用户名: 密码: 验证码:
基于有限差分法正演的大地电磁测深带地形三维反演研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
研发了一套基于有限差分(FD)方法的大地电磁测深数据带地形三维反演算法及代码。其中,在大地电磁场正演数值模拟方面,开发了起伏地形条件下基于交错网格剖分、有限差分方法的大地电磁测深三维正演代码;在满足平面波场假设的前提下,使用长方体网格剖分模拟三维起伏地形,实现了带地形三维正演计算。设计了理论模型,将计算结果分别与前人的解析解响应与有限元法的计算结果进行对比,验证了所研发的带地形三维正演代码的正确性与可靠性。
     在反演方面,本研究基于非线性共轭梯度方法编写了大地电磁测深带地形三维反演代码,试验了不同的共轭梯度搜索因子β,避免了目标函数对海森矩阵(参数二次导数矩阵)的显式计算和存储,初步实现了大地电磁资料的带地形三维反演。为了检验所研发的带地形三维反演计算的可靠性和稳定性,我们首先对一系列理论模型进行正演计算,利用其生成的合成数据模拟实测数据进行反演,验证了三维大地电磁带地形反演方法的可靠性。其次分别利用了面积性阵列和二维剖面的实测大地电磁数据进行反演试算,并与现有的不带地形大地电磁测深三维反演方法的结果进行比较,证明了所研发的大地电磁三维带地形反演方法在实际应用中的适应性和稳定性。
     为满足实际工作中带地形反演的可视化需求,本研究开发了基于matlab的大地电磁三维正反演可视化套件来辅助进行正反演工作。该套件实现了大地电磁标准数据格式的导入与正则化,模型网格自动剖分,数字高程模型数据的导入,地形/海洋模型的人工编辑,反演模型三维交互式显示以及等功能。此外,为研究三维地形对大地电磁测深方法的影响,本研究利用所开发的带地形正反演方法和可视化建模套件,建立了一系列典型的地形和异常体组合模型,进行了大量的正反演运算,得到了具有代表性的正反演结果,对于地形起伏较大地区的三维以至二维大地电磁解释与反演工作具有较强的指导意义。
An inversion algorithm of three-dimensional (3D) magnetotelluric(MT) inversionwith topography based on finite difference (FD) method is presented. Astaggered-mesh, finite-difference method is utilized for the3D magnetotelluricnumerical simulation with surface topography. Rectangular mesh grid is used fordiscretization to meet the plane wave assumptions in magnetotelluric forwardcalculations with topography. Magnetotelluric responses are generated with atopographic model of a hemisphere pit to compare with the analytic response,verifying the correctness and reliability of the forward code. Another topographymodel of square frustum hill is tested to compare with a previous result from finiteelement method, adding
     In the inversion part, a3D MT inversion scheme with topography is developed basingon nonlinear conjugate gradient method. Different conjugate gradient search directionupdater β are tested to improve the global convergence. Explicit calculations andstorage of the Hessian matrix are avoided to save both memory storage andcomputing time. A series of forward models with surface topography is established togenerate synthetic data, which is inverted by the3D inversion method withtopography. The results are hence compared with the results from3D MT inversionwith no topography implications. Field dataset from a geothermal investigation isused to further test the reliability and stability of the inversion scheme.
     A Matlab based visualization package is designed and developed to support the3Dmodeling and inversion procedure and to visualize the inversion results. Thevisualization package consists of a series of data and model editing functionsincluding the import and regulation of MT data, auto meshing of the model grids, theimport of digital elevation data, as well as the edit of topography/bathymetry in themodel. To better understand the topography effects in3D, a series of complexsynthetic models with topography are designed and generated with the numericalmodeling and inversion scheme, as well as the visualization package presented here.Synthetic models with typical topography and anomaly combinations are tested withthe modeling and inversion scheme presented to provide a common guide to theinterpretation of3D and2D magnetotelluric data in cases with rugged terrain.
引文
ádám, A, L Szarka, J Ver, and á Wallner.1986.“Magnetotellurics (MT) in Mountains-Noise,Topography and Crustal Inhomogeneity Effects.” Physics of the Earth and Planetary Interiors42:165–177.
    Avdeev, DB.2005.“Three-dimensional electromagnetic modelling and inversion from theory toapplication.” Surveys in Geophysics26:767–799.
    Avdeev, Dmitry, and Anna Avdeeva.2009.“3D magnetotelluric inversion using a limited-memoryquasi-Newton optimization.” Geophysics74(3):F45–F57.
    Barrett, Richard et al.1994. Templates for the Solution of Linear Systems: Building Blocks for IterativeMethods. Society for Industrial and Applied Mathematics.
    Becken, Michael, Oliver Ritter, Paul a Bedrosian, and Ute Weckmann.2011.“Correlation betweendeep fluids, tremor and creep along the central San Andreas fault.” Nature480(7375):87–90..
    Berdichevsky, M N, L L Vanyan, and V Dmitriev.1989.“Methods used in the U.S.S.R. to reducenear-surface inhomogeneity effects on deep magnetotelluric sounding.” Physics of the Earth andPlanetary Interiors53:194–206.
    Berdichevsky, M. N., I. A. Bezruk, and O. M. Chinavera.1973.“Magnetotelluric Sounding with theUse of Mathematical Filters (in Russian).” Izv. Akad. Nauk SSSR Fiz. Zeml3:72–92.
    Berdichevsky, M.N., and V.I. Dmitriev.1976.“Basic Principles of Interpretation of MagnetotelluricSounding Curves.” Pp.165–221in Geoelectric and Geothermal Studies, edited by A. Adam.Budapest: KAPG Geophysical Monograph, Akademiai Kiado.
    Bertrand, E. a. et al.2012.“Magnetotelluric imaging of upper-crustal convection plumes beneath theTaupo Volcanic Zone, New Zealand.” Geophysical Research Letters39(2):1-6.
    B rner, Ralph-Uwe.2010.“Numerical Modelling in Geo-Electromagnetics: Advances and Challenges.”Surveys in Geophysics31(2):225–245.
    Cagniard, Louis.1953.“Basic theory of the magnetotelluric method of geophysical prospecting.”Geophysics18:605–635.
    Caldwell, T. Grant, Hugh M. Bibby, and Colin Brown.2004.“The magnetotelluric phase tensor.”Geophysical Journal International158(2):457–469.
    Chave, Alan D., and Alan G. Jones.1997.“Electric and Magnetic Field Galvanic DistortionDecomposition of BC87Data.” Journal of geomagnetism and geoelectricity49(6):767–789.
    Chen, Po-fang, Zuo-Zhong Hou, and Guo-Hua Fan.1998.“Three-dimensional topographic responsesin MT using finite difference method.” Acta Seismologica Sinica11(5):631–635..
    Chouteau, K., and M. Bouchard.1988.“Two-dimensional terrain correction in magnetotelluricsurveys.” Geophysics53:854–862.
    Dai, Y. H., and Y. Yuan.1999.“A Nonlinear Conjugate Gradient Method with a Strong GlobalConvergence Property.” SIAM Journal on Optimization10(1):177–182.
    Daniel, JW.1967.“The conjugate gradient method for linear and nonlinear operator equations.” SIAMJournal on Numerical Analysis4(1):10–26.
    Demirci, Ismail, Erhan Erdo an, and M. Emin Candansayar.2012.“Two-dimensional inversion ofdirect current resistivity data incorporating topography by using finite difference techniques withtriangle cells: Investigation of Kera fault zone.” Geophysics77(1):E67–E75.
    Faradzhev, A.S., K.K. Kakhramanov, G.A. Sarkisov, and N.E. Khalilova.1972.“On effects of terrainon magnetotelluric sounding (MTS) and profiling (MTP).” Izvestia Earth Physics5:329–330.
    Fischer, Gaston.1989.“A strong topographic valley effect in AMT and VLF-R measurements.”Geophysical Journal International96(3):469–475.
    Fletcher R, Reeves CM.1964.“Function minimization by conjugate gradients.” Compute, J.7:149–154.
    Franke, Antje, RU B rner, and Klaus Spitzer.2007.“Adaptive unstructured grid finite elementsimulation of two dimensional magnetotelluric fields for arbitrary surface and seafloortopography.” Geophysical Journal International171:71–86.
    Garcia, Xavier, Juanjo Ledo, and Pilar Queralt.1999.“2D inversion of3D magnetotelluric data: TheKayabe dataset.” Earth Planets and Space51:1135–1143.
    Gürer, Aysan, and O.Metin Ilki ik.1997.“The importance of topographic corrections onmagnetotelluric response data from rugged regions of Anatolia.” Geophysical prospecting45:111–125.
    Haber, Eldad, Uri M. Ascher, and Douglas W. Oldenburg.2004.“Inversion of3D electromagnetic datain frequency and time domain using an inexact all-at-once approach.” Geophysics69(5):1216–1228.
    Harinarayana, T., and S.V.S. Sarma.1982.“Topographic effects on telluric field measurements.”Pageoph120:778–783.
    Heise, Wiebke et al.2012.“Magnetotelluric imaging of fluid processes at the subduction interface ofthe Hikurangi margin, New Zealand.” Geophysical Research Letters39(4):1–5.
    Hestenes, MR, and Eduard Stiefel.1952.“Methods of conjugate gradients for solving linear systems.”Journal of Research of the National Bureau of Standards49(6):409–436.
    Hohmann, Gerald W.1983.“Three-dimensional EM modeling.” Surveys in Geophysics6:27–53.
    Jiracek, George R.1990.“NEAR-SURFACE AND TOPOGRAPHIC DISTORTIONS INELECTROMAGNETIC INDUCTION.” Surveys in Geophysics11:163–203.
    Jiracek, George R, R. K. Kojima, and R. P. Reddig.1989.“Application of the Rayleigh-FFT techniqueto magnetotelluric modeling and correction.” Physics of the Earth and Planetary Interiors53:365–375.
    Jones, Alan G.1993.“Electromagnetic images of modern and ancient subduction zones.”Tectonophysics219:29–45.
    Kelbert, Anna, Gary D. Egbert, and C. DeGroot-Hedlin.2012a.“Crust and upper mantle electricalconductivity beneath the Yellowstone Hotspot Track.” Geology40(5):447–450.
    Kelbert, Anna, Gary D. Egbert, and C. DeGroot-Hedlin.2012b.“Inversion Procedure and ResolutionTests.” Geology40(5):1–7.
    Kunetz, G, and J. Chastenet DeGéRY.1956.“EXEMPLES D’APPLICATION DE LAREPRESENTATION CONFORME A L'INTERPRETATION DU CHAMP TELLURIQUE.”Revue De L’institut Franc ais Du Pe′trolle11:1179–1192.
    Larsen, J. C.1977.“REMOVAL OF LOCAL SURFACE CONDUCTIVITY EFFECTS FROM LOWFREQUENCY. MANTLE.” Acta Geodaetica Geophysica et Montanistica Acad.Sci. Hungarica12:183–186.
    Ledo, Juanjo.2005.“2-D Versus3-D Magnetotelluric Data Interpretation.” Surveys in Geophysics26(5):511–543.
    Li, Yuguo, and Josef Pek.2008.“Adaptive finite element modelling of two-dimensionalmagnetotelluric fields in general anisotropic media.” Geophysical Journal International175(3):942–954.
    Mackie, Randall L, William Rodi, and M Donald.2001.“3-D magnetotelluric inversion for resourceexploration.”2001SEG Int ' l Exposition and Annual Meeting, San Antonio, Texas, September9-14,” in SEG Int’l Exposition and Annual Meeting.
    Mackie, Randall L, J Torquil Smith, and Theodore R Madden.1994.“Three-dimensionalelectromagnetic modeling using finite difference equations: The magnetotelluric example.”Radio Science29(4):923–935.
    Mackie, Randall L., Theodore R. Madden, and Philip E. Wannamaker.1993.“Three-dimensionalmagnetotelluric modeling using difference equations-Theory and comparisons to integralequation solutions.” Geophysics58(2):215–226.
    Madden, TM, and RL Mackie.1989.“Three-dimensional magnetotelluric modelling and inversion.”Proceedings of the IEEE77(2):318-333.
    Mitsuhata, Yuji, and Toshihiro Uchida.2004.“3D magnetotelluric modeling using the T‐Ω finite‐element method.” Geophysics69(1):108–119.
    Nam, Myung Jin et al.2007.“3D magnetotelluric modelling including surface topography.”Geophysical Prospecting55(2):277–287.
    Nam, Myung Jin, Hee Joon Kim, Yoonho Song, Tae Jong Lee, and Jung Hee Suh.2009.“Three-dimensional topographic and bathymetric effects on magnetotelluric responses in JejuIsland, Korea.” Geophysical Journal International176(2):457–466.
    Newman, GA, and DL Alumbaugh.2002.“Three-dimensional magnetotelluric inversion usingnon-linear conjugate gradients.” Geophysical Journal International140:410–424.
    Newman, Gregory A, and David L Alumbaugh.1997.“3D ELECTROMAGNETIC MODELINGUSING STAGGERED FINITE DIFFERENCES.” Geoscience and Remote Sensing,1997.IGARSS’97.2:930–932.
    Parry, J. R., and S. H. Ward.1971.“Electromagnetic scattering from cylinders of arbitrarycross-section in a conductive half-space.” Geophysics36:67–100.
    Patro, Prasanta, Makoto Uyeshima, and Weerachai Siripunvaraporn.2013.“Three-dimensionalinversion of magnetotelluric phase tensor data.” Geophysical Journal International192(1):58–66.
    Polak, E, and G Ribiere.1969.“Note sur la convergence de méthodes de directions conjuguées.” Revuefran aise d’informatique et de recherche operationnelle3(1):35–43.
    Press, W. H., B. P. Flannery, S. A. Teukolsky, and W. T. Vetterling.1992.“Secant Method, FalsePosition Method, and Ridders’ Method.” Pp.347–352in Numerical Recipes in FORTRAN: TheArt of Scientific Computing. Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press.
    Pridmore, D. F., G. W. Hohmann, S. H. Ward, and W. R. Sill.1981.“An investigation offinite-element modeling for electrical and electromagnetic data in three dimensions.” Geophysics46(7):1009–1024.
    Rodi, William L.1976.“A Technique for Improving the Accuracy of Finite Element Solutions forMagnetotelluric Data.” Geophysical Journal International44(2):483–506.
    Rodi, William, and Randall L. Mackie.2001.“Nonlinear conjugate gradients algorithm for2-Dmagnetotelluric inversion.” Geophysics66(1):174–187.
    Roy, KK, S Dey, and S Srivastava.2004.“What to trust in a Magnetotelluric Model?” J. Ind. Geophys.Union (Jan.2004)8(2):157–171.
    Sasaki, Yutaka.2001.“Full3-D inversion of electromagnetic data on PC.” Journal of AppliedGeophysics46(1):45–54.
    Schnegg, P. A., G. Fischer, M. Burkhard, and I. Miiller.1986.“VLF Studie eines engen Alpentales.”Protokoll Kolloquium Elektromagnetische Tiefenforschung Bergisch-G(Marz):131–136.
    Shewchuk, JR.1994.“An introduction to the conjugate gradient method without the agonizing pain.”1–58.
    Simpson, Fiona, and Karsten Bahr.2005. Pratical Magnetotellurics. Cambridge, England: CambridgeUniversity Press.
    Siripunvaraporn, Weerachai.2011.“Three-Dimensional Magnetotelluric Inversion: An IntroductoryGuide for Developers and Users.” Surveys in Geophysics33(1):5–27.
    Siripunvaraporn, Weerachai,Gary Egbert.2002“Numerical accuracy of magnetotelluric modeling: Acomparison of finite difference approximations”. Earth, planets and space letters721–725.
    Siripunvaraporn, Weerachai, Gary Egbert, Yongwimon Lenbury, and Makoto Uyeshima.2005.“Three-dimensional magnetotelluric inversion: data-space method.” Physics of the Earth andPlanetary Interiors150(1-3):3–14.
    Siripunvaraporn, Weerachai, Gary Egbert, and Makoto Uyeshima.2005.“Interpretation oftwo-dimensional magnetotelluric profile data with three-dimensional inversion: syntheticexamples.” Geophysical Journal International160(3):804–814.
    Siripunvaraporn, Weerachai, and Weerachai Sarakorn.2011.“An efficient data space conjugategradient Occam’s method for three-dimensional magnetotelluric inversion.” Geophysical JournalInternational186(2):567–579.
    Smith, J. Torquil.1996.“Conservative modeling of3-D electromagnetic fields, Part II: Biconjugategradient solution and an accelerator.” Geophysics61(5):1319–1324.
    Sutherland, IE, RF Sproull, and RA Schumacker.1974.“A characterization of ten hidden-surfacealgorithms.” ACM Computing Surveys6(1):1–55.
    Thayer, Richard E.1974.“Topographic distortion of telluric currents: a simple calculation.”Geophysics40(1):91–95.
    Tikhonov, A N.1950.“On determining electrical characteristics of the deep layers of the earth’s crust.”Doklady73(2):295–297.
    Ting, SC.1981.“Integral equation modeling of three-dimensional magnetotelluric response.”Geophysics46(2):182–197.
    Vallianatos, Filippos.2002.“A note on the topographic distortion of magnetotelluric impedance.”Annals of Geophysics45(April):313–320.
    Vozoff, K.1991.“The magnetotelluric method.” Pp.644–711in Electromagnetic Methods in AppliedGeophysics, II, edited by M. N. Nabighian. Society of Exploration Geophysicists, Tulsa.
    Wannamaker, Philip E, John A Stodt, and Luis Rijo.1986.“Two-dimensional topographic responses inmagnetotellurics modeled using finite elements.” Geophysics51(November):2131–2144.
    Ward, S. H.1967.“Electromagnetic theory for geophysical application.” Pp.13–196in Mininggeophysics, II: Sot. Explor. Geophys.
    Ward, S. H., and Gerald W Hohmann.1987.“Electromagnetic theory for geophysical applications.” Pp.131–311in Electromagnetic methods in applied geophysics, edited by M. N. Nabighian. Societyof Exploration Geophysicists, Tulsa.
    Weaver, J T.1994. Mathematical Methods for Geo-Electromagnetic Induction. Taunton, Somerset, UK:Research Studies Press Ltd.
    Wescott, E. M.1962.“The effect of topography and geology on telluric currents.” Journal ofGeophysical Research67:4813–4823.
    Xiao, Qibin, Xinping Cai, Xingwang Xu, Guanghe Liang, and Baolin Zhang.2010.“Application of the3D magnetotelluric inversion code in a geologically complex area.” Geophysical Prospecting58:1177-1192.
    Zhdanov, Michael S., Robert B. Smith, Alexander Gribenko, Martin Cuma, and Marie Green.2011.“Three-dimensional inversion of large-scale EarthScope magnetotelluric data based on theintegral equation method: Geoelectrical imaging of the Yellowstone conductive mantle plume.”Geophysical Research Letters38(8):1–7.
    Zhdanov, Michael S., Le Wan, and Alexander Gribenko.2011.“Large-scale3D inversion of marinemagnetotelluric data: Case study from the Gemini prospect, Gulf of Mexico.” Geophysics76(1):77–87.
    陈乐寿,刘任,王天生.大地电磁测深数据处理与解释,北京,石油工业出版社.1989,2-8
    陈乐寿,王光鄂.大地电磁测深法,北京,地质出版社.1990,14-16
    陈小斌. MT二维正演计算中地形影响的研究,石油地球物理勘探.2000,39(3):112-120.
    陈小斌,赵国泽,詹艳. MT资料处理与解释的Windows可视化集成系统,石油地球物理勘探.2004,39:11-16.
    董浩,魏文博,叶高峰等.大地电磁二维反演在解决复杂三维构造的适应性研究.地球物理学报.2012,55(12):4003-4014.
    胡祖志,何展翔,孙伟斌等.一种改进的大地电磁地形校正方法及相关讨论.石油地球物理勘探.2008,44:327-335.
    晋光文,孙杰,王立军.地形效应对大地电磁测深(MTS)的影响,地震地质.1997,19:363-369.
    晋光文,赵国泽,徐常芳等,二维倾斜地形对大地电磁资料的影响与地形校正,地震地质.1998,20:454-458.
    林昌洪,谭捍东,佟拓.三维大地电磁共轭梯度反演.应用地球物理.2008,5:314-321.
    林昌洪,谭捍东,佟拓.三维大地电磁倾子数据共轭梯度反演.地球物理学报.2011,54:1106-1113.
    刘云,王绪本.大地电磁二维自适应地形有限元正演模拟.地震地质.2010,32:382-390.
    石应骏,刘国栋,吴广耀.大地电磁测深法教程.北京:地震出版社.1985,23-34.
    阮百尧,王有学.人工源电磁场三维地形边界元数值模拟,地球物理学报.2005,48(5):1197-1204.
    谭捍东,佟拓,林昌洪.大地电磁三维正演并行算法研究,应用地球物理,2006,3:197-202.
    谭捍东,余钦范,John Booker等.大地电磁三维交错网格有限差分正演,地球物理学报.2003,46:705-711.
    王绪本.大地电磁二维地形响应及其校正方法.地球物理计算方法.1999,21:327-332.
    魏文博,金胜,叶高峰等.中国大陆岩石圈导电性结构研究——大陆电磁参数“标准网”实验(SinoProbe-01).地质学报,2010,84(06):788-800
    吴小平,徐果明.利用共轭梯度法的电阻率三维反演研究.地球物理学报,2000.43(3):420-427.
    徐世浙,阮百尧,周辉等.大地电磁三维地形效应数值模拟.1997中国科学:D辑:地球科学40:269-275.
    张翔,胡文宝.带地形的大地电磁测深联合二维反演.石油地球物理勘探.1999,34:190-196.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700