用户名: 密码: 验证码:
改革开放以来中国社会政策的发展及其逻辑
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
进入新世纪以来,社会政策在“统筹发展”、“更加注重公平”、“和谐社会建设”、“民生”等话语中成为我国公共讨论的焦点、社会科学研究的新兴领域。如何理解、评估我国改革开放以来社会政策的发展历程成为重要议题。在社会政策研究的已有理论中,体制研究传统提供了宏观考察的理论基础与基本方法,结合中国社会的特殊性及社会政策的阶段性目标,中国社会政策的体制分析框架可以包括福利供给结构及福利结果两个维度。
     对福利供给结构的考察发现,中国的国家福利角色在市场化改革中发生了重大转变,并导致了福利供给主体的多元化。在国家福利及家庭福利之外,市场、第三部门不同程度地成为福利服务的提供者。然而,无论是市场还是第三部门,其在福利保障供给中的作用都极为有限。同时,家庭的福利功能日益受到挑战,国家在福利供给体系中一直占据着举足轻重位置,尽管与计划经济时期的国家-单位制福利相比,当前的国家更多以制度供给者及福利组织者的新面貌出现。
     福利供给结构的变化必然导致特定的福利结果,社会权利是衡量福利结果的标准之一。与改革前社会权利建立在城市人与单位人的身份基础上不同,改革后的社会权利建立在一系列国家干预的契约关系之上。20世纪80年代中期到20世纪末,社会权利主要建立在劳动契约基础上,突出地与城市正规就业相关联,相应地,大部分社会成员缺失社会权利。新世纪以来,社会权利获得了两方面发展:一方面,公民身份成为一些福利计划的唯一资格条件,如义务教育及审查式的最低社会保障;另一方面,在收入维持及健康保障领域,福利资格日益与覆盖范围更广的个人贡献相关联。社会权利的这些变化是社会政策的重要进展。尽管如此,中国公民所享有的社会权利仍然有限:首先,建立在公民资格基础上的社会权利非常有限,且水平较低;其次,贡献关联的福利资格虽然大大扩展了社会权利享有者的范围,但它使社会权利受制于个人的收入水平,从而或加重最低生活保障的负担,或将一部分社会成员排除在福利体制之外。
     社会政策的分层——流动效应是衡量福利结果的第二项标准。从20世纪80年代到20世纪末,社会政策的分层——流动效应首先体现在国家干预(包括福利安排)对社会结构的“解制”之上。此外,社会政策安排仍然体现了对公共部门雇员阶层的优先保护,政府公务员及行政事业单位工作人员、以及国有企业在岗工人享受了较好的福利待遇。因此,这一时期社会政策的分层效应体现为享有较好福利的公共部门就业人员与大部分几乎没有什么福利待遇的私人部门就业人员、自雇者、农业劳动者之间的二元分化。而且,福利资格与户籍制度之间的关联也使社会政策不支持社会流动,特别是农村居民的向上流动。新世纪以来推出的社会政策计划将更多社会成员纳入到差异化甚至碎片化的福利体制中,形成了福利待遇与贡献程度相匹配的分层化的福利受益体系。因此,它的再分配效应较低,并倾向于强化已有的收入分层结构。
     总之,中国改革开放以来的社会政策发展呈现出渐进性、保守性以及国家角色持续强化等特征。国家角色的转型与强化,表现为国家多以福利的组织者而非融资者或分配者的姿态出现,通过有针对性的制度供给及组织动员初步形成了分层保障的合作保险型福利体系。中国社会政策的上述特征可以从国家干预的历史遗产及当前的威权政治中得到解释。
Since the beginning of new century, social policy has become the focus of public debate. Social policy thus draws more attention in social science study in China, particularly with the rising of discourses such as "Balancing Development", "Pay more attention on equality," "Harmonious society", "Livelihood" etc. How to understand and assess the social policy development process since China's Reform and Opening-up thus become an important research issue. Among various Social Policy theories, the regime analysis tradition provides a theoretical foundation and a specific approach for macro social policy analysis. Given the characteristics of Chinese society and goals of social policy in current stage, a theoretical framework which includes welfare mix and welfare outcomes has been introduced to explore the development of social policy in China.
     An investigation on the welfare mix found that there was a changing role of the state in the welfare provision in China since the marketilization reform. Except for the State and family, market and the third sectors became new agents of social welfare provision, although both the market and the third sectors have only played limited roles in the welfare mix. At the same time, the welfare function of family has increasingly faced challenge; while the role of the state became significantly important. However, the role of State in welfare area a since Reform and Opening-up was not the same role as it was in the State-Danwei welfare regime during Planned Economy period; the state was much more like an institute supplier and welfare organizer rather than a financer or direct welfare distributor.
     Changes of welfare mix result in changes of welfare outcome. Social right is one of the two dimensions in the measurement of welfare outcomes. Differed from the pre-reform period, social rights after Reform were based on a series of intervened contractual relationships rather than identities such as registral citizenship or membership of certain Danwei. From 1980s to 2000s, social rights were mainly based on employment contracts, thus associated welfare entitlement with formal employment, resulting in the lack of social rights of majority members in society. Since the new century, social rights in china have improved in following twofold; firstly, citizenship becomes sufficient eligibility for some social policy programs such as elementary education and social assistant program. Secondly, the coverage of social right has been much wider than before since it is contribution now premises individual's welfare entitlement in the policy field such as income maintenance and healthy security. However, the social right Chinese citizens enjoyed are still narrow. On the one hand, welfare benefit based on citizenship is rare and low; on the other hand, social right now largely depends on income level and individual budget constrain. And this either excludes low income group from social welfare system or aggravates the expense of social assistant program.
     The stratified and mobilized effect of social policy is the second dimension to measure the welfare outcomes. From 1980s to 2000s, the stratified and mobilized effect of social policy can be understood as a kind of de-regulation effect of the state intervention on the social structure; although public sector employees including civil servants, staff of administrative departments and institutions and on-the-job workers of state-owned enterprises still enjoyed priorities on the welfare benefit. Therefore, social policies during this period reflected the stratification between minority well-protected public employees and majority private sector employees, self-employed person and peasants who are olny eligible for bounded welfare benefit. Moreover, the association between welfare entitlement and the household registration system blocked the opportunity of social mobility of rural residents. Since 2000s, new social policy programs have covered different groups of people into a benefit-contribution-matched and stratified welfare system. Consequently social policy tends to strengthen the income stratification. The redistribution effect of china's current social policy system is low. Finally, the social policy development in China since Reform and Open-up demonstrates features as incrementalism, conservatism and a transformed and strengthening role of State in the welfare area. Recent policy innovations continued the organizational function of the state in the welfare governance. An institutionalism perspective shows that those can be explained by China's historical heritage of state intervention and current authoritarian politics.
引文
1.Amenta,E.,and S.Parikh.Capitalists Do Not Want Social Security,Etc.?[J]American Sociological Review,1991,(56):891-909
    2.Ashford,D.E.The Emergence of the Welfare State[M].Oxford:Basil Blackw ell.1986
    3.Aurel Croissant,Changing Welfare Regimes in East and Southeast Asia:Crisis,Changing and Challenge[J].Social Policy &Administration,2004,Vol.38,No.5,pp.504-524
    4.Baldwin,P.The politics of Social Solidarity:Class Bases of European Welfare State,1875-1975[M],New York:Cambridge University Press,1990
    5.Beland,D;Yu,KM,A long financial march:Pension reform in China[J],JOURNAL OF SOCIAL POLICY,2004,(33):267-288 Part 2
    6.Block,F.The Ruling Class Does Not Rule[J].Socialist Revolution 1977,(33):6-27.
    7.Ching Kwan Lee,Livelihood Struggles and Market Reform:(Un)making Chinese Labour after State Socialism[R],The United Nations Research Institute for Social Development(UNRISD) Occasional Paper,2005
    8.Castles,F.G.'Scandinavia:The Politics of Stability'[A]in R.C.Macridis(ed.),Modern Political Systems:Europe,4th ed.Englewood Cliffs:Prentice Hall.1978
    9.Castles,F.G.Comparative Public Policy:Patterns of Post-War Transformation [M].Cheltenham.Edward Elgar.1998
    10.Cook,Sarah,Creating Wealth and Welfare-Entrepreneurship and the developmental state in rural China[J].IDS BULLETIN-INSTITUTE OF DEVELOPMENT STUDIES,1999.30(4)
    11.Cook,S.,Social Security in rural China:A report on the Research in four countries[R].Research report to ESCOR,Department for International Development, Brighton:2001,
    12. Cook S., From Rice Bowl to Safety Net: Insecurity and Social Protection during China's Transition[J], Development Policy Review, 2002, 20(5): 615-635
    13. Clasen, Jochen. Defining comparative social policy [A]. Patricia Kennett (ed.) A Handbook of Comparative Social Policy [C]. Edward Elgar Publishing.2004
    14. Aspalter Christian, The East Asia welfare model [J], International Journal of Social Welfare 2006. 15:290-301
    15. Croissant Aurel, Changing Welfare Regime in East and Southeast Asia: Crisis, Change and Challenge[J], Social Policy & Administration, Vol. 38, No. 5, 2004, pp. 504-524
    16. Croll. Elisabeth J., Social Welfare Reform: Trends and Tensions [J], The China Quarterly, No. 159, Special Issue,The People's Republic of China after 50 Years. (Sep., 1999), pp. 684-699.
    17. Cutright, P., Political Structure, Economic Development and National Social Security Programs [J]. American Journal of Sociology 1965,70: 539-55
    18. Dahl, R. Dilemmas of Pluralist Democracy [M]. New Haven: Yale University, 1982
    19. Davis. Deborah. Chinese Social Welfare: Policies and Outcomes[J], The China Quarterly, No. 119, Special Issue: The People's Republic of China after 40 Years, (Sep., 1989), pp. 577-597
    20. Deyo, F.C. Beneath the Miracle: Labor Subordination in the New Asian Industrialism [M]. Berkeley. CA: University of California Press (1989)
    21. Deyo, F. C. The Political Economy of Social Policy Formation: East Asia's Newly Industrialized Countries [A] in Richard P. Appelbaum and Jeffrey Henderson (eds), States and Development in the Asian Pacific Rim.[C], 1992 Newbury Park CA. Sage, ppl 89-306
    22. Doyal, L. and Gough, I. A theory of human needs[J].Critical Social Policy, 1985(10): 6-38
    23. Evers, A., Shifts in the Welfare Mix: Introducing a New Approach for the Study of Transformations in Welfare and Social Policy [A],In Evers, A. &H. Wintersberger(eds.),Shifts in the welfare mix[C],1988
    24.Evers,A.The Welfare Mix Approach:Understanding the Pluralism of Welfare Systems.[A]in Evers,A.&I.Svetlik(eds.),Balancing Pluralism[C].1993
    25.Flora,P.,and Alber,J.Modernization,Democratization,and the development of Welfare state in Europe and America[A],edited by P.Flora and A.J.Heidenheimer,37-80.New Brunswick[C],N.J.:Transaction.1983
    26.Giddens,A.The Class Structure of Advanced Societies[M].New York:Harper 1973.
    27.Gilbert,N.,Specht,H.& Terrell,P.Dimensions of social welfare policy[M]Englewood Cliffs,N.J.:Prentice Hall.1993
    28.Gilbert,N.,Welfare pluralism and social policy[A],In Midgley,J.,Tracy,M.B.&Livermore,M.(Eds.),Handbook of Social Policy[C],Thousand Oaks,CA:Sage Publications,2000
    29.Goodman,R.and Peng I.,The East Asian welfare states:peripatetic learning,adaptive change,and nation-building[A],in Gφsta Esping-Andersen Welfare States in Transition:National Adaptations in Global Economics[C],London:Sage,1996,pp.192-244
    30.Goodman.R,White G.and Kwon H,The East Asia Welfare Model:Welfare Orientation and the State[C].London:Routledge,1998
    31.Gough,I.and Wood,G.,.Insecurity and Welfare Regime in Asia,Africa and Latin America:Social policy in Development Context[M],Cambridge,2004
    32.Guang Xingping,China's social policy:Reform and Development in the Context of Marketization and Globalization[J],Social Policy & Administration Vol.34,No 1,March 2000,pp.115-130.
    33.Guang Xingping,Globaliztion,Inequality and Social Policy:China on the Threshold of Entry into the World Trade Organization[J],Soial Policy &Administration Vol.35,No.3,July 2001,pp.242-257.
    34.Guang Xingping,China's social policy:Reform and Development in the Context of Markefization and Globalization[A],in Huck-ju Kwon(ed.) Thransforming the Developmental Welfare State in East Asia[C].Palgrave Macmillan,2005
    35.Gu Edward X.Dismantling the Chinese mini-welfare state? Marketiztion and the politics of institutional transformation:1979-1999[J].Communist and Post-Communist Studies,2001,(34):91-111
    36.Hage,J.,Hannen~an,R..The growth of the welfare state in Britain,France,Germany,and Italy:A comparison of three paradigms[A].Comp.Soc.Res.3:45-70 Headey,B.1970.Trade unions and national,1980
    37.Hicks.A.Social Democracy &Welfare Capitalism:A Century of Income Security Politics[M].Cornell University Press:Ithaca and London,1999
    38.Holliday,I.,Productivist Welfare Capitalism:Social Policy in East Asia[J],Political Studies,2000,(48):706-723
    39.Holliday,I.,East Asian Social Policy in the Wake of the Financial Crisis:Farewell to Productivism?[J].Policy and Politics,2005,(18):145-162
    40.Johnson,N.,The Welfare State in Transition:The Theory and Practice of Welfare Pluralism[M].Brighton(England):Wheatsheaf,1987
    41.Johnson,N.,Mixed Economies of Welfare:A Comparative Perspective[M].London;New York:Prentice Hall Europe,1999
    42.Jones,C.The Pacific challenge:Confucian welfare states[A].C.Jones(ed.),New Perspectives on the Welfare State in Europe[C],London:Routledge,1993:pp.198-217
    43.Kennett.P.(ed),A Handbook of Comparative Social Policy[C].Edward Elgar.2004
    44.Kim,Yeon-Myung,Beyond East Asian Welfare Productivism:The Experience of South Korea[A],东亚社会政策国际会议会议论文,北京师范大学,2006
    45.Korpi,W.The Working Class in Welfare Capitalism[M].Lodon:Routledge and Kegan Paul,1978
    46.Ku,Yeun-wen,with Catherine Jones Finer,Developments in East Asian Welfare Studies[J],Social Policy and Adrninistration.2007,41,(2):115-131
    47.Kwon Huck-ju,Beyond European Welfare Regimes:Comparative Perspectives on East Asian Welfare Systm[J],Journal of Social Policy;1997,26,(4):467-484
    48.Kwon Huck-ju,Transforming the Development Welfare State in East Asia[J], Development and Change 2005,36(3):477-497
    49.Kwon Huck-ju(ed.),Transforming the Developmental Welfare State in East Asia[C].Palgrave Macmillan,2005
    50.Kwong-leung Tang,Social Welfare Development in East Asia[M],Palgrave,2000
    51.Lee,Yih-jiunn and Ku,Yeun-wen,East Asia Welfare Regimes:Testing the Hypothesis of the Developmental Welfare State[J],Social Policy &Admirtistration,2007.41,(2):197-212
    52.Lee,James.From Welfare Housing to Home Ownership:The Dilemma of China's Housing Reform[J],Housing Studies,2000,15(1):61-76
    53.Leman,C.The Collapse of Welfare Reform:Political Institutions,Policy,and the Poor in Canada and the United States[M].Cambridge,Mass:MIT Press.1980
    54.Leung JCB.The emergence of social assistance in China[J],International Journal of Social Welfare,2006,(15):188-198
    55.Lin Ka.Chinese perceptions of the Scandinavian social policy model[J].Social Policy and Administration,2001.(35):321-340
    56.Lin Ka and Kangas Olli,Social policymaking and its institutional basis:Transition of the Chinese social security system[J],International Social Security Review,2006.59,(2):61-76.
    57.Marshall.T·H,Citizenship and Social Class[A].Sociology at the Crossroads and other Essays[M]Heinemann Educational Books Ltd,1963.
    58.Midgley,J.Industrialization and welfare:The case of the four Little Tigers[J].Social Policy and Administration,1986,20(3):225-238.
    59.Mishra,Remesh,The Welfare State in Capitalist Society[M].London:Wheatsheaf,1993
    60.Mkandawire.T.Social Policy in a Development Context[R].Social policy and Development Programme Paper No.7,UN:http://www.cep.cl/UNRISD/References/Ref_UNRISD/mkandaw1.pdf
    61.Myrdal,A.Nations and Family:The Swedish Experiment in Democratic Family and Population Policy[M].London:Kegan Paul,Trench,Trubne 1994
    62.Nyland,C;Smyth,R;Zhu,CJH.What determines the extent to which employers will comply with their social security obligations? Evidence from Chinese firm-level data[J].Social Policy & Admnirtistration,2006,40(2):196-214
    53.Orloff,A.S.,Skocpol,T.Why not equal protection? Explainirtg the politics of public social spending in Britain,1900-1911,and the United States,1880s-1920[J].American Socioogy Review,1984,(49):726-50
    64.Peter Nan-Shong Lee,Restructuring China's welfare regime at the local leve:A case study[J],Policy Studies Review,Spring 2001,18(1):59-74
    65.Pierson,P.Beyond the welfare State[M].Cambridge:Polity Press.1994.
    66.Pierson,P.The New Politics of Welfare[J].World Politics.1996.48(2):143-179
    67.Przenworsld,A.Capitalism and Social Democracy[M].New York:Cambridge University Press,1985
    68.Peter Whiteford,From Enterprise Protection to Social Protection:Pension Reform in China[J],Global Social Policy,2003(3);45
    69.Philion,Stephen,Chinese welfare state regimes[J],Journal of Contemporary Asia,1998,28:4,518-536
    70.Peng I.and Wong J.,Institutions and Institutional Purpose:Continuity and Change in East Asian social policy[J],POLITICS & SOCIETY,2008.36(1):61-88
    71.Pryor,F.L.Public Expenditures in Communist and Capitalist Nations[M].London:George Allen & Unwin.1968.
    72.Richard J.Buttimer Jr.,Anthony Yanxiang Gu,Tyler T.Yang,The Chinese Housing Provident Fund[J],International Real Estate Review,2004,7(1):1-30
    73.Rose,R.Common Goals but Different Roles:The State's Contribution to the Welfare Mix[A].in Rose,R.&R.Shiratori,The Welfare State East and West[C].Oxford:Oxford University Press.1986
    74.Saich,Tony,Social Welfare Provision and Economic Transition:Pluralism and Integration of Service Delivery[EB],www.nacsorg.com/nacs2003_papers/nacs_papers_fulltext_lin.pdf/2008-10-1
    75.Saunders.P.& Shang XY,Social Security Reform in China's Transition to a Market Economy[J],Social Policy & Administration,2001,35(3):274-289.
    76.Skocpol,T.and Amenta E.States and social policies[J].Annual Review of Sociology.1986,(12):131-157
    77.Smart,A;Smart,J,Local citizenship:welfare reform urban/rural status,and exclusion in China[J],Environment and Planing,2001,33(10):1853-1869
    78.Tang Kwong-leung & Ngan Raymond,China:developmentalism and social security[J],International Journal of social welfare,2001,(10):253-259
    79.Titmuss,R.Social Policy[M].London:Allen and Unwin.1974
    80.Thelle Hatla,Equity or Efficiency:Thoughts on Social Policy in Reform China[A]in Jorund Buen & Bjorn Kiellgren(Ed) China at Turn of 21st Century:Selevted Proceedings from the sixth biennial NACS conference at Sandbjerg Slott,Demark,June 2001
    81.Therborn,G.What does the Working Class Do When It Rules?[M]London:Verso.1979
    82.UNDP.Human Development Report 2007/2008[R].http://hdr.undp.org/en/reports/global/hdr2007-2008/
    83.Van Kersbergen,K.Social Capitalism.A Study of Christian Democracy and the Welfare State[M].London:Routledge 1995
    84.Walker,A.Social Planning[M],Oxford,Blackwell,1984
    85.White.Gordon,Social security reforms in China:towards an East Asian model?[A]Roger Goodman,Gorden White and Huck-ju Kwon(ed),The East Asia Welfare Model:Welfare Orientation and the State[C].London:Routledge,1998
    86.Wilensky,Harold L.,Lebeaux,Charles N.,Industrial Society and Social Welfare:The impact of industrialization on the supply and Organization of social welfare services in the United States[M].New York:Russell Sage Foundation.1958
    87.Wong,Chack-Kie;Tang,Kwong-Leung;Lo,Vai Io,Unaffordable healthcare amid phenomenal growth:the case of healthcare protection in reform China[J],International Journal of Socail Welfare,2007,16(2):140-149
    88.Wong.C.K.,& Wong K.Y.,Expectations and Practice in Social Citizenship:Some Insights from an Attitude Survey in a Chinese Society[J],Social Policy and Adrnnistration,2005.39(1):19-34
    89.Wong.Linda,Privatization of Social Welfare in Post-Mao China[J],Asian Survey,1994.34,(4):307-325
    90.Wong.Linda,The third sector and residential care for the elderly in China's transitional welfare economy[J],Austrialian Journal of Public Administration,2008,67(1):89-96
    91.Yu Jianxing,Lou Suping,Reform Agenda for the Building of Service-oriented Government in China:Implications from Welfare Regime Analysis[A]:4th International Conference of Public Administration.Minneaplis.USA.ISTP.2008
    92.Dorfman.Mark S.当代风险管理与保险教程[M].第七版.清华大学出版社.2002
    93.OECD.中国公共支出面临的挑战:通往更有效和公平之路[R].清华大学出版社,北京:2006
    94.阿玛蒂亚·森.以自由看待发展[M].北京:中国人民大学出版社.2002
    95.阿玛蒂亚·森.论社会排斥[J].经济社会体制比较.2006,(04):1-7
    96.阿萨·布里格斯.历史视野中的福利国家[A].丁开杰编.后福利国家[C].上海:三联出版社.2004
    97.边馥琴等.中美家庭代际关系比较研究[J],社会学研究.2001,(2):85-95
    98.边燕杰.吴晓刚.李路路.社会分层与社会流动:国外学者对中国研究的新进展[C].北京:中国人民大学出版社.2008
    99.边燕杰.约翰·罗根.卢汉龙.潘允康.关颖.“单位制”与住房商品化[J].社会学研究.1996,(1):82-95
    100.边燕杰.李路路.李煜.郝大海.结构壁垒、体制转型与地位资源含量[J].中国社会科学,2006,(5):100-109
    101.蔡昉.都洋.王美艳.城市排斥外地劳动力的政治经济学:北京案例[A].中国制度变迁的案例研究(第四集),北京:中国财政经济出版社,2005:285-315
    102.蔡昉.杨涛.城乡收入差距的政治经济学[J].中国社会科学.2000,(4):11-23
    103.蔡昉.中国就业制度改革的回顾与思考[J].理论前言,2008,(11)
    104.财政部社会保障司课题组,社会保障支出水平的国家比重[J].财政研究,2007,(10):36-42
    105.邓大松.胡宏伟.流动、剥夺、排斥和融合:社会融合与保障权的获得[J].中国人口科学,2007,(06):14-24
    106.邓广良.经济发展与社会发展:发展中国家的社会福利发展[A].当代社会政策研究[C]天津:天津人民出版社,2005
    107.丁元竹.科学把握我国现阶段的基本服务均等化[J].中国经贸导刊,2007,(13):
    108.丁元竹.促进我国基本公共服务均等化的对策[J].宏观经济管理,2008,(3):
    109.冯兰瑞.中国社会保障制度重构[M].北京:经济科学出版社,1997
    110.傅勇、张晏.中国式分权与财政支出结构偏向:为增长而竞争的代价.管理世界.2007,(3):4-22
    111.弗兰茨-克萨韦尔·考夫曼.社会福利国家面临的挑战[M].北京:商务出版社,2004
    112.高玲芬、贾丽娜.论非正规就业的定义与测量[J].统计研究,2005,(3):74-77
    113.高书生,中国社会保障改革:困境与出路[J].江苏行政学院学报,2005,(6):59-64
    114.高书生.社会保障改革何去何从[M].北京:中国人民大学出版社.2006
    115.顾昕.方黎明.志愿性与强制性之间:中国农村合作医疗的制度嵌入性与可持续性发展分析[J].社会学研究,2004,(5):1-18
    116.顾昕.王旭.从国家主义到合作主义——中国市场转型过程中国家与专业团体关系的演变[J].社会学研究,2005,(2):155-175
    117.顾昕.社区医疗卫生服务体系建设中的政府角色[J],改革,2006,(1):106-114
    118.顾昕.高梦滔.姚洋.诊断与处方:直面中国医疗体制改革[M].北京:社会科学文献出版社,2006
    119.顾昕.走向全民医保:中国医疗体制改革的战略选择[J].中国公共政策评论,2008,(2):69-82
    120.关信平.社会政策发展的国际趋势及我国社会政策的转型[J].江海学刊, 2002,(4):93-98
    121.关信平.现阶段中国城市的贫困问题和反贫困政策[J],江苏社会科学,2003,(2):108-115
    122.关信平.社会政策概论[M].北京:高等教育出版社,2005
    123.关信平.改革开放30年中国社会政策的改革与发展[J].甘肃社会科学,2008,(5):8-12
    124.关信平.农民工参与社会保障问题:需要、制度及社会基础[J].教学与研究,2008,(1):12-17
    125.韩克庆.经济全球化、社会分层和社会保障[M].北京:中国劳动社会保障出版社.2005
    126.黄晨熹.社会政策概念辨析[J].社会学研究,2008(4):163-181
    127.黄晨熹编著.社会政策[M].上海:华东理工大学出版社.2008
    128.黄黎若莲.边缘化与中国的社会福利[M].香港:商务印书馆,2001
    129.黄黎若莲.“福利国”、“福利多元主义”和“福利市场化”[J].改革,2000(10):62-63
    130.黄佩华.迪帕克.中国:国家发展与地方财政[M].北京:中信出版社 2003
    131.胡鞍钢.程永宏.中国就业制度演变[J].经济研究参考.2003,(51):2-19、25
    132.胡颖廉.地方政府竞争与公共服务:基于中部六省数据的实证研究(1996-2005)[J].兰州大学学报(社会科学版),2008.(1):19-29
    133.洪朝辉.论中国城市社会权利的贫困[J].江苏社会科学,2003,(2):116-125
    134.洪大用.改革以来中国城市扶贫工作的发展历程[J],社会学研究,2003,(1):71-86
    135.洪大用.中国大陆的贫困与社会救助[A].景天魁、张志敏编.中国社会政策:特点与经验[M].黑龙江人民出版社,2006.12:150-183
    136.吉尔伯特.特雷尔.社会福利政策导论.黄晨熹等译.上海:华东理工大学出版社.2003
    137.蒋勤.马歇尔公民资格理论评述[J].社会,2003,(3):32-36
    138.姜晓星.论我国社会政策的传统模式及其转变[J].社会学研究,1992,(1): 70-79
    139.卡尔·波兰尼.大转型:我们时代的政治与经济起源[M].冯刚、刘阳译.杭州:浙江人民出版社.2007
    140.考斯塔·艾斯平-安德森.郑秉文译.福利资本主义的三个世界[M],北京:法律出版社,2003
    141.考(哥)斯塔·艾斯平—安德森编,转变中的福利国家[C],重庆:重庆出版社,2003
    142.康晓光.韩恒.分类控制:当前中国大陆国家与社会关系研究[J].社会学研究,2005,(5):73-89
    143.克劳·根,经济改革是一项重大的社会政策[J],山西财经大学学报,1986,(6):67-74
    144.孔善广.分税制后地方政府财事权非对称性及约束激励机制变化研究[J].经济社会体制比较.2007,(1):36-42
    145.劳动与社会保障部医疗保险司.中国医疗保险制度改革政策与管理[M].北京:中国劳动社会保障出版社.1999
    146.李路路.论社会分层研究[J].社会学研究.1999,(1):101-109
    147.李路路.论“单位”研究[J].社会学研究.2002,(5):23-32
    148.李强.政治分层与经济分层[J].社会学研究.1997,(4):32-41
    149.李强.影响中国城乡流动人口的推力与拉力因素分析[J].中国社会科学.2003,(1):125-136
    150.李强.“丁字型”社会结构与“结构紧张”[J].社会学研究.2005,(2):55-73
    151.李实.罗楚亮.中国城乡居民收入差距的重新估计[J].北京大学学报(哲学社会科学版).2007,(02):111-120
    152.李实.古斯塔夫森.八十年代末中国贫困规模和程度的估计[J].中国社会科学.1996年第6期:29-44
    153.李迎生.转型时期的社会政策:问题与选择[M].中国人民大学出版社.2007
    154.零点咨询.2006年中国居民生活质量报告[R].
    155.零点指标数据网.就业问题再成中国市民第一关注热点[EB].http://www.horizonkey.com/showart.asp?art_id=70&cat_id=6
    156.梁鸿.苏南富裕农村社区的贫困问题.中国农村经济,2000,(11):25-27
    157.林闽纲.福利多元主义的兴起及其政策实践[J].社会.2002(7):36-37
    158.林闽纲.从福利国家到社会投资[J]二十一世纪,2008,(8)
    159.林卡、范晓光.贫困和反贫困——对中国贫困类型变迁及反贫困政策的研究[J].社会科学战线.2006,(1):187-194
    160.林卡.社会政策学科发展的国际经验及其对于中国的启示[A]社会政策评论.(2),2008
    161.刘继同、冯喜良.转型期多元福利实践与整体性福利理论框架[J].北京大学学报(哲学社会科学版).2005,(42:3):129-135
    162.楼苏萍.生产主义福利体制的特征、限度及其转变.未刊稿.2008
    163.卢中原.陈志理.城镇居民福利收入分析和建议[J].财贸经济.1997,(06):7-9
    164.陆学艺主编.当代中国社会阶层研究报告[M].北京:社会科学文献出版社,2002
    165.陆学艺、景天魁.转型中的中国社会[M].哈尔滨:黑龙江人民出版社,1994
    166.马杰.郑秉文.计划经济条件下新中国社会保障制度的再评价[J].马克思主义与研究,2005(1):38-48
    167.马仲良.于小静.借鉴国际经验,建立工作导向型社会福利体制[A].第三届全国社会福利理论与政策研讨会论文集[C].2008
    168.迈克尔·希尔.理解社会政策[M].刘升华译.北京:商务印书馆.2003
    169.莫里斯·罗奇(Maurice Roche).社会公民权:社会变迁的基础[A].伊辛.特纳主编,王小章译.公民权研究手册[M].杭州:浙江人民出版社.2007:69-115
    170.穆怀中,国民财政与社会保障收入再分配[M].中国劳动社会保障出版社.2003
    171.尼古拉斯·巴尔.福利国家经济学[M].北京:中国劳动社会保障出版社,2003
    172.潘天舒.我国县级义务教育投资的地区差异及其影响因素分析[J].教育与经济.2004,(4):36-44
    173.潘屹.论中国国家福利的重构[J].经济社会体制比较,2007,(2):58-64
    174.裴宜理.中国式的“权利”观念与社会稳定[J].领导者,2008,(23)或:http://www.tecn.cn/data/detail.php?id=20510
    175.彭华民.社会排斥概念之解析[A].中国社会工作研究(第二辑).北京:社会科学文献出版社,2004
    176.彭华民.福利三角:一个社会政策分析的范式[J].社会学研究.2006(4):157-168
    177.彭华民.黄野青.福利多元主义:福利提供从国家到多元部门的转型[J].南开学报(哲学社会科学版),2006,(6):40-48
    178.彭华民.社会福利与需要满足[M].北京:社会科学文献出版社,2008
    179.彭华民.就业制度转型中的城市新贫穷社群与多重社会排斥研究[A].杨团、关信平主编.当代社会政策研究[C].天津人民出版社,2006:355-374
    180.彭希哲.基于户籍制度的我国社会政策及其改革[A],第三届社会政策论坛论文集[C].2007
    181.乔宝云、范剑勇、冯兴元,中国的财政分权与小学义务教育[J].中国社会科学.2005,(6):37-46
    182.乔晓春.张恺悌.孙陆军.张玲.对中国老年贫困人口的估计[J].人口研究,2005,(2):8-15
    183.钱宁.从人道主义到公民权利——现代社会福利政治到的观念的历史演变[J].社会学研究,2004,(1):46-52
    184.钱宁.社会正义、公民权利和集体主义——论社会福利的政治与道德基础[M].北京:社会科学文献出版社.2007
    185.沙琳.中国的社会福利转型[A].沙琳编.需要和权利资格:转型期中国社会政策研究的新视角[C].北京:中国劳动社会保障出版社.2007:pp5-24
    186.世界银行,1990世界发展报告[R],经济出版社,1991
    187.世界银行编写组,防止老龄危机[M].中国财政经济出版社,1996
    188.尚晓媛 a.“社会福利”与“社会保障”再认识.中国社会科学,2001,(3):113-121
    189.尚晓媛 b.从国家福利到多元福利——南京市和兰州市社会福利服务的案例研究[J].清华大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2001,16,(4):16-23
    190.尚晓援.中国社会保护体制改革研究[M].北京:中国劳动社会保障出版社,2007
    191.尚晓援.中国弱势儿童保护体制研究[M],北京:中国社科文献出版社,2008
    192.沈原.市场、阶级与社会——转型社会学的关键议题[M].北京:社会科学文献文献出版社.2007
    193.宋士云、李成玲,1992-2006年中国社会保障支出水平研究[J].中国人口科学,2008,(3):38-46
    194.宋洪远.山西农村贫困的类型及其形成机理[A].杨团、张秀兰主编.当代社会政策研究Ⅱ.北京:中国劳动社会保障出版社,2007:267-286
    195:时宪民.中国沿海经济中心城市劳动力流动与体制选择——深圳特区流动劳动力管理研究[J].社会学研究,1999,(03):112-125
    196.孙立平.民间公益组织与治理:“希望工程”个案[A].载俞可平主编.中国公民社会的兴起与治理的变迁[C].北京:社会科学文献出版社,2002:67-94
    197.孙立平.断裂:20世纪90年代以来的中国社会[M].北京:社会科学文献出版社,2003
    198.孙立平.改革以来中国社会结构的变迁[M].北京:清华大学出版社.2004
    199.唐均.中国社会救助制度的变迁与评估[EB]社会政策网,又见http://thjp.vip.sina.com
    200.田凯.中国的非营利部门与福利制度转型[A]景跃进.张志敏.中国社会政策:特点与经验[C].黑龙江人民出版社.2006:213-230
    201.托尼·塞奇.盲人摸象:中国地方政府分析[J].经济社会体制比较.2006(4)
    202.王德文.张恺悌.中国老年人口的生活状况与贫困发生率估计,中国人口科学,2005,(1):58-66
    203.王名.中国社团改革——从政府选择到社会选择[M].北京:社会科学文献出版社,2001
    204.王绍光 a.现代国家的再分配制度[A].王绍光.安邦之道:国家转型的目标和途径[M].北京:生活·读书·新知三联书店,2007:169-197
    205.王绍光 b.从经济政策到社会政策:中国公共政策格局的历史性转变[J].中国公共政策评论,2007,(1),上海人民出版社
    206.王绍光.大转型:1980年代以来中国的双向运动[J].中国社会科学.2008,(1):129-148
    207.王绍光、潘毅、潘维、贺雪峰、强世功、张静、单世联等,共和国六十年:回顾与展望.开放时代.2008,(1):pp5-41
    208.王思斌.社会政策时代与政府社会政策能力建设[J].中国社会科学.2004(6)
    209.王文源,从“九五”至“十一五”:民办中小学幼儿教育回顾与展望.[J].教育科学研究.2007,(3):12-15
    210.王延中.中国社会保障发展十年述评[A].第三届社会政策国际会议论文集[C].2007
    211.王卓祺.雅伦·获加.西方社会政策概念转变及对中国福利制度发展的启示[J].社会学研究,1998,(5):44-50
    212.王卓祺.邓广良.魏雁滨编.两岸三地社会政策:理论与实务[C].香港:中文大学出版社,2005
    213.王元华.公民资格理论传统中的社会权利观念:有效性及其限度[J].扬州大学学报(人文社会科学版),2006,(1):70-73
    214.王晶.中国农村医疗筹资公平性研究[J].社会学研究,2008,(5):160-185
    215.王沪宁.从单位到社会:社会调控体系的再造[J].公共行政与人力资源.1995(01)
    216.王永先.我国住房制度改革历程回顾[EB].http://www.lrn.cn/zjtg/societyDiscussion/200710/t20071023-160507.htm.2008年12月下载
    217.王小章.公民权利、市场的两重性和社会保障[J].学术论坛,2007,(7):131-136
    218.王小章.社会分层与社会秩序——一个理论的综述[J].浙江社会科学.2001,(01):87-93
    219.吴晓刚.中国的户籍制度与代际职业流动[J].社会学研究.2007,(6):38-65
    220.吴玉霞.政府购买居家养老服务的政策研究——以宁波市海曙区为例[J].浙江省委党校学报,2007,(2)
    221.吴忠民.共享改革成果的内涵与意义[N].北京日报,2006.5.15
    222.吴忠民.从公平到公正:中国社会政策的演进[J].社会学研究.2004,(1):75-89
    223.魏后凯、杨大利.地方分权与中国地区教育差异[J]中国社会科学.1997,(1):98-112
    224.夏庆杰.宋丽娜.Simon Appleton.中国城镇贫困的变化趋势和模式:1988-2002[J].经济研究,2007,(9):96-111
    225.夏杏珍,农村合作医疗制度的历史考察[J].当代中国史研究.Vol.10,(5):110-118
    226.谢联辉,宋玉华.全球行动——迎接人口老龄化[M].北京:华龄出版社,1998
    227.新华社.2008年五项社会保险基金总收入达13808亿元[EB].见新华社网站:http://news.xinhuanet.com/newscenter/2009-01/20/content_10688328.htm
    228.徐道稳.中国社会政策转型研究[D].南京大学博士论文.2007
    229.徐道稳.迈向发展型社会政策——中国社会政策转型研究[M].北京:中国社会科学出版社,2008
    230.徐月宾.张秀兰.中国政府在社会福利中的角色重建[J].中国社会科学.2005,(5):80-92
    231.徐月宾.刘凤芹.张秀兰.中国农村反贫困政策的反思:从社会救助向社会保护转变[J].中国社会科学,2007,(3):40-53
    232.于学军.从上海看中国老年贫困与保障[J],人口研究,2003,(3)
    233.姚远.中国家庭养老研究述评[J].人口与经济,2001,(1):33-43
    234.严忠勤编.当代中国的职工工资福利和社会保险[C].北京:中国社会科学出版社.1987
    235.杨菊花.人口转变与老年贫困问题的理论思考[J].中国人口科学,2007,(5):88-94
    236.杨团.社会政策的理论与思索[J].社会学研究,2000,(4):16-26
    237.杨团.就地多元化:农村现代化的一种选择[J].中国改革.2005,(11)
    238.杨团.中国社会政策演进、焦点与建构[J].学习与实践,2006,(11):79-89
    239.杨团.医改的第三条道路[J].中国医疗前沿,2007,(7)
    240.杨伟民.当前中国的社会保险在社会分层中的作用[J].社会学研究,2005,(05):125-153
    241.伊辛.特纳.主编,王小章译.公民权研究手册[M].杭州:浙江人民出版社.2007
    242.伊恩·高夫.欧洲福利国家:阐释及发展中国家可借鉴的教训[A].第二届社会政策国际论坛论文集[C],2006
    243.郁建兴.石德金.超越发展型国家与中国的国家转型[J].学术研究,2008,(4):5-12
    244.郁建兴.楼苏萍.公民社会权利在中国:回顾、现状与政策建议[J].教学与研究.2008,(12):23-29
    245.袁国敏、林治芬,中国社会保障资金总量认识[J].社会科学辑刊,2007,(3):57-59
    246.乐章.陈璇.风笑天.城市独生子女家庭养老问题[J].青年研究,2000,(3):16-19
    247.岳经纶.和谐社会与政府职能转变:社会政策的视角[J].武汉大学学报,2007,60(3):416-422
    248.张恒龙、陈宪.财政竞争对地方公共支出结构的影响—以中国的招商引资竞争为例[J]经济社会体制比较.2006(6):pp57-64
    249.张秀兰、徐月宾,建构中国发展型家庭政策[J]中国社会科学,2003,(6):84-96
    250.张秀兰.徐月宾.梅志里.中国发展型社会政策论纲[M].北京:中国劳动社会保障出版社,2007
    251.张秀兰.徐月宾.发展型社会政策及其对我们的启示[A].“第二届社会政策国际论坛”文集[C],北京:中国劳动社会保障出版社,2007
    252.张翼.中国人社会地位的获得——阶级继承和代内流动[J].社会学研究,2004(04):76-90
    253.赵耀辉.李实.中国城镇职工实物收入下降的原因分析[J].经济学(季刊),2002,(02):575-588
    254.郑秉文.合作主义:中国福利制度框架的重构[J].经济研究,2002,(2):71-79
    255.郑秉文.福利资本主义模式的变迁与比较(译者跋),考斯塔·艾斯平-安德森.郑秉文译.福利资本主义的三个世界,北京:法律出版社,2003:315-418
    256.郑功成等.中国社会保障制度变迁与评估[M].北京:中国人民大学出版社,2002
    257.郑功成,中国保险业的发展和改革思考[J].经济评论.1994年第6期:98-101
    258.郑杭生.当代中国社会结构和社会关系研究[M].北京:首都师范大学出版社.1997
    259.郑杭生.序一.见陆益龙.户籍制度——控制与社会差别[M].商务印书馆,2003:P1
    260.郑杭生.洪大用.中国转型期的社会安全隐患与对策[J].中国人民大学学报.2005,(5):2-9
    261.中国社会保障体系研究课题组.中国社会保障制度改革:反恩与重构[J].社会学研究,2000(6):49-65
    262.郑永年.全球化与中国国家转型[M].郁建兴、何子英译.浙江人民出版社.2009
    263.周弘.福利的行政化与政治化[J].中国人口科学,2007,(3):2-10
    264.周莹、梁鸿,中国农村传统家庭养老保障模式的不可持续性研究[J],经济体制改革,2006年第5期:107-110
    265.朱庆芳.我国社会保障指标体系综合评价[J].社会学研究,1995,(4):118-122
    266.朱庆芳.城镇贫困群体的特点及原因[J].中国党政干部论坛,2002,(4):17-19
    267.朱燕敏.一个整合的社会政策制定模型[J].社会福利,2003,(12):11-14
    268.中国发展研究基金会.UNDP.中国人类发展报告 2005:追求公平的人类发展[R].北京:中国对外翻译出版公司,2005.
    269.中国(海南)改革发展研究院.UNDP.中国人类发展报告 2007/2008:惠及13亿人的基本公共服务[R].北京.中国对外翻译出版公司.2008
    270.中国国家统计局.中国农村贫困标准[R].1990
    271.中国国家统计局,2008年中国统计年鉴.中国统计出版社.2008
    国家统计局统计公报:http://www.stats.gov.cn/tjgb/
    卫生统计年鉴及年度公报:http://www.moh.gov.cn/publicfiles//business/htmlfiles/zwgkzt/pwstj/in dex.htm
    教育统计年度数据:http://www.moe.edu.cn/
    民政事业统计数据:http://www.mca.gov.cn/article/zwgk/tjsj/
    劳动和社会保障事业年度统计公报:http://wl.mohrss.gov.cn/gb/zwxx/node_5436.htm

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700