Comment on 鈥淧hase Behavior of Ternary Mixtures of Water鈥揤anillin鈥揈t
hanol for Vanillin Extraction via Dissipative Particle Dyn
amics鈥?/a>
- 刊名:Journal of Chemical & Engineering Data
- 出版年:2015
- 出版时间:November 12, 2015
- 年:2015
- 卷:60
- 期:11
- 全文大小:152K
- ISSN:1520-5134
文摘
This comment addresses a few issues of concern regarding the use of Dissipative Particle Dynamics (DPD) to characterize molecular phase diagrams and identify phase morphologies in the recent paper by Son et al. (J. Chem. Eng. Data 2014, 59, 3036鈥?040). While useful solubility modeling and self-assembly can be aided by various coarse graining strategies including DPD, one should employ as well complementary techniques and ensure consistency of conclusions through experiments or readily available tools. We believe the approach and parametrization scheme is inappropriate to the system of study resulting in unrealistic results and interpretations.