用户名: 密码: 验证码:
基于PLS-SEM的中国高等教育学生满意度测评研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
随着高等教育的大众化,高等教育质量评估和保障受到了社会的广泛关注。但是由于种种原因,现有的高等教育质量评估主体主要是政府、高等学校、学术权威以及用人单位,惟独学生的“消费者权益”没有引起足够的重视,以大学生为导向的高等教育学生满意度测评模式尚未建立。此外,尽管服务质量的内涵、特性及其顾客满意度的测评模型在商业领域得到了广泛的研究,但是关于高等教育学生满意度及其因果关系的研究则显得十分薄弱。因此,本研究具有重要的理论和实践的意义。
     本研究共分四个部分:第一部分,理论研究。通过对高等教育质量观发展的探讨,剖析了高等教育的服务属性、特征和顾客的特殊性,在服务质量和顾客满意理论的基础上分析了高等教育服务质量的内涵与评价方法,深入探讨了高等教育学生满意的内涵以及学生满意度测评及其意义。第二部分,模型研究。借鉴国内外典型顾客满意度指数模型的研究成果,分析了学生满意度的影响因素,构建了符合我国高等教育服务特性的学生满意度指数模型和学生满意度测评指标体系。第三部分,对学生满意度概念模型进行预测试研究。通过对质量感知等变量进行探索性研究,对样本数据进行可靠性分析和多重共线性等检验,以验证影响质量感知等因素的结构模式是否与概念模型中的定义相吻合。第四部分,以江苏省10所高等学校的学生满意度数据为基础,开展学生满意度测评模型的实证研究。依据学生满意度数据呈偏态分布的特点,采用基于PLS技术的结构方程模型对学生满意度概念模型进行估计和检验,计算学生满意度指数并研究潜变量之间的关系以及潜变量与其显变量的关系,通过满意度重要性矩阵分析影响学生满意的主要因素,探讨了模型对各类学生的普遍适用性,最后利用均值结构模型分析学生个人基本属性对满意度模型的影响。
     本研究的主要结论是:学校形象对学生期望具有直接影响、对质量感知具有直接影响、对价值感知的直接影响不显著但存在间接影响、对学生满意度具有直接和间接影响,对学生抱怨存在间接的反向影响、对学生忠诚度的直接影响不显著但存在着间接影响;学生期望对质量感知具有直接影响、对价值感知具有直接和间接影响、对学生满意度具有直接和间接影响;质量感知对价值感知具有直接影响、对学生满意度具有直接和间接影响:价值感知对学生满意度具有直接影响;学生满意度对学生抱怨具有反向的直接影响、对学生忠诚具有直接和间接影响。学生期望、质量感知和价值感知均对学生抱怨具有反向的间接影响、对学生忠诚度具有正向的间接影响;在影响满意度的因素中,学校形象排第一位,其次是质量感知,接下来是价值感知。大学生个体基本属性对高等教育学生满意度模型中的各个潜变量具有不同程度的影响。本研究提出的概念模型对各类学生样本具有一定的普遍适用性。
     根据本研究的结论,我们认为高等学校应该从构建重视学生满意度测评的制度环境、重视高等教育学生感知服务质量、加强高等学校形象建设与有形展示、进一步改革教学和管理模式等方面入手,有效提高高等教育的学生满意度和忠诚度,增强高等学校办学的竞争力。
With the popularization of higher education, higher education quality assessment and protection has been given wide concern by the society. However, for various reasons, the existing quality assessment entities in higher education are mainly Government, universities, academic authorities and the employment. The students' "consumer rights" haven't been paid enough attention to, neither has higher education student satisfaction model based on college students themselves been established. In addition, while the measurement model of service quality connotation, characteristics and customer satisfaction has been extensively researched in the commercial field, the study on higher education student satisfaction and its causality is very weak. Therefore, this research is of great theoretical and practical significance.
     The study is divided into four parts. The first part is theoretical study. Through the discussion on the development of quality of higher education, analysis of higher education in the service properties, characteristics and particularities of the customer, on the basis of service quality and customer satisfaction theory analysis on the connotation and evaluation of service quality of higher education, had an in-depth discussion on the connotation of higher education students'satisfaction and student satisfaction and its significance. The second part is the research on the model., referencing customer satisfaction index model of typical research results at home and abroad and using customer satisfaction index model research results, analyses the influencing factors of student satisfaction and builds student satisfaction index model and student satisfaction evaluation index system conformed to China's higher education service characteristics. Part III is a pre-testing study on conceptual model of student satisfaction. Through research on variables such as quality perception, reliability analysis of sample data and multicollinearity test, this part verifies whether the structure model of factors affecting quality perception is in line with the conceptual model. Part IV is an empirical research on the model of student satisfaction assessment based on student satisfaction data from 10 universities in Jiangsu province. Judging by the partial distribution feature of the student satisfaction data, using structure equation model on PLS technology, this part estimates and tests the conceptual model of student satisfaction, calculates student satisfaction index, researches the relationship between latent variables and explicit variables, analyses, by virtue of importance matrix, factors affecting student satisfaction, explores the model's general applicability to various students, and lastly, by value structure model, discusses the effect of students' individual basic property on the satisfaction model.
     The main conclusions of this research are as follow. School image has direct effect on student expectations and quality perception, insignificant but indirect effect on value perception, direct and indirect effect on student satisfaction, indirect reverse effect on student complaining, and insignificant but indirect effect on student loyalty; student expectations have direct effect on quality perception, direct and indirect effect on value perception and student satisfaction; quality perception has direct effect on value perception, direct and indirect effect on student satisfaction; value perception has direct effect on student satisfaction; student satisfaction has direct reverse effect on student complaining, direct and indirect effect on student loyalty; each of student expectations, quality perception and value perception has indirect reverse effect on student complaining, indirect positive impact on student loyalty; Among factors affecting the satisfaction, school image takes first place, quality perception takes second and value perception third. College students'individual basic property has more or less influence on each latent variable in higher education student satisfaction model. The conceptual model put forward in this study is universally applicable to all categories of student samples.
     According to this study, it's firmly believed that higher education should be aimed at constructing the system environment in which student satisfaction assessment is given added weight, stressing service quality of student perception, enhancing image construction and physical evidence, further reforming teaching and management modes and educating students in accordance with their aptitude in order to improve higher education student satisfaction and loyalty, enhance the competitiveness of each higher education institute.
引文
[1]http://www.moe.edu.cn/publicfiles/business/htimifiles/moe/s5141/index.htm
    [2]http://edu.sina.com.cn/gaokao/2011-3-29/1203290433.shtml
    [3]徐辉,杨天平.以特制胜:大众化高等教育的发展战略[J].高教探索,2006(5):p9-11
    [4]Weaver.T.What is good of higher education?[J].Higher Education Review,1976(8):3-14
    [5]FM Hill. Managing service quality in higher education:the role the student as primary consumer[J]. Quality Enassurance in Education,1995(3):10-21
    [6]Galloway,L. Quality perceptions of internal andexternal cunstomers:a case study in educational administration[J].TQM Magazine,1998(10):20-26
    [7]Shank, M. D., Walker, M., Hayes, T Understanding Professional Service Expectation:Do We Know What OurStudents Expect in a Quality Education [J]. Journal of Professional Services Marketing.1995,13, (1):71-89
    [8]Owlia M.S, Aspinwall E.M. A Framework for measuring quality in engineering education [J]. Total Quality Management,1998(6):501-518
    [9]Smith & Ennew. Measuring Quality and Performance in Higher Education[J]. Quality in Higher Education,2001.17(1):5
    [10]LeBlanc, Gaston, Nguyen, Nha. Searching for excellence in business education:an exploratory study of customer impressions of service quality [J]. The International Journal of Educational Management,1997(2):11-15
    [11]Brenda M.Oldfield &Steve Baron.Beyond service quality dimensions in higher education end towards a service contract [J]. Quality Assurance in Education.1997, (1):7-14
    [12]Sangeeta Sahney, Devinder Kumar Banwet, Sabita Ka-runes,Enhancing quality in education: application of quality function deployment-an industry perspective[J]·working paper, Nov 2003 Volume:52 Issue:6:297-309-
    [13]Martin,A.O and Adrian Palmer, Importance- performance analysis:a useful tool for directing continuous quality improvement in higher education[J]·Quality Assurance in Education,Volume 12, Number 1,2004,39-52-
    [14]John B. Ford:Mathew Joseph and Beatriz. Joseph. Importance-Performance analysis as a strategic tool for service marketers:the case of service quality perceptions of business students in New Zealand and the USA[J]. The Journal of services Marketing, VOL.13 NO.21999, pp.171-186.
    [15]Gaston and Nha, Listeningtothe customer's voice:exam-ining perceived service value among business college students[J],The International Journal of Educational Management 13/4,1999,187-198-
    [16]Firdaus Abdullah, HEdPERF versus SERVPERF The quest for ideal measuring instrument of service quality in higher education sector[J]·Quality Assurance in Education, Vol.13 No. 4,2005,305-328-
    [17]Cuthbert, P. F. Managing service quality in HE:is SERVQUAL the answer? [J].Managing ServiceQuality,1996(3):31-35.
    [18]O'Neil M. The influnece of time on student perception of service quality:the need for longitudinal measures [J]. Journal of Education Administration; 2003,41 (3):310-324
    [19]刘俊学.高等教育服务市场的儿点思考[J],江苏高教,2002(5)11-13
    [20]胡子祥.高等教育服务质量控制链研究[J].四川:理工高教研究,2004第2期:35-38
    [21]赵雄辉.试论大学生的高等教育服务消费者身份,江苏高教,2007(1)50-52
    [22]马万民.高等教育服务质量管理研究[M].上海:上海交通大学出版社,2005(4)
    [23]佘高波.基于服务质量差距理论的华兹音乐教育学校营销策略分析[D].西安:西北工业大学,2004
    [24]林丹.为学生服务:高等教育质量评估的终极目的[J].吉林:现代教育科学,2004第1期:100-108
    [25]姚利民,肖贻杰.高校应提高教育服务质量[J].湖南:当代教育论坛,2003第7期:64-66
    [26]朱国锋.高职教育服务质量评价理论与方法[M].大连:大连海事大学出版社,2004
    [27]赵国杰等.大学生高校教育感知质量测度的初步研究[J].中国地质大学学报(社会科学版),2001(4)
    [28]Stauss B,Hentschel B.Attribute-Based Versus Incident-Based Measurement of Service Quality:Results of an Empirical Study Within the German Car Service Industry. Quality Management in Service.Van Gorcum,Assen/Masstrich,1992.52-78
    [29]胡子祥.高等谈育顾客感知服务质量的实证研究,西南交通大学博十研究生学位论文,P137,2006
    [30]嵇小怡,黄小平.高校教育服务质量满意度测评研究[J].高教发展与评估,2005,(4):29-32.
    [31]顾佳峰.高等教育服务质量研究——以北京大学为例[J].黑龙江高教研究,2006(6)
    [32]洪彩真.高等教育服务质量与学生满意度研究——以福州、厦门、泉州高职院校为例[D].厦门大学教育研究院,2007.
    [33]Kotler, P. Marketing Management, Analysis, Planning, Implementation, and Control [J], Prentice-Hall,1997
    [34]Oliver, R.L. Satisfaction:A behavioral perspective on the consumer. NY:McGraw-Hill,1997
    [35]Oliver R. L. A Cognitive Model of the Antecedents and Consequence of Satisfaction Decisions [J]. Journal of Marketing Research,1980 (17),p460-469
    [36]Churchill,Gilbert A.,JR.,and Carol Surprennant, An Investigation Into the Determinanants of Customer Satisfaction [J],Journal of Marketing Reseaech,1982, ⅩⅨ (Nov),p491-504.
    [37]Oliver Richard L. Cognitive, Affective and Attribute Bases of the Satisfaction Response [J], Journal of Consumer Satisfaction,1993,20(Dec),p418~430
    [38]Ostrom & Iacobucci.Consumer Trade-Office and the Evaluation of Services [J], Journal of Marketing.1995,January, p17-28.
    [39]Zeithaml V., Berry L. Parasuraman A. The Behavioral Consequences of Service Quality [J]. Journal of Marketing,1996,60,p31-46
    [40]Oliver, Richard L. Measurement and Evaluation of Satisfaction Processes in Retailing Setting[J]. Journal of Retailing,1981,Fall, p25-48.
    [41]Tes D.K.,Wilton P.C.Models of Consumer Satisfaction Formation:An Extension[J].
    [42]Boulding, Staelin, Kalra & Zeithaml. A dynamic process model of service quality:From expectation to behavioral intentions [J], Journal of Marketing Research,30(Feb),1993,7-27.
    [43]Fornell C., Larcker D. F. Evaluating Structural Equation Models with Unobservable Variables and Measurement error [J]. Journal of Marketing Research,1996,18(2):39-50
    [44]Joreskog. K.G, and Herman Word. The ML and PLS Techniques for Modeling with Latent Variable:Historical and Comparative Aspects [J].In K.G.. Joreskog and H.Word eds.,Systems under Indirect Observation:Causality, Structure, Prediction, Vol.1,Amsterdam,North-Holland, 1982, p263-270
    [45]Fornell,Claes, and Fred L. Bookstein. Two Structural Equation Models:LISREL and PLS Applied to Consumer Exit-Voice Theory [J].Journal of Marketing Research,1982, ⅩⅨ (Nov),p440-452
    [46]Fornell, Class, and Jaesung Cha. "Partial Least Squares,"In Richard P. Bagozzi eds., Advanced Methods of Marketing Research [J], Cambridage, Basil Black-Well Ltd,1994,P52-78
    [47]Chin, Wynne W., Partial Least Squares is to LISREL as Principal Components Analysis is to Common Factor Analysis [J]. Technology Studies,1995,2,p315-319
    [48]Wold,H. "Soft modeling:The basic design, and some extensions", In K. G. Joreskog and H.Wold (Eds.), Systems under Indirect Observation:Causality-Structure-Prediction(Part Ⅱ).Armisterdam:North-Holland,1982
    [49]Wold, Herman."Partial least squares",in Samuel Kotz& Norman L. Johnson(Eds.),Encyclopedia of Statistical Sciences[M],Vol.6,New York:John Wiley & Sone,1985,581-591
    [50]金勇进梁燕张宗芳.满意度评估系统应用研究[M],中国统计出版社,2007.7p46-148
    [51]Chin, Wynne W., and P. Newsted. Structural Equation Modeling Analysis with Small Samples Using Partial Least Squares [M],In Rich Hoyle eds., Statistical Strategies for Small Sample Research, Thousand Oakes, CA,Sage Publication,1999,p307-341
    [52]Jaynes E.T..Information Theory and Statistical Mechanics[J].Physical Review,1957,106(4): 620-630.
    [53]Jaynes E.T..Information Theory and Statistical Mechanics[J].Physical Review,1957, 108(2):171-190.
    [54]霍映宝.CSI模型构建及其参数的GME的综合估计研究[D],南京理工大学学位论文,2004
    [55]Golan A.,Judge G.,Karp L.A Maximum Entropy Approach to Estimation and Inference in Dynamic Models or Counting Fish in the sea Using Maximum Entropy[J].Economic Dynamics and Control,1996(20):559-582.
    [56]Golan A.,Judge G.,Miller D.Maximum Entropy Economics:Robust Estimation with Limited Data[M].New York:John Wiley and Sons,1996.
    [57]Ludo M.K.,Peeters.Estimating a Random-Coefficient Sample-Selection Model Using Generalized Maximum Entropy[J].Economics Letters,2004(84):87-92.
    [58]Paris,Quirino.Multicollinearity and Maximum Entropy Estimators[J].Economics Bulletin, 2001,3(11):1-9.IEEE Control System Magazine,1990(4):44-48.
    [59]Myers R H.(1990). Classical and Modern Regression with Applications (2nd Edition) Boston: Duxbury Press.
    [60]何毅.基于BP神经网络电容法刨花含水率测试仪的研究与开发[D].南京林业大学博十学位论文,2006.
    [61]黄万杰.基于BP神经网络改进算法的库存控制策略[D].重庆大学硕十学位论文,2003.
    [62]王万森.人工智能原理及其应用[M].北京:电子工业出版社,2000.
    [63]国家质检总局质量管理司,清华大学中国企业研究中心.中国顾客满意指数指南[M].北京:中国标准出版社,2003
    [64]梁燕. 中国顾客满意度指数构建若干问题研究[D].北京:中国人民大学,2004.
    [65]刘新燕. 顾客满意度指数模型研究[M].北京:中国财政经济出版社,2004.
    [66]刘武,李文子.城市公交服务乘客满意度指数模型[J].城市交通,2007,11:65-69
    [67]林盛、刘金兰、韩文秀.基于PLS-结构方程的顾客满意度评价方法[M],系统工程学报,2005(6),p653-656
    [68]张宇.顾客满意阈值及市场营销策略属性的离散估计[J].管理科学学报,2002(6):63-66.
    [69]刘玉敏,张晓丽,徐济超.顾客满意度测评的质量功能展开方法[J].系统工程理论与实践,2004(9):20-27.
    [70]王海燕.关于在P-M模糊测度空间构建CSI测评体系的研究[D].南京理工大学博士学位论文,2003
    [71]安殉.面向顾客满意度改进决策的结构方程和影响图结合研究[D].天津大学博士学位论文,2006
    [72]金瑜.心理测量[M].上海:华东师范大学出版社,2001
    [73]胡子祥,李小平.高等教育顾客感知服务价值的实证研究[J].四川师范大学学报(社会科学版),2006(5)
    [74]Watson S. Closing the feedback loop:ensuring effective action from student feedback [J]. Tertiary Educati on and Management,2003, (2).
    [75]Svetlana A.& Beltyukova. Equating Student Satisfaction Measures Using Rasch Analysis[EB /OL]. htt p://edtech.connect.msu.edu/Search aera2002/viewp r oposaltext.aspp r op ID= 5489,2002-03-10.
    [76]JamesW. (2002). Student Satisfaction:a British model of effective use of student feedback in quality assurance and enhancement[C]. Presented at 14 th International Conference on Assessment and Quality in Higher Education Vien2na,2002.
    [77]Wiers-Jenssen J., Stensaker B. R.&J. B. G. Gaard.Student Satisfaction:towards an empirical deconstructi on ofthe concep t[J]. Quality in Higher Education,2002, (2).
    [78]DEBNATH, ect.al. Students'Satisfaction in Man-agement Education:Study and Insights[J]. Journal of Marketing for Higher Education,2005,(2).
    [79]Li-Wei Mai. A Comparative Study Between UK and US:The Student Satisfaction in Higher Education and its Influential Factors[J].University of Westminster Journal of Marketing Management,2005:859-878
    [80]Dwayne D.Gremler and Michael A.McCol-lough.Student Satisfaction Guarantees:An Empirica Examination of Attitudes,Antecedents,and Consequences[J]Journal of Marketing Education,2002,8:150-160·
    [81]Mavondo,FelixT.Tsarenko,Yelena Gabbott,Mark.International and Local Student Satisfaction:Resources and Capabilities Perspective[J]. Journal of Marketing for Higher Education,2004:41-60.
    [82]Richardson,John T.E. Instruments for Obtaining Student Feedback:a Review of Literature. Assessment & Evaluation in Higher Education [J].2005(4):409
    [83]http://www.noe.noellevitz.com/our+service/retention/tools/student satisfaction inv...2007-9-26
    [84]戴梅红.在高等教育领域树立“顾客满意”质量意识的思考[J].沈阳:高等农业教育,2004第10期:26-29
    [85]徐卫良,黄忠林.以学生满意度为依据改进高等学校教学工作[J].上海:上海电机学院学报,2005第8期:73-78
    [86]孔锐,何大义.中国高等学校顾客满意度问题解决方案简析[J].浙江:中国质量,2005第7期:49-52
    [87]尤海燕.不同批次大学生满意度调查分析[J].宁波工程学院学报,2005(4)
    [14]Churchill, G.A., Jr&Carol Surprenant. An Investigation into the Determinants of Consumer Satisfaction [J]. Journal of Marketing Research,1982. Nov:491-504.
    [88]刘俊学等.大学生求学满意度影响因素及其程度的实证研究[J].高等教育研究,2006,(11):91-97
    [89]王斌,范丽丽,迟铁.独立学院学生满意度影响因素分析[J].国家教育行政学院学报,2007, (6):72-78.
    [90]张倩.高等教育评价与学生满意度[J].中国高教研究,2009,(11):40-43.
    [91]房保俊.工科本科教学质量学生满意度影响因素分析[J].高等教育研究,2010,(6):78-83.
    [92]田喜洲,王晓漫.在校大学生满意度调查与分析[J].高教探索,2007(5):126-128.
    [93]胡晓辉,王焕明.对高等教育顾客满意度的初步研究[J].国家教育行政学院学报,2006(5)
    [94]蔺炜莹..高校学生服务感知质量研究[D].天津大学硕十学位论文,2005.1
    [95]林卉.我国高校学生满意度指数测评研究[J].科技创业,2006(12)
    [96]罗一新,李建湘.高等学校顾客满意度的定量评价方法研究[J].技术经济,2006(10)
    [97]王国强,沙嘉祥.高校学生满意测评应用研讨[J].中国质量(质量学术专刊),2002,(12):55.
    [98]常亚平,侯晓丽,刘艳阳.中国高校大学生求学满意度测评体系和评价模型研究[J].高等教育研究,2007,(9):82-87.
    [99]王灵玲.学习满意度评价指标体系的建立与灰色综合评价[J].宁波职业技术学院学报,2006,(5):11-13.
    [100]杨雪,刘武.中国高等教育顾客满意度指数模型及其应用[J].辽宁教育研究,2006,(10):7-10.
    [101]单天明.七年制和五年制学生对医学教育环境满意度的比较研究[J].西安:西北医学教育,2005第6期:229-231
    [102]小柳佐和子.应十分重视高校师资培训—中国大学生对大学满意度调查及相关分析[D],复旦大学,2001
    [103]赵伶俐,潘莉.高校学生对教学、任课教师和课程满意度的调查[J].重庆大学学报(社会科学版),2001,(3):119-124.
    [104]唐点权..关丁:大学生对当前高校教学管理现状满意度的调查[J].现代教育科学,2002(5)
    [105]李文超,李靖..常州地区高校顾客满意度测评[J].湖北工学院学报,2002
    [106]傅真放.高等学校大学生满意度实证分析研究[J].高教论坛,2004,(5):12-18.
    [107]陈洪套.大学生满意度指数在大学评估中的应用探索[J].经济与社会发展,2005(8)
    [108]邱梅生.大众化高等教育质量研究综述[J].江苏高教,2002,(1)
    [109]陈玉现.超前发展的重点应是高等教育.中国教育报.2001.3.2
    [110]赵婷婷.从精英到大众高等教育质量观的转变[J].江苏高教,2002(1):39-41
    [111]熊志翔.高等教育质量保障体系研究[M],长沙:湖南人民出版社,2002:46-50
    [112]纳伊曼.世界高等教育的探讨[M],北京:教育科学出版社,1982:165-177
    [113]赵蒙成,周川.高等教育质量:概念与现实.江苏高教.2000(2):32-35
    [114]马万民徐小洲.对高等教育服务产品定位问题的思考,中国高教研究,2005(11)40
    [115]孔锐,何大义.中国高等学校顾客满意度问题解决方案简析[J].中国质量,2005(7):49
    [116]刘俊学.再论高等教育服务及其主要特征[J],江苏高教,2008(5)21-24
    [117]刘俊学.高等教育服务的双重属性及其对高教管理的影响[J],现代大学教育2001(3)。
    [118]陈士俊、孙研、王梅.高等教育服务的基本特征及其对高教管理的启示[J].高等工程教育研究,2005(4):20-22
    [119]Shank, M.D., Walker, M., Hayes, T. (1995). Under-standing Professional Service Expectation: Do We Know What Our Students Expect in a Quality Education. New York:Journal of Professional Services Marketing,13(1),71-89.
    [120]郭国庆,钱明辉.市场营销学通论[M].北京:中国人民大学出版社,2007
    [121]白长虹,廖伟.基于顾客感知价值的顾客满意研究[J].南开学报(哲社版),2001,(6):14-20.
    [122]W iers-Jenssen J., Stensaker B. R.&J. B. G. Gaard.StudentSatisfaction:towards an empiricaldeconstruction of the concept[J]. Quality inHigherEducation,2002, (2). educational administration[J]. TQM Magazine,1998(10):20-26
    [123]Parasuraman A., Zeithaml V. A. and Berry L. L., SERVQUAL, A Multiple-Item Scale for Measuring Consumer Perceptions of Service Quality [J]. Journal of Retailing,1988,64(1):12~40
    [124]Ham, L.,& Hayduk, S., Gaining competitive andvantages in higher education:analyzing the gap between expectations and perceptions of service quality [J]. International Journal of Value-Based Management,2003(3)16-20
    [125]Elizabath Andeson, High tech v.high touch:a case study of TQM omplementtation in higher education[J]. managing Service Quality,1995,5(2)
    [126]Mathew Joseph, Beatriz Joseph. Service quality in education:a student perspective[J]. Quality Assurance in Education,1997(1):15-21
    [127]Christine. Wright, Martin.O'Neill. Service Quality Evalution in the Higher Education Sector:An Empirical Investigation of Student' Perceptions[J]. Higher Education Research & Development,2002(1):23-28
    [128]Sureshchandar G S, Rajendran C, Kamalanabhan T J. Customer Perceptions of Service Quality: A Critique[J]. Total Quality Management,2001(12):111-124.
    [129]Dardozo, Richard N. An Experimental Study of Consumer Effort, Expectation, and Satisfaction [J]. Journal of Marketing Research,1965. Aug, p244-249
    [130]Howard, John A.& Jagdish N. Sheth. The Theory of Buyer Behavior. New York Wiley. 1969.pp.27-28.
    [131]Hempel, Donald J. consumer Satisfaction with the Homo Buring Process:Conceptualization and Measurement. The Conceptualization and Measurement of Consumer Satisfaction and Dissatisfaction. Cambridge. MA:Marketing Science. Institute.1977.pp.7-9
    [132]Oliver, Richard L. Measurement and Evaluation of Satisfaction Processes in Retailing Setting. Journal of Retailing,1981,Fall, pp.25-48.
    [133]Churchill, Gilber A., Jr & Carol Superenant. An Investigation into the Determinants of Consumer Satisfaction. Journal of Marketing Research.1982.Nov, pp.491-P504.
    [134]Tes, David K.& Wilton, Peter C. Models of Consumer Satisfaction Formation:An Extension, Journal of Marketing,1988, pp.204-212.
    [135]Engel, James F.,Toger D.Blackwell;& Paul W.Miniard.Consumer Behavior, Harcourt Broce Joranovich. College Publishers. The Dryden Press.1993.
    [136]Parasuraman, A., V. A. Zeithaml, and L. L.Berry.Reassessment of Expectations as A Comparison Standard in Measuring Service Quality:Implications for Further Research, Journal of Marketing,1994,58,pp.111-123.
    [137]Ostrom & Iacobucci; Consumer Trade-Offs and the Evaluation of Services, Journal of Marketing.1995,January, pp.17-28.
    [138]Kotler, P. Marketing Management, Analysis, Planning, Implementation, and Control, Prentice-Hall,1997
    [139]Oliver, Richard L., Whence Consumer Loyalty?, Journal of Marketing[J],1999,63 (Special Issue),p33-44
    [140]Beltyukova, Svetlana A.& Fox, Christine M. Student Satisfaction as a Measure of Student Development:towards a Universal Metric[J] Journal of College Student Development,May/April 2002.
    [141]Bean,J.P & Metzner, B.S..A conceptual model pf nontrational undergraduate student attrition.Review of Education Research,1985(55),485-540.
    [142]Chadwich, K.,& Ward, J..Determinants of consumer satisfaction with education:Implications for college and university administratiors[J].College and University,1987 (93):236-246.
    [143]Oliver,R.L.& Desarbo.W.S. Processing of the satisfaction response in consumption:a suggested framework and research proposition, Journal of Consumer Satisfaction, Dissatisfaction and Complaining,Behavior 1989(2):1-16.
    [144]Delucchi,Michael.Student Satisfaction with Higher Education during 1970's-A Decade of Social Change[M].The Edwin Mellen Press, United Kingdom,2003:42.
    [145]Brown, James B. An Analysis of Studengt Satisfaction at the Community College of Baltimore County, Catonsville[D]. A Dissertation Submitted for the Degree of Doctor of Education, Wilmington College,2005:11
    [146]Understanding Student Satisfaction, British Columbia College & Institute Student Outcome, Issue Paper ISSN1492-3718, Autumn 2003(3))。
    [147]转引自Kao Ju-I. Student Satisfaction in Public,Private and Technical Colleges in Southern Taiwan[D].A Dissertation for the Degree of Doctor of Education, The University of South Dakota,2003:2,40)
    [148]Bean J.P.,& Bradley, R. K.. Untangling the Satisfaction Performance Relationship for College Students[J]. Journal of Higher Education,1986,57(4):393-412
    [149]Chadwick, K.,& Ward, J. Determinants of Consumer Satisfaction with Education:Implications for College & University Administrators [J]. College and University,1987,62(3):236-246)。
    [150]Nord, Sheldon C. Student Satisfaction in Oregon Community Colleges[EB/OL]. ERIC, ED418763,1997:19
    [151][美]德里克·博克.美国高等教育[M].乔佳义泽.北京师范大学出版社,1991:6
    [152]韩玉志.现代大学管理:以美国大学学生满意度测评为例)P31-34,浙江大学出版社,2008.10
    [153]Student Satisfaction Inventory-12 scales for added precision [EB/OL] http://www.noellevitz.com/our+Service/tools/Student+Satisfaction+Inv...2007-9-26
    [154][美]菲利普·G.阿特巴赫.大众高等教育的逻辑[J].蒋凯,陈学飞译,高等教育研究,1999(2):7
    [155]The 2004 National Satisfaction and Priorities Report Introduction and Overview [EB/OL]. http://www.noellevitz.com/Papers+and+Research/Papers+and Reports/Research Library/Satisfaction+and+priorities+reports.htm.2007-03-07)
    [156]Anderson, Eugene W., Claes Fornell, and Donald R. Lehmann, Customer Satisfaction, Market Share, and Profitability:Findings From Sweden[J]. Journel of Marketing, 1994,Vol.58(July),p53-66
    [157]赵平.中国耐用消费品行业顾客抱怨行为研究,清华大学学报(哲学社会科学版,2002年第2期,P32-38)
    [158]Gronroos C. Toward a Third Phase in Service Quality Research:Challenges and Future Directions [J]. Advances in Services Marketing Management,1993,12(3):49-64.
    [159]Michael D,Johnson A G, Tor W A,et al.The Evolution and Future of Nation Customer Satisfac-tion Index Models[J].Journal of Economic Psychol-ogy,2001,22(2):217-245.
    [160]Oliver R Effects of Satisfaction and Its An-tecedents on Consumer Preferences and Intention[J].Advances in Consuer Research,1981,8(5):88-93.
    [161]Tor W A, Bodill, Customer, et al. The complex Services:The Impact of Corporate Image on Quality,Customer Satisfaction and Loyalty for Customers with Varying Degrees of Service Expertise [J].The International Journal of Service Industry Management,1997,8(4):89-97.
    [162]赵平、莫亚琳.中国耐用消费品行业顾客抱怨行为研究,清华大学学报(哲学社会科学版)[J],2002(2)p33
    [163]Olson, Jerry C. and Philip A. Dover, "Disconfirmation of Consumer Expectations Through Product Trial,"[J] Journal of Applied Psychology,1979,64 (April), P179-189
    [164]Oliver R. L. A Cognitive Model of the Antecedents and Consequence of Satisfaction Decisions[J]. Journal of Marketing Research,1980,17:460-469
    [165]Day, Ralph. Toward a Process Model of Consumer Satisfaction. In Conceptualization and Measurement of Consumer Satisfaction and Dissatisfaction, H. Keith Hunt, ed. Cambridge, MA:Marketing Science Institute,1977, (May):153-186.
    [166]Olshavsky, Richard W. and John A. Miller, "Consumer Expectations, Product Performance, and Perceived Product Quality,"[J] Journal of Marketing Research,1972,IX(Feb), p19-21
    [167]Swan, John E. and I. Frederick Trawick, "Disconfirmation of Expectations and Satisfaction with a Retail Service",[J].Journal of Retailing,1981,57(Fall), p49-67
    [168]Bearden, William O. and Jesse E. Teel, Selected Determinants of Consumer Satisfaction and Complaint Reports,[J] Journal of Marketing Research,1983, XX(Feb), p21-28
    [169]Anderson, Eugene W., Claes Fornell, and Donald R. Lehmann. Customer Satisfaction, Market Share, and Profitability:Findings From Sweden[J] Journal of Marketing,1994,58:53-66
    [170]Johnson M. D., Fornell C. A Framework for comparing Customer Satisfaction across Individuals and Product Categories[J]. Journal of Consumer Research,1991,17(12):267-286
    [171]Johnson, M. D., Anderson, E. W. and Fornell, C..Rational and adaptive performance expectations in a customer satisfaction framework[J]. Journal of consumer Research, 1995,21(4):695-707.
    [172]Churchill, Gilbert A., JR., and Carol Surprenant, An Investigation Into the Determinants of Customer Satisfaction, [J] Journal of Marketing Research,1982, ⅩⅨ(Nov), p491-504
    [173]Oliver, Richard L., and Wayne Desarbo, Response Determinants in Satisfaction Judgments, [J] Journal of Consumer Research,1988, Vol.14 (March), p495-507
    [174]Anderson, Eugene W., Fornel, Cales & Lehmann, Donald R.Customer Satisfaction,Market Share and Profitability:Findings from Sweden [J] Journal of Marketing,1994,58:53-66.
    [175]Parasuraman, A., V. A. Zeitheaml, and L.L. Berry, RESSESSMENT OF Expectations as a Comparision Standard in Messuring Service Quality:Implications for Further Research,[J]Journal of Marketing,1994,Vol.58(Jan), p111-124.
    [176]GS.Sureshehandar,Chandrasekharn Rajendran, R. N. Anantharaman. The relationship between service quality and customer satisfaction. [J]. Journal of Marketing.Vol6.No.4.1998 p363-379.
    [177]Oliver, Richard L., Cognitive, Affective and Attribute Bases of the Satisfaction Response.[J].Journal of Consumer Satisfaction,1994,20(Dec), p418-430
    [178]Cronin, J.J., Jr.& Taylor S.A., Measuring Service Quality:A reexamination and Extension, Journal of Marketing,1992,Vol.56, pp.55-68
    [179]Brenda M. Oldfield,Steve Baron. Student perceptions of service quality in a UK university business and management faculty. Quality Assurance in Education. Volume 8 Number 22000 pp.85-95.
    [180]Firdaus Abdullah. HEdPERF versus SERVPERF:The quest for ideal measuring instrument of service quality in higher edueation seetor.Quality Assurance in Eduecation,Vol.13 No.4,2005, pp.305-328.
    [181]Elizabeth Anderson. High tech v. high touch:a case study of TQM implementation in higher edueation Managing, Serviee Quality, Volume 05 Number 21995 pp.48-56.
    [182]Mohammad S. Owlia. Elaine M. Aspinwall, A framework for the dimensions of quality in higher education Quality Assurance in Edueation, Volume 4 Number 21996 pp.12-20.
    [183]Adee Athiyaman. Perceived service quality in the higher education sector:An empirical analysis, ANZMAC 2000 Visionary Marketing for the 21st Century:Facing the Challenge, p50-55.
    [184]Paula Y. K. Kwan, Application of total quality management in edueation:retrospect and prospect, International Journal of Educational Management, Volume 10 Number 5 1996 pp.25~ 35.
    [185]Lagrosen S, Hashemi R. S and Leitner M. Examination of the dimensions of quality in higher education[J]. Quality Assurance in Education Volume12 Number2.2004. pp.61-69.
    [186]Zeithaml, V.A.(1988), Consumer perceptions of price,quality and value:a means-and model and synthesis of evidence, Journal of Marketing,52, pp.2-22.
    [187]Monroe, K.B(1991), Pricing-Making Profitable Decisions, McGraw-Hill, Newyork, NY.
    [188](Dodds,W.B, Monroe, K.B., Grewal, D(1991), Efects of Price, brand, and store information on buyers Produet evaluations. Journal of Marketing Researeh,28, pp.307-319.)
    [189]Bolton, R.N. and Drew, J.H.(1991), Amultistage model of eustomers'assessment of service quality and value, Journal of Consumer Researeh, Vol.17 No.4, pp.375-84.
    [190]Jayanti, R.K., Ghosh,A.K(1996), Service value determination:an integrative Perspective.Journal of Hospitality & Leisure Marketing.Vol.3, No.4, pp.5-25.
    [191]科特勒P.市场营销管理[M].卢泰宏,高辉,译.北京:中国人民大学出版社,2000.
    [192]龙献忠.高等教育工具价值的探讨.现代教育科学[J].2003(6):77-79.
    [193]侯定凯.高等教育价值与高等教育公平和效率.高等教育研究[J].1998(4):31-32.
    [194]Fornell C, Johnson M D, and Erson E W,et al.The American Customer Satisfaction Index, Nature, Purpose and Findings[J].Journal of Market-ing,1996,60(4):7-18.
    [195]Michael D, Johnson A G, Tor W A,et al. The Evolution and Future of Nation Customer Satisfaction Index Models[J].Journal of Economic Psychology,2001,22(2):p217-245.
    [196]Gordon H.G McDougall, TerreneeLeveXue(2000), Customer satisfaetion with serviees:Putting Pereeived value into the equation.The Journal of services Marketing. Vol.14, PP.392.
    [197]李东进,杨凯,周荣海.消费者重复购买意向及其影响因素的实证研究[J].管理学报,2007,4(5):p654-659.
    [198]Oliver, Richard L., Satisfaction:A Behavioral Perspective on the Consumer, New York, NY: Irwin-McGraw-Hill,1997,24
    [199]Ko de Ruyter, Jose Ae Bloemer, Customer loyalty in extended service settings:The interaction between satisfaction, value attainment and Positive mood, International Journal of service industry Management,, Vol.10 No.3,1999, pp.320-336.)
    [200]Lanee A. Betteneourt, Customer Voluntary Performance:Customers As Partners In Service Delivery, Journal of Retailing,1997, Volume73(3), PP.383-406.)
    [201]Pratibha A Dabholkar, C. David Shepherd, Dayle l.'Thorpe. A ComPrehensive Framework for Service Quality An Investigation of Critical Conceptual and Measurement Issues Through a Longitudinal Study. Journal of Retailing, olume76(2) pp.139-173.)
    [202]J.Josephy Cronin, JR, Mieheal K.Brady, G Tomas M. Hult. Assessing the Effeets of Quality, Value, and Customer Satisfaction Consumer Behavioral Intentions in Service Environments. Journal of Retailing, Volume 76(2)pp.2000193-18.
    [203]Michael K. Brady. Christopher J Robertson, J Joseph Cronin Jr. Managing behavioral intentions in diverse cultural environments.an investigation of service quality, service value, and satisfaction for Ameriean and Ecuadorian fast-food customers. Journal of International Management.7(2001). pp.129-149
    [204]Hirschman A O. Exit, Voice, and Loyalty:Re-sponses to Decline in Firms, Organizations, and States [M]. Cambridge, Mass:Harvard University Press,1970. (1)
    [205]Cronin,J.J.and Taylor,S.A..Measuring service quality:a reexamination and extension[J].Journal of Marketing,1992,56:55-68
    [206]Andreassen,T.W..Antecedents to satisfaction with service recovery [J]. European Journal of Marketing,2000,34(1/2):156-175.
    [207]Claes Fornell,刘金兰.顾客满意度与ACSI[M]天津:天津大学出版社,2006.
    [208]Day, Ralph. L., And E. Larid Landon, "Toward a Theory of Consumer Complaining Behavior", in Consumer and Industrial Buying Behavior, A.G Woodside, J.N. Sheth, and P.D. Bennett, eds. New York:North-Holland,1977,:p425-437.
    [209]Dich, Alan S.,and Kunal Basu.Customer Loyalty:Toward an Integrated Conceptual Framework[J]. Journal of Academy of Marketing Science,1994,22 (2):100
    [210]欧阳河.学生评价高等教育服务质量实证研究—以湖南高校2008届毕业生满意度调查为例,现代大学教育[J],2008(6)p31-34
    [211]霍映宝.《CSI模型构建及其参数的GME的综合估计研究》南京理工大学学位论文,2004年
    [212]James F. Petriek(2002), Development of amulti-dimensional scale for measuring the perceived value of a serviee.Joumal of Leisure Researeh,34(2)pp123-134).
    [213]廖颖林.顾客满意度指数测评方法及其应用研究,上海财经大学出版社,2008.4p49-50)
    [214]Wittink D,L Bayer. Statistical Analysis of Customer Satisfaction Date:Results from a Natural Experiment with Measurement Scales.Working Paper 94-04,Cornell University Johnson Graduate School of Management.
    [215]Derek R.Allen, Morris Wilburn.Linking Customer and Employee Satisfaction to the Bottom line[M].ASQ Quality Press,2002.
    [216]金勇进.满意度评估系统应用研究[M],中国统计出版社,2007.7,p166
    [217]Chin, Wynne W., "Partial Least Squares is to LISREL as Principal Components Analysis is to Common Factor Analysis, "Technology Studies,1995,2, p315-319
    [218]Joreskog, K.G, and Herman Word "The ML and PLS Techniques for Modeling with Latent Variable:Historical and Comparative Aspects,"In K.G. Joreskog and H.Word eds.,Systems under Indirect Observation:Causality, Structure, Prediction, Vol.1,Amsterdam,North-Holland, 1982,P263-270
    [219]Bollen,K.A.,Structural Equations with Latent Variables[M].New York:Wiley-Interscience,1989.
    [220]Little, R., A. and Rubin, D.B.(2002)"Statistical analysis with missing data."John Wiley & Sons, Inc, Hoboken,New Jersey.
    [221]Michel Tenenhaus,Vincenzo Esposito Vinzi,Yves-Marie Chatelin,Carlo Lauro. PLS path modeling[J].Computational Statistics & Data Analysis,2005,48:159-205
    [222]数据的统计处理和解释——正态性检验GB/T4882-2001 idt IS05479:1997
    [223]Bollen K A, Long J S. Testing structural equation models[M]. Sage Publications,Inc,1993.
    [224]Scott, James, and Peter Wright, "Modeling and Oraganization Buyer's Product Evaluation Strategy, "Journal of Marketing Research,1976,13 (Aug),p211-224)
    [225]Wold, Herman,"Partial least squares",in Samuel Kotz& Norman L. Johnson(Eds.),Encyclopedia of Statistical Sciences[M],Vol.6,New York:John Wiley & Sone,1985,581-591
    [226]Wold, Herman,"Partial least squares",in Samuel Kotz& Norman L. Johnson(Eds.),Encyclopedia of Statistical Sciences[M],Vol.6,New York:John Wiley & Sone,1985,581-591
    [227]Kline R B.(1998).Principles and Practice of Structural Equation Modeling[M].New York:The Guilford Press.
    [228]Lederer A. and Sethi V. Critical Dimension of strategic information systems planning [J] Decision Sciences 1991,2 (4):104-119
    [229]梁燕,金勇进.顾客满意度模型的样本量研究[J].统计研究,2007,7:68-74
    [230]张新安,田澎.上海顾客满意度指数模型及其稳健性研究[J].管理工程学报,2005,19(3):47-51
    [231]张新安、田澎.顾客满意度线性建模中多重共线性处理方法的模拟研究[J],工业工程与管理,2004(4):73-77
    [232]Kaiser H.F. The Varimax Criterion for Analytic Rotation on Factor Analysis [J]. Psyehometrika, 1960,15(6):189-203.
    [233]金勇进,邵军.缺失数据的统计处理[M],中国统计出版社,2009,p20-114
    [234]Little, R., A. and Rubin, D.B.(2002)"Statistical analysis with missing data."John Wiley & Sons, Inc, Hoboken,New Jersey.
    [235]李洪成.数据的正态性检验方法及其统计软件实现[J],统计与决策,2009(12)p155-156
    [236]吴鹏.大众高等教官质量观的市场价值取向—合理性及其局限[J],江苏高教,2005(4)p37-39
    [237]宣勇.大学内部管理体制改革的价值取向[J],浙江社会科学,2005(5)p81-84
    [238]傅宝英.高等教育质量标准的价值取向与维度分析[J],现代教育科学,2005(1)P20-22
    [239]Word Declaration on Higher Education in the Twenty-first Century:Vision and Action. Adopted by the World Conference on Higher Education.http://www.unesco.org/education/educorog/ wche/declaration.eng.htm.2003-10-09
    [240]龚放.高等教育多样化与质量观的重构[J],中国高等教育,2001(22),p25-27

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700