
    [79]雍岐东,刘居东,高军,张宁.生产安全预警预报指标体系研究[J].中国安全科学学报,2008,18(10):57-61.
    [80]黄敏.企业生产管理预警系统研究[D].武汉理工大学,2000.
    [81]付水法,连民杰.地下矿山系统危险预警与控制技术的研究与应用[J].金属矿山,2007,(8):390-393.
    [82]宋录生.耿村煤矿:基于预警预控的煤炭精细化管理[J].中国煤炭工业,2008(8):42-44.
    [83]王更新.乳品企业风险预控对策研究[J].农业展望,2007,3(7):36-39.
    [84]宣国强.构建反腐败预警系统[J].理论建设,2007,(5):75-76.
    [85]胡华夏.企业成熟期生存风险的预警预控管理[J].武汉汽车工业大学学报,2000,22(2):1-84.
    [86]郭强华.公职人员腐败预警指标体系的构建[J].工作视点,2007,7(4):61-62.
    [87]王显.国有企业腐败预警指标体系构建[J].黑龙江对外经贸,2008,(8):106-108.
    [88]朱兆玲.地方财政风险的防范[J].理论月刊,2008,(15):23-23.
    [89]黄光远,张继坡.实施廉政风险预警与防范管理探索高校预防腐败工作长效机制[J].学校党建与思想教育,2008(11):47-48.
    [90]陆亨伯,庄永达.论体育腐败预警系统的建构[J].宁波大学学报(人文科学版),2003,16(4):144-146.
    [91]王殿安,姜志甫.构建企业内部廉政风险预控机制探析[J].供电企业管理,2009(1):29-31.
    [92]G.Scanlan. The control of corruption [J]. Journal of Financial Crime,2004,11 (4):316-321.
    [93]David Ng. The impact of corruption on financial markets[J].Managerial Finance, Journal off Financial Crime,2007,14 (4):822-836.
    [94]Diana Bowman, George Gilligan. Public awareness of corruption in Australia[J].2007,14 (4): 438-452.
    [95]Peter McAdam, Ole Rummel. Corruption:a non-parametric analysis[J].Journal of Economic Studies,2004,31 (6):509-523.
    [96]Michael Hylton, Gladys Young. Alnti-corruption efforts in the Caribbean:are we doing enough?[J]Journal of Financial Crime,2007,14 (3):250-263.
    [97]Asad Zaman, Faiz-Ur-Rahim. Corruption:measuring the unmeasurable[J].Humanomics,2009, 25 (2):117-126.
    [98]Abdullahi Y. Shehu. Combating corruption in Niqeria-bliss or bluster?[J].Journal of Financial Crime,2004,12 (1):69-87.
    [99]Bamidele Olowu. Combatting corruption and economic crime in Africa-An evaluation of the Botswana Directorate of Corruption and Economic Crime[J].International Journal of Public Sector Management,1999,12 (7):604-614.
    [100]Barry A.K. Rider. Recovering the proceeds of corruption[J].Journal of Money Laundering Control,2007,10 (1):5-32.
    [101]Henry H. Rossbacher. The business of corruption or is the business of business corruption?[J]. Journal of Financial Crime,2006,13 (2):202-213.
    [102]Prateek Goorha. Corruption:theory and evidence through economies in transition[J]. International Journal of Social Economics,2000,27 (12):1180-1204.
    [103]Tanja Rabl, Torsten M. Kuhlmann. Why or why not? Rationalizing corruption in organizations[J].Cross Cultural Management:An International Journal,2009,16 (3): 268-286.
    [104]Ronald D. Picur, Ahmed Riahi-Belkaoui. The impact of bureaucracy, corruption and tax compliance [J].Review of Accounting and Finance,2006,5 (2):174-180.
    [105]Shinichiro Tanaka. Corruption in education sector development:a suggestion for anticipatory strategy [J]. International Journal of Educational Management,2001,15 (4): 158-166.
    [106]Nlerum S. Okogbule. An appraisal of the legal and institutional framework for combating corruption in Nigeria[J]. Journal of Financial Crime,2006,13 (1):92-106.
    [107]George Brown. Prevention of corruption-UK legislation and enforcement[J]. Journal of Financial Regulation and Compliance,2007,15 (2):180-185.
    [108]Peter Kimuyu. Corruption, firm growth and export propensity in kenya[J], International Journal of Social Economics,2007,34 (3):197-217.
    [109]William De Maria. Measurements and markets:deconstructing the corruption perception index[J]. International Journal of Public Sector Management,2008,21 (7):777-797.
    [110]Qhalehang Letsika. Creating a corruption-free zone through legislative instruments:some reflections on Lesotho[J]. Journal of Financial Crime,2004,12 (2):185-191.
    [111]Aimao Zhang. Corruption as a determinant of transaction governance structure[J].Strategic Outsourcing:An International Journal,2009,2 (1):27-36.
    [112]Adam Salifu. Can corruption and economic crime be controlled indeveloping economies-and if so, is the cost worth it?[J].Journal of Money Laundering Control,2008,11 (3):273-283.
    [113]Arvind Verma. Cultural roots of police corruption in India[J].Policing:An International Journal of Police Strategies & Management,1999,22 (3):264-279.
    [114]Ahmed Seleim, Nick Bontis. The relationship between culture and corruption:a cross-national study[J].Journal of Intellectual Capital,2009,10 (1):165-184.
    [115]Hartmut Kreikebaum. Corruption as a moral issue[J].Social Responsibility Journal,2008,4 (2):82-88.
    [116]Gjeneza Budima. Can Corruption and economic crime be controlled in developing econoies, and if so, is the cost worth it? [J]. Journal of Financial Crime,2006,13 (4):408-419.
    [117]Amos Oyesoji Aremu, Francis Pakes, Les Johnston. The effect of locus of control in the reduction of corruption in the Nigerian police[J].Policing:An International Journal of Police Strategies & Management,2009,32 (1):144-156.
    [118]Abdullahi Y. Shehu. International initiatives against corruption and money laundering:an overview [J]. Journal of Financial Crime,2005,12 (3):221-245.
    [119]John T. McCormick, Nancy Paterson. The threat posed by transnational political corruption to global commercial and development banking[J]. Journal of Financial Crime,2006,13 (2):183-194.
    [120]Gautam Bose, Shubhashis Gangopadhyay. Intermediation in corruption markets[J].Indian Growth and Development Review,2009,2 (1):39-55.
    [121]Frederick Stapenhurst, Petter Langseth. The role of the public administration in fighting corruption[J]. International Journal of Public Sector Management,1997,10 (5):311-330.
    [122]Simon N.M. Young. Why civil actions against corruption?[J]. Journal of Financial Crime, 2009,16 (2):79-81.
    [123]宣国强.构建反腐败预警系统[J].理论建设,2007,(5):75-76.
    [124]胡华夏.企业成熟期生存风险的预警预控管理[J].武汉汽车工业大学学报,2000,22(2):1-84.
    [125]郭强华.公职人员腐败预警指标体系的构建[J].工作视点,2007,7(4):61-62.
    [126]王显.国有企业腐败预警指标体系构建[J].黑龙江对外经贸,2008,(8):106-108.
    [127]朱兆玲.地方财政风险的防范[J].理论月刊,2008,(15):23-23.
    [128]黄光远,张继坡.实施廉政风险预警与防范管理探索高校预防腐败工作长效机制[J].学校党建与思想教育,2008(11):47-48.
    [129]陆亨伯,庄永达.论体育腐败预警系统的建构[J].宁波大学学报(人文科学版),2003,16(4):144-146.
    [130]王殿安,姜志甫.构建企业内部廉政风险预控机制探析[J].供电企业管理,2009(]):29-31.
    [131]高凤彦,赵建华.企业营销组织预警管理指标体系初探[J].河北科技大学学报,1999,20(2):83-86.
    [132]高风彦,佘廉.企业营销组织的风险模糊评价与预警管理[J].武汉交通科技大学学报,2000,24(2):125-128.
    [133]张云起,王丕波.客户资信评估AFA方法及其风险预警[J].中国煤炭经济学院学报,2001,15(1):66-70.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700