欧盟在叙利亚危机中的制裁行为分析
|
摘要
自2011年3月叙利亚危机爆发以来,欧盟对叙利亚先后采取了一系列具有针对性的制裁措施。维护"地中海后院"的安全和稳定,拓展欧洲的民主、自由、人权价值观是欧盟制裁叙利亚的主要动因。欧盟对叙制裁过程中"行动一致"的困境、叙利亚对欧盟较低的经济依存度和高度集权的政治体制以及缺乏有效的制裁联盟是欧盟对叙制裁失效的主要原因。欧盟对叙利亚危机的政策前景归根结底取决于叙政府和国内反对派、国际社会武力"倒叙"与和平解决叙利亚危机力量对比的最终结果。
Since the outbreak of the Syrian crisis in March 2011,the European Union has imposed,one after the other,a series of sanctions directly against Syria.The main purpose of the EU's imposition of sanctions on Syria lies in that it wanted to maintain security and stability of "the Mediterranean backyard",and allow Europe's democracy, freedom and human rights values to expand.The main reasons for the failure of the EU's sanctions against Syria can be attributed,in part,to the lack of "collective actions" in the course of sanctions by the whole of EU,a low degree of economic reliance of Syria on the EU and Syria's highly concentrated political system,and of course,the absence of an effective sanction alliance.The prospects of the EU policy toward Syrian crisis will ultimately be determined by the balance of power between the Syrian government and Syrian opposition parties,between the international community in favor of "bringing down the Syrian government by force" and the forces in favor of settling Syrian crisis by peaceful means.
Since the outbreak of the Syrian crisis in March 2011,the European Union has imposed,one after the other,a series of sanctions directly against Syria.The main purpose of the EU's imposition of sanctions on Syria lies in that it wanted to maintain security and stability of "the Mediterranean backyard",and allow Europe's democracy, freedom and human rights values to expand.The main reasons for the failure of the EU's sanctions against Syria can be attributed,in part,to the lack of "collective actions" in the course of sanctions by the whole of EU,a low degree of economic reliance of Syria on the EU and Syria's highly concentrated political system,and of course,the absence of an effective sanction alliance.The prospects of the EU policy toward Syrian crisis will ultimately be determined by the balance of power between the Syrian government and Syrian opposition parties,between the international community in favor of "bringing down the Syrian government by force" and the forces in favor of settling Syrian crisis by peaceful means.
引文
[1]王京烈.动荡中东多视角分析[N].北京:世界知识出版社,1996年版,第35页. [2]李琳,罗海东.地中海联盟的成立及面临的挑战[J].国际资料信息,2008年第8期,第1页. [3]2012年11月7日,叙利亚安全部队关闭哈马斯在大马士革的办公机构,使叙反对派欢呼哈马斯终于站到了他们一边。见“叙利亚与哈马斯决裂,或加剧巴沙尔政权困境”,http:// news.xinhuanet.com/mil/2012-11/08/c_123929500.htm.(上网时间:2012-11 -07) [1]欧盟将地中海国家分为三部分:北部地中海国家(塞浦路斯、马耳他、土耳其、前南斯拉夫、阿尔巴尼亚、安道尔和圣马力诺)、马格里布国家(阿尔及利亚、摩洛哥、突尼斯、利比亚)和马什雷克国家(埃及、约旦、叙利亚、以色列、巴勒斯坦)。详见唐虹、顾怡,《试析欧盟地中海政策的局限性》[J].欧洲研究,2011年第5期. [2]唐虹,顾怡.试析欧盟地中海政策的局限性[J].欧洲研究,2011年第5期,第59页. [3]张迎红.试论欧洲安全战略文化的差异与趋同[J].德国研究,2008年第2期,第38页. [4]张浚.欧盟的“民事力量”及其运行方式[M].第110——124页. [5]尹斌.软实力外交:欧盟的中东政策[M],第1版,北京:光明日报出版社,2010年,第112-113页. [1]所谓“聪明制裁”主要是指将制裁的矛头直接指向被制裁政权或集团的领导、上层人物与支持该政权或集团的个人或集团,以期尽量减少对“弱势群体”和第三方的消极影响,主要内容包括金融制裁(financial sanctions)、武器禁运(arms embargo)和旅行制裁(travel sanctions),其最大特点是制裁的“针对性”,故“聪明制裁”又称“瞄准制裁”。转引自《迈向更为人道和富有成效的制裁?——“聪明制裁”初探》[J],杨祥银,国际论坛,2002年第2期,第16页. [2]张杰.国际观察:欧盟缺少应对叙利亚暴力的措施[EB/OL].http://world.people.com.cn/ GB/57507/18044656.html.(上网时间:2012-11-13) [1]阎梁,何劲汶.欧盟、美国对伊朗的经济制裁:政策分歧及其弥合[J],欧洲研究,2012年第3期.第115页. [2]张杰.国际观察:欧盟缺少应对叙利亚暴力的措施[EB/OL].http://world.people.com.cn/ GB/57507/18044656.html.(上网时间:2012-11-13) [3]有效制裁与“正义制裁”——论国际经济制裁的政治动因与伦理维度[J].世界经济与政治,石斌.2010年第8期,第37页. [1]Sean M.Bolks,Dina Al-Sowayel.How Long Do Economic Sanctions Last?:Examining the Sanctioning Process through Duration:241-265. [2]Gary Hufbauer,et a.l,Economic Sanctions Reconsidered,pp.107. [3]Gary Hufbauer,et a.l,Economic Sanctions Reconsidered,pp.186. [1]贾靖峰.俄官员称不会因叙利亚内乱而中止对其军售[EB/OL].http://war.163.com/11/ 1114/10/7IQHLTLU00011MTO.html.(上网时间:2012-10-08) [1]http://www.comprehensivenews.us/news -1607756 -Henry -Kissinger -the -author -against-the -United-States-rush-to-military-intervention-in-Syria-crisis.html.(上网时间:2012-10-05) [1]阿什顿称欧盟支持和平解决叙利亚危机[EB/OL].http://www.people.com.cn/h/2012/ 0310/c25408-721918769.html.(上网时间:2012-11-06) [2]欧盟重申安南和平计划,称叙政府失去执政合法性[EB/OL].http://www.chinanews.com/ gj/2012/06-13/3958896.shtml.(上网时间:2012-09-25) [3]欧盟高官称军事干预并非解决叙利亚危机方案[EB/OL].http://www.chinanews.com/gj/ 2012/07-13/4029792.shtml.(上网时间:2012-10-07) [1]田文林.地缘政治、中东破碎地带与利比亚战争[J].阿拉伯世界研究,2011年第4期.第31页.