图书开放获取权益分享机制研究溯源与现状分析
|
摘要
[目的/意义]图书开放获取权益分享机制是确保权益分享实现公平与效率均衡的前提,也是研究图书开放获取商业模式与制度体系的基础。本文旨在对目前图书开放获取权益分享机制研究进行溯源与现状分析。[方法/过程]运用文献调研法与内容分析法,在梳理图书开放获取权益分享机制内涵的基础上,进一步探究其理论渊源与研究现状。[结果/结论]图书开放获取权益分享机制研究衍生于以学术期刊为发端的开放获取权益分享机制。目前,图书开放获取权益分享机制在法律、政策、经济、管理与技术方面进行了分析,但还缺少增值、互动视角的权益分享机制体系研究。
[Purpose/significance] The mechanism of book open access rights sharing is not only the precondition to ensure fairness and efficiency of book rights sharing, but also the basis of studying the business model and policy system of book open access. The purpose of this paper is to analyze the theoretical origin and current mechanisms of rights sharing of book open access so as to deepen the study of book open access.[Method/process] Based on the analysis of the connotation of the open access rights sharing mechanism of books, the paper further explores its theoretical origin and research status by using the method of literature research and content analysis. [Result/conclusion]Research on the mechanism of book open access rights sharing and the mechanism derived from information resource sharing as well as the mechanism of open access rights sharing stemmed from academic journals. At present, the book open access rights sharing mechanism has been analyzed in the aspects of law, policy, economy, management and technology. However, the study on the rights sharing mechanism system from the perspective of added value and interaction is ignored.
[Purpose/significance] The mechanism of book open access rights sharing is not only the precondition to ensure fairness and efficiency of book rights sharing, but also the basis of studying the business model and policy system of book open access. The purpose of this paper is to analyze the theoretical origin and current mechanisms of rights sharing of book open access so as to deepen the study of book open access.[Method/process] Based on the analysis of the connotation of the open access rights sharing mechanism of books, the paper further explores its theoretical origin and research status by using the method of literature research and content analysis. [Result/conclusion]Research on the mechanism of book open access rights sharing and the mechanism derived from information resource sharing as well as the mechanism of open access rights sharing stemmed from academic journals. At present, the book open access rights sharing mechanism has been analyzed in the aspects of law, policy, economy, management and technology. However, the study on the rights sharing mechanism system from the perspective of added value and interaction is ignored.
引文
[1] SUBER P.Open access[M].Boston:MIT Press,2012:3-9.
[2] CONNAW L S,WICHT H L.What happened to the e-book revolution?The gradual integration of e-books into academic libraries[J].Journal of electronic publishing,2007,10 (3):3-9.
[3] FAYAZ A L.Open access e-book collection on Central Asia in selected digital archives[J].Collection building,2011,30 (3):126-130.
[4] 魏蕊.OAPEN 学术专著开放获取研究与实践进展述评 [J].图书情报工作,2017(9):135-144.
[5] 魏蕊,初景利.学术图书开放获取与美国大学图书馆出版服务 [J].大学图书馆学报,2014(3):17-22.
[6] 叶继元.学术图书、学术著作、学术专著概念辨析 [J].中国图书馆学报,2016(1):21-29.
[7] MCGRATH M.Interlending and document supply:a review of the recent literature:85 [J].Interlending & document supply,2014,42(1):33-38.
[8] MARTIN P E.Open access publishing and scholarly communications in non-scientific disciplines [J].Online information review,2015,39(5):717-732.
[9] BEN C P,KATIA P.Intellectual property rights and knowledge sharing across countries [J].Journal of knowledge management,2009,13 (5):331-344.
[10] GIUDITTA DE P,JEAN P S.Public policies and government interventions in the book publishing industry [J].Info,2014,16(2):47-66.
[11] 张晓林,张冬荣,李麟,等.机构知识库内容保存与传播权利管理 [J].中国图书馆学报,2012(7):46-54.
[12] 陈靖.英国《开放存取专著服务报告》的解读与思考 [J].图书馆理论与实践,2017(6):48-52.
[13] 傅蓉.开放内容许可协议及其应用研究 [J].情报理论与实践,2012(12):37-43.
[14] JASSL G,WEGENER B.Methods for empirical justice analysis:Part 1.Framework,model,and quantities [J].Social justice research.,1997,10(4):393-430.
[15] 杨杨,陈思.起点公平、过程公平和结果公平辨析 [J].辽宁师范大学学报(社会科学版),2010(5):33-35.
[16] DINESH R,LISA M G,ERIC F.Interorganisational partnerships and knowledge sharing:the perspective of non-profit organisations (NPOs) [J].Journal of knowledge management,2014,18 (5):867-885.
[17] 吴志强,刘梅.数字资源权益分享的法律机制研究 [J].图书情报知识,2011(5):93-100.
[18] 丁大尉,胡志强.网络环境下的开放获取知识共享机制——基于科学社会学视角的分析 [J].科学学研究,2016(10):1441-1448.
[19] 李武,刘兹恒.一种全新的学术出版模式:开放存取出版模式探析 [J].中国图书馆学报,2004(6):66-69.
[20] ROBIN O.Open access publishing,academic research and scholarly communication [J].Online information review,2015,39(5):637-648.
[21] STEPHEN P.Making open access work:the “state-of-the-art” in providing open access to scholarly literature [J].Online information review,2015,39(5):604-636.
[22] 赵文义.学术期刊开放获取的内在逻辑与发展路径 [J].出版发行研究,2016(10):67-69.
[23] MARC S.On the access principle in science:a law and economics analysis.Copyright versus open access——on the organisation and international political economy of access to scientific knowledge[M].Berlin:Springer,2015:83-139.
[24] JOSE C,CATIA L,VASCO V et al.Monitoring a national open access funder mandate[J].Procedia computer science,2017 (3):283 - 290.
[25] GEORGIA K H.OA,IRs and IP:Open access,digital copyright and marketplace competition[OL].[2018-10-12].http://www.doc88.com/p-7754494707906.html.
[26] ANN R H,MILES A K,MAURA I.Mandatory open access publishing for electronic theses and dissertations:ethics and enthusiasm [J].The journal of academic librarianship,2013,39(1):32-60.
[27] 杨峰,韩倩倩,张文韬.机构知识库权益平衡机制探析[J].图书馆建设,2015 (5):13-16.
[28] 相丽玲,樊晓璐.中美机构知识库利用中的政策法律机制比较[J].情报理论与实践,2015(5):114-118.
[29] 牛晓宏.开放数据政策协同对图书开放获取政策的启示[J].现代情报,2018(9):24-28.
[30] 贾丽君.国外图书开放获取中的政策机制分析 [J].图书与情报,2017(3):93-97.
[31] 王应宽,王元杰,季方,等.国外开放存取出版最新研究进展与发展动态 [J].中国科技期刊研究,2015,26(10):1054-1064.
[32] 金品.开放存取期刊出版模式及其版权特点探析 [J].中国版权,2014(4):63-67.
[33] 刘勇.开放存取出版的原理、模式与影响因素分析 [J].出版广角,2016(11):36-38.
[34] MARY A K.Learning to share:mandates and open access[J].Library management,2011,32 (4/5):302-318.
[35] 苏红英.基于供给方付费的开放存取期刊的经济模式分析:以国外的实践为视角 [J].图书馆界,2017(3):42-45.
[36] 陈晋.开放存取期刊的经济运作模式 [J].图书馆学刊,2012(6):3-6.
[37] 涂志芳;刘兹恒.国内外学术图书馆参与开放存取出版的实践进展述略——从出版途径的视角 [J].图书与情报,2017(3):61-71.
[38] 李瑾.盛小平.利益视角下的学术图书开放获取出版模式研究 [J].图书情报工作,2017(3):39-46.
[39] 刘海霞,孙振球,胡德华,等.开放存取期刊的经济学分析 [J].情报理论与实践,2007,30(1):48-51.
[40] GEOGINA A T,VALETINO M L.A business model for electronic books[J].Social and behavioral sciences,2014(147):268 - 274.
[41] 马小琪,李亚赟.信息栈视角下微信公众平台出版模式研究[J].出版发行研究,2017(7):27-30.
[42] MICHELE S,MARIE P D,JILL E.Consortial monograph interlending in the UK:a case study[J].Interlending & document supply,2006,34(1):24-28.
[43] 宁圣红.学术图书开放获取新模式:Knowledge Unlatched [J].图书馆论坛,2015(7):14-20.
[44] JOSEPH W I.Research into open access science publishing [J].Library hi tech news,2009(26):16-18.
[45] 常江.数字版权管理与合理使用权利冲突的解决路径 [J].出版广角,2016(8):38-40.
[46] 李春旺.网络环境下学术信息的开放存取 [J].中国图书馆学报,2005(1):33-37.
[47] 朱本军,龙世彤,肖珑,等.图书 开放 获取模式 及整 合利 用研 究 [J].大学图书馆学报,2015(5):25-30.
[48] 刘春艳.产学研协同创新团队内部知识转移影响机理[M].北京:知识产权出版社.2017:298-300.
[49] 孙瑞英,马海群.太极哲理对开放数据与数据安全政策协同的启示[J].现代情报,2018(5):3-10.
[2] CONNAW L S,WICHT H L.What happened to the e-book revolution?The gradual integration of e-books into academic libraries[J].Journal of electronic publishing,2007,10 (3):3-9.
[3] FAYAZ A L.Open access e-book collection on Central Asia in selected digital archives[J].Collection building,2011,30 (3):126-130.
[4] 魏蕊.OAPEN 学术专著开放获取研究与实践进展述评 [J].图书情报工作,2017(9):135-144.
[5] 魏蕊,初景利.学术图书开放获取与美国大学图书馆出版服务 [J].大学图书馆学报,2014(3):17-22.
[6] 叶继元.学术图书、学术著作、学术专著概念辨析 [J].中国图书馆学报,2016(1):21-29.
[7] MCGRATH M.Interlending and document supply:a review of the recent literature:85 [J].Interlending & document supply,2014,42(1):33-38.
[8] MARTIN P E.Open access publishing and scholarly communications in non-scientific disciplines [J].Online information review,2015,39(5):717-732.
[9] BEN C P,KATIA P.Intellectual property rights and knowledge sharing across countries [J].Journal of knowledge management,2009,13 (5):331-344.
[10] GIUDITTA DE P,JEAN P S.Public policies and government interventions in the book publishing industry [J].Info,2014,16(2):47-66.
[11] 张晓林,张冬荣,李麟,等.机构知识库内容保存与传播权利管理 [J].中国图书馆学报,2012(7):46-54.
[12] 陈靖.英国《开放存取专著服务报告》的解读与思考 [J].图书馆理论与实践,2017(6):48-52.
[13] 傅蓉.开放内容许可协议及其应用研究 [J].情报理论与实践,2012(12):37-43.
[14] JASSL G,WEGENER B.Methods for empirical justice analysis:Part 1.Framework,model,and quantities [J].Social justice research.,1997,10(4):393-430.
[15] 杨杨,陈思.起点公平、过程公平和结果公平辨析 [J].辽宁师范大学学报(社会科学版),2010(5):33-35.
[16] DINESH R,LISA M G,ERIC F.Interorganisational partnerships and knowledge sharing:the perspective of non-profit organisations (NPOs) [J].Journal of knowledge management,2014,18 (5):867-885.
[17] 吴志强,刘梅.数字资源权益分享的法律机制研究 [J].图书情报知识,2011(5):93-100.
[18] 丁大尉,胡志强.网络环境下的开放获取知识共享机制——基于科学社会学视角的分析 [J].科学学研究,2016(10):1441-1448.
[19] 李武,刘兹恒.一种全新的学术出版模式:开放存取出版模式探析 [J].中国图书馆学报,2004(6):66-69.
[20] ROBIN O.Open access publishing,academic research and scholarly communication [J].Online information review,2015,39(5):637-648.
[21] STEPHEN P.Making open access work:the “state-of-the-art” in providing open access to scholarly literature [J].Online information review,2015,39(5):604-636.
[22] 赵文义.学术期刊开放获取的内在逻辑与发展路径 [J].出版发行研究,2016(10):67-69.
[23] MARC S.On the access principle in science:a law and economics analysis.Copyright versus open access——on the organisation and international political economy of access to scientific knowledge[M].Berlin:Springer,2015:83-139.
[24] JOSE C,CATIA L,VASCO V et al.Monitoring a national open access funder mandate[J].Procedia computer science,2017 (3):283 - 290.
[25] GEORGIA K H.OA,IRs and IP:Open access,digital copyright and marketplace competition[OL].[2018-10-12].http://www.doc88.com/p-7754494707906.html.
[26] ANN R H,MILES A K,MAURA I.Mandatory open access publishing for electronic theses and dissertations:ethics and enthusiasm [J].The journal of academic librarianship,2013,39(1):32-60.
[27] 杨峰,韩倩倩,张文韬.机构知识库权益平衡机制探析[J].图书馆建设,2015 (5):13-16.
[28] 相丽玲,樊晓璐.中美机构知识库利用中的政策法律机制比较[J].情报理论与实践,2015(5):114-118.
[29] 牛晓宏.开放数据政策协同对图书开放获取政策的启示[J].现代情报,2018(9):24-28.
[30] 贾丽君.国外图书开放获取中的政策机制分析 [J].图书与情报,2017(3):93-97.
[31] 王应宽,王元杰,季方,等.国外开放存取出版最新研究进展与发展动态 [J].中国科技期刊研究,2015,26(10):1054-1064.
[32] 金品.开放存取期刊出版模式及其版权特点探析 [J].中国版权,2014(4):63-67.
[33] 刘勇.开放存取出版的原理、模式与影响因素分析 [J].出版广角,2016(11):36-38.
[34] MARY A K.Learning to share:mandates and open access[J].Library management,2011,32 (4/5):302-318.
[35] 苏红英.基于供给方付费的开放存取期刊的经济模式分析:以国外的实践为视角 [J].图书馆界,2017(3):42-45.
[36] 陈晋.开放存取期刊的经济运作模式 [J].图书馆学刊,2012(6):3-6.
[37] 涂志芳;刘兹恒.国内外学术图书馆参与开放存取出版的实践进展述略——从出版途径的视角 [J].图书与情报,2017(3):61-71.
[38] 李瑾.盛小平.利益视角下的学术图书开放获取出版模式研究 [J].图书情报工作,2017(3):39-46.
[39] 刘海霞,孙振球,胡德华,等.开放存取期刊的经济学分析 [J].情报理论与实践,2007,30(1):48-51.
[40] GEOGINA A T,VALETINO M L.A business model for electronic books[J].Social and behavioral sciences,2014(147):268 - 274.
[41] 马小琪,李亚赟.信息栈视角下微信公众平台出版模式研究[J].出版发行研究,2017(7):27-30.
[42] MICHELE S,MARIE P D,JILL E.Consortial monograph interlending in the UK:a case study[J].Interlending & document supply,2006,34(1):24-28.
[43] 宁圣红.学术图书开放获取新模式:Knowledge Unlatched [J].图书馆论坛,2015(7):14-20.
[44] JOSEPH W I.Research into open access science publishing [J].Library hi tech news,2009(26):16-18.
[45] 常江.数字版权管理与合理使用权利冲突的解决路径 [J].出版广角,2016(8):38-40.
[46] 李春旺.网络环境下学术信息的开放存取 [J].中国图书馆学报,2005(1):33-37.
[47] 朱本军,龙世彤,肖珑,等.图书 开放 获取模式 及整 合利 用研 究 [J].大学图书馆学报,2015(5):25-30.
[48] 刘春艳.产学研协同创新团队内部知识转移影响机理[M].北京:知识产权出版社.2017:298-300.
[49] 孙瑞英,马海群.太极哲理对开放数据与数据安全政策协同的启示[J].现代情报,2018(5):3-10.