用户名: 密码: 验证码:
农村信用社治理机制及治理效率研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
农村信用社在我国从20世纪50年代初诞生至今,历经半个多世纪的风雨,虽数经改革,但成效不大。目前农村信用社以股份合作制形式存在,虽然有些已改制为农村合作银行和农村商业银行,但产权不清、内部治理机制弱化、外部治理机制缺失的问题一直没有得到真正解决。尤其是“内部人控制”现象严重,权力缺乏制衡,由此而建立的社员大会、理事会、监事会形同虚设,管理层完全操控了农村信用社,无法形成有效的激励监督机制,单纯依靠形式上的内部治理结构的改善,无法解决其高昂的代理成本与治理机制的缺陷问题。
     本文主要以委托代理理论为基础,从农村信用社制度变迁出发,剖析了农村信用社特殊的双重委托代理关系;从农村信用社双重委托代理的视角,揭示了农村信用社产权不够明晰、主体虚置和内部人控制严重等内部治理机制的缺陷,阐释了所有权和经营权分离条件下的信息不对称与合约不完全是农村信用社滋生“内部人控制”治理风险产生的根源。为了解决农村信用社公司治理机制的深层次问题,本文尝试使用“预先承诺制”,较好的解决了各利益相关者与农村信用社及信用社主任之间的目标冲突。
     其次,从治理效率最优化过程分析入手,探索了建立在不完备产权契约理论基础上的农村信用社治理结构的动态均衡与优化,并系统研究了利益相关者共同治理模式下的农村信用社内部治理优化机制。在对农村信用社内部治理效益与治理成本重新界定的基础上,提出了基于成本与收益视角的农村信用社最优内部治理效率标准,为其合理配置股权结构和提高治理效率提供了有益的参考。同时,尝试以AHP法在构建农村信用社内部治理评价指标体系的基础上,运用InternalGovernance-Analytic Network Process(IG-ANP),对山东省各地区农村信用社内部治理能力进行了客观评价。
     最后,从山东省农村信用社内部治理结构特征分析入手,揭示了农村信用社内部治理结构与经营业绩的内在联系。选取能够反映山东省农村信用社总体水平的主要指标,在对各市经营状况进行因子分析的基础上,采用统计分析软件SPSS,运用聚类分析方法对17个市的发展水平进行了综合评价,并从明晰产权归属、优化股权结构、完善制衡机制等方面,探索了在国家新的改革政策环境中,信用社内部治理机制优化和治理效率提高的可行途径,为解决信用社产权主体虚置和“内部人控制”问题提供了有力的支撑。
Born from the early 1950s,rural credit cooperatives in China have reached limited success,even though they have suffered a lot for more than half a century.Up to now,rural credit cooperatives set up in the form of joint-stock cooperative system. Although some have reformed into rural cooperative banks,the problems like unclear property rights,weaken the internal governance,external governance mechanisms for the issue of missing has not been solved at all.
     Especially for the serious phenomenon of "internal control" and the lack of balance in power in rural credit cooperatives,the formerly established members of the General Assembly,the Council,and the board of supervisors exist in name only,and the managers of rural credit cooperatives have full control over the rural credit cooperatives,which can not stimulate the formation of an effective incentive mechanism.To rely solely on the improvement of the formal structure of internal governance can not solve the high agents cost and the defects of governance mechanisms in rural credit cooperatives.
     Starting from the transition of system in rural credit cooperatives,the principle-agency theory has been mainly utilized,and the special double agency relationship of rural credit cooperatives was analyzed.Meanwhile,the serious deficiencies in internal control mechanisms such as the lack of clear property rights and the main and severe internal control have been fully revealed.That demonstrated that it is the asymmetric information and incomplete contract under the separation of ownership and the right to operate that is the root of the insider-control risk.To solve this deep rooted problem,this paper tries to use the term "pre-commitment approach" as a better solution for the conflict between all stakeholders and Rural Credit Cooperatives and all directors.
     In addition,based on the process of governance efficiency optimization,the dynamic balance and optimization of the rural credit cooperatives based on incomplete contract theory has been explored and the optimizing mechanism of internal governance under model of co-governance of all stakeholders was systematically studied.Besides,on the basis of redefining internal governance efficiency and governance costs,this paper comes up with criteria for optimal internal governance efficiency from the perspective of cost and revenue,acting as helpful reference for rational allocation and the improvement of Rural Credit Cooperatives' governance efficiency.Meanwhile,trying to apply AHP to the construction of Rural Credit Cooperatives' internal governance criteria system,the paper aims at carrying out objective evaluation over the internal governance capability of all Rural Credit Cooperatives around Shandong Province based on the use of IG-ANP.
     Finally,starting from analyzing the structure characteristics of Shandong Rural Credit Cooperatives' internal governance,the artical revealed the internal relationship between internal governance structure and business achievement,able to select the indicators which reflect the overall level of Shandong Rural Credit Cooperatives, and based on the analysis of all operation factors and the statistical analysis software SPSS,conducted a comprehensive evaluation for 17 city-level Rural Credit Cooperatives' developing condition using the method of cluster analysis,as well as explored possible channels for Rural Credit Cooperatives to enhance internal governance mechanism and governance efficiency under new national reforming environment,in terms of identifying the property rights,optimizing the equity structure,improving the balance mechanism and etc.which provides powerful support for the solution of virtual property and "insider control" in Rural Credit Cooperatives.
引文
[1]袁江天,张维.多任务委托代理模型下国企经理激励问题研究[J].管理科学学报,2006,9(3):45-53.
    [2]Taussings F W,Baker W S.American corporations and their executives:A statistical inquiry [J].Quarterly Journal of Ecomomics,1925,(3):1-51.
    [3]张正堂,陶学禹.国外企业经营者报酬理论研究的新进展[J].管理科学学报,2002,5(6):83-90.
    [4]Alchian A A,Demsetz H.Production,informationcost,and economic organization[J].American Economic Review,1972,(62):777-795.
    [5]Holmstrom B.Moral hazard and observability[J].Bell Journal of Economics,1979,(10):74-91.
    [6]Coase R H.The nature of the firm[J].Economica,1937,(4):386-405.
    [7]周其仁.市场里的企业:一个人力资本与物质资本的特殊契约[J].经济研究,1996,(6):71-79.
    [8]周其仁.“控制权回报”与“企业家控制的企业”[J].经济研究,1997,(6):31-42.
    [9]席酉民,张建琦.不对等契约关系与国有企业改革[J].管理科学学报,1998,(1):43-49.
    [10]张维迎.产权安排与企业内部的权利斗争[J].经济研究,2000,(6):41-50.
    [11]张维迎.博奕论与信息经济学[M].上海:上海三联书店,上海人民出版社,1996:258.
    [12]Holmstrom B,Milgrom P.Aggregation and linearity in the provision of intertemporal incentives[J].Econometrica,1987,55(2):303-328.
    [13]Holmstrom B,Milgrom P.Multi-task principal-agent analyses:Incentive contracts,asset ownership and job design[J].Journal of Law,Economics and Organization,1991,(7):24-52.
    [14]严建苗,万建军.国有企业间经理人市场的声誉机制分析[J].数量经济技术经济研究,2002,(3):36-39.
    [15]李成,王菁.构建预先承诺制的激励相容监管机制的思考[J].金融教学与研究,2004,(5):2-5.
    [16]Considine.Jill,Daripan.Arupratan,etc."Incentive Compatible Regulation:Views on the Pre-commitment Approach"[J].Economic Policy Review(Federal Reserve Bank of New York),1998,(10):24-45.
    [17]Prescott.Edward S,"the Pre-commitment Approach in a model of regulation"[J].Economic quarterly(Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond),1997,(11):124-135.
    [18]Kupiec.P.and J.O.Brien."the Pre-commitment Approach:Using Incentive to Set Market Risk Capital Requirements"[J].Federal Reserve Board Finance Economics Discussion Series,1997,(3):45-56.
    [19]杜传忠.激励规制理论研究综述[J].经济学动态,2003,(2):2-9.
    [20]陈建梁,赵永伟.银行监管理论的最新发展[J].国际金融研究,1999,(9):14-18.
    [21]郑超愚,蔡浩仪,徐忠.外部性、不确定性、非对称信息与金融监管[J].经济研究,2000,(9):67-73.
    [22]冯根福.双重委托代理理论:上市公司治理的另一种分析框架[J].经济研究,2004,(12):16-25.
    [23]冯根福,韩冰,闫冰.中国上市公司股权集中度变动的实证分析[J].经济研究,2002(8):12-18.
    [24]张维迎.博弈论与信息经济学[M].上海:上海三联出版社,1996.
    [25]蒋海.金融监管中的激励冲突与调整[J].财经研究,2004,(1):50-60.
    [26]陈珠明,陈建梁.对金融机构资本监管的激励相容机制—预先承诺制的信息经济学分析[J].经济科学,2001,(3):41-48.
    [27]Benjamin E.Hermalin & Michael S.Weisbach "The Determinants of Board Composition"[J].Rand Journal of Economics,1988,19(4):241-251.
    [28]冯根福,闫冰.公司股权的“市场结构”类型与股东治理行为[J].中国工业经济,2004,(6):85-92.
    [29]冯根福.关于健全和完善我国上市公司治理结构几个关键问题的思考[J].当代经济科学,2001,(1)23-28.
    [30]青木昌彦.公司治理的比较制度分析[J].公司治理中外比较,2002,(4):2-11.
    [31]孙永祥.公司治理结构:理论与实证研究[M].上海三联书店,上海人民出版社,2002.
    [32]唐宗明,蒋位.中国上市公司大股东侵害度实证分析[J].经济研究,2002(4):44-50.
    [33]泰勒尔.产业组织理论[M].北京中国人民大学出版社,1997.
    [34]因内恩·马克—斯达德勒,丁·大卫·佩雷斯—卡斯特里罗.信息经济学引论:激励与合约[M].上海财经大学出版社,2004.
    [35]郑红亮.公司治理理论与中国国有企业改革[J].经济研究,1998(10):20-27.
    [36]Coase,Ronald.The Nature of the Firm[J].Economics,1937,4:386-405.
    [37]Claessens,S.,S.Djan kovand L.H.P.Lang.The Separation of Ownership and Control in East Asian Corporations[J].Journal of Financial Economics,2000,(58):81-112.
    [38]Faccio,M.and L.H.P.Lang."The Ultimate Ownership of Western European Corporations [J].Journal of Financial Economics,2002,(65):365-396.
    [39]Fama,Eugence,Michael Jensen.Separation of Ownership and Control[J].Journal of Law and Economics,1983,(26):301-325.
    [40]Fama,Eugence,and Michael Jensen.Agency Problems and Residuals Claims[J].Journal of Law and Economics,1983,(26):327-349.
    [41]张金昌.公司治理结构及其效率的国际比较[J].中国经贸导刊,2003,(19):29-31.
    [42]Rajan,Raghuram.Insiders and Outsiders:the Choice between Relationship and Arms-length Debt[J].Journal of Finance,1992,(47):1367-1400.
    [43]Shleifer,A,&Vishy,R.W.A Survey of Corporate Governance[J].Journal of Finance,1997,(52):737-783.
    [44]Vives,Xavier.Corporate Governance:Does It Matter? In Vives,Xavier(Eds)[J].Corporate Governance,2001,(12):1-22.
    [45]Weinstein,David E.and Yishay Yafeh.On the Costs of a Bank-centered Financial System:Evidence from the Changing Main Bank Relations in Japan[J].Manuscript Harvard University,2000,(123):223-254.
    [46]张维迎.博弈论与信息经济学[M].上海人民出版社,1996.
    [47]李维安.中国公司治理原则与国际比较[M].中国财政经济出版社,2001.
    [48]马忠富.中国农村合作金融发展研究[M].中国金融出版社,2001.
    [49]奥立弗·E·威廉森著.治理机制[M].北京:中国社会科学出版社,2001.
    [50]于海.中外农业金融制度比较研究[M].中国金融出版社,2003.
    [51]何广文.合作金融发展模式及运行机制研究[M].中国金融出版社,2001
    [52]张元红、李静、张军.农村金融转型与创新—关于合作基金会的思考[M].山西经济出版社,2002.
    [53]孙永祥.公司治理结构:理论与实践[M].上海三联书店,2002.
    [54]郑德程,沈华珊,张晓顺.股权结构的理论、实践与创新[M].经济科学出版,2003.
    [55]潘敏.资本结构、金融契约与公司治理[M].中国金融出版,2002.
    [56]徐茂魁.现代公司制度概论[M].中国人民大学出版社,2001.
    [57]李维安.公司治理[M].南开大学出版社,2001.
    [58]梁能.公司治理结构:中国的实践与美国的经验[M].中国人民大学出版社,2000.
    [59]何安耐,胡必亮.农村金融与发展[M].经济科学出版社,2000.
    [60]李树生.农村经济发展与农村金融市场化研究[M].中国金融出版社,1999.
    [61]周小川,王林,肖梦等.企业改革:模式选择与配套设计[M].中国经济出版社,1994.
    [62]北京经济法学会.公司治理结构的理论与实践[M].机械工业出版社,2004.
    [63]玛格丽特·M·布莱尔.所有权与控制:面向21世纪的公司治理探索[M](中译本).中国社会科学出版社,1999.
    [64]孙经纬.董事会的结构、职能与效率.现代企业研究[J].2000,(2):3-6.
    [65]道格拉斯·C·诺思.经济史中的结构与变迁[M].上海人民出版,1994.
    [66]R·科斯、A·阿尔钦、D·诺思等.财产权利与制度变迁—产权学派与新制度学派译文集[M](中译本).上海人民出版社,1994.
    [67]屠光绍、朱从玖主编.公司治理:国际经验与中国实践[M].人民出版社,2001.
    [68]谢德仁.企业剩余索取权:分享安排与剩余计量[M].上海人民出版社,2001.
    [69]杨瑞龙,周业安.企业的利益相关者理论及其应用[M].经济科学出版社,2000.
    [70]杨瑞龙主编.企业共同治理的经济学分析[M].经济科学出版社,2001.
    [71]张维迎.产权、政府与信誉[M].北京三联书店,2001.
    [72]玛格丽特·M·布莱尔.共同的所有权[J].经济社会体制比较,1996,(3):37-40
    [73]李维安,曹廷求.商业银行公司治理理论模式与我国的选择[J].南开大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2003,(1)42-50:.
    [74]张旭阳.改进银行业的公司治理结构——国际银行业的实践及对我国银行业的启示[J].国际金融研究,2001,(4):52-58.
    [75]杨瑞龙.论国有经济中的多级委托代理关系[J].管理世界,1997,(1):106-115.
    [76]林国春.博弈论在金融领域的应用述评[J].经济学动态,2001,(12):73-77.
    [77]姜长云.农村金融制度对农业结构调整的不适应性及其制度根源[J].产业经济研究,2003,5:13-19.
    [78]何广文.中国农村金融供求特征及均衡供求的路径选择[J].中国农村经济,2001,(10):40-45.
    [79]何广文.农村信用社制度创新不存在最优模式[J].金融时报,2003,6(9):2-3.
    [80]高帆.我国农村中的需求型金融抑制及其解除[J].中国农村经济,2002,(12):68-72.
    [81]李丹红.农村民间金融发展现状与重点改革政策[J].金融研究,2000,(5):118-125.
    [82]谢平.中国农村信用合作社体制改革的争论[J].金融研究,2001,(1):1-13.
    [83]严谷军,何嗣江.制度扭曲、金融需求与路径选择—发达地区农村信用社的体制创新及发展[J].浙江社会科学,2002,(3):186-190.
    [84]丛正.农村信用社发展问题浅析[J].农业经济,2004,(5):35-36.
    [85]凌涛.探索农村金融改革新思路—也谈我国农村信用合作社体制改革的争论[J].金融研究,2001,(7):60-66.
    [86]李庆旗.民间资本进入银行体系问题探索[J].金融参考,2003,(9):76-81.
    [87]陈雪飞.合作制与股份制—不同经济背景下农村信用社的制度选择[J].金融研 究,2003,(6):115-120.
    [88]李树生.再谈新时期我国合作金融的生存和创新[J].财贸经济,2003,(5):58-61.
    [89]韩俊梅.对农村金融制度创新的思考[J].华南金融研究,2002,(1):15-17.
    [90]王子恢.民间金融发展需要制度空间[J].中国经济时报,2002,12(20):1-3.
    [91]何广文,欧阳海洪.把握农村金融需求特点,完善农村金融服务体系[J].中国金融,2003,(11):14-16.
    [92]吴蕾.中国农村信用合作社改革发展模式探讨[D].西南财经大学,2002.
    [93]宗涛.农村信用社产权改革与农村信用社发展—问题研究[D].西南财经大学,2003.
    [94]刘波.我国农村合作金融改革与发展问题研究[D].华中农业大学,2002.
    [95]袁洪斌.农村合作金融产权制度改革问题及对策研究[D].西南农业大学,2002.
    [96]蔡瑶.发达地区农村信用社产权改革研究[D].浙江大学,2003.
    [97]谢安.我国农村信用合作社的制度变迁[D].湖南农业大学,2001.
    [98]中秀文.欠发达地区农村信用社改革探索[D].厦门大学,2002
    [99]詹向阳.银行风险控制应强化治理结构和信用制度建设[J].商业银行,2005,(6):39.
    [100]罗南旺.论我国农村信用合作社改革与发展方向[D].湖南大学,2001.
    [101]戴可嘉.从法人治理结构到法人治理——浅析防范和化解农村信用社金融风险的途径[J].河南金融管理干部学院学报,2004,(6):98-99.
    [102]胡舜.金融企业的公司治理结构与体制性风险防范[J].湖南财经高等专科学校学报,2005,21(2):20-22.
    [103]王慧卿,郭春松.从新制度经济学视角探讨我国农村信用社体制改革[J].武汉金融,2004,(11):18-20.
    [104]何问陶,蒋海.农村信用社产权制度改革与组织制度选择[J].金融研究,2000,(11):78-83.
    [105]费方域.什么是公司治理[J].上海经济研究,1996,(5):36-39.
    [106]张春霖.存在道德风险的委托代理关系:理论分析及其应用中的问题[J].经济研究,1995,(8):3-8.
    [107]费方域.董事和董事会的结构[J].上海经济研究,1996,(11):37-40.
    [108]费方域.谁拥有企业:股东还是利益相关者?[J].上海经济研究,1996,(9):46-48.
    [109]何卫东.论非执行董事对公司战略的参与[J].南开管理评论,1999,(4):20-22.
    [110]杨瑞龙,周业安.论利益相关者合作逻辑下的企业共同治理机制[J].中国工业经济,1998,(1):38-45.
    [111]刘伟团.委托—代理下的不确定性决策研究[D].西安理工大学,2007.
    [112]熊鹏,郑权.中国农村信用社组织结构研究:委托代理的解释[J].兰州商学院学报,2005,(4):1-3.
    [113]Beasley,M.S.An empirical analysis of the relation between the board of director composition and financial statement fraud[J].The Accounting Review 1996,71(10):443-465.
    [114]陈敏,杜才明.委托代理理论述评[J].中国农业银行武汉培训学院学报,2006,(6):76-78.
    [115]王大林,张敏军.农村信用社委托代理关系问题探讨[J].南方金融,2007,(6):30-32.
    [116]Amason,A.,Sapienza,H."The effects of Top Management Team Size and Interaction Norms on Cognitive and Affective Conflict"[J].Journal of Management,1997,23:495-516.
    [117]Baysinger,B.and H.Butler,Corporate Governance and the Board of Directors."Performance Effects of Changes in Board Composition"[J].Journal of Law,Economics and Organizationl,1985:101-124.
    [118]钟怀宇.从契约理论看公司治理结构优化与资本结构优化[J].经济师,2004,(4):26-27.
    [119]刘芍佳,李骥.超产权论与企业绩效[J].经济研究,1998,(8):3-12.
    [120]李占猛,杨宏伟.美国公司独立董事制度研究[J].证券市场导报,2000,(3):15-21.
    [121]马连福.公司治理模式趋同代初探[J].南开经济研究,2000,(2):17-21.
    [122]E Philip Davis.Institutional investors,corporate governance and the performance of the corporate sector[J].Economic Systems,2002,(26):203-229.
    [123]Jensen,M.C.Agency costs of free cash flow,corporate finance,and takeovers[J].American Economic Review,1986,76:323-329.
    [124]Myers,S.C.The capital structure puzzle[J].Journal of Finance,1984,39:575-592.
    [125]Andrei Shleifer,Robert W·Vishny.A Survey of Corporate Governance[J].The Journal of Finance,1997,(45):145-156.
    [126]缪仁炳.比较公司治理、演化趋势及其意义[J].改革,2000,(1):20-22.
    [127]王跃生.国际企业制度创新与企业理论的发展[J].经济社会体制比较,2001,(6):83-90.
    [128]夏冬林,钱苹.‘搭便车'与公司治理结构中股东行为的分析[J].经济科学,2000,(4):14-20.
    [129]郑红亮.荷兰企业的治理结构问题透析[J].经济学动态,1999,(1):77-78.
    [130]朱武祥.一股独大与股权多元化[J].上市公司,2001,(3):16-22
    [131]黎志成,侯锡林.简评管理学中的激励理论,科技进步与对策[J].2003,(12):182-184.
    [132]郭马兵.激励理论评述,首都经济贸易大学学报[J].2002,(6):37-39.
    [133]李永平.中国农村金融制度变迁与经济主体行为研究[D].:山东大学,2006.
    [134]徐东红.中国农村金融改革的路径依赖与政策分析[D].内蒙古农业大学,2005.
    [135]IFAD.Rural Financial Services in China[J].Thematic Study Report,2001,88(20):88-91.
    [136]刘继新.我国农村信用合作社管理体制的缺陷及其治理[D].中南大学,2004.
    [137]胡涛,查元桑.委托代理理论及其新的发展方向之一[J].财经理论与实践,2002,(13):41-43.
    [138]朱欣.委托代理理论和我国国有企业代理人的约束激励问题研究[D].湖南大学,2001.
    [139]向荣,贾生华.对代理理论的综述与反思[J].商业经济与管,2001,(8):17-21.
    [140]汪贤裕,颜锦江.委托代理关系中的激励和监督[J].中国管理科学,2000,(3):30-34.
    [141]赵世君.从激励与约束的关系角度看经营者激励约束问题[J].统计与决策,2005,(10):56-57.
    [142]李维安,武立东.公司治理教程[M].上海:上海人民出版社,2002.
    [143]秦汉锋.从委托代理的角度看农村信用社法人治理结构的缺陷[J].金融论坛,2003,(7):23-26
    [144]顾秋平.加快建立农村信用社激励机制[J].现代金融,2003,(2):37-39.
    [145]王家传,刘廷伟.农村信用社改革与发展问题研究——山东省农村信用社问卷调查综合分析报告[J].金融研究,2001,(8):23-25.
    [146]李霞.基于平衡计分卡的公司绩效评价研究[D].山东大学,2006.
    [147]刘大伟.完善农村信用社法人治理结构问题研究[D].首都经济贸易大学,2005.
    [148]Hart O,J Tirole.Contract Renegotiation and Coasian Dynamics[J].Review of Economic Studies,1988,55(8):509-540.
    [149]Anderson,D.Francis,J.R.,Stokes,D.J.,Auditing,"Directotships and the Demand for Monitoring"[J].Journal of Accounting and Public Policy,1993,(12):353-375.
    [150]April Klein.Firm performance and board committee structure[J].Journal of Law and Economics,1998,(4):275-303.
    [151]Brickly,J,Coles,J,and Terry,R.Outside directors and the adoption of poison pills[J].Journal of Financial Economics,1994,(34):371-390.
    [152]杨国祥.中国农村信用社产权和法人治理结构之研究[J].改革,2002,(6):7-11.
    [153]张勇,彭洁.对当前农村信用社法人治理结构架构之探析[J].经济研究参考,2007,(4):24-25.
    [154]李建华.论农村信用社法人治理结构的缺陷与改造,金融参考,2001,(2):8-12.
    [155]SugiharaK,IshiiH,TanakaH.Fuzzy AHP with Incomplete Information[J].IFSA World Congress and 20~(th) NAFIPS International Conference,2001,(5):2730-2733.
    [156]赖胜强.试论内部市场化管理模式的激励相容约束机制[J].攀枝花学院学报,2005,(6):15-18.
    [157]Trond Randoy and Jan Inge Jenssen.Board independence and product market competition in Swedish firms[J].Blackwell Publishing Lid,2004,(45):144-154.
    [158]丁家美,邹爱平,金松.如何构建农村信用社激励机制[J].现代金融,2004,(8):21-24.
    [159]Vincent A.W.Board Effectiveness and Board Dissent.A Model of the Board's Relationship to Management and Shareholders[J].Journal of Corporate Finance,1998,(4):53-70.
    [160]The Uncertain Relationship Between Board Composition and Firm Performance [J].Bussiness Lawyer,1999,(54):921-963.
    [161]Borokhvich,Parmo and Trapani.Outside directors and CEO selection[J].Journal of Financial and Quantitative Anaalysis,1996,(9):337-355.
    [162]Cotter,J,Ahivadasani,A,and Zenner,M.Do independent directors enhance target share-holder wealth during tender offers[J].Journal of Financial Economics,1997,43:195-218.
    [163]张守凤.完善农信社法人治理的对策修正[J].中国信用合作,2006,(12):44-45.
    [164]万大为.国有商业银行治理结构问题研究[D].辽宁大学,2006.
    [165]McAfee,R.and J McMillan.Optimal Contracts for Teams[J].International Economic Review,1991,32(12):561-577.
    [166]Bhagat,Sanjai and Bermard Black.The non-correlation between board independence and long-term firm performance[J].Journal of Corporation Law,2002,27(2):12-23.
    [167]Brickley,J.James.The Takeover Market,Corporate BOARD Composition and Ownership Structure[J].Journal of Law and Economics,1987,(80):161-181.
    [168]盖路.农村信用社产权制度与内部治理结构问题研究[D].西安交通大学,2003.
    [169]Kesner,I.,Johnson,R.An Investigation of the Relationship Between Board Composition and Stockholder Suits[J].Strategic Management Journal,1990,11:327-336.
    [170]Mark S.Beasley.An Empirical Analysis of the Relation Between the Board of Director Composition and Financial Statement Fraud[J].The Accounting Review,1996,71(4):443-465.
    [171]崔新民.我国农村信用社体制改革与发展研究[D].郑州大学,2002.
    [172]Joel sobel.Information Control in the Principle-Agent Problem[J].International Economic Review,1993,34(2):109-111.
    [173]Holmstrom,B.Moral Hazard in Team[J].Bell Journal of Economics,1982,(13):324-340.
    [174]王树娟,霍学喜,何学松.农村信用社农民信用综合评价模型[J].财贸研究,2005,(5):35-39.
    [175]张运鹏.事先承诺制的再思考[J].CCER学刊,2003,(1):53-58.
    [176]Benjamin E.Hermalin and Michael S.Weisbach[J].Board of Directors As An Endogenously Determined Institution,1999,(41):14-45.
    [177]A Survey of The Economic Literature",NBER Working Paper 8186,http.//www.nber.org/papers/w8186.Bhagat and Black.
    [178]Chinmoy Ghosh and C.F.Sirmans.Board independence,ownership structure and performance,evidence from real estate investment trusts[J].Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics,2003,(78):45-75.
    [179]乐山银监分局课题组.农村信用社内部控制问题研究,西南金融,2006,(3):40-43.
    [180]Sahlman.The Structure and Governance of Venture Capital Organization[J].Journal of Financial Economics,1990,27:473-521.
    [181]Fama.E.Agency problem and the theory of the firm[J].Journal of Political Economy,1980,(2):288-307.
    [182]Dezoort,F.T,and S.Salterio.The Effects of Corporate Governance Experience and Audit Knowledge on Audit Committee Members 'Judgments",Auditing[J].A Journal of Practice &Theory(Forthcoming),2001,(8):15-45.
    [183]Daily,C.Schwenk,C.Top Management Teams and Board of Directors Congruent or Countervailing Forces?[J].Journal of Management,1996,(22):185-208.
    [184]Edward E.Gill,George S.B,David L.F.,and Jay A.C.Corporate Boards.Key s to Effectiveness[J].Organizational Dynamics,2002,30(4):314-318.
    [185]Eichenseher,J.W.,Shields,D.Corporate Drector Lability and Monitoring Peferences[J].Journal of Accounting and Public Policy,1985,4:13-31.
    [186]Fama,E.F.Aency pblems and the theory of the firm[J].Journal of Political Economy,1980,(88):134-145.
    [187]Gilson,S.C.,Bankruptcy.Boards,Banks,and Block-holders.Evidence on Changes in Corporate Ownership and Control when Firms Default[J].Journal of Financial Economics,1990,27:355-388.
    [188]Hermallin,Benjamin and Michael Weisbach.Boards of directors as an endogenously determined institution[J],a survey of the economic literature,2001,(2):12-23.
    [189]Hermalin,B.E.,and M.S.Weisbach.Endogenously Chosen Boards of Directors and their Monitoring of the CEO[J].American Economic Review,1998,88:96-118.
    [190]Jongmoo Jay Choi,Sae Woon Park,Sehyun Yoo.Do Outside directors enhance firm performance[J].Evidence from an emerging market,2004,(8):45-75.
    [191]Kose,J.and Lemma W.S.Corporate Governance and Board Effectiveness[J].Journal of Banking and Finance,1998,22:371-403.
    [192]K.Raghunandan,WilliamJ.Read,and Dasaratha V.Rama.Audit Committee Composition,Gray Directors,and Interaction with Internal Auditing[J].Accounting Horizons,2001,15(2):105-118.
    [193]Mark.Y.T.and Routh M.L.Factors Affecting the Characteristics of Boards of Directors[J].Journal of Business Research,2000,(47):62-78.
    [194]Shleifer,Andrei and Robert W.Vishny.A survey of corporate governance[J].Journal of Finance,1997,(52):737-830.
    [195]Caprio and Levine.Corporate Governance of Banks Concepts and International Observations[J].World Bank Working Papers,2002,(6):14-45.
    [196]李维安.公司治理学[M].北京:高等教育出版社,2005:89-95.
    [197]王家传,刘廷伟.农村信用社改革与发展问题研究——山东省农村信用社问卷调查综合分析报告[J].金融研究,2001,(8):23-25.
    [198]张天阳,李丹.论产权制度与公司治理[J].会计之友,2008,(1):20-21.
    [199]吕斐适,吴德胜.公司治理变革中的治理成本研究[J].江汉论坛,2006,(12):27-29.
    [200]Hart.o.Corporate Governance.Some Theory and Implication[J].The Economic Joural,1995,(3):45-75.
    [201]Hart.o.Firm's Contracts and Financial Structure[J].Oxford university press,1996:89-123.
    [202]刘远方.QD建设银行内部控制机制评价及对策研究[D].西安交通大学,2003.
    [203]何德见.论公司治理与内部控制[D].财政部财政科学研究所,2004.
    [204]Mishra,D.P.,Heide,J.B.,Cort,S.G.Information Asymmetry and Levels of Agency Relationships[J].Journal of Marketing Research,1998,35(3):277-295.
    [205]陈继勇.产权契约的不完备性与企业治理效率优化[J].当代经济,2006,(2):57-58.
    [206]Fama,E.Agency Problem and the Theory of the Firm[J].Journal of Political Economy,1980,10(11):54-57.
    [207]Charles J.P.Chen & Bikki Jaggi.Association between Independent Non-executive Directors,Family Control and Financial Disclosures in Hong Kong[J].Journal of Accounting and Public Policy,2000,(6):45-78.
    [208]Collier and Gregory.Audit committee activity and agency costs[J].Journal of Accounting and Public Policy,1999,18(4):311-332.
    [209]Collier,P.A.Factors Affecting the Voluntary Formation of Audit Committees in Major UK Listed Companies[J].Accounting and Business Research,1993,(23):421-430.
    [210]Price Waterhouse Management Consultants Ltd.Corporate Governance in Thailand.a Price Waterhouse study[J].Commissioned by the Stock Exchange of Thailand,1997,(1):14-45.
    [211]刘明.强化农村信用社成本管理探析[J].河南金融管理干部学院学报,2006,(3):137-140.
    [212]桑士俊,吴德胜,吕斐适.公司治理机制与公司治理效率——基于公司治理成本的分析[J].会计研究,2007,(6):83-85.
    [213]Boyd,John H..Expansion of commercial banking powers or universal banking is the cart,not the horse[J].Journal of Banking & Finance,1999,23(2):655-662.
    [214]Perry,T.Incentive Composition for Outside Directors and CEO Turnover[J].Working Paper,2000:123-145.
    [215]Rosenstein,S.Vishny,R.W.Outside Directors,Board Independence and Shareholder Wealth[J].Journal of Financial Economics,1990,(26):175-191.
    [216]Rosenstein,S.Vishny and J.G.Wyatt.Inside Directors,Board Effectiveness and Shareholder Wealth[J].Journal of Financial Economics,1997,(44):299-250.
    [217]John.W.pratt and Richard.J.Zeckauser.Principles and Agents[J].The Structure of Business,1985,(4):45-56.
    [218]Adams R.and H.Mehran.Is Corporate Governance Different for Bank Holding Companies [J].FRBHY,Economic Policy Review,2003,(9):123-142.
    [219]王竹泉,杜嫒.解读利益相关者理论的治理效率困境[J].财会月刊(理论)2006,(1):78-79.
    [220]徐昶,刘小差.国有商业银行公司治理研究——基于利益相关者理论的分析[J].学术交流,2007(7):19-22.
    [221]李维安,曹廷求.商业银行公司治理:理论模式与我国选择[J].南开学报(哲学社会科学版),2003,(1):42-50.
    [222]岳意定,刘思扬.利益相关者的界定与分类在我国农村信用社的应用[J].中南大学学报(社会科学版),2006,12(2):225-230.
    [223]万建华.利益相关者管理[M].深圳:海天出版社,1998:5-8.
    [224]李心合.面向可持续发展的利益相关者管理[J].当代财经,2001,(1):66-70.
    [225]陈宏辉.企业的利益相关者管理与实证研究[D].浙江大学,2003.
    [226]杨瑞龙,周业安.企业的利益相关者理论及其应用[M].北京:经济科学出版社,2000:131.
    [227]Shleifer,A.and S.Singh.Large Shareholders and Corporate Control[J].Journal of Political Economy,1986,94(3):461-488.
    [228]Hart,O.,and Holmstrom,B.,and P.Milgrom.In T.Bewley.Advances in economic theory.Fifth world congress[C].Cambridge University Press,1987,(6):78-98.
    [229]Caprio,G.Jr.L.Laeven and R.Levine.Governance and Bank Valuation[J].NBER Working Paper 2003,(10):158.
    [230]Deangelo,H.and L.Deangelo,Managerial Ownership of Voting Rights.A Study of Public Corporations with Dual Classes of Common Stock[J].Journal of Financial Economics,1985,(14):33-69.
    [231]Fama,E.Agency Problems and the Theory of the Firm[J].Journal of Political Econom y,1980,(88):28-307.
    [232]John,K.and L.Senbet,Corporate Governance and Board Effectiveness[J].Journal of Banking and Finance,1998,22(4):371-403.
    [233]Cao Yuan Zheng,Fan Gang and Wang Wing.Chinese economic reforms past successes and future challenges[J].The MIT Press,1997,(6):19-39.
    [234]Miltiadis Makris.The Theory of Incentives.The Principal-Agent Model[J].The Economic Journal,2003,113(488):394.
    [235]John,K.and Y.Qian,Incentive Feature in CEO Compensation in the Banking Industry[J].FRBNY Economic Policy Review,2003,(9):109-121.
    [236]Macey,J.R.and M.O'Hara.The Corporate Governance of Banks[J].FRBNY Economic Policy Review,2003,(9):91-107.
    [237]Prowse,S.D.Alternative Methods of Corporate Control in Commercial Banks[J].Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas Economic Review Third Quarter,1995,(12):224-254.
    [238]叶正茂,洪远朋.共享利益与股份合作制的产权界定[J].学术月刊,2002,(4):69-75.
    [239]Shleifer,A.and R.W.Vishny.A Survey of Corporate Governance[J].Journal of Finance,1997:737-775.
    [240]Agusman Gary S.Monroe.Bank Moral Hazard and the Disciplining Factors of Risk Taking [J].Evidence from Asian Banks,2003,(78):231-241.
    [241]Arun and Turner.Corporate Government of Banking Institutions in Developing Economics.The Indian Experience[J].University of Ulster Working Papers,2004,(34):67-98.
    [242]Macey and O'Hara.The Corporate Governance of Banks[J].FRBNY Economic Policy Review,2001,(56):90-108.
    [243]Jonathan R.Macey,Maureen O'Hara.The Corporate Governance of Bank[J].Economic Policy Review,2003,(4):91-101.
    [244]郝允峰,顾江.社会人属性和企业治理效率的改善[J].财经科学,2007,(11):91-97.
    [245]许英.事业单位法人治理结构影响因素初探[J].经济师,2008,(7):291-293.
    [246]王延增,曹稚玮.提高大型商业银行公司治理效率的思考[J].上海农村金融,2008,(5):29-32.
    [247]毕克新,高岩.美日公司治理模式对技术创新的影响及对我国的启示[J].科技进步与对策,2008,25(6):185-189.
    [248]陶虎,齐新家.山东省国有独资企业治理效率评价指标体系及模型构建[J].山东经济,2007,141(4):125-127.
    [249]陶虎,齐新家.山东省国有独资企业治理效率实证研究[J].技术经济,2007,26(12):93-96.
    [250]邓玫,王寮凤.基于治理效率的国有企业权利配置模式研究[J].企业参考,2007,(5):77-80.
    [251]宋周,何燕.论最优企业所有权安排的配置原则[J].西南民族大学学报,2004,(3):117-120.
    [252]奥利弗·哈特.公司治理:理论与启示[J].经济学动态,1996,(6):86-98.
    [253]国家统计局.中国统计年鉴-2007[M].北京:中国统计出版社,2008.
    [254]李维安.公司治理学[M].高等教育出版社,2005.
    [255]魏末梅.企业技术创新能力评价体系与ANP法的研究[D].重庆大学,2006.
    [256]Blair,Margaret.Ownership and Control.Rethinking Corporate Governance for the 21Century[M].Washington.the Brooking Institution,1995.
    [257]Measures of Performance in Executive Compensation Contracts[J].Journal of Accounting Research,2004,25:85-125.
    [258]曾北川.风险导向的商业银行内部控制评价体系重构[D].北京师范大学,2005.
    [259]吕萍.我国商业银行内部控制研究[D].华南农业大学,2002
    [260]山东省统计局.山东统计年鉴-2007[M].北京:山东统计出版社,2008.
    [261]江州,李富强,董直庆等.竞争、产权和我国国有企业治理效率的实证检验[J].中国软科学,2007,(12):122-129.
    [262]范莉莉.论我国家族企业内部治理结构的关键影响因素[J].现代商贸工业,2008,(7):139-140.
    [263]Ciancanelli and Gonzalez.Corporate Governance in Banking:A Concept Framework [J].Strathclyde University Working Papers,2000,14(54):145-125.
    [264]Gary Gorton and Frank schmid,Class Struggle inside the Firm.A Study of German Co-determination[J].Working Paper,2000,(7945):14-24.
    [265]杨海芬,李志远,胡汉祥.上市公司董事会治理结构与治理效率的均衡分析[J].石家庄铁道学院学报(社会科学版),2007,1(2):40-43.
    [266]邢有洪,程江.上市公司债权治理效应的实证研究[J].煤炭经济研究,2007,(12):30-33.
    [267]朱小斌译.时间序列计量经济学(上)-协整和自回归条件异方差模型[J].外国经济与管理,2003,25(11):39-45.
    [268]朱小斌译.时间序列计量经济学(下)-协整和自回归条件异方差模型[J].外国经济与管理,2003,25(12):40-46.
    [269]马云玲.建立计量经济模型时解释变量的筛选[J].云南财贸学院学报(经济管理版),2003,17(6):171-172.
    [270]陈晓,王琨.关联交易、公司治理与国有股改革—来自我国资本市场的实证证据[J].经济研究,2005,(4):77-86.
    [271]张立达,蔺晓杰,马玉刚.债务融资治理效应的实证评析[J].技术经济与管理研究,2008,(1):93-95.
    [272]匡洪燕,周泉恭.证券投资基金组织治理效率和优化路径探究[J].当代财经,2007,(12):64-66.
    [273]张维迎.从现代企业理论看国有企业改革[J].改革,1995,(1):30-33.
    [274]唐英.债权人参与公司治理主体和形式选择初探[J].吉林财税高等专科学校学报,2005,(1):57-61.
    [275]唐海.新时期农村信用社改革工作指导[M].北京:中国财政经济出版社,2004:101-102.
    [276]于俊年.计量经济学软件—Eviews的使用[M].对外经济贸易出版社,2006.
    [277]范秀红.农村信用社改革过程中法人治理结构问题的研究[J].金融与经济,2008,5:67-69.
    [278]何广文.中国农村金融发展与制度变迁[M].北京:中国财政经济出版社,2005.
    [279]陈凡,赵领恩,王丽华.我国农村信用社法人治理结构的完善对策[J].合作经济,2008,(4):83-85.
    [280]殷玉润.农村信用社的“内、外部人”控制与治理结构改造[J].华北金融,2007,(6):46-48.
    [281]于良春,王会宗.商业银行市场结构与经济增长关系的实证分析[J].延安大学学报(社会科学版),2007,29(6):52-55.
    [282]刘书祥.央行支农再贷款政策效应实证研究[J].黑龙江金融,2006,(1):3-7.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700