用户名: 密码: 验证码:
排污权交易及其在中国的应用研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
自20世纪60年代,随着社会生产力和科学技术迅猛发展,人类改造自然的规模不断扩大,经济增长与环境保护的矛盾越来越突出。实践表明,环境政策是世界各国在保持经济增长的同时,对环境实施有效保护和改善的重要手段。排污权交易在承认环境容量资源有限的前提下,允许排污单位对环境资源的使用权进行交易,能够很好地协调经济发展与环境保护的关系,是一项成本效益高的环境政策。
     本文将排污权交易作为研究对象,在分析和总结国内外实践基础上,对排污权总量确定、初始分配及其在非点源污染中的应用进行了研究,并结合大连市具体现状,提出大连市应用排污权交易的构想。本文主要对以下问题进行了探讨:
     ①应用环境负荷理论确定排污总量。排污权交易政策的特点之一是排污总量有上限。总量的确定在理论上并不十分困难,它主要由环境容量、环境质量等因素决定。目前确定方法主要有两种:依据环境容量和历史排放水平,然而这两种方法均未考虑经济发展因素,导致污染控制与经济发展脱钩。尤其值得注意的是,我国现有的总量控制计划忽视了计划的长期性和可延续性,造成每一期之间总量目标的随意变更,从根本上动摇了政策的稳定性并影响了政策的执行效果。本文针对上述现象,通过分析传统经济增长方式与环境负荷之间的关系,对排污权交易中的总量管理创新问题进行探索研究。以二氧化硫的排放控制为例分析探讨如何在排污权交易中应用环境负荷的控制方程将污染的远期允许目标总量分解,进而确定交易的近期总量目标。
     ②排污权初始分配问题的探讨。已有的分配方法主要包括无偿分配、拍卖等形式,而这些方式都难以保证环境资源的有效配置。本文将“排放效率”引入初始分配中,通过排污权的初始分配,促使低于排放效率平均值的排污者被淘汰出局,引导排污权交易从利用经济方法控制环境污染向利用环境容量促进经济增长转变,进而在环境排污总量不增加的情况下促进经济增长最大化。
     ③将排污权交易应用于非点源污染。对于中国政府而言,解决非点源污染问题关键既不在于缺乏对非点源污染相关知识的了解,也不在于缺少控制污染的技术,问题的关键在于缺少相关政策及配套制度。本文通过分析点源与非点源的减污成本,进一步分析了排污权在点源与非点源之间交易的可行性,并遵循清洁发展机制的设计思路,提出点源与非点源进行排污权交易的具体方案。由于监控非点源污染的成本较高,因此可以采取代理转换机制,将非点源转换成点源或类点源,以实现排污权在点源与非点源之间的有效交易。
     ④在考察大连市自然状况、产业结构、工业发展布局以及近年环境状况基础上,分析了排污权交易在大连市实施的可行性及必要性,并从总量确定、初始分配及市场建立、交易监控等方面入手,构架了大连市的排污权交易体系,期望能够为大连及其他相似城市排污权交易体系的建立提供参考和借鉴。通过研究指出,完善明确的法律依据也是有效实施排污权交易的基础,因此,相关的立法及执法力度也必须加强。
Since 1960s, the scale of natural transformation has been expanded gradually along with the rapid development of productivity,science and technology. The incompatibility between high-speed economic growth and limited environmental capacity has been worsening dramatically in recent years. We have known from practice that environment policy is a very important way to protect environment effectively, while the speed of economics growth is guaranteed. Based on tradable emissions, polluting sources can trade their pollution rights on the premise that environment capacity is limited. It is a cost-effective policy for reducing pollutions and well harmonizing the relationship of economic development and environment protection.
     Taking tradable emissions as a study object, this dissertation discusses the following three issues on basis of a survey of international and demestic experience: total setting of emission rights, primary allocation for allowances and the application of tradable emissions to ANPS (agriculture non-point source) pollutions. In addition, this dissertation proposes the conception of applying tradable emission to Dalian City according to Dalian present situation. The following details are the conclusion of this thesis:
     1. Setting Total Emissions. One characteristic of emissions trading is that it has an upper limits (the cap for the total permissible emissions). It is not very difficult in theory when setting the total emissions, it mainly relates to the environmental quantity and quality. There are two methods, one is traditional cap-and-trade system and the other is "pollution level".In practice, this level is a historic level or a part of present level. However these two methods has not considered the economical development factor, which divides the contamination control and the economical development. Particularly, our current total control plans ignore the long-term and continuity nature of the program , resulting in the random change of total goals between each period, fundamentally shaken the policy and affect the stability of the the implementation of the policy. Based on the phenomenon, this thesis studies the innovation of environment capacity management by analyzing the relationship between traditional mode of economic growth and the environmental load, and explores how to change the forward target into annual goals.
     2. Discussion on primary allocation for allowances. Total emissions must be set and allocated to every pollution source by government. There are various options when it comes to the primary allocation of emission allowance, auctioning and free allocation of allowances are the main approaches. But these two ways can not enable the environment resources to obtain the most superior assignment. The notion "discharge efficiency" is introduced in prinary allocation, this notion in our study not only provides theoretical basis for eliminating enterprises with discharge efficiency below average,but also helps promote the optimal socio-economic development under the constraint of environmental capacity.
     3. Applying tradable emissions to ANPS pollutions. The key issue for Chinese government is neither the lack of knowledge about ANPS pollution nor the lack of technologies to control it. A proper policy frame and the matching systems on ANPS pollution control are needed. This dissertation analyzes the feasibility of emission rights trading between point pollutions and ANPS pollutions based on their reduction pollution costs. A concrete plan for trading emission rights between point and ANPS pollutions is also designed following the design mentality of Clean Development Mechanism. In order to reduce monitoring cost, "agent mechanism" method is adopted, in this method, ANPS pollutions are collected to be a whole object and traded with other point pollution.
     4. In view of the present situation of Dalian, this dissertation analyzes the feasibility and the necessity of tradable emissions which will implement in Dalian, and devises a tradable emissions system (including total setting, primary allocation, market establishent,transaction monitoring etc) for Dalian, expectes to provide a model for other similar cities. The paper points out through the research that, effective implementation of tradable emissions needs explicit law. Therefore, the correlation legislation and lawenforcement must be strengthen.
引文
[1]国家环境保护总局.全国环境统计公报(2003).
    [2]国家环境保护总局.全国环境统计公报(2005).
    [3]温总理强调要采取四方面措施强化环保工作.http://www.zhb.gov.cn/ztbd/hjbhdh/xgbd/200604/t20060417_75849.html,2006-4-17.
    [4]张象枢,魏国印,李克国.环境经济学.北京:中国环境科学出版社,1994,18-52.
    [5]郑庭伟.论排污权的性质.环境法电子期刊,2004,(1).
    [6]Dales J H.Pollution,Property and Prices.University of Toronto Press,1968:23-29
    [7]Tom Tietenberg.Environmental and Natural Resource Economics.Third Edition.New York:HarperCollins Publishers Inc.,1992.45-46.
    [8]鲍莫尔著,严旭阳译.环境经济理论与政策设计(第二版).北京:经济科学出版社,2003.
    [9]罗杰·A·阿诺德著,沈可挺等译.环境政策和法规的经济分析,北京:经济科学出版社,1995.
    [10]戴维·皮尔斯著,张世秋等译.世界无末日——经济学、环境与可持续发展.北京:中国财政经济出版社,1996.
    [11]Tom Tietenberg.Emissions Trading:An Exercise in Reforming Pollution Policy.Washington DC:Resources for the Future,1985.
    [12]Hahn R.W.Market power and transferable property right.Journal of Economies,1984,(3):753-765.
    [13]Spence M.Cost reduction competition and industry performance.Journal of Economies,1984,(52):101-121.
    [14]Stavins,R.N.Transaction Costs and Tradable Permits.Journal of Environmental Economies and Management,1995,(29):133-148.
    [15]Cason T.N.and L.Gandgadharan.Transactions Cost in Tradable Permit Markets:an Experimental Study of Pollution Market Designs.Journal of Regulation Economies,2003,23(2):145-165.
    [16]Gangadharan L.Transaction Costs in Pollution Markets.Land Economies,2000,76(4):601-614.
    [17]Malik.Enforcement costs and the choice of policy instruments for controlling pollution.Economic Inquiry,1996,(30):161-173.
    [18]Van Egteren H,Weber M.Marketable permits,market power and cheating.Journal of Environmental Economies and Management,2000,(24):115-118.
    [19]Laffont J,Tirole J.Pollution permits and strategies.Journal of Public Economies,1996,(62):85-125.
    [20]Montgomery,WD.Markets in Lieenses and efficient pollution control Programs.Joumal of Economic theory,1972,VOI.5,395-418.
    [21]林红.大气污染物排放总量控制方案的确定.中国环境科学,1993(5):328-333.
    [22]马小明,李诗刚,奕胜基,叶文虎.中国城市大气污染物总量控制方法及案例研究.北京大学学报(自然科学版),1999(3):265-270.
    [23]马中,杜丹德.总量控制与排污权交易,北京:中国环境科学出版社,1999,179-180.
    [24]王金南,杨金田.二氧化硫排放交易——中国的可行性.北京:中国环境科学出版社,2002.
    [25]宋国君.排污权交易.北京:化学工业出版社,2004,89-90.
    [26]吴健.排污权交易—环境容量管理制度创新,北京:中国人民大学出版社,2005,46.
    [27]李寿德,王家祺.初始排污权不同分配下的交易对市场结构的影响研究.武汉理工大学学报(交通科学与工程版),2004,(1):40-43.
    [28]施圣炜,黄桐城.期权理论在排污权初始分配中的应用.中国人口.资源与环境,2005,(1):52-55.
    [29]肖江文,赵勇,罗云峰,岳超源.寡头垄断条件下的排污权交易博弈模型.系统工程理论与实践,2003,(4):27-32.
    [30]王先甲,肖文,胡振鹏.排污权初始权分配的两种方法及其效率比较.自然科学进展,2004,(1):81-87.
    [31]陈德湖,李寿德,蒋馥.排污权交易市场中厂商行为与政府管制.系统工程,2004,(3):44-46.
    [32]陈磊,张世秋.排污权交易中企业行为的微观博弈分析.北京大学学报(自然科学版),2005,(11):926-934.
    [33]黄桐城,武邦涛.基于治理成本和排污收益的排污权交易定价模型.上海管理科学,2004,(6):34-36.
    [34]沈满洪,赵丽秋.排污权价格决定的理论探讨.浙江社会科学,2005,(2):26-30.
    [35]李赤林,马纪云.城市水污染处理的排污权交易策略及定价机理研究.现代管理科学,2005,(11):5-6.
    [36]唐浩阳,任玉珑,卢安文.行业排污定价机制研究.生态经济,2005,(12):73-75.
    [37]汤姆·泰坦伯格.环境经济学与政策,上海:上海财经大学出版社,2004,180.
    [38]胡妍斌.排污权交易问题研究:(博士学位论文).上海:复旦大学,2003,22.
    [39]Ellerman.Emission Trading Under The U.S.Acid Rain Program-Evaluation of Compliance Costs and Allowance Market Performance.Cambridge,Massachusetts:Center for Energy and Environmental Policy Research,Massachusetts Institute of Technology,1997.
    [40]Paul R.Portney and Robert N.Stavins.Public Policies for Environmental Protection.Second Edition.US Washington:Resources for the Future,2000,35-41.
    [41]US EPA.The United States Experience with Economic Incentives to Control Environmental Pollution.EPA-230-R-92-001.Washington D.C.:U.S.EPA,1992
    [42]张安华.排污权交易的可持续发展潜力分析.北京:经济科学出版社,2005,56.
    [43]U.S.EPA.http://www.epa.gov/airmarkets/trading/2007/07summary.2006-4-3
    [44]Brian J.Mclean.The Evolution of Marketable Permits:The U.S.Experience with Sulfur Dioxide Allowance Trading.The International Journal of Environmental and Pollution,Vol.8,Nos.1/2(1997):19-36.
    [45]Air Pollution:Allowance Trading Offers an Opportunity to Reduce Emissions at Less Cost.GAO/RCED-95-30,U.S.General Accounting Office,Washington,DC,December 1995
    [46]Title Ⅳ of CAAA-Acid Deposition Control,Section 411 Excess Emissions Penalty [42 U.S.C.7651j].
    [47]美国国家环保局.www.epa.gov/air/urbanair/so_2.
    [48]吕学都,刘德顺.清洁发展机制在中国,北京:清华大学出版社,2005,161.
    [49]罗明,何伟军.“京都议定书”对三峡区域经济的有利影响.特区经济,2005,(9):132.
    [50]蔡守秋.论排污权交易的法律问题.河南大学学报(社会科学版),2003,(5).
    [51]郑爽.日本执行清洁发展机制的动向.中国能源,2003,(3):18.
    [52]刘绍,叶琳,游江峰.广州市实施二氧化硫排污权交易研究.环境科学与管理,2005,30(6):12-15
    [53]张喆.中国电力行业SO_2排污权交易经济分析(硕士学位论文).北京:中国环境科学研究院,2007,15-17.
    [54]龙平川,吴建丽.排污权交易之中国试验.http://www.dffy.com 2005-8-11.
    [55]施纪文.排污权交易在浙江电力SO_2治理中的可行性研究.华东电力,2005,33(6):33-37.
    [56]开远市环境保护局.开远市大气污染物排放许可证试点验收技术报告,1994,(3):48.
    [57]杨君,李强.浅析二氧化硫总量控制制度对山西省电力企业的影响.华北电力技术,2004,(6):14-17.
    [58]柳州市环境保护管理局.柳州市二氧化硫排污补偿交易试点工作总结报告(内部报告).1994.
    [59]祝兴祥,夏青,李小平等.中国的排污许可证制度.北京:中国环境科学出版社,1991,32-33.
    [60]宋国君.中国污染物排放总量控制和浓度控制.环境保护,2000,(6):11-13.
    [61]张玉清.河流功能区水污染物容量总量控制的原理和方法.北京:中国环境科学出版社,2001,(9).
    [62]国家环境保护局中国环境科学研究院.城市大气污染总量控制典型范例.北京:中国环境科学出版社,1993,(5).
    [63]日本环境厅大气保全局控制课.总量控制手册.1974.
    [64]程炜,魏东星,杨云飞.大气污染物区域总量控制目标确定方法的研究.环境导报,2002,(1).
    [65]Dinda S.Environmental Kuznets Curve Hypothesis:A Survey.Ecological Economics,2004,49(4):431-455.
    [66]国家统计局,中国统计年鉴2005
    [67]中国环境统计年鉴,1991-2004.
    [68]李周,包晓斌.中国环境库兹涅茨曲线的估计.科技导报,2002,(4):57-58.
    [69]李慧明,卜欣欣.环境与经济如何双赢——环境库兹涅茨曲线引发的思考.南开学报,2003,(1):58.
    [70]Grossman G & Krueger A.Economic growth and the environment.Quarterly Journal of Economics,1995,110(2):353-337.
    [71]Shafik N & Bandyopadhyay S.Economic Growth and Environmental Quality:Time Series and Cross-country Evidence.Background Paper for World Development Report 1992,Washington DC,USA:World Bank.
    [72]Lopez R.The Environment as a Factor of Production:The Effects of Economic Growth and Trade Liberalization.Journal of Environmental Economics and Management,1994(27):163-184.
    [73]Jean Agras.A Dynamic Approach to the Environmental Kuznets Curve Hypothesis,Ecological Economics,1999(28):267-277.
    [74]David I.Stern.Explaining Changes in Global Sulfur Emissions:An Econometric Decomposition Approach.Ecological Economics,2002(42):201-220.
    [75]Markus P.Technical Progress,Structural Change,and the Environmental Kuznets Curve.Ecological Economics,2002(42):381-389.
    [76]Antonio F.Empirical Evidence in the Analysis of the Environmental and Energy Policies of a Series of Industrialized Nations,During the Period 1960-1997,Using Widely Employed Macro Economic Indicators.Energy Policy,2003(31):333-352.
    [77]Sunnevag K.Auction design for the allocation of emission permits in the.Presence of market power.Environmental and Resource Economics,2003(26):385-400.
    [78]Hilton F & Levinson A.Factoring the environmental kuznets curve:evidence from automotive lead emissions.Journal of Environmental Economics and Management,1998(35):126-141.
    [79]陈华文,刘康兵.经济增长与环境质量:关于环境库兹涅茨曲线的经验分析.复旦学报(社会科学版),2004,(2):87-94.
    [80]Elisabetta Magnani.The Environmental Kuznets Curve,environmental protection policy and income distribution.Ecological Economics,2000(32):431-443.
    [81]Harbaugh W,Levinson A,Wilson D.Reexamining the empirical evidence for an environmental Kuznets curve.The Review of Economics and Statistics 2002,84(3):541-551.
    [82]Giles D,Mosk C.Ruminant Eructation and a Long-Run Environmental Kuznets' Curvefor Enteric Methane in New Zealand:Conventional and Fuzzy Regression Analysis.Econometrics Working Paper EWP0306 of Department of Economics,University of Victoria,B.C.,Canada,1-37.
    [83]Ezzati M,Singer B & Kammen D.Towards an integrated framework for development and environmental policy:the dynamics of environmental Kuznets curves.World Development,2001,29(8):1421-1434.
    [84]Dasgupta S,Laplante B,Wang H.Confronting the environmental Kuznets curve.Journal of Economic Perspectives,2002,16(1):147-168.
    [85]Cole M,Rayner A,Bates J.The environmental kuznets curve:an empirical analysis.Environment and Development Economics,1997,(2):401-416.
    [86]Bartoszczuk P,Ma T,Nakamori Y.Environmental Kuznets Curve for some countries-regression and agent-based approach.In:Air Pollution X(Ecology and the Environment volume53),C A Brebbia & J F Martin-Duque.Southampton,UK:WIT Press.
    [87]Panayotou T.Demystifying the environmental kuznets curve:turning a black box into a policy tool.Environment and DevelopmentEconomics,1997,(2):465-484.
    [88]Selden T,Song D.Environmental quality and development:Is there a Kuznets curve for air pollution estimates? Journal of Environmental Economics and Management,1994,(27):147-162.
    [89]Cole M,Rayner A,Bates J.The environmental kuznets curve:an empirical analysis.Environment and Development Economics,1997,(2):401-416.
    [90]Paudel K,Susanto D,Cramer G.An Empirical Test of the Environmental Kuznets Curve for Water Pollution.Natural Resource Economics Meeting:Aquaculture and Effluents Proceedings of a Regional Workshop,SERA-IEG-30,Mississippi.State University,May 16-17,2002.
    [91]Holtz-Eakin D,Selden T.Stoking the fires? CO_2 emissions and economic growth.Journal of Public Economics,1995,57(1):85-101.
    [92]Egli H.Are Cross-Country Studies of the Environmental Kuznets Curve Misleading? New Evidence from Time Series Data for Germany.Discussion Paper 10/2001 of Ernst-Moritz-Arndt University of Greifswald,Germany.
    [93]吴玉萍,董锁成.北京市环境政策评价研究.城市环境与城市生态,2002,15(2):4-6.
    [94]杨凯,叶茂,徐启新.上海城市废弃物增长的环境库兹涅茨特征研究.地理研究,2003,(22):60-66.
    [95]高振宁,缪旭波,邹长新.江苏省环境库兹涅茨特征分析.农村生态环境,2004,(1):41-43.
    [96]张云,申玉铭,徐谦.南京市工业废气排放的环境库兹涅茨特征及因素分析,首都师范大学学报(自然科学版),2005,(1):113-116.
    [97]沈满洪,许云华.一种新型的环境库兹涅茨曲线——浙江省工业化进程中经济增长与环境变迁的关系研究,浙江社会科学,2000,(4):53-57.
    [98]凌亢,王浣尘,刘涛.城市经济发展与环境污染关系的统计研究——以南京市为例.统计研究,2001,(10):46-52.
    [99]陆虹.中国环境问题与经济发展的关系分析——以大气污染为例.财经研究,2000,26(10):53-59.
    [100]陈艳莹.污染治理的规模收益与环境库兹涅茨曲线——对环境库兹涅茨曲线成因的新解释.预测,2002,21(5):46-49.
    [101]赵云君,文启湘.环境库兹涅茨曲线及其在我国的修正.经济学家,2004,(5):70-72.
    [102]孙立,李俊清.可利用的水与环境库兹涅茨曲线的拓展和分析.科学技术与工程,2004,(5):404-406.
    [103]T.E.Graedel,B.R.Allenby.Industrial Ecology.New Jersey.Prentice Hall,1995,31.
    [104]陆钟武,毛建素.穿越“环境高山”——论经济增长过程中环境负荷的上升与下降.中国工程科学,2003,(12):10-20.
    [105]支海宇.将环境负荷应用于排污权交易政策研究.科技进步与对策,2007,(5):16-18.
    [106]中国能源环境战略与对策 http://www.zhb.gov.en/,2006-04-14.
    [107]国家环境保护“十五”计划指标完成情况分析.http://www.zhb.gov.cn/,2006-04-12.
    [108]Friedman L.A Competitive Bidding Strategy.Operations Research,1956,(4):104-112.
    [109]Vichrey H.Counter Speculation,Auctions,and Competitive Sealed Tenders.Journal of Finance,1961,(16):8-37.
    [110]Maskin E S,Riley J G.Optimal auctions with risk averse buyers.Econometry,1984,(52):1473-1518.
    [111]张维迎.博弈论与信息经济学.上海:上海三联书店,1996:256.
    [112]吴亚琼,赵勇等.初始排污权分配的协商仲裁机制.系统工程,2003,21(5):70-74.
    [113]Howe C H.Taxes versus tradable discharge permits:a review in the light of the U.S.and European experience.Environmental and Resource Economics,1994,4(2):151-169.
    [114]葛察忠.排放绩效标准:让电力行业“换个活法”.环境经济,2004,(3):5-38.
    [115]薛人杰,朱法华,朱庚富等.江苏省电力行业SO_2排放配额分配的探索.污染防治技术,2003,(S1):188-191.
    [116]朱法华,王圣.SO_2排放指标分配方法研究及在我国的实践.环境科学研究,2005(4):6-40.
    [117]刘娜,谢绍东.城市点源大气污染物总量分配方法及其进展.北京大学学报(自然科学版),2006,(11):826-827.
    [118]期刊编辑部.环境效率——从环境方面评估可持续发展工具.国际化工信息,2002,(11):1-5.
    [119]APERC.Energy efficiency indicators,a study of energy efficiency indicators for industry in APEC economies.Asia Pacific Energy Research Centre.Tokyo,2000.
    [120]Bosseboeuf D,Chateau B,Lapillonne B.Cross-country comparison on energy efficiency indicators:the on-going European effort towards a common methodology.Energy Policy,1997,(25),:673-682.
    [121]王庆一.中国的能源效率及国际比较(上).节能与环保,2003,(8):5-7.
    [122]Patterson,M.G.Hhat is energy efficiency? Concepts,indicators and methodological issues.Energy Policy,1996,5(24):377-390.
    [123]吕彬,杨建新.生态效率方法研究与应用.生态学报,2006,26(11):3899.
    [124]BjErn Stigson.Eco-efficiency:Creating more value with less impact.WBCSD,2000,5-36.
    [125]Gjalt Huppes,Hasanobu Ishikawa.Eco-efficiency and Its Terminology.Journal of Industrial Ecology,2005,(4):43-46.
    [126]Five Winds International.The Role of Eco-Efficiency:Global Challenges and Opportunities in the 21st Century.May 2000.
    [127]Katherine Hadden,Rebekah Young,Kevin Brady,etal.Developing the eco-efficiency:learning module.WBCSD,205-211.
    [128]Hillary Ruth.Small and Hedium-Sized Enterprises and the Environment:Business Imperatives.Sheffield:Greenleaf Publishing,2000,11-23.
    [129]Sangwon Suh,Kun Mo Lee,Sangsun Ha.Eco-efficiency for Pollution Prevention in Small to Medium-Sized Enterprises:A Case from South Korea.Journal of Industrial Ecology,2005,9(4):223-240.
    [130]Marcio D Agosto,Suzana Kahn Ribeiro.Eco-efficiency management program(EEMP) a model for road fleet operation.Transportation Research Part D:Transport and Environment,2004,9(6):497-511.
    [131]Dominique Maxime,Hichele Marcotte,Yves Arcand.Development of eco-efficiency indicators for the Canadian food and beverage industry.Journal of Cleaner Production,2006,14(627):636-648.
    [132]Ina Rdenauer,Dietlinde Quack.Eco-Efficiency Analysis of Washing machines.Freiburg,2004,1-80.
    [133]曹光辉,章欣,张宗益等.污染物排放效率分析与评价指标.环境保护,2005,(8):24-26.
    [134]许赛缘.福建省开展二氧化硫排污权交易的设想.发展研究,2007,(4):51.
    [135]Lee S I.Non-point Source Pollution.Fisheries,1979,(2):50-52.
    [136]Novotny,V,Olem,H.Water Quality:Prevention Identification,and Hanagement of Diffuse Pollution.John Wiley & Sons,1993.
    [137]张宏艳.发达地区农村面源污染的经济学研究.北京:经济科学出版社,2005,(12):14.
    [138]纪江玮.菜篮子里漏下的公害.http://www.lifeweek.com.cn/2002-11-25/000533373.html 2002-11-25.
    [139]国家环境保护总局.2000年中国环境状况公报.http://www.zhb.gov.cn/eic/20000620/html.
    [140]朱兆良,孙波,杨林章等.我国农业非点源污染的控制政策和措施.农业,2005,(4):50.
    [141]国土资源部.2006年度全国土地利用变更调查结果报告.http://www.chinanews.com.cn/gn/news/2007/04-12/914423.shtml,2007-4-12.
    [142]王宝维.畜牧业可持续发展的必由之路——生态畜牧业.甘肃农业,2005,(2):66-68.
    [143]国家统计局.2006年国家统计年鉴.
    [144]中国社科院可持续发展研究组.2001年中国可持续发展战略报告.北京:科学出版社,2001.
    [145]林玉锁.农药与生态环境保护.北京:化学工业出版社,2000,5-9.
    [146]殷丽萍.农村生活垃圾问题及对策.云南环境科学,2006,(25):130-131.
    [147]崔兆杰,王艳艳,张荣荣.农村生活垃圾分类收集的建设方法及运行模式研究.科学技术与工程,2006,9(18):65.
    [148]何萍,王家骥.非点源污染控制与管理研究的现状、困境与挑战.农业环境保护,1999,18(5):235-236.
    [149]贺缠生,傅伯杰,陈利顶.非点源污染的管理及控制.环境科学,1998,19(5):88.
    [150]鲁传一,刘德顺.减缓全球气候变化的京都机制的经济学分析.世界经济,2002,(8):73-74.
    [151]Segerson K.Uncertainty and incentives for nonpoint pollution control.Journal of Environment Economics and Management.1988,(15):87-89.
    [152]Anastasio Xepapadeas.Controlling Environmental Externalities:Observability and Optimal Policy Rules.Non-point Source Pollution Regulation:Issues and Policy Analysis.1994,67-86.
    [153]Ramu Govindasamy,Joseph A.Herriges and Jason F.Shogren.Non-point Tournaments.Non-point Source Pollution Regulation:Issues and Policy Analysis.1994,1-37.
    [154]张巍,王学军,李莹.在总量控制体系下实施点源与非点源排污权交易的理论研究.环境科学学报,2001,(6):749.
    [155]James S.The allocative efficiency implications of water pollution abatement cost comparisons[J].Water Resources Research,1990,26(5):793-797.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700